BlueFriends: measuring, analyzing and preventing social exclusion between elementary school students

Social exclusion is a relatively recent term, whose creation is attributed to René Lenoir(Lenoir, 1974). Its concept covers a remarkably wide range of social and economic problems, and can be triggered for various reasons: mentally and physically handicapped, abused children, delinquents, multi-problem households, asocial people, and other social “misfits” (Silver, 1995, pp. 63; Foucault, 1992). With an increasingly multi-cultural population, cultural and social inequalities rapidly ascend, bringing with them the need for educational restructuring. We are living in an evermore diverse world, and children need to be educated to be receptive to the different types of people around them, especially considering social and cultural aspects. It is with these goals that inclusive education has seen an increased trend in today’s academic environment, reminding us that even though children may be taught under the same roof, discriminatory practices might still happen. There are, however, a number of developed tools to assess the various dimensions of social networks. These are mostly based on questionnaires and interviews, which tend to be fastidious and don’t allow for longitudinal, large scale measurement. This thesis introduces BlueFriends, a Bluetooth-based measurement tool for social inclusion/exclusion on elementary school classes. The main goals behind the development of this tool were a) understanding how exclusion manifests in students’ behaviors, and b) motivating pro-social behaviors on children through the use of a persuasive technology. BlueFriends is a distributed application, comprised by an application running on several smartphones, a web-hosted database and a computer providing a visual representation of the data collected on a TV screen, attempting to influence children behaviors. The application makes use of the Bluetooth device present on each phone to continuously sample the RSSI (Received Signal Strength Indication) from other phones, storing the data locally on each phone. All of the stored data is collected, processed and then inserted into the database at the end of each day. At the beginning of each recess, children are reminded of how their behaviors affect others with the help of a visual display, which consists of interactions between dogs. This display illustrates every child’s best friends, as well as which colleagues they don’t interact with as much. Several tips encouraging social interaction and inclusiveness are displayed, inspiring children to change their behaviors towards the colleagues they spend less time with. This thesis documents the process of designing, deploying and analyzing the results of two field studies. On the first study, we assess how the current developed tools are inferior to our measuring tool by deploying a measurement only study, aimed at perceiving how much information can be obtained by the BlueFriends application and attempting to understand how exclusion manifests itself in the school environment. On the second study, we pile on the previous to try and motivate pro-social behaviors on students, with the use of visual cues and recommendations. Ultimately, we confirm that our measurement tool’s results were satisfying towards measuring and changing children’s behaviors, and conclude with our thoughts on possible future work, suggesting a number of possible extensions and improvements.

Modelagem de comunicações móveis com a utilização de series temporais e geoestatísticas

O presente trabalho apresenta os resultados da modelagem de canal de propagação baseado em séries temporais multivariadas com a utilização de dados coletados em campanhas de medição e as principais características da urbanização de onze vias do centro da cidade de Belém-Pa. Modelos de função de transferência foram utilizados para avaliar efeitos na série temporal da potência do sinal recebido (dBm) que foi utilizada como variável resposta e como variáveis explicativas a altura dos prédios e as distâncias entre os prédios. Como nos modelos em séries temporais desconsideram-se as possíveis correlações entre amostras vizinhas, utilizou-se um modelo geoestatístico para se estabelecer a correção do erro deste modelo. Esta fase do trabalho consistiu em um conjunto de procedimentos necessários às técnicas geoestatísticas. Tendo como objetivo a análise em duas dimensões para dados espacialmente distribuídos, no que diz respeito à interpolação de superfícies geradas a partir das mostras georreferenciadas obtidas dos resíduos da potência do sinal recebido calculados com o modelo em séries temporais. Os resultados obtidos com o modelo proposto apresentam um bom desempenho, com erro médio quadrático na ordem de 0,33 dB em relação ao sinal medido, considerando os dados das onze vias do centro urbano da cidade de Belém/Pa. A partir do mapa de distribuição espacial da potência do sinal recebido (dBm), pode se identificar com facilidade as zonas infra ou supra dimensionadas em termos desta variável, isto é, beneficiadas ou prejudicadas com relação a recepção do sinal, o que pode resultar em um maior investimento da operadora (concessionária de telefonia celular móvel) local naquelas regiões onde o sinal é fraco.

Multi-antenna non-line-of-sight identification techniques for target localization in mobile ad-hoc networks

Target localization has a wide range of military and civilian applications in wireless mobile networks. Examples include battle-field surveillance, emergency 911 (E911), traffc alert, habitat monitoring, resource allocation, routing, and disaster mitigation. Basic localization techniques include time-of-arrival (TOA), direction-of-arrival (DOA) and received-signal strength (RSS) estimation. Techniques that are proposed based on TOA and DOA are very sensitive to the availability of Line-of-sight (LOS) which is the direct path between the transmitter and the receiver. If LOS is not available, TOA and DOA estimation errors create a large localization error. In order to reduce NLOS localization error, NLOS identifcation, mitigation, and localization techniques have been proposed. This research investigates NLOS identifcation for multiple antennas radio systems. The techniques proposed in the literature mainly use one antenna element to enable NLOS identifcation. When a single antenna is utilized, limited features of the wireless channel can be exploited to identify NLOS situations. However, in DOA-based wireless localization systems, multiple antenna elements are available. In addition, multiple antenna technology has been adopted in many widely used wireless systems such as wireless LAN 802.11n and WiMAX 802.16e which are good candidates for localization based services. In this work, the potential of spatial channel information for high performance NLOS identifcation is investigated. Considering narrowband multiple antenna wireless systems, two xvNLOS identifcation techniques are proposed. Here, the implementation of spatial correlation of channel coeffcients across antenna elements as a metric for NLOS identifcation is proposed. In order to obtain the spatial correlation, a new multi-input multi-output (MIMO) channel model based on rough surface theory is proposed. This model can be used to compute the spatial correlation between the antenna pair separated by any distance. In addition, a new NLOS identifcation technique that exploits the statistics of phase difference across two antenna elements is proposed. This technique assumes the phases received across two antenna elements are uncorrelated. This assumption is validated based on the well-known circular and elliptic scattering models. Next, it is proved that the channel Rician K-factor is a function of the phase difference variance. Exploiting Rician K-factor, techniques to identify NLOS scenarios are proposed. Considering wideband multiple antenna wireless systems which use MIMO-orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) signaling, space-time-frequency channel correlation is exploited to attain NLOS identifcation in time-varying, frequency-selective and spaceselective radio channels. Novel NLOS identi?cation measures based on space, time and frequency channel correlation are proposed and their performances are evaluated. These measures represent a better NLOS identifcation performance compared to those that only use space, time or frequency.

SDR-based Passive Indoor Localization System for GSM

This study deals with indoor positioning using GSM radio, which has the distinct advantage of wide coverage over other wireless technologies. In particular, we focus on passive localization systems that are able to achieve high localization accuracy without any prior knowledge of the indoor environment or the tracking device radio settings. In order to overcome these challenges, newly proposed localization algorithms based on the exploitation of the received signal strength (RSS) are proposed. We explore the effects of non-line-of-sight communication links, opening and closing of doors, and human mobility on RSS measurements and localization accuracy. We have implemented the proposed algorithms on top of software defined radio systems and carried out detailed empirical indoor experiments. The performance results show that the proposed solutions are accurate with average localization errors between 2.4 and 3.2 meters.

Range-based Weighted-likelihood Particle Filter for RSS-based Indoor Tracking

Attractive business cases in various application fields contribute to the sustained long-term interest in indoor localization and tracking by the research community. Location tracking is generally treated as a dynamic state estimation problem, consisting of two steps: (i) location estimation through measurement, and (ii) location prediction. For the estimation step, one of the most efficient and low-cost solutions is Received Signal Strength (RSS)-based ranging. However, various challenges - unrealistic propagation model, non-line of sight (NLOS), and multipath propagation - are yet to be addressed. Particle filters are a popular choice for dealing with the inherent non-linearities in both location measurements and motion dynamics. While such filters have been successfully applied to accurate, time-based ranging measurements, dealing with the more error-prone RSS based ranging is still challenging. In this work, we address the above issues with a novel, weighted likelihood, bootstrap particle filter for tracking via RSS-based ranging. Our filter weights the individual likelihoods from different anchor nodes exponentially, according to the ranging estimation. We also employ an improved propagation model for more accurate RSS-based ranging, which we suggested in recent work. We implemented and tested our algorithm in a passive localization system with IEEE 802.15.4 signals, showing that our proposed solution largely outperforms a traditional bootstrap particle filter.

Fine-grained indoor positioning and tracking systems

Indoor positioning has attracted considerable attention for decades due to the increasing demands for location based services. In the past years, although numerous methods have been proposed for indoor positioning, it is still challenging to find a convincing solution that combines high positioning accuracy and ease of deployment. Radio-based indoor positioning has emerged as a dominant method due to its ubiquitousness, especially for WiFi. RSSI (Received Signal Strength Indicator) has been investigated in the area of indoor positioning for decades. However, it is prone to multipath propagation and hence fingerprinting has become the most commonly used method for indoor positioning using RSSI. The drawback of fingerprinting is that it requires intensive labour efforts to calibrate the radio map prior to experiments, which makes the deployment of the positioning system very time consuming. Using time information as another way for radio-based indoor positioning is challenged by time synchronization among anchor nodes and timestamp accuracy. Besides radio-based positioning methods, intensive research has been conducted to make use of inertial sensors for indoor tracking due to the fast developments of smartphones. However, these methods are normally prone to accumulative errors and might not be available for some applications, such as passive positioning. This thesis focuses on network-based indoor positioning and tracking systems, mainly for passive positioning, which does not require the participation of targets in the positioning process. To achieve high positioning accuracy, we work on some information of radio signals from physical-layer processing, such as timestamps and channel information. The contributions in this thesis can be divided into two parts: time-based positioning and channel information based positioning. First, for time-based indoor positioning (especially for narrow-band signals), we address challenges for compensating synchronization offsets among anchor nodes, designing timestamps with high resolution, and developing accurate positioning methods. Second, we work on range-based positioning methods with channel information to passively locate and track WiFi targets. Targeting less efforts for deployment, we work on range-based methods, which require much less calibration efforts than fingerprinting. By designing some novel enhanced methods for both ranging and positioning (including trilateration for stationary targets and particle filter for mobile targets), we are able to locate WiFi targets with high accuracy solely relying on radio signals and our proposed enhanced particle filter significantly outperforms the other commonly used range-based positioning algorithms, e.g., a traditional particle filter, extended Kalman filter and trilateration algorithms. In addition to using radio signals for passive positioning, we propose a second enhanced particle filter for active positioning to fuse inertial sensor and channel information to track indoor targets, which achieves higher tracking accuracy than tracking methods solely relying on either radio signals or inertial sensors.

An energy-efficient strategy for combined RSS-PDR indoor localization

We propose an optimization-based framework to minimize the energy consumption in a sensor network when using an indoor localization system based on the combination of received signal strength (RSS) and pedestrian dead reckoning (PDR). The objective is to find the RSS localization frequency and the number of RSS measurements used at each localization round that jointly minimize the total consumed energy, while ensuring at the same time a desired accuracy in the localization result. The optimization approach leverages practical models to predict the localization error and the overall energy consumption for combined RSS-PDR localization systems. The performance of the proposed strategy is assessed through simulation, showing energy savings with respect to other approaches while guaranteeing a target accuracy.

Dynamic chanel model LMS updating for RSS-based localization

Received signal strength-based localization systems usually rely on a calibration process that aims at characterizing the propagation channel. However, due to the changing environmental dynamics, the behavior of the channel may change after some time, thus, recalibration processes are necessary to maintain the positioning accuracy. This paper proposes a dynamic calibration method to initially calibrate and subsequently update the parameters of the propagation channel model using a Least Mean Squares approach. The method assumes that each anchor node in the localization infrastructure is characterized by its own propagation channel model. In practice, a set of sniffers is used to collect RSS samples, which will be used to automatically calibrate each channel model by iteratively minimizing the positioning error. The proposed method is validated through numerical simulation, showing that the positioning error of the mobile nodes is effectively reduced. Furthermore, the method has a very low computational cost; therefore it can be used in real-time operation for wireless resource-constrained nodes.

Distributed collaborative processing in wireless sensor networks with application to target localization and beamforming

Abstract The proliferation of wireless sensor networks and the variety of envisioned applications associated with them has motivated the development of distributed algorithms for collaborative processing over networked systems. One of the applications that has attracted the attention of the researchers is that of target localization where the nodes of the network try to estimate the position of an unknown target that lies within its coverage area. Particularly challenging is the problem of estimating the target’s position when we use received signal strength indicator (RSSI) due to the nonlinear relationship between the measured signal and the true position of the target. Many of the existing approaches suffer either from high computational complexity (e.g., particle filters) or lack of accuracy. Further, many of the proposed solutions are centralized which make their application to a sensor network questionable. Depending on the application at hand and, from a practical perspective it could be convenient to find a balance between localization accuracy and complexity. Into this direction we approach the maximum likelihood location estimation problem by solving a suboptimal (and more tractable) problem. One of the main advantages of the proposed scheme is that it allows for a decentralized implementation using distributed processing tools (e.g., consensus and convex optimization) and therefore, it is very suitable to be implemented in real sensor networks. If further accuracy is needed an additional refinement step could be performed around the found solution. Under the assumption of independent noise among the nodes such local search can be done in a fully distributed way using a distributed version of the Gauss-Newton method based on consensus. Regardless of the underlying application or function of the sensor network it is al¬ways necessary to have a mechanism for data reporting. While some approaches use a special kind of nodes (called sink nodes) for data harvesting and forwarding to the outside world, there are however some scenarios where such an approach is impractical or even impossible to deploy. Further, such sink nodes become a bottleneck in terms of traffic flow and power consumption. To overcome these issues instead of using sink nodes for data reporting one could use collaborative beamforming techniques to forward directly the generated data to a base station or gateway to the outside world. In a dis-tributed environment like a sensor network nodes cooperate in order to form a virtual antenna array that can exploit the benefits of multi-antenna communications. In col-laborative beamforming nodes synchronize their phases in order to add constructively at the receiver. Some of the inconveniences associated with collaborative beamforming techniques is that there is no control over the radiation pattern since it is treated as a random quantity. This may cause interference to other coexisting systems and fast bat-tery depletion at the nodes. Since energy-efficiency is a major design issue we consider the development of a distributed collaborative beamforming scheme that maximizes the network lifetime while meeting some quality of service (QoS) requirement at the re¬ceiver side. Using local information about battery status and channel conditions we find distributed algorithms that converge to the optimal centralized beamformer. While in the first part we consider only battery depletion due to communications beamforming, we extend the model to account for more realistic scenarios by the introduction of an additional random energy consumption. It is shown how the new problem generalizes the original one and under which conditions it is easily solvable. By formulating the problem under the energy-efficiency perspective the network’s lifetime is significantly improved. Resumen La proliferación de las redes inalámbricas de sensores junto con la gran variedad de posi¬bles aplicaciones relacionadas, han motivado el desarrollo de herramientas y algoritmos necesarios para el procesado cooperativo en sistemas distribuidos. Una de las aplicaciones que suscitado mayor interés entre la comunidad científica es la de localization, donde el conjunto de nodos de la red intenta estimar la posición de un blanco localizado dentro de su área de cobertura. El problema de la localization es especialmente desafiante cuando se usan niveles de energía de la seal recibida (RSSI por sus siglas en inglés) como medida para la localization. El principal inconveniente reside en el hecho que el nivel de señal recibida no sigue una relación lineal con la posición del blanco. Muchas de las soluciones actuales al problema de localization usando RSSI se basan en complejos esquemas centralizados como filtros de partículas, mientas que en otras se basan en esquemas mucho más simples pero con menor precisión. Además, en muchos casos las estrategias son centralizadas lo que resulta poco prácticos para su implementación en redes de sensores. Desde un punto de vista práctico y de implementation, es conveniente, para ciertos escenarios y aplicaciones, el desarrollo de alternativas que ofrezcan un compromiso entre complejidad y precisión. En esta línea, en lugar de abordar directamente el problema de la estimación de la posición del blanco bajo el criterio de máxima verosimilitud, proponemos usar una formulación subóptima del problema más manejable analíticamente y que ofrece la ventaja de permitir en¬contrar la solución al problema de localization de una forma totalmente distribuida, convirtiéndola así en una solución atractiva dentro del contexto de redes inalámbricas de sensores. Para ello, se usan herramientas de procesado distribuido como los algorit¬mos de consenso y de optimización convexa en sistemas distribuidos. Para aplicaciones donde se requiera de un mayor grado de precisión se propone una estrategia que con¬siste en la optimización local de la función de verosimilitud entorno a la estimación inicialmente obtenida. Esta optimización se puede realizar de forma descentralizada usando una versión basada en consenso del método de Gauss-Newton siempre y cuando asumamos independencia de los ruidos de medida en los diferentes nodos. Independientemente de la aplicación subyacente de la red de sensores, es necesario tener un mecanismo que permita recopilar los datos provenientes de la red de sensores. Una forma de hacerlo es mediante el uso de uno o varios nodos especiales, llamados nodos “sumidero”, (sink en inglés) que actúen como centros recolectores de información y que estarán equipados con hardware adicional que les permita la interacción con el exterior de la red. La principal desventaja de esta estrategia es que dichos nodos se convierten en cuellos de botella en cuanto a tráfico y capacidad de cálculo. Como alter¬nativa se pueden usar técnicas cooperativas de conformación de haz (beamforming en inglés) de manera que el conjunto de la red puede verse como un único sistema virtual de múltiples antenas y, por tanto, que exploten los beneficios que ofrecen las comu¬nicaciones con múltiples antenas. Para ello, los distintos nodos de la red sincronizan sus transmisiones de manera que se produce una interferencia constructiva en el recep¬tor. No obstante, las actuales técnicas se basan en resultados promedios y asintóticos, cuando el número de nodos es muy grande. Para una configuración específica se pierde el control sobre el diagrama de radiación causando posibles interferencias sobre sis¬temas coexistentes o gastando más potencia de la requerida. La eficiencia energética es una cuestión capital en las redes inalámbricas de sensores ya que los nodos están equipados con baterías. Es por tanto muy importante preservar la batería evitando cambios innecesarios y el consecuente aumento de costes. Bajo estas consideraciones, se propone un esquema de conformación de haz que maximice el tiempo de vida útil de la red, entendiendo como tal el máximo tiempo que la red puede estar operativa garantizando unos requisitos de calidad de servicio (QoS por sus siglas en inglés) que permitan una decodificación fiable de la señal recibida en la estación base. Se proponen además algoritmos distribuidos que convergen a la solución centralizada. Inicialmente se considera que la única causa de consumo energético se debe a las comunicaciones con la estación base. Este modelo de consumo energético es modificado para tener en cuenta otras formas de consumo de energía derivadas de procesos inherentes al funcionamiento de la red como la adquisición y procesado de datos, las comunicaciones locales entre nodos, etc. Dicho consumo adicional de energía se modela como una variable aleatoria en cada nodo. Se cambia por tanto, a un escenario probabilístico que generaliza el caso determinista y se proporcionan condiciones bajo las cuales el problema se puede resolver de forma eficiente. Se demuestra que el tiempo de vida de la red mejora de forma significativa usando el criterio propuesto de eficiencia energética.

A practical approach for outdoors distributed target localization in wireless sensor networks

Wireless sensor networks are posed as the new communication paradigm where the use of small, low-complexity, and low-power devices is preferred over costly centralized systems. The spectra of potential applications of sensor networks is very wide, ranging from monitoring, surveillance, and localization, among others. Localization is a key application in sensor networks and the use of simple, efficient, and distributed algorithms is of paramount practical importance. Combining convex optimization tools with consensus algorithms we propose a distributed localization algorithm for scenarios where received signal strength indicator readings are used. We approach the localization problem by formulating an alternative problem that uses distance estimates locally computed at each node. The formulated problem is solved by a relaxed version using semidefinite relaxation technique. Conditions under which the relaxed problem yields to the same solution as the original problem are given and a distributed consensusbased implementation of the algorithm is proposed based on an augmented Lagrangian approach and primaldual decomposition methods. Although suboptimal, the proposed approach is very suitable for its implementation in real sensor networks, i.e., it is scalable, robust against node failures and requires only local communication among neighboring nodes. Simulation results show that running an additional local search around the found solution can yield performance close to the maximum likelihood estimate.

A novel methodology for planning reliable wireless sensor networks

Wireless sensor networks (WSNs) have shown their potentials in various applications, which bring a lot of benefits to users from both research and industrial areas. For many setups, it is envisioned thatWSNs will consist of tens to hundreds of nodes that operate on small batteries. However due to the diversity of the deployed environments and resource constraints on radio communication, sensing ability and energy supply, it is a very challenging issue to plan optimized WSN topology and predict its performance before real deployment. During the network planning phase, the connectivity, coverage, cost, network longevity and service quality should all be considered. Therefore it requires designers coping with comprehensive and interdisciplinary knowledge, including networking, radio engineering, embedded system and so on, in order to efficiently construct a reliable WSN for any specific types of environment. Nowadays there is still a lack of the analysis and experiences to guide WSN designers to efficiently construct WSN topology successfully without many trials. Therefore, simulation is a feasible approach to the quantitative analysis of the performance of wireless sensor networks. However the existing planning algorithms and tools, to some extent, have serious limitations to practically design reliable WSN topology: Only a few of them tackle the 3D deployment issue, and an overwhelming number of works are proposed to place devices in 2D scheme. Without considering the full dimension, the impacts of environment to the performance of WSN are not completely studied, thus the values of evaluated metrics such as connectivity and sensing coverage are not sufficiently accurate to make proper decision. Even fewer planning methods model the sensing coverage and radio propagation by considering the realistic scenario where obstacles exist. Radio signals propagate with multi-path phenomenon in the real world, in which direct paths, reflected paths and diffracted paths contribute to the received signal strength. Besides, obstacles between the path of sensor and objects might block the sensing signals, thus create coverage hole in the application. None of the existing planning algorithms model the network longevity and packet delivery capability properly and practically. They often employ unilateral and unrealistic formulations. The optimization targets are often one-sided in the current works. Without comprehensive evaluation on the important metrics, the performance of planned WSNs can not be reliable and entirely optimized. Modeling of environment is usually time consuming and the cost is very high, while none of the current works figure out any method to model the 3D deployment environment efficiently and accurately. Therefore many researchers are trapped by this issue, and their algorithms can only be evaluated in the same scenario, without the possibility to test the robustness and feasibility for implementations in different environments. In this thesis, we propose a novel planning methodology and an intelligent WSN planning tool to assist WSN designers efficiently planning reliable WSNs. First of all, a new method is proposed to efficiently and automatically model the 3D indoor and outdoor environments. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that the advantages of image understanding algorithm are applied to automatically reconstruct 3D outdoor and indoor scenarios for signal propagation and network planning purpose. The experimental results indicate that the proposed methodology is able to accurately recognize different objects from the satellite images of the outdoor target regions and from the scanned floor plan of indoor area. Its mechanism offers users a flexibility to reconstruct different types of environment without any human interaction. Thereby it significantly reduces human efforts, cost and time spent on reconstructing a 3D geographic database and allows WSN designers concentrating on the planning issues. Secondly, an efficient ray-tracing engine is developed to accurately and practically model the radio propagation and sensing signal on the constructed 3D map. The engine contributes on efficiency and accuracy to the estimated results. By using image processing concepts, including the kd-tree space division algorithm and modified polar sweep algorithm, the rays are traced efficiently without detecting all the primitives in the scene. The radio propagation model iv is proposed, which emphasizes not only the materials of obstacles but also their locations along the signal path. The sensing signal of sensor nodes, which is sensitive to the obstacles, is benefit from the ray-tracing algorithm via obstacle detection. The performance of this modelling method is robust and accurate compared with conventional methods, and experimental results imply that this methodology is suitable for both outdoor urban scenes and indoor environments. Moreover, it can be applied to either GSM communication or ZigBee protocol by varying frequency parameter of the radio propagation model. Thirdly, WSN planning method is proposed to tackle the above mentioned challenges and efficiently deploy reliable WSNs. More metrics (connectivity, coverage, cost, lifetime, packet latency and packet drop rate) are modeled more practically compared with other works. Especially 3D ray tracing method is used to model the radio link and sensing signal which are sensitive to the obstruction of obstacles; network routing is constructed by using AODV protocol; the network longevity, packet delay and packet drop rate are obtained via simulating practical events in WSNet simulator, which to the best of our knowledge, is the first time that network simulator is involved in a planning algorithm. Moreover, a multi-objective optimization algorithm is developed to cater for the characteristics of WSNs. The capability of providing multiple optimized solutions simultaneously allows users making their own decisions accordingly, and the results are more comprehensively optimized compared with other state-of-the-art algorithms. iMOST is developed by integrating the introduced algorithms, to assist WSN designers efficiently planning reliable WSNs for different configurations. The abbreviated name iMOST stands for an Intelligent Multi-objective Optimization Sensor network planning Tool. iMOST contributes on: (1) Convenient operation with a user-friendly vision system; (2) Efficient and automatic 3D database reconstruction and fast 3D objects design for both indoor and outdoor environments; (3) It provides multiple multi-objective optimized 3D deployment solutions and allows users to configure the network properties, hence it can adapt to various WSN applications; (4) Deployment solutions in the 3D space and the corresponding evaluated performance are visually presented to users; and (5) The Node Placement Module of iMOST is available online as well as the source code of the other two rebuilt heuristics. Therefore WSN designers will be benefit from v this tool on efficiently constructing environment database, practically and efficiently planning reliable WSNs for both outdoor and indoor applications. With the open source codes, they are also able to compare their developed algorithms with ours to contribute to this academic field. Finally, solid real results are obtained for both indoor and outdoor WSN planning. Deployments have been realized for both indoor and outdoor environments based on the provided planning solutions. The measured results coincide well with the estimated results. The proposed planning algorithm is adaptable according to the WSN designer’s desirability and configuration, and it offers flexibility to plan small and large scale, indoor and outdoor 3D deployments. The thesis is organized in 7 chapters. In Chapter 1, WSN applications and motivations of this work are introduced, the state-of-the-art planning algorithms and tools are reviewed, challenges are stated out and the proposed methodology is briefly introduced. In Chapter 2, the proposed 3D environment reconstruction methodology is introduced and its performance is evaluated for both outdoor and indoor environment. The developed ray-tracing engine and proposed radio propagation modelling method are described in details in Chapter 3, their performances are evaluated in terms of computation efficiency and accuracy. Chapter 4 presents the modelling of important metrics of WSNs and the proposed multi-objective optimization planning algorithm, the performance is compared with the other state-of-the-art planning algorithms. The intelligent WSN planning tool iMOST is described in Chapter 5. RealWSN deployments are prosecuted based on the planned solutions for both indoor and outdoor scenarios, important data are measured and results are analysed in Chapter 6. Chapter 7 concludes the thesis and discusses about future works. vi Resumen en Castellano Las redes de sensores inalámbricas (en inglés Wireless Sensor Networks, WSNs) han demostrado su potencial en diversas aplicaciones que aportan una gran cantidad de beneficios para el campo de la investigación y de la industria. Para muchas configuraciones se prevé que las WSNs consistirán en decenas o cientos de nodos que funcionarán con baterías pequeñas. Sin embargo, debido a la diversidad de los ambientes para desplegar las redes y a las limitaciones de recursos en materia de comunicación de radio, capacidad de detección y suministro de energía, la planificación de la topología de la red y la predicción de su rendimiento es un tema muy difícil de tratar antes de la implementación real. Durante la fase de planificación del despliegue de la red se deben considerar aspectos como la conectividad, la cobertura, el coste, la longevidad de la red y la calidad del servicio. Por lo tanto, requiere de diseñadores con un amplio e interdisciplinario nivel de conocimiento que incluye la creación de redes, la ingeniería de radio y los sistemas embebidos entre otros, con el fin de construir de manera eficiente una WSN confiable para cualquier tipo de entorno. Hoy en día todavía hay una falta de análisis y experiencias que orienten a los diseñadores de WSN para construir las topologías WSN de manera eficiente sin realizar muchas pruebas. Por lo tanto, la simulación es un enfoque viable para el análisis cuantitativo del rendimiento de las redes de sensores inalámbricos. Sin embargo, los algoritmos y herramientas de planificación existentes tienen, en cierta medida, serias limitaciones para diseñar en la práctica una topología fiable de WSN: Sólo unos pocos abordan la cuestión del despliegue 3D mientras que existe una gran cantidad de trabajos que colocan los dispositivos en 2D. Si no se analiza la dimensión completa (3D), los efectos del entorno en el desempeño de WSN no se estudian por completo, por lo que los valores de los parámetros evaluados, como la conectividad y la cobertura de detección, no son lo suficientemente precisos para tomar la decisión correcta. Aún en menor medida los métodos de planificación modelan la cobertura de los sensores y la propagación de la señal de radio teniendo en cuenta un escenario realista donde existan obstáculos. Las señales de radio en el mundo real siguen una propagación multicamino, en la que los caminos directos, los caminos reflejados y los caminos difractados contribuyen a la intensidad de la señal recibida. Además, los obstáculos entre el recorrido del sensor y los objetos pueden bloquear las señales de detección y por lo tanto crear áreas sin cobertura en la aplicación. Ninguno de los algoritmos de planificación existentes modelan el tiempo de vida de la red y la capacidad de entrega de paquetes correctamente y prácticamente. A menudo se emplean formulaciones unilaterales y poco realistas. Los objetivos de optimización son a menudo tratados unilateralmente en los trabajos actuales. Sin una evaluación exhaustiva de los parámetros importantes, el rendimiento previsto de las redes inalámbricas de sensores no puede ser fiable y totalmente optimizado. Por lo general, el modelado del entorno conlleva mucho tiempo y tiene un coste muy alto, pero ninguno de los trabajos actuales propone algún método para modelar el entorno de despliegue 3D con eficiencia y precisión. Por lo tanto, muchos investigadores están limitados por este problema y sus algoritmos sólo se pueden evaluar en el mismo escenario, sin la posibilidad de probar la solidez y viabilidad para las implementaciones en diferentes entornos. En esta tesis, se propone una nueva metodología de planificación así como una herramienta inteligente de planificación de redes de sensores inalámbricas para ayudar a los diseñadores a planificar WSNs fiables de una manera eficiente. En primer lugar, se propone un nuevo método para modelar demanera eficiente y automática los ambientes interiores y exteriores en 3D. Según nuestros conocimientos hasta la fecha, esta es la primera vez que las ventajas del algoritmo de _image understanding_se aplican para reconstruir automáticamente los escenarios exteriores e interiores en 3D para analizar la propagación de la señal y viii la planificación de la red. Los resultados experimentales indican que la metodología propuesta es capaz de reconocer con precisión los diferentes objetos presentes en las imágenes satelitales de las regiones objetivo en el exterior y de la planta escaneada en el interior. Su mecanismo ofrece a los usuarios la flexibilidad para reconstruir los diferentes tipos de entornos sin ninguna interacción humana. De este modo se reduce considerablemente el esfuerzo humano, el coste y el tiempo invertido en la reconstrucción de una base de datos geográfica con información 3D, permitiendo así que los diseñadores se concentren en los temas de planificación. En segundo lugar, se ha desarrollado un motor de trazado de rayos (en inglés ray tracing) eficiente para modelar con precisión la propagación de la señal de radio y la señal de los sensores en el mapa 3D construido. El motor contribuye a la eficiencia y la precisión de los resultados estimados. Mediante el uso de los conceptos de procesamiento de imágenes, incluyendo el algoritmo del árbol kd para la división del espacio y el algoritmo _polar sweep_modificado, los rayos se trazan de manera eficiente sin la detección de todas las primitivas en la escena. El modelo de propagación de radio que se propone no sólo considera los materiales de los obstáculos, sino también su ubicación a lo largo de la ruta de señal. La señal de los sensores de los nodos, que es sensible a los obstáculos, se ve beneficiada por la detección de objetos llevada a cabo por el algoritmo de trazado de rayos. El rendimiento de este método de modelado es robusto y preciso en comparación con los métodos convencionales, y los resultados experimentales indican que esta metodología es adecuada tanto para escenas urbanas al aire libre como para ambientes interiores. Por otra parte, se puede aplicar a cualquier comunicación GSM o protocolo ZigBee mediante la variación de la frecuencia del modelo de propagación de radio. En tercer lugar, se propone un método de planificación de WSNs para hacer frente a los desafíos mencionados anteriormente y desplegar redes de sensores fiables de manera eficiente. Se modelan más parámetros (conectividad, cobertura, coste, tiempo de vida, la latencia de paquetes y tasa de caída de paquetes) en comparación con otros trabajos. Especialmente el método de trazado de rayos 3D se utiliza para modelar el enlace de radio y señal de los sensores que son sensibles a la obstrucción de obstáculos; el enrutamiento de la red se construye utilizando el protocolo AODV; la longevidad de la red, retardo de paquetes ix y tasa de abandono de paquetes se obtienen a través de la simulación de eventos prácticos en el simulador WSNet, y según nuestros conocimientos hasta la fecha, es la primera vez que simulador de red está implicado en un algoritmo de planificación. Por otra parte, se ha desarrollado un algoritmo de optimización multi-objetivo para satisfacer las características de las redes inalámbricas de sensores. La capacidad de proporcionar múltiples soluciones optimizadas de forma simultánea permite a los usuarios tomar sus propias decisiones en consecuencia, obteniendo mejores resultados en comparación con otros algoritmos del estado del arte. iMOST se desarrolla mediante la integración de los algoritmos presentados, para ayudar de forma eficiente a los diseñadores en la planificación de WSNs fiables para diferentes configuraciones. El nombre abreviado iMOST (Intelligent Multi-objective Optimization Sensor network planning Tool) representa una herramienta inteligente de planificación de redes de sensores con optimización multi-objetivo. iMOST contribuye en: (1) Operación conveniente con una interfaz de fácil uso, (2) Reconstrucción eficiente y automática de una base de datos con información 3D y diseño rápido de objetos 3D para ambientes interiores y exteriores, (3) Proporciona varias soluciones de despliegue optimizadas para los multi-objetivo en 3D y permite a los usuarios configurar las propiedades de red, por lo que puede adaptarse a diversas aplicaciones de WSN, (4) las soluciones de implementación en el espacio 3D y el correspondiente rendimiento evaluado se presentan visualmente a los usuarios, y (5) El _Node Placement Module_de iMOST está disponible en línea, así como el código fuente de las otras dos heurísticas de planificación. Por lo tanto los diseñadores WSN se beneficiarán de esta herramienta para la construcción eficiente de la base de datos con información del entorno, la planificación práctica y eficiente de WSNs fiables tanto para aplicaciones interiores y exteriores. Con los códigos fuente abiertos, son capaces de comparar sus algoritmos desarrollados con los nuestros para contribuir a este campo académico. Por último, se obtienen resultados reales sólidos tanto para la planificación de WSN en interiores y exteriores. Los despliegues se han realizado tanto para ambientes de interior y como para ambientes de exterior utilizando las soluciones de planificación propuestas. Los resultados medidos coinciden en gran medida con los resultados estimados. El algoritmo de planificación x propuesto se adapta convenientemente al deiseño de redes de sensores inalámbricas, y ofrece flexibilidad para planificar los despliegues 3D a pequeña y gran escala tanto en interiores como en exteriores. La tesis se estructura en 7 capítulos. En el Capítulo 1, se presentan las aplicaciones de WSN y motivaciones de este trabajo, se revisan los algoritmos y herramientas de planificación del estado del arte, se presentan los retos y se describe brevemente la metodología propuesta. En el Capítulo 2, se presenta la metodología de reconstrucción de entornos 3D propuesta y su rendimiento es evaluado tanto para espacios exteriores como para espacios interiores. El motor de trazado de rayos desarrollado y el método de modelado de propagación de radio propuesto se describen en detalle en el Capítulo 3, evaluándose en términos de eficiencia computacional y precisión. En el Capítulo 4 se presenta el modelado de los parámetros importantes de las WSNs y el algoritmo de planificación de optimización multi-objetivo propuesto, el rendimiento se compara con los otros algoritmos de planificación descritos en el estado del arte. La herramienta inteligente de planificación de redes de sensores inalámbricas, iMOST, se describe en el Capítulo 5. En el Capítulo 6 se llevan a cabo despliegues reales de acuerdo a las soluciones previstas para los escenarios interiores y exteriores, se miden los datos importantes y se analizan los resultados. En el Capítulo 7 se concluye la tesis y se discute acerca de los trabajos futuros.

Multi-agent location system in wireless networks

In this paper we propose a flexible Multi-Agent Architecture together with a methodology for indoor location which allows us to locate any mobile station (MS) such as a Laptop, Smartphone, Tablet or a robotic system in an indoor environment using wireless technology. Our technology is complementary to the GPS location finder as it allows us to locate a mobile system in a specific room on a specific floor using the Wi-Fi networks. The idea is that any MS will have an agent known at a Fuzzy Location Software Agent (FLSA) with a minimum capacity processing at its disposal which collects the power received at different Access Points distributed around the floor and establish its location on a plan of the floor of the building. In order to do so it will have to communicate with the Fuzzy Location Manager Software Agent (FLMSA). The FLMSAs are local agents that form part of the management infrastructure of the Wi-Fi network of the Organization. The FLMSA implements a location estimation methodology divided into three phases (measurement, calibration and estimation) for locating mobile stations (MS). Our solution is a fingerprint-based positioning system that overcomes the problem of the relative effect of doors and walls on signal strength and is independent of the network device manufacturer. In the measurement phase, our system collects received signal strength indicator (RSSI) measurements from multiple access points. In the calibration phase, our system uses these measurements in a normalization process to create a radio map, a database of RSS patterns. Unlike traditional radio map-based methods, our methodology normalizes RSS measurements collected at different locations on a floor. In the third phase, we use Fuzzy Controllers to locate an MS on the plan of the floor of a building. Experimental results demonstrate the accuracy of the proposed method. From these results it is clear that the system is highly likely to be able to locate an MS in a room or adjacent room.

Contribución a la localización en interiores basada en comunicaciones inalámbricas

Determinar con buena precisión la posición en la que se encuentra un terminal móvil, cuando éste se halla inmerso en un entorno de interior (centros comerciales, edificios de oficinas, aeropuertos, estaciones, túneles, etc), es el pilar básico sobre el que se sustentan un gran número de aplicaciones y servicios. Muchos de esos servicios se encuentran ya disponibles en entornos de exterior, aunque los entornos de interior se prestan a otros servicios específicos para ellos. Ese número, sin embargo, podría ser significativamente mayor de lo que actualmente es, si no fuera necesaria una costosa infraestructura para llevar a cabo el posicionamiento con la precisión adecuada a cada uno de los hipotéticos servicios. O, igualmente, si la citada infraestructura pudiera tener otros usos distintos, además del relacionado con el posicionamiento. La usabilidad de la misma infraestructura para otros fines distintos ofrecería la oportunidad de que la misma estuviera ya presente en las diferentes localizaciones, porque ha sido previamente desplegada para esos otros usos; o bien facilitaría su despliegue, porque el coste de esa operación ofreciera un mayor retorno de usabilidad para quien lo realiza. Las tecnologías inalámbricas de comunicaciones basadas en radiofrecuencia, ya en uso para las comunicaciones de voz y datos (móviles, WLAN, etc), cumplen el requisito anteriormente indicado y, por tanto, facilitarían el crecimiento de las aplicaciones y servicios basados en el posicionamiento, en el caso de poderse emplear para ello. Sin embargo, determinar la posición con el nivel de precisión adecuado mediante el uso de estas tecnologías, es un importante reto hoy en día. El presente trabajo pretende aportar avances significativos en este campo. A lo largo del mismo se llevará a cabo, en primer lugar, un estudio de los principales algoritmos y técnicas auxiliares de posicionamiento aplicables en entornos de interior. La revisión se centrará en aquellos que sean aptos tanto para tecnologías móviles de última generación como para entornos WLAN. Con ello, se pretende poner de relieve las ventajas e inconvenientes de cada uno de estos algoritmos, teniendo como motivación final su aplicabilidad tanto al mundo de las redes móviles 3G y 4G (en especial a las femtoceldas y small-cells LTE) como al indicado entorno WLAN; y teniendo siempre presente que el objetivo último es que vayan a ser usados en interiores. La principal conclusión de esa revisión es que las técnicas de triangulación, comúnmente empleadas para realizar la localización en entornos de exterior, se muestran inútiles en los entornos de interior, debido a efectos adversos propios de este tipo de entornos como la pérdida de visión directa o los caminos múltiples en el recorrido de la señal. Los métodos de huella radioeléctrica, más conocidos bajo el término inglés “fingerprinting”, que se basan en la comparación de los valores de potencia de señal que se están recibiendo en el momento de llevar a cabo el posicionamiento por un terminal móvil, frente a los valores registrados en un mapa radio de potencias, elaborado durante una fase inicial de calibración, aparecen como los mejores de entre los posibles para los escenarios de interior. Sin embargo, estos sistemas se ven también afectados por otros problemas, como por ejemplo los importantes trabajos a realizar para ponerlos en marcha, y la variabilidad del canal. Frente a ellos, en el presente trabajo se presentan dos contribuciones originales para mejorar los sistemas basados en los métodos fingerprinting. La primera de esas contribuciones describe un método para determinar, de manera sencilla, las características básicas del sistema a nivel del número de muestras necesarias para crear el mapa radio de la huella radioeléctrica de referencia, junto al número mínimo de emisores de radiofrecuencia que habrá que desplegar; todo ello, a partir de unos requerimientos iniciales relacionados con el error y la precisión buscados en el posicionamiento a realizar, a los que uniremos los datos correspondientes a las dimensiones y realidad física del entorno. De esa forma, se establecen unas pautas iniciales a la hora de dimensionar el sistema, y se combaten los efectos negativos que, sobre el coste o el rendimiento del sistema en su conjunto, son debidos a un despliegue ineficiente de los emisores de radiofrecuencia y de los puntos de captura de su huella. La segunda contribución incrementa la precisión resultante del sistema en tiempo real, gracias a una técnica de recalibración automática del mapa radio de potencias. Esta técnica tiene en cuenta las medidas reportadas continuamente por unos pocos puntos de referencia estáticos, estratégicamente distribuidos en el entorno, para recalcular y actualizar las potencias registradas en el mapa radio. Un beneficio adicional a nivel operativo de la citada técnica, es la prolongación del tiempo de usabilidad fiable del sistema, bajando la frecuencia en la que se requiere volver a capturar el mapa radio de potencias completo. Las mejoras anteriormente citadas serán de aplicación directa en la mejora de los mecanismos de posicionamiento en interiores basados en la infraestructura inalámbrica de comunicaciones de voz y datos. A partir de ahí, esa mejora será extensible y de aplicabilidad sobre los servicios de localización (conocimiento personal del lugar donde uno mismo se encuentra), monitorización (conocimiento por terceros del citado lugar) y seguimiento (monitorización prolongada en el tiempo), ya que todos ellas toman como base un correcto posicionamiento para un adecuado desempeño. ABSTRACT To find the position where a mobile is located with good accuracy, when it is immersed in an indoor environment (shopping centers, office buildings, airports, stations, tunnels, etc.), is the cornerstone on which a large number of applications and services are supported. Many of these services are already available in outdoor environments, although the indoor environments are suitable for other services that are specific for it. That number, however, could be significantly higher than now, if an expensive infrastructure were not required to perform the positioning service with adequate precision, for each one of the hypothetical services. Or, equally, whether that infrastructure may have other different uses beyond the ones associated with positioning. The usability of the same infrastructure for purposes other than positioning could give the opportunity of having it already available in the different locations, because it was previously deployed for these other uses; or facilitate its deployment, because the cost of that operation would offer a higher return on usability for the deployer. Wireless technologies based on radio communications, already in use for voice and data communications (mobile, WLAN, etc), meet the requirement of additional usability and, therefore, could facilitate the growth of applications and services based on positioning, in the case of being able to use it. However, determining the position with the appropriate degree of accuracy using these technologies is a major challenge today. This paper provides significant advances in this field. Along this work, a study about the main algorithms and auxiliar techniques related with indoor positioning will be initially carried out. The review will be focused in those that are suitable to be used with both last generation mobile technologies and WLAN environments. By doing this, it is tried to highlight the advantages and disadvantages of each one of these algorithms, having as final motivation their applicability both in the world of 3G and 4G mobile networks (especially in femtocells and small-cells of LTE) and in the WLAN world; and having always in mind that the final aim is to use it in indoor environments. The main conclusion of that review is that triangulation techniques, commonly used for localization in outdoor environments, are useless in indoor environments due to adverse effects of such environments as loss of sight or multipaths. Triangulation techniques used for external locations are useless due to adverse effects like the lack of line of sight or multipath. Fingerprinting methods, based on the comparison of Received Signal Strength values measured by the mobile phone with a radio map of RSSI Recorded during the calibration phase, arise as the best methods for indoor scenarios. However, these systems are also affected by other problems, for example the important load of tasks to be done to have the system ready to work, and the variability of the channel. In front of them, in this paper we present two original contributions to improve the fingerprinting methods based systems. The first one of these contributions describes a method for find, in a simple way, the basic characteristics of the system at the level of the number of samples needed to create the radio map inside the referenced fingerprint, and also by the minimum number of radio frequency emitters that are needed to be deployed; and both of them coming from some initial requirements for the system related to the error and accuracy in positioning wanted to have, which it will be joined the data corresponding to the dimensions and physical reality of the environment. Thus, some initial guidelines when dimensioning the system will be in place, and the negative effects into the cost or into the performance of the whole system, due to an inefficient deployment of the radio frequency emitters and of the radio map capture points, will be minimized. The second contribution increases the resulting accuracy of the system when working in real time, thanks to a technique of automatic recalibration of the power measurements stored in the radio map. This technique takes into account the continuous measures reported by a few static reference points, strategically distributed in the environment, to recalculate and update the measurements stored into the map radio. An additional benefit at operational level of such technique, is the extension of the reliable time of the system, decreasing the periodicity required to recapture the radio map within full measurements. The above mentioned improvements are directly applicable to improve indoor positioning mechanisms based on voice and data wireless communications infrastructure. From there, that improvement will be also extensible and applicable to location services (personal knowledge of the location where oneself is), monitoring (knowledge by other people of your location) and monitoring (prolonged monitoring over time) as all of them are based in a correct positioning for proper performance.

Space division multiple access for wireless sensor networks

This dissertation proposed a self-organizing medium access control protocol (MAC) for wireless sensor networks (WSNs). The proposed MAC protocol, space division multiple access (SDMA), relies on sensor node position information and provides sensor nodes access to the wireless channel based on their spatial locations. SDMA divides a geographical area into space divisions, where there is one-to-one map between the space divisions and the time slots. Therefore, the MAC protocol requirement is the sensor node information of its position and a prior knowledge of the one-to-one mapping function. The scheme is scalable, self-maintaining, and self-starting. It provides collision-free access to the wireless channel for the sensor nodes thereby, guarantees delay-bounded communication in real time for delay sensitive applications. This work was divided into two parts: the first part involved the design of the mapping function to map the space divisions to the time slots. The mapping function is based on a uniform Latin square. A Uniform Latin square of order k = m 2 is an k x k square matrix that consists of k symbols from 0 to k-1 such that no symbol appears more than once in any row, in any column, or in any m x in area of main subsquares. The uniqueness of each symbol in the main subsquares presents very attractive characteristic in applying a uniform Latin square to time slot allocation problem in WSNs. The second part of this research involved designing a GPS free positioning system for position information. The system is called time and power based localization scheme (TPLS). TPLS is based on time difference of arrival (TDoA) and received signal strength (RSS) using radio frequency and ultrasonic signals to measure and detect the range differences from a sensor node to three anchor nodes. TPLS requires low computation overhead and no time synchronization, as the location estimation algorithm involved only a simple algebraic operation.

VHITS: Vertical handoff initiation and target selection in a heterogeneous wireless network

Global connectivity, for anyone, at anyplace, at anytime, to provide high-speed, high-quality, and reliable communication channels for mobile devices, is now becoming a reality. The credit mainly goes to the recent technological advances in wireless communications comprised of a wide range of technologies, services, and applications to fulfill the particular needs of end-users in different deployment scenarios (Wi-Fi, WiMAX, and 3G/4G cellular systems). In such a heterogeneous wireless environment, one of the key ingredients to provide efficient ubiquitous computing with guaranteed quality and continuity of service is the design of intelligent handoff algorithms. Traditional single-metric handoff decision algorithms, such as Received Signal Strength (RSS) based, are not efficient and intelligent enough to minimize the number of unnecessary handoffs, decision delays, and call-dropping and/or blocking probabilities. This research presented a novel approach for the design and implementation of a multi-criteria vertical handoff algorithm for heterogeneous wireless networks. Several parallel Fuzzy Logic Controllers were utilized in combination with different types of ranking algorithms and metric weighting schemes to implement two major modules: the first module estimated the necessity of handoff, and the other module was developed to select the best network as the target of handoff. Simulations based on different traffic classes, utilizing various types of wireless networks were carried out by implementing a wireless test-bed inspired by the concept of Rudimentary Network Emulator (RUNE). Simulation results indicated that the proposed scheme provided better performance in terms of minimizing the unnecessary handoffs, call dropping, and call blocking and handoff blocking probabilities. When subjected to Conversational traffic and compared against the RSS-based reference algorithm, the proposed scheme, utilizing the FTOPSIS ranking algorithm, was able to reduce the average outage probability of MSs moving with high speeds by 17%, new call blocking probability by 22%, the handoff blocking probability by 16%, and the average handoff rate by 40%. The significant reduction in the resulted handoff rate provides MS with efficient power consumption, and more available battery life. These percentages indicated a higher probability of guaranteed session continuity and quality of the currently utilized service, resulting in higher user satisfaction levels.