983 resultados para Cross flow
Resumo:
A green ceramic tape micro-heat exchanger was developed using Low Temperature Co-fired Ceramics technology (LTCC). The device was designed by using Computational Aided Design software and simulations were made using a Computational Fluid Dynamics package (COMSOL Multiphysics) to evaluate the homogeneity of fluid distribution in the microchannels. Four geometries were proposed and simulated in two and three dimensions to show that geometric details directly affect the distribution of velocity in the micro-heat exchanger channels. The simulation results were quite useful for the design of the microfluidic device. The micro-heat exchanger was then constructed using the LTCC technology and is composed of five thermal exchange plates in cross-flow arrangement and two connecting plates, with all plates stacked to form a device with external dimensions of 26 x 26 x 6 mm(3).
Resumo:
The settling characteristics of cell debris and inclusion bodies prior to, and following, fractionation in a disc-stack centrifuge were measured using Cumulative Sedimentation Analysis (CSA) and Centrifugal Disc photosedimentation (CDS). The impact of centrifuge feedrate and repeated homogenisation on both cell debris and inclusion body collection efficiency was investigated. Increasing the normalised centrifuge feedrate (Q/Sigma) from 1.32 x 10(-9) m s(-1) to 3.97 x 10(-9) m s(-1) leads to a 36% increase in inclusion body paste purity. Purity may also be improved by repeated homogenisation. Increasing the number of homogeniser passes results in smaller cell debris size whilst leaves inclusion body size unaltered. At a normalised centrifuge feedrate of 2.65 x 10(-9) m s(-1), increasing the number of homogeniser passes from two (2) to ten (10) improved overall inclusion body paste purity by 58%. Grade-efficiency curves for both the cell debris and inclusion bodies have also been generated in this study. The data are described using an equation developed by Mannweiler (1989) with parameters of k = 0.15-0.26 and n = 2.5-2.6 for inclusion bodies, and k = 0.12-0.14 and n = 2.0-2.2 for cell debris. This is the first accurate experimentally-determined grade efficiency curve for cell debris. Previous studies have simply estimated debris grade efficiency curves using an approximate debris size distribution and grade efficiency curves determined with 'ideal particles' (e.g. spherical PVA particles). The findings of this study may be used to simulate and optimise the centrifugal fractionation of inclusion bodies from cell debris.
Resumo:
Este trabalho na área dos processos físicos de separação por membranas, nomeadamente, a nanofiltração (NF), tem como objectivo principal a recuperação dos efluentes resultantes das águas da 3ª lavagem utilizadas na operação de tingimento de fibras de algodão, com corantes reactivos. Estão inerentes as problemáticas: da escassez da água como matéria-prima na vertente de água potável; da diminuição de efluentes que necessitam de tratamentos devido à sua carga poluente; da recuperação sempre que seja viável dos produtos químicos adicionados nesta fase de tratamento das fibras de algodão e por último e não menos importante, da energia contida nestes efluentes que vão para o esgoto a temperaturas na ordem dos 50 ºC. A metodologia adoptada na realização deste trabalho consistiu, inicialmente num estudo sobre os trabalhos realizados até hoje nesta área, seguindo-se a recolha dos efluentes na empresa ―Estamparia Têxtil Adalberto Pinto da Silva, S.A.‖ (ETAPS) e posterior estudo da recuperação dos efluentes em causa pelo processo de NF utilizando a membrana NF270-2540 da empresa FILMTEC. Os efluentes estudados no presente trabalho continham corantes reactivos sendo um corante azul-claro (CAC) de composição (Amarelo Bril Remazol GL 150% + Azul Brilhante Remazol BB 133% + Azul Turqueza Remazol G) e o outro corante azul-marinho (CAM) de composição (Preto Remazol B 133% + Vermelho Remazol RGB + Amarelo Ouro Remazol RGB). Estes estudos de recuperação compreenderam basicamente 3 fases: caracterização do efluente recolhido na empresa; tratamento desse efluente utilizando uma instalação piloto de NF de fluxo cruzado ou também conhecido por membrana de fluxo tangencial instalado no Laboratório de Tecnologia (LT) do Instituto Superior de Engenharia do Porto (ISEP), e caracterização dos permeados e dos rejeitados obtidos. A análise de resultados do presente trabalho permitiu concluir ser possível a recuperação e reutilização das 3ª águas de lavagem do processo de tingimento quando tratadas pelo processo de NF a pressões de operação de 6 bar. Nestas circunstâncias os permeados obtidos (tanto no efluente com corante azul-claro como no efluente com corante azul-marinho) apresentam valores, em todos os parâmetros estudados, significativamente abaixo dos valores limites recomendáveis para uma água de abastecimento na Industria Têxtil (IT). Salienta-se reduções mais expressivas nos permeados do corante CAM, com vários parâmetros a sofrerem reduções no intervalo de 98 a 100%, nomeadamente, na cor, turvação, CQO, dureza total, alumínio e manganês. Os resultados obtidos para as pressões de operação de 4 e 8 bar mostram alguns parâmetros com valores acima dos recomendados para uma água de abastecimento na Indústria Têxtil, nomeadamente a cor no corante CAC quando se opera a 4 bar e no corante CAM quando se opera a 8 bar e os sulfatos e ferro no CAM à pressão de 4 bar. Estes resultados mostram ser possível a reutilização da água na própria instalação industrial, trazendo um benefício económico e ambiental, pela redução no consumo de água fresca e energia, além da redução do volume de efluentes que necessitam ser tratados, estando na mesma linha de pensamento de Gross et al (1999), que refere que o uso de membranas para o tratamento de efluentes do processo de tingimento tem como principal objectivo a viabilidade económica, a redução no consumo de água, de sais, de corantes e energia, bem como, a redução do volume de efluentes a ser tratado.
Resumo:
Este trabalho realizou-se na empresa Continental – Indústria Têxtil do Ave, S.A (CITA) em colaboração com a empresa Cofely GDF Suez – Energia e Serviços Portugal, S.A. O principal objetivo desta dissertação foi a otimização energética da máquina de impregnar telas para pneus – a máquina ZELL, tendo em conta as principais utilidades envolvidas: eletricidade e gás natural. Deste modo foi feito um levantamento prévio das condições de operação desta máquina relativamente às telas mais representativas da produção da empresa. Tendo-se verificado que as telas em poliéster representam 65% da produção total da máquina ZELL. Para este tipo de produto, foi feita uma análise dos consumos energéticos anuais para avaliar qual das utilidades referidas corresponde à maior parcela energética. Verificou-se que o consumo de gás natural representa a maior parcela da fatura energética anual da empresa correspondendo a 47%. Além disso, da energia total consumida anualmente pela ZELL, que corresponde a 1360 tep, 32% é relativo à energia elétrica e os restantes 68% ao consumo de gás natural. Por fim, procedeu-se à otimização energética estudando as alterações possíveis no sentido de reduzir os consumos energéticos da máquina, sem prejuízo da qualidade do produto final. Para isso propôs-se a instalação de permutadores de fluxo cruzado para pré-aquecer quer o ar fresco quer o ar de combustão. A implementação desta medida tem um período de retorno à volta de três anos e pode levar a uma poupança anual entre 1.359.639 kWh e 2.370.114 kWh para o ar fresco e 393.523 kWh e 639.475 kWh para o ar de combustão.
Resumo:
Dissertation presented to Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia, Universidade Nova de Lisboa for obtaining the master degree in Membrane Engineering
Resumo:
Tämän työn tavoitteena oli selvittää erään ilmanvaihtokoneen lämmöntalteenottokennon vuosihyötysuhde japohtia voitaisiinko ilmastointikoneen energiatehokkuutta parantaa käyttämällä nykyisen ristivirtalämmönsiirtimen tilalla vastavirtalämmönsiirrintä tai poistoilmalämpöpumppua. Lisäksi tavoitteena oli mitata kahden ilmanvaihtokoneeseen liitettävän äänenvaimentimen vaimennuskyky ja pyrkiä parantamaan näiden vaimennusta. Työn teoriaosassa käsitellään yleisellä tasolla eri ilmanvaihtotapojen ja lämmöntalteenottomenetelmien toimintaperiaatteita ja soveltuvuuksiaeri tilanteisiin. Työn kokeellisessa osassa mitataan ilmanvaihtokoneen lämmöntalteenoton toiminta eri sääolosuhteissa ja lasketaan tulosten perusteella laitteelle lämpötila- ja entalpiavuosihyötysuhteet. Äänenvaimentimesta rakennetaan kaksi kehitysversiota, joiden mittaustuloksia verrataan alkuperäisen vaimentimen vaimennuskykyyn. Lämmöntalteenottoja vertailtaessa havaittiin, että suositeltavin kehitysvaihtoehto olisi vastavirtalämmönsiirtimeen siirtyminen sen yksinkertaisen rakenteen ja hyvän hyötysuhteen ansiosta.Äänenvaimentimien rakenteessa kannattaa mittausten ja pohdinnan perusteella siirtyä seinämillä jaettuun vaimentimeen.
Resumo:
In this thesis the membrane filtration equipment for plate type ceramic membranes was developed based on filtration results achieved with different kinds of wastewaters. The experiments were mainly made with pulp and board mill wastewaters, but some experiments were also made with a bore well water and a stone cutting mine wastewater. The ceramicmembranes used were alpha-alumina membranes with a pore size of 100 nm. Some ofthe membranes were coated with a gamma-alumina layer to reduce the membrane pore size to 10 nm, and some of them were modified with different metal oxides in order to change the surface properties of the membranes. The effects of operationparameters, such as cross-flow velocity, filtration pressure and backflushing on filtration performance were studied. The measured parameters were the permeateflux, the quality of the permeate, as well as the fouling tendency of the membrane. A dynamic membrane or a cake layer forming on top of the membrane was observed to decrease the flux and increase separa-tion of certain substances, especially at low cross-flow velocities. When the cross-flow velocities were increased the membrane properties became more important. Backflushing could also be used to decrease the thickness of the cake layer and thus it improved the permeate flux. However, backflushing can lead to a reduction of retentions in cases where the cake layer is improving them. The wastewater quality was important for the thickness of the dynamic membrane and the membrane pore size influenced the permeate flux. In general, the optimization of operation conditions is very important for the successful operation of a membrane filtration system. The filtration equipment with a reasonable range of operational conditions is necessary, especiallywhen different kinds of wastewaters are treated. This should be taken into account already in the development stage of a filtration equipment.
Resumo:
In this thesis different parameters influencing critical flux in protein ultrafiltration and membrane foul-ing were studied. Short reviews of proteins, cross-flow ultrafiltration, flux decline and criticalflux and the basic theory of Partial Least Square analysis (PLS) are given at the beginning. The experiments were mainly performed using dilute solutions of globular proteins, commercial polymeric membranes and laboratory scale apparatuses. Fouling was studied by flux, streaming potential and FTIR-ATR measurements. Critical flux was evaluated by different kinds of stepwise procedures and by both con-stant pressure and constant flux methods. The critical flux was affected by transmembrane pressure, flow velocity, protein concentration, mem-brane hydrophobicity and protein and membrane charges. Generally, the lowest critical fluxes were obtained at the isoelectric points of the protein and the highest in the presence of electrostatic repulsion between the membrane surface and the protein molecules. In the laminar flow regime the critical flux increased with flow velocity, but not any more above this region. An increase in concentration de-creased the critical flux. Hydrophobic membranes showed fouling in all charge conditionsand, furthermore, especially at the beginning of the experiment even at very low transmembrane pressures. Fouling of these membranes was thought to be due to protein adsorption by hydrophobic interactions. The hydrophilic membranes used suffered more from reversible fouling and concentration polarisation than from irreversible foul-ing. They became fouled at higher transmembrane pressures becauseof pore blocking. In this thesis some new aspects on critical flux are presented that are important for ultrafiltration and fractionation of proteins.
Resumo:
Työn tarkoituksena oli kehittää kerrosleijukattilan sekundääri-ilmansyöttöä. Työssä tutkittiin tulipesässä ilmasuihkujen käyttäytymiseen vaikuttavia tekijöitä sekä eri ilmansyöttömallien vaikutuksia tulipesäolosuhteisiin. Sekundääri- ja tertiääri-ilmasuihkujen tehtävänä on sekoittaa tulipesän kaasuja sekä tuoda happi leijupetin yläpuolelle haihtuneiden aineiden palamisen loppuun saattamiseksi. Kaasujen sekoittumiseen vaikuttavat ilmasuihkun ja ristivirtauksen liikemäärien suhde, suutinten koko ja sijoittelu toisiinsa nähden. Ilmasuihku saavuttaa paremman tunkeutuvuuden ja siten tehokkaamman sekoittumisen suuttimen koon kasvaessa. Lisäksi tunkeutuvuus paranee suutinten välisen etäisyyden sekä ilmasuihkun ja ristivirtauksen liikemäärien suhteen kasvaessa. Optimaalisen suutinten välisen etäisyyden osoitettiin riippuvan suuttimen ja tulipesän koosta sekä ilmasuihkun ja ristivirtauksen liikemäärien suhteesta. Saatujen tulosten mukaan sekundääri- ja tertiääri-ilmatasoilla tulee suosia suuria harvaan ja lomittain sijoitettuja suuttimia. Ilmansyöttömalleja tutkittiin numeerisesti mallintamalla, ja saatujen tulosten perusteella tehokkain sekoittuminen saavutettiin sijoittamalla sekundääri-ilmasuuttimet tulipesän kahdelle vastakkaiselle seinälle.
Resumo:
Työssä selvitettiin suodatusolosuhteiden vaikutusta neutraalien polymeerien pidättymiseen niiden vesiliuoksia suodatettaessa. Suodatuksissa käytettiin kahta regeneroidusta selluloosasta valmistettua ultrasuodatuskalvoa (Microdyn-Nadir UC 030T ja JSC STC Vladipor C 30V). Malliaineina käytettiin polyetyleeniglykolia ja dekstraania. Kirjallisuusosassa esiteltiin aluksi lyhyesti ultrasuodatus erotusmenetelmänä. Lisäksi käsiteltiin ultrasuodatuskalvojen huokoskoon karakterisointimenetelmiä ja selvitettiin polymeerien erottumiseen ultrasuodatuksen aikana vaikuttavia tekijöitä. Työn kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin paineen ja virtausnopeuden vaikutusta malliaineiden pidättymiseen ultrasuodatuskalvoilla. Lisäksi pyrittiin löytämään suodatusolosuhteet, joissa toinen aineista läpäisisi suodatuskalvon lähes täydellisesti toisen konsentroituessa syöttöliuokseen. Työssä myös määritettiin tutkimuksissa käytetyille kalvoille katkaisukoko, joka kuvaa kalvon kykyä pidättää moolimassaltaan erikokoisia molekyylejä. Lisäksi kokeellisessa osassa selvitettiin työssä käytettyjen kalvojen tasalaatuisuutta vertailemalla keskenään samanlaisissa suodatusolosuhteissa eri kalvopaloilla tehtyjen suodatusten tuloksia. Työssä saatiin erotettua kaksi lähes samankokoista malliaineeksi valittua neutraalia polymeeriä toisistaan siten, että toinen aine pidättyi kalvolla huomattavasti toista ainetta paremmin. Parhaimpaan erotustulokseen päästiin, kun permeaattivuo kalvon läpi oli noin 400 l/(m2 h). Tällöin suodatuspaine oli noin 2 bar ja virtausnopeus alle 2 m/s. Työn aikana määritettyjen katkaisukokojen havaittiin poikkeavan huomattavasti kalvojen valmistajien ilmoittamista arvoista, mutta olevan kuitenkin samaa suuruusluokkaa kuin muiden tutkimusryhmien vastaaville ultrasuodatuskalvoille esittämät arvot. Työn tulosten perusteella C 30V olisi hieman tasalaatuisempi kalvo kuin UC 030T.
Resumo:
Results on the optimization of analytical methods for the determination of phosphorus in phosphino-polycarboxylate (PPCA), used frequently as scale inhibitor during oil production, by ICP-AES and ICP-MS are presented. Due to the complex matrix of production waters (brines) and their high concentration in inorganic phosphorus, the separation of organic phosphorus prior to its determination is necessary. In this work, minicolumns of silica immobilized C18 were used. Optimization of the separation step resulted in the following working conditions: (1) prewashing of the column with methanol (80% v/v); (2) use of a flow rate of 5 mL/min and 10 mL/min, respectively, for the preconditioning step and for percolation of the water sample; (3) final elution of organic phosphorus with 7 mL of buffer of H3BO3/NaOH (0.05 M, pH 9) with a flow rate of 1 mL/min. Sample detection limits (3s) for different combinations of nebulizers and spectrometric methods, based on 10 mL water aliquots, are: ICP-AES -Cross flow (47 mg/L) and Ultrasonic (18 mug/L); ICP-MS -Cross flow (1.2 mug/L), Cyclonic (0.7 mug/L) and Ultrasonic (0.5 mug/L). Typical recoveries of organic phosphorus are between 90 and 95% and the repeatability of the whole procedure is better than 10%. The developed methodology was applied successfully to samples from the oil-well NA 46, platform PNA 2, Campos basin, Brazil. Assessment of the PPCA inhibitor was possible at lower concentrations than achieved by current analytical methods, resulting in benefits such as reduced cost of chemicals, postponed oil production and lower environmental impacts.
Resumo:
Streaming potential measurements for the surface charge characterisation of different filter media types and materials were used. The equipment was developed further so that measurements could be taken along the surfaces, and so that tubular membranes could also be measured. The streaming potential proved to be a very useful tool in the charge analysis of both clean and fouled filter media. Adsorption and fouling could be studied, as could flux, as functions of time. A module to determine the membrane potential was also constructed. The results collected from the experiments conducted with these devices were used in the study of the theory of streaming potential as an electrokinetic phenomenon. Several correction factors, which are derived to take into account the surface conductance and the electrokinetic flow in very narrow capillaries, were tested in practice. The surface materials were studied using FTIR and the results compared with those from the streaming potentials. FTIR analysis was also found to be a useful tool in the characterisation of filters, as well as in the fouling studies. Upon examination of the recorded spectra from different depths in a sample it was possible to determine the adsorption sites. The influence of an external electric field on the cross flow microflltration of a binary protein system was investigated using a membrane electroflltration apparatus. The results showed that a significant improvement could be achieved in membrane filtration by using the measured electrochemical properties to help adjust the process conditions.
Resumo:
In many industries, such as petroleum production, and the petrochemical, metal, food and cosmetics industries, wastewaters containing an emulsion of oil in water are often produced. The emulsions consist of water (up to 90%), oils (mineral, animal, vegetable and synthetic), surfactants and other contaminates. In view of its toxic nature and its deleterious effects on the surrounding environment (soil, water) such wastewater needs to be treated before release into natural water ways. Membrane-based processes have successfully been applied in industrial applications and are considered as possible candidates for the treatment of oily wastewaters. Easy operation, lower cost, and in some cases, the ability to reduce contaminants below existing pollution limits are the main advantages of these systems. The main drawback of membranes is flux decline due tofouling and concentration polarisation. The complexity of oil-containing systems demands complementary studies on issues related to the mitigation of fouling and concentration polarisation in membranebased ultrafiltration. In this thesis the effect of different operating conditions (factors) on ultrafiltration of oily water is studied. Important factors are normally correlated and, therefore, their effect should be studied simultaneously. This work uses a novel approach to study different operating conditions, like pressure, flow velocity, and temperature, and solution properties, like oil concentration (cutting oil, diesel, kerosene), pH, and salt concentration (CaCl2 and NaCl)) in the ultrafiltration of oily water, simultaneously and in a systematic way using an experimental design approach. A hypothesis is developed to describe the interaction between the oil drops, salt and the membrane surface. The optimum conditions for ultrafiltration and the contribution of each factor in the ultrafiltration of oily water are evaluated. It is found that the effect on permeate flux of the various factors studied strongly depended on the type of oil, the type of membrane and the amount of salts. The thesis demonstrates that a system containing oil is very complex, and that fouling and flux decline can be observed even at very low pressures. This means that only the weak form of the critical flux exists for such systems. The cleaning of the fouled membranes and the influence of different parameters (flow velocity, temperature, time, pressure, and chemical concentration (SDS, NaOH)) were evaluated in this study. It was observed that fouling, and consequently cleaning, behaved differently for the studied membranes. Of the membranes studied, the membrane with the lowest propensity for fouling and the most easily cleaned was the regenerated cellulose membrane (C100H). In order to get more information about the interaction between the membrane and the components of the emulsion, a streaming potential study was performed on the membrane. The experiments were carried out at different pH and oil concentration. It was seen that oily water changed the surface charge of the membrane significantly. The surface charge and the streaming potential during different stages of filtration were measured and analysed being a new method for fouling of oil in this thesis. The surface charge varied in different stages of filtration. It was found that the surface charge of a cleaned membrane was not the same as initially; however, the permeability was equal to that of a virgin membrane. The effect of filtration mode was studied by performing the filtration in both cross-flow and deadend mode. The effect of salt on performance was considered in both studies. It was found that salt decreased the permeate flux even at low concentration. To test the effect of hydrophilicity change, the commercial membranes used in this thesis were modified by grafting (PNIPAAm) on their surfaces. A new technique (corona treatment) was used for this modification. The effect of modification on permeate flux and retention was evaluated. The modified membranes changed their pore size around 33oC resulting in different retention and permeability. The obtained results in this thesis can be applied to optimise the operation of a membrane plant under normal or shock conditions or to modify the process such that it becomes more efficient or effective.
Resumo:
Hydroksihapoille on olemassa useita käyttömahdollisuuksia teollisuudessa, joten niiden hyödyntäminen sellunvalmistuksen sivuvirrasta eli mustalipeästä on suuren kiinnostuksen kohteena. Tässä työssä selvitettiin, onko hydroksihappojen erotus ja puhdistus mustalipeästä mahdollista nanosuodatuksella. Kokeellisessa osassa suodatettiin emäksisen mustalipeän lisäksi hapotettua ja jäähdytyskiteytettyä mustalipeää, johon oli lisätty liuotinta. Mustalipeäsuodatuksissa käytettiin viittä erilaista nanosuodatusmembraania (Microdyn Nadir® NP010 ja NP030, Dow Chemical Company NF-90, Woongjin Chemical NE-70 sekä Ge-Osmonics Desal 5 DK). Kirjallisuusosassa käsiteltiin puun sisältämien yhdisteiden kemiallista koostumusta, sellun valmistuksen pääperiaatteita, mustalipeän ja hydroksihappojen ominaisuuksia sekä hydroksihappojen käyttömahdollisuuksia. Lisäksi tarkasteltiin erilaisia hydroksihappojen erotusmenetelmiä, nanosuodatuksen teoriaa ja prosessiin sopivan membraanin valintakriteerejä. Työn kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin emäksisen mustalipeän monivaiheisen nanosuodatuksen tehokkuutta hydroksihappojen erotuksessa. Hapotetun ja jäähdytyskiteytetyn mustalipeän suodatuskokeissa tutkittiin erityyppisten membraanien erotuskykyä sekä syötön liuotinlisäyksen vaikutusta hydroksihappojen erottumiseen. Lisäksi tarkasteltiin membraanien kestävyyttä ja foulaantumista suodatusolosuhteissa. Työn tulokset osoittivat, että hydroksihappoja voidaan fraktioida mustalipeästä nanosuodatuksella. Hydroksihappojen fraktiointiin vaikuttaa merkittävästi mustalipeässä käytetyn liuottimen läsnäolo sekä suodatuspaine. Lisäksi koetulosten perusteella havaittiin, että monivaiheisella nanosuodatuksella hydroksihapot läpäisevät membraanin ja permeaattiin saavutetaan puhtaampi happojae.
Resumo:
Työn tarkoituksena oli tutkia arvometalleja sisältävän liuoksen puhdistamista jat-kuvatoimisella ioninvaihdolla. Teoriaosassa käsitellään ioninvaihdon periaate, sekä jatkuvatoimisen ioninvaihdon laiteratkaisuja ristivirta- ja vastavirtasysteemeissä. Lopuksi esitellään Simuloidun liikkuvapedin (SMB) virtausnopeuksien laske-miseksi käytettävä kolmiomenetelmä. Kokeellisen osan tarkoituksena on demonstroida laboratorioon rakennetun jatku-vatoimisen ioninvaihtimen, Simuloidun liikkuvapedin, käyttö arvometallia sisäl-tävän liuoksen puhdistamiseksi kahdenarvoisista metalli-ioneista. Kokeissa käy-tettiin hopeaa sisältävää NaCl-liuosta, josta pyrittiin puhdistamaan Mg2+, Ca2+, Pb2+ ja Zn2+-ionit ekstraktina. Laitteistolla suoritettiin kolme ajoa, joista kaksi edusti vastavirtasysteemiä ja yksi ristivirtasysteemiä. Ensimmäisessä vastavirta-ajossa sekä ekstrakti että raffinaattin erottuva hopealiuos tulivat puhtaina. Toisessa vastavirta-ajossa pyrittiin parantamaan tuottavuutta nostamalla syötön virtausnopeutta, jolloin raffinaatin puhtaus kärsi Pb2+ ja Mg2+-ionien kulkeutuessa liuosfaasin mukana raffinaattiin. Ristivirta-ajossa vain yksi kolmesta raffinaatista saavutti 100 % puhtauden. Kokeet osoittivat, että Mg2+, Ca2+, Pb2+ ja Zn2+-ionien erottaminen hopeaionista on mahdollista käyttämällämme SMB-laitteistolla. Tuottavuuden parantaminen syötön virtausnopeutta nostamalla kuitenkin heikentää puhtautta. Cross-flow-systeemin erilleenkytkettyjen kolonnien ansioista painehäviö on pienempi, mikä mahdollistaa korkeammat virtausnopeudet, mikäli ei vaadita 100 % puhtautta.