Empirical Bayes method in the study of traffic safety via heterogeneous negative multinomial model

In the study of traffic safety, expected crash frequencies across sites are generally estimated via the negative binomial model, assuming time invariant safety. Since the time invariant safety assumption may be invalid, Hauer (1997) proposed a modified empirical Bayes (EB) method. Despite the modification, no attempts have been made to examine the generalisable form of the marginal distribution resulting from the modified EB framework. Because the hyper-parameters needed to apply the modified EB method are not readily available, an assessment is lacking on how accurately the modified EB method estimates safety in the presence of the time variant safety and regression-to-the-mean (RTM) effects. This study derives the closed form marginal distribution, and reveals that the marginal distribution in the modified EB method is equivalent to the negative multinomial (NM) distribution, which is essentially the same as the likelihood function used in the random effects Poisson model. As a result, this study shows that the gamma posterior distribution from the multivariate Poisson-gamma mixture can be estimated using the NM model or the random effects Poisson model. This study also shows that the estimation errors from the modified EB method are systematically smaller than those from the comparison group method by simultaneously accounting for the RTM and time variant safety effects. Hence, the modified EB method via the NM model is a generalisable method for estimating safety in the presence of the time variant safety and the RTM effects.

A summary review of traffic safety problems and programs through June 1973.

Mode of access: Internet.

A summary review of traffic safety highlights, problems and programs. June 1974 through June 1975.

Mode of access: Internet.

A summary review of the status of traffic safety, problems, priorities, programs and of NHTSA activities June 1975 through September 1976.

Mode of access: Internet.

The effectiveness of traffic safety material in influencing the driving performance of the general driving population. Final report.

Federal Highway Administration, Washington, D.C.

Newsletter University of Illinois Division of University Extenstion.

Mode of access: Internet.

Citizen-police communications system, Illinois State Police : interim report /

On cover: Illinois traffic safety programs, report of evaluation or assessment.

Emergency rescue vehicles : interim evaluation report as of summer 1980 /

"March 1981."

Evaluation of the 2006 Labor Day You Drink & Drive, You Lose, Campaign : July 24 - September 17, 2006.

"February 2007"

FFE-2 : participation of the Illinois Department of Nuclear Safety in the Federal Radiological Emergency Response Plan Field Exercise of June 1987 /

Cover title.

Geological-geotechnical studies for siting the superconducting super collider in Illinois : results of the 1986 test drilling program /

Bibliography: p. 106-107.

Illinois crash facts and statistics.

Issued by the Division of Traffic Safety.

Occupant restraint usage in Illinois.

Description based on: Apr. 1985.

Program and management audit of the Illinois Department of Public Aid's Kidcare Program.

"To the Legislative Audit Commission, the Speaker and Minority Leader of the House of Representative, the President and Minority Leader of the Senate, the members of the General Assembly, and the Governor."--Cover letter.