Utilizing the Internet of Things to promote energy awareness and efficiency at discrete production processes: Practices and methodology

El actual contexto de fabricación, con incrementos en los precios de la energía, una creciente preocupación medioambiental y cambios continuos en los comportamientos de los consumidores, fomenta que los responsables prioricen la fabricación respetuosa con el medioambiente. El paradigma del Internet de las Cosas (IoT) promete incrementar la visibilidad y la atención prestada al consumo de energía gracias tanto a sensores como a medidores inteligentes en los niveles de máquina y de línea de producción. En consecuencia es posible y sencillo obtener datos de consumo de energía en tiempo real proveniente de los procesos de fabricación, pero además es posible analizarlos para incrementar su importancia en la toma de decisiones. Esta tesis pretende investigar cómo utilizar la adopción del Internet de las Cosas en el nivel de planta de producción, en procesos discretos, para incrementar la capacidad de uso de la información proveniente tanto de la energía como de la eficiencia energética. Para alcanzar este objetivo general, la investigación se ha dividido en cuatro sub-objetivos y la misma se ha desarrollado a lo largo de cuatro fases principales (en adelante estudios). El primer estudio de esta tesis, que se apoya sobre una revisión bibliográfica comprehensiva y sobre las aportaciones de expertos, define prácticas de gestión de la producción que son energéticamente eficientes y que se apoyan de un modo preeminente en la tecnología IoT. Este primer estudio también detalla los beneficios esperables al adoptar estas prácticas de gestión. Además, propugna un marco de referencia para permitir la integración de los datos que sobre el consumo energético se obtienen en el marco de las plataformas y sistemas de información de la compañía. Esto se lleva a cabo con el objetivo último de remarcar cómo estos datos pueden ser utilizados para apalancar decisiones en los niveles de procesos tanto tácticos como operativos. Segundo, considerando los precios de la energía como variables en el mercado intradiario y la disponibilidad de información detallada sobre el estado de las máquinas desde el punto de vista de consumo energético, el segundo estudio propone un modelo matemático para minimizar los costes del consumo de energía para la programación de asignaciones de una única máquina que deba atender a varios procesos de producción. Este modelo permite la toma de decisiones en el nivel de máquina para determinar los instantes de lanzamiento de cada trabajo de producción, los tiempos muertos, cuándo la máquina debe ser puesta en un estado de apagada, el momento adecuado para rearrancar, y para pararse, etc. Así, este modelo habilita al responsable de producción de implementar el esquema de producción menos costoso para cada turno de producción. En el tercer estudio esta investigación proporciona una metodología para ayudar a los responsables a implementar IoT en el nivel de los sistemas productivos. Se incluye un análisis del estado en que se encuentran los sistemas de gestión de energía y de producción en la factoría, así como también se proporcionan recomendaciones sobre procedimientos para implementar IoT para capturar y analizar los datos de consumo. Esta metodología ha sido validada en un estudio piloto, donde algunos indicadores clave de rendimiento (KPIs) han sido empleados para determinar la eficiencia energética. En el cuarto estudio el objetivo es introducir una vía para obtener visibilidad y relevancia a diferentes niveles de la energía consumida en los procesos de producción. El método propuesto permite que las factorías con procesos de producción discretos puedan determinar la energía consumida, el CO2 emitido o el coste de la energía consumida ya sea en cualquiera de los niveles: operación, producto o la orden de fabricación completa, siempre considerando las diferentes fuentes de energía y las fluctuaciones en los precios de la misma. Los resultados muestran que decisiones y prácticas de gestión para conseguir sistemas de producción energéticamente eficientes son posibles en virtud del Internet de las Cosas. También, con los resultados de esta tesis los responsables de la gestión energética en las compañías pueden plantearse una aproximación a la utilización del IoT desde un punto de vista de la obtención de beneficios, abordando aquellas prácticas de gestión energética que se encuentran más próximas al nivel de madurez de la factoría, a sus objetivos, al tipo de producción que desarrolla, etc. Así mismo esta tesis muestra que es posible obtener reducciones significativas de coste simplemente evitando los períodos de pico diario en el precio de la misma. Además la tesis permite identificar cómo el nivel de monitorización del consumo energético (es decir al nivel de máquina), el intervalo temporal, y el nivel del análisis de los datos son factores determinantes a la hora de localizar oportunidades para mejorar la eficiencia energética. Adicionalmente, la integración de datos de consumo energético en tiempo real con datos de producción (cuando existen altos niveles de estandarización en los procesos productivos y sus datos) es esencial para permitir que las factorías detallen la energía efectivamente consumida, su coste y CO2 emitido durante la producción de un producto o componente. Esto permite obtener una valiosa información a los gestores en el nivel decisor de la factoría así como a los consumidores y reguladores. ABSTRACT In today‘s manufacturing scenario, rising energy prices, increasing ecological awareness, and changing consumer behaviors are driving decision makers to prioritize green manufacturing. The Internet of Things (IoT) paradigm promises to increase the visibility and awareness of energy consumption, thanks to smart sensors and smart meters at the machine and production line level. Consequently, real-time energy consumption data from the manufacturing processes can be easily collected and then analyzed, to improve energy-aware decision-making. This thesis aims to investigate how to utilize the adoption of the Internet of Things at shop floor level to increase energy–awareness and the energy efficiency of discrete production processes. In order to achieve the main research goal, the research is divided into four sub-objectives, and is accomplished during four main phases (i.e., studies). In the first study, by relying on a comprehensive literature review and on experts‘ insights, the thesis defines energy-efficient production management practices that are enhanced and enabled by IoT technology. The first study also explains the benefits that can be obtained by adopting such management practices. Furthermore, it presents a framework to support the integration of gathered energy data into a company‘s information technology tools and platforms, which is done with the ultimate goal of highlighting how operational and tactical decision-making processes could leverage such data in order to improve energy efficiency. Considering the variable energy prices in one day, along with the availability of detailed machine status energy data, the second study proposes a mathematical model to minimize energy consumption costs for single machine production scheduling during production processes. This model works by making decisions at the machine level to determine the launch times for job processing, idle time, when the machine must be shut down, ―turning on‖ time, and ―turning off‖ time. This model enables the operations manager to implement the least expensive production schedule during a production shift. In the third study, the research provides a methodology to help managers implement the IoT at the production system level; it includes an analysis of current energy management and production systems at the factory, and recommends procedures for implementing the IoT to collect and analyze energy data. The methodology has been validated by a pilot study, where energy KPIs have been used to evaluate energy efficiency. In the fourth study, the goal is to introduce a way to achieve multi-level awareness of the energy consumed during production processes. The proposed method enables discrete factories to specify energy consumption, CO2 emissions, and the cost of the energy consumed at operation, production and order levels, while considering energy sources and fluctuations in energy prices. The results show that energy-efficient production management practices and decisions can be enhanced and enabled by the IoT. With the outcomes of the thesis, energy managers can approach the IoT adoption in a benefit-driven way, by addressing energy management practices that are close to the maturity level of the factory, target, production type, etc. The thesis also shows that significant reductions in energy costs can be achieved by avoiding high-energy price periods in a day. Furthermore, the thesis determines the level of monitoring energy consumption (i.e., machine level), the interval time, and the level of energy data analysis, which are all important factors involved in finding opportunities to improve energy efficiency. Eventually, integrating real-time energy data with production data (when there are high levels of production process standardization data) is essential to enable factories to specify the amount and cost of energy consumed, as well as the CO2 emitted while producing a product, providing valuable information to decision makers at the factory level as well as to consumers and regulators.

Guidelines for Linked Data generation and publication: an example in building energy consumption

Linked Data is the key paradigm of the Semantic Web, a new generation of the World Wide Web that promises to bring meaning (semantics) to data. A large number of both public and private organizations have published their data following the Linked Data principles, or have done so with data from other organizations. To this extent, since the generation and publication of Linked Data are intensive engineering processes that require high attention in order to achieve high quality, and since experience has shown that existing general guidelines are not always sufficient to be applied to every domain, this paper presents a set of guidelines for generating and publishing Linked Data in the context of energy consumption in buildings (one aspect of Building Information Models). These guidelines offer a comprehensive description of the tasks to perform, including a list of steps, tools that help in achieving the task, various alternatives for performing the task, and best practices and recommendations. Furthermore, this paper presents a complete example on the generation and publication of Linked Data about energy consumption in buildings, following the presented guidelines, in which the energy consumption data of council sites (e.g., buildings and lights) belonging to the Leeds City Council jurisdiction have been generated and published as Linked Data.

Typing of urinary JC virus DNA offers a novel means of tracing human migrations

Although polyomavirus JC (JCV) is the proven pathogen of progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy, the fatal demyelinating disease, this virus is ubiquitous as a usually harmless symbiote among human beings. JCV propagates in the adult kidney and excretes its progeny in urine, from which JCV DNA can readily be recovered. The main mode of transmission of JCV is from parents to children through long cohabitation. In this study, we collected a substantial number of urine samples from native inhabitants of 34 countries in Europe, Africa, and Asia. A 610-bp segment of JCV DNA was amplified from each urine sample, and its DNA sequence was determined. A worldwide phylogenetic tree subsequently constructed revealed the presence of nine subtypes including minor ones. Five subtypes (EU, Af2, B1, SC, and CY) occupied rather large territories that overlapped with each other at their boundaries. The entire Europe, northern Africa, and western Asia were the domain of EU, whereas the domain of Af2 included nearly all of Africa and southwestern Asia all the way to the northeastern edge of India. Partially overlapping domains in Asia were occupied by subtypes B1, SC, and CY. Of particular interest was the recovery of JCV subtypes in a pocket or pockets that were separated by great geographic distances from the main domains of those subtypes. Certain of these pockets can readily be explained by recent migrations of human populations carrying these subtypes. Overall, it appears that JCV genotyping promises to reveal previously unknown human migration routes: ancient as well as recent.

Matchings and phylogenetic trees

This paper presents a natural coordinate system for phylogenetic trees using a correspondence with the set of perfect matchings in the complete graph. This correspondence produces a distance between phylogenetic trees, and a way of enumerating all trees in a minimal step order. It is useful in randomized algorithms because it enables moves on the space of trees that make random optimization strategies “mix” quickly. It also promises a generalization to intermediary trees when data are not decisive as to their choice of tree, and a new way of constructing Bayesian priors on tree space.

Fluorescent RNA cytochemistry: tracking gene transcripts in living cells

The advent of jellyfish green fluorescent protein and its spectral variants, together with promising new fluorescent proteins from other classes of the Cnidarian phylum (coral and anemones), has greatly enhanced and promises to further boost the detection and localization of proteins in cell biology. It has been less widely appreciated that highly sensitive methods have also recently been developed for detecting the movement and localization in living cells of the very molecules that precede proteins in the gene expression pathway, i.e. RNAs. These approaches include the microinjection of fluorescent RNAs into living cells, the in vivo hybridization of fluorescent oligonucleotides to endogenous RNAs and the expression in cells of fluorescent RNA-binding proteins. This new field of ‘fluorescent RNA cytochemistry’ is summarized in this article, with emphasis on the biological insights it has already provided. These new techniques are likely to soon collaborate with other emerging approaches to advance the investigation of RNA birth, RNA–protein assembly and ribonucleoprotein particle transport in systems such as oocytes, embryos, neurons and other somatic cells, and may even permit the observation of viral replication and transcription pathways as they proceed in living cells, ushering in a new era of nucleic acids research in vivo.

Efficient pyrophosphorolysis by a hepatitis B virus polymerase may be a primer-unblocking mechanism

Effective antiviral agents are thought to inhibit hepatitis B virus (HBV) DNA synthesis irreversibly by chain termination because reverse transcriptases (RT) lack an exonucleolytic activity that can remove incorporated nucleotides. However, since the parameters governing this inhibition are poorly defined, fully delineating the catalytic mechanism of the HBV-RT promises to facilitate the development of antiviral drugs for treating chronic HBV infection. To this end, pyrophosphorolysis and pyrophosphate exchange, two nonhydrolytic RT activities that result in the removal of newly incorporated nucleotides, were characterized by using endogenous avian HBV replication complexes assembled in vivo. Although these activities are presumed to be physiologically irrelevant for every polymerase examined, the efficiency with which they are catalyzed by the avian HBV-RT strongly suggests that it is the first known polymerase to catalyze these reactions under replicative conditions. The ability to remove newly incorporated nucleotides during replication has important biological and clinical implications: these activities may serve a primer-unblocking function in vivo. Analysis of pyrophosphorolysis on chain-terminated DNA revealed that the potent anti-HBV drug β-l-(−)-2′,3′-dideoxy-3′-thiacytidine (3TC) was difficult to remove by pyrophosphorolysis, in contrast to ineffective chain terminators such as ddC. This disparity may account for the strong antiviral efficacy of 3TC versus that of ddC. The HBV-RT pyrophosphorolytic activity may therefore be a novel determinant of antiviral drug efficacy, and could serve as a target for future antiviral drug therapy. The strong inhibitory effect of cytoplasmic pyrophosphate concentrations on viral DNA synthesis may also partly account for the apparent slow rate of HBV genome replication.

Clonagem molecular, expressão, purificação e caracterização estrutural da endoglucanase de Trichoderma harzianum visando o desenvolvimento de coquetéis enzimáticos para a produção de etanol lignocelulósico

O aumento na demanda mundial por energia, a perspectiva de encolhimento dos recursos energéticos e a preocupação global com a questão ambiental, despertaram o interesse por fontes alternativas de energia. A biomassa lignocelulósica é abundante e de baixo custo, com potencial para complementar a produção em larga escala de combustíveis. A degradação das moléculas constituintes da parede celular à açúcares fermentescíveis e então à etanol, ocorre através da hidrólise enzimática da biomassa. Contudo, a utilização de enzimas para esse fim encontra-se em estágio exploratório e representa um gargalo na implementação de tecnologias de etanol 2G em escala industrial, desencadeando a busca de celulases bioquimicamente mais ativas, estáveis e economicamente viáveis. O presente trabalho visou a caracterização da endoglucanase I do fungo Trichoderma harzianum, e para isso foi realizada expressão, ensaios bioquímicos e biofísicos do domínio catalítico (ThCel7B-CCD) e da proteína inteira (ThCel7B-full). A enzima exibiu um perfil acidofílico, com atividade ótima em pH 3,0 a 55°C. A proteína também se mostrou capaz de hidrolisar uma variedade de substratos, sendo a maior atividade hidrolítica em β-glucano (75 U mg-1). Ao analisar a estabilidade térmica medida a 55°C em pH 5, a atividade residual manteve-se intacta por mais de 2 meses. Outra característica relevante foi o elevado grau de sinergismo entre ThCel7B e ThCel7A. Análises de microscopia eletrônica de flocos de aveia submetidas à hidrólise com ThCel7B evidenciaram os efeitos de degradação do substrato em relação às amostras controle. O conjunto desses resultados, além de importante para a compreensão do mecanismo molecular de ThCel7B e de outras endoglucanases da família GH7, também revelou uma enzima de interesse biotecnológicos uma vez que o comportamento ácido e sua estabilidade térmica são características relevantes para aplicações industriais sob condições extremamente ácidas.

Direito, democracia e cultura digital: a experiência de elaboração legislativa do Marco Civil da Internet

Este trabalho tem como objeto de pesquisa o processo de consulta pública online para elaboração do Marco Civil da Internet, nova lei que dispõe sobre os direitos dos usuários de Internet no Brasil. Ele busca responder às seguintes perguntas: (i) como foi idealizado processo de consulta pública online do Marco Civil da Internet? (ii) Como a consulta foi gerenciada e executada? (iii) Quais foram os resultados da consulta em termos de soluções jurídicas aos conflitos políticos do setor da Internet? A proposta é realizar uma descrição desta experiência de participação social pela Internet a partir de um mapeamento das contribuições dos cidadãos e instituições, de informações em fontes variadas (imprensa especializada ou não e outros trabalhos acadêmicos) e do confronto deste levantamento com entrevistas dadas pelos gestores do projeto sobre seu planejamento e execução. A pesquisa trabalhou com a hipótese de que a consulta pública online que elaborou o Marco Civil da Internet se colocou como alternativa a um debate instaurado dentro do Congresso Nacional e bloqueado por propostas de lei de enfoque penal. O resultado da pesquisa sugere a confirmação dessa hipótese, bem como a relevância da experiência analisada para o sucesso uma estratégia política de reversão dessa agenda legislativa anterior.

O management e o índio: um estudo sobre o programa de sustentabilidade socioambiental e cultural na terra indigena Apucaraninha, Paraná

O Programa de Desenvolvimento Sustentável Socioambiental e Cultural da Terra Indígena Apucaraninha foi criado como condicionalidade para que a comunidade pudesse receber parte dos recursos oriundos da compensação pela construção e operação da Usina Hidrelétrica de Apucaraninha, instalada dentro das terras indígenas. Teoricamente criado para ser um programa em que os índios participassem de forma ativa e igualitária na sua construção e implementação, já nasce contraditório frente à hegemonia da ideologia da sociedade envolvente imersa na ideologia do management. É assim que tenho como objetivo compreender como o management, enquanto ideologia que se materializa em discurso, atua sobre o Programa de Sustentabilidade Socioambiental e Cultural na Terra Indígena Apucaraninha, Paraná. Para isso, faço uma pesquisa qualitativa em que os discursos, coletados por meio de entrevistas semiestruturadas e grupo focal, aplicados aos indígenas e aos não-indígenas participantes do programa, foram interpretados sob a perspectiva dos elementos da Análise do Discurso na Linha Francesa. Como apoio, ainda analisei documentos do programa e os emitidos pelo Ministério Público Federal. Os principais resultados mostram que, como eu já desconfiava, o programa exclui a participação dos indígenas de fato, uma vez que eles são considerados pelos \"brancos\", de maneira estereotipada, como irracionais, indolentes e atrasados e, assim, incapazes de escolher o \"melhor caminho\" para a sustentabilidade do programa que, neste momento, passa se orientar por uma visão economicista e materialista, contrário a lógica dos índios Kaingang. Ao discurso do management, sustentado pelo discurso capitalista, que promete a felicidade, se junta o discurso do colonizador, que trabalha desclassificando o modo de vida dos indígenas, os colocando em uma situação de vulnerabilidade que pode, assim, promover o seu extermínio, mesmo que não seja físico

Incidencia de las herramientas tecnológicas digitales en las rutinas periodísticas. Estudio de El Mercurio y La Tercera, como exponentes de los medios impresos y en línea chilenos

Already entered in the XXI century "new technologies of information and communication" are hardly "new". Beyond the continuous generation of new technological tools, many more associated with technological dazzle than a real contribution to innovation, there have been few certainties and many promises which, from the advent of Internet in the civilian world, were generated. One of the areas where special Internet has generated excitement has been in the media. In the media field, which is the segment to which we dedicate this research, extreme market liberalization has meant an increasing concentration of media, such as will be discussed at greater length in Chapter IV. According to figures from the Association of Journalists of Chile, 90% of printed newspapers are controlled by two groups; one radio station signals concentrated twenty and 50% of the advertising pie, while increasing arrival of the financial sector to television is observed...

Declaration signed by Harvard students to not speak in the vernacular for one year, 1712 August 23

The declaration, handwritten in Latin and signed by members of the junior and sophomore classes (Harvard Classes of 1714 and 1715), promises that the undersigned will not use the vernacular but instead "whenever, at meals, at banquets,...in our rooms, in all our gatherings, wherever and whenever" will speak in Latin, Greek, or Hebrew through the next May. Additional Latin text appears on both the front and back of the document. The original is accompanied by a typed transcription and two partial handwritten translations. Note at top of original: "Script. Leonardo Dowding, Composit. a Tho. Foxcroft."

Letter from William Tudor to his brother, Henry James Tudor,

In this letter written to his youngest brother from London, Tudor promises when he returns to America, he will protect him from their siblings if they have been picking on him.

Taking stock after the Warsaw COP. CEPS Commentary, 4 December 2013

Drawing on his direct participation in the latest round of climate talks in Warsaw, Andrei Marcu looks at the results of the 19th COP through the lens of three basic questions, with a view to understanding how much progress was made and where we stand two years ahead of Paris. Are the targets adequate and how do we reach environmentally adequate targets? Can one understand and compare what other Parties are promising to do to ensure that the level of effort is comparable and equitable, and that companies are not asked to do more than their competitors in other jurisdictions? Is there comparability and equity in the eyes of the beholder? Do we understand what tools each country uses (what is available, what one gets as support) to ensure that no one country (and its companies) gets an easier ride or competitive advantage in meeting the commitment/promises that countries make. The author asserts that these questions need to be answered if an agreement is to be reached in 2015. And if they are not, he warns of mistrust, fear of carbon leakage and the temptation to resort to protectionist measures to compensate for competitive disadvantage.

The 2011 Constitutional reform in Morocco: more flaws than merits. Jean Monnet Occasional Paper No. 07/2014

Introduction. In the speech given to both Houses of Parliament on 11 October 2013 during the first parliamentary session, King Mohammed VI said that the “Moroccan democratic model” was “a precursor in the region as well as on the continental level.”1 Similarly, with the purpose of stressing the “democratic exceptionalism”2 of the country, the new government, led by Abdeilah Benkirane, emphasised that Morocco represents a “third way” compared to countries such as Tunisia, Libya or Egypt since it “…has not embarked on a limited process of reform from the top, driven and controlled by the King. Nor has it experienced a revolution brought a angry citizens rising up against the regime. Rather, it has chosen an alternate path based on a genuine partnership between the King and the PJD (Parti de la justice et du développement) that promises to bring about more far-reaching reform than palace alone would grant, without the disruption caused by uncontrolled popular upheaval.”4 It should not be at all surprising that the regime and the new Government consider Morocco a “democratic model” or a “third way.” After all, they are refe country. What is harder to understand is that when discussing the Arab uprisings, even prominent Western political leaders, representatives of the European Union institutions and the mainstream media (when they do not forget about Morocc to praise the process of democratic reform carried out by Mohammed VI. For example, on 12 September 2012, Hillary Clinton, former US Secretary of State, said, “in many ways, the United States looks to Morocco to be a leader and a model […] On political reform, we have all seen remarkable changes taking place across North Africa and the Middle East. I commend Morocco and your government for your efforts to stay ahead of these changes by holding free and fair elections, empowering the elected parliament, taking other steps to ensure that the government reflects the will of the people.”5 Similarly, former French President Nicolas Sarkozy sang the praises of the process that led to the adoption of the new 2011 Constitution: “King Mohammed VI has shown the path towards a profound, peaceful and modern transformation of Moroccan institutions and society […] France fully supports this exemplary process.” Interestingly enough, even at the European Union level the constitutional reform that took more far-reaching reform than palace alone would grant, without the disruption caused by uncontrolled popular upheaval.”4 It should not be at all surprising that the regime and the new Government consider Morocco a “democratic model” or a “third way.” After all, they are refe country. What is harder to understand is that when discussing the Arab uprisings, even prominent Western political leaders, representatives of the European Union institutions and the mainstream media (when they do not forget about Morocc to praise the process of democratic reform carried out by Mohammed VI. For example, on 12 September 2012, Hillary Clinton, former US Secretary of State, said, “in many ways, the United States looks to Morocco to be a leader and a model […] On political reform, we have all seen remarkable changes taking place across North Africa and the Middle East. I commend Morocco and your government for your efforts to stay ahead of these changes by holding free and fair elections, empowering the elected parliament, taking other steps to ensure that the government reflects the will of the people.”5 Similarly, former French President Nicolas Sarkozy sang the praises of the process that led to the adoption of the new 2011 Constitution: “King Mohammed VI has shown the path towards a profound, peaceful and modern transformation of Moroccan institutions and society […] France fully supports this exemplary process.” Interestingly enough, even at the European Union level the constitutional reform that took place in Morocco was considered an extremely positive step taken by the country, as well as a means to strengthen the cooperation between the EU and Morocco. Indeed, according to the High Representative Catherine Ashton, this reform “constitute[s] a significant response to the legitimate aspirations of the Moroccan people and [is] consistent with Morocco’s Advanced Status with the EU.”7 When it comes to the media, it is worth noting that following the ratification of the 2011 Constitution, The New York Times headlined: “All Hail the (Democratic) King.” Even sections of the academic literature have commended the constitutional reform carried out by the Moroccan Sovereign.9 In this paper I argue against the aforementioned idea, according to which Morocco should be considered a model in the region, and in particular I show that the constitution-making process, the 2011 Constitution and its subsequent implementation have more flaws than merits. Accordingly, this paper proceeds in five steps. First of all, I examine the reaction of the regime to the upheavals that broke out in the country after 20 February 2011. Secondly, I analyse the process of constitution showing its main strengths and weaknesses, and comparing it with other constituent processes that took place in the region following the Arab uprisings. In the third section, I highlight the most significant elements of continuity and discontinuity with the previous 1996 Constitution. The fourth section deals with the process of implementation: specifically process is proceeding quite slowly and that in some cases ordinary legislation is in contrast with the new Constitution and international human rights treaties. Moreover, I discuss the role that the judiciary and the Constitutional Court can play in the implementation and interpretation of the Constitution. Finally, I draw some concluding remarks.

The tug of war. Russia's response to changes on the European gas market. OSW Study 50/2014

Russia, being aware of the evolution of the EU gas market and the fluctuations in trends that accompany it, and in an attempt to maintain its position on the European gas market, is sticking to a dichotomous strategy. On the one hand, Moscow has taken an offensive approach: it continues its traditionally critical rhetoric with regard to the legal and institutional changes; by negating the legitimacy of the new rules, it has been making efforts to undermine them by employing legal and political measures; Russia has used such traditional economic means as investments in assets and pushing through the implementation of new gas pipeline construction projects. On the other hand, the evolution of the EU gas market has forced Russia to take steps to adapt to a certain extent: partial changes in the operation of the internal gas sector; promises to further curb Gazprom’s dominant position; the concessions made in trade negotiations with European partners; partial adjustments to the EU’s so called third energy package regulations. Hoping that the unfolding situation on the gas markets will contribute to slowing down the recent liberalisation tendencies in the EU and that EU member states won’t make progress in decreasing their dependence on Russian gas, Moscow is thus preparing itself for the ‘long game’ in gas with its European partners.