Argumentation as Distributed Belief Revision: Conflict Resolution in Decentralised Multi-agent Systems

Decentralised co-operative multi-agent systems are computational systems where conflicts are frequent due to the nature of the represented knowledge. Negotiation methodologies, in this case argumentation based negotiation methodologies, were developed and applied to solve unforeseeable and, therefore, unavoidable conflicts. The supporting computational model is a distributed belief revision system where argumentation plays the decisive role of revision. The distributed belief revision system detects, isolates and solves, whenever possible, the identified conflicts. The detection and isolation of the conflicts is automatically performed by the distributed consistency mechanism and the resolution of the conflict, or belief revision, is achieved via argumentation. We propose and describe two argumentation protocols intended to solve different types of identified information conflicts: context dependent and context independent conflicts. While the protocol for context dependent conflicts generates new consensual alternatives, the latter chooses to adopt the soundest, strongest argument presented. The paper shows the suitability of using argumentation as a distributed decentralised belief revision protocol to solve unavoidable conflicts.

Improving Assumption based Distributed Belief Revision

Belief revision is a critical issue in real world DAI applications. A Multi-Agent System not only has to cope with the intrinsic incompleteness and the constant change of the available knowledge (as in the case of its stand alone counterparts), but also has to deal with possible conflicts between the agents’ perspectives. Each semi-autonomous agent, designed as a combination of a problem solver – assumption based truth maintenance system (ATMS), was enriched with improved capabilities: a distributed context management facility allowing the user to dynamically focus on the more pertinent contexts, and a distributed belief revision algorithm with two levels of consistency. This work contributions include: (i) a concise representation of the shared external facts; (ii) a simple and innovative methodology to achieve distributed context management; and (iii) a reduced inter-agent data exchange format. The different levels of consistency adopted were based on the relevance of the data under consideration: higher relevance data (detected inconsistencies) was granted global consistency while less relevant data (system facts) was assigned local consistency. These abilities are fully supported by the ATMS standard functionalities.

Distributed Belief Revision and Environmental Decision Support

This article discusses the development of an Intelligent Distributed Environmental Decision Support System, built upon the association of a Multi-agent Belief Revision System with a Geographical Information System (GIS). The inherent multidisciplinary features of the involved expertises in the field of environmental management, the need to define clear policies that allow the synthesis of divergent perspectives, its systematic application, and the reduction of the costs and time that result from this integration, are the main reasons that motivate the proposal of this project. This paper is organised in two parts: in the first part we present and discuss the developed - Distributed Belief Revision Test-bed - DiBeRT; in the second part we analyse its application to the environmental decision support domain, with special emphasis on the interface with a GIS.

Distributed Belief Revision and Environmental Decision Support

This article discusses the development of an Intelligent Distributed Environmental Decision Support System, built upon the association of a Multi-agent Belief Revision System with a Geographical Information System (GIS). The inherent multidisciplinary features of the involved expertises in the field of environmental management, the need to define clear policies that allow the synthesis of divergent perspectives, its systematic application, and the reduction of the costs and time that result from this integration, are the main reasons that motivate the proposal of this project. This paper is organised in two parts: in the first part we present and discuss the developed ; in the second part we analyse its application to the environmental decision support domain, with special emphasis on the interface with a GIS.

Environmental Decision Support: a Distributed Artificial Intelligence Approach

Decision making in any environmental domain is a complex and demanding activity, justifying the development of dedicated decision support systems. Every decision is confronted with a large variety and amount of constraints to satisfy as well as contradictory interests that must be sensibly accommodated. The first stage of a project evaluation is its submission to the relevant group of public (and private) agencies. The individual role of each agency is to verify, within its domain of competence, the fulfilment of the set of applicable regulations. The scope of the involved agencies is wide and ranges from evaluation abilities on the technical or economical domains to evaluation competences on the environmental or social areas. The second project evaluation stage involves the gathering of the recommendations of the individual agencies and their justified merge to produce the final conclusion. The incorporation and accommodation of the consulted agencies opinions is of extreme importance: opinions may not only differ, but can be interdependent, complementary, irreconcilable or, simply, independent. The definition of adequate methodologies to sensibly merge, whenever possible, the existing perspectives while preserving the overall legality of the system, will lead to the making of sound justified decisions. The proposed Environmental Decision Support System models the project evaluation activity and aims to assist developers in the selection of adequate locations for their projects, guaranteeing their compliance with the applicable regulations.

Beliefs and Conflicts in a Real World Multi-Agent System

In a real world multiagent system, where the agents are faced with partial, incomplete and intrinsically dynamic knowledge, conflicts are inevitable. Frequently, different agents have goals or beliefs that cannot hold simultaneously. Conflict resolution methodologies have to be adopted to overcome such undesirable occurrences. In this paper we investigate the application of distributed belief revision techniques as the support for conflict resolution in the analysis of the validity of the candidate beams to be produced in the CERN particle accelerators. This CERN multiagent system contains a higher hierarchy agent, the Specialist agent, which makes use of meta-knowledge (on how the con- flicting beliefs have been produced by the other agents) in order to detect which beliefs should be abandoned. Upon solving a conflict, the Specialist instructs the involved agents to revise their beliefs accordingly. Conflicts in the problem domain are mapped into conflicting beliefs of the distributed belief revision system, where they can be handled by proven formal methods. This technique builds on well established concepts and combines them in a new way to solve important problems. We find this approach generally applicable in several domains.

Distributed Generation and Demand Response Dispatch for a Virtual Power Player Energy and Reserve Provision

Recent changes in the operation and planning of power systems have been motivated by the introduction of Distributed Generation (DG) and Demand Response (DR) in the competitive electricity markets' environment, with deep concerns at the efficiency level. In this context, grid operators, market operators, utilities and consumers must adopt strategies and methods to take full advantage of demand response and distributed generation. This requires that all the involved players consider all the market opportunities, as the case of energy and reserve components of electricity markets. The present paper proposes a methodology which considers the joint dispatch of demand response and distributed generation in the context of a distribution network operated by a virtual power player. The resources' participation can be performed in both energy and reserve contexts. This methodology contemplates the probability of actually using the reserve and the distribution network constraints. Its application is illustrated in this paper using a 32-bus distribution network with 66 DG units and 218 consumers classified into 6 types of consumers.

Distributed controllers modeling through Petri nets with multi-asynchronous-channels

This paper proposes the concept of multi-asynchronous-channel for Petri nets. Petri nets extended with multi-asynchronous-channels and time-domains support the specification of distributed controllers, where each controller has a synchronous execution but the global system is asynchronous (globally-asynchronous locally-synchronous systems). Each multi-asynchronous-channel specify the interaction between two or more distributed controllers. These channels, together with the time-domain concept, ensure the creation of network-independent models to support implementations using heterogeneous communication networks. The created models support not only the systems documentation but also their validation and implementation through simulation tools, verification tools, and automatic code generators. An application example illustrates the use of a Petri net class extended with the proposed channels. © 2015 IEEE.

Multi-agent management system for electric vehicle charging

This paper proposes an implementation, based on a multi-agent system, of a management system for automated negotiation of electricity allocation for charging electric vehicles (EVs) and simulates its performance. The widespread existence of charging infrastructures capable of autonomous operation is recognised as a major driver towards the mass adoption of EVs by mobility consumers. Eventually, conflicting requirements from both power grid and EV owners require automated middleman aggregator agents to intermediate all operations, for example, bidding and negotiation, between these parts. Multi-agent systems are designed to provide distributed, modular, coordinated and collaborative management systems; therefore, they seem suitable to address the management of such complex charging infrastructures. Our solution consists in the implementation of virtual agents to be integrated into the management software of a charging infrastructure. We start by modelling the multi-agent architecture using a federated, hierarchical layers setup and as well as the agents' behaviours and interactions. Each of these layers comprises several components, for example, data bases, decision-making and auction mechanisms. The implementation of multi-agent platform and auctions rules, and of models for battery dynamics, is also addressed. Four scenarios were predefined to assess the management system performance under real usage conditions, considering different types of profiles for EVs owners', different infrastructure configurations and usage and different loads on the utility grid (where real data from the concession holder of the Portuguese electricity transmission grid is used). Simulations carried with the four scenarios validate the performance of the modelled system while complying with all the requirements. Although all of these have been performed for one charging station alone, a multi-agent design may in the future be used for the higher level problem of distributing energy among charging stations. Copyright (c) 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Petri net model decomposition - a model based approach supporting distributed execution

Dissertação apresentada para obtenção do Grau de Doutor em Engenharia Electrotécnica, Especialidade de Sistemas Digitais, pela Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia

Time-domain optimization of amplifiers based on distributed genetic algorithms

Thesis presented in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the subject of Electrical and Computer Engineering

RealCrono –sistema de difusão de resultados em tempo real na web

A velocidade de difusão de conteúdos numa plataforma web, assume uma elevada relevância em serviços onde a informação se pretende atualizada e em tempo real. Este projeto de Mestrado, apresenta uma abordagem de um sistema distribuído de recolher e difundir resultados em tempo real entre várias plataformas, nomeadamente sistemas móveis. Neste contexto, tempo real entende-se como uma diferença de tempo nula entre a recolha e difusão, ignorando fatores que não podem ser controlados pelo sistema, como latência de comunicação e tempo de processamento. Este projeto tem como base uma arquitetura existente de processamento e publicação de resultados desportivos, que apresentava alguns problemas relacionados com escalabilidade, segurança, tempos de entrega de resultados longos e sem integração com outras plataformas. Ao longo deste trabalho procurou-se investigar fatores que condicionassem a escalabilidade de uma aplicação web dando ênfase à implementação de uma solução baseada em replicação e escalabilidade horizontal. Procurou-se também apresentar uma solução de interoperabilidade entre sistemas e plataformas heterogêneas, mantendo sempre elevados níveis de performance e promovendo a introdução de plataformas móveis no sistema. De várias abordagens existentes para comunicação em tempo real sobre uma plataforma web, adotou-se um implementação baseada em WebSocket que elimina o tempo desperdiçado entre a recolha de informação e sua difusão. Neste projeto é descrito o processo de implementação da API de recolha de dados (Collector), da biblioteca de comunicação com o Collector, da aplicação web (Publisher) e sua API, da biblioteca de comunicação com o Publisher e por fim a implementação da aplicação móvel multi-plataforma. Com os componentes criados, avaliaram-se os resultados obtidos com a nova arquitetura de forma a aferir a escalabilidade e performance da solução criada e sua adaptação ao sistema existente.

Dispatch of distributed Energy Resources to Provide Energy and Reserve in Smart Grids using a Particle Swarm Optimization Approach

The smart grid concept is a key issue in the future power systems, namely at the distribution level, with deep concerns in the operation and planning of these systems. Several advantages and benefits for both technical and economic operation of the power system and of the electricity markets are recognized. The increasing integration of demand response and distributed generation resources, all of them mostly with small scale distributed characteristics, leads to the need of aggregating entities such as Virtual Power Players. The operation business models become more complex in the context of smart grid operation. Computational intelligence methods can be used to give a suitable solution for the resources scheduling problem considering the time constraints. This paper proposes a methodology for a joint dispatch of demand response and distributed generation to provide energy and reserve by a virtual power player that operates a distribution network. The optimal schedule minimizes the operation costs and it is obtained using a particle swarm optimization approach, which is compared with a deterministic approach used as reference methodology. The proposed method is applied to a 33-bus distribution network with 32 medium voltage consumers and 66 distributed generation units.

Remuneration Structure Definition for Distributed Generation Units and Demand Response Participants Aggregation

The implementation of competitive electricity markets has changed the consumers’ and distributed generation position power systems operation. The use of distributed generation and the participation in demand response programs, namely in smart grids, bring several advantages for consumers, aggregators, and system operators. The present paper proposes a remuneration structure for aggregated distributed generation and demand response resources. A virtual power player aggregates all the resources. The resources are aggregated in a certain number of clusters, each one corresponding to a distinct tariff group, according to the economic impact of the resulting remuneration tariff. The determined tariffs are intended to be used for several months. The aggregator can define the periodicity of the tariffs definition. The case study in this paper includes 218 consumers, and 66 distributed generation units.

Tolerância a falhas em sistemas de tempo-real distribuídos e embebidos

Este documento descreve um modelo de tolerância a falhas para sistemas de tempo-real distribuídos. A sugestão deste modelo tem como propósito a apresentação de uma solu-ção fiável, flexível e adaptável às necessidades dos sistemas de tempo-real distribuídos. A tolerância a falhas é um aspeto extremamente importante na construção de sistemas de tempo-real e a sua aplicação traz inúmeros benefícios. Um design orientado para a to-lerância a falhas contribui para um melhor desempenho do sistema através do melhora-mento de aspetos chave como a segurança, a confiabilidade e a disponibilidade dos sis-temas. O trabalho desenvolvido centra-se na prevenção, deteção e tolerância a falhas de tipo ló-gicas (software) e físicas (hardware) e assenta numa arquitetura maioritariamente basea-da no tempo, conjugada com técnicas de redundância. O modelo preocupa-se com a efi-ciência e os custos de execução. Para isso utilizam-se também técnicas tradicionais de to-lerância a falhas, como a redundância e a migração, no sentido de não prejudicar o tempo de execução do serviço, ou seja, diminuindo o tempo de recuperação das réplicas, em ca-so de ocorrência de falhas. Neste trabalho são propostas heurísticas de baixa complexida-de para tempo-de-execução, a fim de se determinar para onde replicar os componentes que constituem o software de tempo-real e de negociá-los num mecanismo de coordena-ção por licitações. Este trabalho adapta e estende alguns algoritmos que fornecem solu-ções ainda que interrompidos. Estes algoritmos são referidos em trabalhos de investiga-ção relacionados, e são utilizados para formação de coligações entre nós coadjuvantes. O modelo proposto colmata as falhas através de técnicas de replicação ativa, tanto virtual como física, com blocos de execução concorrentes. Tenta-se melhorar ou manter a sua qualidade produzida, praticamente sem introduzir overhead de informação significativo no sistema. O modelo certifica-se que as máquinas escolhidas, para as quais os agentes migrarão, melhoram iterativamente os níveis de qualidade de serviço fornecida aos com-ponentes, em função das disponibilidades das respetivas máquinas. Caso a nova configu-ração de qualidade seja rentável para a qualidade geral do serviço, é feito um esforço no sentido de receber novos componentes em detrimento da qualidade dos já hospedados localmente. Os nós que cooperam na coligação maximizam o número de execuções para-lelas entre componentes paralelos que compõem o serviço, com o intuito de reduzir atra-sos de execução. O desenvolvimento desta tese conduziu ao modelo proposto e aos resultados apresenta-dos e foi genuinamente suportado por levantamentos bibliográficos de trabalhos de in-vestigação e desenvolvimento, literaturas e preliminares matemáticos. O trabalho tem também como base uma lista de referências bibliográficas.