Impoverishment of The Law by The Law: A Critique of The Attorney General's Vision of The Rule of Law and The Federal Principle

This brief article is devoted to a critique of the arguments put forward by the Attorney General of Canada in connection with the Reference concerning certain questions relating to the secession of Quebec (hereinafter, "the Reference"). This critique will not be presented from a plainly positivist standpoint. On the contrary, I will be examining in particular (1) how the approach taken by the Attorney General impoverished the legal concepts of the rule of law anf federalism, both of which were, however, central to her submission; and, in a more general way, (2) how the excessively detailed analysis of constitutional texts contributes to the impoverishment of the symbolic function of the law, however essential that dimension may be to its legitimacy. My criticism will take into account the reasons for judgement delivered recently by the Supreme Court in the Reference.

A compilation of the laws of Illinois, relating to township organization and management of county affairs : with numerous forms and notes of instruction, supported by adjudicated cases, opinions of the attorney general and rulings of the auditor of public accounts, with an appendix /

Includes index.

Report of the Attorney General of the United States prepared pursuant to section 708(e) of the Defense Production Act of 1950, as amended. Identical bidding as of August 9, 1961.

Includes bibliographical references.

Report of the Honorable James P. McGranery, Attorney General of the United States, to the Judicial Conference of the United States.

"September 22, 1952."

Report of the Honorable Herbert Brownell, Jr., Attorney General of the United States, to the Judicial Conference of the United States.

"September 24, 1953."

Report of the Attorney General's National Committee to study the antitrust laws.

Cover title.

The Pacific railroads : suggestions submitted to the Hon. Charles Devens, attorney-general of the United States, on the resolutions of the Senate and House of Representatives in respect to the operation of the Union Pacific Railroad and branches : on behalf of said railroad company /

Mode of access: Internet.

A general charter for trade associations. Correspondence between the attorney general and the secretary of commerce. Permissible activities of trade associations. Text of Supreme court decision condemning certain practices. Text of act legalizing agricultural cooperative marketing associations, together with a treatise on the application of these pronouncements.

Mode of access: Internet.

Opinions of the Attorney-General of Porto Rico to the Governor, the heads of departments, the Judiciary and other officials in relation to their official duties and construing and explaining the insular constitution and laws.

Vol.1 includes the annual reports of the Attorney-General to the Governor of Puerto Rico and to the Attorney-General of the United States.

Argument submitted on behalf of the Kansas Pacific Railway Co., before the Secretary of the Interior and the Attorney-General of the U.S. /

Includes a bill filed by the Kansas Pacific and Denver railway companies to compel the Union Pacific Railroad Company to operate and use its road as required by the several acts of Congress relating thereto.

Annual report of the Attorney General to the Governor of the state of Ohio for the year ending .

Includes opinions of the Attorney General.

Report of the attorney general for the year ending ...

Title varies slightly.

Annual report of the Attorney General.

Description based on: 1852.

Report of the Attorney General of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, for the years .

Description based on: 1887 and 1888.

Statement by Herbert Brownell, Jr., attorney general of the United States before the Senate Committee on the Judiciary on S. J. Res. 1 (83d Cong.) a proposed amendment to the Constitution of the United States relative to the making of treaties and executive agreements, and S. J. Res. 43 (83d Cong.) a proposed amendment to the Constitution of the United States relating to the legal effect of certain treaties.

Mode of access: Internet.