The biology of cancer stem cells : part 1: nuclear translocation of CD44 : part 2: IMP2 in glioblastoma cancer stem cells

SummaryCancer stem cells (CSC) are poorly differentiated, slowly proliferating cells, with high tumorigenic potential. Some of these cells, as it has been shown in leukemia, evade chemo- and radiotherapy and recapitulate the tumor composed of CSC and their highly proliferative progeny. Therefore, understanding the molecular biology of those cells is crucial for improvement of currently used anti-cancer therapies.This work is composed of two CSC-related projects. The first deals with CD44, a frequently used marker of CSC; the second involves Imp2 and its role in CSC bioenergetics. PART 1. CD44 is a multifunctional transmembrane protein involved in migration, homing, adhesion, proliferation and survival. It is overexpressed in many cancers and its levels are correlated with poor prognosis. CD44 is also highly expressed by CSC and in many malignancies it is used for CSC isolation.In the present work full-lenght CD44 nuclear localization was studied, including the mechanism of nuclear translocation and its functional role in the nucleus. Full-length CD44 can be found in nuclei of various cell types, regardless of their tumorigenic potential. For nuclear localization, CD44 needs to be first inserted into the cell membrane, from which it is transported via the endocytic pathway. Upon binding to transportinl it is translocated to the nucleus. The nuclear localization signal recognized by transportinl has been determined as the first 20 amino acids of the membrane proximal intracellular domain. Nuclear export of CD44 is facilitated by exportin Crml. Investigation of the function of nuclear CD44 revealed its implication in de novo RNA synthesis.PART 2. Glioblastoma multiforme is the most aggressive and most frequent brain malignancy. It was one of the first solid tumors from which CSC have been isolated. Based on the similarity between GBM CSC and normal stem cells expression of an oncofetal mRNA binding protein Imp2 has been investigated.Imp2 is absent in normal brain as well as in low grade gliomas, but is expressed in over 75% GBM cases and its expression is higher in CSC compared to their more differentiated counterparts. Analysis of mRNA transcripts bound by Imp2 and its protein interactors revealed that in GBM CSC Imp2 may be implicated in mitochondrial metabolism. Indeed, shRNA mediated silencing of protein expression led to decreased mitochondrial activity, decreased oxygen consumption and decreased activity of respiratory chain protein complex I. Moreover, lack of Imp2 severely affected self-renewal and tumorigenicity of GBM CSC. Experimental evidence suggest that GBM CSC depend on mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation as an energy producing pathway and that Imp2 is a novel regulator of this pathway.RésuméLes cellules cancéreuses souches sont des cellules peu différentiées, à proliferation lente et hautement tumorigénique. Ces cellules sont radio-chimio résistantes et sont capable reformer la tumeur dans sont intégralité, reproduisant l'hétérogénéité cellulaire présent dans la tumeur d'origine. Pour améliorer les therapies antitumorales actuelles il est crucial de comprendre les mécanismes moléculaires qui caractérisent cette sous-population de cellules hautement malignes.Ce travail de thèse se compose de deux projets s'articulant autour du même axe :Le CD44 est une protéine multifonctionnelle et transmembranaire très souvent utilisée comme marqueur de cellules souches tumorales dans différents cancers. Elle est impliquée dans la migration, l'adhésion, la prolifération et la survie des cellules. Lors de ce travail de recherche, nous nous sommes intéressés à la localisation cellulaire du CD44, ainsi qu'aux mécanismes permettant sa translocation nucléaire. En effet, bien que principalement décrit comme un récepteur de surface transmembranaire, le CD44 sous sa forme entière, non clivée en peptides, peut également être observé à l'intérieur du noyau de diverses cellules, quel que soit leur potentiel tumorigénique. Pour passer ainsi d'un compartiment cellulaire à un autre, le CD44 doit d'abord être inséré dans la membrane plasmique, d'où il est transporté par endocytose jusqu'à l'intérieur du cytoplasme. La transportai permet ensuite la translocation nucléaire du CD44 via une « séquence signal » contenue dans les 20 acides aminés du domaine cytoplasmique qui bordent la membrane. A l'inverse, le CD44 est exporté du noyau grâce à l'exportin Crml. En plus des mécanismes décrits ci-dessus, cette étude a également mis en évidence l'implication du CD44 dans la synthèse des ARN, d'où sa présence dans le noyau.Le glioblastome est la plus maligne et la plus fréquente des tumeurs cérébrales. Dans ce second projet de recherche, le rôle de IMP2 dans les cellules souches tumorales de glioblastomes a été étudié. La présence de cette protéine oncofoetale a d'abord été mise en évidence dans 75% des cas les plus agressifs des gliomes (grade IV, appelés glioblastomes), tandis qu'elle n'est pas exprimée dans les grades I à III de ces tumeurs, ni dans le cerveau sain. De plus, IMP2 est apparue comme étant davantage exprimée dans les cellules souches tumorales que dans les cellules déjà différenciées. La baisse de l'expression de IMP2 au moyen de shRNA a résulté en une diminution de l'activité mitochondriale, en une réduction de la consommation d'oxygène ainsi qu'en une baisse de l'activité du complexe respiratoire I.L'inhibition de IMP2 a également affecté la capacité de renouvellement de la population des cellules souches tumorales ainsi que leur aptitude à former des tumeurs.Lors de ce travail de thèse, une nouvelle fonction d'un marqueur de cellules souches tumorales a été mise en évidence, ainsi qu'un lien important entre la bioénergétique de ces cellules et l'expression d'une protéine oncofoetale.

Anti-angiogenic therapies in cancer: achievements and open questions.

The approval in 2004 of bevacizumab (Avastin), a neutralizing monoclonal antibody directed against vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) as the first anti-angiogenic systemic drug to treat cancer patients validated the notion introduced 33 years earlier by Dr. Judah Folkman, that inhibition of tumor angiogenesis might be a valid approach to control tumor growth. Anti-angiogenic therapy was greeted in the clinic a major step forward in cancer treatment. At the same time this success recently boosted the field to the quest for new anti-angiogenic targets and drugs. In spite of this success, however, some old questions in the field have remained unanswered and new ones have emerged. They include the identification for surrogate markers of angiogenesis and anti-angiogenesis, the understanding about how anti-angiogenic therapy and chemotherapy synergize, the characterization of the biological consequences of sustained suppression of angiogenesis on tumor biology and normal tissue homeostasis, and the mechanisms of tumor escape from anti-angiogenesis. In this review we summarize some of these outstanding questions, and highlight future challenges in clinical, translational and experimental research in anti-angiogenic therapy that need to be addressed in order to improve current treatments and to design new drugs.

Tumour biology, metastatic sites and taxanes sensitivity as determinants of eribulin mesylate efficacy in breast cancer: results from the ERIBEX retrospective, international, multicenter study.

BACKGROUND: Our retrospective, international study aimed at evaluating the activity and safety of eribulin mesylate (EM) in pretreated metastatic breast cancer (MBC) in a routine clinical setting. METHODS: Patients treated with EM for a locally advanced or MBC between March 2011 and January 2014 were included in the study. Clinical and biological assessment of toxicity was performed at each visit. Tumour response was assessed every 3 cycles of treatment. A database was created to collect clinical, pathological and treatment data. RESULTS: Two hundred and fifty-eight patients were included in the study. Median age was 59 years old. Tumours were Hormone Receptor (HR)-positive (73.3 %) HER2-positive (10.2 %), and triple negative (TN, 22.5 %). 86.4 % of the patients presented with visceral metastases, mainly in the liver (67.4 %). Median previous metastatic chemotherapies number was 4 [1-9]. Previous treatments included anthracyclines and/or taxanes (100 %) and capecitabine (90.7 %). Median number of EM cycles was 5 [1-19]. The relative dose intensity was 0.917. At the time of analysis (median follow-up of 13.9 months), 42.3 % of the patients were still alive. The objective response rate was 25.2 % (95 %CI: 20-31) with a 36.1 % clinical benefit rate (CBR). Median time to progression (TTP) and overall survival were 3.97 (95 %CI: 3.25-4.3) and 11.2 (95 %CI: 9.3-12.1) months, respectively. One- and 2-year survival rates were 45.5 and 8.5 %, respectively. In multivariate analysis, HER2 positivity (HR = 0.29), the presence of lung metastases (HR = 2.49) and primary taxanes resistance (HR = 2.36) were the only three independent CBR predictive factors, while HR positivity (HR = 0.67), the presence of lung metastases (HR = 1.52) and primary taxanes resistance (HR = 1.50) were the only three TTP independent prognostic factors. Treatment was globally well tolerated. Most common grade 3-4 toxicities were neutropenia (20.9 %), peripheral neuropathy (3.9 %), anaemia (1.6 %), liver dysfunction (0.8 %) and thrombocytopenia (0.4 %). Thirteen patients (5 %) developed febrile neutropenia. CONCLUSION: EM is an effective new option in heavily pretreated MBC, with a favourable efficacy/safety ratio in a clinical practice setting. Our results comfort the use of this new molecule and pledge for the evaluation of EM-trastuzumab combination in this setting. Tumour biology, primary taxanes sensitivity and metastatic sites could represent useful predictive and prognostic factors.

Chemical Biology Screen for Prostate Cancer Therapeutics

Prostate cancer initially responds to hormone-based therapeutics such as anti-androgen treatment or chemotherapeutics but eventually becomes resistant. Novel treatment options are therefore urgently needed. This thesis study applied a high-throughput screen of 4910 known drugs and drug-like small molecules to identify compounds that selectively inhibit growth of prostate cancer cells. In addition, the mechanisms underlying the cellular sensitivity to potent cancer selective compounds were addressed. Surprisingly, many of the compounds currently used in the clinics or studied in clinical trials were not cancer-selective. Only four drugs, aldehyde dehydrogenase inhibitor disulfiram (Antabus), antibiotic ionophore monensin, histone deacetylase inhibitor tricostatin A and fungicide thiram inhibited prostate cancer cell growth at nanomolar concentrations without major effects on non-malignant prostate epithelial cells. Disulfiram, monensin and a structurally similar compound to monensin, salinomycin, induced oxidative stress and inhibited aldehyde dehydrogenase activity. Moreover, monensin and salinomycin reduced androgen receptor signalling and steroidogenesis, enforced cell differentiation and reduced the overall levels of cancer stem cells. Taken together, novel and potentially prostate cancer-selective therapeutic agents were identified in this study, including the description of a multitude of intoxicating mechanisms such as those relating to oxidative stress. The results provide novel insights into prostate cancer biology and exemplify useful means of considering novel approaches to cancer treatment.

A Farewell to Flat Biology. Three-dimensional Cell Culture Models in Cancer Drug Target Identification and Validation

Cells of epithelial origin, e.g. from breast and prostate cancers, effectively differentiate into complex multicellular structures when cultured in three-dimensions (3D) instead of conventional two-dimensional (2D) adherent surfaces. The spectrum of different organotypic morphologies is highly dependent on the culture environment that can be either non-adherent or scaffold-based. When embedded in physiological extracellular matrices (ECMs), such as laminin-rich basement membrane extracts, normal epithelial cells differentiate into acinar spheroids reminiscent of glandular ductal structures. Transformed cancer cells, in contrast, typically fail to undergo acinar morphogenic patterns, forming poorly differentiated or invasive multicellular structures. The 3D cancer spheroids are widely accepted to better recapitulate various tumorigenic processes and drug responses. So far, however, 3D models have been employed predominantly in the Academia, whereas the pharmaceutical industry has yet to adopt a more widely and routine use. This is mainly due to poor characterisation of cell models, lack of standardised workflows and high throughput cell culture platforms, and the availability of proper readout and quantification tools. In this thesis, a complete workflow has been established entailing well-characterised 3D cell culture models for prostate cancer, a standardised 3D cell culture routine based on high-throughput-ready platform, automated image acquisition with concomitant morphometric image analysis, and data visualisation, in order to enable large-scale high-content screens. Our integrated suite of software and statistical analysis tools were optimised and validated using a comprehensive panel of prostate cancer cell lines and 3D models. The tools quantify multiple key cancer-relevant morphological features, ranging from cancer cell invasion through multicellular differentiation to growth, and detect dynamic changes both in morphology and function, such as cell death and apoptosis, in response to experimental perturbations including RNA interference and small molecule inhibitors. Our panel of cell lines included many non-transformed and most currently available classic prostate cancer cell lines, which were characterised for their morphogenetic properties in 3D laminin-rich ECM. The phenotypes and gene expression profiles were evaluated concerning their relevance for pre-clinical drug discovery, disease modelling and basic research. In addition, a spontaneous model for invasive transformation was discovered, displaying a highdegree of epithelial plasticity. This plasticity is mediated by an abundant bioactive serum lipid, lysophosphatidic acid (LPA), and its receptor LPAR1. The invasive transformation was caused by abrupt cytoskeletal rearrangement through impaired G protein alpha 12/13 and RhoA/ROCK, and mediated by upregulated adenylyl cyclase/cyclic AMP (cAMP)/protein kinase A, and Rac/ PAK pathways. The spontaneous invasion model tangibly exemplifies the biological relevance of organotypic cell culture models. Overall, this thesis work underlines the power of novel morphometric screening tools in drug discovery.

Libyan breast cancer: Health services and biology. Diagnosis delay and prognostic value of DNA pploidy, S-phase fraction, and Ki-67 and Bcl-2 immunohistochemistry

The aim of this study was to investigate the diagnosis delay and its impact on the stage of disease. The study also evaluated a nuclear DNA content, immunohistochemical expression of Ki-67 and bcl-2, and the correlation of these biological features with the clinicopathological features and patient outcome. 200 Libyan women, diagnosed during 2008–2009 were interviewed about the period from the first symptoms to the final histological diagnosis of breast cancer. Also retrospective preclinical and clinical data were collected from medical records on a form (questionnaire) in association with the interview. Tumor material of the patients was collected and nuclear DNA content analysed using DNA image cytometry. The expression of Ki-67 and bcl-2 were assessed using immunohistochemistry (IHC). The studies described in this thesis show that the median of diagnosis time for women with breast cancer was 7.5 months and 56% of patients were diagnosed within a period longer than 6 months. Inappropriate reassurance that the lump was benign was an important reason for prolongation of the diagnosis time. Diagnosis delay was also associated with initial breast symptom(s) that did not include a lump, old age, illiteracy, and history of benign fibrocystic disease. The patients who showed diagnosis delay had bigger tumour size (p<0.0001), positive lymph nodes (p<0.0001), and high incidence of late clinical stages (p<0.0001). Biologically, 82.7% of tumors were aneuploid and 17.3% were diploid. The median SPF of tumors was 11% while the median positivity of Ki-67 was 27.5%. High Ki-67 expression was found in 76% of patients, and high SPF values in 56% of patients. Positive bcl-2 expression was found in 62.4% of tumors. 72.2% of the bcl-2 positive samples were ER-positive. Patients who had tumor with DNA aneuploidy, high proliferative activity and negative bcl-2 expression were associated with a high grade of malignancy and short survival. The SPF value is useful cell proliferation marker in assessing prognosis, and the decision cut point of 11% for SPF in the Libyan material was clearly significant (p<0.0001). Bcl-2 is a powerful prognosticator and an independent predictor of breast cancer outcome in the Libyan material (p<0.0001). Libyan breast cancer was investigated in these studies from two different aspects: health services and biology. The results show that diagnosis delay is a very serious problem in Libya and is associated with complex interactions between many factors leading to advanced stages, and potentially to high mortality. Cytometric DNA variables, proliferative markers (Ki-67 and SPF), and oncoprotein bcl-2 negativity reflect the aggressive behavior of Libyan breast cancer and could be used with traditional factors to predict the outcome of individual patients, and to select appropriate therapy.

Computational models for and from biology : simple gene assembly and reaction systems

The advancement of science and technology makes it clear that no single perspective is any longer sufficient to describe the true nature of any phenomenon. That is why the interdisciplinary research is gaining more attention overtime. An excellent example of this type of research is natural computing which stands on the borderline between biology and computer science. The contribution of research done in natural computing is twofold: on one hand, it sheds light into how nature works and how it processes information and, on the other hand, it provides some guidelines on how to design bio-inspired technologies. The first direction in this thesis focuses on a nature-inspired process called gene assembly in ciliates. The second one studies reaction systems, as a modeling framework with its rationale built upon the biochemical interactions happening within a cell. The process of gene assembly in ciliates has attracted a lot of attention as a research topic in the past 15 years. Two main modelling frameworks have been initially proposed in the end of 1990s to capture ciliates’ gene assembly process, namely the intermolecular model and the intramolecular model. They were followed by other model proposals such as templatebased assembly and DNA rearrangement pathways recombination models. In this thesis we are interested in a variation of the intramolecular model called simple gene assembly model, which focuses on the simplest possible folds in the assembly process. We propose a new framework called directed overlap-inclusion (DOI) graphs to overcome the limitations that previously introduced models faced in capturing all the combinatorial details of the simple gene assembly process. We investigate a number of combinatorial properties of these graphs, including a necessary property in terms of forbidden induced subgraphs. We also introduce DOI graph-based rewriting rules that capture all the operations of the simple gene assembly model and prove that they are equivalent to the string-based formalization of the model. Reaction systems (RS) is another nature-inspired modeling framework that is studied in this thesis. Reaction systems’ rationale is based upon two main regulation mechanisms, facilitation and inhibition, which control the interactions between biochemical reactions. Reaction systems is a complementary modeling framework to traditional quantitative frameworks, focusing on explicit cause-effect relationships between reactions. The explicit formulation of facilitation and inhibition mechanisms behind reactions, as well as the focus on interactions between reactions (rather than dynamics of concentrations) makes their applicability potentially wide and useful beyond biological case studies. In this thesis, we construct a reaction system model corresponding to the heat shock response mechanism based on a novel concept of dominance graph that captures the competition on resources in the ODE model. We also introduce for RS various concepts inspired by biology, e.g., mass conservation, steady state, periodicity, etc., to do model checking of the reaction systems based models. We prove that the complexity of the decision problems related to these properties varies from P to NP- and coNP-complete to PSPACE-complete. We further focus on the mass conservation relation in an RS and introduce the conservation dependency graph to capture the relation between the species and also propose an algorithm to list the conserved sets of a given reaction system.

KAIRON PROJECT : assessing the role of expressive arts in community-based breast cancer support systems in the Niagara Region

Research Report Written for the Canadian Breast Cancer Foundation.

Performances de la puce exon et son application dans l’analyse de l’épissage alternatif associé à la métastase du cancer de sein

Nous montrons l’utilisation de la puce exon d’Affymetrix pour l’analyse simultanée de l’expression des gènes et de la variation d’isoformes. Nous avons utilisé les échantillons d’ARN du cerveau et des tissus de référence qui ont été antérieurement utilisés dans l’étude du consortium MicroArray Quality Control (MAQC). Nous démontrons une forte concordance de la quantification de l’expression des gènes entre trois plateformes d’expression populaires à savoir la puce exon d’Affymetrix, la puce Illumina et la puce U133A d’Affymetrix. Plus intéressant nous montrons que la majorité des discordances entre les trois plateformes résulterait des positions différentes des sondes à travers les plateformes et que les variations d’isoforme exactes ne peuvent être identifiées que par la puce exon. Nous avons détecté avec succès, entre les tissus de référence et ceux du cerveau, une centaine de cas d’évènements d’épissage alternatif. La puce exon est requise dans l’analyse de l’épissage alternatif associé aux pathologies telles que les cancers et les troubles neurologiques. Comme application de cette technologie, nous avons analysé les variations d’épissage dans la métastase du cancer de sein développé dans le model de la souris. Nous avons utilisé une gamme bien définie de trois lignées de tumeur mammaire ayant différents potentiels métastatiques. Par des analyses statistiques, nous avons répertorié 2623 transcripts présentant des variations d’expression et d’isoformes entre les types de tumeur. Une analyse du réseau de gènes montre qu’environ la moitié d’entre eux est impliquée dans plusieurs activités cellulaires, ainsi que dans nombreux cancers et désordres génétiques.

Développement et caractérisation de nouveaux modèles du cancer épithélial de l’ovaire

Le cancer épithélial de l’ovaire (EOC) est le plus mortel des cancers gynécologiques. Cette maladie complexe progresse rapidement de façon difficilement décelable aux stades précoces. De plus, malgré une chirurgie cytoréductive et des traitements de chimiothérapie le taux de survie des patientes diagnostiquées aux stades avancées demeurt faible. Dans le but d’étudier l’EOC dans un contexte ex vivo, l’utilisation de modèles cellulaires est indispensable. Les lignées cellulaires d’EOC sont un outil pratique pour la recherche cependant, la façon dont l'expression des gènes est affectée en culture par comparaison à la tumeur d'origine n'est pas encore bien élucidée. Notre objectif était donc de développer et de caractériser de nouveaux modèles de culture in vitro qui réflèteront plus fidèlement la maladie in vivo. Nous avons tout d’abord utiliser des lignées cellulaires disponibles au laboratoire afin de mettre au point un modèle 3D de culture in vitro d’EOC. Des sphéroïdes ont été générés à l’aide de la méthode des gouttelettes inversées, une méthode pionnière pour la culture des cellules tumorales. Nous avons ensuite procédé à une analyse des profils d’expression afin de comparer le modèle sphéroïde au modèle de culture en monocouche et le modèle xénogreffe in vivo. Ainsi, nous avons identifié des gènes stratifiant les modèles tridimensionnels, tant in vivo qu’in vitro, du modèle 2D monocouche. Parmi les meilleurs candidats, nous avons sélectionné S100A6 pour une caractérisation ultérieure. L’expression de ce gène fût modulée afin d’étudier l’impact de son inhibition sur les paramètres de croissance des sphéroïdes. L’inhibition de ce gène a comme effet de réduire la motilité cellulaire mais seulement au niveau du modèle sphéroïde. Finalement, toujours dans l’optique de développer des modèles d’EOC les plus représentatifs de la maladie in vivo, nous avons réussi à développer des lignées cellulaires uniques dérivées de patientes atteintes d’EOC du type séreux, soit le plus commun des EOC. Jusque là, très peu de lignées cellulaires provenant de ce type de cancer et de patientes n’ayant pas reçu de chimiothérapie ont été produites. De plus, nous avons pour la première fois caractérise des lignées d’EOC de type séreux provenant à la fois de l’ascite et de la tumeur solide de la même patiente.

Purification and Characterization of an Anti-cancer Enzyme Produced by Marine Vibrio Costicola Under A Novel Solid State Fermentation Process

L - Glutaminase, a therapeutically and industrially important enzyme, was produced from marine Vibrio costicola by a novel solid state fermentation process using polystyrene beads as inert support. The new fermentation system offered several advantages over the conventional systems, such as the yield of leachate with minimum viscosity and high specific activity for the target product besides facilitating the easy estimation of biomass. The enzyme thus produced was purified and characterised. It was active at physiological pH, showed high substrate specificity towards L - glutamine and had a Km value of 7.4 x 10-2 M. It also exhibited high salt and temperature tolerance indicating good scope for its industrial and therapeutic applications

First steps in experimental cancer evolution

Evolutionary processes play a central role in the development, progression and response to treatment of cancers. The current challenge facing researchers is to harness evolutionary theory to further our understanding of the clinical progression of cancers. Central to this endeavour will be the development of experimental systems and approaches by which theories of cancer evolution can be effectively tested. We argue here that the experimental evolution approach – whereby evolution is observed in real time and which has typically employed microorganisms – can be usefully applied to cancer. This approach allows us to disentangle the ecological causes of natural selection, identify the genetic basis of evolutionary changes and determine their repeatability. Cell cultures used in cancer research share many of the desirable traits that make microorganisms ideal for studying evolution. As such, experimental cancer evolution is feasible and likely to give great insight into the selective pressures driving the evolution of clinically destructive cancer traits. We highlight three areas of evolutionary theory with importance to cancer biology that are amenable to experimental evolution: drug resistance, social evolution and resource competition. Understanding the diversity, persistence and evolution of cancers is vital for treatment and drug development, and an experimental evolution approach could provide strategic directions and focus for future research.

Aluminium and breast cancer: sources of exposure, tissue measurements and mechanisms of toxicological actions on breast biology

This review examines recent evidence linking exposure to aluminium with the aetiology of breast cancer. The human population is exposed to aluminium throughout daily life including through diet, application of antiperspirants, use of antacids and vaccination. Aluminium has now been measured in a range of human breast structures at higher levels than in blood serum and experimental evidence suggests that the tissue concentrations measured have the potential to adversely influence breast epithelial cells including generation of genomic instability, induction of anchorage-independent proliferation and interference in oestrogen action. The presence of aluminium in the human breast may also alter the breast microenvironment causing disruption to iron metabolism, oxidative damage to cellular components, inflammatory responses and alterations to the motility of cells. The main research need is now to investigate whether the concentrations of aluminium measured in the human breast can lead in vivo to any of the effects observed in cells in vitro and this would be aided by the identification of biomarkers specific for aluminium action.