Allocation d'organes et exigences de justice

(Résumé de l'ouvrage) Die Verteilung knapper menschlicher Organe wirft schwierige Fragen der Verteilungsgerechtigkeit und der Organisation auf. Rein medizinische Aussagen etwa über die Überlebenschance eines Organs in einem bestimmten Empfänger sind vorausgesetzt, bestimmen aber nie allein die Entscheidung. Effizienzüberlegungen sprechen zwar häufig für die primäre Berücksichtigung des Empfängers mit der grössten Lebenserwartung. Schon der Einbezug qualitativer Kriterien für die Überlebensphase kompliziert die Materie, erst recht aber die Berücksichtigung auch der Wartezeit als Element der Gleichbehandlung, der Dringlichkeit für den Empfänger oder gar von Marktkriterien. Auch die Frage einer Priorität für den seinerseits Spendewilligen wird kontrovers diskutiert. Und selbst dann, wenn man sich über die Gewichtung der unterschiedlichen Kriterien von Verteilungsgerechtigkeit einig wäre, bliebe immer noch die optimale organisatorische Durchsetzung dieser Entscheidung zu klären: soll man zum Beispiel mit regionalen, nationalen oder übernationalen Pools arbeiten? Die zweite Tagung im Tagungszyklus zu Grundsatzfragen der Transplantationsmedizin erörterte Themen rund um die Allokationproblematik bei Organen. Referenten aus verschiedenen Ländern, Sprachregionen und Disziplinen sprachen über medizinische, ethische, juristische, aber auch ökonomische Aspekte der Verteilung von Organen.

Organallokation : ethische und rechtliche Fragen

Die Verteilung knapper menschlicher Organe wirft schwierige Fragen der Verteilungsgerechtigkeit und der Organisation auf. Rein medizinische Aussagen etwa über die Überlebenschance eines Organs in einem bestimmten Empfänger sind vorausgesetzt, bestimmen aber nie allein die Entscheidung. Effizienzüberlegungen sprechen zwar häufig für die primäre Berücksichtigung des Empfängers mit der grössten Lebenserwartung. Schon der Einbezug qualitativer Kriterien für die Überlebensphase kompliziert die Materie, erst recht aber die Berücksichtigung auch der Wartezeit als Element der Gleichbehandlung, der Dringlichkeit für den Empfänger oder gar von Marktkriterien. Auch die Frage einer Priorität für den seinerseits Spendewilligen wird kontrovers diskutiert. Und selbst dann, wenn man sich über die Gewichtung der unterschiedlichen Kriterien von Verteilungsgerechtigkeit einig wäre, bliebe immer noch die optimale organisatorische Durchsetzung dieser Entscheidung zu klären: soll man zum Beispiel mit regionalen, nationalen oder übernationalen Pools arbeiten? Die zweite Tagung im Tagungszyklus zu Grundsatzfragen der Transplantationsmedizin erörterte Themen rund um die Allokationproblematik bei Organen. Referenten aus verschiedenen Ländern, Sprachregionen und Disziplinen sprachen über medizinische, ethische, juristische, aber auch ökonomische Aspekte der Verteilung von Organen.

Le myélome à chaînes légères ou les pièges du diagnostic du myélome [Light chain myeloma or the pitfalls of myeloma diagnosis]

The diagnosis of multiple myeloma is often suggested by disturbances found in routine laboratory tests such as sedimentation rate, electrophoresis of serum proteins and search for proteinuria. In light chain myeloma these tests are nonspecific and therefore misleading. We present 8 cases of light chain myeloma and discuss the diagnosis of multiple myeloma with its associated pitfalls.

Traitement des fibroses pulmonaires idiopathiques [Treatment of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis]

Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis still has to be diagnosed by elimination. Neoplasm, toxic treatments, collagen vascular disease, professional exposure or diagnosis such as sarcoidosis have to be ruled out. The repercussions on gas exchange are the most reliable indications of the severity of the disease, the pulmonary function test or chest x-rays alone being often misleading. Transbronchic biopsies, thoracotomy or thoracoscopies provide a precise diagnosis. In many cases only broncho-alveolar lavage and a high resolution CT-scan are performed to rule out infection or tumor and to assess the inflammatory state of the disease. Due to the often poor prognosis of this disease and its often poor response to steroids, the role of cytostatic drugs, cyclosporine and colchicine, and of pulmonary graft is discussed.

Klinisch-immunologische Teste--Standortbestimmung 1976

[Clinical-immunological tests; current state].

Utilité et limites du dosage de l'antigène carcinoembryonnaire (CEA) dans la surveillance postopératoire de malades atteints de carcinomes du côlon et du rectu

An attempt is made to define the usefulness and limitations of carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) radioimmunoassay for evaluation of tumor resection and detection of tumor relapse in patients with large-bowel carcinoma. In 45 patients for whom complete tumor resection was reported, all but 5 showed a drop in CEA to normal values after surgery. The 5 patients whose CEA did not fall to below 5 ng/ml showed a subsequent rise in CEA level and later were all found to have a tumor relapse. The results indicate that an incomplete drop in circulating CEA level one month after surgery is a bad prognostic sign. Twenty-two of these patients were followed up by repeated CEA radioimmunoassay for several months after surgery; 8 showed a progressive increase in CEA levels preceding clinical diagnosis of tumor relapse by 2-10 months. The clinical history of these 8 patients is briefly described. The results demonstrate that relapses of colon and rectum carcinoma can be detected by increased CEA levels months before the appearance of any clinical evidence.

Quelques mécanismes moléculaires impliqués dans la pathogenèse du diabète de type II et leur importance thérapeutique potentielle [Various molecular mechanisms involved in the pathogenesis of type II diabetes and their potential therapeutic importance]

The pancreatic beta cell presents functional abnormalities in the early stages of development of non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM). The disappearance of the first phase of insulin secretion induced by a glucose load is a early marker of NIDDM. This abnormality could be secondary to the low expression of the pancreatic glucose transporter GLUT2. Together with the glucokinase enzyme, GLUT2 is responsible for proper beta cell sensing of the extracellular glucose levels. In NIDDM, the GLUT2 mRNA levels are low, a fact which suggests a transcriptional defect of the GLUT2 gene. The first phase of glucose-induced insulin secretion by the beta pancreatic cell can be partly restored by the administration of a peptide discovered by a molecular approach, the glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1). The gene encoding for the glucagon is expressed in a cell-specific manner in the A cells of the pancreatic islet and the L cells of the intestinal tract. The maturation process of the propeptide encoded by the glucagon gene is different in the two cells: the glucagon is the main hormone produced by the A cells whereas the glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1) is the major peptide synthesized by the L cells of the intestine. GLP-1 is an incretin hormone and is at present the most potent insulinotropic peptide. The first results of the administration of GLP-1 to normal volunteers and diabetic patients are promising and may be a new therapeutic approach to treating diabetic patients.

Concentrations plasmatiques et articulaires pendant l'administration de céfacétrile pour arthrite septique (6 cas) [Serum and joint levels of cefacetrile during its administration for septic arthritis]

Six patients, five of whom had normal and one impaired renal function, and all suffering from purulent arthritis caused by cephalosporin-sensitive germs, were given a seven-day course of 8 g cephacetrile daily. On the first day, 6 g were administered by continuous intravenous infusion at the rate of 500 mg/h, followed by 2 g over a further 45 min. On days 2 to 7, the patients received 2 short infusions of 4 g each at an interval of 12 h. In four patients with normal renal function, serum half-life ranged from 0.8 to 1.4 h, serum levels during continuous infusion from 19 to 31 microgram/ml, and total clearances from 265 to 434 ml/min. In one patients, these values were 1.6 h, 70 microgram/ml and 131 ml/min respectively (small volume of distribution). The concentrations in the synovial fluid varied from 2 to 29 mcirogram/ml; they were generally lower than the serum levels, but clearly exceeded the minimum inhibitory concentrations for germs commonly present in purulent arthritis. In five patients, the synovial fluid became germ-free and the arthritis was clinically cured. In the case presenting with renal insufficiency, the serum half-life was 5.8 h. During continuous administration, a steady state was not attained; peak serum levels amo9nted to 75 microgram/ml and the total clearance to 61 ml/min. The cephacetrile concentrations in the synovial fluid were very high (26 and 67 microgram/ml). In this case, in which the renal insufficiency associated with mycosis fungoides was present before the treatment, renal function deteriorated futher during treatment while the arthritis improved.

Historia morbi atrocis--deux nouveaux cas de ruptures spontanées de l'oesophage (syndrome de Boerhaave) [Historia morbi atrocis--2 new cases of spontaneous rupture of the esophagus (Boerhaave syndrome)].]

We report the case of two patients hospitalized within a few weeks of each other and both presenting with spontaneous rupture of the esophagus whose evolution proved fatal. We take the opportunity of drawing attention to this rare and challenging disease, which is often diagnosed too late.

Dépistage du cancer du sein par l'examen physique: qui en bénéficie? [Physical examination in screening for breast cancer: who benefits?].

A survey was undertaken among a representative sample of the female population, aged 20 to 74, of the Canton of Vaud, Switzerland (total population 550,000) to assess the knowledge, attitudes and practices of women in respect to breast cancer and its prevention. The present study focuses on access by women to medical preventive measures (breast examination by physician and information on breast self-examination). The data are analyzed in relation to the individual risk factors affecting women, in particular age. While with age the risk of breast cancer grows in a linear fashion, the proportion of women having their breast examined by a physician declines. Women over 50 who had no children before the age of 30 constitute an especially high risk category, with the lowest access to information and prevention. This is explained in large part by the fact that they consult gynecologists less often. In this regard it should be noted that a visit to a gynecologist's office is associated much more often with breast examination than a visit to a family physician. It is important to take such findings into account in providing more appropriate and complete care for those groups. This involves sensitization of the physician and improved information for the women themselves.

"Iatrogenicity cascade": doing harm by treating harm?

An electronic survey on substance-induced epileptic crisis was conducted in order to investigate whether doctors, who recognise their own prescription errors, increase their therapeutic aggressiveness, resulting in a so-called "iatrogenicity cascade". Two pairs of clinical vignettes were constructed, in which a patient suffers from iatrogenic (original version) or non-iatrogenic (control version) epileptic crisis. Vignettes were randomised and sent to doctors at the University Hospital of Lausanne, Switzerland, at an interval of 3 weeks. The results of the present survey in the surveyed population of doctors suggest that inappropriate prescription does not increase therapeutic aggressiveness.

Capacité de travail en cas d'affections pulmonaires

This short review begins by defining some basic medico-legal concepts such as "impairment" and "disability" and gives the corresponding terms in French and German. It is then shown how, in stable obstructive and restrictive respiratory diseases such as COPD and lung fibrosis, the degree of impairment can be assessed on the basis of FEV1 and indices of gas exchange. In the case of bronchial asthma, however, with its typically variable degree of airflow limitation, the amount of reversibility and treatment necessary to achieve optimum bronchodilatation must be taken into account. This can best be done using a score system. Impairment represents a base but in no way equals the final percentage of disability pension or compensation, which are always assessed by the competent administrative authority. However, it is the physician who specifies the amount and type of work an individual patient, with his or her particular degree of disability, can or cannot be expected to do.

Caractéristiques cliniques des leucémies lymphoblastiques aiguës de type T immature (E-rosette négatif) détecté par l'anticorps monoclonal LAU-A1 [Clinical characteristics of immature T-type (negative E-rosette) acute lymphoblastic leukemia detected by LAU-A1 monoclonal antibody]

Immature T-ALL is a newly defined subgroup of ALL in which the blasts lack the receptor for sheep erythrocytes (ER) and the usual T-cell markers, but express the 40 kDa pan-T surface antigen recognized by our monoclonal antibody LAU-A1. Patients with immature T-ALL represent 10% of all cases of adult ALL. Leukocyte counts are lower and spleen, liver and lymph node enlargement is less prominent, but mediastinal enlargement is more frequent than in mature (ER-positive) T-ALL. 7 patients with immature T-ALL (median age 42 years, range 13-73) were treated with intensified chemotherapy regimens, and only one 47-year-old female entered a short-lived complete remission. The overall survival of our patients was poor (median 7.5 months, with only one patient surviving at 15 months) and seemed not to be influenced by age. Our study indicates that immature T-ALL can only be accurately identified by the use of monoclonal antibodies recognizing the 40 kDa pan-T antigen, and that immature T-ALL is a separate disease entity typified by a poor prognosis.

Apports et limites de la scintigraphie pulmonaire dans le diagnostic de l'embolie pulmonaire [Value and limitation of pulmonary scintigraphy in the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism].

Perfusion lung scan, whether associated with a ventilation lung scan or not, is frequently used in the diagnosis of pulmonary emboli. The characteristics of perfusion lung scan are reviewed. The added diagnostic value of standard chest X-ray and of ventilation scan is discussed, as well as its use in the intensive care unit.