Selection for in vivo regulators of bacterial virulence

We devised a noninvasive genetic selection strategy to identify positive regulators of bacterial virulence genes during actual infection of an intact animal host. This strategy combines random mutagenesis with a switch-like reporter of transcription that confers antibiotic resistance in the off state and sensitivity in the on state. Application of this technology to the human intestinal pathogen Vibrio cholerae identified several regulators of cholera toxin and a central virulence gene regulator that are operative during infection. These regulators function in chemotaxis, signaling pathways, transport across the cell envelope, biosynthesis, and adherence. We show that phenotypes that appear genetically independent in cell culture become interrelated in the host milieu.

Enhanced antitumor efficacy of a herpes simplex virus mutant isolated by genetic selection in cancer cells

Replication-competent, attenuated herpes simplex virus-1 (HSV-1) derivatives that contain engineered mutations into the viral γ34.5 virulence gene have been used as oncolytic agents. However, as attenuated mutants often grow poorly, they may not completely destroy some tumors and surviving cancer cells simply regrow. Thus, although HSV-1 γ34.5 mutants can reduce the growth of human tumor xenografts in mice and have passed phase I safety studies, their efficacy is limited because they replicate poorly in many human tumor cells. Previously, we selected for a γ34.5 deletion mutant variant that regained the ability to replicate efficiently in tumor cells. Although this virus contains an extragenic suppressor mutation that confers enhanced growth in tumor cells, it remains attenuated. Here, we demonstrate that the suppressor virus replicates to greater levels in prostate carcinoma cells and, importantly, is a more potent inhibitor of tumor growth in an animal model of human prostate cancer than the γ34.5 parent virus. Thus, genetic selection in cancer cells can be used as a tool to enhance the antitumor activity of a replication-competent virus. The increased therapeutic potency of this oncolytic virus may be useful in the treatment of a wide variety of cancers.

DNA sequence insertion and evolutionary variation in gene regulation.

Current evidence on the long-term evolutionary effect of insertion of sequence elements into gene regions is reviewed, restricted to cases where a sequence derived from a past insertion participates in the regulation of expression of a useful gene. Ten such examples in eukaryotes demonstrate that segments of repetitive DNA or mobile elements have been inserted in the past in gene regions, have been preserved, sometimes modified by selection, and now affect control of transcription of the adjacent gene. Included are only examples in which transcription control was modified by the insert. Several cases in which merely transcription initiation occurred in the insert were set aside. Two of the examples involved the long terminal repeats of mammalian endogenous retroviruses. Another two examples were control of transcription by repeated sequence inserts in sea urchin genomes. There are now six published examples in which Alu sequences were inserted long ago into human gene regions, were modified, and now are central in control/enhancement of transcription. The number of published examples of Alu sequences affecting gene control has grown threefold in the last year and is likely to continue growing. Taken together, all of these examples show that the insertion of sequence elements in the genome has been a significant source of regulatory variation in evolution.

Analysis of genetic instability during mammary tumor progression using a novel selection-based assay for in vivo mutations in a bacteriophage lambda transgene target.

Genetic instability is thought to be responsible for the numerous genotypic changes that occur during neoplastic transformation and metastatic progression. To explore the role of genetic instability at the level of point mutations during mammary tumor development and malignant progression, we combined transgenic mouse models of mutagenesis detection and oncogenesis. Bitransgenic mice were generated that carried both a bacteriophage lambda transgene to assay mutagenesis and a polyomavirus middle T oncogene, mammary gland-targeted expression of which led to metastatic mammary adenocarcinomas. We developed a novel assay for the detection of mutations in the lambda transgene that selects for phage containing forward mutations only in the lambda cII gene, using an hfl- bacterial host. In addition to the relative ease of direct selection, the sensitivity of this assay for both spontaneous and chemically induced mutations was comparable to the widely used mutational target gene, lambda lacI, making the cII assay an attractive alternative for mutant phage recovery for any lambda-based mouse mutagenesis assay system. The frequencies of lambda cII- mutants were not significantly different in normal mammary epithelium, primary mammary adenocarcinomas, and pulmonary metastases. The cII mutational spectra in these tissues consisted mostly of G/C-->A/T transitions, a large fraction of which occurred at CpG dinucleotides. These data suggest that, in this middle T oncogene model of mammary tumor progression, a significant increase in mutagenesis is not required for tumor development or for metastatic progression.

Protein-protein interaction: a genetic selection for compensating mutations at the barnase-barstar interface.

Barnase and barstar are trivial names of the extracellular RNase and its intracellular inhibitor produced by Bacillus amyloliquefaciens. Inhibition involves the formation of a very tight one-to-one complex of the two proteins. With the crystallographic solution of the structure of the barnase-barstar complex and the development of methods for measuring the free energy of binding, the pair can be used to study protein-protein recognition in detail. In this report, we describe the isolation of suppressor mutations in barstar that compensate for the loss in interaction energy caused by a mutation in barnase. Our suppressor search is based on in vivo selection for barstar variants that are able to protect host cells against the RNAse activity of those barnase mutants not properly inhibited by wild-type barstar. This approach utilizes a plasmid system in which barnase expression is tightly controlled to keep the mutant barnase gene silent. When expression of barnase is turned on, failure to form a complex between the mutant barnase and barstar has a lethal effect on host cells unless overcome by substitution of the wild-type barstar by a functional suppressor derivative. A set of barstar suppressors has been identified for barnase mutants with substitutions in two amino acid positions (residues 102 and 59), which are critically involved in both RNase activity and barstar binding. The mutations selected as suppressors could not have been predicted on the basis of the known protein structures. The single barstar mutation with the highest information content for inhibition of barnase (H102K) has the substitution Y30W. The reduction in binding caused by the R59E mutation in barnase can be partly reversed by changing Glu-76 of barstar, which forms a salt bridge with the Arg-59 in the wild-type complex, to arginine, thus completing an interchange of the two charges.

The estrogen receptor locus is associated with a major gene influencing litter size in pigs.

Identification of individual major genes affecting quantitative traits in livestock species has been limited to date. By using a candidate gene approach and a divergent breed cross involving the Chinese Meishan pig, we have shown that a specific allele of the estrogen receptor (ER) locus is associated with increased litter size. Female pigs from synthetic lines with a 50% Meishan background that were homozygous for this beneficial allele produced 2.3 more pigs in first parities and 1.5 more pigs averaged over all parities than females from the same synthetic lines and homozygous for the undesirable allele. This beneficial ER allele was also found in pigs with Large White breed ancestory. Analysis of females with Large White breed background showed an advantage for females homozygous for the beneficial allele as compared to females homozygous for the other allele of more than 1 total pig born. Analyses of growth performance test records detected no significant unfavorable associations of the beneficial allele with growth and developmental traits. Mapping of the ER gene demonstrated that the closest known genes or markers were 3 centimorgans from ER. To our knowledge, one of these, superoxide dismutase gene (SOD2), was mapped for the first time in the pig. Analysis of ER and these linked markers indicated that ER is the best predictor of litter size differences. Introgression of the beneficial allele into commercial pig breeding lines, in which the allele was not present, and marker-assisted selection for the beneficial allele in lines with Meishan and Large White background have begun.

Selection of transduced CD34+ progenitors and enzymatic correction of cells from Gaucher patients, with bicistronic vectors.

The gene transfer efficiency of human hematopoietic stem cells is still inadequate for efficient gene therapy of most disorders. To overcome this problem, a selectable retroviral vector system for gene therapy has been developed for gene therapy of Gaucher disease. We constructed a bicistronic retroviral vector containing the human glucocerebrosidase (GC) cDNA and the human small cell surface antigen CD24 (243 bp). Expression of both cDNAs was controlled by the long terminal repeat enhancer/promoter of the Molony murine leukemia virus. The CD24 selectable marker was placed downstream of the GC cDNA and its translation was enhanced by inclusion of the long 5' untranslated region of encephalomyocarditis virus internal ribosomal entry site. Virus-producing GP+envAM12 cells were created by multiple supernatant transductions to create vector producer cells. The vector LGEC has a high titer and can drive expression of GC and the cell surface antigen CD24 simultaneously in transduced NIH 3T3 cells and Gaucher skin fibroblasts. These transduced cells have been successfully separated from untransduced cells by fluorescence-activated cell sorting, based on cell surface expression of CD24. Transduced and sorted NIH 3T3 cells showed higher GC enzyme activity than the unsorted population, demonstrating coordinated expression of both genes. Fibroblasts from Gaucher patients were transduced and sorted for CD24 expression, and GC enzyme activity was measured. The transduced sorted Gaucher fibroblasts had a marked increase in enzyme activity (149%) compared with virgin Gaucher fibroblasts (17% of normal GC enzyme activity). Efficient transduction of CD34+ hematopoietic progenitors (20-40%) was accomplished and fluorescence-activated cell sorted CD24(+)-expressing progenitors generated colonies, all of which (100%) were vector positive. The sorted, CD24-expressing progenitors generated erythroid burst-forming units, colony-forming units (CFU)-granulocyte, CFU-macrophage, CFU-granulocyte/macrophage, and CFU-mix hematopoietic colonies, demonstrating their ability to differentiate into these myeloid lineages in vitro. The transduced, sorted progenitors raised the GC enzyme levels in their progeny cells manyfold compared with untransduced CD34+ progenitors. Collectively, this demonstrates the development of high titer, selectable bicistronic vectors that allow isolation of transduced hematopoietic progenitors and cells that have been metabolically corrected.

Pollen selection: a transgenic reconstruction approach.

A transgenic reconstruction experiment has been performed to determine the feasibility of male gametophytic selection to enhance transmission of genes to the next sporophytic generation. For tobacco pollen from a transgenic plant containing a single hygromycin-resistance (hygromycin phosphotransferase, hpt-) gene under control of the dc3 promoter, which is active in both sporophytic and gametophytic tissues, 3 days of in vitro maturation in hygromycin-containing medium was sufficient to result in a 50% reduction of germinating pollen, as expected for meiotic segregation of a single locus insert. Pollination of wild-type plants with the selected pollen yielded 100% transgenic offspring, as determined by the activity of the linked kanamycin-resistance gene--present within the same transferred T-DNA borders--under control of the nos promoter. This is direct proof that selection acting on male gametophytes can be a means to alter the frequency of genes in the progeny.

High-efficiency retroviral-mediated gene transfer into human and nonhuman primate peripheral blood lymphocytes.

Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) are primary targets for gene therapy of inherited and acquired disorders of the immune system. We describe the development of an optimized transduction system that provides for high-efficiency retrovirus-mediated gene transfer into primary PBLs. This optimized transduction protocol combines centrifugation of the lymphocytes (1000 x g) at the inception of transduction with phosphate depletion, low-temperature incubation (32 degrees C), and the use of the packaging cell line PG13. Gene marking studies of human and primate PBLs using these optimized transduction conditions demonstrated that the transduction efficiency exceeded 50% of the total lymphocyte population. The optimized transduction efficiency of PBLs with amphotropic retroviral vectors was in excess of 25%. The transduction procedure does not alter phenotype, viability, or expansion of the transduced cells. Our data indicate that this optimized transduction system leads to high-efficiency gene transfer into primary human lymphocytes, which obviates the requirement for selection of transduced cells prior to gene-therapy procedures. Thus, large quantities of healthy retrovirally transduced lymphocytes containing a broad immunological repertoire can be generated for use in clinical protocols. Our results represent a significant improvement in the methodology for the transduction of lymphocytes for gene therapy.

Preferential expansion and survival of B lymphocytes based on VH framework 1 and framework 3 expression: "positive" selection in appendix of normal and VH-mutant rabbits.

B cells with a rearranged heavy-chain variable region VHa allotype-encoding VH1 gene segment predominate throughout the life of normal rabbits and appear to be the source of the majority of serum immunoglobulins, which thus bear VHa allotypes. The functional role(s) of these VH framework region (FR) allotypic structures has not been defined. We show here that B cells expressing surface immunoglobulin with VHa2 allotypic specificities are preferentially expanded and positively selected in the appendix of young rabbits. By flow cytometry, a higher proportion of a2+ B cells were progressing through the cell cycle (S/G2/M) compared to a2- B cells, most of which were in the G1/G0 phase of the cell cycle. The majority of appendix B cells in dark zones of germinal centers of normal 6-week-old rabbits were proliferating and very little apoptosis were observed. In contrast, in 6-week-old VH-mutant ali/ali rabbits, little cell proliferation and extensive apoptosis were observed. Nonetheless even in the absence of VH1, B cells with a2-like surface immunoglobulin had developed and expanded in the appendix of 11-week-old mutants. The numbers and tissue localization of B cells undergoing apoptosis then appeared similar to those found in 6-week-old normal appendix. Thus, B cells with immunoglobulin receptors lacking the VHa2 allotypic structures were less likely to undergo clonal expansion and maturation. These data suggest that "positive" selection of B lymphocytes through FR1 and FR3 VHa allotypic structures occurs during their development in the appendix.

De novo decorin gene expression suppresses the malignant phenotype in human colon cancer cells.

The rapid progress in the cloning of proteoglycan genes has enabled investigators to examine in depth the functional roles these polyhedric molecules play in the control of cell proliferation. Decorin, a leucine-rich proteoglycan expressed by most connective tissues, is a prototype molecule that regulates cellular growth via two mechanisms: modulation of growth factor activity and matrix assembly. We now provide direct evidence that human colon cancer cells stably transfected with decorin cDNA exhibit a marked suppression of the transformed phenotype: the cells have a reduced growth rate in vitro, form small colonies in soft agar, and do not generate tumors in scid/scid mice. Several independent clones are arrested in the G1 phase of the cell cycle, and their growth suppression can be restored by treatment with decorin antisense oligodeoxynucleotides. These effects are independent of growth factors and are not due to either clonal selection or integration site of the decorin gene. These findings correlate well with the observation that decorin gene expression is markedly up-regulated during quiescence. Decorin thus appears to be one component of a negative loop that controls cell growth.

Complete congruence between gene diversity estimates derived from genotypic data at enzyme and random amplified polymorphic DNA loci in black spruce.

Controversy still exists over the adaptive nature of variation of enzyme loci. In conifers, random amplified polymorphic DNAs (RAPDs) represent a class of marker loci that is unlikely to fall within or be strongly linked to coding DNA. We have compared the genetic diversity in natural populations of black spruce [Picea mariana (Mill.) B.S.P.] using genotypic data at allozyme loci and RAPD loci as well as phenotypic data from inferred RAPD fingerprints. The genotypic data for both allozymes and RAPDs were obtained from at least six haploid megagametophytes for each of 75 sexually mature individuals distributed in five populations. Heterozygosities and population fixation indices were in complete agreement between allozyme loci and RAPD loci. In black spruce, it is more likely that the similar levels of variation detected at both enzyme and RAPD loci are due to such evolutionary forces as migration and the mating system, rather than to balancing selection and overdominance. Furthermore, we show that biased estimates of expected heterozygosity and among-population differentiation are obtained when using allele frequencies derived from dominant RAPD phenotypes.

Cloning and sequencing of CATR1.3, a human gene associated with tumorigenic conversion.

The human squamous cell carcinoma cell line SCC83-01-82 (SCC) contains mutations in both the H-ras and p53 genes, but it exhibits a nontumorigenic phenotype in nude mice. This cell line can be converted into a cell line with a tumorigenic phenotype, SCC83-01-82CA (CA), by treatment with the mutagen methyl methanesulfonate (MMS). This indicates that additional genetic events leading to expression of a cooperating tumor susceptibility gene(s) may be required for tumorigenicity. To identify the cooperating gene(s), an expression cDNA library was made from tumorigenic Ca cells. The library DNA was transfected into nontumorigenic SCC cells and the transfected SCC cells were then injected into nude mice for the selection of a tumorigenic phenotype. Tumors developed in 3 of the 18 mice after injection. Several new cell lines were established from these transfected cell-induced tumors and designated as CATR cells. Tumor histology and karyotype analysis of these cells indicated that they were of human epithelial cell origin. All the CATR cells have the library vector sequence integrated in their genome. Cell line CATR1 expressed a single message from the integrated library representing a 1.3-kb cDNA insert that was absent from untransfected SCC cells or MMS-converted CA cells. This 1.3-kb cDNA insert was cloned by PCR amplification of reverse-transcribed CATR1 total RNA and was designated CATR1.3. The nucleotide sequence of CATR1.3 encodes a peptide of 79 amino acids, has a long 3' untranslated region, and represents an unknown gene product that was associated with the tumorigenic conversion due to the transfected expression library.

Genetic footprinting: a genomic strategy for determining a gene's function given its sequence.

This report describes an efficient strategy for determining the functions of sequenced genes in microorganisms. A large population of cells is subjected to insertional mutagenesis. The mutagenized population is then divided into representative samples, each of which is subjected to a different selection. DNA is prepared from each sample population after the selection. The polymerase chain reaction is then used to determine retrospectively whether insertions into a particular sequence affected the outcome of any selection. The method is efficient because the insertional mutagenesis and each selection need only to be performed once to enable the functions of thousands of genes to be investigated, rather than once for each gene. We tested this "genetic footprinting" strategy using the model organism Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Anti-melanoma antibodies from melanoma patients immunized with genetically modified autologous tumor cells: selection of specific antibodies from single-chain Fv fusion phage libraries.

Fusion phage libraries expressing single-chain Fv antibodies were constructed from the peripheral blood lymphocytes of two melanoma patients who had been immunized with autologous melanoma cells transduced the gamma-interferon gene to enhance immunogenicity, in a trial conducted at another institution. Anti-melanoma antibodies were selected from each library by panning the phage against live cultures of the autologous tumor. After two or three rounds of panning, clones of the phage were tested by ELISA for binding to the autologous tumor cells; > 90% of the clones tested showed a strong ELISA reaction, demonstrating the effectiveness of the panning procedure for selecting antimelanoma antibodies. The panned phage population was extensively absorbed against normal melanocytes to enrich for antibodies that react with melanoma cells but not with melanocytes. The unabsorbed phage were cloned, and the specificities of the expressed antibodies were individually tested by ELISA with a panel of cultured human cells. The first tests were done with normal endothelial and fibroblast cells to identify antibodies that do not react, or react weakly, with two normal cell types, indicating some degree of specificity for melanoma cells. The proportion of phage clones expressing such antibodies was approximately 1%. Those phage were further tested by ELISA with melanocytes, several melanoma lines, and eight other tumor lines, including a glioma line derived from glial cells that share a common lineage with melanocytes. The ELISA tests identified three classes of anti-melanoma antibodies, as follows: (i) a melanoma-specific class that reacts almost exclusively with the melanoma lines; (ii) a tumor-specific class that reacts with melanoma and other tumor lines but does not react with the normal melanocyte, endothelial and fibroblast cells; and (iii) a lineage-specific class that reacts with the melanoma lines, melanocytes, and the glioma line but does not react with the other lines. These are rare classes from the immunized patients' repertoires of anti-melanoma antibodies, most of which are relatively nonspecific anti-self antibodies. The melanoma-specific class was isolated from one patient, and the lineage-specific class was isolated from the other patient, indicating that different patients can have markedly different responses to the same immunization protocol. The procedures described here can be used to screen the antibody repertoire of any person with cancer, providing access to an enormous untapped pool of human monoclonal anti-tumor antibodies with clinical and research potential.