VEGF is a mediator of retinal pigment epithelium permeability leading to photoreceptor cell death in light-induced retinal degeneration : gene therapy strategy to prevent AMD-disorders

ABSTRACTIn normal tissues, a balance between pro- and anti-angiogenic factors tightly controls angiogenesis. Alterations of this balance may have pathological consequences. For instance, concerning the retina, the vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) is a potent pro-angiogenic factor, and has been identified has a key player during ocular neovascularization implicated in a variety of retinal diseases. In the exudative form (wet-form) of age-related macular degeneration (AMD), neovascularizations occurring from the choroidal vessels are responsible for a quick and dramatic loss of visual acuity. In diabetic retinopathy and retinopathy of prematurity, sprouting from the retinal vessels leads to vision loss. Furthermore, the aging of the population, the increased- prevalence of diabetes and the better survival rate of premature infants will lead to an increasing rate of these conditions. In this way, anti-VEGF strategy represents an important therapeutic target to treat ocular neovascular disorders.In addition, the administration of Pigmented Epithelial growth factor, a neurotrophic and an anti- angiogenic factor, prevents photoreceptor cell death in a model of retinal degeneration induced by light. Previous results analyzing end point morphology reveal that the light damage (LD) model is used to mimic retinal degenerations arising from environmental insult, as well as aging and genetic disease such as advanced atrophic AMD. Moreover, light has been identified as a co-factor in a number of retinal diseases, speeding up the degeneration process. This protecting effect of PEDF in the LD retina raises the possibility of involvement of the balance between pro- and anti-angiogenic factors not only for angiogenesis, but also in cell survival and maintenance.The aim of the work presented here was to evaluate the importance of this balance in neurodegenerative processes. To this aim, a model of light-induced retinal degeneration was used and characterized, mainly focusing on factors simultaneously controlling neuron survival and angiogenesis, such as PEDF and VEGF.In most species, prolonged intense light exposure can lead to photoreceptor cell damage that can progress to cell death and vision loss. A protocol previously described to induce retinal degeneration in Balb/c mice was used. Retinas were characterized at different time points after light injury through several methods at the functional and molecular levels. Data obtained confirmed that toxic level of light induce PR cell death. Variations were observed in VEGF pathway players in both the neural retina and the eye-cup containing the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE), suggesting a flux of VEGF from the RPE towards the neuroretina. Concomitantly, the integrity of the outer blood-retinal-barrier (BRB) was altered, leading to extravascular albumin leakage from the choroid throughout the photoreceptor layer.To evaluate the importance of VEGF during light-induced retinal degeneration process, a lentiviral vector encoding the cDNA of a single chain antibody directed against all VEGF-A isoforms was developed (LV-V65). The bioactivity of this vector to block VEGF was validated in a mouse model of laser-induced choroidal neovascularization mediated by VEGF upregulation. The vector was then used in the LD model. The administration of the LV-V65 contributed to the maintenance of functional photoreceptors, which was assessed by ERG recording, visual acuity measurement and histological analyses. At the RPE level, the BRB integrity was preserved as shown by the absence of albumin leakage and the maintenance of RPE cell cohesion.These results taken together indicate that the VEGF is a mediator of light induced PR degeneration process and confirm the crucial role of the balance between pro- and anti-angiogenic factors in the PR cell survival. This work also highlights the prime importance of BRB integrity and functional coupling between RPE and PR cells to maintain the PR survival. VEGF dysregulation was already shown to be involved in wet AMD forms and our study suggests that VEGF dysregulation may also occur at early stages of AMD and could thus be a potential therapeutic target for several RPE related diseases.RESUMEDans les différents tissues de l'organisme, l'angiogenèse est strictement contrôlée par une balance entre les facteurs pro- et anti-angiogéniques. Des modifications survenant dans cette balance peuvent engendrer des conséquences pathologiques. Par exemple, concernant la rétine, le facteur de croissance de l'endothélium vasculaire (VEGF) est un facteur pro-angiogénique important. Ce facteur a été identifié comme un acteur majeur dans les néovascularisations oculaires et les processus pathologiques angiogéniques survenant dans l'oeil et responsables d'une grande variété de maladies rétiniennes. Dans la forme humide de la dégénérescence maculaire liée à l'âge (DMLA), la néovascularisation choroïdienne est responsable de la perte rapide et brutale de l'acuité visuelle chez les patients affectés. Dans la rétinopathie diabétique et celle lié à la prématurité, l'émergence de néovaisseaux rétiniens est la cause de la perte de la vision. Les néovascularisations oculaires représentent la principale cause de cécité dans les pays développés. De plus, l'âge croissant de la population, la progression de la prévalence du diabète et la meilleure survie des enfants prématurés mèneront sans doute à l'augmentation de ces pathologies dans les années futures. Dans ces conditions, les thérapies anti- angiogéniques visant à inhiber le VEGF représentent une importante cible thérapeutique pour le traitement de ces pathologies.Plusieurs facteurs anti-angiogéniques ont été identifiés. Parmi eux, le facteur de l'épithélium pigmentaire (PEDF) est à la fois un facteur neuro-trophique et anti-angiogénique, et l'administration de ce facteur au niveau de la rétine dans un modèle de dégénérescence rétinienne induite par la lumière protège les photorécepteurs de la mort cellulaire. Des études antérieures basées sur l'analyse morphologique ont révélé que les modifications survenant lors de la dégénération induite suite à l'exposition à des doses toxiques de lumière représente un remarquable modèle pour l'étude des dégénérations rétiniennes suite à des lésions environnementales, à l'âge ou encore aux maladies génétiques telle que la forme atrophique avancée de la DMLA. De plus, la lumière a été identifiée comme un co-facteur impliqué dans un grand nombre de maladies rétiniennes, accélérant le processus de dégénération. L'effet protecteur du PEDF dans les rétines lésées suite à l'exposition de des doses toxiques de lumière suscite la possibilité que la balance entre les facteurs pro- et anti-angiogéniques soit impliquée non seulement dans les processus angiogéniques, mais également dans le maintient et la survie des cellules.Le but de ce projet consiste donc à évaluer l'implication de cette balance lors des processus neurodégénératifs. Pour cela, un modèle de dégénération induite par la lumière à été utilisé et caractérisé, avec un intérêt particulier pour les facteurs comme le PEDF et le VEGF contrôlant simultanément la survie des neurones et l'angiogenèse.Dans la plupart des espèces, l'exposition prolongée à une lumière intense peut provoquer des dommages au niveau des cellules photoréceptrices de l'oeil, qui peut mener à leur mort, et par conséquent à la perte de la vision. Un protocole préalablement décrit a été utilisé pour induire la dégénération rétinienne dans les souris albinos Balb/c. Les rétines ont été analysées à différents moments après la lésion par différentes techniques, aussi bien au niveau moléculaire que fonctionnel. Les résultats obtenus ont confirmé que des doses toxiques de lumière induisent la mort des photorécepteurs, mais altèrent également la voie de signalisation du VEGF, aussi bien dans la neuro-rétine que dans le reste de l'oeil, contenant l'épithélium pigmentaire (EP), et suggérant un flux de VEGF provenant de ΙΈΡ en direction de la neuro-rétine. Simultanément, il se produit une altération de l'intégrité de la barrière hémato-rétinienne externe, menant à la fuite de protéine telle que l'albumine, provenant de la choroïde et retrouvée dans les compartiments extravasculaires de la rétine, telle que dans la couche des photorécepteurs.Pour déterminer l'importance et le rôle du VEGF, un vecteur lentiviral codant pour un anticorps neutralisant dirigée contre tous les isoformes du VEGF a été développé (LV-V65). La bio-activité de ce vecteur a été testé et validée dans un modèle de laser, connu pour induire des néovascularisations choroïdiennes chez la souris suite à l'augmentation du VEGF. Ce vecteur a ensuite été utilisé dans le modèle de dégénération induite par la lumière. Les résultats des électrorétinogrammes, les mesures de l'acuité visuelle et les analyses histologiques ont montré que l'injection du LV-V65 contribue à la maintenance de photorécepteurs fonctionnels. Au niveau de l'EP, l'absence d'albumine et la maintenance des jonctions cellulaires des cellules de l'EP ont démontré que l'intégrité de la barrière hémato-rétinienne externe est préservée suite au traitement.Par conséquent, tous les résultats obtenus indiquent que le VEGF est un médiateur important impliquée dans le processus de dégénération induit par la lumière et confirme le rôle cruciale de la balance entre les facteurs pro- et anti-angiogéniques dans la survie des photorécepteurs. Cette étude révèle également l'importance de l'intégrité de la barrière hémato-rétinienne et l'importance du lien fonctionnel et structurel entre l'EP et les photorécepteurs, essentiel pour la survie de ces derniers. Par ailleurs, Cette étude suggère que des dérèglements au niveau de l'équilibre du VEGF ne sont pas seulement impliqués dans la forme humide de la DMLA, comme déjà démontré dans des études antérieures, mais pourraient également contribuer et survenir dans des formes précoces de la DMLA, et par conséquent le VEGF représente une cible thérapeutique potentielle pour les maladies associées à des anomalies au niveau de l'EP.

Gene therapy regenerates protein expression in cone photoreceptors in Rpe65(R91W/R91W) mice.

Cone photoreceptors mediate visual acuity under daylight conditions, so loss of cone-mediated central vision of course dramatically affects the quality of life of patients suffering from retinal degeneration. Therefore, promoting cone survival has become the goal of many ocular therapies and defining the stage of degeneration that still allows cell rescue is of prime importance. Using the Rpe65(R91W/R91W) mouse, which carries a mutation in the Rpe65 gene leading to progressive photoreceptor degeneration in both patients and mice, we defined stages of retinal degeneration that still allow cone rescue. We evaluated the therapeutic window within which cones can be rescued, using a subretinal injection of a lentiviral vector driving expression of RPE65 in the Rpe65(R91W/R91W) mice. Surprisingly, when applied to adult mice (1 month) this treatment not only stalls or slows cone degeneration but, actually, induces cone-specific protein expression that was previously absent. Before the intervention only part of the cones (40% of the number found in wild-type animals) in the Rpe65(R91W/R91W) mice expressed cone transducin (GNAT2); this fraction increased to 64% after treatment. Correct S-opsin localization is also recovered in the transduced region. In consequence these results represent an extended therapeutic window compared to the Rpe65(-/-) mice, implying that patients suffering from missense mutations might also benefit from a prolonged therapeutic window. Moreover, cones are not only rescued during the course of the degeneration, but can actually recover their initial status, meaning that a proportion of altered cones in chromophore deficiency-related disease can be rehabilitated even though they are severely affected.

A next step in adeno-associated virus-mediated gene therapy for neurological diseases: regulation and targeting.

Recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors mediating long term transgene expression are excellent gene therapy tools for chronic neurological diseases. While rAAV2 was the first serotype tested in the clinics, more efficient vectors derived from the rh10 serotype are currently being evaluated and other serotypes are likely to be tested in the near future. In addition, aside from the currently used stereotaxy-guided intraparenchymal delivery, new techniques for global brain transduction (by intravenous or intra-cerebrospinal injections) are very promising. Various strategies for therapeutic gene delivery to the central nervous system have been explored in human clinical trials in the past decade. Canavan disease, a genetic disease caused by an enzymatic deficiency, was the first to be approved. Three gene transfer paradigms for Parkinson's disease have been explored: converting L-dopa into dopamine through AADC gene delivery in the putamen; synthesizing GABA through GAD gene delivery in the overactive subthalamic nucleus and providing neurotrophic support through neurturin gene delivery in the nigro-striatal pathway. These pioneer clinical trials demonstrated the safety and tolerability of rAAV delivery in the human brain at moderate doses. Therapeutic effects however, were modest, emphasizing the need for higher doses of the therapeutic transgene product which could be achieved using more efficient vectors or expression cassettes. This will require re-addressing pharmacological aspects, with attention to which cases require either localized and cell-type specific expression or efficient brain-wide transgene expression, and when it is necessary to modulate or terminate the administration of transgene product. The ongoing development of targeted and regulated rAAV vectors is described.

Non-viral gene therapy for GDNF production in RCS rat: the crucial role of the plasmid dose.

Glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) is one of the candidate molecules among neurotrophic factors proposed for a potential treatment of retinitis pigmentosa (RP). It must be administered repeatedly or through sustained releasing systems to exert prolonged neuroprotective effects. In the dystrophic Royal College of Surgeon's (RCS) rat model of RP, we found that endogenous GDNF levels dropped during retinal degeneration time course, opening a therapeutic window for GDNF supplementation. We showed that after a single electrotransfer of 30 μg of GDNF-encoding plasmid in the rat ciliary muscle, GDNF was produced for at least 7 months. Morphometric, electroretinographic and optokinetic analyses highlighted that this continuous release of GDNF delayed photoreceptors (PRs) as well as retinal functions loss until at least 70 days of age in RCS rats. Unexpectedly, increasing the GDNF secretion level accelerated PR degeneration and the loss of electrophysiological responses. This is the first report: (i) demonstrating the efficacy of GDNF delivery through non-viral gene therapy in RP; (ii) establishing the efficacy of intravitreal administration of GDNF in RP associated with a mutation in the retinal pigment epithelium; and (iii) warning against potential toxic effects of GDNF within the eye/retina.

Administration of IL-18BP by gene therapy reduces inflammation and prevents joint destruction by downregulation of MMP-9 in rat AIA Role of MMP-9 in bone and joint destruction in arthritis

Background and objectives: Interleukin-18 (IL-18) is a pleiotropic cytokine involved in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) pathogenesis. This studywas carried out to evaluate the efficicacy of interleukin-18 binding protein (IL-18BP) gene therapy in the rat adjuvant-induced arthritis (AIA) model and to decipher the mechanisms by which IL-18BP delivery lessens bone destruction. Materials and methods: Arthritis was induced in female Lewis rat by Mycobacterium butyricum and the mRNA expression of IL-18 and IL-18BP was determined in the joints. In a preventative study, rats were divided into an adenovirus producing IL-18BP-Fc (AdmIL-18BP-Fc) group (n=8) and an adenovirus producing green fluorescent protein (AdGFP) group (n=7). On day 8 after AIA induction, adenoviruses were injected. Clinical parameters were assessed. At day 18, during maximal arthritis, the rats were euthanized, ankles were collected, and X-rays were performed. mRNA and protein were extracted from joints for analyses by qRT-PCR, multiplex, Western blot, and zymography. Results: We observed a decrease in the [IL-18BP/IL-18] ratio from day 7 to day 45. Administration of AdmIL-18BPd-Fc decreased clinical parameters and prevented bone and joint destruction compared to AdGFP administration. IL-18BP delivery reduced the metalloproteinase 9 (MMP-9) levels by 33% (at protein level (Fig. 1B) and functional level (Fig. 1C) and the tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) level by 44% (Fig. 1D) in the joint homogenates from AdmIL-18BPd-Fc compared to AdGFP treated rats.However, no variationwas observed forMMP-2 at the protein level (Fig.1A) and functional level (Fig. 1C). Conclusions: In rat AIA, a decrease in the [IL-18BP/ IL-18] ratio was observed. IL-18BP delivery prevented joint and bone destruction by downregulating MMP-9 and TRAP, suggesting a potential benefit of a similar therapy in RA.

Selecting highly affine and well-expressed TCRs for gene therapy of melanoma.

A recent phase 1 trial has demonstrated that the generation of tumor-reactive T lymphocytes by transfer of specific T-cell receptor (TCR) genes into autologous lymphocytes is feasible. However, compared with results obtained by infusion of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes, the response rate observed in this first TCR gene therapy trial is low. One strategy that is likely to enhance the success rate of TCR gene therapy is the use of tumor-reactive TCRs with a higher capacity for tumor cell recognition. We therefore sought to develop standardized procedures for the selection of well-expressed, high-affinity, and safe human TCRs. Here we show that TCR surface expression can be improved by modification of TCR alpha and beta sequences and that such improvement has a marked effect on the in vivo function of TCR gene-modified T cells. From a panel of human, melanoma-reactive TCRs we subsequently selected the TCR with the highest affinity. Furthermore, a generally applicable assay was used to assess the lack of alloreactivity of this TCR against a large series of common human leukocyte antigen alleles. The procedures described in this study should be of general value for the selection of well- and stably expressed, high-affinity, and safe human TCRs for subsequent clinical testing.

Non-viral ocular gene therapy: potential ocular therapeutic avenues.

Non-viral vectors for potential gene replacement and therapy have been developed in order to overcome the drawbacks of viral vectors. The diversity of non-viral vectors allows for a wide range of various products, flexibility of application, ease of use, low-cost of production and enhanced "genomic" safety. Using non-viral strategies, oligonucleotides (ODNs) can be delivered naked (less efficient) or entrapped in cationic lipids, polymers or peptides forming slow release delivery systems, which can be adapted according to the organ targeted and the therapy purposes. Tissue and cell internalization can be further enhanced by changing by physical or chemical means. Moreover, a specific vector can be selected according to disease course and intensity of manifestations fulfilling specific requirements such as the duration of drug release and its level along with cells and tissues specific targeting. From accumulating knowledge and experience, it appears that combination of several non-viral techniques may increase the efficacy and ensure the safety of these evolving and interesting gene therapy strategies.

A single epidermal stem cell strategy for safe ex vivo gene therapy.

There is a widespread agreement from patient and professional organisations alike that the safety of stem cell therapeutics is of paramount importance, particularly for ex vivo autologous gene therapy. Yet current technology makes it difficult to thoroughly evaluate the behaviour of genetically corrected stem cells before they are transplanted. To address this, we have developed a strategy that permits transplantation of a clonal population of genetically corrected autologous stem cells that meet stringent selection criteria and the principle of precaution. As a proof of concept, we have stably transduced epidermal stem cells (holoclones) obtained from a patient suffering from recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa. Holoclones were infected with self-inactivating retroviruses bearing a COL7A1 cDNA and cloned before the progeny of individual stem cells were characterised using a number of criteria. Clonal analysis revealed a great deal of heterogeneity among transduced stem cells in their capacity to produce functional type VII collagen (COLVII). Selected transduced stem cells transplanted onto immunodeficient mice regenerated a non-blistering epidermis for months and produced a functional COLVII. Safety was assessed by determining the sites of proviral integration, rearrangements and hit genes and by whole-genome sequencing. The progeny of the selected stem cells also had a diploid karyotype, was not tumorigenic and did not disseminate after long-term transplantation onto immunodeficient mice. In conclusion, a clonal strategy is a powerful and efficient means of by-passing the heterogeneity of a transduced stem cell population. It guarantees a safe and homogenous medicinal product, fulfilling the principle of precaution and the requirements of regulatory affairs. Furthermore, a clonal strategy makes it possible to envision exciting gene-editing technologies like zinc finger nucleases, TALENs and homologous recombination for next-generation gene therapy.

Targeting Adenoviral Gene Therapy Vectors to Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma and Heart

Gene therapy aims to treat diseases by introducing genetic material to the diseased tissue. For cancer treatment it is important to destroy cancerous cells; this can be achieved by introducing a gene, which induces cell death or by allowing viral vectors to replicate, which also results in destruction of cancerous cells. For cardiac diseases the approach is more like the former, except the gene produces beneficial effects, like angiogenesis. Adenoviruses have many beneficial qualities, which make the virus an interesting gene therapy vector; it can be produced relatively easily, its manipulation is quite easy and it has naturally broad tropism. By removing or replacing certain genes in the adenoviral genome, it can be made non-replicative. In this study, adenoviral receptor expression patterns were characterized in both head and neck squamous cell carcinoma and the human heart. Adenovirus serotype 5 receptor expression in head and neck cancer cell lines was found to be highly variable between cell lines and overall at lower levels, while Ad35 receptor expression was more uniform and at higher levels in all analyzed cell lines. It was also shown that a hybrid virus Ad5/35 is able to infect cells refractory to Ad5, which correlates with receptor expression in these cells. Furthermore, this difference in infection properties extends to cell killing efficiency in case of conditionally replicative viruses. Expression levels of adenoviral receptors CAR, CD46, CD86 and αv-integrins were found to be high both in normal and dilated cardiomyopathy heart tissue. The receptor levels also correlate with transduction efficiency after intracardiac injection. Ad5 showed superior transduction ability compared with Ad5/35, but evoked also a more profound immune reaction when administered this way. Adenoviral gene therapy vectors are the most used delivery vehicles in clinical trials to date. These vectors have proven to be well tolerated and positive results have been obtained when combined with traditional treatments, although poor transduction efficiency has often been reported due to low-level expression of viral receptors on target cells. In spite of this, the results are encouraging and merit for further research.

Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) pathogenesis and HSV gene therapy of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

The aim of this thesis was to develop new herpes simplex virus (HSV) vectors for gene therapy of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), the principal model of multiple sclerosis (MS), and to study the pathogenesis of wild-type HSV-1 and HSV-1 vectors in vivo. By introducing potential immunomodulatory factors into mice with EAE we strived to develop therapies and possibly find molecules improving recovery from EAE. We aimed at altering the immune response by inducing favorable Th2-type cytokines, thus shifting the immune response from a Th1- or a Th17-response. Our HSV vector expressing interleukin (IL)-5 modulated the cytokine responses, decreased inflammation and alleviated EAE. The use of a novel method, bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC), for engineering recombinant HSV facilitated the construction of a new vector expressing leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF). LIF is a neurotropic cytokine with broad functions in the central nervous system (CNS). LIF promotes oligodendrocyte maturation and decreases demyelination and oligodendrocyte loss. The BAC-derived HSV-LIF vector alleviated the clinical symptoms, induced a higher number of oligodendrocytes and modulated T cell responses. By administering HSV via different infection routes, e.g. peripherally via the nose or eye, or intracranially to the brain, the effect of the immune response on HSV spread at different points of the natural infection route was studied. The intranasal infection was an effective delivery route of HSV to the trigeminal ganglion and CNS, whereas corneal infection displayed limited spread. The corneal and intranasal infections induced different peripheral immune responses, which might explain the observed differences in viral spread.

The challenge of vector development in gene therapy

Gene therapy is the treatment of diseases based on the transfer of genetic information. Agents that carry or deliver DNA to target cells are called vectors (Latin vector: carrier, deliverer). Ideally, a vector should accommodate an unlimited amount of inserted DNA, lack the ability of autonomous replication of its own DNA, be easily manufactured, and be available in concentrated form. Secondly, it should have the ability to target specific cell types or to limit its gene expression to specific cell types, and to achieve sustained gene expression in the long term or in a controlled fashion. Finally, it should not be toxic or immunogenic. Such a vector does not exist and none of the DNA delivery systems so far available for in vivo gene transfer is perfect with respect to any of these points. Gene therapy and the means to promote it depend heavily on the development and improvement of new gene vector systems.

Somatic gene therapy for hypertension

Gene therapy for hypertension is needed for the next generation of antihypertensive drugs. Current drugs, although effective, have poor compliance, are expensive and short-lasting (hours or one day). Gene therapy offers a way to produce long-lasting antihypertensive effects (weeks, months or years). We are currently using two strategies: a) antisense oligodeoxynucleotides (AS-ODN) and b) antisense DNA delivered in viral vectors to inhibit genes associated with vasoconstrictive properties. It is not necessary to know all the genes involved in hypertension, since many years of experience with drugs show which genes need to be controlled. AS-ODN are short, single-stranded DNA that can be injected in naked form or in liposomes. AS-ODN, targeted to angiotensin type 1 receptors (AT1-R), angiotensinogen (AGT), angiotensin converting enzyme, and ß1-adrenergic receptors effectively reduce hypertension in rat models (SHR, 2K-1C) and cold-induced hypertension. A single dose is effective up to one month when delivered with liposomes. No side effects or toxic effects have been detected, and repeated injections can be given. For the vector, adeno-associated virus (AAV) is used with a construct to include a CMV promoter, antisense DNA to AGT or AT1-R and a reporter gene. Results in SHR demonstrate reduction and slowing of development of hypertension, with a single dose administration. Left ventricular hypertrophy is also reduced by AAV-AGT-AS treatment. Double transgenic mice (human renin plus human AGT) with high angiotensin II causing high blood pressure, treated with AAV-AT1-R-AS, show a normalization of blood pressure for over six months with a single injection of vector. We conclude that ODNs will probably be developed first because they can be treated like drugs for the treatment of hypertension with long-term effects. Viral vector delivery needs more engineering to be certain of its safety, but one day may be used for a very prolonged control of blood pressure.

Combating oncogene activation associated with retrovirus-mediated gene therapy of X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency

A successful gene therapy clinical trial that also encountered serious adverse effects has sparked extensive study and debate about the future directions for retrovirus-mediated interventions. Treatment of X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency with an oncoretrovirus harboring a normal copy of the gc gene was applied in two clinical trials, essentially curing 13 of 16 infants, restoring a normal immune system without the need for additional immune-related therapies. Approximately 3 years after their gene therapy, tragically, 3 of these children, all from the same trial, developed leukemia as a result of this experimental treatment. The current understanding of the mechanism behind this leukemogenesis involves three critical and cooperating factors, i.e., viral integration, oncogene activation, and the function of the therapeutic gene. In this review, we will explore the causes of this unwanted event and some of the possibilities for reducing the risk of its reoccurrence.

Death switch for gene therapy: application to erythropoietin transgene expression

The effectiveness of the caspase-9-based artificial "death switch" as a safety measure for gene therapy based on the erythropoietin (Epo) hormone was tested in vitro and in vivo using the chemical inducer of dimerization, AP20187. Plasmids encoding the dimeric murine Epo, the tetracycline-controlled transactivator and inducible caspase 9 (ptet-mEpoD, ptet-tTAk and pSH1/Sn-E-Fv’-Fvls-casp9-E, respectively) were used in this study. AP20187 induced apoptosis of iCasp9-modified C2C12 myoblasts. In vivo, two groups of male C57BI/6 mice, 8-12 weeks old, were injected intramuscularly with 5 µg/50 g ptet-mEpoD and 0.5 µg/50 g ptet-tTAk. There were 20 animals in group 1 and 36 animals in group 2. Animals from group 2 were also injected with the 6 µg/50 g iCasp9 plasmid. Seventy percent of the animals showed an increase in hematocrit of more than 65% for more than 15 weeks. AP20187 administration significantly reduced hematocrit and plasma Epo levels in 30% of the animals belonging to group 2. TUNEL-positive cells were detected in the muscle of at least 50% of the animals treated with AP20187. Doxycycline administration was efficient in controlling Epo secretion in both groups. We conclude that inducible caspase 9 did not interfere with gene transfer, gene expression or tetracycline control and may be used as a safety mechanism for gene therapy. However, more studies are necessary to improve the efficacy of this technique, for example, the use of lentivirus vector.