Avaliação de projetos de investimento em cogeração de energia utilizando bagaço de cana-de-açúcar em biorrefinarias a partir do uso da teoria das opções reais

O cenário de continuo aumento do consumo de derivados do petróleo aliado a conscientização de que é necessário existir um equilíbrio com relação a exploração de recursos naturais e preservação do meio ambiente, vem impulsionando a busca por fontes alternativas de energia. Esse crescente interesse vem se aplicando a geração de energia a partir de biomassa da cana de açúcar, que vem se tornando cada vez mais comuns no Brasil, porém ainda existe um imenso potencial a ser explorado. Dentro deste contexto, se torna relevante a tomada de decisão de investimentos em projetos de cogeração e este trabalho busca incrementar a analise e tomada de decisão com a utilização da Teoria das Opções Reais, uma ferramenta de agregação de valor às incertezas, cabendo perfeitamente ao modelo energético brasileiro, onde grandes volatilidades do preço de energia são observadas ao longo dos anos. O objetivo do trabalho é determinar o melhor momento para uma biorrefinaria investir em unidades de cogeração. A estrutura do trabalho foi dividida em três cenários de porte de biorrefinarias, as de 2 milhões de capacidade de moagem de cana-de-açúcar por ano, as de 4 milhões e as de 6 milhões, visando assim ter uma representação amostral das biorrefinarias do país. Além disso, analisaram-se três cenários de volatilidade atrelados ao preço futuro de energia, dado que a principal variável de viabilização deste tipo de projeto é o preço de energia. As volatilidades foram calculadas de acordo com histórico do ambiente regulado, o dobro do ambiente regulado e projeção de PLD, representando, respectivamente, níveis baixos, médios e altos, de volatilidade do preço de energia. Após isso, foram elaboradas as nove árvores de decisão, que demonstram para os gestores de investimento que em um cenário de baixa volatilidade cria-se valor estar posicionado e ter a opção real de investir ou adiar investimento para qualquer porte de usina. No cenário de média volatilidade de preço, aconselha-se ao gestor estar posicionado em usinas de médio a grande porte para viabilização do investimento. Por fim, quando o cenário de preços é de grande volatilidade, tem-se um maior risco e existe a maior probabilidade de viabilização do investimento em usinas de grande porte.

Utilização da opção de diferimento na avaliação de implantação de projeto de mecanismo de desenvolvimento limpo em uma empresa de cerâmica vermelha

A evolução da teoria de precificação de opções considera um conjunto de ferramentas necessárias para gerenciar e explorar o valor advindo da incerteza e da volatilidade que ampliam os parâmetros da geração de valor ao acrescentarem os conceitos de flexibilidade gerencial. Dentro deste contexto, o presente estudo teve como objetivo avaliar economicamente a implantação do Mecanismo de Desenvolvimento Limpo em uma empresa de cerâmica vermelha localizada no Arranjo Produtivo de São Miguel do Guamá, nordeste do Pará. A avaliação pretendeu demonstrar o valor da flexibilidade gerencial de Diferimento conforme adaptações realizadas na metodologia proposta por Copeland & Antikarov (2001), a qual adiciona à avaliação tradicional de fluxo de caixa descontado a Opção Real – OR – que a pesquisa considerou; e que fundamentou-se por meio de revisão de literatura para formulação do método. Essa determinação seguiu um roteiro de etapas essenciais para a análise das variáveis que compreendem o modelo e que possibilitou a ordenação dos resultados quanto aos valores da OR considerada e do valor presente incluindo a flexibilidade gerencial; com a aplicação do método na empresa objeto da pesquisa. Finalmente, como resultado deste estudo conclui-se que a Teoria de Opções Reais por meio da Opção de Diferimento ou Adiamento contribui com informações que auxiliam nas decisões gerenciais de investimento em projetos quando comparados à metodologia tradicional de avaliação visto que são consideradas incertezas inerentes ao projeto, tal como o ambiente real.

Análise de investimento em confinamento bovino no centro-oeste brasileiro: um estudo de caso.

This study analyzed the economic viability of an investment in feedlot cattle on a farm in the midsize state of Goias. The research identified that different thematic studies whose interests have focused mainly on cost analysis and profitability punctual. Differently, this study used the approaches of the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) and the Real Options Theory (ROT). The first used the projected cash flow for 10 years and a discount rate determined by CAPM at 8% p.a. for containment of heads 400. The second was modeled by the binomial model of Cox, Ross and Rubinstein (1979) incorporating the option of waiting. This methodology has not been employed in Brazilian cattle industry. The search results pointed to the economic viability of the project when considered possible scenarios for the different price ranges of the ox that state bushel. In addition, the TOR proved to be a more robust tool for investment analysis, by incorporating the flexibility of farmers to wait for the right time to make the confinement.

Le scelte di investimento delle aziende agricole e la PAC post-2013: valutazione di scenari mediante un modello real options

Negli ultimi decenni la Politica Agricola Comune (PAC) è stata sottoposta a diverse revisioni, più o meno programmate, che ne hanno modificato gli obiettivi operativi e gli strumenti per perseguirli. In letteratura economica agraria sono state eseguite diverse ricerche che affrontano analisi ex-ante sui possibili impatti delle riforme politiche, in particolare al disaccoppiamento, riguardo all’allocazione dei terreni alle diverse colture e all’adozione di tecniche di coltivazione più efficienti. Ma tale argomento, nonostante sia di grande importanza, non è stato finora affrontato come altri temi del mondo agricolo. Le principali lacune si riscontrano infatti nella carenza di analisi ex-ante, di modelli che includano le preferenze e le aspettative degli agricoltori. Questo studio valuta le scelte di investimento in terreno di un’azienda agricola di fronte a possibili scenari PAC post-2013, in condizioni di incertezza circa le specifiche condizioni in cui ciascuno scenario verrebbe a verificarsi. L’obiettivo è di ottenere indicazioni utili in termini di comprensione delle scelte di investimento dell’agricoltore in presenza di incertezza sul futuro. L’elemento maggiormente innovativo della ricerca consiste nell’applicazione di un approccio real options e nell’interazione tra la presenza di diversi scenari sul futuro del settore agricolo post-2013, e la componente di incertezza che incide e gravita su di essi. La metodologia adottata nel seguente lavoro si basa sulla modellizzazione di un’azienda agricola, in cui viene simulato il comportamento dell’azienda agricola in reazione alle riforme della PAC e alla variazione dei prezzi dei prodotti in presenza di incertezza. Mediante un modello di Real Option viene valutata la scelta della tempistica ottimale per investire nell’acquisto di terreno (caratterizzato da incertezza e irreversibilità). Dai risultati emerge come in presenza di incertezza all’agricoltore convenga rimandare la decisione a dopo il 2013 e in base alle maggiori informazioni disponibili eseguire l’investimento solo in presenza di condizioni favorevoli. La variazione dei prezzi dei prodotti influenza le scelte più dell’incertezza dei contributi PAC. Il Real Option sembra interpretare meglio il comportamento dell’agricoltore rispetto all’approccio classico del Net Present Value.

Financial decision making about found oil and gas in Ghana : real options vs. traditional methods

This research is a study of the use of capital budgeting methods for investment decisions. It uses both the traditional methods and the newly introduced approach called the real options analysis to make a decision. The research elucidates how capital budgeting can be done when analysts encounter projects with high uncertainty and are capital intensive, for example oil and gas production. It then uses the oil and gas find in Ghana as a case study to support its argument. For a clear understanding a thorough literature review was done, which highlights the advantages and disadvantages of both methods. The revenue that the project will generate and the costs of production were obtained from the predictions by analysts from GNPC and compared to others experts’ opinion. It then applied both the traditional and real option valuation on the oil and gas find in Ghana to determine the project’s feasibility. Although, there are some short falls in real option analysis that are presented in this research, it is still helpful in valuing projects that are capital intensive with high volatility due to the strategic flexibility management possess in their decision making. It also suggests that traditional methods of evaluation should still be maintained and be used to value projects that have no options or those with options yet the options do not have significant impact on the project. The research points out the economic ripples the production of oil and gas will have on Ghana’s economy should the project be undertaken. These ripples include economic growth, massive job creation and reduction of the balance of trade deficit for the country. The long run effect is an eventually improvement of life of the citizens. It is also belief that the production of gas specifically can be used to generate electricity in Ghana which would enable the country to have a more stable and reliable power source necessary to attract more foreign direct investment.

Real Options: A Tool for Managing Technical Risk in a Mine Plan

NPV is a static measure of project value which does not discriminate between levels of internal and external risk in project valuation. Due to current investment project?s characteristics, a much more complex model is needed: one that includes the value of flexibility and the different risk levels associated with variables subject to uncertainty (price, costs, exchange rates, grade and tonnage of the deposits, cut off grade, among many others). Few of these variables present any correlation or can be treated uniformly. In this context, Real Option Valuation (ROV) arose more than a decade ago, as a mainly theoretical model with the potential for simultaneous calculation of the risk associated with such variables. This paper reviews the literature regarding the application of Real Options Valuation in mining, noting the prior focus on external risks, and presents a case study where ROV is applied to quantify risk associated to mine planning.

Estudio de opciones reales para decisiones de inversión en un proyecto minero de nueva ejecución

El objetivo principal es desarrollar la metodología de opciones reales para evaluar la posible puesta en marcha de un proyecto minero. Para esto, el proyecto se divide en dos partes: En la primera parte, con carácter teórico se analizan las inversiones desde el punto de vista tradicional, comparando la problemática de estas valoraciones en ambientes de incertidumbre y flexibilidad operativa. Se analizan las opciones financieras y se comparan con las opciones reales, en cuanto a similitudes y problemáticas. Se desarrollan también los procesos estocásticos que afectan a las variables del proyecto de inversión. Se explican además, las metodologías para el cálculo de las opciones reales, incluido el cálculo de la volatilidad de las mismas. En una segunda parte, se estudia el yacimiento aurífero de Corcoesto, para el cual se realiza la simulación del plan de negocio según las características necesarias para la explotación, donde los ingresos se modelizan mediante un movimiento geométrico browniano para simular el comportamiento del precio de la onza de oro. Se elige un desarrollo de árboles binomiales para estimar el valor futuro del proyecto, a la vez que se establece un intervalo de precios de la opción para adquirir el proyecto minero. Este intervalo estará determinado por las incertidumbres del proyecto calculadas según las metodologías de Copeland y Antikarov, y Heraht y Park. Abstract This project is aimed mainly to develop real options theory to assess a mining project start-up. The project is divided in two documents: The first document with theorical content, investments are analyzed from the clasical point of view, comparing the advantages and disadvantages of this appraisal in high uncertainity and operational flexibility conditions. Financial options are analyzed and compared to real options, in both similarities and problematics. Stochastical process that affect the project variables are also developed. Methods for estimating real options value, including the methods for volatility estimation are commented. In the second document, the Corcoesto gold deposit has been studied. A bussines plan simulation has been maked according to the characteristics of the extraction, where incomes have been simulated with a geometrical Brownian movement to estimate the gold onze behaviour. The binomial tree method has been generated to study the future project value, as well as a range of option prices, for adquiring the mine project. This interval is determined by the project uncertainity calculated with the theories from Copeland and Antikarov and Herath and Park

Las Opciones Reales en los Expedientes de Regulación de Empleo

Las empresas en situación económica negativa, recurren en España a los Expedientes de Regulación de Empleo que es la figura legal que permite ajustar sus plantillas y cuya utilización se acrecienta en épocas de crisis. El objetivo de esta investigación se focaliza en la integración de la Teoría de Opciones Reales en los proyectos organizativos de recursos humanos, en particular en el estudio y aplicación de la opción de contracción y de la opción de aplazamiento a los proyectos de desarrollo de los Expedientes de Regulación de Empleo. Las opciones reales son una herramienta de gestión, novedosa y contrastada, que posibilita realizar la valoración de los Expedientes de Regulación de Empleo tomando en consideración las incertidumbres futuras, lo que permite cuantificar mejor el resultado de la decisión y supone un avance sobre la valoración realizada de forma estática. Dos aspectos clave ha sido necesario resolver. En primer lugar determinar la fuente de incertidumbre que ponga en valor las opciones reales para este tipo de proyectos y como consecuencia desarrollar los procedimientos para obtener el valor de la opción. La puesta en valor de la opción de contracción permite, a partir de la consideración de la demanda como factor de incertidumbre, desarrollar un modelo que proporciona el valor óptimo del número de contratos de trabajo a extinguir, de modo que sitúa a la organización en la mejor posición para la toma de decisiones. La resolución del modelo se logra con la ayuda de la herramienta “The Newsvendor Model”, que facilita la obtención el valor óptimo. En la aplicación de la opción de aplazamiento se ha concluido asimismo, que la volatilidad de la demanda es la fuente de incertidumbre que hace viable la opción y a partir de dicha incertidumbre se ha desarrollado un procedimiento basado en el árbol binomial que permite obtener su valor. Una vez desarrollados los dos modelos para las opciones de contracción y aplazamiento, se ha elaborado un modelo conjunto con ambas opciones, integrando los resultados obtenidos en cada caso. Para validar los modelos obtenidos se presenta su aplicación al caso real de una empresa en situación económica negativa que requiere la necesidad de llevar a cabo un Expediente de Regulación de Empleo, lo que ha permitido comprobar la utilidad de dichos desarrollos, al obtener resultados que facilitan la toma de decisiones y que presentan soluciones que pueden ser más equilibradas para los trabajadores de la empresa, aspecto clave a tener en cuenta, dado el coste personal, familiar y social de este tipo de proyectos. La integración de las opciones reales en la gestión de recursos humanos tiene un amplio campo de aplicación, dadas las diferentes inversiones que se pueden llevar a cabo sobre el capital humano. Aunque esta investigación se ha focalizado en la opcionalidad de las inversiones para el ajuste de plantilla, existen otro tipo de inversiones en recursos humanos, como son las dedicadas a formación, motivación, adecuación o incorporación de personal, que también estarán sujetas a opcionalidad si existen incertidumbres a futuro. Con el objetivo de avanzar en el estudio y aplicación de las opciones reales a estas inversiones, se presenta un marco conceptual que identifica las bases de partida en lo referente a los retornos de las inversiones y las incertidumbres futuras. Con los resultados obtenidos en esta investigación se entiende que se ha conseguido el objetivo de aplicar la Teoría de Opciones Reales a los Expedientes de Regulación de Empleo y con ello establecer la posibilidad de mejorar las implicaciones sociales de estos proyectos dentro de la empresa y en la sociedad. ABSTRACT During crisis times, like the one Spain has been going through on the last years, the Collective Dismissal Procedure is an important issue to be considered within companies that are having a negative economic situation. This research focuses on the integration of the Real Options Theory for organizational projects in the management of human resources, and particularly the study and inclusion of the option to contract and the deferral option in Collective Dismissal Procedures. The Real Options Theory, an innovative management tool that has been proven as correct, help to improve the assessment of the Collective Dismissal Procedures using the dynamic demand instead of the static demand, giving a better quantification of the decision that is going to be taken. Two main issues which are hoped to be resolve are examined: the search for a source of uncertainty to make the real options viable for this type of projects, and consequently the development of a procedure to obtain the value of the option. The option to contract allows, from the consideration of the demand as a factor of uncertainty, to develop a model obtaining the optimal value in the reduction of the workforce, therefore allowing the organization to place itself in the best position for the decision making. The resolution of this model is achieved with the help of "The Newsvendor Model" tool, which facilitates obtaining the optimal value. The analysis performed in the deferral option also concluded that the volatility of demand is the source of the uncertainty that makes the option viable and the procedure developed by the binomial tree is the tool that enables the value of the option to be found. Once developed two models for contraction and deferment options, a joint model has been developed including both options by integrating the results obtained in each case. To validate the models, the real case of a company in negative economic situation requiring the need to carry out a procedure for collective redundancies is applied. This has demonstrated the usefulness of this kind of development that can deliver results to improve the decision making and provide more balanced solutions for company employees, key consideration given the impact on personal, family life and social environment of these Collective Dismissal Procedures. The integration of real options in the management of human resources has broad scope, given the different investments that can be performed on the human capital. Although this research has focused on the optionality of investments for downsizing, there are other investments in human resources for training, motivation, arrangement or incorporation of staff that are also subject to optionality if there are future uncertainties. With the aim of advancing the study and application of real options to these investments, a conceptual framework is presented that identifies the basis of research in terms of the investment returns and future uncertainties. With the results obtained on this research it is clearly defined the objectives for which this work was started for, the application of the Real Options Theory to the Collective Dismissal Procedure. And thereby achieve the final goal of improving the social impact of these projects within a company and society.

A robustness framework for monitoring real options under uncertainty

This paper presents a problem structuring methodology to assess real option decisions in the face of unpredictability. Based on principles of robustness analysis and scenario planning, we demonstrate how decision-aiding can facilitate participation in projects setting and achieve effective decision making through the use of real options reasoning. We argue that robustness heuristics developed in earlier studies can be practical proxies for real options performance, hence indicators of efficient flexible planning. The developed framework also highlights how to integrate real options solutions in firms’ strategic plans and operating actions. The use of the methodology in a location decision application is provided for illustration.

Exchange rate economic exposure and hedging:the significance of currency options

This thesis focuses on the theoretical examination of the exchange rate economic (operating) exposure within the context of the theory of the firm, and proposes some hedging solutions using currency options. The examination of economic exposure is based on such parameters as firms' objectives, industry structure and production cost efficiency. In particular, it examines an hypothetical exporting firm with costs in domestic currency, which faces competition from foreign firms in overseas markets and has a market share expansion objective. Within this framework, the hypothesis is established that economic exposure, portrayed in a diagram connecting export prices and real exchange rates, is asymmetric (i.e. the negative effects depreciation are higher than the positive effects of a currency depreciation). In this case, export business can be seen as a real option, given by exporting firms to overseas customer. Different scenarios about the asymmetry hypothesis can be derived for different assumptions about the determinants of economic exposure. Having established the asymmetry hypothesis, the hedging against this exposure is analysed. The hypothesis is established, that a currency call option should be used in hedging against asymmetric economic exposure. Further, some advanced currency options stategies are discussed, and their use in hedging several scenarios of exposure is indicated, establishing the hypothesis that, the optimal options strategy is a function of the determinants of exposure. Some extensions on the theoretical analysis are examined. These include the hedging of multicurrency exposure using options, and the exposure of a purely domestic firm facing import competition. The empirical work addresses two issues: the empirical validity of the asymmetry hypothesis and the examination of the hedging effectiveness of currency options.

Real options and multinational investments : an empirical study of risk, performance and organisational awareness

DUE TO COPYRIGHT RESTRICTIONS ONLY AVAILABLE FOR CONSULTATION AT ASTON UNIVERSITY LIBRARY AND INFORMATION SERVICES WITH PRIOR ARRANGEMENT This thesis is a cross-disciplinary study of the empirical impact of real options theory in the fields of decision sciences and performance management. Borrowing from the economics, strategy and operations research literature, the research examines the risk and performance implications of real options in firms’ strategic investments and multinational operations. An emphasis is placed on the flexibility potential and competitive advantage of multinational corporations to explore the extent to which real options analysis can be classified as best practice in management research. Using a combination of qualitative and quantitative techniques the evidence suggests that, if real options are explored and exploited appropriately, real options management can result in superior performance for multinational companies. The qualitative findings give an overview of the practical advantages and disadvantages of real options and the statistical results reveal that firms which have developed a high awareness of their real options are, as predicted by the theory, able to reduce their downside risk and increase profits through flexibility, organisational slack and multinationality. Although real options awareness does not systematically guarantee higher returns from operations, supplementary findings indicate that firms with evidence of significant investments in the acquisition of real options knowledge tend to outperform competitors which are unaware of their real options. There are three contributions of this research. First, it extends the real options and capacity planning literature to path-dependent contingent-claims analysis to underline the benefits of average type options in capacity allocation. Second, it is thought to be the first to explicitly examine the performance effects of real options on a sample of firms which have developed partial capabilities in real options analysis suggesting that real options diffusion can be key to value creation. Third, it builds a new decision-aiding framework to facilitate the use of real options in projects appraisal and strategic planning.

Real options in management and organizational strategy:a review of decision-making and performance implications

This paper contributes to the debate on the role of real options theory in business strategy and organizational decision-making. It analyses and critiques the decision-making and performance implications of real options within the management theories of the (multinational) firm, reviews and categorizes the organizational, strategic and operational facets of real options management in large business settings. It also presents the views of scholars and practitioners regarding the incorporation and validity of real options in strategy, international management and business processes. The focus is particularly on the decision-making and performance attributes of the real options logic concerning strategic investments, governance modes and multinational operations management. These attributes are examined from both strategic and operating perspectives of decision-making in organizations, also with an overview of the empirical evidence on real options decision-making and performance.

A geometriai Brown-mozgás feltevésének elfogadhatósága a reálopciók értékelésében (The acceptability of the assumption of geometric brownian motion in the valuation of real options)

A reálopciók a döntési rugalmasság megtestesítőiként jelen vannak a vállalatvezetők mindennapjaiban, és cégtől függően jelentős értéket képviselhetnek. Értékelésük a hagyományos diszkontált pénzáramlás módszerekkel csak korlátozottan lehetséges, ezért alternatívaként felmerül a pénzügyi opcióárazás módszertana, amelynek hagyományos változatai az alaptermék alakulásáról geometriai Brown-mozgást feltételeznek. A cikk ezt a feltevést veszi górcső alá a reálopciókra történő alkalmazás szempontjából, és megmutatja, hogy habár önkényesnek tűnhet, valójában nem pusztán egy matematikai szempontból kényelmes megoldás, hanem pénzügyileg is elfogadható feltétel. _______ Real options represent the fl exibility of decision-making, and are thus part of the everyday work of corporate executives, often having great value. Valuing them with the use of traditional Discounted Cash Flow models has limited relevance, therefore arises the alternative methodology of fi nancial option pricing, the traditional versions of which assume that the price of the underlying asset follows Geometric Brownian Motion. The paper examines this assumption from the aspect of real option valuation and shows that although it might seem arbitrary, it is not only a mathematically convenient choice, but also a fi nancially acceptable one.

A villamos erőművek szén-dioxid-kibocsátásának modellezése reálopciók segítségével = Modelling of the carbon dioxide emissions of a power plant, using real options

A szerző egy, a szennyezőanyag-kibocsátás európai kereskedelmi rendszerében megfelelésre kötelezett gázturbinás erőmű szén-dioxid-kibocsátását modellezi négy termékre (völgy- és csúcsidőszaki áramár, gázár, kibocsátási kvóta) vonatkozó reálopciós modell segítségével. A profitmaximalizáló erőmű csak abban az esetben termel és szennyez, ha a megtermelt áramon realizálható fedezete pozitív. A jövőbeli időszak összesített szén-dioxid-kibocsátása megfeleltethető európai típusú bináris különbözetopciók összegének. A modell keretein belül a szén-dioxid-kibocsátás várható értékét és sűrűségfüggvényét becsülhetjük, az utóbbi segítségével a szén-dioxid-kibocsátási pozíció kockáztatott értékét határozhatjuk meg, amely az erőmű számára előírt megfelelési kötelezettség teljesítésének adott konfidenciaszint melletti költségét jelenti. A sztochasztikus modellben az alaptermékek geometriai Ornstein-Uhlenbeck-folyamatot követnek. Ezt illesztette a szerző a német energiatőzsdéről származó publikus piaci adatokra. A szimulációs modellre támaszkodva megvizsgálta, hogy a különböző technológiai és piaci tényezők ceteris paribus megváltozása milyen hatással van a megfelelés költségére, a kockáztatott értékére. ______ The carbon-dioxide emissions of an EU Emissions Trading System participant, gas-fuelled power generator are modelled by using real options for four underlying instruments (peak and off-peak electricity, gas, emission quota). This profit-maximizing power plant operates and emits pollution only if its profit (spread) on energy produced is positive. The future emissions can be estimated by a sum of European binary-spread options. Based on the real-option model, the expected value of emissions and its probability-density function can be deducted. Also calculable is the Value at Risk of emission quota position, which gives the cost of compliance at a given confidence level. To model the prices of the four underlying instruments, the geometric Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process is supposed and matched to public available price data from EEX. Based on the simulation model, the effects of various technological and market factors are analysed for the emissions level and the cost of compliance.

Booms, Recessions and Financial Turmoil: A Fresh Look at Investment Decisions under Cyclical Uncertainty

The paper studies the interaction between cyclical uncertainty and investment in a stochastic real option framework where demand shifts stochastically between three different states, each with different rates of drift and volatility. In our setting the shifts are governed by a three-state Markov switching model with constant transition probabilities. The magnitude of the link between cyclical uncertainty and investment is quantified using simulations of the model. The chief implication of the model is that recessions and financial turmoil are important catalysts for waiting. In other words, our model shows that macroeconomic risk acts as an important deterrent to investments.