Radio halos in a mass-selected sample of galaxy clusters

A fraction of galaxy clusters host Mpc-scale Radio Halos (RH), generated by ultrarelativistic electrons in the magnetized intra cluster medium (ICM). In the current view they trace turbulent regions in merging clusters, where relativistic particles are trapped and accelerated. This model has clear expectations about the statistical properties of RHs. To test these expectations large mass-selected samples of galaxy clusters with adequate radio and X-ray data are necessary. We used the Planck SZ cluster catalogue as suitable starting point of our investigation, selecting clusters with M500>6x10^14 Msun at 0.08clusters at z<0.2 and with the Extended GMRT RH Survey for 0.2clusters with RH with the mass of the parent cluster and show that this increase is in line with statistical calculations based on the re-acceleration scenario. We confirm earlier findings that RHs are exclusively found in merging systems.

Constraining mass and shape of galaxy clusters through large scale structures

The mass estimation of galaxy clusters is a crucial point for modern cosmology, and can be obtained by several different techniques. In this work we discuss a new method to measure the mass of galaxy clusters connecting the gravitational potential of the cluster with the kinematical properties of its surroundings. We explore the dynamics of the structures located in the region outside virialized cluster, We identify groups of galaxies, as sheets or filaments, in the cluster outer region, and model how the cluster gravitational potential perturbs the motion of these structures from the Hubble fow. This identification is done in the redshift space where we look for overdensities with a filamentary shape. Then we use a radial mean velocity profile that has been found as a quite universal trend in simulations, and we fit the radial infall velocity profile of the overdensities found. The method has been tested on several cluster-size haloes from cosmological N-body simulations giving results in very good agreement with the true values of virial masses of the haloes and orientation of the sheets. We then applied the method to the Coma cluster and even in this case we found a good correspondence with previous. It is possible to notice a mass discrepancy between sheets with different alignments respect to the center of the cluster. This difference can be used to reproduce the shape of the cluster, and to demonstrate that the spherical symmetry is not always a valid assumption. In fact, if the cluster is not spherical, sheets oriented along different axes should feel a slightly different gravitational potential, and so give different masses as result of the analysis described before. Even this estimation has been tested on cosmological simulations and then applied to Coma, showing the actual non-sphericity of this cluster.

The relation between mass and concentration in x-ray galaxy clusters at high-redshift.

In this Thesis work we have studied the properties of high-redshift galaxy clusters through the X-ray emission from their intracluster gas. In particular, we have focused on the relation between concentration and mass that is related to the density of the universe at the formation time of the clusters and therefore, it is a powerful cosmological probe. Concentration is expected to be a decreasing function of mass but a complete characterization of this relation has not been reached yet. We have analysed 22 clusters observed withe the Chandra satellite at high redshift and we have investigated the concentration-mass relation.

Connection between x-ray and radio properties of cool-core galaxy clusters hosting radio mini-halos

Gli ammassi di galassie sono gli oggetti gravitazionalmente legati più grandi dell’Universo. Questi emettono principalmente in banda X tramite bremsstrahlung. Una frazione mostra anche emissione radio diffusa da parte di elettroni relativistici che spiraleggiano nel campo magnetico. Si possono classificare tre tipi di emissione: alon, relitti e mini-aloni radio (MH). I MH sono sorgenti radio su scale di ≥ 200 – 500 kpc, osservate al centro di ammassi caratterizzati dalla presenze di cool-core (CC). L’origine dei MH non è ancora chiara. Gli elettroni relativistici che emettono in banda radio hanno tempi di vita radiativi di molto inferiori a quelli necessari per diffondere sulle scale dell’emissione diffusa. Quindi non sono semplicemente iniettati dalle galassie presenti negli ammassi ed è necessario un meccanismo di accelerazione “in-situ” nell’ICM. I MH testimoniano la presenza di meccanismi che canalizzano parte del budget energetico disponibile nei CC nell’ICM.Quindi lo studio è importante per comprendere la fisica dell’ICM e l’interazione fra le componenti non termiche e termiche. I MH si formano attraverso la riaccelerazione delle particelle relativistiche ad opera della turbolenza del gas. L’origine di questa turbolenza tuttavia non è ancora ben compresa. Gli ammassi CC sono caratterizzati da un picco della brillanza X nelle regioni centrali e da un drop della temperatura verso il centro accompagnata da aumento della densità del gas. Si ritiene che questo sia dovuto al raffreddamento del gas che quindi fluisce nelle zone centrali. Recenti osservazioni in X risultan inconsistenti con il modello classico di CF, suggerendo la presenza di una sorgente di riscaldamento del gas su scale del core degli ammassi. Recentemente Zhuravleva (2014) hanno mostrato che il riscaldamento dovuto alla turbolenza prodotta dall'AGN centrale è in grado di bilanciare il processo di raffreddamento. Abbiamo assunto che la turbolenza responsabile del riscaldamento del gas è anche responsabile dell’accelerazione delle particelle nei MH. Nell’ambito di questo scenario ci si aspetta una correlazione tra la potenza del cooling flow, PCF, che è una misura del tasso di energia emessa dal gas che raffredda nei CC, e la luminosità radio, che è una frazione dell’energia della turbolenza che è canalizzata nell’accelerazione delle particelle. In questo lavoro di tesi abbiamo utilizzato il più grande campione disponibile di MH, allo scopo di studiare la connessione fra le proprietà dei MH e quelle del gas termico nei core degli ammassi che li ospitano. Abbiamo analizzato i dati di 21 ammassi e ricavato i parametri fisici all’interno del raggio di cooling e del MH. Abbiamo ricavato la correlazione fra luminosità radio, e PCF. Abbiamo trovato che le due quantità correlano in modo quasi-lineare confermando i risultati precedenti. Tale correlazione suggerisce uno stretto legame fra le proprietà del gas nei CC e l’origine dei MH.

Radio relics and magnetic fields in galaxy clusters

Radio relics are diffuse synchrotron sources generally located in the peripheries of galaxy clusters in merging state. According to the current leading scenario, relics trace gigantic cosmological shock waves that cross the intra-cluster medium where particle acceleration occurs. The relic/shock connection is supported by several observational facts, including the spatial coincidence between relics and shocks found in the X-rays. Under the assumptions that particles are accelerated at the shock front and are subsequently deposited and then age downstream of the shock, Markevitch et al. (2005) proposed a method to constrain the magnetic field strength in radio relics. Measuring the thickness of radio relics at different frequencies allows to derive combined constraints on the velocity of the downstream flow and on the magnetic field, which in turns determines particle aging. We elaborate this idea to infer first constraints on magnetic fields in cluster outskirts. We consider three models of particle aging and develop a geometric model to take into account the contribution to the relic transverse size due to the projection of the shock-surface on the plane of the sky. We selected three well studied radio relics in the clusters A 521, CIZA J2242.8+5301 and 1RXS J0603.3+4214. These relics have been chosen primarily because they are almost seen edge-on and because the Mach number of the shock that is associated with these relics is measured by X-ray observations, thus allowing to break the degeneracy between magnetic field and downstream velocity in the method. For the first two clusters, our method is consistent with a pure radiative aging model allowing us to derive constraints on the relics magnetic field strength. In the case of 1RXS J0603.3+4214 we find that particle life-times are consistent with a pure radiative aging model under some conditions, however we also collect evidences for downstream particle re-acceleration in the relic W-region and for a magnetic field decaying downstream in its E-region. Our estimates of the magnetic field strength in the relics in A 521 and CIZA J2242.8+5301 provide unique information on the field properties in cluster outskirts. The constraints derived for these relics, together with the lower limits to the magnetic field that we derived from the lack of inverse Compton X-ray emission from the sources, have been combined with the constraints from Faraday rotation studies of the Coma cluster. Overall results suggest that the spatial profile of the magnetic field energy density is broader than that of the thermal gas, implying that the ε_th /ε_B ratio decreases with cluster radius. Alternatively, radio relics could trace dynamically active regions where the magnetic field strength is biased high with respect to the average value in the cluster volume.

Ultra-compact dwarf galaxies in galaxy clusters

We review the evidence that the ultra-compact dwarf (UCD) galaxies we recently discovered in the Fornax Cluster form a new, previously unknown class of galaxies and we discuss possible scenarios for their formation. We then present recent results that UCDs are also present in the Virgo Cluster, and that there is a much larger than expected population of fainter UCDs in the Fornax Cluster. The size and properties of this population may lead us to revise our original 'galaxy threshing' hypothesis for the formation of UCDs.

Diffuse optical light in galaxy clusters. I. Abell 3888

We are undertaking a program to measure the characteristics of the intracluster light ( ICL; total flux, profile, color, and substructure) in a sample of 10 galaxy clusters with a range of cluster mass, morphology, and redshift. We present here the methods and results for the first cluster in that sample, A3888. We have identified an ICL component in A3888 in V and r that contains 13% +/- 5% of the total cluster light and extends to 700 h(70)(-1) kpc (similar to 0.3r(200)) from the center of the cluster. The ICL color in our smallest radial bin is V - r 0.3 +/- 0.1, similar to the central cluster elliptical galaxies. The ICL is redder than the galaxies at 400 h(70)(-1) kpc < r < 700 h(70)(-1) kpc, although the uncertainty in any one radial bin is high. Based on a comparison of V - r color with simple stellar models, the ICL contains a component that formed more than 7 Gyr ago ( at z less than 1) with a high-metallicity ( 1.0 Z(circle dot) < Z(ICL) less than or similar to 2.5 Z(circle dot)) and a more centralized component that contains stars formed within the past 5 Gyr ( at z similar to 1). The profile of the ICL can be roughly fitted by a shallow exponential in the outer regions and a steeper exponential in the central region. We also find a concentration of diffuse light around a small group of galaxies 1.4 h(70)(-1) Mpc from the center of the cluster. In addition, we find three low surface brightness features near the cluster center that are blue ( V - r 0.0) and contain a total flux of 0.1M*. Based on these observations and X-ray and galaxy morphology, we suggest that this cluster is entering a phase of significant merging of galaxy groups in the core, whereupon we expect the ICL fraction to grow significantly with the formation of a cD galaxy, as well as the infall of groups.

Redshifts and velocity dispersions of galaxy clusters in the horologium-reticulum supercluster

We present 118 new optical redshifts for galaxies in 12 clusters in the Horologium-Reticulum supercluster (HRS) of galaxies. For 76 galaxies, the data were obtained with the Dual Beam Spectrograph on the 2.3 m telescope of the Australian National University at Siding Spring Observatory. After combining 42 previously unpublished redshifts with our new sample, we determine mean redshifts and velocity dispersions for 13 clusters in which previous observational data were sparse. In 6 of the 13 clusters, the newly determined mean redshifts differ by more than 750 km s(-1) from the published values. In three clusters, A3047, A3109, and A3120, the redshift data indicate the presence of multiple components along the line of sight. The new cluster redshifts, when combined with other reliable mean redshifts for clusters in the HRS, are found to be distinctly bimodal. Furthermore, the two redshift components are consistent with the bimodal redshift distribution found for the intercluster galaxies in the HRS by Fleenor and coworkers.

The Las Campanas/Anglo-Australian Telescope Rich Cluster Survey - III. Spectroscopic studies of X-ray bright galaxy clusters at z similar to 0.1

We present the analysis of the spectroscopic and photometric catalogues of 11 X-ray luminous clusters at 0.07 < z < 0.16 from the Las Campanas/Anglo-Australian Telescope Rich Cluster Survey. Our spectroscopic data set consists of over 1600 galaxy cluster members, of which two-thirds are outside r(200). These spectra allow us to assign cluster membership using a detailed mass model and expand on our previous work on the cluster colour-magnitude relation ( CMR) where membership was inferred statistically. We confirm that the modal colours of galaxies on the CMR become progressively bluer with increasing radius d( B - R)/dr(p) = - 0.011 +/- 0.003 and with decreasing local galaxy density d( B - R)/dlog ( Sigma)= - 0.062 +/- 0.009. Interpreted as an age effect, we hypothesize that these trends in galaxy colour should be reflected in mean H delta equivalent width. We confirm that passive galaxies in the cluster increase in Hd line strength as dH delta/dr(p) = 0.35 +/- 0.06. Therefore, those galaxies in the cluster outskirts may have younger luminosity-weighted stellar populations; up to 3 Gyr younger than those in the cluster centre assuming d( B - R)/dt = 0.03 mag per Gyr. A variation of star formation rate, as measured by [ O II]lambda 3727 angstrom, with increasing local density of the environment is discernible and is shown to be in broad agreement with previous studies from the 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey and the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. We divide our spectra into a variety of types based upon the MORPHs classification scheme. We find that clusters at z similar to 0.1 are less active than their higher-redshift analogues: about 60 per cent of the cluster galaxy population is non-star forming, with a further 20 per cent in the post-starburst class and 20 per cent in the currently active class, demonstrating that evolution is visible within the past 2 - 3 Gyr. We also investigate unusual populations of blue and very red non-star forming galaxies and we suggest that the former are likely to be the progenitors of galaxies which will lie on the CMR, while the colours of the latter possibly reflect dust reddening. We show that the cluster galaxies at large radii consist of both backsplash ones and those that are infalling to the cluster for the first time. We make a comparison to the field population at z similar to 0.1 and examine the broad differences between the two populations. Individually, the clusters show significant variation in their galaxy populations which we suggest reflects their recent infall histories.

Study of new particle acceleration mechanisms in galaxy clusters through low frequency radio observations

Diffuse radio emission in galaxy clusters has been observed with different size and properties. Giant radio halos (RH), Mpc-size sources found in merging clusters, and mini halos (MH), 0.1-0.5 Mpc size sources located in relaxed cool-core clusters, are thought to be distinct classes of objects with different formation mechanisms. However, recent observations have revealed the unexpected presence of diffuse emission on Mpc-scales in relaxed clusters that host a central MH and show no signs of major mergers. The study of these sources is still at the beginning and it is not yet clear what could be the origin of their unusual emission. The main goal of this thesis is to test the occurrence of these peculiar sources and investigate their properties using low frequency radio observations. This thesis consists in the study of a sample of 12 cool-core galaxy clusters which present some level of dynamical disturbances on large-scale. The heterogeneity of sources in the sample allowed me to investigate under which conditions a halo-type emission is present in MH clusters; and also to study the connection between AGN bubbles and the local environment. Using high sensitivity LOFAR observations, I have detected large-scale emission in four non-merging clusters, in addition to the central MH. I have constrained for the first time the spectral properties of diffuse emission in these double radio component galaxy clusters, and I have investigated the connection between their thermal and non-thermal emission for a better comprehension of the acceleration mechanism. Furthermore, I derived upper limits to the halo power for the other clusters in the sample, which could present large-scale diffuse emission under the detection threshold. Finally, I have reconstructed the duty-cycle of one of the most powerful AGN known, located at the centre of a galaxy cluster of the sample.

Non-thermal phenomena in galaxy clusters: the LOFAR revolution

Turbulence introduced into the intra-cluster medium (ICM) through cluster merger events transfers energy to non-thermal components (relativistic particles and magnetic fields) and can trigger the formation of diffuse synchrotron radio sources. Owing to their steep synchrotron spectral index, such diffuse sources can be better studied at low radio frequencies. In this respect, the LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR) is revolutionizing our knowledge thanks to its unprecedented resolution and sensitivity below 200 MHz. In this Thesis we focus on the study of radio halos (RHs) by using LOFAR data. In the first part of this work we analyzed the largest-ever sample of galaxy clusters observed at radio frequencies. This includes 309 Planck clusters from the Second Data Release of the LOFAR Two Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS-DR2), which span previously unexplored ranges of mass and redshift. We detected 83 RHs, half of which being new discoveries. In 140 clusters we lack a detected RH; for this sub-sample we developed new techniques to derive upper limits to their radio powers. By comparing detections and upper limits, we carried out the first statistical analysis of populations of clusters observed at low frequencies and tested theoretical formation models. In the second part of this Thesis we focused on ultra-steep spectrum radio halos. These sources are almost undetected at GHz frequencies, but are thought to be common at low frequencies. We presented LOFAR observations of two interesting clusters hosting ultra-steep spectrum radio halos. With complementary radio and X-ray observations we constrained the properties and origin of these targets.

A comprehensive study of the AGN feedback cycle in galaxy clusters from high resolution X-ray and radio observations

At the center of galaxy clusters, a dramatic interplay known as feedback cycle occurs between the hot intracluster medium (ICM) and the active galactic nucleus (AGN) of the central galaxy. The footprints of this interplay are evident from X-ray observations of the ICM, where X-ray cavities and shock fronts are associated with radio lobe emission tracing energetic AGN outbursts. While such jet activity reduces the efficiency of the hot gas to cool to lower temperatures, residual cooling can generate warm and cold gas clouds around the central galaxy. The condensed gas parcels can ultimately reach the core of the galaxy and be accreted by the AGN. This picture is the result of tremendous advances over the last three decades. Yet, a deeper understanding of the details of how the heating–cooling regulation is achieved and maintained is still missing. In this Thesis, we delve into key aspects of the feedback cycle. To this end, we leverage high-resolution (sub-arcsecond), multifrequency observations (mainly X-ray and radio) of several top-level facilities (e.g., Chandra, JVLA, VLBA, LOFAR). First, we investigate which conditions trigger a feedback response to gas cooling, by studying the properties of clusters where feedback is just about to start. Then, we focus on the details of how the AGN–ICM interaction progresses by examining cavity and shock heating in the cluster RBS797, an exemplary case of the jet feedback paradigm. Furthermore, we explore the importance of shock heating and the coupling of distinct jet power regimes (i.e., FRII, FRI and FR0 radio galaxies) to the environment. Ultimately, as heating models rely on the connection between the direct evidence (the jets) and the smoking gun (the X-ray cavities) of feedback, we examine the cases in which these two are dramatically misaligned.

Cosmology from probe combination: synergies between the number counts of galaxy clusters and cosmic voids

This Thesis work concerns the complementary study of the abundance of galaxy clusters and cosmic voids identified in cosmological simulations, at different redshifts. In particular, we focus our analyses on the combination of the cosmological constraints derived from these probes, which can be considered statistically independent, given the different aspects of Universe density field they map. Indeed, we aim at showing the orthogonality of the derived cosmological constraints and the resulting impressive power of the combination of these probes. To perform this combination we apply three newly implemented algorithms that allow us to combine independent probes. These algorithms represent a flexible and user-friendly tool to perform different techniques for probe combination and are implemented within the environment provided by the large set of free software C++/Python CosmoBolognaLib. All the new implemented codes provide simple and flexible tools that will be soon applied to the data coming from currently available and next-generation wide-field surveys to perform powerful combined cosmological analyses.

Spiral-like structure at the centre of nearby clusters of galaxies

Context. X-ray data analysis have found that fairly complex structures at cluster centres are more common than expected. Many of these structures have similar morphologies, which exhibit spiral-like substructure. Aims. It is not yet well known how these structures are formed or maintained. Understanding the origin of these spiral-like features at the centre of some clusters is the major motivation behind this work. Methods. We analyse deep Chandra observations of 15 nearby galaxy clusters ( 0.01 < z < 0.06), and use X-ray temperature and substructure maps to detect small features at the cores of the clusters. Results. We detect spiral-like features at the centre of 7 clusters: A85, A426, A496, Hydra A cluster, Centaurus, Ophiuchus, and A4059. These patterns are similar to those found in numerical hydrodynamic simulations of cluster mergers with non-zero impact parameter. In some clusters of our sample, a strong radio source also occupies the inner region of the cluster, which indicates a possible connection between the two. Our investigation implies that these spiral-like structures may be caused by off-axis minor mergers. Since these features occur in regions of high density, they may confine radio emission from the central galaxy producing, in some cases, unusual radio morphology.

Cluster and cluster galaxy evolution history from IR to X-ray observations of the young cluster RX J1257.2+4738 at z=0.866

Context. The cosmic time around the z similar to 1 redshift range appears crucial in the cluster and galaxy evolution, since it is probably the epoch of the first mature galaxy clusters. Our knowledge of the properties of the galaxy populations in these clusters is limited because only a handful of z similar to 1 clusters are presently known. Aims. In this framework, we report the discovery of a z similar to 0.87 cluster and study its properties at various wavelengths. Methods. We gathered X-ray and optical data (imaging and spectroscopy), and near and far infrared data (imaging) in order to confirm the cluster nature of our candidate, to determine its dynamical state, and to give insight on its galaxy population evolution. Results. Our candidate structure appears to be a massive z similar to 0.87 dynamically young cluster with an atypically high X-ray temperature as compared to its X-ray luminosity. It exhibits a significant percentage (similar to 90%) of galaxies that are also detected in the 24 mu m band. Conclusions. The cluster RXJ1257.2+4738 appears to be still in the process of collapsing. Its relatively high temperature is probably the consequence of significant energy input into the intracluster medium besides the regular gravitational infall contribution. A significant part of its galaxies are red objects that are probably dusty with on-going star formation.