Must We Forgive?: Exploring the Limits and Possibilities of Forgiveness and Resentment

Conflict has marked civilization from Biblical times to the present day. Each of us, with our different and competing interests, and our desires to pursue those interests, have over time wronged another person. Not surprisingly then, forgiveness is a concern of individuals and groups¿communities, countries, religious groups, races¿yet it is a complex idea that philosophers, theologians, political scientists, and psychologists have grappled with. Some have argued that forgiveness is a therapeutic means for overcoming guilt, pain, and anger. Forgiveness is often portrayed as a coping mechanism¿how often we hear the phrase, ¿forgive and forget,¿ as an arrangement to help two parties surmount the complications of disagreement. But forgiveness is not simply a modus vivendi; the ability to forgive and conversely to ask for forgiveness, is counted as an admirable trait and virtue. This essay will explore the nature of forgiveness, which in Christian dogma is often posited as an unqualified virtue. The secular world has appropriated the Christian notion of forgiveness as such a virtue¿but are there instances wherein offering forgiveness is morally inappropriate or dangerous? I will consider the situations in which forgiveness, understood in this essay as the overcoming of resentment, may not be a virtue¿when perhaps maintaining resentment is as virtuous, if not more virtuous, than forgiving. I will explain the various ethical frameworks involved in understanding forgiveness as a virtue, and the relationship between them. I will argue that within Divine Command Theory forgiveness is a virtue¿and thus morally right¿because God commands it. This ethical system has established forgiveness as unconditional, an idea which has been adopted into popular culture. With virtue ethics in mind, which holds virtues to be those traits which benefit the person who possesses them, contributing to the good life, I will argue unqualified forgiveness is not always a virtue, as it will not always benefit the victim. Because there is no way to avoid wrongdoing, humans are confronted with the question of forgiveness with every indiscretion. Its limits, its possibilities, its relationship to one¿s character¿forgiveness is a concern of all people at some time if for no other reason than the plain fact that the past cannot be undone. I will be evaluating the idea of forgiveness as a virtue, in contrast to its counterpart, resentment. How can forgiveness be a response to evil, a way to renounce resentment, and a means of creating a positive self-narrative? And what happens when a sense of moral responsibility is impossible to reconcile with the Christian (and now, secularized imperative of) forgiveness? Is it ever not virtuous to forgive? In an attempt to answer that question I will argue that there are indeed times when forgiveness is not a virtue, specifically: when forgiveness compromises one¿s own self-respect; when it is not compatible with respect for the moral community; and when the offender is unapologetic. The kind of offense I have in mind is a dehumanizing one, one that intends to diminish another person¿s worth or humanity. These are moral injuries, to which I will argue resentment is a better response than forgiveness when the three qualifications cannot be met.

Public Drinking in the Early Modern World: Voices from the Tavern, 1500-1800

Until recently the role of the public drinking house has been approached from elitist, folkloric and anecdotal perspectives. The work of a new generation of social historians, however, has raised the tavern’s profile in the academic consciousness and confirmed its position within the mainstream of social and cultural history. It is now recognized that an understanding of the centrality of public drinking to the development of both elite and popular culture is vital to studies of social behaviour. The study of taverns has also been at the forefront of emerging interest in the history of consumption and material culture, and has contributed to a richer understanding of economic history. Constructions of gender and identity are also visible through research into the patterns of behaviour and discourse in and around the public house. This four-volume reset edition presents a wide-ranging collection of primary sources which uncover the language and behaviour of local and state authorities, of peasants and town-dwellers, and of drinking companions and irate wives. The documents are translated and set in their social and historical context, providing a multidisciplinary collection that will be of great importance to scholars of all areas of social and cultural history of the early modern period. The vast majority of this material is published here for the first time, ensuring that the collection will open up new avenues of research. Volume 1 draws heavily from the Parisian police archives and includes inspectors’ reports, complaints by the general public and details of court cases to build a picture of drinking in early modern France. Volumes 2 and 3 address public drinking in the Holy Roman Empire through a variety of chronicles, civic ordinances, court records, travel reports and surveys of public houses. Volume 4 locates taverns within a broader analysis of America’s public houses, drawing on visual material as well as journal entries, business reports and newspaper articles. Each volume is accompanied by editorial introductions and is annotated to provide readers with a high-quality resource of scholarly material.

Female Imitatio Christi in early modernity – the search for strong virgins like St Wilgefortis

At first glance you think that this is Christ crucified. At a second glance, you recognize a woman hanging on a cross. This is not an invention of the 20th century but reaches back to history where we we can find women cross-dressed or even bearded as men. St Wilgefortis or St Uncumber was a bearded and crucified woman who was venerated widely in northern Europe during the fifteeneth and sixteenth centuries. Wilgefortis is a corruption of the term „virgo fortis“ („strong virgin“). She and other female saints were considered as „imitations of Christ“. The paper deals with the reasons why this saint became so popular and how even today ideas about such strong virgins which mirror androgynous symbolism live on in popular culture.

Street-Ball: The Myth of the Ghetto Basketball Star

In recent decades, countless scholars have examined the developing trend of African American dominance in United States’ professional sports. Many have hypothesized that this over-representation is caused by the presumed reliance on sports as an avenue out of poverty for the African American youths. This trend, it is believed, has a highly detrimental effect the African American community. In actuality, this argument is flawed because it works under the stereotypical assumption that the overwhelming majority of African Americans come from abject poverty. To dispel this fallacy, the author has analyzed the upbringings of each All-National Basketball League First Team player over the past thirty years. The author discovered that while the majority of the players selected were African American, only a small percentage of these athletes were raised in a poverty-stricken environment. Logically, this would not be the case if poor African Americans relied more heavily on sports than middle-class African Americans. This data proves that stereotypes, not empirical evidence, are the substance of nearly every previous study conducted on the topic.

The Sweet Script: A Critical Analysis of American Sportswriting

This thesis analyzes the sportswriting genre as a form of personal essay. It explores the art over time through writers Red Smith, A.J. Liebling, Roger Angell, George Plimpton, Bart Giamatti, Frank Deford, and Rick Reilly, as well as anthologized writers from 2008 and blogs.

Entrevista a Angela McRobbie : los estudios culturales y el imperativo de entender y explicar los cambios sociales

Angela McRobbie es socióloga y dirige el Departamento de Comunicación en Goldsmiths College, Universidad de Londres. En la actualidad, se encuentra entre las referentes más destacadas de los Estudios Culturales británicos. Ha publicado numerosos ensayos en revistas internacionales sobre problemáticas vinculadas con la juventud, los estilos musicales y los consumos culturales, así como ha indagado en los cambios sociales y políticos ocurridos desde los tiempos del thatcherismo. Entre sus libros, sobresalen: Postmodernism and Popular Culture (Routledge, 1994); Feminism and Youth Culture (Macmillan, 1994); Back to Reality? Social Experience and Cultural Studies (Manchester University Press, 1997); British Fashion Design (1998), In the Culture Society. Art, Fashion and Popular Music (Routledge, 1999) y compiló junto a Paul Gilroy y Lawrence Grossberg, Without Guarantees. In Honour of Stuart Hall (Verso, 2000), con motivo del retiro de éste de la Open University en 1997.

La teoría de la cultura, la teoría literaria y sus laberintos

Este trabajo se propuso en lo básico elucidar dos preguntas importantes: 1 - ¿cuál es la conceptualización de la cultura que trabaja en las actuales discusiones sobre la legitimidad de lo popular?; 2 -¿es justa la apropiación de la cultura popular por parte de las instituciones, aunque con ese gesto se esté reconociendo la legitimidad de aquélla? Se ha querido revisar variadas posiciones en esta problemática que van desde lo más actual a lo más tradicional, ambos coexistentes en muchos casos.

Convergencias y divergencias respecto de las poéticas de la década del '60 en tres proyectos de escritura : César Fernández Moreno, Joaquín Giannuzzi y Alfredo Veiravé

La crítica especializada reconoce dos líneas dominantes en el campo intelectual argentino a partir de las producciones de las décadas del sesenta y sus prolongaciones en los setenta, aunque ambas se inscribirían en una genealogía que implica dos modos diferentes de leer la dicotomía arte/vida, una de las tensiones en las estéticas de las vanguardias históricas. Una de ellas, iniciada en los años cincuenta en torno de la famosa revista Poesía Buenos Aires, dirigida por Raúl Gustavo Aguirre, emerge como consecuencia, principalmente, del procesamiento de la vanguardia francesa [especialmente el surrealismo] y podría ser caracterizada como trascendentalismo poético [Calabrese: 2001 y 2002], un aspecto de la ideología del arte que, representado en plenitud por los poetas llamados "malditos", concibe a la poesía como un modo de vida y al poeta como vate, un ser singular, que se constituye en la poesía misma y que atisba un universo diferente al de la cotidianeidad. Mientras que la segunda de las líneas mencionadas, -surgida entre 1955, con "El solicitante descolocado" de Leónidas Lamborghini y prolongada hasta los '70- conocida como la de los "sesentistas", se instaura en polémica con la índole gratuita y estetizante del arte. Se trata de aproximar el texto a lo que se denominaba el contexto aludiendo a lo histórico-social; para ello se intenta crear un imaginario que establezca una continuidad entre la escritura y un determinado modo de ver el mundo; la literatura, inscripta así en el imperativo sartreano, debe identificarse con la praxis política y con los discursos sociales de procedencia referencial [Dalmaroni: 1993 y 1998]. Ingresan, así, elementos procedentes de la cultura popular [por ejemplo, el tango] y las jergas urbanas que construyen un simulacro de oralidad, como materiales a inscribir en la poesía, enfatizando su índole "antiliteraria": tales elementos, al desplazarse de su contexto de procedencia, generan un efecto de extrañamiento, apto para promover una estimulación de la conciencia crítica y develar los ideologemas vigentes. En este contexto, se trata de problematizar la generalización de esta periodización dicotómica, mediante el estudio de las obras de los tres poetas mencionados, instaladas en un espacio de cruce e hibridaciones entre estos mandatos y la vertiente experimental o más intelectual, por lo que no responderían a los rasgos dominantes que permitirían inscribirlos en uno u otro extremo del campo diseñado.

Nota complementaria a "La escritura proverbial de Santillana"

Este trabajo se propone complementar el artículo de Miguel Ángel Pérez Priego, "La escritura proverbial de Santillana" (1992), en el que aborda la cuestión desde la variación estilística que significaron los Proverbios o Centiloquio en la producción poética del Marqués de Santillana. Al inscribir el poema en la categoría genérica del proverbio, Pérez Priego reconoce las características propias de la escritura proverbial en el texto de Santillana, al mismo tiempo que destaca el uso estilístico diferenciado de proverbios y refranes según los tipos de poemas que los contienen. A partir del estudio de la interpolación de paremias en sus poesías doctrinales más extensas, en composiciones líricas representativas y en textos prosísticos, podemos aportar otro aspecto distintivo del discurso proverbial del poeta: la confluencia de la tradición paremiológica medieval y de nuevos paradigmas humanistas. Esto es resultado de la vasta erudición y conocimiento de la Antigüedad clásica, así como del continuo interés por la cultura popular, que caracterizan la obra y formación del Marqués de Santillana