The brain decade in debate: II. Panic or anxiety? From animal models to a neurobiological basis

This article is a transcription of an electronic symposium sponsored by the Brazilian Society of Neuroscience and Behavior (SBNeC). Invited researchers from the European Union, North America and Brazil discussed two issues on anxiety, namely whether panic is a very intense anxiety or something else, and what aspects of clinical anxiety are reproduced by animal models. Concerning the first issue, most participants agreed that generalized anxiety and panic disorder are different on the basis of clinical manifestations, drug response and animal models. Also, underlying brain structures, neurotransmitter modulation and hormonal changes seem to involve important differences. It is also common knowledge that existing animal models generate different types of fear/anxiety. A challenge for future research is to establish a good correlation between animal models and nosological classification.

The brain decade in debate: III. Neurobiology of emotion

This article is a transcription of an electronic symposium in which active researchers were invited by the Brazilian Society of Neuroscience and Behavior (SBNeC) to discuss the advances of the last decade in the neurobiology of emotion. Four basic questions were debated: 1) What are the most critical issues/questions in the neurobiology of emotion? 2) What do we know for certain about brain processes involved in emotion and what is controversial? 3) What kinds of research are needed to resolve these controversial issues? 4) What is the relationship between learning, memory and emotion? The focus was on the existence of different neural systems for different emotions and the nature of the neural coding for the emotional states. Is emotion the result of the interaction of different brain regions such as the amygdala, the nucleus accumbens, or the periaqueductal gray matter or is it an emergent property of the whole brain neural network? The relationship between unlearned and learned emotions was also discussed. Are the circuits of the former the underpinnings of the latter? It was pointed out that much of what we know about emotions refers to aversively motivated behaviors, like fear and anxiety. Appetitive emotions should attract much interest in the future. The learning and memory relationship with emotions was also discussed in terms of conditioned and unconditioned stimuli, innate and learned fear, contextual cues inducing emotional states, implicit memory and the property of using this term for animal memories. In a general way it could be said that learning modifies the neural circuits through which emotional responses are expressed.

Decreased left temporal lobe volume of panic patients measured by magnetic resonance imaging

Reported neuroimaging studies have shown functional and morphological changes of temporal lobe structures in panic patients, but only one used a volumetric method. The aim of the present study was to determine the volume of temporal lobe structures in patients with panic disorder, measured by magnetic resonance imaging. Eleven panic patients and eleven controls matched for age, sex, handedness, socioeconomic status and years of education participated in the study. The mean volume of the left temporal lobe of panic patients was 9% smaller than that of controls (t21 = 2.37, P = 0.028). In addition, there was a trend (P values between 0.05 and 0.10) to smaller volumes of the right temporal lobe (7%, t21 = 1.99, P = 0.06), right amygdala (8%, t21 = 1.83, P = 0.08), left amygdala (5%, t21 = 1.78, P = 0.09) and left hippocampus (9%, t21 = 1.93, P = 0.07) in panic patients compared to controls. There was a positive correlation between left hippocampal volume and duration of panic disorder (r = 0.67, P = 0.025), with recent cases showing more reduction than older cases. The present results show that panic patients have a decreased volume of the left temporal lobe and indicate the presence of volumetric abnormalities of temporal lobe structures.

Absence-like seizures in adult rats following pilocarpine-induced status epilepticus early in life

Administration of pilocarpine causes epilepsy in rats if status epilepticus (SE) is induced at an early age. To determine in detail the electrophysiological patterns of the epileptogenic activity in these animals, 46 Wistar rats, 7-17 days old, were subjected to SE induced by pilocarpine and electro-oscillograms from the cortex, hippocampus, amygdala, thalamus and hypothalamus, as well as head, rostrum and vibrissa, eye, ear and forelimb movements, were recorded 120 days later. Six control animals of the same age range did not show any signs of epilepsy. In all the rats subjected to SE, iterative spike-wave complexes (8.1 ± 0.5 Hz in frequency, 18.9 ± 9.1 s in duration) were recorded from the frontal cortex during absence fits. However, similar spike-wave discharges were always found also in the hippocampus and, less frequently, in the amygdala and in thalamic nuclei. Repetitive or single spikes were also detected in these same central structures. Clonic movements and single jerks were recorded from all the rats, either concomitantly with or independently of the spike-wave complexes and spikes. We conclude that rats made epileptic with pilocarpine develop absence seizures also occurring during paradoxical sleep, showing the characteristic spike-wave bursts in neocortical areas and also in the hippocampus. This is in contrast to the well-accepted statement that one of the main characteristics of absence-like fits in the rat is that spike-wave discharges are never recorded from the hippocampal fields.

The neurobiology of infant maternal odor learning

Infant rats must learn to identify their mother’s diet-dependent odor. Once learned, maternal odor controls pups’ approach to the mother, their social behavior and nipple attachment. Here we present a review of the research from four different laboratories, which suggests that neural and behavioral responses to the natural maternal odor and neonatal learned odors are similar. Together, these data indicate that pups have a unique learning circuit relying on the olfactory bulb for neural plasticity and on the hyperfunctioning noradrenergic locus coeruleus flooding the olfactory bulb with norepinephrine to support the neural changes. Another important factor making this system unique is the inability of the amygdala to become incorporated into the infant learning circuit. Thus, infant rats appear to be primed in early life to learn odors that will evoke approach responses supporting attachment to the caregiver.

Neural regulation of the stress response: glucocorticoid feedback mechanisms

The mammalian stress response is an integrated physiological and psychological reaction to real or perceived adversity. Glucocorticoids are an important component of this response, acting to redistribute energy resources to both optimize survival in the face of challenge and to restore homeostasis after the immediate challenge has subsided. Release of glucocorticoids is mediated by the hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, driven by a neural signal originating in the paraventricular nucleus (PVN). Stress levels of glucocorticoids bind to glucocorticoid receptors in multiple body compartments, including the brain, and consequently have wide-reaching actions. For this reason, glucocorticoids serve a vital function in negative feedback inhibition of their own secretion. Negative feedback inhibition is mediated by a diverse collection of mechanisms, including fast, non-genomic feedback at the level of the PVN, stress-shut-off at the level of the limbic system, and attenuation of ascending excitatory input through destabilization of mRNAs encoding neuropeptide drivers of the HPA axis. In addition, there is evidence that glucocorticoids participate in stress activation via feed-forward mechanisms at the level of the amygdala. Feedback deficits are associated with numerous disease states, underscoring the necessity for adequate control of glucocorticoid homeostasis. Thus, rather than having a single, defined feedback ‘switch’, control of the stress response requires a wide-reaching feedback ‘network’ that coordinates HPA activity to suit the overall needs of multiple body systems.

The influence of stress on fear memory processes

It is well recognized that stressful experiences promote robust emotional memories, which are well remembered. The amygdaloid complex, principally the basolateral complex (BLA), plays a pivotal role in fear memory and in the modulation of stress-induced emotional responses. A large number of reports have revealed that GABAergic interneurons provide a powerful inhibitory control of the activity of projecting glutamatergic neurons in the BLA. Indeed, a reduced GABAergic control in the BLA is essential for the stress-induced influence on the emergence of associative fear memory and on the generation of long-term potentiation (LTP) in BLA neurons. The extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) subfamily of the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) signaling pathway in the BLA plays a central role in the consolidation process and synaptic plasticity. In support of the view that stress facilitates long-term fear memory, stressed animals exhibited a phospho-ERK2 (pERK2) increase in the BLA, suggesting the involvement of this mechanism in the promoting influence of threatening stimuli on the consolidation fear memory. Moreover, the occurrence of reactivation-induced lability is prevented when fear memory is encoded under intense stressful conditions since the memory trace remains immune to disruption after recall in previously stressed animals. Thus, the underlying mechanism in retrieval-induced instability seems not to be functional in memories formed under stress. All these findings are indicative that stress influences both the consolidation and reconsolidation fear memory processes. Thus, it seems reasonable to propose that the emotional state generated by an environmental challenge critically modulates the formation and maintenance of long-term fear memory.

What ethologically based models have taught us about the neural systems underlying fear and anxiety

Classical Pavlovian fear conditioning to painful stimuli has provided the generally accepted view of a core system centered in the central amygdala to organize fear responses. Ethologically based models using other sources of threat likely to be expected in a natural environment, such as predators or aggressive dominant conspecifics, have challenged this concept of a unitary core circuit for fear processing. We discuss here what the ethologically based models have told us about the neural systems organizing fear responses. We explored the concept that parallel paths process different classes of threats, and that these different paths influence distinct regions in the periaqueductal gray - a critical element for the organization of all kinds of fear responses. Despite this parallel processing of different kinds of threats, we have discussed an interesting emerging view that common cortical-hippocampal-amygdalar paths seem to be engaged in fear conditioning to painful stimuli, to predators and, perhaps, to aggressive dominant conspecifics as well. Overall, the aim of this review is to bring into focus a more global and comprehensive view of the systems organizing fear responses.

On the relationships between ultrasonic calling and anxiety-related behavior in rats

In the present review, the phenomenon of ultrasonic vocalization in rats will be outlined, including the three classes of vocalizations, namely 40-kHz calls of pups, and 22- and 50-kHz calls of juvenile and adult rats, their general relevance to behavioral neuroscience, and their special relevance to research on anxiety, fear, and defense mechanisms. Here, the emphasis will be placed on 40- and 22-kHz calls, since they are typical for various situations with aversive properties. Among other topics, we will discuss whether such behavioral signals can index a certain affective state, and how these signals can be used in social neuroscience, especially with respect to communication. Furthermore, we will address the phenomenon of inter-individual variability in ultrasonic calling and what we currently know about the mechanisms, which may determine such variability. Finally, we will address the current knowledge on the neural and pharmacological mechanisms underlying 22-kHz ultrasonic vocalization, which show a substantial overlap with mechanisms known from other research on fear and anxiety, such as those involving the periaqueductal gray or the amygdala.

Psychopathy and Aggression: Examining the Role of Empathy

Empirical research has consistently demonstrated a positive association between psychopathic traits and physical aggression (Campbell, Porter, & Santor, 2004; Gretton, Hare, & Catchpole, 2004; Raine et aI., 2006; Spain, Douglas, Poythress, & Epstein, 2004). Moreover, research has also found that the emotional/interpersonal (Factor 1) psychopathy traits tend to be more closely associated with goal oriented, proactive aggression, whereas the social deviance (Factor 2) psychopathy characteristics have been more closely linked to reactive aggression, which is perpetrated in response to threat or provocation (Flight & Forth, 2007). Blair (2004; 2005; 2006) has recently proposed the Integrated Emotions Systems Model (lES), which posits that the association between Factor 1 psychopathy traits and proactive aggression is due to amygdala dysfunction leading to failed moral socialization. Consequently, individuals who exhibit Factor 1 psychopathy traits do not experience affective empathy in response to distress cues exhibited by others, thus, preventing the inhibition of proactive aggression. The current investigation sought to test this model by examining the associations among the emotional/interpersonal (Factor 1) psychopathy traits, proactive aggression, and affective empathy. After accounting for head injury, Factor 2 psychopathy traits, reactive aggression, and cognitive empathy, it was hypothesized that 1) Factor 1 psychopathy traits would predict proactive aggression, and 2) that affective empathy is a common cause of Factor 1 psychopathy traits, proactive aggression, and of the relationship between these two constructs. This hypothesis assumed that (a) affective empathy would uniquely predict Factor 1 psychopathy traits, (b) that affective empathy would uniquely predict proactive aggression, and (c) that affective empathy would account for the relationship between Factor I psychopathy traits and proactive aggression. The total sample consisted of 137 male undergraduate students. Participants completed measures of psychopathy (SRP III; Paulhus, Hemphill, & Hare, in press), aggression (PCS; Marsee, Kimonis, & Frick, 2004; RPQ; Raine et at, 2006), dispositional cognitive and affective empathy (BES; Jolliffe & Farrington, 2006; TES; Spreng, McKinnon, Mar, & Levine, 2009), and situational cognitive and affective empathy in response to neutral and empathy eliciting video clips. Physiological indices (heart rate & electrodermal activity) of affective empathy were also obtained while participants viewed the neutral and empathy eliciting videos. Findings indicated that Factor I psychopathy traits predicted proactive aggression. In addition, results demonstrated that affective empathy predicted both Factor I psychopathy traits and proactive aggression. However, the association between affective empathy and proactive aggression appeared to be dependent on the conceptualization and measurement of affective empathy. Conversely, affective empathy did not appear to account for the relationship between Factor I psychopathy traits and proactive aggression. Overall, results demonstrated partial support for the IES model. Implications of the results, limitations of the study and future research directions are discussed.

Effects of social context on endocrine function and Zif268 expression in response to an acute stressor in adolescent and adult rats

There is a paucity of studies comparing social buffering in adolescents and adults, despite their marked differences in social behaviour. I investigated whether greater effects of social buffering on plasma corticosterone concentrations and expression of Zif268 in neural regions after an acute stressor would be found in adolescent compared with adult rats. Samples were obtained before and after one hour of isolation stress and after either one or three hours of recovery back in the colony with either a familiar or unfamiliar cage partner. Adolescent and adult rats did not differ in plasma concentrations of corticosterone at any time point. Corticosterone concentrations were higher after one hour isolation than at baseline (p < 0.001), and rats with a familiar partner during the recovery phase had lower corticosterone concentrations than did rats with an unfamiliar partner (p = 0.02). Zif268 immunoreactive cell counts were higher in the arcuate nucleus in both age groups after isolation (p = 0.007) and higher in the paraventricular nucleus of adolescents compared with adults during the recovery phase irrespective of partner familiarity. There was a significant decrease in immunoreactive cell counts after one hour isolation compared to baseline in the basolateral amygdala, central nucleus of the amygdala, and in the pyramidal layer of the hippocampus (all p < 0.05). An effect of partner familiarity on Zif268 immunoreactive cell counts was found in the granule layer of the dentate gyrus irrespective of age (higher in those with a familiar partner, p = 0.03) and in the medial prefrontal cortex in adolescents (higher with an unfamiliar partner, p = 0.02). Overall, the acute stress and partner familiarity produced a similar pattern of results in adolescents and adults, with both age groups sensitive to the social context.

Mécanismes de plasticité synaptique dans l’amygdale lors de la réactivation de la mémoire de peur auditive chez le rat : interaction dynamique des récepteurs NMDA et AMPA

La plasticité synaptique est une propriété indispensable à l’acquisition de la mémoire chez toutes les espèces étudiées, des invertébrés aux primates. La formation d’une mémoire débute par une phase de plasticité qui inclut une restructuration synaptique ; ensuite elle se poursuit par la consolidation de ces modifications, contribuant à la mémoire à long terme. Certaines mémoires redeviennent malléables lorsqu’elles sont rappelées. La trace mnésique entre alors dans une nouvelle de phase de plasticité, au cours de laquelle certaines composantes de la mémoire peuvent être mises à jour, puis reconsolidées. L’objectif de la présente thèse est d’étudier les mécanismes cellulaires et moléculaires qui sont activés lors du rappel d’une mémoire. Nous avons utilisé un modèle de conditionnement Pavlovien, combiné à l’administration d’agents pharmacologiques et à l’analyse quantitative de marqueurs de plasticité synaptique, afin d’étudier la dynamique de la mémoire de peur auditive chez des rats Sprague Dawley. La circuiterie neuronale et les mécanismes associatifs impliqués dans la neurobiologie de cette mémoire sont bien caractérisés, en particulier le rôle des récepteurs glutamatergiques de type NMDA et AMPA dans la plasticité synaptique et la consolidation. Nos résultats démontrent que le retour de la trace mnésique à un état de labilité nécessite l’activation des récepteurs NMDA dans l’amygdale baso-latérale à l’instant même du rappel, alors que les récepteurs AMPA sont requis pour l’expression comportementale de la réponse de peur conditionnée. D’autre part, les résultats identifient le rappel comme une phase bien plus dynamique que présumée, et suggèrent que l’expression de la peur conditionnée mette en jeu la régulation du trafic des récepteurs AMPA par les récepteurs NMDA. Le présent travail espère contribuer à la compréhension de la neurobiologie fondamentale de la mémoire. De plus, il propose une intégration des résultats aux modèles animaux d’étude des troubles psychologiques conséquents aux mémoires traumatiques chez l’humain, tels que les phobies et les syndromes de stress post-traumatiques.

Les mécanismes endogènes de modulation de la douleur et leur dysfonction dans le syndrome de l'intestin irritable

La douleur est une expérience subjective multidimensionnelle accompagnée de réponses physiologiques. Ces dernières sont régulées par des processus cérébraux qui jouent un rôle important dans la modulation spinale et cérébrale de la douleur. Cependant, les mécanismes de cette régulation sont encore mal définis et il est essentiel de bien les comprendre pour mieux traiter la douleur. Les quatre études de cette thèse avaient donc comme objectif de préciser les mécanismes endogènes de modulation de la douleur par la contreirritation (inhibition de la douleur par une autre douleur) et d’investiguer la dysfonction de ces mécanismes chez des femmes souffrant du syndrome de l’intestin irritable (Sii). Dans un premier temps, un modèle expérimental a été développé pour mesurer l’activité cérébrale en imagerie par résonance magnétique fonctionnelle concurremment à l’enregistrement du réflexe nociceptif de flexion (RIII : index de nociception spinale) et des réponses de conductance électrodermale (SCR : index d’activation sympathique) évoqués par des stimulations électriques douloureuses. La première étude indique que les différences individuelles d’activité cérébrale évoquée par les stimulations électriques dans les cortex orbitofrontal (OFC) et cingulaire sont associées aux différences individuelles de sensibilité à la douleur, de réactivité motrice (RIII) et de réactivité autonomique (SCR) chez des sujets sains. La deuxième étude montre que l’analgésie par contreirritation produite chez des sujets sains est accompagnée de l’inhibition de l’amygdale par OFC et d’une modulation du réflexe RIII par la substance grise périaqueducale (PAG) et le cortex somesthésique primaire (SI). Dans les troisième et quatrième études, il est montré que la contreirritation ne produit pas d’inhibition significative de la douleur et du réflexe RIII chez les patientes Sii en comparaison aux contrôles. De plus, les résultats indiquent que la sévérité des symptômes psychologiques est associée au déficit de modulation de la douleur et à une hypersensibilité diffuse chez les patientes Sii. Dans l’ensemble, cette thèse précise le rôle de certaines structures cérébrales dans les multiples composantes de la douleur et dans l’analgésie par contreirritation et montre que les patientes Sii présentent une dysfonction des mécanismes spinaux et cérébraux impliqués dans la perception et la modulation de la douleur.

Lactobacillus helveticus R0052 et Bifidobacterium longum R0175 en combinaison réduisent l’apoptose dans le système limbique après ischémie myocardique transitoire chez le rat

Nous avons démontré la présence d'apoptose dans le système limbique suivant un infarctus du myocarde. Cette mort cellulaire serait partiellement reliée à l'augmentation de cytokines pro-inflammatoires. Des études démontrent que certains probiotiques ont des effets bénéfiques en diminuant le ratio de cytokines pro/anti-inflammatoires. La prise de probiotiques en prévention, avant l’occlusion d’une artère coronarienne, pourrait-elle diminuer l’apoptose dans le système limbique? Méthodes : La combinaison de probiotiques Lactobacillus helveticus R0052 et Bifidobacterium longum R0175 ou son véhicule fut additionné dans l’eau des rats pendant 28 jours consécutifs. Un infarctus du myocarde fut provoqué par l’occlusion de l’artère coronaire gauche. Après 40 minutes d'occlusion, les régions ischémiques ont été reperfusées pour 72 heures. Les animaux furent sacrifiés et la taille de l'infarctus mesurée. L'amygdale et l'hippocampe furent prélevés pour déterminer l'activité de la caspase-3 (pro-apoptotique), le ratio Bax/Bcl2(proapoptotique/ anti-apoptotique) et l'activité d'Akt (survie cellulaire). Résultats : La taille de l’infarctus n'est pas diminuée dans le groupe probiotique (45% de la région à risque)comparé au groupe placebo. Nos marqueurs d’apoptose démontrent une diminution dans les régions du gyrus denté, de l’amygdale latérale et médiane dans le groupe probiotique par rapport au placebo. L’activité de la caspase-3 et le ratio Bax:Bcl2 furent réduits dans le groupe probiotique de 50% et 40% respectivement (p < 0.05) et phosphorylation d’Akt fut augmentée de 35% (p<0.05). Aucune différence fut observée pour les régions Ca1 et Ca3. Conclusion : La combinaison de probiotiques utilisée réduit l’apoptose dans différentes régions du système limbique 72 heures après un IM.

Caractérisation de l’apoptose observée dans le système limbique après une ischémie myocardique transitoire chez le rat

Au niveau clinique, il a été observé que de 15 à 30 % des patients qui ont subi un infarctus du myocarde développent une dépression majeure. De plus, la population atteinte de dépression post-infarctus présente un risque de mortalité de trois à quatre fois plus élevé, et ce, en comparaison avec la population non dépressive post-infarctus. Dans un modèle de rat développé pour étudier la dépression post-infarctus, des cellules apoptotiques ont été retrouvées au niveau du système limbique. Il apparaît que les cytokines seraient en partie responsables de cette mort cellulaire qui relie le cœur en ischémie et le système nerveux central. Donc, les objectifs de cette thèse sont : 1) de caractériser spatialement et temporellement la survenue de la mort cellulaire par apoptose dans les structures du système limbique du rat, à la suite d’un infarctus du myocarde ; 2) de déterminer l’effet de l’anti-inflammatoire celecoxib sur cette apoptose observée au niveau de l’amygdale et de déterminer l’implication de l’enzyme COX-2 ; 3) de déterminer l’implication de la cytokine pro-inflammatoire TNF-α dans l’apoptose observée au niveau des structures du système limbique du rat, à la suite d’un infarctus du myocarde. Afin d’atteindre ces objectifs, les rats ont subi une ischémie de 40 minutes, suivi d’une période de reperfusion qui varie d’un protocole à l’autre (15 minutes, 24, 48, 72 heures ou 7 jours). De plus, en fonction du protocole, ces rats ont été traités avec soit du célécoxib (inhibiteur sélectif de la COX-2), soit avec du PEG sTNF-R1 (inhibiteur du TNF-α). À la suite de ces protocoles, les rats ont été sacrifiés, la taille de l’infarctus a été déterminée et les différentes structures cérébrales du système limbique prélevées. Des tests biochimiques propres à chaque protocole ont été réalisés afin de documenter l'apoptose. Il a alors été observé qu’aucun des deux traitements ne présentait d’effet sur la taille de l’infarctus. L’étude de l’apoptose dans le système limbique a révélé que : 1) le processus apoptotique se mettait en place dans l’hippocampe dès les 15 premières minutes de reperfusion suivant l’infarctus du myocarde et que ce processus était spatialement dynamique dans le système limbique jusqu’au septième jour postreperfusion ; 2) il est apparu que la COX-2 était impliquée dans l'apoptose du système limbique ; 3) il a été observé que le TNF-α périphérique était impliqué dans ce processus apoptotique après 72 heures de reperfusion en activant la voie extrinsèque de l'apoptose. Ces résultats ont permis de caractériser la survenue de l’apoptose au niveau du système limbique chez le rat à la suite d’un infarctus du myocarde et de documenter l'implication de la COX-2 et du TNF-α dans ce processus. Bien que ces résultats n’apportent pas de schémas thérapeutiques clairs ou de mécanismes physiopathologiques globaux ces derniers permettent une meilleure compréhension de la relation existante entre le cœur et le système nerveux central dans le cadre de l’infarctus du myocarde. De manière moins spécifique ils précisent la relation entre le système inflammatoire et le système nerveux central.