Resilience and critique

I would like to thank Philip Hammond and Julian Reid for their thoughtful reviews. For Reid, the ‘life’ focus of resilience thinking is just another liberal/ neoliberal governmentality, enabling the reproduction and extension of biopolitical rule, thus my book provides interesting insights, but is not necessarily essential for the making of such claims. For Hammond, the conceptual distinctions made in the book shed some useful insights into current discussions of how policy understandings are being transformed and the emergence of the new doxa of complexity and its relational ontology (drawing adherents from across the, now defunct, Left–Right ideological divide).

Resilience and the ‘everyday’: beyond the paradox of ‘liberal peace’

Over the last decade there has been a shift towards critical understandings of ‘liberal peace’ approaches to international intervention, which argue that local culture holds the key to the effectiveness of peace interventions. In this ‘bottom-up’ approach, peace, reconciliation, and a ‘culture of law’ then become secondary effects of sociocultural norms and values. However, these liberal peace critiques have remained trapped in the paradox of liberal peace: the inability to go beyond the binaries of liberal universalism and cultural relativism. This understanding will be contrasted with the rise of ‘resilience’ approaches to intervention – which build on this attention to the particular context of application but move beyond this paradox through philosophical pragmatism and the focus on concrete social practices. This article clarifies the nature of this shift through the focus on the shifting understanding of international intervention to address the failings of the ‘war on drugs’ in the Americas.

How the World Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Failure: Big Data, Resilience and Emergent Causality

In modernity, failure was the discourse of critique, today, it is increasingly the discourse of power: failure has changed its allegiances. Over the last two decades, failure has been enfolded into discourses of power, facilitating the development of new policy approaches. Foremost among governing approaches that seek to include and to govern through failure is that of resilience. This article seeks to reflect upon how the understanding of failure has become transformed in this process, particularly linking this transformation to the radical appreciation of contingency and of the limits to instrumental cause-and-effect approaches to rule. Whereas modernity was shaped by a contestation over failure as an epistemological boundary, under conditions of contingency and complexity there appears to be a new consensus on failure as an ontological necessity. This problematic ‘ontological turn’ is illustrated using examples of changing approaches to risks, especially anthropogenic understandings of environmental threats, formerly seen as ‘natural’.

Using Computational Significance and Resilience in System Software Stacks.:Keynote Talk

This talk explores how the runtime system and operating system can leverage metrics that express the significance and resilience of application components in order to reduce the energy footprint of parallel applications. We will explore in particular how software can tolerate and indeed exploit higher error rates in future processors and memory technologies that may operate outside their safe margins.

Towards a Resilience Metric Framework for Cyber-Physical Systems

Resilience is widely accepted as a desirable system property for cyber-physical systems. However, there are no metrics that can be used to measure the resilience of cyber-physical systems (CPS) while the multi-dimensional nature of performance in these systems is considered. In this work, we present first results towards a resilience metric framework. The key contributions of this framework are threefold: First, it allows to evaluate resilience with respect to different performance indicators that are of interest. Second, complexities that are relevant to the performance indicators of interest, can be intentionally abstracted. Third and final, it supports the identification of reasons for good or bad resilience to improve system design.

Total Synthesis of the Antitumor Macrolides, (+)-Brefeldin A and 4‑Epi-Brefeldin A from D‑Glucose: Use of the Padwa Anionic Allenylsulfone [3+2]-Cycloadditive Elimination To Construct Trans-Configured Chiral Cyclopentane Systems

A new synthesis of (+)-brefeldin A is reported via Padwa allenylsulfone [3+2]-cycloadditive elimination. Cycloadduct 13 was initially elaborated into iodide
27, which, following treatment with Zn, gave aldehyde 28 whose C(9) stereocenter was epimerized. Further elaboration into enoate 38 and Julia−Kocienski olefination with 5 subsequently afforded 39, which was deprotected at C(1) and O(15). Yamaguchi macrolactonization of the seco-acid thereafter afforded a macrocycle that underwent O-desilylation and inversion at C(4) to give (+)-brefeldin A following deprotection

Tropical limestone forest resilience and late Pleistocene foraging during MIS-2 in the Tràng An massif, Vietnam

In this paper we present a multi-proxy study of tropical limestone forest and its utilization by human groups during the major climatic and environmental upheavals of MIS-2 (29-11.7 kBP). Our data are drawn from new field research within the Tràng An World Heritage property on the edge of the Red River Delta, northern Vietnam. Key findings from this study include 1) that limestone forest formations were resilient to the large-scale landscape transformation of the Sunda continent at the end of the last glaciation; 2) that prehistoric human groups were probably present in this habitat through-out MIS-2; and 3) that the forested, insular, karst of Tràng An provided foragers with a stable resource-base in a wider changing landscape. These results have implications for our understanding of the prehistoric utilization of karst environments, and resonance for their conservation in the face of climate and environmental change today.

Parental alcohol use and resilience in young people: A study of family, peer and school processes

Funded by HSC R&D Division, Public Health Agency Parental alcohol misuse or ‘hidden harm’ presents a very significant challenge to public health policy and practice in the UK and internationally. A parent’s alcohol problems can have a profound impact on their children. Children depend on their family to meet their physical, psychological and social needs, their economic security and well-being, all of which can be jeopardised by parents misusing substances (NACD, 2011). The prevalence of parental alcohol misuse is extremely difficult to estimate, due to the ‘hidden’ nature of the problem within the family unit. Approximately 40,000 children in Northern Ireland are estimated to live with parental alcohol misuse (DHSSPS, 2008). In the UK, 30% of children (3.3 to 3.5 million) under 16 years, live with at least one binge drinking parent and 22% of children (2.6. million) with a hazardous drinker (Manning et al., 2009).  

Resilience and the cultural landscape : the case of the Lower Ninth Ward after Hurricane Katrina

Le but de cette recherche est d’évaluer l’importance du paysage culturel dans la résilience des communautés urbaines post-catastrophes. Ce travail se concentre sur le quartier du Lower Ninth Ward dans la ville de La Nouvelle-Orléans (États-Unis) après le passage de l’ouragan Katrina en 2005. Les catastrophes naturelles prennent une envergure et causent des dommages considérables lorsqu’elles touchent des villes. La reconstruction post -désastre est donc très dispendieuse pour les villes et les gouvernements, d’autant que certaines régions sont dévastées au point qu’elles doivent être reconstruites au complet. Cependant, le coût le plus lourd à assumer reste celui en vies humaines et si rebâtir les éléments concrets d’une ville est une tâche difficile à entreprendre, reconstruire une communauté est considérablement plus complexe. Dans le but de comprendre une telle démarche, cette recherche se concentre sur les éléments intangibles, comme l’attachement au lieu et les réseaux sociaux, dont une communauté a besoin pour se reconstituer de façon durable et résiliente. Le concept de résilience est très contesté dans la littérature et plusieurs chercheurs se sont essayés à le mesurer. Cette recherche adopte une perspective critique sur le concept et le revisite d’un point de vue holistique pour mettre en lumière sa complexité. Cette démarche permet de remettre en question l’importance de mesurer un concept finalement en perpétuelle redéfinition dans le temps et selon les échelles géographiques. De plus, en établissant une relation entre résilience et paysage culturel, il a été possible de mieux comprendre la complexité de la résilience. Touchant à plusieurs disciplines (architecture de paysage, urbanisme et sociologie), cette recherche utilise une méthodologie qui reflète son aspect multidisciplinaire : les méthodes mixtes. Ces dernières permettent la collecte de données quantitatives et qualitatives qui produisent une vue globale de la situation post-Katrina à travers le regroupement de recensions statistiques, d’observations de terrain et d’articles de journaux. Parallèlement, des entretiens ont été réalisés avec des résidents du quartier ainsi qu’avec des professionnels pour mieux comprendre les différents points de vue. Cette méthodologie a permis de produire des résultats au niveau du cas d’étude autant qu’au niveau théorique. La recherche valide l’importance de prendre en compte le paysage culturel dans les situations post-catastrophes, (en particulier) dans la mesure où il s’agit d’un élément souvent négligé par les urbanistes et les acteurs locaux. En effet, les éléments constitutifs du paysage culturel tels que l’attachement au lieu et les réseaux sociaux, participent d’un sentiment d'appartenance (« home ») et d’une volonté, pour les résidents, de reconstruire leurs habitations, leur communauté ainsi que leur quartier. Toutefois, il faut reconnaître que ces éléments ne suffisent pas à retrouver ce qu’ils ont perdu. Ainsi, l’étude du paysage culturel permet non seulement de mieux comprendre la complexité de la résilience, mais démontre également que cette dernière est une construction sociale.

Estudo Preliminar de Adaptação e Validação da Escala de Avaliação do Eu Resiliente: resiliência, autodano e ideação suicida em adolescentes

Introdução: Em Portugal, são escassos os instrumentos validados para a população adolescente, que avaliem o importante construto da resiliência. Assim, o principal objetivo deste estudo consistiu na adaptação e validação preliminar da Escala de Avaliação do EU Resiliente (EAER) para adolescentes portugueses. Como segundo objetivo pretendemos, ainda, explorar as associações, na mesma amostra, entre a resiliência, o autodano e a ideação suicida na adolescência. Método: A amostra foi constituída por 226 adolescentes (sexo masculino, n = 139, 61,5%), entre os 12 e os 18 anos, que preencheram um protocolo composto por um questionário sociodemográfico, pela Escala de Avaliação do EU Resiliente (EAER), pelo Questionário de Impulso, Autodano e Ideação Suicida na Adolescência (QIAIS-A) e pela Escala de autoconceito. Resultados: Os resultados obtidos mostraram que a EAER possui boa fidelidade/consistência interna (α = 0,857) e boa estabilidade temporal (r = 0,720). Uma análise de componentes principais mostrou que a EAER apresenta três fatores: fator suporte externo, fator forças pessoais internas e fator estratégias de coping. Encontraram-se correlações negativas entre a resiliência e o autodano e ideação suicida e correlações positivas entre a resiliência e o autoconceito, confirmando-se a validade divergente e convergente da EAER. Verificaram-se níveis elevados de resiliência nos adolescentes da nossa amostra (M = 58,69; DP = 6,67). Na amostra total, 61,5% (n = 139) apresentou ideação suicida e 26,5% (n = 60) apresentou comportamentos de autodano. Conclusão: No seu conjunto, a EAER possui boas características psicométricas, pelo que pode ser considerada uma escala válida e útil e que pode ser usada com segurança na avaliação da resiliência em adolescentes portugueses. Com este estudo alargámos o leque de instrumentos válidos para a medição da resiliência em adolescentes e contribuímos para o avanço da investigação na área da adolescência em Portugal. / Introduction: In Portugal, there are few validated instruments to the adolescent population, to assess the important construct of resilience. Thus, the main objective of this study was the preliminary adaptation and validation of the Escala de Avaliação do EU Resiliente (EAER) to Portuguese adolescents. As a second objective, there is an intention to also explore the associations, on the same sample, between resilience, self-harm and suicidal ideation in adolescence. Method: The sample consisted of 226 adolescents (male, n = 139, 61.5%), between 12 and 18 years, who filled in a protocol consisting of a sociodemographic questionnaire, by the Escala de Avaliação do EU Resiliente (EAER), by the Impulse, Self-harm and Suicide Ideation Questionnaire for Adolescents (ISSIQ-A) and by the Self-concept Scale. Results: The results showed that the EAER has good fidelity/internal consistency (α = 0.857) and good temporal stability (r = 0.720). A principal component analysis showed that EAER has three factors: external support factor, internal personal strengths factor and coping strategies factor. There were negative correlations between resilience and the self-harm and suicidal ideation and positive correlations between resilience and self-concept, confirming the divergent and convergent validity of EAER. There were high levels of resilience in the adolescents of the sample (M = 58.69, SD = 6.67). In the total sample, 61.5% (n = 139) had suicidal ideation and 26,5% (n = 60) had self-harm behaviors. Conclusion: As a whole, the EAER has good psychometric properties, therefore it can be considered a valid and useful range, and can be safely used in the evaluation of resilience in Portuguese adolescents. With this study we have extended the range of valid instruments for the measurement of resilience in adolescents and contributed to the advance of research in the adolescence area in Portugal.