Teacher-student relationships

An updated edition of the comprehensive introduction to the rapidly growing area of middle schooling, for teachers, teacher education students and school administrators.The middle years of schooling are increasingly recognised as a crucial stage in students' lives, one that has significant consequences for ongoing educational success. International research indicates that young adolescents benefit from programs designed especially for their needs. Teaching Middle Years offers a systematic overview of the philosophy, principles and issues in middle schooling. It includes contributions from academics and school-based practitioners on intellectual and emotional development in early adolescence, pedagogy, curriculum and assessment of middle years students. This second edition is fully revised to reflect the latest research findings. It includes new chapters on students with diverse needs, school partnerships with families and community, and effective team teaching. Also new to this edition is a chapter that brings middle schooling concepts to life by providing real examples of reform in action.Written for teachers, student teachers, education leaders and policy makers, Teaching Middle Years is an essential resource for anyone involved in educating young adolescents.

Teachers’ understandings of their relationships with students : pedagogic connectedness

This paper reports on a doctoral study that explored the nature of pedagogic connectedness and revealed the ways in which teachers experience this phenomenon. Pedagogic connectedness is defined as the engagements between teacher and student that impact on student learning. In this study, twenty teachers in an independent college in South-East Queensland, Australia, were interviewed and the interview transcripts analysed iteratively. Five qualitatively different ways of experiencing pedagogic connectedness emerged from the data. The findings of this phenomenographic-related study are instructive in developing a framework for changes to teachers’ pedagogic practices.

Discriminating between primary school students with high and low self-esteem.

From an initial sample of 747 primary school students, the top 16 percent (n =116) with high self-esteem (HSE) and the bottom 15 percent (n = I1 I) with low selfesteem (LSE) were se/eeted. These two groups were then compared on personal and classroom variables. Significant differences were found for all personal (self-talk, selfconcepts) and classroom (teacher feedback, praise, teacher-student relationship, and classroom environment) variables. Students with HSE scored more highly on all variables. Discriminant Function Analysis (DFA) was then used to determine which variables discriminated between these two groups of students. Learner self-concept, positive and negative self-talk, classroom environment, and effort feedback were the best discriminators of students with high and low self-esteem. Implications for educational psychologists and teachers are discussed.

Building bridges to participation : sociocultural case studies of AfL

Assessment for Learning(AfL) case studies in a North Queensland school highlight the significance of the teacher-student relationship in creating a supportive culture within which students can negotiate new learner identities. AfL practices are school based evaluative practices that occur within the regular flow of teaching and learning with the purpose of informing and improving student learning to enhance learner autonomy. The identity of an autonomous learner is socially negotiated through participation in the community of practice of the class. Underpinned by a sociocultural perspective this research shows how AfL is manifested in action in its complexity and how positive teacher-student interactions can build bridges for students to move towards full participation.

Towards learner autonomy : an assessment for learning approach

Using Assessment for Learning (AfL) may develop learner autonomy however, very often AfL is reduced to a set of strategies that do not always achieve the desired outcome. This research adopted a different approach that examined AfL as a cultural practice, situated within influential social relationships that shape learner identity. The study addressed the question “What are the qualities of the teacher-student relationship that support student learning autonomy in an AfL context?” Three case studies of the interactions of Queensland middle school teachers and their classes of Year 7, 8 and 9 were developed over one year. Data were collected from field notes and video recordings of classroom interactions and individual and focus group interviews with teachers and students. The analysis began with a close look at the field data. Interpretations that emerged from a sociocultural theoretical understanding were helpful in informing the process of analysis. Themes and patterns of interrelationships were identified through thematic coding using a constant comparative approach. Validation was achieved through methodological triangulation. Four findings that inform an understanding of AfL and the development of learner autonomy emerged. Firstly, autonomy is theorised as a context-specific identity mediated through the teacher-student relationship. Secondly, it was observed that learners negotiated their identities as knowers through AfL practices in various tacit, explicit, group and individual ways in a ‘generative dance’ of knowing in action (Cook & Brown, 2005). Thirdly, teachers and learners negotiated their participation by drawing from identities in multiple communities of practice. Finally it is proposed that a new participative identity or narrative for assessment is needed. This study contributes to understandings about teacher AfL practices that can help build teacher assessment capacity. Importantly, autonomy is understood as an identity that is available to all learners. This study is also significant as it affirms the importance of teacher assessment to support learners in developing autonomy, a focus that challenges the singular assessment policy focus on measuring performance. Finally this study contributes to a sociocultural theoretical understanding of AfL.

‘Personal Response’ and English Teaching

A case study relating to secondary education, examining the teacher student relationship as it operates within the English classroom is the topic of this paper. It describes how a certain conception of 'personal response' to literature provided a means for the teacher/counsellor to form the ethical capacities of children. 'Personal response' is usually associated with the moment in which the child is freed to be most natural. But for all the emphasis upon the irreducibly individual nature of the 'genuinely felt response', this pedagogic exercise finds its place within a series of strategies designed both to cherish and correct the child, to nurture and to scrutinise, to guide and to reconstruct.

Shifting centres: Pedagogical relations in the Era of Big Data

This paper presents a cautious argument for re-thinking both the nature and the centrality of the one-to-one teacher/student relationship in contemporary pedagogy. A case is made that learning in and for our times requires us to broaden our understanding of pedagogical relations beyond the singularity of the teacher/student binary and to promote the connected teacher as better placed to lead learning for these times. The argument proceeds in three parts: first, a characterization of our times as defined increasingly by the digital knowledge explosion of Big Data; second, a re-thinking of the nature of pedagogical relationships in the context of Big Data; and third, an account of the ways in which leaders can support their teachers to become more effective in leading learning by being more closely connected to their professional colleagues.

Vigiar sem punir? o medo na relação professor-aluno

Essa dissertação trata do medo na relação entre alunos e professores.O medo enquanto emoção humana determina alterações biofísicas que são responsáveis pela manutenção da vida. No entanto, em nível elevado, o medo pode se tornar paralisante ou causador de patologias psíquicas. Mobilizador ou paralisante, o medo pode ser causado por situações reais ou imaginárias. O mesmo medo pode ser causa de angústia para uns e não para outros. Existem aqueles que são só de uns e outros que são de todos. Ao longo da História o medo foi utilizado como forma de disciplinarização de indivíduos e até de populações inteiras. Também foi utilizado na Escola, como forma de controle e exercício do poder do adulto sobre a criança e o jovem. Punições, humilhações, palmatórias, varas, joelhos no milho foram alguns dos instrumentos utilizados por longo tempo na intimidação do aluno. O Século XXI, que já vem sendo conhecido como o Século do Medo, vem trazendo as mudanças nos comportamentos, o aumento da violência do mundo e as mudanças na escola. O professor outrora amedrontador, detentor do poder legitimado socialmente, vem se tornando um amedrontado tanto no exercício profissional quanto cidadão da grande cidade. Analisaremos nesse trabalho o quanto do professor amedrontador e do aluno amedrontado convivem hoje como o professor amedrontado e o aluno amedrontador

A influência do movimento renovador em aulas de educação física de escolas municipais do Rio de Janeiro

Como crítica à perspectiva da Educação Física Escolar (EFE) voltada à aptidão física e ao desenvolvimento técnico-esportivo, tão comum até a década de 1970, surgem, a partir da década de 1980, novas propostas de ensino que a aproximariam dos reais objetivos da escola é o que se chama de movimento renovador da EFE. Ao longo dos anos, essas propostas foram incorporadas aos cursos de graduação, de pós-graduação e aos documentos oficiais de ensino. Era de se esperar que as aulas de EFE nas escolas brasileiras, hoje, representassem, hegemonicamente, as propostas do movimento renovador, mas paradoxalmente temos visto intervenções difusas e até aleatórias, muitas vezes representadas pelo rola a bola. Diante da necessidade de investir em práticas renovadoras e a fim de abolir o caráter de estudos que apenas pomovem denúncias de práticas caducas, este estudo buscou professores que, alinhados aos conhecimentos renovadores, procuram desenvolver aulas de EFE que se aproximam e representam tais conhecimentos didático-metodológicos. Assim, buscou-se investigar a influência do movimento renovador na intervenção pedagógica de cinco professores de Educação Física da rede municipal de ensino do Rio de Janeiro. O estudo divide-se em três artigos complementares. O primeiro traz a problematização e a revisão bibliográfica. O segundo busca identificar o que os professores pensam acerca do movimento renovador, bem como analisar características acadêmicas e profissionais-interventivas. Os resultados do artigo 2 apontam que os professores parecem conhecer, se alinham e afirmam ministrar aulas em acordo com as propostas renovadoras, mas possuem ambientes e condições de trabalho distintas. O terceiro artigo traz a análise de 20 aulas de EFE dos cinco professores, a partir de uma ficha de observação sistemática composta por indicadores didático-metodológicos sugeridos por Resende e Nascimento (2004), além da discussão de uma entrevista sobre questões didáticas e metodológicas e críticas às intervenções. Percebeu-se que, apesar de intervenções com características distintas, a maioria das ações intervetivas se aproximou dos indicadores nas categorias planejamento, objetivo, conteúdo, método, avaliação e relação professor-aluno. Todos os professores fizeram críticas às aulas, acreditando que estas deveriam ser melhores e diferentes do que frequentemente são, o que representa limitações do campo interventivo e o compromisso dos professores com a qualidade da intervenção. Acredita-se que os dados deste estudo representam mais um pequeno passo às discussões e construções de práticas renovadoras no campo da EFE, ao buscar e apontar possibilidades, limitações e exemplos de ações didáticas concretas do cotidiano.

Le rôle et l'influence de la relation élève-enseignant sur l'adaptation scolaire et sociale des élèves dans les écoles primaires québécoises

Cette étude explore pour la première fois auprès d'une population québécoise le lien existant entre la qualité de la relation élève-enseignant (REE) et l'adaptation scolaire d'élèves ayant un trouble du comportement. La qualité du lien affectif des 80 élèves participants est étudiée sous l'angle de la théorie de l'attachement et mesurée à l'aide du STRS (Student-Teacher Relationship Scale) ainsi que du TSRI (Teacher-Student Relationship Inventory). Des analyses de corrélation font ressortir de nombreux liens entre la qualité de la REE et les variables d'adaptation scolaire utilisées: la compétence académique (notes et habitudes de travail), les habiletés sociales/ appréciation par les pairs, les problèmes de comportement extériorisés, puis finalement, la motivation/satisfaction scolaire de l'élève. De plus, la qualité de la REE en fin d'année scolaire a été comparée selon la fréquentation de l'élève à l'un ou l'autre des services: 1) des classes spéciales traditionnelles (N=30) et 2) des classes kangourou, dont la philosophie est axée sur l'établissement d'une REE positive (N=50). Les résultats de cette comparaison indiquent peu de différence significative dans l'évolution des élèves selon les deux services et pas de différence au niveau de la qualité de la REE pour cet échantillon.

Indisciplina na sala de aula: a perspetiva de professores do 3º Ciclo do Ensino Básico e do Ensino Secundário

Dissertação apresentada à Escola Superior de Educação de Lisboa para obtenção de grau de mestre em Ciências da Educação

Symptômes dépressifs et consommation problématique de substances psychoactives : effets modérateurs du contexte social

Seulement une minorité d’adolescents qui consomment des substances psychoactives développe des problèmes significatifs reliés à cette consommation. Il importe donc de connaître et de comprendre les processus par lesquels se développe la consommation problématique afin de pouvoir la prévenir. Cette étude examine le rôle des symptômes dépressifs et des relations sociales dans le développement de la consommation problématique à l’adolescence. Plus précisément, elle vise à déterminer, à l’aide d’un devis longitudinal corrélationnel prospectif, si le soutien des pairs, le soutien des parents et la qualité de la relation maître-élève ont des effets modérateurs protecteurs sur la relation entre les symptômes dépressifs et la consommation problématique. L’échantillon utilisé pour cette étude est tiré de la Stratégie d’Intervention Agir Autrement et comprend 4473 adolescents. Des régressions linéaires multiples ont été effectuées et ont démontré que les symptômes dépressifs et le soutien des parents augmentent le risque d’une consommation problématique, alors que le soutien des pairs le diminue. De plus, les résultats confirment le rôle protecteur du soutien des pairs, mais indiquent que le soutien des parents exacerbe le lien entre les symptômes dépressifs et la consommation problématique. Par ailleurs, la qualité de la relation maître-élève est associée à une consommation moins problématique uniquement chez les jeunes qui n’ont pas beaucoup de symptômes dépressifs. Les implications de ces résultats sont discutées.

L’incidence de la relation maître-élève sur la motivation d’élèves du primaire provenant de milieux défavorisés

Cette étude avait pour but de vérifier l’incidence de la relation maître-élève sur la motivation des élèves particulièrement en milieux défavorisés. Notre hypothèse stipulait que meilleure est la relation maître-élève, plus grande est la motivation de l’élève. Nos objectifs étaient d’analyser la valeur prédictive de la relation maître-élève sur les déterminants de la motivation scolaire afin d’identifier quels aspects de la relation maître-élève, dans une perspective d’attachement (chaleur, soutien ou conflit), prédisent le mieux chacune des variables motivationnelles retenues. Aussi, nous voulions identifier quelles variables motivationnelles sont les plus affectées par la qualité de la relation maître-élève. La motivation scolaire a été évaluée à deux niveaux soit général et spécifique au français et aux mathématiques. Certains des déterminants retenus sont en lien avec les modèles Attentes-Valeur (le sentiment de compétence, l’intérêt et la perception de l’utilité de l’école en général ainsi qu’en français et en mathématiques). Les autres déterminants retenus sont en lien avec la théorie des buts d’accomplissement (le but de maîtrise, le but de performance et le but d’évitement du travail). Nous avons aussi vérifié l’effet modérateur du sexe dans les relations entre les variables d’attachement et la motivation. Nos résultats montrent que la relation maître-élève prédit avec assurance l’intérêt général envers l’école, l’intérêt spécifique au français et aux mathématiques ainsi que la présence de buts d’évitement du travail. Nous avons aussi été en mesure de déterminer qu’une relation soutenante serait l’aspect de la relation maître-élève qui prédirait la présence du plus grand nombre de déterminants de la motivation scolaire. Il a aussi été surprenant de constater l’effet de la relation chaleureuse sur les trois dimensions en lien avec l’intérêt (général, en français et en mathématiques). De son côté, l’intérêt général fut aussi remarqué comme étant le déterminant motivationnel étant le mieux prédit par la relation maître-élève. Nous avons aussi fait ressortir que la perception de conflit serait l’aspect de la relation maître-élève qui présenterait la plus grande valeur prédictive de certains déterminants de la motivation. Par contre, nos résultats ne permettent pas de supporter que le sexe de l’élève a un effet modérateur dans les relations.

Préparation à l'école et engagement scolaire : le rôle médiateur de la relation maître-élève

Bien que les facteurs de risque associés au faible engagement scolaire aient été largement étudiés, les mécanismes qui conduisent les enfants moins bien préparés pour l’école à se désengager dès le début de leur parcours scolaire demeurent méconnus. Une meilleure compréhension de ces mécanismes permettrait de prévenir le désinvestissement de ces élèves et favoriserait leur persévérance scolaire. Étant donné l’importance des relations sociales en début de scolarisation, la présente étude a pour objectif d’examiner dans quelle mesure la relation que l’élève entretient avec son enseignant en première année peut expliquer le lien entre la préparation à l’école en maternelle et l’engagement scolaire en deuxième année. Des régressions linéaires multiples hiérarchiques réalisées sur un échantillon de 1492 élèves québécois ont permis de vérifier cette hypothèse. Les résultats obtenus confirment que la relation maître-élève chaleureuse et conflictuelle permet d’expliquer le niveau d’engagement des élèves qui présentent une faible préparation à l’école lorsqu’ils entrent à la maternelle. Les implications pour la recherche et la pratique des intervenants en milieu scolaire seront discutées.