Calcareous microfossil isotopes and Miocene datum events of ODP Holes 189-1170A and 189-1172A

Downcore oxygen and carbon stable isotope records of planktonic and benthic foraminifers and fine-fraction carbonate from the southern high latitudes provide critical paleohydrographic constraints on the evolution of the Southern Ocean climate. In particular, the potential effects of an intensified Antarctic Circumpolar Current on the thermal isolation and cooling of the southern high latitudes, production of cold deep waters, and, ultimately, accumulation of continental ice on Antarctica in the middle Miocene are matters of interest. Using sediment materials from Ocean Drilling Program Leg 189 Sites 1170 and 1172 off Tasmania, Ennyu and Arthur (2004, doi:10.1029/151GM13) established the surface- and deepwater stable isotope records in the Southern Ocean across the middle Miocene event of the east Antarctic ice sheet expansion and discussed the paleoclimate proxy records in terms of the thermal evolution of the southern high latitudes and its effect on deepwater circulation. This report provides data tables and other supporting information relevant to discussions presented in Ennyu and Arthur (2004, doi:10.1029/151GM13). Items included in this report are (1) the oxygen and carbon stable isotope data measured on the Miocene bulk fine-fraction (i.e., <63 µm, primarily polyspecific nannofossil assemblage) carbonate and planktonic and benthic foraminifers from Holes 1170A and 1172A and (2) the Miocene depth-age models for the two sites.

Stable oxygen and carbon isotope record of benthic foraminifera in Pliocene sediments of the Californian margin

New benthic foraminiferal stable isotopic records of northeast Pacific intermediate water (ODP Site 1014, 1177 m) and mid-depth water (ODP Site 1018, 2476 m) were compared to isotopic records of deep water in the tropical Pacific (ODP Site 849, 3851 m) for the reconstruction of vertical profiles of nutrient and physical properties from the Early Pliocene to the Early Pleistocene (approx. 5-1.4 Ma). Our data indicate that, for the entire interval, there was enhanced north Pacific intermediate water ventilation relative to today, and a similar to modern circulation pattern with northward flowing Pacific Bottom Water (PBW) beneath its southward flowing return flow. However, the core of maximally aged return flow resided as deep as ~2500 m (as compared to ~1500 m today), probably due to the strengthened intermediate water flow. Less apparent aging of deep water along its path before 2.7 Ma indicates that thermohaline overturning may have been more rapid in the warm period of the Early Pliocene. In addition, prior to 2.7 Ma, foraminiferal oxygen isotopic values at mid-depth sites are higher than at deep sites (a reversed vertical gradient relative to today) in both the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. We suggest that NADW was warmer and more saline than today and that it influenced mid-depth waters throughout the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. Enhanced Pliocene formation of warmer/saltier intermediate water in the north Pacific, and deep water in the north Atlantic, may have been a result of higher than modern high/mid-latitude sea surface temperatures, evaporation, and salinity.

Middle Miocene stable carbon and oxygen isotope record of ODP Holes 130-805B and 130-806B

Bulk carbon isotope records are an effective chemostratigraphic tool for the middle Miocene because of the large and systematic variation in first-order d13C signals. Bulk d13C measurements support the presence of a hiatus at 305 mbsf in Hole 805B (latest middle Miocene), provisionally located while on board ship using biostratigraphic and magnetostratigraphic events. Records at Holes 805B and 806B show the middle Miocene Monterey carbon isotope excursion although the record at Hole 806B is apparently more stratigraphically continuous. Detailed analysis of multispecies foraminiferal carbon isotope records during the middle Miocene ("Monterey excursion") segment at Hole 806B support the assertion that this carbon isotope excursion comprises mainly between-reservoir effects. The benthic d18O data increase after 15.3 Ma, which we suggest corresponds to the mid-Miocene cooling step/ice volume increase of other authors. Planktonic foraminiferal d18O evidence exists for steepening of the thermocline at 17.4 Ma. A second-order d13C excursion superimposed at 13.8 Ma on the first-order Monterey excursion is associated with a second-order negative d18O excursion.

Benthic foraminiferal Mg/Ca ratios

Core-top samples from different ocean basins have been analyzed to refine our current understanding of the sensitivity of benthic foraminiferal calcite magnesium/calcium (Mg/Ca) to bottom water temperatures (BWT). Benthic foraminifera collected from Hawaii, Little Bahama Bank, Sea of Okhotsk, Gulf of California, NE Atlantic, Ceara Rise, Sierra Leone Rise, the Ontong Java Plateau, and the Southern Ocean covering a temperature range of 0.8 to 18°C were used to revise the Cibicidoides Mg/Ca-temperature calibration. The Mg/Ca-BWT relationship of three common Cibicidoides species is described by an exponential equation: Mg/Ca = 0.867 ± 0.049 exp (0.109 ± 0.007 * BWT) (stated errors are 95% CI). The temperature sensitivity is very similar to a previously published calibration. However, the revised calibration has a significantly different preexponential constant, resulting in different predicted absolute temperatures. We attribute this difference in the preexponential constant to an analytical issue of accuracy. Some genera, notably Uvigerina, show apparently lower temperature sensitivity than others, suggesting that the use of constant offsets to account for vital effects in Mg/Ca may not be appropriate. Downcore Mg/Ca reproducibility, as determined on replicate foraminiferal samples, is typically better than 0.1 mmol/mol (2 S.E.). Thus, considering the errors associated with the Cibicidoides calibration and the downcore reproducibility, BWT may be estimated to within ±1°C. Application of the revised core-top Mg/Ca-BWT data to Cenozoic foraminiferal Mg/Ca suggests that seawater Mg/Ca was not more than 35% lower than today in the ice-free ocean at 50 Ma.

Stable Oxygen and carbon isotope record of benthic foraminifera of ODP Leg 121 holes

Oxygen and carbon isotopic records have been developed for the Cenozoic carbonate oozes of Sites 752, 754, 756, and 757 based on the analysis of monospecific benthic foraminifers. The intent of this report is to provide a basic isotopic stratigraphy for use in other paleoceanographic studies. The oxygen isotope record displays the enrichments associated with cooling or ice volume buildup at the Eocene/Oligocene boundary, in the middle Miocene, and in the upper Pliocene. The carbon isotopic record contains the Chron 16 enrichment in the lower Miocene and the Chron 6 depletion in the uppermost Miocene.

Sand fraction, foraminifer isotopic composition and foraminifer element ratios of ODP Site 198-1209 sediments, Shatsky Rise

Stable oxygen and carbon isotope measurements (d18O and d13C) of planktonic and benthic foraminifers were conducted to assess the temperature history and circulation patterns over Shatsky Rise during the Paleocene and Eocene. A record of Mg/Ca for benthic foraminifers was also constructed in order to better determine the relative influence of temperature, salinity, and/or ice volume upon the benthic d18O record. Isotopic analyses were carried out on several planktonic taxa (Acarinina, Morozovella, Globigerinatheka, Praemurica, and Subbotina) as well as several benthic taxa (Nuttalides, Oridorsalis, Cibicidoides, Gavelinella, and Lenticulina). Elemental analyses were restricted to three benthic taxa: Nuttalides, Oridorsalis, and Gavelinella. All specimens were derived from the composite sediment section recovered from Ocean Drilling Program Site 1209 on the Southern High of Shatsky Rise.

Stable isotope ratios of foraminifera from various DSDP/ODP sites

The equator to high southern latitude sea surface and vertical temperature gradients are reconstructed from oxygen isotope values of planktonic and benthic foraminifers for the following five time intervals: late Paleocene, early Eocene, early middle Eocene, late Eocene, and early Oligocene. Paleotemperatures are calculated using standard oxygen isotope/temperature equations with adjustments to account for (1) variations in sea water delta18O related to changes in global ice volume over time and (2) latitudinal gradients in surface water delta18O. These reconstructions indicate that sea-surface temperatures (SST) of the Southern Oceans in the early Eocene were as high as 15°C, whereas temperatures during the late Paleocene and early middle Eocene reached maximum levels of 10°-12°C. By the late Eocene and early Oligocene high latitude SST had declined to 6 and 4°C, respectively. For most of the early Paleogene, low latitude sub-tropical temperatures remained constant and well within the range of Holocene temperatures (24°-25°C) but by the late Eocene and early Oligocene declined to values in the range of 18° to 22°C. The late Paleogene apparent decline in tropical temperatures, however, might be artificial because of dissolution of near-surface foraminifera tests which biased sediment assemblages toward deeper-dwelling foraminifera. Moreover, according to recent plate reconstructions, it appears that the majority of sites upon which the late Eocene and early Oligocene tropical temperatures were previously established were located either in or near regions likely to have been influenced by upwelling. Global deepwater temperature on average paralleled southern ocean SST for most of the Paleogene. We speculate based on the overall timing and character of marine sea surface temperature variation during the Paleogene that some combination of both higher levels of greenhouse gases and increased heat transport was responsible for the exceptional high-latitude warmth of the early Eocene.

Stable and strontium isotope ratios and age determination of ODP Site 130-803

Stratigraphic information from strontium, oxygen, and carbon isotopic ratios has been integrated with diatom and planktonic foraminifer datums to refine the Oligocene to early Miocene chemostratigraphy of Site 803. The Sr isotope results are based on analyses of mixed species of planktonic foraminifer and bulk carbonate samples. 87Sr/86Sr ratios of bulk carbonate samples are, in most cases, less radiogenic than contemporaneous seawater. Estimated sediment ages based on planktonic foraminifer 87Sr/86Sr ratios, using the Sr-isotope-age relation determined by Hess and others in 1989, are in moderately good agreement with the biostratigraphic ages. Chronological resolution is significantly enhanced with the correlation of oxygen and carbon isotope records to those of the standard Oligocene section tied to the Geomagnetic Polarity Time Scale at Site 522. Ages revised by this method and other published ages of planktonic foraminifer datums are used to revise the Oligocene stratigraphy of Site 77 to correlate the stable isotope records of Sites 77 and 803. Comparison of the Cibicidoides stable isotope records of Sites 77 and 574 with paleodepths below 2500 m in the central equatorial Pacific, and Site 803 at about 2000-m paleodepth in the Ontong Java Plateau reveals inversions in the vertical d18O gradient at several times during the Oligocene and in the early Miocene. The shallower water site had significantly-higher d18O values than the deeper water sites after the earliest Oligocene 18O enrichment and before 34.5 Ma, in the late Oligocene from 27.5 to at least 25 Ma, and in the early Miocene from 22.5 to 20.5 Ma. It is not possible to ascertain if the d18O inversion persisted during the Oligocene/Miocene transition because the deeper sites have hiatuses spanning this interval. We interpret this pattern to reflect that waters at about 2000 m depth were cold and may have formed from mixing with colder waters originating in northern or southern high-latitude regions. The deeper water appear to have been warmer and may have been a mixture with warm saline waters from mid- or low-latitude regions. No apparent vertical d13C gradient is present during the Oligocene, suggesting that the age difference of these water masses was small.

Stable isotope record of foraminifera from sediment core EW9209-1JPC

Stable isotopic measurements of G. sacculifer and C. wuellerstorfi in a core from the western equatorial Atlantic imply that there are parallel, suborbital oscillations in surface water hydrography and deep water circulation occurring during oxygen isotope stages 2 and 3. Low values of G. sacculifer delta18O accompany high values of C. wuellerstorfi delta13C, linking warmer sea surface temperatures (SSTs) in the tropics with increased production of lower North Atlantic Deep Water (NADW). The amplitude of the delta18O oscillations is 0.6 per mil (or 2°-3°C), which is superimposed on a glacial/interglacial amplitude of about 2.1per mil. Using the G. sacculifer delta18O data, we calculate that surface waters were colder during stage 2 than calculated by CLIMAP [1976, 1981]. The longer-period (>2 kyr) oscillations in air temperature recorded in the Greenland and Antarctic ice cores appear to correlate with oscillations in sea surface temperature in the equatorial Atlantic. The magnitude of these oscillations in tropical SST is too large to have resulted from changes in meridional heat transport caused by the global conveyor alone. The apparent synchroneity of equatorial SST and polar air temperature changes, as well as the amplitude of the SST changes at the equator, are consistent with the climate effects expected from changes in the atmosphere's greenhouse gas content (H2Ovapor, CO2, and CH4).

Age model and stable isotope record of DSDP holes 48-401 and 86-577

Early Paleogene warm climates may have been linked to different modes and sources of deepwater formation. Warm polar temperatures of the Paleocene and Eocene may have resulted from either increased atmospheric trace gases or increased heat transport through deep and intermediate waters. The possibility of increasing ocean heat transport through the production of warm saline deep waters (WSDW) in the Tethyan region has generated considerable interest. In addition, General Circulation Model results indicate that deepwater source regions may be highly sensitive to changing basin configurations. To decipher deepwater changes, we examined detailed benthic foraminiferal faunal and isotopic records of the late Paleocene through the early Eocene (~60 to 50 Ma) from two critical regions: the North Atlantic (Bay of Biscay Site 401) and the Pacific (Shatsky Rise Site 577). These records are compared with published data from the Southern Ocean (Maud Rise Site 690, Islas Orcadas Rise Site 702). During the late Paleocene, similar benthic foraminiferal delta18O values were recorded at all four sites. This indicates uniform deepwater temperatures, consistent with a single source of deep water. The highest delta13C values were recorded in the Southern Ocean and were 0.5 per mil more positive than those of the Pacific. We infer that the Southern Ocean was proximal to a source of nutrient-depleted deep water during the late Paleocene. Upper Paleocene Reflector Ab was cut on the western Bermuda Rise by cyclonically circulating bottom water, also suggesting a vigorous source of bottom water in the Southern Ocean. A dramatic negative excursion in both carbon and oxygen isotopes occurred in the latest Paleocene in the Southern Ocean. This is a short-term (<100 kyr), globally synchronous event which also is apparent in both the Atlantic and Pacific records as a carbon isotopic excursion of approximately 1 per mil. Faunal analyses from the North Atlantic and Pacific sites indicate that the largest benthic foraminiferal faunal turnover of the Cenozoic was synchronous with the isotopic excursion, lending support to the hypothesis that the extinctions were caused by a change in deepwater circulation. We speculate that the Southern Ocean deepwater source was reduced or eliminated at the time of the excursion. During the early Eocene, Southern Ocean delta13C values remained enriched relative to the North Atlantic and Pacific. However, the Southern Ocean was also enriched in delta18O relative to these basins. We interpret that these patterns indicate that although the Southern Ocean was proximal to a source of cool, nutrient-depleted water, the intermediate to upper deep water sites of the North Atlantic and Pacific were ventilated by a different source that probably originated in low latitudes, i.e., WSDW.

Stable isotope ratios of benthic foraminifera in mid-Pleitsocene sediments of ODP Site 108-664 in the equatorial Atlantic

Five delta13C records from the deep ocean, extending back to 1.3 Ma, were examined in order to constrain changes in mean ocean carbon isotope composition and thermohaline circulation over the 41- to 100-ka climate transition. These data show that significant perturbations in mean ocean carbon chemistry were associated with the mid-Pleistocene climate transition. Notable features of the last 1.3 Myr are (1) a pronounced ~0.3? decrease in mean ocean delta13C between 0.9 and 1.0 Myr, followed by a return to pre-1.0 Ma values by 400 ka B.P., which we propose was due to the onetime addition of isotopically depleted terrestrial carbon to the ocean, possibly associated with an increase in global aridity (and decrease in the size of the biosphere) across the 41- to 100-ka transition; (2) no change in the Atlantic-Pacific (A-P) delta13C gradient over the last 1.3 Myr, suggesting no change in mean ocean nutrient content accompanied the addition of light carbon; and (3) stronger vertical nutrient fractionation in the North Atlantic in the middle Pleistocene between sites 607 and 552, suggesting weaker North Atlantic Deep Water formation at this time relative to the early and late Pleistocene. We also find evidence for a more pronounced deep recirculation gyre in the western North Atlantic basin in the early Brunhes, as evidenced by "aging" of deep northern basin water (site 607) relative to deep water in the equatorial Atlantic (site 664).

Stable carbon and oxygen isotope ratios of Miocene to Recent foraminifera from the Rio Grande Rise, South Atlantic

Miocene to Recent species of planktic foraminifera in the Globorotalia (Globoconella) lineage evolved entirely within the thermocline. All species are most abundant within subtropical-temperate watermasses throughout their history. The near stasis in distribution within the thermocline and the subtropical convergence suggests the major morphological changes in Globorotalia (Globoconella) may have occurred through habitat subdivision rather than by vicariant shifts into new watermasses. At the Rio Grande Rise, in the South Atlantic, modern G. inflata is 0.66-0.84? more positive for delta18O than the most enriched coexisting Globigerinoides sacculifer and probably grows in the mid thermocline deeper than 325 m. All extinct globoconellid species have mean delta18O ratios 0.5-0.8? more positive than Globigerinoides trilobus and G. sacculifer and probably lived within the thermocline as well. Major events in skeletal evolution are poorly correlated with changes in delta18O in this group. These include evolutionary transitions to compressed, smooth-walled tests and acquisition of keels. In addition, morphological reversals from the umbilically-inflated G. conomiozea to biconvex G. pliozea and to unkeeled G. puncticulata occur in the absence of changes in delta18O signature. Instead, the ranges of delta18O between different species almost completely overlap once corrected for temporal changes in delta18O of sea water. Foraminifera morphologies have been widely considered to evolve in response to changes in watermasses or depth habitats. However, the variety of skeletal shapes in the globoconellid lineage apparently are not adaptations to a progressive radiation from the surface mixed layer into deeper waters.

Late Miocene carbon isotope and paleoproductivity record

We examine whether or not a relationship exists between the late Miocene carbon isotope shift (~7.6-6.6 Ma) and marine productivity at four sites from the Indian and Pacific Oceans (Ocean Drilling Program Sites 721, 1146, 1172, and 846). We use a multiproxy approach based on benthic foraminiferal accumulation rates, elemental ratios, and dissolution indices, and we compare these data to benthic foraminiferal d13C values measured on the same samples. Although some of these sites have been targeted previously in studies of either the late Miocene/early Pliocene "biogenic bloom" (Sites 721 and 846) or the late Miocene carbon isotope shift (Site 1172), our records are the first to establish paired proxy records of carbon isotopes and paleoproductivity allowing a direct assessment of a potential link. Our results indicate that at all sites, productivity increased sometime during the d13C shift; at three sites (721, 1146, and 846), productivity increased at the beginning of the shift. The correlation coefficients derived from linear regression between micropaleontologically derived productivity and foraminiferal d13C values are relatively high during the time interval containing the late Miocene d13C shift (and statistically significant at three of the sites). Carbon flux and isotope mass balance considerations illustrate that transfer of organic matter between the terrestrial and marine reservoirs together with enhanced oceanic upwelling best approximates observed changes in carbon isotope records and paleoproductivity. We note that long-term trend in the Site 846 paleoproductivity record can be correlated to the long-term trend in the Site 848 eolian flux reconstructions of Hovan (1995, doi:10.2973/odp.proc.sr.138.132.1995) hinting at a link between strengthened wind regime and productivity during the late Miocene.

Benthic foraminifera and ostracoda in ODP Hole 107-650A

Twenty-three sediment intervals from top of Site 650 down to 510 m below seafloor have been studied. Their thicknesses vary between 0.25 m and about 40 m. The studied deposits are turbidites or parts of them except one which is interpreted as an ash-fall layer. The composition of the turbidites signalizes sources from shallow water/coastal areas as well as from deep water levels. Repeated mobilization and displacement seems to have been common. Volcaniclastic material is the dominant component of the whole studied part of Site 650 sedimentary sequence. Ashfall deposits as well as normal open marine sediments are rare.