A High-Resolution 2D/3D Seismic Study of a Thrust Fault Zone in Lake Geneva, Switzerland

P130 A HIGH-RESOLUTION 2D/3D SEISMIC STUDY OF A THRUST FAULT ZONE IN LAKE GENEVA SWITZERLAND M. SCHEIDHAUER M. BERES D. DUPUY and F. MARILLIER Institute of Geophysics University of Lausanne 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland Summary A high-resolution three-dimensional (3D) seismic reflection survey has been conducted in Lake Geneva near the city of Lausanne Switzerland where the faulted molasse basement (Tertiary sandstones) is overlain by complex Quaternary sedimentary structures. Using a single 48-channel streamer an area of 1200 m x 600 m was surveyed in 10 days. With a 5-m shot spacing and a receiver spacing of 2.5 m in the inline direction and 7.5 m in the crossline direction, a 12-fold data coverage was achieved. A maximum penetration depth of ~150 m was achieved with a 15 cu. in. water gun operated at 140 bars. The multi-channel data allow the determination of an accurate velocity field for 3D processing, and they show particularly clean images of the fault zone and the overlying sediments in horizontal and vertical sections. In order to compare different sources, inline 55 was repeated with a 30/30 and a 15/15 cu. in. double-chamber air gun (Mini GI) operated at 100 and 80 bars, respectively. A maximum penetration depth of ~450 m was achieved with this source.

Contribution to the geology of Southern Turkey: new insights from the Mersin mélanges and from the Lycian and Antalya nappes

Abstract The study of fossil Tethyan continental margins implies the consideration of the oceanic domains to which they were connected. The advent of plate tectonics confirmed the importance of the detection of accretion-related mélanges. Ophiolitic mélanges are derived from both an upper ophiolitic obducting plate and a lower oceanic plate. Besides ophiolitic elements, the mélanges may incorporate parts of a magmatic arc and dismembered fragments of a passive continental margin. As the lower plate usually totally disappears during the obduction process, it can only be reconstructed from its elements found in the mélanges. Because of their key location at active margin boundaries, preserved accretion-related mélanges provide strong constraints on the geological evolution of former oceanic domains and their adjacent margins. The identification of Palaeotethyan remnants as accretionary series or reworked during the Late Triassic Eo-Cimmerian event, as well as the recognition of HugluPindos marginal sequences in southern Turkey and in the external Hellenides represent the main achievements of this work, making possible to establish new palaeogeographical correlations. The Mersin mélanges (Turkey), together with the Antalya and Mamonia (Cyprus) domains, are characterized by a series of exotic units found now south of the main Taurus range and compose the South-Taurides Exotic Units. The Mersin mélanges are subdivided in a Triassic and a Late Cretaceous unit. These units consist of the remnants of three major Tethyan oceans, the Palaeotethys, the Neotethys and the Huglu-Pindos. The definition and inventory of the Upper Antalya Nappes (Turkey) are still a matter of controversies and often conflicting interpretations. The recognition of Campanian radiolarians on top of the Kerner Gorge unit directly overlain by the Ordovician Seydi§ehir Fm. of the Tahtah Dag Nappe outlines a tectonic contact and demonstrates that the Upper Antalya Nappes system is composed of three different nappes, the Kerner Gorge, Bakirli and the Tahtah Dag nappes. Additionally, a limestone block in a doubtful tectonic position at the base of the Upper Antalya Nappes yielded for the first time two middle Viséan associations of foraminifers and problematic algae. The Tavas Nappe in the Lycian Nappes (Turkey) is classically divided into the Karadag, Teke Dere, Köycegiz and Haticeana units. As for the Mersin mélanges, the Tavas Nappe is highly composite and includes dismembered units belonging to the Palaeotethyan, Neotethyan and HugluPindos realms. The Karadag unit consists of a Gondwana-type platform succession ranging from the Late Devonian to the Late Triassic. It belongs to the Cimmerian Taurus terrane and was part of the northern passive margin of the Neotethys. The Teke Dere unit is composed of different parts of the Palaeotethyan succession including Late Carboniferous OIB-type basalts, Carboniferous MORB-type basalts, an Early Carboniferous siliciclastic series and a Middle Permian arc sequence. The microfauna and microflora identified in different horizons within the Teke Dere unit share strong biogeographical affinities with the northern Palaeotethyan borders. Kubergandian limestones in primary contact above the Early Carboniferous siliciclastics yielded a rich and diverse microfauna and microflora also identified in reworked cobbles within the Late Triassic Gevne Fm. of the Aladag unit (Turkey). The sedimentological evolution of the Köycegiz and Haticeana series is in many points similar to classical Pindos sequences. These series originated in the Huglu-Pindos Ocean along the northern passive margin of the Anatolian (Turkish transect) and Sitia-Pindos (Greek transect) terranes. Conglomerates at the base of the Lentas Unit in southern Crete (Greece) yielded a microfauna and microflora presenting also strong affinities with the northern borders of the Palaeotethys. This type of reworked sediments at the base of Pindos-like series would suggest a derivation from the Palaeotethyan active margin. -Résumé (French abstract) L'étude des marges continentales fossiles de l'espace téthysien implique d'étudier les domaines océaniques qui y étaient rattachés. Les progrès de la tectonique des plaques ont confirmé l'importance de la reconnaissance des mélanges d'accrétion. Les mélanges ophiolitiques dérivent d'une plaque supérieure ophiolitique qui obducte, et d'une plaque inférieure océanique. En plus d'éléments ophiolitiques, les mélanges peuvent aussi incorporer des parties d'un arc magmatique, ou des fragments d'une marge continentale passive. Comme la plaque inférieure disparaît généralement complètement durant le processus d'obduction, elle ne peut être reconstruite qu'au travers de ses éléments trouvés dans les mélanges. A cause de leur situation aux limites de marges actives, les mélanges d'accrétion bien préservés permettent de contraindre l'évolution géologique d'anciens océans et de leurs marges. L'identification de vestiges de la Paléotéthys en série d'accrétion ou remaniés lors de l'orogenèse éo-cimmérienne au Trias supérieur, ainsi que l'observation de séquences marginales de Huglu-Pinde en Turquie du sud et dans les Hellénides externes représentent les principaux résultats de ce travail, permettant d'établir de nouvelles corrélations paléogéographiques. Les mélanges de Mersin (Turquie), avec les domaines d'Antalya et de Mamonia (Chypre), sont caractérisés par des unités exotiques se trouvant au sud de la chaîne taurique, et forment les Unités Exotiques Sud-Tauriques. Les mélanges de Mersin sont subdivisés en une unité triasique, et une autre du Crétacé supérieur. Ces unités comprennent les reliques de trois principaux océans téthysiens, la Paléotéthys, la Néotéthys et Huglu-Pinde. L'inventaire et la définition des nappes supérieures d'Antalya (Turquie) sont encore matière à controverse et donne lieu à des interprétations conflictuelles. La découverte de radiolaires campaniens au sommet de l'unité de la Gorge de Kemer, directement recouverts par la formation ordovicienne de Seydisehir de la nappe du Tahtali Dag met en évidence un contact tectonique et démontre que les nappes supérieures sont composées de trois différentes nappes, celle de la Gorge de Kemer, celle du Bakirli et celle Tahtali Dag. De plus, un bloc de calcaire dont la position tectonique demeure incertaine à la base des nappes supérieures a fourni pour la première fois deux associations viséennes de foraminifères et d'algues problématiques. La nappe de Tavas dans les nappes lyciennes (Turquie) est séparée en unités du Karadag, du Teke Dere, de Köycegiz et d'Haticeana. Comme pour les mélanges de Mersin, la nappe de Tavas est composite et inclut des unités appartenant à la Paléotéthys, à la Néotéthys et à Huglu-Pinde. L'unité du Karadag est une plateforme carbonatée de type Gondwana se développant du Dévonien supérieur au Trias supérieur. Elle appartient au domaine cimmérien du Taurus et formait la marge nord de la Néotéthys. L'unité du Teke Dere est composée de différentes écailles paléotéthysiennes et inclut des basaltes d'île océanique du Carbonifère supérieur, des basaltes de ride océanique du Carbonifère, une série siliciclastique du Carbonifère supérieur et un arc du Permien moyen. Les microfaunes et -flores trouvées à différents niveaux de la série du Teke Dere partagent de fortes affinités paléogéographiques avec les marges nord de la Paléotéthys. Des calcaires du Kubergandien en contact primaire au-dessus de la série siliciclastique a donné de riches microfaunes et -flores, également identifiées dans des galets remaniés dans la formation de Gevne du Trias supérieur de l'Aladag. L'évolution sédimentologique des séries de Köycegiz et d'Haticeana sont très similaires aux séries classiques du Pinde. Ces séquences prennent leur racine dans l'océan de Huglu-Pinde, le long de la marge passive nord anatolienne (profil turc) et de la marge de Sitia-Pinde (profil grec). Des conglomérats à la base de l'unité de Lentas au sud de la Crète (Grèce) ont donné des microfaunes et flores partageant également de fortes similitudes avec les bordures nord de la Paléotéthys. Le type de sédiments remaniés à la base d'unités de type Pinde suggère une dérivation depuis la marge active de la Paléotéthys. -Résumé grand public (non-specialized abstract) Au début du 20ème siècle, Alfred Wegener bouleverse les croyances géologiques de l'époque et publie plusieurs articles sur la dérive ou la translation des continents. En utilisant des arguments géographiques (similarités des lignes de côte), paléontologiques (faunes et flores similaires) et climatiques (dépôts tropicaux et glaciaires), Wegener explique qu'il y a plusieurs millions d'années, les terres émergées actuelles ne devaient former qu'un seul et grand continent. La fin du 20ème siècle verra l'avènement de la théorie de la tectonique des plaques suite à la reconnaissance du cycle de Wilson, des rides médio-océaniques, des anomalies magnétiques dans les océans et des sutures océaniques qui représentent les reliques d'océans disparus. Le Cycle de Wilson se caractérise par une suite d'évènements géologiques majeurs pouvant se résumer de la manière suivante : (1) séparation d'un craton continental en deux parties, créant une limite de plaque divergente. C'est ce que l'on appelle un rift; (2) développement et croissance d'un océan entre ces deux blocs. Des roches magmatiques remontent à la surface de la terre et forment une chaîne de montagne sous-marine que l'on appelle ride médio-océanique ou dorsale. L'océan continue de se développer, et des sédiments se déposent à sa surface formant la suite ophiolitique ou trinité de Steinmann; (3) après une phase d'expansion plus ou moins longue, les conditions imposées aux limites des plaques à la surface de la terre changent, et l'océan se met à se refermer par disparition progressive (subduction) de sa croûte océanique sous une croûte continentale par exemple. Ceci crée une nouvelle limite de plaque, convergente cette fois; (4) la subduction de la plaque océanique sous la plaque continentale provoque une remontée de magma formant des chaînes volcaniques à la surface de la Terre ; (5) une fois que la plaque océanique a complètement disparu, les deux blocs préalablement séparés par l'océan font collision, formant ainsi une chaîne de montagne. Les chaînes de montagnes sont de manière générale formées par un empilement plus ou moins complexe de nappes. C'est au coeur de certaines de ces nappes que se trouvent les vestiges de l'océan disparu. Un des objectifs de ce travail était la recherche de ces vestiges dans le domaine téthysien de la Méditerranée orientale. Pour ce faire, nous avons parcourus une grande partie du sud de la Turquie, nous sommes allés à Chypre, dans le Sultanat d'Oman, en Iran, en Crète, et nous avons visités quelques îles grecques du Dodécanèse. La région de la Méditerranée orientale est une zone qui a été tectoniquement très active, et qui continue de l'être de nos jours par des phénomènes de subduction (ex. les volcans de Santorin), et par des mouvements coulissants entre des plaques continentales (ex. la faille nord-anatolienne) qui donnent régulièrement lieu à des tremblements de terre. Pour le géologue, la complexité de ces zones d'étude réside dans le fait que les chaînes de montagne actuelles ne contiennent en général pas seulement les restes d'un océan, mais bien de plusieurs bassins océaniques qui se sont succédés dans l'espace et dans le temps. Les nappes qui se trouvent au sud de la Turquie et dans le Dodécanèse forment un important jalon dans la chaîne alpine qui s'étend depuis les Alpes jusque dans l'Himalaya. L'idée d'un continuum au coeur de ce système se basait principalement sur l'âge des océans et sur la reconnaissance de similarités dans l'évolution des séries sédimentaires. La localisation des vestiges de la Paléotéthys ainsi que l'identification des séries sédimentaires ayant appartenu à l'océan de HugluPinde repris sous forme de nappes en Turquie et en Grèce sont cruciales pour permettre de bonnes corrélations locales et régionales. La reconnaissance, la compréhension et l'interprétation de ces séries sédimentaires permettront d'élaborer un modèle d'évolution géodynamique régional, s'appuyant sur des faits de terrains indiscutables, et prenant en compte les contraintes globales que ce genre d'exercice implique.

Old ferricrete landscape dismantling in Central Africa rain forest zone: formation of the present downslope iron accumulations.

Present downslope iron accumulations were investigated in the rainforest zone in southern Cameroon. Six clay and Fe-hydroxide dominated patterns have been identified and occur on the lower part of hill slopes. They can be subdivided in three different sequences, related to gentle, moderate or steep slopes. They are discontinuous with respect to the dismantling zone of the old ferricrete cap formed at Cretaceous period. They show a gradual development from a soft Fe-crust (carapace) to a vesicular facies that will, with time, cover the whole landscape again.

Thrusting, extension, and doming during the polyphase tectonometamorphic evolution of the High Himalayan Crystalline Zone in NW India

In the NW Himalaya of India, high-grade metamorphic rocks of the High Himalayan Crystalline Zone (HHCZ) are exposed as a 50 km large dome along the Miyar and Gianbul valleys. This Gianbul dome is cored by migmatitic paragneiss formed at peak conditions around 750 degreesC and 8 kbar, and symmetrically surrounded by sillimanite, kyanite +/- staurolite, garnet, biotite, and chlorite Barrovian mineral zones. Thermobarometric and structural investigations reveal that the Gianbul dome results from a polyphase tectono-metamorphic evolution. The first phase corresponds to the NE-directed thrusting of the Shikar Beh nappe, that is responsible for the Barrovian prograde metamorphic field gradient in the southern limb of the dome. In the northern limb of the dome, the Barrovian prograde metamorphism is the consequence of a second tectonic phase, associated with the SW-directed thrusting of the Nyimaling-Tsarap nappe. Following these crustal thickening events, exhumation and doming of the HHCZ high-grade rocks were controlled by extension along the north-dipping Zanskar Shear Zone, in the frontal part of the Nyimaling-Tsarap nappe, as well as by coeval to late extension along the south-dipping Khanjar Shear Zone, in the southern limb of the Gianbul dome. Rapid syn-convergence extension along both of these detachments induced a nearly isothermal decompression, resulting in a high-temperature/low-pressure metamorphic overprint, as well as enhanced partial melting. Such a rapid exhumation within a compressional orogenic context appears unlikely to be controlled solely by granitic diapirism. Alternatively, large-scale doming in the Himalaya could reflect a sub-vertical ductile extrusion of partially melted rocks.

Application of K-feldspar-jadeite-quartz barometry to eclogite facies metagranites and metapelites in the Sesia Lanzo Zone (Western Alps, Italy)

The eclogite facies assemblage K-feldspar-jadeite-quartz in metagranites and metapelites from the Sesia-Lanzo Zone (Western Alps, Italy) records the equilibration pressure by dilution of the reaction jadeite + quartz = albite. The metapelites show partial transformation from a pre-Alpine assemblage of garnet (Alm(63)Prp(26)Grs(10))-K-feldspar-plagioclase-biotite +/- sillimanite to the Eo-Alpine high-pressure assemblage garnet (Alm(50)Prp(14)Grs(35))-jadeite (Jd(80-97)Di(0-4)Hd(0-8)Acm(0-7))=zoisite-phengite. Plagioclase is replaced by jadeite-zoisite-kyanite-K-feldspar-quartz and biotite is replaced by garnet-phengite or omphacite-kyanite-phengite. Equilibrium was attained only in local domains in the metapelites and therefore the K-feldspar-jadeite-quartz (KJQ) barometer was applied only to the plagioclase pseudomorphs and K-feldspar domains. The albite content of K-feldspar ranges from 4 to 11 mol% in less equilibrated assemblages from Val Savenca and from 4 to 7 mol% in the partially equilibrated samples from Monte Mucrone and the equilibrated samples from Montestrutto and Tavagnasco. Thermodynamic calculations on the stability of the assemblage K-feldspar-jadeite-quartz using available mixing data for K-feldspar and pyroxene indicate pressures of 15-21 kbar (+/- 1.6-1.9 kbar) at 550 +/- 50 degrees C. This barometer yields direct pressure estimates in high-pressure rocks where pressures are seldom otherwise fixed, although it is sensitive to analytical precision and the choice of thermodynamic mixing model for K-feldspar. Moreover, the KJQ barometer is independent of the ratio P-H2O/P-T. The inferred limiting a(H2O) for the assemblage jadeite-kyanite in the metapelites from Val Savenca is low and varies from 0.2 to 0.6.

Adaptation to marginal habitats

The ability to adapt to marginal habitats, in which survival and reproduction are initially poor, plays a crucial role in the evolution of ecological niches and species ranges. Adaptation to marginal habitats may be limited by genetic, developmental, and functional constraints, but also by consequences of demographic characteristics of marginal populations. Marginal populations are often sparse, fragmented, prone to local extinctions, or are demographic sinks subject to high immigration from high-quality core habitats. This makes them demographically and genetically dependent on core habitats and prone to gene flow counteracting local selection. Theoretical and empirical research in the past decade has advanced our understanding of conditions that favor adaptation to marginal habitats despite those limitations. This review is an attempt at synthesis of those developments and of the emerging conceptual framework.

Synorogenic extension: Quantitative constraints on the age and displacement of the Zanskar shear zone (northwest Himalaya)

subsequent extension-induced exhumation. Geochronological dating of various Structural, thermobarometric, and geochronological data place limits on the age and tectonic displacement along the Zanskar shear zone, a major north-dipping synorogenic extensional structure separating the high-grade metamorphic sequence of the High Himalayan Crystalline Sequence from the overlying low-grade sedimentary rocks of the Tethyan Himalaya, A complete Barrovian metamorphic succession, from kyanite to biotite zone mineral assemblages, occurs within the I-km-thick Zanskar shear zone. Thermobarometric data indicate a difference In equilibration depths of 12 +/- 3 km between the lower kyanite zone and the garnet zone, which is Interpreted as a minimum estimate for the finite vertical displacement accommodated by the Zanskar shear zone. For the present-day dip of the structure (20 degrees), a simple geometrical model shows that a net slip of 35 +/- 9 km is required to regroup these samples to the same structural level. Because the kyanite to garnet zone rocks represent only part of the Zanskar shear zone, and because its original dip may have been less than the present-day dip, these estimates fur the finite displacement represent minimum values. Field relations and petrographic data suggest that migmatization and associated leucogranite intrusion in the footwall of the Zanskar shear zone occurred as a continuous profess starting at the Barrovian metamorphic peak and lasting throughout the subsequent extension-induced exhumation. Geochronological dataing of various leucogranitic plutons and dikes in the Zanskar shear zone footwall indicates that the main ductile shearing along the structure ended by 19.8 Ma and that extension most likely initiated shortly before 22.2 Ma.

The central Sesia-Lanzo zone (Western Italian Alps) - New field observations and lithostratigraphic subdivisions

An extensive study of the central part of the Sesia Lanzo Zone has been undertaken to identify pre-Alpine protoliths and to reconstruct the lithologic and tectonic setting of this part of the Western Alps. Three main complexes have been defined: 1) the Polymetamorphic Basement Complex, corresponding to the lower unit of the Sesia Lanzo Zone after COMPAGNONI et al. (1977), is further subdivided into the three following units: a) an Internal Unit characterized by eo-Alpine high pressure (HP) assemblages (DAL PIAZ et al., 1972) (Eclogitic Micaschists); b) an Intermediate Unit where HP parageneses are partially re-equilibrated under greenschist conditions and c) an External Unit where the main foliation is defined by a greenschist paragenesis (Gneiss Minuti auct.). 2) the Monometamorphic Cover Complex, subdivided into the followings: a) the Bonze Unit, composed of sheared metagabbros, eclogitized metabasalts with MORB geochemical affinity and related metasediments (micaschists, quartzites and Mn-cherts) and b) the Scalaro Unit, containing predominantly metasediments of supposed Permo-Triassic age (yellow dolomitic marbles, calcschists and conglomeratic limestones, micaschists and quartzites with thin levels of basic rocks with within plate basalts [WPB] geochimical affinity). Multiple lithostratigraphic sequences for the Monometamorphic Cover Complex are proposed. The contact between the Bonze and Scalaro Units is defined by repetitions of dolomitic marbles and metabasalts; the ages of the metasediments have been assigned solely by analogy with other sediments of the Western Alps, due to the absence of fossils. The Monometamorphic Cover Complex can be considered as the autochthonous cover of the Sesia Lanzo Zone because of the primary contacts with the basement and because of the presence of preAlpine HT basement blocks in the cover sequences. 3) The pre-Alpine high temperature (HT) Basement Complex (or `'Seconda Zona Diorito-Kinzigitica''), comprises HT Hercynian rocks like kinzigites, amphibolites, granulites and calcite marbles; this Complex is always located between the Internal and the External Units and can be followed continuously for several kilometers south of the Gressoney Valley to the Orco Valley. A schematic evolution for the Sesia Lanzo Zone is proposed; based on available data together with new geochronological data, this study shows that the internal and external parts of the polymetamorphic basement of the Sesia Zone experienced different cooling histories .

Local ocular immunomodulation resulting from electrotransfer of plasmid encoding soluble TNF receptors in the ciliary muscle.

PURPOSE: Plasmid electrotransfer in the ciliary muscle allows the sustained release of therapeutic proteins within the eye. The aim of this study was to evaluate whether the ocular production of TNF-alpha soluble receptor, using this nonviral gene therapy method, could have a beneficial local effect in a model of experimental autoimmune uveoretinitis (EAU). METHODS: Injection of a plasmid encoding a TNF-alpha p55 receptor (30 microg) in the ciliary muscle, combined with electrotransfer (200 V/cm), was carried out in Lewis rat eyes 4 days before the induction of EAU by S-antigen. Control eyes received naked plasmid electrotransfer or simple injection of the therapeutic plasmid. The disease was evaluated clinically and histologically. Cytokines and chemokines were analyzed in the ocular media by multiplex assay performed 15 and 21 days after immunization. RESULTS: Ocular TNF-alpha blockade, resulting from the local secretion of soluble receptors, was associated with delayed and significantly less severe uveitis, together with a reduction of the retinal damages. Compared with the controls, treated eyes showed significantly lower levels of IL-1beta and MCP1, higher levels of IL-13 and IL-4, and reduced NOS-2 expression in infiltrating cells. Treatment did not influence TNF-alpha levels in inguinal lymph nodes. CONCLUSIONS: Taken together, these results indicate that local immunomodulation was achieved and that no systemic adverse effects of TNF-alpha blockade observed after systemic injection of TNF-alpha inhibitors should be expected.

Numerical modeling of the effect of variation of boundary conditions on vadose zone hydraulic properties

An accurate estimation of hydraulic fluxes in the vadose zone is essential for the prediction of water, nutrient and contaminant transport in natural systems. The objective of this study was to simulate the effect of variation of boundary conditions on the estimation of hydraulic properties (i.e. water content, effective unsaturated hydraulic conductivity and hydraulic flux) in a one-dimensional unsaturated flow model domain. Unsaturated one-dimensional vertical water flow was simulated in a pure phase clay loam profile and in clay loam interlayered with silt loam distributed according to the third iteration of the Cantor Bar fractal object Simulations were performed using the numerical model Hydrus 1D. The upper and lower pressure heads were varied around average values of -55 cm for the near-saturation range. This resulted in combinations for the upper and lower constant head boundary conditions, respectively, of -50 and -60 cm, -40 and -70 cm, -30 and -80 cm, -20 and -90 cm, and -10 and -100 cm. For the drier range the average head between the upper and lower boundary conditions was set to -550 cm, resulting in the combinations -500 and -600 cm, -400 and -700 cm, -300 and -800 cm, -200 and -900 cm, and -100 and -1,000 cm, for upper and lower boundary conditions, respectively. There was an increase in water contents, fluxes and hydraulic conductivities with the increase in head difference between boundary conditions. Variation in boundary conditions in the pure phase and interlayered one-dimensional profiles caused significant deviations in fluxes, water contents and hydraulic conductivities compared to the simplest case (a head difference between the upper and lower constant head boundaries of 10 cm in the wetter range and 100 cm in the drier range).

Clear Zone – A Synthesis of Practice and an Evaluation of the Benefi ts of Meeting the 10-ft Clear Zone Goal on Urban Streets, November 2008

In urban communities, there are often limited amounts of right-of-way available for establishing a large setback distance from the curb for fixed objects. Urban communities must constantly weigh the cost of purchasing additional right-of-way for clear zones against the risk of fixed object crashes. From 2004 to 2006, this type of crash on curbed roads represented 15% of all fatal crashes and 3% of all crashes in the state of Iowa. Many states have kept the current minimum AASHTO recommendations as their minimum clear zone standards; however, other states have decided that these recommendations are insufficient and have increased the required minimum clear zone distance to better suit the judgment of local designers. This report presents research on the effects of the clear zone on urban curbed streets. The research was conducted in two phases. The first phase involved a synthesis of practice that included a literature review and a survey of practices in jurisdictions that have developmental and historical patterns similar to those of Iowa. The second phase involved investigating the benefits of a 10 ft clear zone, which included examining urban corridors in Iowa that meet or do not meet the 10 ft clear zone goal. The results of this study indicate that a consistent fixed object offset results in a reduction in the number of fixed object crashes, a 5 ft clear zone is most effective when the goal is to minimize the number of fixed object c ashes, and a 3 ft clear zone is most effective when the goal is to minimize the cost of fixed object crashes.