Strengthening impact evaluation in natural resource management

The workshop on Strengthening Evaluation in Natural Resource Management Research is part of an ACIAR-funded Small Research and Development Activity (SRA) on Assessing the Impacts of Natural Resource Management and Policy Research in Development Programs, with WorldFish and Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO) as partners. The SRA objectives included a review of literature to identify challenges in assessing the impact of NRMR programs and to propose a framework that addresses them. An exploratory workshop was held in February 2012 to initiate collective action within the CGIAR Research Programs (CRPs) to identify and address their impact challenges and led to the creation of the NRMR impact community of practice (COP). This follow-up workshop brought together members of the COP and partners in the SRA to discuss and reach agreement on how to progress on our collective goals of building new and appropriate approaches for NRMR IE and how to put these approaches into action through our research programs. This report is a documentation of the workshop process and outputs.

Estudo transversal sobre a exposição às tecnologias não-invasivas de cuidado de enfermagem obstétrica na atenção ao parto e sua repercussão na vitalidade do recém-nascido

Estudo cujo objeto foi o emprego de tecnologias não-invasivas de cuidado de enfermagem obstétrica (TNICEO) por enfermeiras obstétricas durante o acompanhamento do trabalho de parto e parto, e suas repercussões sobre a vitalidade do recém-nascido. A tese é: a disponibilização de TNICEO pelas enfermeiras obstétricas na atenção ao trabalho de parto, parto e nascimento está associada a recém-natos com índice de Apgar (IA) >8, quando comparado com o índice de Apgar de recém-nascidos cujas mães não puderam optar pelo uso destas tecnologias. Objetivou: a) descrever as características obstétricas das mulheres e de seu trabalho de parto e parto acompanhados por enfermeiras obstétricas; b) descrever as TNICEO disponibilizadas pelas enfermeiras obstétricas no cuidado à parturiente; c) medir e comparar a associação entre o IA de primeiro e quinto minutos de vida dos recém-nascidos cujas mães fizeram uso das TNICEO com: o IA do primeiro e quinto minutos de vida dos recém-nascidos cujas mães foram submetidas ao tratamento tradicional (intervenções); o IA do primeiro e quinto minutos de vida dos recém-nascidos cujas mães utilizaram tanto TNICEO e assistência tradicional (AT); o IA do primeiro e quinto minutos de vida dos recém-nascidos cujas mães e não foram submetidas a nenhum tipo de assistência (TNICEO ou AT) durante o trabalho de parto. Tratou-se de estudo observacional descritivo, transversal, retrospectivo. Realizado em Hospital Maternidade Municipal localizado na zona norte do Município do Rio de Janeiro. A amostra foi 6.790 parturientes, que tiveram parto vaginal acompanhado por enfermeiras obstétricas, entre setembro/2004 e dezembro/2011. A fonte de informações foi o Livro de Registros de Partos (LRP) da maternidade. Os resultados evidenciaram que: 91,9% utilizaram um ou mais recurso relacionado às TNICEO e 60,2% foram submetidas a uma ou mais intervenção da AT. Quanto ao IA no 1 e no 5 minuto de vida, com relação às variáveis relacionadas aos tipos de assistência que utilizaram, constatou-se que os neonatos cujas mães durante o trabalho de parto e parto utilizaram algum tipo de TNICEO apresentaram percentuais mais elevados de IA > 8, tanto no 1 minuto (93,4%) como no 5 minuto de vida (99,0%). Em contrapartida os neonatos cujas mães foram submetidas a algum procedimento relacionado à AT apresentaram os menores percentuais de IA (82,8%) no 1 minuto e (94,7%) no 5 minuto de vida. Confirmando a tese proposta, conclui-se que a razão de chance do IA ser > 8 no primeiro minuto de vida é aumentada (OR 4,564; IC95%: 1,887 11,038; p valor 0,0008) a favor do grupo de mulheres que utilizaram apenas as TNICEO durante TP e/ou P, comparado ao grupo de mulheres submetidas às intervenções da AT. Referente ao quinto minuto de vida, a razão de chance de um recém-nascido cuja mãe que teve seu TP e/ou P acompanhados pelas enfermeiras obstétricas e utilizaram as somente as TNICEO na assistência foi maior (OR = 4,927; IC95% 2,349 10,334 ; p valor 0,00020), quando comparado com o grupo de parturientes da AT.

Using theory of change to achieve impact in AAS

The CGIAR Strategy and Results Framework sets out four system level outcomes (SLOs), namely: reducing rural poverty, improving food security, improving nutrition and health and sustainable management of natural resources. In pursuit of these objectives the CGIAR has developed a set of sixteen CGIAR Research Programs (CRPs), each of which is expected to make specific contributions to a range of intermediate development outcomes (IDOs) linked to the SLOs. As part of this work the CRPs are developing impact pathways and theories of change designed to explain how the programs will achieve IDOs. The purpose of the present paper is to explain the approach that the CRP on Aquatic Agricultural Systems (AAS) is taking to using these programmatic tools to help achieve impact.

Research in development: the approach of AAS

The CGIAR Research Program on Aquatic Agricultural Systems (AAS) is pursuing a Research in Development approach that emphasizes the importance of embedding research in the development context. Reflecting this emphasis the six elements of this approach are a commitment to people and place, participatory action research, gender transformative research, learning and networking, partnerships, and capacity building. It is through the careful pursuit of these six elements that we believe that the program will achieve the development outcomes we aspire to, and do so at scale.

Research in development: learning from the CGIAR Research Program on Aquatic Agricultural Systems

This working paper aims to synthesize and share learning from the experience of adapting and operationalizing the Research in Development(RinD) approach to agricultural research in the five hubs under the The CGIAR Research Program on Aquatic Agricultural Systems. It seeks to share learning about how the approach is working in context and to explore the outcomes it is achieving through initial implementation over 3 ½ years. This learning can inform continuation of agricultural research in the second phase of the CGIAR research programs and will be useful to others aiming to implement research programs that seek to equitably build capacity to innovate in complex social-ecological systems. Each of the chapters in this working paper have shown that RinD has produced a range of outcomes that were often unexpected and broader in scope than might result from other approaches to agricultural research. RinD also produces innovations, and there is evidence that it builds capacity to innovate.

Surveillance during pregnancy: methods and response rates from a hospital based pilot study of the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System in Ireland

Background: Many European countries including Ireland lack high quality, on-going, population based estimates of maternal behaviours and experiences during pregnancy. PRAMS is a CDC surveillance program which was established in the United States in 1987 to generate high quality, population based data to reduce infant mortality rates and improve maternal and infant health. PRAMS is the only on-going population based surveillance system of maternal behaviours and experiences that occur before, during and after pregnancy worldwide.Methods: The objective of this study was to adapt, test and evaluate a modified CDC PRAMS methodology in Ireland. The birth certificate file which is the standard approach to sampling for PRAMS in the United States was not available for the PRAMS Ireland study. Consequently, delivery record books for the period between 3 and 5 months before the study start date at a large urban obstetric hospital [8,900 births per year] were used to randomly sample 124 women. Name, address, maternal age, infant sex, gestational age at delivery, delivery method, APGAR score and birth weight were manually extracted from records. Stillbirths and early neonatal deaths were excluded using APGAR scores and hospital records. Women were sent a letter of invitation to participate including option to opt out, followed by a modified PRAMS survey, a reminder letter and a final survey.Results: The response rate for the pilot was 67%. Two per cent of women refused the survey, 7% opted out of the study and 24% did not respond. Survey items were at least 88% complete for all 82 respondents. Prevalence estimates of socially undesirable behaviours such as alcohol consumption during pregnancy were high [>50%] and comparable with international estimates.Conclusion: PRAMS is a feasible and valid method of collecting information on maternal experiences and behaviours during pregnancy in Ireland. PRAMS may offer a potential solution to data deficits in maternal health behaviour indicators in Ireland with further work. This study is important to researchers in Europe and elsewhere who may be interested in new ways of tailoring an established CDC methodology to their unique settings to resolve data deficits in maternal health.

PREDICTION OF NETILMICIN DISPOSITION IN NEONATES

Multiple regression analyses of data from 33 neonates who received netilmicin therapy showed that concurrent treatment with other drugs (Drg), creatinine clearance (CL(cr)), gestational age (GA), and an apgar score of less than 6 at 1 min (Agl') were significant determinants of netilmicin clearance. Apparent volume of distribution was significantly affected by postnatal age (PNA), gender, the presence of ascites and/or oedema (A/O), and whether or not the neonate was small for gestational age (SGA). The following formulae were obtained: CL (ml min-1 kg-1) = -0.108 - 0.210 (Drg) + 0.152(CL(cr)) + 0.019(GA) -0.128(Agl') (multiple R = 0.725, p

Impact of Neonatal Intensive Care on Late Preterm Infants: Developmental Outcomes at 3 Years

BACKGROUND: Late preterm infants (LPIs) (34-36 weeks' gestation) account for up to 75% of preterm births and constitute a significant proportion of all neonatal admissions. This study assessed the impact of neonatal intensive or high-dependency care (IC) on developmental outcomes of LPIs at 3 years of age. METHODS: This cohort study included 225 children born late preterm in Northern Ireland during 2006. Children born late preterm who received IC were compared with children born late preterm who did not receive IC. Cognitive, motor, and language skills were assessed by using the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development, Third Edition. Growth was assessed by using anthropometric measures of height and weight. RESULTS: LPIs who received IC were more often less mature (34 weeks' gestation), with lower birth weight (<= 2500 g) and Apgar scores (<7 at 5 minutes) compared with the control group. They were more often born by cesarean delivery and more likely to have received resuscitation at birth. At 3 years of age, children born late preterm who received IC demonstrated similar cognitive, motor, and language skills compared with children in the control group. Measurements of growth also did not differ significantly between groups. CONCLUSIONS: Despite having increased maternal, perinatal, and neonatal risk factors, there were no significant differences in early childhood development between LPIs who received IC and those who did not. LPIs do not receive routine follow-up after IC and this study provides useful and reassuring data for parents and clinicians on the longer-term outcome of this infant group.

Are there developmentally distinct motor indicators of pain in preterm infants?

The aims of this study were to examine preterm infant reactions to pain in detail over prolonged time periods using multiple measures, and to assess the value of including specific body movements of the Neonatal Individualized Developmental Care and Assessment Program (NIDCAP) system to evaluate pain. Ten preterm infants born at 31 weeks mean gestational age (GA) and mean birth weight 1676 g were studied during a routine blood collection in a Level III neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). At 32-week post-conceptional age, computerized physiologic and video recordings were obtained continuously for 60 min (prior to, during and after lance). Motor and facial behaviors were coded independently, using the NIDCAP and the NFCS (Neonatal Facial Coding System), respectively, and compared with heart rate (HR) and oxygen saturation responses. Of the movements hypothesized to be stress cues in the NIDCAP model, extension of arms and legs (80%) and finger splay (70%) were the most common following lance. Contrary to the model, most infants (70%) had lower incidence of twitches and startles post-lance compared to baseline. Whereas all infants showed some NFCS response to lance, for three infants, the magnitude was low. HR increased and oxygen saturation decreased post-lance. Infants with more prior pain exposure, lower Apgar, and lower GA at birth, displayed more motor stress cues but less facial activity post-lance. Extension of extremities and finger splay, but not twitches and startles, from the NIDCAP, appear to be stress cues and show promise as clinical pain indicators to supplement facial and physiological pain measures in preterm infants.

High variability in the dosing of commonly used antibiotics revealed by a Europe-wide point prevalence study: implications for research and dissemination

BACKGROUND: Antibiotic dosing in neonates varies between countries and centres, suggesting suboptimal exposures for some neonates. We aimed to describe variations and factors influencing the variability in the dosing of frequently used antibiotics in European NICUs to help define strategies for improvement.

METHODS: A sub-analysis of the European Study of Neonatal Exposure to Excipients point prevalence study was undertaken. Demographic data of neonates receiving any antibiotic on the study day within one of three two-week periods from January to June 2012, the dose, dosing interval and route of administration of each prescription were recorded. The British National Formulary for Children (BNFC) and Neofax were used as reference sources. Risk factors for deviations exceeding ±25% of the relevant BNFC dosage recommendation were identified by multivariate logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS: In 89 NICUs from 21 countries, 586 antibiotic prescriptions for 342 infants were reported. The twelve most frequently used antibiotics - gentamicin, penicillin G, ampicillin, vancomycin, amikacin, cefotaxime, ceftazidime, meropenem, amoxicillin, metronidazole, teicoplanin and flucloxacillin - covered 92% of systemic prescriptions. Glycopeptide class, GA <32 weeks, 5(th) minute Apgar score <5 and geographical region were associated with deviation from the BNFC dosage recommendation. While the doses of penicillins exceeded recommendations, antibiotics with safety concerns followed (gentamicin) or were dosed below (vancomycin) recommendations.

CONCLUSIONS: The current lack of compliance with existing dosing recommendations for neonates needs to be overcome through the conduct of well-designed clinical trials with a limited number of antibiotics to define pharmacokinetics/pharmacodynamics, efficacy and safety in this population and by efficient dissemination of the results.

Can group exercise programs improve health outcomes in pregnant women? A systematic review

Current scientific evidence supports the recommendation to initiate or continue the practice of physical exercise in healthy pregnant women. Group exercise programs have positive effects in improving health and well-being, as well as social support. In order to understand the scientific evidence in this field, and the outcomes in maternal health, it has generated wide interest in exploring the studies carried out with more relevant group exercise programs. The aim of this systematic review was to evaluate the available evidence on the effectiveness of group exercise programs in improving women’s and newborns health outcomes during pregnancy. Three databases were used to conduct literature searches and strict inclusion and exclusion criteria were employed. Seventeen studies were selected for analysis. All studies were randomized control trials conducted with pregnant women that evaluated the effect of group exercise programs on the health outcomes of mother and newborn. Most studies followed a supervised structured exercise program including a main aerobic part, resistance training, pelvic floor training and stretching and relaxation sections. The significant effects of the programs are related with improved maternal perception of health status, lower maternal weight gain, improved levels of maternal glucose tolerance, improved aerobic fitness and muscular strength, lower frequency of urinary incontinence, improved sick leave due to lumbopelvic pain, fewer cesarean and instrumental deliveries, higher newborn Apgar score and faster postpartum recovery. Exercise and health professionals should advise pregnant women that aerobic group exercise during pregnancy improves a wide range of health outcomes for the women and newborn

Contribuição da ecografia cerebral transfontanelar para a avaliação do crescimento cerebral do recém-nascido pré-termo

Tese de doutoramento, Medicina (Pediatria), Universidade de Lisboa, Faculdade de Medicina, 2013

Association between birth weight and neuromotor performance: a twin study

The development of neonatal intensive care has led to an increase in the prevalence of children with low birth weight and associated morbidity. The objectives of this study are to verify (1) The association between birth weight (BW) and neuromotor performance? (2) Is the neuromotor performance of twins within the normal range? (3) Are intra-pair similarities in neuromotor development of Monozygotic (MZ) and Disygotic (DZ) twins of unequal magnitude? The sample consisted of 191 children (78 MZ and 113 DZ), 8.9+3.1 years of age and with an average BW of 2246.3+485.4g. In addition to gestational characteristics, sports participation and Zurich Neuromotor Assessment (ZNA) were observed at childhood age. The statistical analysis was carried out with software SPSS 18.0, the STATA 10 and the ZNA performance scores. The level of significance was 0.05. For the neuromotor items high intra and inter-investigator reliabilities were obtained (0.793Apgar 5´ accounted for <26% of the variance. Twins showed elevated percentages of subjects (32.7%<76.9%) with low performance

Análise Descritiva de Parturientes e Recém-Nascidos na Maternidade: Hospital Dona Estefânia entre 2005 e 2008

Entre 2005 e 2008, registaram-se 8413 nascimentos na maternidade do Hospital Dona Estefânia (HDE), aproximadamente 8% do total nacional no mesmo período. A mortalidade fetal (0,20%) atingiu os objectivos do Plano Nacional de Saúde (PNS) para 2010 e está aos melhores niveis da União Europeia. Contudo, a percentagem média de nascimentos prétermo (8,1%) e de cesarianas (31,9%) situam-se ainda acima das metas estabelecidas pelo PNS de, respectivamente, 4,9% e 24,8%. O odds ratio de ocorrência de um índice Apgar baixo aos 5 minutos por cada 100 g de peso a menos à nascença foi de 1,35 e por cada semana a menos de gestação foi de 1,33. As parturientes tiveram em média 30,4 anos de idade, sendo 3,8% adolescentes. Cerca de 22% eram estrangeiras, valor superior à média nacional de 9%. Registou-se variabilidade entre as principais nacionalidades quanto a percentagem de partos pré-termo e de cesarianas, sendo menor nas mães chinesas. Encontrou-se significado estatístico na relação do peso à nascença com a idade de gestação,tipo de gravidez (simples/gemelar), sexo, paridade e idade da mãe. Fixando as covariáveis,uma semana de gestação a mais correspondeu, em média, a mais 176 g; um recém-nascido(RN) gémeo teve, em média, menos 381 g que um não-gémeo e um RN do sexo feminino pesou, em média, menos 48 g que um masculino. Apresentam-se tabelas de percentis de peso por sexo e idade gestacional (36-41 semanas) para os RN do HDE.

L'effet de l'entrainement avec le ballon d'exercice pendant la grossesse sur l'accouchement.

Résumé Introduction : L’entrainement avec le ballon d’exercice pendant la grossesse a des effets positifs sur le déroulement de l’accouchement. Le but de l’étude était d’identifier si une association existe entre le volume d’entrainement avec le ballon d’exercice durant la grossesse en milieu naturel sur l’issue du déroulement de l’accouchement, soit la durée des phases 1 (dilatation/phase active) et 2 (expulsion), ainsi que l’usage de la péridurale et de la césarienne. Méthode: Cette étude quasi-expérimentale a été menée auprès d'un échantillon de convenance composée de 32 femmes enceintes qui ont pris part entre un et 28 cours d'exercice supervisé durant la grossesse (programme Ballon Forme), avec la possibilité d'effectuer des exercices supplémentaires à la maison avec le ballon d’exercice. Un questionnaire et un journal de bord ont été remplis par les participantes, avec l'aide d'une infirmière de l’hôpital pour les données médicales. Résultats: Un volume d’entrainement élevé, incluant l’entraînement sous forme de cours et à domicile, a été significativement associé à une durée plus courte d’accouchement, que ce soit pour le temps total de l’accouchement (r = -0,408, p = 0,031) ou pour les deux phases spécifiques de l’accouchement [la phase 1: r = -0,372 ; p = 0,043 et la phase 2: r = -0,415, p = 0,028]. Un volume d’entrainement élevé a aussi été lié à une réduction de la deuxième phase chez les femmes qui donnaient naissance pour la première fois. La durée totale des exercices exécutés lors des cours a été significativement associée à cette réduction comparativement aux exercices à la maison. Aucun effet indésirable n'a été observé avec le volume d’entrainement élevé sur les paramètres de l’accouchement et la santé du bébé (Apgar et poids du bébé à la naissance). En fait, un nombre très faible de césarienne (6%), de recours à la péridurale (47%) et d'extraction instrumentale (forceps ou ventouse: 13%) a été observé dans notre échantillon de femmes. Conclusion: La pratique du ballon d’exercice est une avenue prometteuse pour les femmes enceintes et un niveau élevé d’entraînement est associé à un accouchement plus rapide et sans complications pour le bébé. L’implantation de ce programme pourrait éventuellement contribuer à réduire considérablement les coûts de santé au Québec en favorisant l’accouchement naturel. Des interventions et des recherches ultérieures devront considérer et examiner cette modalité spécifique d’entrainement pour les femmes enceintes.