Tendering ethics : a study of collusive tendering from a marketing perspective

This thesis provides a behavioural perspective to the problem of collusive tendering in the construction market by examining the decision making factors of individuals potentially involved in such agreements using marketing ethics theory and techniques. The findings of a cross disciplinary literature review were synthesised into a model of factors theoretically expected to determine the individual's behavioural intent towards a set of collusive tendering agreements and the means of reaching them. The factors were grouped as internal cognitive (the individuals' value systems) and affective (demographic and psychographic characteristics) as well as external environmental (legal, industrial and organisational codes and norms) and situational (company, market and economic conditions). The model was tested using empirical data collected through a questionnaire survey of estimators employed in the largest Australian construction firms. All forms of explicit collusive tendering agreements were considered as having a prohibitive moral content by the majority of respondents who also clearly differentiated between agreements and discussions of contract terms (which they found to be a moral concern but not prohibitive) or of prices. The comparisons between those of the respondents that would never participate in a collusive agreement and the potential offenders clearly showed two distinctly different groups. The law abiding estimators are less reliant on situational factors, happier and more comfortable in their work environments and they live according to personal value and belief systems. The potential offenders on the other hand are mistrustful of colleagues, feel their values are not respected, put company priorities above principles and none of them is religious or a member of a professional body. The research results indicate that Australian estimators are, overall law abiding and principled and accept the existing codification of collusion as morally defensible and binding. Professional bodies' and organisational codes of conduct as well as personal value and belief systems that guide one's own conduct appear to be deterrents to collusive tendering intent and so are moral comfort and work satisfaction. These observations are potential indicators of areas where intervention and behaviour modification can increase individuals' resistance to collusion.

The attack of the clones: Patent law and stem cell research

This article considers the integral role played by patent law in respect of stem cell research. It highlights concerns about commercialization, access to essential medicines and bioethics. The article maintains that there is a fundamental ambiguity in the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) as to whether stem cell research is patentable subject matter. There is a need to revise the legislation in light of the establishment of the National Stem Cell Centre and the passing of the Research Involving Embryos Act 2002 (Cth). The article raises concerns about the strong patent protection secured by the Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation and Geron Corporation in respect of stem cell research in the United States. It contends that a number of legal reforms could safeguard access to stem cell lines, and resulting drugs and therapies. Finally, this article explores how ethical concerns are addressed within the framework of the European Biotechnology Directive. It examines the decision of the European Patent Office in relation to the so-called Edinburgh patent, and the inquiry of the European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technologies into The Ethical Aspects of Patenting Involving Human Stem Cells.

Australia’s first Allied Health Prescribing Program - exploring participants' perspectives on the study program's learning objectives

BACKGROUND The Queensland University of Technology in collaboration with Queensland Health pioneered development of the Allied Health Prescribing Training Program to assist allied health professionals (AHPs) to competently prescribe medicines within their scope of practice. The study program consisted of two modules: Introduction to Clinical Therapeutics for Prescribers and Prescribing and Quality Use of Medicines. METHODS Pre- and post- surveys were developed for both modules. Key themes explored were understanding and confidence in selecting therapeutic choices for patients. For module 2 the learning objectives for safe and effective prescribing were investigated. Data were collected from participants in weeks one and thirteen of the modules via online surveys. RESULTS In the pre-module survey for the first module, participants had a limited degree of understanding and confidence regarding safe and effective use of medicines and appropriate therapeutic choices for managing patients, particularly for complex patients. This improved significantly in the post-module survey. In the pre-module survey for module 2, participants had a moderate degree of understanding and confidence regarding various prescribing learning objectives (including safe and effective prescribing, professional, legal and ethical aspects, communicating medication orders, prescribing safely in their select areas of practice, prescribing safely for complex patients in their area of practice). This increased significantly in the post-module survey. DISCUSSION This training program was implemented to develop a framework of knowledge and skills for AHPs to undertake a prescribing role. The program delivered an increase in participants’ knowledge in the key prescribing areas; and increased participants’ confidence in prescribing safely for patients and for complex patients in their select practice areas. An important aspect of this program was inclusion of prescribing–related activities under supervision of a designated medical practitioner. In conclusion, this educational program for Queensland Health AHP prescribers was successfully developed and is in the final stages of delivery.

Groundwater Management in India:Physical, Institutional and Policy Alternatives

Groundwater constitutes a vital natural resource for sustaining India’s agricultural economy and meeting the country’s social, ecological and environmental goals. It is a unique resource, widely available, providing security against droughts and yet it is closely linked to surface-water resources and the hydrological cycle. Its availability depends on geo-hydrological conditions and characteristics of aquifers, from deep to alluvium, sediment crystalline rocks to basalt formations; and agro-climate from humid to subhumid and semi-arid to arid. Its reliable supply, uniform quality and temperature, relative turbidity, pollution-safe, minimal evaporation losses, and low cost of development are attributes making groundwater more attractive compared to other resources. It plays a key role in the provision of safe drinking water to rural populations. For example, already almost 80% of domestic water use in rural areas in India is groundwater-supplied, and much of it is being supplied to farms, villages and small towns. Inadequate control of the use of groundwater, indiscriminate application of agrochemicals and unrestrained pollution of the rural environment by other human activities make groundwater usage unsustainable, necessitating proper management in the face of the twin demand for water of good quality for domestic supply and adequate supply for irrigation, ensuring equity, efficiency and sustainability of the resource. Groundwater irrigation has overtaken surface irrigation in the early 1980s, supported by well energization. It is estimated that there are about 24 million energised wells and tube wells now and it is driven by demand rather than availability, evident through the greater occurrence of wells in districts with high population densities. Apart from aquifer characteristics, land fragmentation and landholding size are the factors that decide the density of wells. The ‘rise and fall’ of local economies dependent on groundwater can be summarized as: the green revolution of 1980s, groundwaterbased agrarian boom, early symptoms of groundwater overdraft, and decline of the groundwater socio-ecology. The social characteristics and policy interventions typical of each stage provide a fascinating insight into the human-resource dynamics. This book is a compilation of nine research papers discussing various aspects of groundwater management. It attempts to integrate knowledge about the physical system, the socio-economic system, the institutional set-up and the policy environment to come out with a more realistic analysis of the situation with regard to the nature, characteristics and intensity of resource use, the size of the economy the use generates, and the negative socioeconomic consequences. Complex variables addressed in this regard focusing on northern Gujarat are the stock of groundwater available in the region, its hydrodynamics, its net outflows against inflows, the economics of its intensive use (particularly irrigation in semi-arid and arid regions), its criticality in the regional hydroecological regime, ethical aspects and social aspects of its use. The first chapter by Dinesh Kumar and Singh, dwells on complex groundwater socio-ecology of India, while emphasizing the need for policy measures to address indiscriminate over-exploitation of dwindling resources. The chapter also explores the nature of groundwater economy and the role of electricity prices on it. The next chapter on groundwater issue in north Gujarat provides a description of groundwater resource characteristics followed by a detailed analysis of the groundwater depletion and quality deterioration problems in the region and their undesirable consequences on the economy, ecosystem health and the society. Considering water-buyers and wellowning farmers individually, a methodology for economic valuation of groundwater in regions where its primary usage is in agriculture, and as assessment of the groundwater economy based on case studies from north Gujarat is presented in the fourth chapter. The next chapter focuses on the extent of dependency of milk production on groundwater, which includes the water embedded in green and dry fodder and animal feed. The study made a realistic estimate of irrigation water productivity in terms of the physics and economics of milk production. The sixth chapter analyses the extent of reduction in water usage, increase in yield and overall increase in physical productivity of alfalfa with the use of the drip irrigation system. The chapter also provides a detailed synthesis of the costs and benefits associated with the use of drip irrigation systems. A linear programmingbased optimization model with the objective to minimize groundwater use taking into account the interaction between two distinct components – farming and dairying under the constraints of food security and income stability for different scenarios, including shift in cropping pattern, introduction of water-efficient crops, water- saving technologies in addition to the ‘business as usual’ scenario is presented in the seventh chapter. The results show that sustaining dairy production in the region with reduced groundwater draft requires crop shifts and adoption of water-saving technologies. The eighth chapter provides evidences to prove that the presence of adequate economic incentive would encourage farmers to adopt water-saving irrigation devices, based on the findings of market research with reference to the level of awareness among farmers of technologies and the factors that decide the adoption of water-saving technologies. However, now the marginal cost of using electricity for agricultural pumping is almost zero. The economic incentives are strong and visible only when the farmers are either water-buyers or have to manage irrigation with limited water from tube-well partnerships. The ninth chapter explores the socio-economic viability of increasing the power tariff and inducing groundwater rationing as a tool for managing energy and groundwater demand, considering the current estimate of the country’s annual economic loss of Rs 320 billion towards electricity subsidy in the farm sector. The tenth chapter suggests private tradable property rights and development of water markets as the institutional tool for achieving equity, efficiency and sustainability of groundwater use. It identifies the externalities for local groundwater management and emphasizes the need for managing groundwater by local user groups, supported by a thorough analysis of groundwater socio-ecology in India. An institutional framework for managing the resource based on participatory approach that is capable of internalizing the externalities, comprising implementation of institutional and technical alternatives for resource management is also presented. Major findings of the analyses and key arguments in each chapter are summarized in the concluding chapter. Case studies of the social and economic benefits of groundwater use, where that use could be described as unsustainable, are interesting. The benefits of groundwater use are outlined and described with examples of social and economic impacts of groundwater and the negative aspects of groundwater development with the compilation of environmental problems based on up-to-date research results. This publication with a well-edited compilation of case studies is informative and constitutes a useful publication for students and professionals.

Técnicas de tratamiento de la esterilidad : aspectos tecnológicos y éticos abordados en el Informe Warnock

El Informe Warnock aborda parte de los problemas que surgen a partir del diagnóstico de esterilidad, tanto para los individuos como para toda la sociedad. Justifica el recurso de técnicas para solucionar la imposibilidad de concebir. Se describen los distintos procedimientos dando las recomendaciones para cada una de las técnicas empleadas hasta el momento: inseminación artificial (homóloga y heteróloga), fecundación in vitro, donación de óvulos y embriones, útero subrogado. Aborda el uso extendido de las técnicas de tratamiento de la esterilidad para otros fines: evitar la transmisión de enfermedades hereditarias y selección de sexo. Asimismo, realiza sugerencias para una práctica correcta en todos los procedimientos y propone seguimientos y revisiones. En paralelo al análisis exhaustivo de la Comisión Warnock, se actualizan los datos procedimentales, evaluando los aspectos éticos y la eficiencia de algunas técnicas.

Aspectos bioéticos del trasplante con donantes vivos

Resumen: El 4 de junio de 2010 se solicita al Comité de Bioética del Hospital Privado de Córdoba, Argentina, una consulta para que se analicen los aspectos éticos de un trasplante pulmonar lobar bilateral, con donante vivo relacionado para dos hermanas gemelas de 17 años con diagnóstico de fibrosis quística (Acta 172). Este caso nos permite revisar dos ejes esenciales de la constitución de la Bioética como son las funciones y actuación de los comités de Bioética en las instituciones hospitalarias, y la licitud de los trasplantes de órganos cuando hay donantes vivos. Se justificará la actuación del Comité de Bioética en este caso, analizando los puntos a tener en cuenta y los recaudos y recomendaciones que habrían de considerarse frente a esta situación planteada.

Enfermagem cuidando do recém-nascido na Unidade de Terapia Intensiva Neonatal: um olhar ético da ação profissional

Trata-se de um estudo do tipo qualitativo, sobre as ações experienciadas pela equipe de enfermagem no cotidiano da Unidade de Terapia Intensiva Neonatal (UTI Neonatal), tendo como objetivo apreender os aspectos éticos implícitos nas ações experienciadas pelos profissionais de enfermagem ao cuidar do recém-nascido (RN). Foram utilizados como referencial teórico-filosófico alguns autores renomados como: Mehry, Pegoraro, Pessini, entre outros. A abordagem metodológica aplicada no estudo foi a fenomenologia sociológica de Alfred Schutz, buscando, na intencionalidade das ações de enfermagem, a motivação que sustenta este cuidar. A aproximação face a face aos sujeitos do estudo deu-se solicitando o seguinte: Fale-me sobre a sua experiência ao cuidar de um RN no cotidiano da UTI. Para alcançar o objetivo proposto, utilizei as questões orientadoras da entrevista fenomenológica: O que você tem em vista ao cuidar do RN na UTI? Em relação à ética, o que você pensa ao cuidar do RN? As entrevistas foram realizadas com 16 profissionais da equipe de enfermagem da UTI de uma Maternidade Pública do Município do Rio de Janeiro, escolhidos de forma aleatória. Foram respeitados os critérios estabelecidos pela Resolução n 196/96, garantindo a privacidade e o anonimato dos entrevistados, bem como aprovação do estudo pelo comitê de ética em pesquisa. A partir da análise das falas emergiram três categorias, que possibilitaram a apreensão dos aspectos éticos das ações de enfermagem na UTI como um típico. Esses profissionais têm em vista realizar o melhor cuidado desejando a cura e a alta do RN, apoiando-se na tecnologia para valorizar a perspectiva humana do cuidado na UTI e na possibilidade de agir com ética. Na realidade pesquisada, a tecnologia manifestou-se de maneira positiva no projeto intencional dos profissionais, mostrando uma enfermagem que acredita estar fazendo o seu melhor, envolvida com as questões éticas e humanas. A apreensão do típico da ação e compreensão do cotidiano da equipe de enfermagem permitirá uma avaliação crítica e reflexiva sobre a adequação da tecnologia no cuidado neonatal, bem como a adoção de medidas e estratégias que valorizem e respeitem a vida humana em toda a sua dimensão. Ratifica a sensibilidade, intuição e percepção do cuidador, propiciando um cuidado individualizado e personalizado ao RN e sua família. Além disso, contribui para se repensar novas maneiras de cuidar, utilizando a arte e a criatividade na adequação e humanização das tecnologias.

Sobre repercussões de atividades extensionistas na construção de valores e virtudes durante a formação em medicina.

A questão central que norteou este estudo relaciona-se às dimensões político-pedagógicas das atividades extensionistas. No sentido de investigar maneiras pelas quais a Extensão Universitária pode colaborar para a formação de um senso ético para a atuação no setor saúde, em consonância com os princípios do SUS, nos debruçamos especificamente sobre narrativas de estudantes de medicina acerca suas experiências em ações extensionistas para compreender acerca do desenvolvimento de valores e virtudes condizentes com a prática do cuidado integral em saúde. Afirmando o caráter sócio-filosófico desta pesquisa, optamos pelo referencial teórico de Hannah Arendt, num desafio epistemológico de fazer dialogar Filosofia e Saúde Coletiva. Tal estratégia mostrou-se coerente com a escolha metodológica de utilizar a narrativa como substância para análise e discussão a que este estudo se propunha, pois, desse modo, foi possível atentar-nos à humanidade das experiências narradas, às histórias e às memórias, valorizando os significados das experiências formativas atribuídos pelos sujeitos. Foram construídas dez narrativas sobre experiências de formação e de participação em ações extensionistas, seguindo o procedimento metodológico de gravação das entrevistas em profundidade, transcrição dos áudios, transcriação e validação das narrativas pelos próprios sujeitos narradores. De estratégia metodológica, a utilização de narrativas constituiu espaço importante na análise dos dados empíricos, sendo possível afirmar que a participação em atividades de extensão universitária possibilitou o exercício de certa competência narrativa como ferramenta que aponta para o cuidado integral em saúde. Um fenômeno que ganhou espaço nas narrativas aponta para o surgimento e organização das Ligas Acadêmicas na FCMUERJ. Assinalamos para a necessidade de que haja um permanente zelo institucional em relação à criação e manejo das Ligas. Se, por um lado, essas possuem potencialidades em termos do processo formativo, por outro é preciso atentar para o provimento aos estudantes de espaços de reflexão crítica sobre as ações das Ligas e permitir que essas ações estejam em conformidade com as propostas político-pedagógicas da instituição. Perscrutando as narrativas em seus aspectos éticos, foi possível inferir que, ao participar de atividades extensionistas, o estudante desenvolve, para além de uma competência narrativa, a possibilidade de alargar sua imaginação e seu pensamento num exercício de reconhecimento do outro. O desenvolvimento dessa virtude não se opera simplesmente por meio da empatia, mas pela possibilidade de trazer à faculdade do pensamento o ponto de vista, a cultura, a experiência de sofrimento do outro. Concluímos com a aposta numa extensão universitária enquanto espaço potente para radicalizar a educação como processo político de produção de subjetividades.

Condições de trabalho e saúde do enfermeiro residente no hospital geral: riscos psicossociais

Objetivou-se nesse estudo identificar os fatores de risco psicossocial que o enfermeiro residente encontra-se exposto em unidades especializadas; descrever as repercussões dos fatores de risco psicossocial para a saúde do enfermeiro residente em unidades especializadas e analisar as formas de enfrentamento adotadas pelo enfermeiro residente diante dos riscos psicossociais em unidades especializadas. Pesquisa qualitativa do tipo exploratória descritiva, cujo campo foi um hospital universitário situado no município do Rio de Janeiro. A partir dos critérios de seleção adotados participaram do estudo 20 enfermeiros residentes do 1 e 2 anos, lotados em unidades especializadas (CTI adulto, UTI neonatal, CTI cardíaco, UI clínica, Unidade Coronariana e Unidade de Doenças Infecto Parasitárias). O estudo obedeceu aos aspectos éticos em conformidade com a Resolução 466/12 sendo aprovado pelo Comitê de Ética em Pesquisa (067/2012). Utilizou-se a técnica de entrevista semiestruturada mediante um instrumento contendo em sua primeira parte as características dos sujeitos e na segunda um roteiro com questões abertas que possibilitaram ao residente falar sobre os riscos no ambiente laboral, o modo como era afetado e os mecanismos de enfrentamento adotados. Ao término das entrevistas, realizadas no segundo semestre de 2012 e registradas em meio digital, aplicou-se a técnica de análise de conteúdo, sendo os resultados discutidos a luz da Psicodinâmica do Trabalho. Os resultados evidenciaram que o enfermeiro residente de unidades especializadas encontra-se exposto a inúmeros fatores de risco psicossocial e entre eles: a sobrecarga física e psíquica do trabalho, a ambiguidade de papéis, o relacionamento interpessoal conflituoso, a pouca autonomia, o baixo controle em relação ao processo de trabalho e a precariedade das condições de trabalho. Tais fatores, além de afetarem o processo de formação do residente, acarretam prejuízos a sua saúde física e mental; identificados a partir de queixas como: cansaço, estresse, desgaste, padrão de sono ruim, problemas gastrintestinais, dermatológicos e osteomusculares. Diante do sofrimento no trabalho, o enfermeiro residente elabora estratégias de manejo centradas na emoção (autocontrole, aceitação das responsabilidades, fuga, confronto e resignação) e no problema (negociação, tentativa de solução, suporte social, reavaliação positiva). Concluiu-se que o enfermeiro residente encontra-se exposto a inúmeros fatores de risco psicossocial em unidades especializadas que afetam a sua saúde física e mental. No intuito de concluir a residência e preservar a saúde, o residente elabora estratégias de manejo, que apesar de essenciais não eliminam o sofrimento no trabalho e os problemas vivenciados no dia a dia. Cabe ao órgão formador identificar, monitorar e combater os riscos referidos pelo residente no intuito de promover a capacitação, a satisfação e o bem estar no trabalho, ao se considerar a responsabilidade social pela formação, saúde e inserção do futuro profissional no mercado de trabalho.

O naruszaniu podstawowych zasad postępowania naukowego. “Wzgórze przeznaczenia archeologii” górą skandalu

„We are paying a high price for the increasingly unequivocal equation drawn between knowledge and science and ordinary market product. The ideal of perfectly unrestrained cognition, the true mother of science, is threatened by the mass drive towards practical use and application of knowledge, a looming departure into nothingness. Politicians and managers of scientific life are guilty of considerable contribution in corrupting respectable university structures, and thus undermining culture of science and scholarly ethics. (…). Acquisition of funds, sponsorship, media presence, popularisation or even striving for commercial gain are recognised by politicians and scientific consultants, but most of all they are accepted by the university management as objectives worthy of effort, not to say the foremost goals of science. University rectors are nowadays interested primarily in the amounts of acquired moneys. The outcomes of research thus financed is subject to virtually no control, nor does it arouse any interest, unless it turns out to be fit to be announced in the media as a sensation, thereby serving the ‘prestige’ of the university”.

Does the existing Corporate Governance structure and strict Legal Framework, affect the strategic decisionmaking of CEOs?

This thesis is a case study on Corporate Governance and Business Ethics, using the Portuguese Corporate Law as a general setting. The thesis was conducted in Portugal with illustrations on past cases under the Business Judgment Rule of the State of Delaware, U.SA along with illustrations on current cases in Portugal under the Portuguese Judicial setting, along with a comparative analysis between both. A debate is being considered among scholars and executives; a debate on best practices within corporate governance and corporate law, associated with recent discoveries of unlawful investments that lead to the bankruptcy of leading institutions and an aggravation of the crisis in Portugal. The study aimed at learning possible reasons and causes for the current situation of the country’s corporations along with attempts to discover the best way to move forward. From the interviews and analysis conducted, this paper concluded that the corporate governance structure and legal frameworks in Portugal were not the sole influencers behind the actions and decisions of Corporate Executives, nor were they the main triggers for the recent corporate mishaps. But it is rather a combination of different factors that played a significant role, such as cultural and ethical aspects, individual personalities, and others all of which created gray areas beyond the legal structure, which in turn accelerated and aggravated the corporate governance crisis in the country.

Utilitarianism and Buddist ethics: a comparative approach to the ethics of animal research

This thesis explores the comparison utilitarianism and Buddhist ethics as they can be applied to animal research. It begins by examining some of the general discussions surrounding the use of animals in research. The historical views on the moral status of animals, the debate surrounding their use in animals, as well as the current 3R paradigm and its application in Canadian research are explored. The thesis then moves on to expound the moral system of utilitarianism as put forth by Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, as well as contemporary additions to the system. It also looks at the basics of Buddhist ethics well distinguishing the Mahayana from the Therevada. Three case studies in animal research are used to explore how both systems can be applied to animal research. It then offers a comparison as to how both ethical systems function within the field of animal research and explores the implications in their application on its practice.