Symbiotic effectiveness and ecological characterization of indigenous Rhizobium loti populations in Uruguay

The objectives of this work were to describe the distribution, density and seasonal variation of the indigenous populations of Rhizobium loti in different Uruguayan soils and to determine the symbiotic effectiveness and stress tolerance factors of different isolates, both with the aim of obtaining selected strains to re-introduce as inoculants in Lotus pastures. R. loti was present in ten soils studied and their densities varied from year to year and within each soil. All the isolates nodulated Lotus corniculatus effectively. The nodules in Lotus pedunculatus and Lotus subbiflorus were small, red on the surface and ineffective in nitrogen fixation. The study of 50 isolates from the ten soils showed high variability in their symbiotic efficiency and tolerance to pH. The indigenous population was acid tolerant in culture medium (pH 4.5), 83% of them could grow at pH 4.5 in 3 days. This work showed that there was a great diversity between the strains of R. loti isolated from Uruguayan soils and supports the importance of selecting among them the most efficient and resistant strains to be included in the inoculants.

Defining molecular components of symbiotic phosphate uptake in rice

Phosphate (Pi) acquisition of crops via arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) symbiosis acquires increasing importance due to the limited rock Pi reserves and the demand for environmentally sustainable agriculture. However, the symbiotic Pi uptake machinery has not been characterized in any monocotyledonous plant species. Among these, rice is the primary staple food for more than half of the human population and thus central for future food security. However, the relevance of the AM symbiosis for rice Pi nutrition is presently unclear. Here, we show that 70% of the overall Pi acquired by rice is delivered via the symbiotic route. To better understand this pathway we combined genetic, molecular and physiological approaches to determine the specific functions of the two rice Pi transporters, PT11 and PT13, which are expressed only during AM symbiosis. The PT11 lineage of proteins is present in mono- and dicotyledons whereas PT13, while found across the Poaceae, is absent from dicotyledons. Surprisingly, mutations in either PT11 or PT13 affected fungal colonization and arbuscule formation demonstrating that both genes are essential for AM symbiosis between rice and Glomus intra.rad.ices. Importantly, for symbiotic Pi uptake, only PT11 is necessary and sufficient. We found that mycorrhizal rice, remarkably, received almost all Pi via the symbiotic route. Such dominating mycorrhizal Pi uptake was found in plants grown under controlled conditions as well as in field soils, suggesting that the AM symbiosis is relevant for the Pi nutrition of field grown rice. Development of smaller arbuscules in PT11 mutants suggested that symbiotic Pi signaling is required for fungal nourishment by the plant. However, co-culture of mutant with wild type nurse plants did not restore normal arbuscule size in mutant roots, indicating that other factors than malnutrition accounted for the altered arbuscule phenotype. Surprisingly, the loss of PT13 did not affect symbiotic Pi uptake although it impacted arbuscule morphology, suggesting that PT13 is involved in signaling during arbuscule development. However, induction of PT13 was not only monitored in arbusculated cells but also in inner cortex cells of non-inoculated roots of plants grown under high Pi fertilization conditions. According to preliminary observations, PT13 localized at the tonoplast in arbusculated and non-arbusculated cells, suggesting that it might be involved in transporting Pi into the vacuole, possibly for maintaining cellular Pi homeostasis. The further investigation showed that fungal colonization level was significantly affected in the crown roots of two ptlS mutant alleles, but not in large lateral roots, implying the possible role of PT13 for maintaining Pi homeostasis in the crown roots. - L'acquisition de phosphate (Pi) par les plantes cultivées s'effectue grâce à une symbiose mycorhizienne arbasculaire (AM). L'étude de cette symbiose devient fondamentale puisque d'une part, les réserves en phosphate minéral sont limitées, et, d'autre part, la demande pour une agriculture écologiquement soutenable se renforce. La machinerie d'absorption symbiotique du phosphate n'est cependant pas encore élucidée chez les plantes monocotylédones. Parmi celles-ci, le riz occupe une place primordiale. Aliment de base pour plus de la moitié de la population mondiale, il revêt de ce fait une dimension essentielle en termes de sécurité alimentaire. Pourtant, l'importance de la symbiose AM chez le riz dans le processus d'acquisition du phosphate n'est, encore de nos jours, que peu comprise. Dans cette étude, nous montrons que 70% du phosphate acquis par le riz est mis à disposition de la plante grâce à la symbiose AM. Afin de mieux comprendre ce mécanisme, nous avons employé des approches physiologiques et génétiques nous permettant de déterminer les fonctions spécifiques de deux transporteurs de Pi, PT11 et PT13, présents chez le riz et exprimés uniquement durant la symbiose AM. La famille de gènes à laquelle appartient PT11 est présente chez les monocotylédones ainsi que chez les dicotylédones tandis que PT13, bien que retrouvé au sein des Poaceae, est absent chez les dicotylédones. Etonnamment, des versions mutées de PT11 ou de PT13 affectent la colonisation par le champignon endo-mycorhizien ainsi que la formation d'arbuscules, démontrant l'importance de ces deux gènes dans la symbiose AM entre le riz et Glomus intraradices. Il est à noter que seul PT11 se révèle nécessaire et suffisant pour l'apport de Pi grâce à la symbiose. Nous avons observé que la presque totalité du phosphate dont dispose le riz lors d'une symbiose AM provient du champignon. De telles proportions ont été observées tant chez des plantes cultivées en conditions contrôlées que chez des plantes cultivées dans les champs. Cela suggère l'importance de la symbiose AM dans le processus d'acquisition du Pi chez le riz cultivé à l'extérieur. Le développement d'arbuscules plus petits chez le mutant PT11 tend à montrer qu'une voie signalétique impliquant le Pi symbiotique est nécessaire pour l'entretien du champignon par la plante. Toutefois, une co-culture du mutant avec des plantes sauvages ne permet pas de restaurer des arbuscules de taille normale dans les racines du mutant. Ce résultat indique le rôle de facteurs autres que la malnutrition aboutissant à la formation d'arbuscules altérés. Si la perte de PT13 n'affecte pas l'acquisition de phosphate symbiotique, la morphologie de l'arbuscule est, quant à elle, modifiée. Ceci suggère un rôle de PT13 durant le développement de l'arbuscule. Or, l'induction de PT13 est non seulement détectée dans des cellules contenant des arbuscules mais également dans des cellules du cortex, ceci chez des plantes cultivées sans champignon mais dans des conditions de fortes concentrations en engrais phosphaté. En accord avec des observations précédentes, PT13 est localisé au niveau du tonoplaste des cellules contenant ou non des arbuscules. Ceci suggère que PT13 pourrait être impliqué dans le transport du Pi vers la vacuole, éventuellement pour maintenir une certaine homéostasie du phosphate. Dans cette étude, nous démontrons également que le niveau de colonisation par le champignon est affecté de manière significative dans les racines principales des deux allèles du mutants ptl3, mais pas dans les grosses racines latérales. Cela impliquerait un rôle possible de PT13 dans le maintien de l'homéostasie du phosphate dans les racines principales. RESUME POUR UN LARGE PUBLIC Le phosphate (Pi), l'un des éléments minéraux essentiel au développement des plantes, se trouve généralement en faible quantité dans le sol, limitant ainsi la croissance des plantes. Le rendement de la production agricole dépend dès lors de l'addition d'engrais contenant du phosphate inorganique (Pi), obtenu à partir de ressources minières riches en phosphate. Or, ces ressources devraient être épuisées d'ici la fin du siècle. Les racines des plantes possèdent des transporteurs de phosphate efficaces leur permettant d'acquérir rapidement le Pi présent dans le sol. Comme le Pi s'avère immobile dans le sol, l'absorption rapide par les racines crée des zones pauvres en Pi autour des systèmes racinaires. Pour surmonter cet obstacle, les plantes ont développé une symbiose avec des champignons endomycorhiziens, la symbiose mycorhizienne arbusculaire (AM). Cette association leur donne accès à d'autres ressources en phosphate puisque le mycélium de ces champignons se développe sur une surface 100 fois supérieure à celle des racines. Cela augmente considérablement la surface de nutrition, dépassant ainsi la zone appauvrie en Pi. Le phosphate, transporté grâce au champignon jusqu'à l'intérieur des racines, est fourni à la plante par le biais de structures établies à l'intérieur des cellules végétales, appelées arbuscules. De leur côté, les plantes possèdent des transporteurs spécifiques afin de recevoir le Pi fourni par les champignons. A l'heure actuelle, la machinerie nécessaire à cette absorption a été uniquement décrite chez des plantes dicotylédones. Or, comprendre l'apport de phosphate par les champignons mycorhiziens s'avère particulièrement pertinent dans le cas des espèces monocotylédones cultivées telles que les céréales. Ces dernières constituent en effet la majeure partie de l'alimentation humaine. Parmi les céréales, le riz demeure l'aliment de base de la population mondiale, d'où son importance en terme de sécurité alimentaire. Durant mon travail de thèse, j'ai identifié et caractérisé le transporteur du riz impliqué dans l'apport de phosphate par ce type de symbiose AM. J'ai également démontré que le riz, lorsqu'il vit en symbiose, bénéficie de la presque totalité du Pi transporté par le champignon. Environ 40% de la production globale de riz est cultivée dans des conditions permettant la symbiose avec des mycorhizes arbusculaires. Les variétés de riz adaptées à ces conditions aérobiques deviennent des alternatives favorables aux cultivars actuels nécessitant une forte irrigation. Elles se révèlent en effet plus tolérantes aux pénuries d'eau et permettent l'utilisation de pratiques agricoles moins intensives. Les données présentées dans cette étude enrichissent nos connaissances concernant l'absorption du phosphate chez le riz grâce à la symbiose AM. Ces connaissances peuvent s'avérer décisives pour le développement de cultivars du riz plus adaptés à une agriculture écologiquement soutenable.

Rice perception of symbiotic arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi requires the karrikin receptor complex.

In terrestrial ecosystems, plants take up phosphate predominantly via association with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF). We identified loss of responsiveness to AMF in the rice (Oryza sativa) mutant hebiba, reflected by the absence of physical contact and of characteristic transcriptional responses to fungal signals. Among the 26 genes deleted in hebiba, DWARF 14 LIKE is, the one responsible for loss of symbiosis . It encodes an alpha/beta-fold hydrolase, that is a component of an intracellular receptor complex involved in the detection of the smoke compound karrikin. Our finding reveals an unexpected plant recognition strategy for AMF and a previously unknown signaling link between symbiosis and plant development.

Low variation in ribosomal DNA and internal transcribed spacers of the symbiotic fungi of leaf-cutting ants (Attini: Formicidae)

Leaf-cutting ants of the genera Atta and Acromyrmex (tribe Attini) are symbiotic with basidiomycete fungi of the genus Leucoagaricus (tribe Leucocoprineae), which they cultivate on vegetable matter inside their nests. We determined the variation of the 28S, 18S, and 5.8S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) gene loci and the rapidly evolving internal transcribed spacers 1 and 2 (ITS1 and ITS2) of 15 sympatric and allopatric fungi associated with colonies of 11 species of leafcutter ants living up to 2,600 km apart in Brazil. We found that the fungal rDNA and ITS sequences from different species of ants were identical (or nearly identical) to each other, whereas 10 GenBank Leucoagaricus species showed higher ITS variation. Our findings suggest that Atta and Acromyrmex leafcutters living in geographic sites that are very distant from each other cultivate a single fungal species made up of closely related lineages of Leucoagaricus gongylophorus. We discuss the strikingly high similarity in the ITS1 and ITS2 regions of the Atta and Acromyrmex symbiotic L. gongylophorus studied by us, in contrast to the lower similarity displayed by their non-symbiotic counterparts. We suggest that the similarity of our L. gongylophorus isolates is an indication of the recent association of the fungus with these ants, and propose that both the intense lateral transmission of fungal material within leafcutter nests and the selection of more adapted fungal strains are involved in the homogenization of the symbiotic fungal stock.

Phisicochemical, sensory, and microbiological evaluation and development of symbiotic fermented drink

The goal of this study was to develop a symbiotic lacteous drink, evaluate its physicochemical and sensory characteristics, and verify the viability of Lactobacillus acidophilus in the drink. The milk serum-based drink consisted of 50% milk serum containing 10% saccharose, 25% powdered milk, 15% yacon pulp, and cultures of Lactobacillus acidophilus-La 5E and Bifidobacterium bifidum BB12. It was stored for up to 21 days under refrigeration. The milk serum-based drink was analyzed for protein, ether extract, total dietary fiber, total frutans, carbohydrate content, color, pH, acidity, and contamination by coliforms, and Salmonella sp. Coliforms and Salmonella sp were not detected, and L. acidophilus and B. bifidum provided satisfactory probiotic counts up to 21 days of storage under refrigeration. Lactobacillus acidophilus resistance to gastric acids and bile salts was detected only up to seven days of storage when evaluated in vitro. Sensory analysis and purchase viability were evaluated by consumers at 0, 7, 14, and 21 days of storage. Based on the analytical results and consumer evaluation, the drink was acceptable up to seven days of storage.

Characterization of goat milk and potentially symbiotic non-fat yogurt

Combining prebiotics and probiotic microorganisms improve quality in the formulation of foods. In this paper, the characteristics of goat milk and symbiotic yogurt were studied. Raw goat milk was analyzed and the skimming process was optimized. For the formulation of a potentially non-fat symbiotic yogurt made with skimmed goat milk, inulin, gelatin, sugar, and Streptococcus salivarius subsp. thermophilus, Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus and Lactobacillus casei subsp. rhamnoshus. Chemical characteristics, acceptability, and viability of lactic acid bacteria and probiotic culture were assessed. The protein and fat content of the raw milk was 2.90 and 3.56 g/100 mL, respectively. The optimum skimming process was obtained at 9,800 rpm and 4 °C for 15 minutes. The product formulated had a protein and fat content of 4.04 to 0.04 g/100 mL, good sensory properties, and acceptability of 95%. The lactic bacteria count was 9 × 10(7) CFU mL- 1, and probiotic culture count was higher than 1 × 10(6) CFU mL- 1, which guarantees their effect and capacity to survive in the digestive tract and spread in the intestine. The yogurt was stable during the 21 days of storage. Therefore, this study shows that goat milk yogurt is an adequate delivery vehicle of the probiotic culture L. casei and inulin.

Pea-barley intercropping for efficient symbiotic N-2-fixation, soil N acquisition and use of other nutrients in European organic cropping systems

Complementarity in acquisition of nitrogen (N) from soil and N-2-fixation within pea and barley intercrops was studied in organic field experiments across Western Europe (Denmark, United Kingdom, France, Germany and Italy). Spring pea and barley were sown either as sole crops, at the recommended plant density (P100 and B100, respectively) or in replacement (P50B50) or additive (P100B50) intercropping designs, in each of three cropping seasons (2003-2005). Irrespective of site and intercrop design, Land Equivalent Ratios (LER) between 1.4 at flowering and 1.3 at maturity showed that total N recovery was greater in the pea-barley intercrops than in the sole Crops Suggesting a high degree of complementarity over a wide range of growing conditions. Complementarity was partly attributed to greater soil mineral N acquisition by barley, forcing pea to rely more on N-2-fixation. At all sites the proportion of total aboveground pea N that was derived from N-2-fixation was greater when intercropped with barley than when grown as a sole crop. No consistent differences were found between the two intercropping designs. Simultaneously, the accumulation Of Phosphorous (P), potassium (K) and sulphur (S) in Danish and German experiments was 20% higher in the intercrop (P50B50) than in the respective sole crops, possibly influencing general crop yields and thereby competitive ability for other resources. Comparing all sites and seasons, the benefits of organic pea-barley intercropping for N acquisition were highly resilient. It is concluded that pea-barley intercropping is a relevant cropping strategy to adopt when trying to optimize N-2-fixation inputs to the cropping system. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

The symbiotic roles of empirical experimentation and thought experimentation in the learning of physics

This study was an attempt to identify the epistemological roots of knowledge when students carry out hands-on experiments in physics. We found that, within the context of designing a solution to a stated problem, subjects constructed and ran thought experiments intertwined within the processes of conducting physical experiments. We show that the process of alternating between these two modes- empirically experimenting and experimenting in thought- leads towards a convergence on scientifically acceptable concepts. We call this process mutual projection. In the process of mutual projection, external representations were generated. Objects in the physical environment were represented in an imaginary world and these representations were associated with processes in the physical world. It is through this coupling that constituents of both the imaginary world and the physical world gain meaning. We further show that the external representations are rooted in sensory interaction and constitute a semi-symbolic pictorial communication system, a sort of primitive 'language', which is developed as the practical work continues. The constituents of this pictorial communication system are used in the thought experiments taking place in association with the empirical experimentation. The results of this study provide a model of physics learning during hands-on experimentation.

Free atmospheric CO2 enrichment increased above ground biomass but did not affect symbiotic N2-fixation and soil carbon dynamics in a mixed deciduous stand in Wales

Through increases in net primary production (NPP), elevated CO2 is hypothesizes to increase the amount of plant litter entering the soil. The fate of this extra carbon on the forest floor or in mineral soil is currently not clear. Moreover, increased rates of NPP can be maintained only if forests can escape nitrogen limitation. In a Free atmospheric CO2 Enrichment (FACE) experiment near Bangor, Wales, 4 ambient CO2 and 4 FACE plots were planted with patches of Betula pendula, Alnus glutinosa and Fagus sylvatica on a former arable field. Four years after establishment, only a shallow L forest floor litter layer had formed due to intensive bioturbation. Total soil C and N contents increased irrespective of treatment and species as a result of afforestation. We could not detect an additional C sink in the soil, nor were soil C stabilization processes affected by FACE. We observed a decrease of leaf N content in Betula and Alnus under FACE, while the soil C/N ratio decreased regardless of CO2 treatment. The ratio of N taken up from the soil and by N2-fixation in Alnus was not affected by FACE. We infer that increased nitrogen use efficiency is the mechanism by which increased NPP is sustained under elevated CO2 at this site.

Plant-symbiotic fungi as chemical engineers: multi-genome analysis of the Clavicipitaceae reveals dynamics of alkaloid Loci

The fungal family Clavicipitaceae includes plant symbionts and parasites that produce several psychoactive and bioprotective alkaloids. The family includes grass symbionts in the epichloae clade (Epichloë and Neotyphodium species), which are extraordinarily diverse both in their host interactions and in their alkaloid profiles. Epichloae produce alkaloids of four distinct classes, all of which deter insects, and some—including the infamous ergot alkaloids—have potent effects on mammals. The exceptional chemotypic diversity of the epichloae may relate to their broad range of host interactions, whereby some are pathogenic and contagious, others are mutualistic and vertically transmitted (seed-borne), and still others vary in pathogenic or mutualistic behavior. We profiled the alkaloids and sequenced the genomes of 10 epichloae, three ergot fungi (Claviceps species), a morning-glory symbiont (Periglandula ipomoeae), and a bamboo pathogen (Aciculosporium take), and compared the gene clusters for four classes of alkaloids. Results indicated a strong tendency for alkaloid loci to have conserved cores that specify the skeleton structures and peripheral genes that determine chemical variations that are known to affect their pharmacological specificities. Generally, gene locations in cluster peripheries positioned them near to transposon-derived, AT-rich repeat blocks, which were probably involved in gene losses, duplications, and neofunctionalizations. The alkaloid loci in the epichloae had unusual structures riddled with large, complex, and dynamic repeat blocks. This feature was not reflective of overall differences in repeat contents in the genomes, nor was it characteristic of most other specialized metabolism loci. The organization and dynamics of alkaloid loci and abundant repeat blocks in the epichloae suggested that these fungi are under selection for alkaloid diversification. We suggest that such selection is related to the variable life histories of the epichloae, their protective roles as symbionts, and their associations with the highly speciose and ecologically diverse cool-season grasses.

Dimer formation by symbiotic donor–acceptor interaction between two molecules of a specially designed dioxomolybdenum(VI) complex containing both donor and acceptor centers – A structural, spectroscopic and DFT study

This work presents a model study for the formation of a dimeric dioxomolybdenum(VI) complex [MoO2L]2, generated by simultaneous satisfaction of acceptor and donor character existing in the corresponding monomeric Mo(VI) complex MoO2L. This mononuclear complex is specially designed to contain a coordinatively unsaturated Mo(VI) acceptor centre and a free donor group, (e.g. –NH2 group) strategically placed in the ligand skeleton [H2L = 2-hydroxyacetophenonehydrazone of 2-aminobenzoylhydrazine]. Apart from the dimer [MoO2L]2, complexes of the type MoO2L·B (where B = CH3OH, γ-picoline and imidazole) are also reported. All the complexes are characterized by elemental analysis, spectroscopic (UV–Vis, IR, 1H NMR) techniques and cyclic voltammetry. Single crystal X-ray structures of [MoO2L]2 (1), MoO2L·CH3OH (2), and MoO2L.(γ-pic) (3) have been determined and discussed. DFT calculation on these complexes corroborates experimental data and provides clue for the facile formation of this type of dimer not reported previously. The process of dimer formation may also be viewed as an interaction between two molecules of a specially designed complex acting as a monodentate ligand. This work is expected to open up a new field of design and synthesis of dimeric complexes through the process of symbiotic donor–acceptor (acid–base) interaction between two molecules of a specially designed monomer.

Molecular species delimitation of a symbiotic fig-pollinating wasp species complex reveals extreme deviation from reciprocal partner specificity

Background: Symbiotic relationships have contributed to major evolutionary innovations, the maintenance of fundamental ecosystem functions, and the generation and maintenance of biodiversity. However, the exact nature of host/symbiont associations, which has important consequences for their dynamics, is often poorly known due to limited understanding of symbiont taxonomy and species diversity. Among classical symbioses, figs and their pollinating wasps constitute a highly diverse keystone resource in tropical forest and savannah environments. Historically, they were considered to exemplify extreme reciprocal partner specificity (one-to-one host-symbiont species relationships), but recent work has revealed several more complex cases. However, there is a striking lack of studies with the specific aims of assessing symbiont diversity and how this varies across the geographic range of the host. Results: Here, we use molecular methods to investigate cryptic diversity in the pollinating wasps of a widespread Australian fig species. Standard barcoding genes and methods were not conclusive, but incorporation of phylogenetic analyses and a recently developed nuclear barcoding gene (ITS2), gave strong support for five pollinator species. Each pollinator species was most common in a different geographic region, emphasising the importance of wide geographic sampling to uncover diversity, and the scope for divergence in coevolutionary trajectories across the host plant range. In addition, most regions had multiple coexisting pollinators, raising the question of how they coexist in apparently similar or identical resource niches. Conclusion: Our study offers a striking example of extreme deviation from reciprocal partner specificity over the full geographical range of a fig-wasp system. It also suggests that superficially identical species may be able to co-exist in a mutualistic setting albeit at different frequencies in relation to their fig host’s range. We show that comprehensive sampling and molecular taxonomic techniques may be required to uncover the true structure of cryptic biodiversity underpinning intimate ecological interactions.

Effect of a symbiotic on the response to seasonal influenza vaccination is strongly influenced by degree of immunosenescence

Background Ageing increases risk of respiratory infections and impairs the response to influenza vaccination. Pre- and probiotics offer an opportunity to modulate anti-viral defenses and the response to vaccination via alteration of the gut microbiota. This study investigated the effect of a novel probiotic, Bifidobacterium longum bv. infantis CCUG 52486, combined with a prebiotic, gluco-oligosaccharide (B. longum + Gl-OS), on the response to seasonal influenza vaccination in young and older subjects in a double-blind, randomized controlled trial, taking into account the influence of immunosenescence markers at baseline. Results Vaccination resulted in a significant increase in total antibody titres, vaccine-specific IgA, IgM and IgG and seroprotection to all three subunits of the vaccine in both young and older subjects, and in general, the increases in young subjects were greater. There was little effect of the synbiotic, although it tended to reduce seroconversion to the Brisbane subunit of the vaccine and the vaccine-specific IgG response in older subjects. Immunological characterization revealed that older subjects randomized to the synbiotic had a significantly higher number of senescent (CD28-CD57+) helper T cells at baseline compared with those randomized to the placebo, and they also had significantly higher plasma levels of anti-CMV IgG and a greater tendency for CMV seropositivity. Moreover, higher numbers of CD28-CD57+ helper T cells were associated with failure to seroconvert to Brisbane, strongly suggesting that the subjects randomized to the synbiotic were already at a significant disadvantage in terms of likely ability to respond to the vaccine compared with those randomized to the placebo. Conclusions Ageing was associated with marked impairment of the antibody response to influenza vaccination in older subjects and the synbiotic failed to reverse this impairment. However, the older subjects randomized to the synbiotic were at a significant disadvantage due to a greater degree of immunosenscence at baseline compared with those randomized to the placebo. Thus, baseline differences in immunosenescence between the randomized groups are likely to have influenced the outcome of the intervention, highlighting the need for detailed immunological characterization of subjects prior to interventions.