Theoretical Calculations of Acid Dissociation Constants: A Review Article

Acid dissociation constants, or pKa values, are essential for understanding many fundamental reactions in chemistry. These values reveal the deprotonation state of a molecule in a particular solvent. There is great interest in using theoretical methods to calculate the pKa values for many different types of molecules. These include molecules that have not been synthesized, those for which experimental pKa determinations are difficult, and for larger molecules where the local environment changes the usual pKa values, such as for certain amino acids that are part of a larger polypeptide chain. Chemical accuracy in pKa calculations is difficult to achieve, because an error of 1.36 kcal/mol in the change of free energy for deprotonation in solvent results in an error of 1 pKa unit. In this review the most valuable methods for determining accurate pKa values in aqueous solution are presented for educators interested in explaining or using these methods for their students.

Article Accurate Experimental Values for the Free Energies of Hydration of H+, OH-, and H3O+

Accurate experimental values for the free energies of hydration, or the free energies of solvation, of the H+, OH-, and H3O+ ions are of fundamental importance. By use of the most accurate value for the free energy of solvation of H+, the known value for the free energy of solvation of water, and the known values for the gas phase and aqueous phase deprotonation of water, the corresponding experimental free energy of solvation for OH- is −106.4 ± 0.5 kcal/mol. Similarly, by use of the known values for ΔGf 0 for H3O, H2O+, and OH-, the known values for ΔGs for H+ and OH-, and the known value for the aqueous phase autoionization of water, we obtain an experimental free energy of solvation value for H3O+ of −103.4 ± 0.5 kcal/mol. These values are in excellent agreement with the commonly accepted values and with the value for ΔGs(OH-) obtained from embedding clusters of OH-(H2O)n in a dielectric continuum.

Absolute pKa Determinations for Substituted Phenols

The CBS-QB3 method was used to calculate the gas-phase free energy difference between 20 phenols and their respective anions, and the CPCM continuum solvation method was applied to calculate the free energy differences of solvation for the phenols and their anions. The CPCM solvation calculations were performed on both gas-phase and solvent-phase optimized structures. Absolute pKa calculations with solvated phase optimized structures for the CPCM calculations yielded standard deviations and root-mean-square errors of less than 0.4 pKa unit. This study is the most accurate absolute determination of the pKa values of phenols, and is among the most accurate of any such calculations for any group of compounds. The ability to make accurate predictions of pKa values using a coherent, well-defined approach, without external approximations or fitting to experimental data, is of general importance to the chemical community. The solvated phase optimized structures of the anions are absolutely critical to obtain this level of accuracy, and yield a more realistic charge separation between the negatively charged oxygen and the ring system of the phenoxide anions.

Further Quantum Mechanical Evidence that Difluorotoluene does not Hydrogen Bond

Calculations were run on the methylated DNA base pairs adenine:thymine and adenine:difluorotoluene to further investigate the hydrogen-bonding properties of difluorotoluene (F). Geometries were optimized using hybrid density functional theory. Single-point calculations at the MP2(full) level were performed to obtain more rigorous energies. The functional counterpoise method was used to correct for the basis set superposition error (BSSE), and the interaction energies were also corrected for fragment relaxation. These corrections brought the B3LYP and MP2 interaction energies into excellent agreement. In the gas phase, the Gibbs free energies calculated at the B3LYP and MP2 levels of theory predict that A and T will spontaneously form an A:T pair while A:F spontaneously dissociates into A and F. Solvation effects on the pairing of the bases were explored using implicit solvent models for water and chloroform. In aqueous solution, both A:T and A:F are predicted to dissociate into their component monomers. Semiempirical calculations were performed on small sections of B-form DNA containing the two pairs, and the results provide support for the concept that base stacking is more important than hydrogen bonding for the stability of the A:F pair within a DNA helix.

Comparison of Experimental and Theoretical Structures of a Transition State Analogue Used for the Induction of Anti-Cocaine Catalytic Antibodies

Comparison of the crystal structure of a transition state analogue that was used to raise catalytic antibodies for the benzoyl ester hydrolysis of cocaine with structures calculated by ab initio, semiempirical, and solvation semiempirical methods reveals that modeling of solvation is crucial for replicating the crystal structure geometry. Both SM3 and SM2 calculations, starting from the crystal structure TSA I, converged on structures similar to the crystal structure. The 3-21G(*)/HF, 6-31G*/HF, PM3, and AM1 calculations converged on structures similar to each other, but these gas-phase structures were significantly extended relative to the condensed phase structures. Two transition states for the hydrolysis of the benzoyl ester of cocaine were located with the SM3 method. The gas phase calculations failed to locate reasonable transition state structures for this reaction. These results imply that accurate modeling of the potential energy surfaces for the hydrolysis of cocaine requires solvation methods.

Use of the Supermolecule Approach To Model the Syn and Anti Conformations of Solvated Cyclic 3‘,5‘-Adenosine Monophosphate

The supermolecule approach has been used to model the hydration of cyclic 3‘,5‘-adenosine monophosphate, cAMP. Model building combined with PM3 optimizations predict that the anti conformer of cAMP is capable of hydrogen bonding to an additional solvent water molecule compared to the syn conformer. The addition of one water to the syn superstructure with concurrent rotation of the base about the glycosyl bond to form the anti superstructure leads to an additional enthalpy of stabilization of approximately −6 kcal/mol at the PM3 level. This specific solute−solvent interaction is an example of a large solvent effect, as the method predicts that cAMP has a conformational preference for the anti isomer in solution. This conformational preference results from a change in the number of specific solute−solvent interactions in this system. This prediction could be tested by NMR techniques. The number of waters predicted to be in the first hydration sphere around cAMP is in agreement with the results of hydration studies of nucleotides in DNA. In addition, the detailed picture of solvation about this cyclic nucleotide is in agreement with infrared experimental results.

Investigation of the Potential Energy Surface for the First Step in the Alkaline Hydrolysis of Methyl Acetate

The potential energy surface for the first step of the alkaline hydrolysis of methyl acetate was explored by a variety of methods. The conformational search routine within SPARTAN was used to determine the lowest energy am1 and pm3 structures for the anionic tetrahedral intermediate. Ab initio single point and geometry optimization calculations were performed to determine the lowest energy conformer, and the linear synchronous transition (lst) method was used to provide an initial structure for transition state optimization. Transition states were obtained at the am1, pm3, 3-21G, and 3-21 + G levels of theory. These transition states were compared with the anionic tetrahedral intermediates to examine the assumption that the intermediate is a good model for the transition state. In addition, the Cramer/Truhlar sm3 solvation model was used at the semiempirical level to compare gas phase and aqueous alkaline hydrolysis of methyl acetate.

A Computationally Efficient Procedure for Modeling the First Step in the Alkaline Hydrolysis of Esters

A computationally efficient procedure for modeling the alkaline hydrolysis of esters is proposed based on calculations performed on methyl acetate and methyl benzoate systems. Extensive geometry and energy comparisons were performed on the simple ester methyl acetate. The effectiveness of performing high level single point ab initio energy calculations on the geometries obtained from semiempirical and ab initio methods was determined. The AM1 and PM3 semiempirical methods are evaluated for their ability to model the transition states and intermediates for ester hydrolysis. The Cramer/Truhlar SM3 solvation method was used to determine activation energies. The most computationally efficient way to model the transition states of large esters is to use the PM3 method. The PM3 transition structure can then be used as a template for the design of haptens capable of inducing catalytic antibodies.

Vibronic Spectra of Jet-Cooled 2-Aminopurine center dot H2O Clusters Studied by UV Resonant Two-Photon Ionization Spectroscopy and Quantum Chemical Calculations

For understanding the major- and minor-groove hydration patterns of DNAs and RNAs, it is important to understand the local solvation of individual nucleobases at the molecular level. We have investigated the 2-aminopurine center dot H2O. monohydrate by two-color resonant two-photon ionization and UV/UV hole-burning spectroscopies, which reveal two isomers, denoted A and B. The electronic spectral shift delta nu of the S-1 <- S-0 transition relative to bare 9H-2-aminopurine (9H-2AP) is small for isomer A (-70 cm(-1)), while that of isomer B is much larger (delta nu = 889 cm(-1)). B3LYP geometry optimizations with the TZVP basis set predict four cluster isomers, of which three are doubly H-bonded, with H2O acting as an acceptor to a N-H or -NH2 group and as a donor to either of the pyrimidine N sites. The "sugar-edge" isomer A is calculated to be the most stable form with binding energy D-e = 56.4 kJ/mol. Isomers B and C are H-bonded between the -NH2 group and pyrimidine moieties and are 2.5 and 6.9 kJ/mol less stable, respectively. Time-dependent (TD) B3LYP/TZVP calculations predict the adiabatic energies of the lowest (1)pi pi* states of A and B in excellent agreement with the observed 0(0)(0) bands; also, the relative intensities of the A and B origin bands agree well with the calculated S-0 state relative energies. This allows unequivocal identification of the isomers. The R2PI spectra of 9H-2AP and of isomer A exhibit intense low-frequency out-of-plane overtone and combination bands, which is interpreted as a coupling of the optically excited (1)pi pi* state to the lower-lying (1)n pi* dark state. In contrast, these overtone and combination bands are much weaker for isomer B, implying that the (1)pi pi* state of B is planar and decoupled from the (1)n pi* state. These observations agree with the calculations, which predict the (1)n pi* above the (1)pi pi* state for isomer B but below the (1)pi pi* for both 9H-2AP and isomer A.

Proteins in silico-modeling and sampling

Proteins are linear chain molecules made out of amino acids. Only when they fold to their native states, they become functional. This dissertation aims to model the solvent (environment) effect and to develop & implement enhanced sampling methods that enable a reliable study of the protein folding problem in silico. We have developed an enhanced solvation model based on the solution to the Poisson-Boltzmann equation in order to describe the solvent effect. Following the quantum mechanical Polarizable Continuum Model (PCM), we decomposed net solvation free energy into three physical terms– Polarization, Dispersion and Cavitation. All the terms were implemented, analyzed and parametrized individually to obtain a high level of accuracy. In order to describe the thermodynamics of proteins, their conformational space needs to be sampled thoroughly. Simulations of proteins are hampered by slow relaxation due to their rugged free-energy landscape, with the barriers between minima being higher than the thermal energy at physiological temperatures. In order to overcome this problem a number of approaches have been proposed of which replica exchange method (REM) is the most popular. In this dissertation we describe a new variant of canonical replica exchange method in the context of molecular dynamic simulation. The advantage of this new method is the easily tunable high acceptance rate for the replica exchange. We call our method Microcanonical Replica Exchange Molecular Dynamic (MREMD). We have described the theoretical frame work, comment on its actual implementation, and its application to Trp-cage mini-protein in implicit solvent. We have been able to correctly predict the folding thermodynamics of this protein using our approach.

Reaction of Copper(II) Chloroacetate with Pyrazole. Synthesis of a One-Dimensional Coordination Polymer and Unexpected Dehydrochlorination Reaction

The reaction of copper(II) chloroacetate (1d) with pyrazole (Hpz) mainly yielded the mononuclear compound [Cu(μ-ClCH2COO)2(Hpz)2] (2m), which self-assembled generating a one-dimensional coordination polymer. Moreover, the concomitant isolation of the tetranuclear [{Cu2(μ-pz)(μ-OCH2COO)(Hpz)(MeOH)}2(μ-ClCH2COO)2] (3t) and hexanuclear [{Cu3(μ3-OH)(μ-pz)3(Hpz)2}2(μ-ClCH2COO)2](Cl)2 (4h) species evidenced the occurrence of a peculiar, previously unreported, dehydrochlorination reaction and the formation of the trinuclear triangular moiety [Cu3(μ3-OH)(μ-pz)3]. Theoretical calculations based on density functional theory including solvation effects indicate a possible pathway for the formation of 3t. Interestingly, besides the energy minimum corresponding to 3t, a further relative energy minimum is found for a species which can be considered a possible reaction intermediate.

Computational study of ligand binding in lipid transfer proteins: Structures, interfaces, and free energies of protein-lipid complexes

Plant nonspecific lipid transfer proteins (nsLTPs) bind a wide variety of lipids, which allows them to perform disparate functions. Recent reports on their multifunctionality in plant growth processes have posed new questions on the versatile binding abilities of these proteins. The lack of binding specificity has been customarily explained in qualitative terms on the basis of a supposed structural flexibility and nonspecificity of hydrophobic protein-ligand interactions. We present here a computational study of protein-ligand complexes formed between five nsLTPs and seven lipids bound in two different ways in every receptor protein. After optimizing geometries inmolecular dynamics calculations, we computed Poisson- Boltzmann electrostatic potentials, solvation energies, properties of the protein-ligand interfaces, and estimates of binding free energies of the resulting complexes. Our results provide the first quantitative information on the ligand abilities of nsLTPs, shed new light into protein-lipid interactions, and reveal new features which supplement commonly held assumptions on their lack of binding specificity.

Optimización de operaciones unitarias utilizando líquidos iónicos como agentes materiales de separación

En este trabajo se estudia la modelización y optimización de procesos industriales de separación mediante el empleo de mezclas de líquidos iónicos como disolventes. Los disolventes habitualmente empleados en procesos de absorción o extracción suelen ser componentes orgánicos muy volátiles y dañinos para la salud humana. Las innovadoras propiedades que presentan los líquidos iónicos, los convierten en alternativas adecuadas para solucionar estos problemas. La presión de vapor de estos compuestos es muy baja y apenas varía con la temperatura. Por tanto, estos compuestos apenas se evaporan incluso a temperaturas altas. Esto supone una gran ventaja en cuanto al empleo de estos compuestos como disolventes industriales ya que permite el reciclaje continuo del disolvente al final del proceso sin necesidad de introducir disolvente fresco debido a la evaporación del mismo. Además, al no evaporarse, estos compuestos no suponen un peligro para la salud humana por inhalación; al contrario que otros disolventes como el benceno. El único peligro para la salud que tienen estos compuestos es por tanto el de contacto directo o ingesta, aunque de hecho muchos Líquidos Iónicos son inocuos con lo cual no existe peligro para la salud ni siquiera a través de estas vías. Los procesos de separación estudiados en este trabajo, se rigen por la termodinámica de fases, concretamente el equilibrio líquido-vapor. Para la predicción de los equilibrios se ha optado por el empleo de modelos COSMO (COnductor-like Screening MOdel). Estos modelos tienen su origen en el empleo de la termodinámica de solvatación y en la mecánica cuántica. En el desarrollo de procesos y productos, químicos e ingenieros frecuentemente precisan de la realización de cálculos de predicción de equilibrios de fase. Previamente al desarrollo de los modelos COSMO, se usaban métodos de contribución de grupos como UNIFAC o modelos de coeficientes de actividad como NRTL.La desventaja de estos métodos, es que requieren parámetros de interacción binaria que únicamente pueden obtenerse mediante ajustes por regresión a partir de resultados experimentales. Debido a esto, estos métodos apenas tienen aplicabilidad para compuestos con grupos funcionales novedosos debido a que no se dispone de datos experimentales para llevar a cabo los ajustes por regresión correspondientes. Una alternativa a estos métodos, es el empleo de modelos de solvatación basados en la química cuántica para caracterizar las interacciones moleculares y tener en cuenta la no idealidad de la fase líquida. Los modelos COSMO, permiten la predicción de equilibrios sin la necesidad de ajustes por regresión a partir de resultados experimentales. Debido a la falta de resultados experimentales de equilibrios líquido-vapor de mezclas en las que se ven involucrados los líquidos iónicos, el empleo de modelos COSMO es una buena alternativa para la predicción de equilibrios de mezclas con este tipo de materiales. Los modelos COSMO emplean las distribuciones superficiales de carga polarizada (sigma profiles) de los compuestos involucrados en la mezcla estudiada para la predicción de los coeficientes de actividad de la misma, definiéndose el sigma profile de una molécula como la distribución de probabilidad de densidad de carga superficial de dicha molécula. Dos de estos modelos son COSMO-RS (Realistic Solvation) y COSMO-SAC (Segment Activity Coefficient). El modelo COSMO-RS fue la primera extensión de los modelos de solvatación basados en continuos dieléctricos a la termodinámica de fases líquidas mientras que el modelo COSMO-SAC es una variación de este modelo, tal y como se explicará posteriormente. Concretamente en este trabajo se ha empleado el modelo COSMO-SAC para el cálculo de los coeficientes de actividad de las mezclas estudiadas. Los sigma profiles de los líquidos iónicos se han obtenido mediante el empleo del software de química computacional Turbomole y el paquete químico-cuántico COSMOtherm. El software Turbomole permite optimizar la geometría de la molécula para hallar la configuración más estable mientras que el paquete COSMOtherm permite la obtención del perfil sigma del compuesto mediante el empleo de los datos proporcionados por Turbomole. Por otra parte, los sigma profiles del resto de componentes se han obtenido de la base de datos Virginia Tech-2005 Sigma Profile Database. Para la predicción del equilibrio a partir de los coeficientes de actividad se ha empleado la Ley de Raoult modificada. Se ha supuesto por tanto que la fracción de cada componente en el vapor es proporcional a la fracción del mismo componente en el líquido, dónde la constante de proporcionalidad es el coeficiente de actividad del componente en la mezcla multiplicado por la presión de vapor del componente y dividido por la presión del sistema. Las presiones de vapor de los componentes se han obtenido aplicando la Ley de Antoine. Esta ecuación describe la relación entre la temperatura y la presión de vapor y se deduce a partir de la ecuación de Clausius-Clapeyron. Todos estos datos se han empleado para la modelización de una separación flash usando el algoritmo de Rachford-Rice. El valor de este modelo reside en la deducción de una función que relaciona las constantes de equilibrio, composición total y fracción de vapor. Para llevar a cabo la implementación del modelado matemático descrito, se ha programado un código empleando el software MATLAB de análisis numérico. Para comprobar la fiabilidad del código programado, se compararon los resultados obtenidos en la predicción de equilibrios de mezclas mediante el código con los resultados obtenidos mediante el simulador ASPEN PLUS de procesos químicos. Debido a la falta de datos relativos a líquidos iónicos en la base de datos de ASPEN PLUS, se han introducido estos componentes como pseudocomponentes, de manera que se han introducido únicamente los datos necesarios de estos componentes para realizar las simulaciones. El modelo COSMO-SAC se encuentra implementado en ASPEN PLUS, de manera que introduciendo los sigma profiles, los volúmenes de la cavidad y las presiones de vapor de los líquidos iónicos, es posible predecir equilibrios líquido-vapor en los que se ven implicados este tipo de materiales. De esta manera pueden compararse los resultados obtenidos con ASPEN PLUS y como el código programado en MATLAB y comprobar la fiabilidad del mismo. El objetivo principal del presente Trabajo Fin de Máster es la optimización de mezclas multicomponente de líquidos iónicos para maximizar la eficiencia de procesos de separación y minimizar los costes de los mismos. La estructura de este problema es la de un problema de optimización no lineal con variables discretas y continuas, es decir, un problema de optimización MINLP (Mixed Integer Non-Linear Programming). Tal y como se verá posteriormente, el modelo matemático de este problema es no lineal. Por otra parte, las variables del mismo son tanto continuas como binarias. Las variables continuas se corresponden con las fracciones molares de los líquidos iónicos presentes en las mezclas y con el caudal de la mezcla de líquidos iónicos. Por otra parte, también se ha introducido un número de variables binarias igual al número de líquidos iónicos presentes en la mezcla. Cada una de estas variables multiplican a las fracciones molares de sus correspondientes líquidos iónicos, de manera que cuando dicha variable es igual a 1, el líquido se encuentra en la mezcla mientras que cuando dicha variable es igual a 0, el líquido iónico no se encuentra presente en dicha mezcla. El empleo de este tipo de variables obliga por tanto a emplear algoritmos para la resolución de problemas de optimización MINLP ya que si todas las variables fueran continuas, bastaría con el empleo de algoritmos para la resolución de problemas de optimización NLP (Non-Linear Programming). Se han probado por tanto diversos algoritmos presentes en el paquete OPTI Toolbox de MATLAB para comprobar cuál es el más adecuado para abordar este problema. Finalmente, una vez validado el código programado, se han optimizado diversas mezclas de líquidos iónicos para lograr la máxima recuperación de compuestos aromáticos en un proceso de absorción de mezclas orgánicas. También se ha usado este código para la minimización del coste correspondiente a la compra de los líquidos iónicos de la mezcla de disolventes empleada en la operación de absorción. En este caso ha sido necesaria la introducción de restricciones relativas a la recuperación de aromáticos en la fase líquida o a la pureza de la mezcla obtenida una vez separada la mezcla de líquidos iónicos. Se han modelizado los dos problemas descritos previamente (maximización de la recuperación de Benceno y minimización del coste de operación) empleando tanto únicamente variables continuas (correspondientes a las fracciones o cantidades molares de los líquidos iónicos) como variables continuas y binarias (correspondientes a cada uno de los líquidos iónicos implicados en las mezclas).

Comparison of x-ray crystal structures of an acyl-enzyme intermediate of subtilisin Carlsberg formed in anhydrous acetonitrile and in water

The x-ray crystal structures of trans-cinnamoyl–subtilisin, an acyl-enzyme covalent intermediate of the serine protease subtilisin Carlsberg, have been determined to 2.2-Å resolution in anhydrous acetonitrile and in water. The cinnamoyl–subtilisin structures are virtually identical in the two solvents. In addition, their enzyme portions are nearly indistinguishable from previously determined structures of the free enzyme in acetonitrile and in water; thus, acylation in either aqueous or nonaqueous solvent causes no appreciable conformational changes. However, the locations of bound solvent molecules in the active site of the acyl- and free enzyme forms in acetonitrile and in water are distinct. Such differences in the active site solvation may contribute to the observed variations in enzymatic activities. On prolonged exposure to organic solvent or removal of interstitial solvent from the crystal lattice, the channels within enzyme crystals are shown to collapse, leading to a drop in the number of active sites accessible to the substrate. The mechanistic and preparative implications of our findings for enzymatic catalysis in organic solvents are discussed.

Femtosecond cluster studies of the solvated 7-azaindole excited state double-proton transfer

Presented here are femtosecond pump-probe studies on the water-solvated 7-azaindole dimer, a model DNA base pair. In particular, studies are presented that further elucidate the nature of the reactive and nonreactive dimers and also provide new insights establishing that the excited state double-proton transfer in the dimer occurs in a stepwise rather than a concerted manner. A major question addressed is whether the incorporation of a water molecule with the dimer results in the formation of species that are unable to undergo excited state double-proton transfer, as suggested by a recent study reported in the literature [Nakajima, A., Hirano, M., Hasumi, R., Kaya, K., Watanabe, H., Carter, C. C., Williamson, J. M. & Miller, T. (1997) J. Phys. Chem. 101, 392–398]. In contrast to this earlier work, our present findings reveal that both reactive and nonreactive dimers can coexist in the molecular beam under the same experimental conditions and definitively show that the clustering of water does not induce the formation of the nonreactive dimer. Rather, when present with a species already determined to be a nonreactive dimer, the addition of water can actually facilitate the occurrence of the proton transfer reaction. Furthermore, on attaining a critical hydration number, the data for the nonreactive dimer suggest a solvation-induced conformational structure change leading to proton transfer on the photoexcited half of the 7-azaindole dimer.