A Study of the State of the Art of Process Planning for Additive Manufacturing

In the manufacturing industry the term Process Planning (PP) is concerned with determining the sequence of individual manufacturing operations needed to produce a given part or product with a certain machine. In this technical report we propose a preliminary analysis of scientific literature on the topic of process planning for Additive Manufacturing (AM) technologies (i.e. 3D printing). We observe that the process planning for additive manufacturing processes consists of a small set of standard operations (repairing, orientation, supports, slicing and toolpath generation). We analyze each of them in order to emphasize the most critical aspects of the current pipeline as well as highlight the future challenges for this emerging manufacturing technology.

A MARKET-BASED APPROACH TO 3D PRINTING FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN GHANA

The purpose of this report is to create the foundation for further study of a market-based approach to 3D printing as an instrument for economic development in Ghana. The delivery of improved products and services to the most underserved markets is needed to spur economic activity and improve standards of living. The relationship between economic development and the advancement of technology is considered within the context of Ghana. An opportunity for market entry exists within both the bottom of the economic pyramid and the mid-segment market. 3D printing (additive manufacturing) has proven to be a disruptive technology that has demonstrated an ability to expedite the speed of innovations and create products that were previously not possible. An investigation of how 3D printers can be used to create improved products for the most underserved markets within Ghana is presented. Questions are asked to elucidate how and when adoption of 3D printers and 3D printed products may occur in the future. Based upon the existing barriers to adoption, 3D printing technology must improve before widespread adoption will occur in Ghana.

Processing and additive manufacturing of bones for the teaching of human anatomy

Traditionally, the teaching of human anatomy in health sciences has been based on the use of cadaveric material and bone parts for practical study. The bone materials get deteriorated and hardly mark the points of insertion of muscles. However, the advent of new technologies for 3D printing and creation of 3D anatomical models applied to teaching, has enabled to overcome these problems making teaching more dynamic, realistic and attractive. This paper presents some examples of the construction of three-dimensional models of bone samples, designed using 3D scanners for posterior printing with addition printers or polymer injection printers.

Advanced Functional Organic-Inorganic Hybrid (Nano)Materials: from Theranostics to Organic Electronics and Additive Manufacturing

This work is going to show the activities performed in the frame of my PhD studies at the University of Bologna, under the supervision of Prof. Mauro Comes Franchini, at the Department of Industrial Chemistry “Toso Montanari”. The main topic of this dissertation will be the study of organic-inorganic hybrid nanostructures and materials for advanced applications in different fields of materials technology and development such as theranostics, organic electronics and additive manufacturing, also known as 3D printing. This work is therefore divided into three chapters, that recall the fundamentals of each subject and to recap the state-of-the-art of scientific research around each topic. In each chapter, the published works and preliminary results obtained during my PhD career will be discussed in detail.

L'additive manufacturing nel planning pre-operatorio in chirurgia maxillofacciale

Il 3D printing è presente da tempo in molti settori economici e da sempre ha nella sanità uno dei principali ambiti di applicazione. Durante il corso del presente lavoro sono state esaminate le principali applicazioni in campo sanitario con particolare focus sulla fase di planning in caso di chirurgia complessa. La pianificazione risulta essere la fase maggiormente impattante nel contesto più globale di gestione del paziente in quanto una maggior accuratezza nella visualizzazione del caso clinico consente di ottimizzare l’identificazione di un adeguato approccio chirurgico con ovvie conseguenti ripercussioni positive sulla totalità della degenza del paziente all’interno della struttura clinica ospitante. Nel dettaglio è stato valutato l’utilizzo di un innovativo protocollo di pre-planning e follow-up operatorio tramite la realizzazione di modelli stampati 3D a partire da immagini di diagnostica classica (TAC, MRI, 3Dscan) che hanno consentito di poter fornire allo specialista clinico di riferimento un prodotto che riproducendo perfettamente l’anatomia del soggetto (morfologia-proprietà fisiche del tessuto) ha consentito allo stesso un miglioramento delle usuali pratiche chirurgiche e terapeutiche in casi di elevata complessità in un arco temporale ristretto. I parametri utilizzati per la valutazione dei reali benefici dell’approccio esposto sono stati: tempi di pianificazione chirurgica e tempi di intervento all’interno di una più globale analisi dei costi associati. A fronte di un’indagine interna preventiva presso l’azienda ospedaliera ospitante sono stati designati i seguenti reparti come settori pilota: maxillofacciale, neurochirurgia e radiologia interventistica. Lo studio è stato svolto in collaborazione con l’ospedale M.Bufalini di Cesena in qualità di referente clinico e l’azienda Aid4Med Srl in qualità di azienda leader in pianificazione operatoria tramite ausili realizzati tramite tecniche di additive manufacturing.

Computational design of a new type of sandwich cross-section for a defined solution of a tree-like column produced by wire-and-arc additive manufacturing

When it comes to designing a structure, architects and engineers want to join forces in order to create and build the most beautiful and efficient building. From finding new shapes and forms to optimizing the stability and the resistance, there is a constant link to be made between both professions. In architecture, there has always been a particular interest in creating new shapes and types of a structure inspired by many different fields, one of them being nature itself. In engineering, the selection of optimum has always dictated the way of thinking and designing structures. This mindset led through studies to the current best practices in construction. However, both disciplines were limited by the traditional manufacturing constraints at a certain point. Over the last decades, much progress was made from a technological point of view, allowing to go beyond today's manufacturing constraints. With the emergence of Wire-and-Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) combined with Algorithmic-Aided Design (AAD), architects and engineers are offered new opportunities to merge architectural beauty and structural efficiency. Both technologies allow for exploring and building unusual and complex structural shapes in addition to a reduction of costs and environmental impacts. Through this study, the author wants to make use of previously mentioned technologies and assess their potential, first to design an aesthetically appreciated tree-like column with the idea of secondly proposing a new type of standardized and optimized sandwich cross-section to the construction industry. Parametric algorithms to model the dendriform column and the new sandwich cross-section are developed and presented in detail. A catalog draft of the latter and methods to establish it are then proposed and discussed. Finally, the buckling behavior of this latter is assessed considering standard steel and WAAM material properties.

Benchmarking di sistemi di additive manufacturing in termini di precisione di forma con ispirazione al sistema GD&T

Questo studio si pone come obiettivo lo sviluppo e la sperimentazione di un metodo per eseguire un benchmarking di due diversi sistemi di Additive Manufacturing mediante macchina di misura a coordinate Renishaw Cyclone. In particolare sono valutate le prestazioni in termini di precisione di forma di un sistema di tipo FDM e di uno di tipo PolyJet al fine di ottenere dati indicanti le potenzialità di queste due tecnologie per parti di piccole dimensioni. Dopo un’introduzione generale sull’Additive Manufacturing, si scende nei dettagli delle due tecniche oggetto dello studio e si discute di come strutturare il piano sperimentale in funzione degli obiettivi dell’attività e dei metodi scelti per l’acquisizione e la valutazione dei dati. Si parte, infatti, con la fabbricazione di un modello di benchmark, le cui geometrie vengono poi rilevate tramite una macchina di misura a coordinate per ottenere i valori di precisione di forma, che sono presentati come tolleranze geometriche del sistema GD&T. Successivamente, si descrivono tutte le fasi dell’attività sperimentale, iniziando con l’ideazione del modello di benchmark e proseguendo con i processi di fabbricazione e misurazione, per poi arrivare alla deduzione dei valori di precisione di forma tramite un post-processing dei dati. Infine, si presentano i valori di tolleranza ottenuti e si traggono le conclusioni riguardo la riuscita dell’attività sperimentale e il confronto tra le due tecnologie di Additive Manufacturing.

Design, fabrication and mechanical characterization of a structural node made using Wire and Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) technology

Additive Manufacturing (AM), also known as “3D printing”, is a recent production technique that allows the creation of three-dimensional elements by depositing multiple layers of material. This technology is widely used in various industrial sectors, such as automotive, aerospace and aviation. With AM, it is possible to produce particularly complex elements for which traditional techniques cannot be used. These technologies are not yet widespread in the civil engineering sector, which is slowly changing thanks to the advantages of AM, such as the possibility of realizing elements without geometric restrictions, with less material usage and a higher efficiency, in particular employing Wire-and-Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) technology. Buildings that benefit most from AM are all those structures designed using form-finding and free-form techniques. These include gridshells, where joints are the most critical and difficult elements to design, as the overall behaviour of the structure depends on them. It must also be considered that, during the design, the engineer must try to minimize the structure's own weight. Self-weight reductions can be achieved by Topological Optimization (TO) of the joint itself, which generates complex geometries that could not be made using traditional techniques. To sum up, weight reductions through TO combined with AM allow for several potential benefits, including economic ones. In this thesis, the roof of the British Museum is considered as a case study, analysing the gridshell structure of which a joint will be chosen to be designed and manufactured, using TO and WAAM techniques. Then, the designed joint will be studied in order to understand its structural behaviour in terms of stiffness and strength. Finally, a printing test will be performed to assess the production feasibility using WAAM technology. The computational design and fabrication stages were carried out at Technische Universität Braunschweig in Germany.

Calibration of design strength values of Wire and Arc Additive Manufacturing inclined bars and intersections

Although being studied only for few years, Wire and Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) will become the predominant way of producing stainless-steel elements in a near-like future. The analysis and study of such elements has yet to be defined in a proper way, but the projects regarding this subject are innovating more and more thanks to the findings discovered by the latter. This thesis is focused on an initial stage on the analysis of mechanical and geometrical properties of such stainless-steel elements produced by MX3D laboratories in Amsterdam, and to perform a calibration of the design strength values by means of Annex D of Eurocode 0, which talks about the analysis of the semi-probabilistic safety factors, hence the definition of characteristic values. Moreover, after testing the stainless-steel specimens by means of strain gauges and after obtaining mechanical and geometrical properties, a statistical analysis of such properties and an evaluation of characteristic values is performed. After this, there is to execute the calibration of design strength values of WAAM inclined bars and intersections.

Katsaus lisäävän valmistuksen (aka 3D-tulostus) mahdollisuuksiin ja kustannuksiin metallisten tuotteiden valmistuksessa: Case jauhepetitekniikka

Suurelle yleisölle lisäävä valmistustekniikka eli ns. 3D-tulostustekniikka näyttäytyy lehtien otsikoissa ja artikkeleissa esiin pulpahtavana ”muotiaiheena”, mutta sekä muovien 3D-tulostustekniikka että metallienkin vastaava valmistustekniikka on ollut olemassa maailmalla ja Suomessa 80-luvun puolivälistä alkaen. Yhdysvalloissa ja Saksassa tekniikkaa käytetään valmistavassa teollisuudessa toiminnallisten osien tuotannossa. Esimerkiksi lentokoneen suihkumoottorien osia ja lääketieteellisiä välineitä tehdään metallijauheesta lisäävän valmistuksen avulla. Itse asiassa eräs menetelmä metalliesineiden valmistamiseksi lasersäteen avulla keksittiin Suomessa ja sitä myös kehiteltiin täällä, mutta teollisuudenala lähti aikanaan nousuun Saksassa. Lisäävä valmistus on tällä hetkellä maailmanlaajuisesti eräs kiinnostavista tuotantotekniikoista, jonka uskotaan muuttavan monia asioita tuotteiden suunnittelussa, toiminnoissa ja valmistuksessa. Tämä tekniikka ei kiinnosta pelkästään valmistavaa teollisuutta, vaan tietotekniikan, lääketieteen, koruvalmistuksen ja muotoilun osaajat sekä uusien liiketoimintamallien kehittäjät ja logistiikka operaattorit ovat teknologiasta kiinnostuneita. Suomelle 3D-tulostustekniikka on suuri mahdollisuus, sillä maassamme on vahva teollinen tieto- ja viestintätekniikkaosaaminen sekä lisäksi olemme maassamme erikoistuneet varsin vaativien teollisiin laitteiden valmistukseen. Eräät suurimmista mahdollisuuksista tällä tekniikalla ovat toimitusketjuihin liittyvät muutokset. Uutta on, että pienetkin yritykset ja organisaatiot voivat soveltaa tätä tekniikkaa valmistuksessa ja jopa kehitellä täysin uusia tuotteita. On myös arvioitu, että lisäävän valmistuksen merkitys valmistustapoihin ja toimitusketjuihin voi olla suurempi kuin koskaan aikaisemmin minkään teknologisen uudistuksen kohdalla. Lisäävästä valmistuksesta usein puhutaankin kolmantena teollisena vallankumouksena juuri tämän takia. 3D-tulostuksen kustannuksia tarkasteltaessa on tärkeätä huomata että vain sulatetun jauheen määrä ratkaisee, ei käytettävän geometrian monimutkaisuus. Tämä erottaa perinteisen ja lisäävän valmistuksen toisistaan. Perinteisesti kappaleen keventäminen on maksanut ”ylimääräistä”, kun taas lisäävässä valmistuksessa kappaleen keveys on jopa kustannusta alentava tekijä. Valmistettavan kappaleen korkeus on yksi kriittisimpiä kustannuksiin vaikuttavia tekijöitä. Tämän vuoksi useamman kappaleen valmistus yhdellä kertaa parantaa kannattavuutta huomattavasti. Samalla kertaa voi ja itse asiassa kannattaakin valmistaa keskenään erilaisia kappaleita. Perinteiset valmistustavat sen sijaan ovat nykyajan vaatimuksille liian hitaita; ne joustavat huonosti, kun kyseessä on pienet, asiakaslähtöiset erät. Trendi on globaalisti kohden yksilöllisiä asiakaslähtöisiä tuotteita, jolloin myös valmistustekniikoiden on oltava joustavia pysyäkseen näiden vaatimusten perässä. Lisäävä valmistus sopii erityisesti hyvin piensarjatuotantoon. Suuremmissa valmistuserissä kuitenkin perinteiset tekniikat ovat kustannustehokkaampia.

CRITERIA FOR SUSTAINABLE PRODUCT DESIGN WITH 3D PRINTING IN THE DEVELOPING WORLD

The demand for consumer goods in the developing world continues to rise as populations and economies grow. As designers, manufacturers, and consumers look for ways to address this growing demand, many are considering the possibilities of 3D printing. Due to 3D printing’s flexibility and relative mobility, it is speculated that 3D printing could help to meet the growing demands of the developing world. While the merits and challenges of distributed manufacturing with 3D printing have been presented, little work has been done to determine the types of products that would be appropriate for such manufacturing. Inspired by the author’s two years of Peace Corps service in the Tanzania and the need for specialty equipment for various projects during that time, an in-depth literature search is undertaken to better understand and summarize the process and capabilities of 3D printing. Human-centered design considerations are developed to focus on the product desirability, the technical feasibility, and the financial viability of using 3D printing within Tanzania. Beginning with concerns of what Tanzanian consumers desire, many concerns later arise in regards to the feasibility of creating products that would be sufficient in strength and quality for the demands of developing world consumers. It is only after these concerns are addressed that the viability of products can be evaluated from an economic perspective. The larger impacts of a product beyond its use are vital in determining how it will affect the social, economic, and environmental well-being of a developing nation such as Tanzania. Thus technology specific criteria are necessary for assessing and quantifying the broader impacts that a 3D-printed product can have within its ecosystem, and appropriate criteria are developed for this purpose. Both sets of criteria are then demonstrated and tested while evaluating the desirability, feasibility, viability, and sustainability of printing a piece of equipment required for the author’s Peace Corps service: a set of Vernier calipers. Required for science educators throughout the country, specialty equipment such as calipers initially appear to be an ideal candidate for 3D printing, though ultimately the printing of calipers is not recommended due to current restrictions in the technology. By examining more specific challenges and opportunities of the products 3D printing can produce, it can be better determined what place 3D printing will have in manufacturing for the developing world. Furthermore, the considerations outlined in this paper could be adapted for other manufacturing technologies and regions of the world, as human centered design and sustainability will be critical in determining how to supply the developing world with the consumer goods it demands.

Ku band waveguide diplexer design for satellite communication. Implementation by additive manufacturing and experimental characterization

Gran cantidad de servicios de telecomunicación tales como la distribución de televisión o los sistemas de navegación están basados en comunicaciones por satélite. Del mismo modo que ocurre en otras aplicaciones espaciales, existe una serie de recursos clave severamente limitados, tales como la masa o el volumen. En este sentido, uno de los dispositivos pasivos más importantes es el diplexor del sistema de alimentación de la antena. Este dispositivo permite el uso de una única antena tanto para transmitir como para recibir, con la consiguiente optimización de recursos que eso supone. El objetivo principal de este trabajo es diseñar un diplexor que cumpla especificaciones reales de comunicaciones por satélite. El dispositivo consiste en dos estructuras filtrantes unidas por una bifurcación de tres puertas. Además, es imprescindible utilizar tecnología de guía de onda para su implementación debido a los altos niveles de potencia manejados. El diseño del diplexor se lleva a cabo dividiendo la estructura en diversas partes, con el objetivo de que todo el proceso sea factible y eficiente. En primer lugar, se han desarrollado filtros con diferentes respuestas – paso alto, paso bajo y paso banda – aunque únicamente dos de ellos formarán el diplexor. Al afrontar su diseño inicial, se lleva a cabo un proceso de síntesis teórica utilizando modelos circuitales. A continuación, los filtros se optimizan con técnicas de diseño asistido por ordenador (CAD) full-wave, en concreto mode matching. En este punto es esencial analizar las estructuras y su simetría para determinar qué modos electromagnéticos se están propagando realmente por los dispositivos, para así reducir el esfuerzo computacional asociado. Por último, se utiliza el Método de los Elementos Finitos (FEM) para verificar los resultados previamente obtenidos. Una vez que el diseño de los filtros está terminado, se calculan las dimensiones correspondientes a la bifurcación. Finalmente, el diplexor al completo se somete a un proceso de optimización para cumplir las especificaciones eléctricas requeridas. Además, este trabajo presenta un novedoso valor añadido: la implementación física y la caracterización experimental tanto del diplexor como de los filtros por separado. Esta posibilidad, impracticable hasta ahora debido a su elevado coste, se deriva del desarrollo de las técnicas de manufacturación aditiva. Los prototipos se imprimen en plástico (PLA) utilizando una impresora 3D de bajo coste y posteriormente se metalizan. El uso de esta tecnología conlleva dos limitaciones: la precisión de las dimensiones geométricas (±0.2 mm) y la conductividad de la pintura metálica que recubre las paredes internas de las guías de onda. En este trabajo se incluye una comparación entre los valores medidos y simulados, así como un análisis de los resultados experimentales. En resumen, este trabajo presenta un proceso real de ingeniería: el problema de diseñar un dispositivo que satisfaga especificaciones reales, las limitaciones causadas por el proceso de fabricación, la posterior caracterización experimental y la obtención de conclusiones.

AIR SIDE HEAT TRANSFER ENHANCEMENT IN HEAT EXCHANGERS UTILIZING INNOVATIVE DESIGNS AND THE ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING TECHNIQUE

Over the last decade, rapid development of additive manufacturing techniques has allowed the fabrication of innovative and complex designs. One field that can benefit from such technology is heat exchanger fabrication, as heat exchanger design has become more and more complex due to the demand for higher performance particularly on the air side of the heat exchanger. By employing the additive manufacturing, a heat exchanger design was successfully realized, which otherwise would have been very difficult to fabricate using conventional fabrication technologies. In this dissertation, additive manufacturing technique was implemented to fabricate an advanced design which focused on a combination of heat transfer surface and fluid distribution system. Although the application selected in this dissertation is focused on power plant dry cooling applications, the results of this study can directly and indirectly benefit other sectors as well, as the air-side is often the limiting side for in liquid or single phase cooling applications. Two heat exchanger designs were studied. One was an advanced metallic heat exchanger based on manifold-microchannel technology and the other was a polymer heat exchanger based on utilization of prime surface technology. Polymer heat exchangers offer several advantages over metals such as antifouling, anticorrosion, lightweight and often less expensive than comparable metallic heat exchangers. A numerical modeling and optimization were performed to calculate a design that yield an optimum performance. The optimization results show that significant performance enhancement is noted compared to the conventional heat exchangers like wavy fins and plain plate fins. Thereafter, both heat exchangers were scaled down and fabricated using additive manufacturing and experimentally tested. The manifold-micro channel design demonstrated that despite some fabrication inaccuracies, compared to a conventional wavy-fin surface, 15% - 50% increase in heat transfer coefficient was possible for the same pressure drop value. In addition, if the fabrication inaccuracy can be eliminated, an even larger performance enhancement is predicted. Since metal based additive manufacturing is still in the developmental stage, it is anticipated that with further refinement of the manufacturing process in future designs, the fabrication accuracy can be improved. For the polymer heat exchanger, by fabricating a very thin wall heat exchanger (150μm), the wall thermal resistance, which usually becomes the limiting side for polymer heat exchanger, was calculated to account for only up to 3% of the total thermal resistance. A comparison of air-side heat transfer coefficient of the polymer heat exchanger with some of the commercially available plain plate fin surface heat exchangers show that polymer heat exchanger performance is equal or superior to plain plate fin surfaces. This shows the promising potential for polymer heat exchangers to compete with conventional metallic heat exchangers when an additive manufacturing-enabled fabrication is utilized. Major contributions of this study are as follows: (1) For the first time demonstrated the potential of additive manufacturing in metal printing of heat exchangers that benefit from a sophisticated design to yield a performance substantially above the respective conventional systems. Such heat exchangers cannot be fabricated with the conventional fabrication techniques. (2) For the first time demonstrated the potential of additive manufacturing to produce polymer heat exchangers that by design minimize the role of thermal conductivity and deliver a thermal performance equal or better that their respective metallic heat exchangers. In addition of other advantages of polymer over metal like antifouling, anticorrosion, and lightweight. Details of the work are documented in respective chapters of this thesis.

IDeS methodology applied to automotive component re-engineering focused on lightweight and high-strength by additive manufacturing

The project aims to gather an understanding of additive manufacturing and other manufacturing 4.0 techniques with an eyesight for industrialization. First the internal material anisotropy of elements created with the most economically feasible FEM technique was established. An understanding of the main drivers for variability for AM was portrayed, with the focus on achieving material internal isotropy. Subsequently, a technique for deposition parameter optimization was presented, further procedure testing was performed following other polymeric materials and composites. A replicability assessment by means of the use of technology 4.0 was proposed, and subsequent industry findings gathered the ultimate need of developing a process that demonstrate how to re-engineer designs in order to show the best results with AM processing. The latest study aims to apply the Industrial Design and Structure Method (IDES) and applying all the knowledge previously stacked into fully reengineer a product with focus of applying tools from 4.0 era, from product feasibility studies, until CAE – FEM analysis and CAM – DfAM. These results would help in making AM and FDM processes a viable option to be combined with composites technologies to achieve a reliable, cost-effective manufacturing method that could also be used for mass market, industry applications.

What Bees Want: Algorithm-Aided Design di un'arnia progettata per le api e realizzata in Additive Manufacturing

L’importanza delle api per la vita sulla Terra ed il rischio alle quali sono sottoposte per via dell’azione dell’uomo sono ormai un dato di fatto. La concezione antropocentrica della natura e l’allevamento al solo fine produttivo di questi piccoli insetti, ha da sempre danneggiato il loro habitat e interferito con i loro cicli biologici. L’apicoltura, nata come un rapporto mutualistico in cui l’uomo offriva un rifugio alle api e loro in cambio provvedevano al suo nutrimento, si è trasformato in una dannosa dipendenza ed in un assoggettamento di questi insetti ai ritmi artificiali e tutt’altro che naturali della produzione rapida e seriale volta all’ottenimento di un profitto. Un’evidente prova di questa condizione, sono i rifugi per le api, le arnie. Ci siamo mai chiesti perché le arnie hanno questa forma? È quella che preferiscono le api, o quella che rende più pratici e veloci processi di costruzione, gestione e produzione? In natura le api colonizzano cavità quali tronchi cavi di alberi, forme lontane, per non dire diametralmente opposte a quelle in cui le vediamo vivere negli allevamenti. In questa ottica, il design e le nuove tecnologie, poste al servizio della Natura, conducono ad un punto di incontro tra le esigenze umane e quelle degli altri esseri viventi, delle api in questo caso. I concetti di Additive Manufacturing e Design Computazionale, permettono processi di produzione simili a quelli evolutivi naturali e trovano per questa motivazione un’applicazione ideale per progetti che si pongono come fine quello di discostarsi da una visione troppo artificiale, per riavvicinarsi alla perfezione e all’armonia delle leggi della Natura.