Fatty acids, eicosanoids, and hypolipidemic agents identified as ligands of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors by coactivator-dependent receptor ligand assay.

Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors (PPARs) are nuclear hormone receptors controlling the expression of genes involved in lipid homeostasis. PPARs activate gene transcription in response to a variety of compounds including hypolipidemic drugs as well as natural fatty acids. From the plethora of PPAR activators, Scatchard analysis of receptor-ligand interactions has thus far identified only four ligands. These are the chemotactic agent leukotriene B4 and the hypolipidemic drug Wy 14,643 for the alpha-subtype and a prostaglandin J2 metabolite and synthetic antidiabetic thiazolidinediones for the gamma-subtype. Based on the hypothesis that ligand binding to PPAR would induce interactions of the receptor with transcriptional coactivators, we have developed a novel ligand sensor assay, termed coactivator-dependent receptor ligand assay (CARLA). With CARLA we have screened several natural and synthetic candidate ligands and have identified naturally occurring fatty acids and metabolites as well as hypolipidemic drugs as bona fide ligands of the three PPAR subtypes from Xenopus laevis. Our results suggest that PPARs, by their ability to interact with a number of structurally diverse compounds, have acquired unique ligand-binding properties among the superfamily of nuclear receptors that are compatible with their biological activity.

Functional interaction between the estrogen receptor and CTF1: analysis of the vitellogenin gene B1 promoter in yeast.

Eukaryotic gene expression depends on a complex interplay between the transcriptional apparatus and chromatin structure. We report here a yeast model system for investigating the functional interaction between the human estrogen receptor (hER) and CTF1, a member of the CTF/NFI transcription factor family. We show that a CTF1-fusion protein and the hER transactivate a synthetic promoter in yeast in a synergistic manner. This interaction requires the proline-rich transactivation domain of CTF1. When the natural estrogen-dependent vitellogenin B1 promoter is tested in yeast, CTF1 and CTF1-fusion proteins are unable to activate transcription, and no synergy is observed between hER, which activates the B1 promoter, and these factors. Chromatin structure analysis on this promoter reveals positioned nucleosomes at -430 to -270 (+/-20 bp) and at -270 to - 100 (+/-20 bp) relative to the start site of transcription. The positions of the nucleosomes remain unchanged upon hormone-dependent transcriptional activation of the promoter, and the more proximal nucleosome appears to mask the CTF/NFI site located at - 101 to -114. We conclude that a functional interaction of hER with the estrogen response element located upstream of a basal promoter occurs in yeast despite the nucleosomal organization of this promoter, whereas the interaction of CTF1 with its target site is apparently precluded by a nucleosome.

The distribution of the dinucleotide CpG and cytosine methylation in the vitellogenin gene family.

Sequence data from regions of five vertebrate vitellogenin genes were used to examine the frequency, distribution, and mutability of the dinucleotide CpG, the preferred modification site for eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases. The observed level of the CpG dinucleotide in all five genes was markedly lower than that expected from the known mononucleotide frequencies. CpG suppression was greater in introns than in exons. CpG-containing codons were found to be avoided in the vitellogenin genes, but not completely despite the redundancy of the genetic code. Frequency and distribution patterns of this dinucleotide varied dramatically among these otherwise closely related genes. Dense clusters of CpG dinucleotides tended to appear in regions of either functional or structural interest (e.g., in the transposon-like Vi-element of Xenopus) and these clusters contained 5-methylcytosine (5 mC). 5 mC is known to undergo deamination to form thymidine, but the extent to which this transition occurs in the heavily methylated genomes of vertebrates and its contribution to CpG suppression are still unclear. Sequence comparison of the methylated vitellogenin gene regions identified C----T and G----A substitutions that were found to occur at relatively high frequencies. The predicted products of CpG deamination, TpG and CpA, were elevated. These findings are consistent with the view that CpG distribution and methylation are interdependent and that deamination of 5 mC plays an important role in promoting evolutionary change at the nucleotide sequence level.

Regulation by aldosterone of Na+,K+-ATPase mRNAs, protein synthesis, and sodium transport in cultured kidney cells.

Transepithelial Na+ reabsorption across tight epithelia is regulated by aldosterone. Mineralocorticoids modulate the expression of a number of proteins. Na+,K+-ATPase has been identified as an aldosterone-induced protein (Geering, K., M. Girardet, C. Bron, J. P. Kraehenbuhl, and B. C. Rossier, 1982, J. Biol. Chem., 257:10338-10343). Using A6 cells (kidney of Xenopus laevis) grown on filters we demonstrated by Northern blot analysis that the induction of Na+,K+-ATPase was mainly mediated by a two- to fourfold accumulation of both alpha- and beta-subunit mRNAs. The specific competitor spironolactone decreased basal Na+ transport, Na+,K+-ATPase mRNA, and the relative rate of protein biosynthesis, and it blocked the response to aldosterone. Cycloheximide inhibited the aldosterone-dependent sodium transport but did not significantly affect the cytoplasmic accumulation of Na+,K+-ATPase mRNA induced by aldosterone.

The contact region between three domains of the extracellular loop of ASIC1a is critical for channel function.

Acid-sensing ion channels are members of the epithelial Na(+) channel/degenerin family. They are neuronal nonvoltage-gated Na(+) channels that are activated by extracellular acidification. In this study, we investigated the role of a highly conserved region of the extracellular part of ASIC1a that forms the contact between the finger domain, the adjacent beta-ball, and the upper palm domain in ASIC1a. The finger domain contributes to the pH-dependent gating and is linked via this contact zone to the rest of the protein. We found that mutation to Cys of residues in this region led to decreased channel expression and current amplitudes. Exposure of the engineered Cys residues to Cd(2+) or to charged methane thiosulfonate sulfhydryl reagents further reduced current amplitudes. This current inhibition was not due to changes in acid-sensing ion channel pH dependence or unitary conductance and was likely due to a decrease of the probability of channel opening. For some mutants, the effect of sulfhydryl reagents depended on the pH of exposure in the range 7.4 to 6.8, suggesting that this zone undergoes conformational changes during inactivation. Our study identifies a region in ASIC1a whose integrity is required for normal channel function.

The estrogen-responsive element as an inducible enhancer: DNA sequence requirements and conversion to a glucocorticoid-responsive element.

The estrogen-responsive element (ERE) present in the 5'-flanking region of the Xenopus laevis vitellogenin (vit) gene B1 has been characterized by transient expression analysis of chimeric vit-tk-CAT (chloramphenicol acetyltransferase) gene constructs transfected into the human estrogen-responsive MCF-7 cell line. The vit B1 ERE behaves like an inducible enhancer, since it is able to confer estrogen inducibility to the heterologous HSV thymidine kinase (tk) promoter in a relative position- and orientation-independent manner. In this assay, the minimal B1 ERE is 33 bp long and consists of two 13 bp imperfect palindromic elements both of which are required for the enhancer activity. A third imperfect palindromic element is present further upstream within the 5'-flanking region of the gene but is unable to confer hormone responsiveness by itself. Similarly, neither element forming the B1 ERE can alone confer estrogen inducibility to the tk promoter. However, in combinations of two, all three imperfect palindromes can act cooperatively to form a functional ERE. In contrast a single 13 bp perfect palindromic element, GGTCACTGTGACC, such as the one found upstream of the vit gene A2, is itself sufficient to act as a fully active ERE. Single point mutations within this element abolish estrogen inducibility, while a defined combination of two mutations converts this ERE into a glucocorticoid-responsive element.

Sequence homologies in the region preceding the transcription initiation site of the liver estrogen-responsive vitellogenin and apo-VLDLII genes.

In the liver of oviparous vertebrates vitellogenin gene expression is controlled by estrogen. The nucleotide sequence of the 5' flanking region of the Xenopus laevis vitellogenin genes A1, A2, B1 and B2 has been determined. These sequences have been compared to each other and to the equivalent region of the chicken vitellogenin II and apo-VLDLII genes which are also expressed in the liver in response to estrogen. The homology between the 5' flanking region of the Xenopus genes B1 and B2 is higher than between the corresponding regions of the other closely related genes A1 and A2. Four short blocks of sequence homology which are present at equivalent positions in the vitellogenin genes of both Xenopus laevis and chicken are characterized. A short sequence with two-fold rotational symmetry (GGTCANNNTGACC) was found at similar positions upstream of the five vitellogenin genes and is also present in two copies close to the 5' end of the chicken apo-VLDLII gene. The possible functional significance of this sequence, common to liver estrogen-responsive genes, is discussed.

Estrogen-dependent in vitro transcription from the vitellogenin promoter in liver nuclear extracts.

One approach to analyzing the molecular mechanisms of gene expression in vivo is to reconstitute these events in cell-free systems in vitro. Although there is some evidence for tissue-specific transcription in vitro, transcriptionally active extracts that mimic a steroid hormone-dependent enhancement of transcription have not been described. In the study reported here, nuclear extracts of liver from the frog Xenopus laevis were capable of estrogen-dependent induction of a homologous vitellogenin promoter that contained the estrogen-responsive element.

Activation/division of lymphocytes results in increased levels of cytoplasmic activation/proliferation-associated protein-1: prototype of a new family of proteins.

We purified from activated T lymphocytes a novel, highly conserved, 116-kDa, intracellular protein that occurred at high levels in the large, dividing cells of the thymus, was up-regulated when resting T or B lymphocytes or hemopoietic progenitors were activated, and was down-regulated when a monocytic leukemia, M1, was induced to differentiate. Expression of the protein was highest in the thymus and spleen and lowest in tissues with a low proportion of dividing cells such as kidney or muscle, although expression was high in the brain. The protein was localized to the cytosol and was phosphorylated, which is consistent with a previous report that the Xenopus laevis ortholog was phosphorylated by a mitotically activated kinase (1 ). The cDNA was previously mischaracterized as encoding p137, a 137-kDa GPI-linked membrane protein (2 ). We propose that the authentic protein encoded by this cDNA be called cytoplasmic activation/proliferation-associated protein-1 (caprin-1), and show that it is the prototype of a novel family of proteins characterized by two novel protein domains, termed homology regions-1 and -2 (HR-1, HR-2). Although we have found evidence for caprins only in urochordates and vertebrates, two insect proteins exhibit well-conserved HR-1 domains. The HR-1 and HR-2 domains have no known function, although the HR-1 of caprin-1 appeared necessary for formation of multimeric complexes of caprin-1. Overexpression of a fusion protein of enhanced green fluorescent protein and caprin-1 induced a specific, dose-dependent suppression of the proliferation of NIH-3T3 cells, consistent with the notion that caprin-1 plays a role in cellular activation or proliferation.

PPAR disruption: Cellular mechanisms and physiological consequences

Endocrine disruption is defined as the perturbation of the endocrine system, which includes disruption of nuclear hormone receptor signalling. Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors (PPARs) represent a family of nuclear receptors that has not yet been carefully studied with regards to endocrine disruption, despite the fact that PPARs are known to be important targets for xenobiotics. Here we report a first comprehensive approach aimed at defining the mechanistic basis of PPAR disruption focusing on one chemical, the plasticizer monethylhexyl phthalate (MEHP), but using a variety of methodologies and models. We used mammalian cells and a combination of biochemical and live cell imaging techniques to show that MEHP binds to PPAR gamma and selectively regulates interactions with coregulators. Micro-array experiments further showed that this selectivity is translated at the physiological level during adipocyte differentiation. In that context, MEHP functions as a selective PPAR modulator regulating only a subset of PPAR gamma target genes compared to the action of a full agonist. We also explored the action of MEHP on PPARs in an aquatic species, Xenopus laevis, as many xenobiotics are found in aquatic ecosystems. In adult males, micro-array data indicated that MEHP influences liver physiology, possibly through a cross-talk between PPARs and estrogen receptors (ER). In early Xenopus laevis embryos, we showed that PPAR beta/delta exogenous activation by an agonist or by MEHP affects development. Taken together our results widen the concept of endocrine disruption by pinpointing PPARs as key factors in that process.

Amphibian albumins as members of the albumin, alpha-fetoprotein, vitamin D-binding protein multigene family.

The Xenopus laevis 68-kd and 74-kd albumin amino acid sequences are examined with respect to their relationship to the other known members of the albumin/alpha-fetoprotein/vitamin D-binding protein gene family. Each of the three members of this family presents a unique pattern of conserved regions indicating a differential selective pressure related to specific functional characteristics. Furthermore, an evolutionary tree of these genes was deduced from the divergence times calculated from direct nucleotide sequence comparisons of individual gene pairs. These calculations indicate that the vitamin D-binding protein/albumin separation occurred 560-600 million years (Myr) ago and the albumin/alpha-fetoprotein divergence 280 Myr ago. This observation leads to the hypothesis according to which the albumin/alpha-fetoprotein gene duplication occurred shortly after the amphibian/reptile separation. Consequently, and unlike mammals, amphibians and fishes should lack an alpha-fetoprotein in their serum at larval stages, which is consistent with a recent analysis of serum proteins in Xenopus laevis larvae. This hypothesis now will have to be tested further in additional lower vertebrates.

Regulation of the vitellogenin gene B1 promoter after transfer into hepatocytes in primary cultures.

The estrogen-dependent and tissue-specific regulation of the Xenopus laevis vitellogenin gene B1 promoter has been studied by lipid-mediated DNA transfer into Xenopus hepatocytes in primary culture. Hepatocytes achieve an efficient hormonal control of this promoter through a functional interaction between the estrogen responsive elements and a promoter proximal region upstream of the TATA box, which is characterized by a high density of binding sites for the transcription factors CTF/NF-1, C/EBP and HNF3. DNA accessibility to restriction enzymes within the chromosomal copy of the vitellogenin gene B1 promoter shows that the estrogen responsive unit and the promoter proximal region are sensitive to digestion in uninduced and estrogen-induced hepatocytes but not in erythrocyte nuclei. Together, these findings support the notion that chromatin configuration as well as the interplay of promoter elements mediate proper hormone-dependent and tissue-specific expression of the B1 vitellogenin gene.

Génération d'une souris dépourvue du gène VIT32 de manière conditionnelle: étude du phénotype rénal chez les souris dépourvues de RGS2

Résumé Dans le rein, la vasopressine possède un rôle essentiel dans la régulation fine du transport d'eau et participe au contrôle de la réabsorption du sodium. Cette action est conduite par l'activation du récepteur à la vasopressine V2R situé dans l'anse de Henle, dans le tubule connecteur et dans le canal collecteur du néphron des rongeurs et conduit à la formation d'AMPc entraînant un mécanisme d'action caractérisé par deux phases distinctes. Le premier effet de la vasopressine est non génomique et a lieu rapidement après l'activation du récepteur, la deuxième phase est plus tardive et possède la caractéristique de moduler la transcription d'un réseau de gènes. Parmi ces gènes, plusieurs sont directement impliqués dans le transport d'eau et de sodium, comme l'Aqp2 et 3, ENaC et la Na,K-ATPase. L'identification des effets de la voie de signalisation de la vasopressine représente un point crucial pour la compréhension des mécanismes moléculaires de la réabsorption de l'eau et du sodium dans le néphron. L'analyse en série de l'expression de gènes (SAGE) réalisée en 2001 dans notre laboratoire a permis de caractériser le transcriptome dépendant de la vasopressine dans la lignée cellulaire mpkCCDc14,a dérivée du canal collecteur cortical (CCD) de souris. Deux des transcrits induits par la vasopressine (VIT) ont fait l'objet des études de ce travail de thèse. Le premier est VIT32 (Vasopressin induced transcript 32) qui code pour une protéine ne possédant aucune homologie avec des domaines protéiques dont la fonction est connue. Dans le système d'expression de l'ovocyte de Xenopus laevis, VIT32 induit la maturation des ovocytes et diminue le courant sensible à l'amiloride de manière dépendante de la voie des MAPK. Dans les mpkCCDc14, l'inhibition de la voie des MAPK diminue le courant sodique en diminuant l'activité de la Na,K-ATPase, mais sans modifier le courant d'ENaC. Ainsi la voie de signalisation des MAPK peut avoir des cibles différentes suivant le système dans lequel elle est étudiée. C'est pourquoi nous avons décidé de poursuivre l'étude de VIT32 dans un contexte physiologique en créant une souris dépourvue du gène codant pour VIT32 de manière conditionnelle (conditional knockout). La première partie de cette thèse a donc consisté à générer cette souris. Le deuxième transcrit induit par la vasopressine qui a été étudié dans cette thèse est RGS2 (Regulator of G protein Signaling 2). In vitro, il a été montré que RGS2 inhibe des voies de signalisation dépendantes de récepteurs couplés à des protéines Gq et Gs. Dans notre étude, nous avons montré que dans le néphron de rein de souris, RGS2 est colocalisé avec V2R. In vivo, la vasopressine sécrétée lors d'une restriction en eau imposée à des souris augmente l'expression de RGS2. De plus, l'accumulation d'AMPc engendrée par l'action de la vasopressine sur les canaux collecteurs est significativement plus grande chez les souris dépourvues de RGS2 (rgs2 -/-). Cette induction de la signalisation de la vasopressine est corrélée à une augmentation de la réabsorption d'eau chez les souris rgs2 -/-. Ainsi RGS2 serait impliqué dans le rétrocontrôle négatif de la voie de signalisation de la vasopressine. Abstract In the kidney, vasopressin plays a key role in the control of water balance and participates in salt reabsorption. These actions are induced by the activation of V2 vasopressin receptor (V2R) located in the loop of Henle, in the connecting tubule and in the collecting duct leading to an increase in intracellular cAMP levels. The V2R-mediated vasopressin action elicits a rapid, non-genomic effect, during which water and salt reabsorption is rapidly increased and a late or genomic effect characterised by the long-term regulation of water and salt reabsorption through the transcriptional activation of a gene network that includes Aqp2, Aqp3, ENaC and Na,K-ATPase. Serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE) performed in 2001 in our laboratory characterised the vasopressin induced transcripts (VIT) in the mpkCCDc14 cell line. Two of them are studied in this thesis. The first one is VIT32 (Vasopressin induced transcript 32) that encodes a protein that has no homology with any protein domain of known function. In the Xenopus laevis oocyte, VIT32 induces oocyte maturation and downregulates the ENaC amiloride sensitive current via the activation of the MAPK pathway. In mpkCCDc14 cell line, the MAPK pathway inhibition leads to a decrease of Na,K-ATPase activity without affecting ENaC current. Therefore, the MAPK pathway can act on different targets depending on the cellular context. Thus, we decided to investigate the function of VIT32 in its physiological environment by performing a conditional knockout mouse of VIT32. The first part of this thesis consisted in generating this mouse. The second studied vasopressin induced transcript is RGS2 (Regulator of G protein Signaling 2). In vitro, RGS2 has been shown to inhibit Gq and Gs protein-coupled receptor pathway. In our study we show that RGS2 is co-localized with V2R in the mouse nephron. In vivo, vasopressin secreted during water restriction up-regulates RGS2 expression. Moreover, vasopressin-dependant accumulation of CAMP is significantly increased in the cortical collecting duct of RGS2 knockout mice. This increase is correlated with an increase in water reabsorption. RGS2 could be involved in the negative feedback regulation of V2R signalling. Résumé tout public Le corps humain est composé d'environ 60% d'eau répartie à l'intérieur et à l'extérieur des cellules de notre organisme. Les cellules, unités fondamentales du vivant, puisent l'oxygène et les nutriments indispensables à leur fonctionnement dans le liquide extracellulaire. La composition du milieu doit être constante, car les variations peuvent perturber considérablement et parfois fatalement la fonction des cellules. Ainsi les organismes pluricellulaires ont développé des mécanismes permettant de contrôler la constance du milieu extracellulaire afin de maintenir l'état d'équilibre nommé homéostasie. Le rein joue un rôle majeur dans cette homéostasie grâce à sa capacité de réabsorber l'eau et les solutés en fonction des besoins de l'organisme. Cette fonction du rein est régulée par différentes hormones comme la vasopressine, qui permet de contrôler la réabsorption fine de l'eau et des solutés. Dans leurs membranes, les cellules possèdent des récepteurs leur permettant de répondre aux signaux extracellulaires comme le sont entre autres les hormones. Ainsi les cellules sensibles à la vasopressine possèdent un récepteur nommé V2R qui permet d'intégrer les signaux de la vasopressine en déclenchant tout une cascade d'événements conduisant à une modification de l'expression de certaines protéines impliquées directement ou non dans la réabsorption de l'eau et des solutés. Une étude précédente élaborée au sein de notre laboratoire a permis de répertorier les protéines dont l'expression est augmentée par de la vasopressine. Deux de ces protéines ont fait l'objet des études de cette thèse. La première protéine induite par la vasopressine est VIT32 (Vasopressin induced transcript 32). Cette protéine est entre autres impliquée dans la réabsorption du sodium, mais la fonction précise de VIT32 dans ce transport n'a pas pu être déterminée. Une des approches possibles pour l'étude de la fonction d'une protéine est de supprimer son expression chez la souris et d'étudier les conséquences de son absence. Ces souris sont appelées des souris knockout, puisque la protéine en question ne peut plus agir. La première partie de cette thèse a donc consisté à générer une souris dépourvue du gène de VIT32. La deuxième protéine étudiée est RGS2 (Regulator of G protein Signaling 2). Cette protéine inhibe certaines voies de signalisation activées par différentes hormones. Dans cette partie du travail de thèse, nous avons pu mettre en évidence que RGS2 agit comme un inhibiteur de la voie de signalisation de la vasopressine. En modifiant cette signalisation, RGS2 serait donc un médiateur du contrôle de la réabsorption d'eau dans les cellules du rein sensibles à la vasopressine.

Molecular cloning of exons II and III of the a-globin major gene from Odontophrynus americanus 2n and 4n (Amphibia, Anura)

The a-globin major genes from diploid and tetraploid Odontophrynus americanus were studied using PCR-based technology. The cloned and sequenced amplified fragments were shown to contain most of the exon II sequences as well as the whole exon III sequence of the a-globin gene. Unexpectedly, intron 2 was entirely absent in the amplified fragments of both 2n and 4n origin. High conservation was observed among the obtained sequences when compared to corresponding sequences from human and Xenopus laevis origin. The possibility that these sequences might be pseudogenes is raised

Alternative splicing of DNA polymerase beta in vertebrates

Alternative splicing (AS) is the predominant mechanism responsible for increasing eukaryotic transcriptome and proteome complexity. In this phenomenon, numerous mRNA transcripts are produced from a single pre-mRNA sequence. AS is reported to occur in 95% of human multi-exon genes; one specific gene that undergoes AS is DNA polymerase beta (POLB). POLB is the main DNA repair gene which performs short patch base excision repair (BER). In primate untransformed primary fibroblast cell lines, it was determined that the splice variant (SV) frequency of POLB correlates positively with species lifespan. To date, AS patterns of POLB have only been examined in mammals primarily through the use of cell lines. However, little attention has been devoted to investigating if such a relationship exists in non-mammals and whether cell lines reflect what is observed in vertebrate tissues. This idea was explored through cloning and characterization of 1,214 POLB transcripts from four non-mammalian species (Gallus gallus domesticus, Larus glaucescens, Xenopus laevis, and Pogona vitticeps) and two mammalian species (Sylvilagus floridanus and Homo sapiens) in two tissue types, liver and brain. POLB SV frequency occurred at low frequencies, < 3.2%, in non-mammalian tissues relative to mammalian (>20%). The highest POLB SV frequency was found in H. sapiens liver and brain tissues, occurring at 65.4% and 91.7%, respectively. Tissue specific AS of POLB was observed in L. glaucescens, P. vitticeps, and H. sapiens, but not G. gallus domesticus, X. laevis and S. floridanus.The AS patterns of a second gene, transient receptor potential cation channel subfamily V member 1 (TRPV1), were compared to those of POLB in liver and brain tissues of G. gallus domesticus, X. laevis and H. sapiens. This comparison was performed to investigate if any changes (either increase or decrease) observed in the AS of POLB were gene specific or if they were tissue specific, in which case similar changes in AS would be seen in POLB and TRPV1. Analysis did not reveal an increase or decrease in both the AS of POLB and TRPV1 in either the liver or brain tissues of G. gallus domesticus and H. sapiens. This result suggested that the AS patterns of POLB were not influenced by tissue specific rates of AS. Interestingly, an increase in the AS of both genes was only observed in X. laevis brain tissue. This result suggests that AS in general may be increased in the X. laevis brain as compared to liver tissue. No positive correlation between POLB SV frequency and species lifespan was found in non-mammalian tissues. The AS patterns of POLB in human primary untransformed fibroblast cell lines were representative of those seen in human liver tissue but not in brain tissue. Altogether, the AS patterns of POLB from vertebrate tissues and primate cell lines revealed a positive correlation between POLB SV frequency and lifespan in mammals, but not in non-mammals. It appears that this positive correlation does not exist in vertebrate species as a whole.