Competition law proceedings before the European Commission and the right to a fair trial: no need for reform? Research Papers in Law, 5/2008

From the Introduction. This paper will thus show that, given the rapid "criminalisation" of competition law proceedings, sanctions should in principle be imposed at first instance I. Sanctions imposed by the Commission in competition proceedings are "criminal charges" within the meaning of Article 6 ECHR by an independent and impartial tribunal fulfilling all the conditions of Article 6 ECHR (part I). Or at the very least, these sanctions should be subject to full jurisdictional review by an independent and impartial tribunal in order to comply with Article 6 ECHR and to cure the defects of the administrative procedure (part II). It is doubtful however whether such a full jurisdictional review, as it is understood by the ECtHR, is available at Community-level in antitrust cases.

An Assessment of the Penalties System for Infringements of EU Competition Law: Can Personal Sanctions be the Missing Piece of the Puzzle? IES WORKING PAPER 6/2013

Competition law seeks to protect competition on the market as a means of enhancing consumer welfare and of ensuring an efficient allocation of resources. In order to be successful, therefore, competition authorities should be adequately equipped and have at their disposal all necessary enforcement tools. However, at the EU level the current enforcement system of competition rules allows only for the imposition of administrative fines by the European Commission to liable undertakings. The main objectives, in turn, of an enforcement policy based on financial penalties are two fold: to impose sanctions on infringing undertakings which reflect the seriousness of the violation, and to ensure that the risk of penalties will deter both the infringing undertakings (often referred to as 'specific deterrence') and other undertakings that may be considering anti-competitive activities from engaging in them (often referred to as 'general deterrence'). In all circumstances, it is important to ensure that pecuniary sanctions imposed on infringing undertakings are proportionate and not excessive. Although pecuniary sanctions against infringing undertakings are a crucial part of the arsenal needed to deter competition law violations, they may not be sufficient. One alternative option in that regard is the strategic use of sanctions against the individuals involved in, or responsible for, the infringements. Sanctions against individuals are documented to focus the minds of directors and employees to comply with competition rules as they themselves, in addition to the undertakings in which they are employed, are at risk of infringements. Individual criminal penalties, including custodial sanctions, have been in fact adopted by almost half of the EU Member States. This is a powerful tool but is also limited in scope and hard to implement in practice mostly due to the high standards of proof required and the political consensus that needs first to be built. Administrative sanctions for individuals, on the other hand, promise to deliver up to a certain extent the same beneficial results as criminal sanctions whilst at the same time their adoption is not likely to meet strong opposition and their implementation in practice can be both efficient and effective. Directors’ disqualification, in particular, provides a strong individual incentive for each member, or prospective member, of the Board as well as other senior executives, to take compliance with competition law seriously. It is a flexible and promising tool that if added to the arsenal of the European Commission could bring balance to the current sanctioning system and that, in turn, would in all likelihood make the enforcement of EU competition rules more effective. Therefore, it is submitted that a competition law regime in order to be effective should be able to deliver policy objectives through a variety of tools, not simply by imposing significant pecuniary sanctions to infringing undertakings. It is also clear that individual sanctions, mostly of an administrative nature, are likely to play an increasingly important role as they focus the minds of those in business who might otherwise be inclined to regard infringing the law as a matter of corporate risk rather than of personal risk. At the EU level, in particular, the adoption of directors’ disqualification promises to deliver more effective compliance and greater overall economic impact.

Federal food, drug, and cosmetic act; judicial and administrative records 1938-49,

Mode of access: Internet.

Federal food, drug, and cosmetic act, judicial and administrative record, 1938-1949,

Mode of access: Internet.

The Montana insurance commissioner : a study of administrative regulation in action /

Mode of access: Internet.

Federal food, drug, and cosmetic act; judicial and administrative record, 1949-1950,

Mode of access: Internet.

Federal food, drug, and cosmetic act; judicial and administrative record, 1951-1952,

Mode of access: Internet.

Federal food, drug, and cosmetic act: judicial and administrative record, 1953-1957,

Mode of access: Internet.

Traffic law adjudication.

Mode of access: Internet.

The practice of the Court of Quarter Sessions, and its civil, administrative and appellate jurisdiction; to which is added a short treatise on its criminal jurisdiction, with tables of statutes under which appeals lie and of all indictable offences triable at Quarter Sessions; and appendices.

Criminal appeal rules and forms, 1908: p. 655-706.

A study of administrative hearings conducted by state driver licensing agencies. Volume I. Final report.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, D.C.

A study of administrative hearings conducted by state driver licensing agencies. Volume II - appendices. Final report.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, D.C.

Address of Silas W. Gardiner (representing the Central Yellow Pine Association) : delegate to the Interstate Commerce Law Convention held at Chicago, October 26th and 27th, 1905.

Caption title: Some reflections as to President Roosevelt's recommendations for governmental regulation of freight rates through the administrative arm of the government, rather than through the judiciary.

Administrative procedure, subdivision regulations, zoning ordinance of the Township of West Bloomfield ; Oakland County, Michigan.

"Effective April 20, 1966."

Annales des mines, partie administrative, ou Recueil de lois, décrets, arrètés et autres actes concernant les mines et usines.

Vol. for 1942 bound with Annales des mines ; recueil de mémoires & de documents ... 1944.