Le mouvement peut-il guérir? : histoire de l'engagement des médecins français dans l'élaboration de l'éducation physique (1741-1888)

Résumé : Cette recherche doctorale analyse l'engagement des médecins français autour de l'éducation physique entre 1741 et 1888. Basé sur un travail prosopographique d'identification des médecins qui ont participé à l'élaboration de l'éducation physique, ce travail repose sur une mise en dialogue de leurs prises de position respectives. Pour réaliser cette enquête, nous avons compulsé un large corpus de sources primaires, composé des ouvrages consacrés à la gymnastique médicale mais aussi une très large portion de la production d'imprimés touchant à l'anatomie, l'hygiène, la thérapeutique, la physiologie, l'orthopédie, etc. Le corpus contient également des articles des principaux dictionnaires médicaux de la période et des principales revues médicales du XIXe siècle. Avec une approche critique de l'historiographie et à partir de ce corpus, nous avons travaillé dans le cadre de contextes définis pour saisir au plus près les logiques sociales et scientifiques amenant les médecins auprès de l'éducation physique. Trois conjonctures successives structurent l'engagement médical. Entre 1741 et 1817, la thèse retrace l'émergence d'un questionnement ; les années 1817-1847 constituent un « moment orthopédique » dans la formulation de la gymnastique ; et finalement entre 1847 et 1888, on observe une diversification des voies de légitimation médicale des exercices du corps. Ces trois moments de l'histoire des « discours gymniques médicaux » proposent un certain nombre de convergences : la prégnance de l'orthopédie, une certaine concentration autour de la santé des corps féminins, l'inclusion dans un « projet hygiéniste » ; mais aussi des divergences et des singularités : relatives à la progressive structuration en cours du champ médical, à l'implication progressive du politique (surtout après 1845/1850), aux transformations des pathologies/doctrines médicales « dominantes », ainsi qu'à l'importance plus ou moins forte de l'une ou l'autre des facettes de l'éducation physique (militaire, athlétique, « médicinale » ou pédagogique). Le processus est aussi celui de l'expérimentation de la curation de certaines pathologies (scolioses, affections nerveuses), dans des configurations idéologiques/scientifiques marquées par la « dégénération » (XVIIIe siècle), l'anatomie pathologique (début du XIXe siècle) et plus tard la « dégénérescence » et les affections nerveuses (après 1850). Dans le cadre d'une dynamique d'inspiration « foucaldienne », ces recommandations évoluent d'une anatomopolitique - caractérisée par un essor de discours empreints d'anatomie au XVIIIe siècle - vers une biopolitique - caractérisée par l'engagement de l'Etat qui fait de la gymnastique une discipline d'enseignement, pensée à des fins hygiéniques dans la seconde moitié du XIXe - où le processus réside en fait dans une biologisation progressive des recommandations pratiques. Observée à l'aune de la formulation médicale de l'éducation physique, la biopolitique n'est pas réalisée dans la seconde moitié du XVIIIe, elle se compose lentement aux marges de l'institution scolaire et des gymnastiques pédagogico-militaires pour constituer un projet thérapeutique et hygiénique plus construit après 1850. Abstract : This dissertation analyzes French doctor's involvement in debates and initiatives concerning physical education between 1741 and 1888. Based on a prosopographic inventory of those physicians who participated in the development of physical education, it explores the variety of their discourses with respect to the practice of physical exercises. This investigation relies on a large selection of primary sources: works devoted to medical gymnastic, but also medical treatises related to anatomy, hygiene, therapeutics, physiology, orthopedics, etc. The sources also include articles from the major medical dictionaries and journals of the nineteenth century. These documents are used to explore the socio-scientific mechanisms that underlay physicians' commitment to physical education. Three chronological periods structure medical engagement in the area of physical education. Between 1741 and 1817 the thesis traces the emergence of a questioning; the years 1817 to 1847 represent an « orthopedic moment » in the development of gymnastics; finally between 1847 and 1888, one witnesses a diversification of the legitimation process between medicine and gymnastics. These three moments in the history of « medical and gymnastic discourses » offer a number of similarities: the weight of orthopedics, the ongoing focus on the health of the female body, and the association of these discourses with a « hygienic project ». But differences also distinguish these periods as the medical field became more structured and new medical doctrines became dominant, with the increasing involvement of politics (especially after 1850), and with the changing weight of priorities within physical education (military, athletic, « medical » or pedagogic). Medical discourses centered on the curing of certain diseases (scoliosis or nervous disorders) are analyzed within an ideological configuration marked by the idea of « degeneration » (in the eighteenth century), « pathological anatomy » (in the early nineteenth century) and later « dégénérescence » associated with nervous disorders (after 1850). The dissertation draws on Foucault's historical epistemology to understand how medical recommendations evolve from an anatomopolitics - characterized by a surge in anatomical discourses - toward a biopolitics - characterized by the commitment of the State to introduce gymnastics for hygienic purposes into schools in the second half of the nineteenth century. This process reveals a progressive "biologization" of practical recommendations. The medical discourses about physical education show that Foucault's biopolitical power is not achieved in the second half of the eighteenth century, but develops slowly at the margins of the school system and of pedagogical and military gymnastic, becoming a veritable hygienic and therapeutic project only after 1850.

Use of trochanteric nail for proximal femoral extracapsular fractures.

Proximal femoral extracapsular fractures have shown a significantly high morbidity and mortality rate at 1 year in cases of nonoperative treatment. The standard gamma nail was originally designed to provide stable fixation and allow early mobilization and weight bearing for elderly patients. The design of the standard gamma nail, however, appears to be associated with intraoperative or postoperative femoral shaft fractures in < or = 17% of patients, compromising the outcome. The trochanteric nail was developed to overcome the problems encountered with the use of the standard gamma nail. Between July 2000 and January 2001, 88 consecutive proximal femoral extracapsular fractures were treated with a trochanteric nail, Seventy-five patients (76 fractures) were observed clinically and radiographically for 2 years.

Cross-cultural adaptations of the Oxford-12 HIP score to the French speaking population.

BACKGROUND: An objective measurement of surgical procedures outcomes is inherent to professional practices quality control; this especially applies in orthopaedics to joint replacement outcomes. A self-administered questionnaire offers an attractive alternative to surgeon's judgement but is infrequently used in France for these purposes. The British questionnaire, the 12-item Oxford Hip Score (OHS) was selected for this study because of its ease of use. HYPOTHESIS: The objective of this study was to validate the French translation of the self-assessment 12-item Oxford Hip Score and compare its results with those of the reference functional scores: the Harris Hip Score (HHS) and the Postel-Merle d'Aubigné (PMA) score. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Based on a clinical series of 242 patients who were candidates for total hip arthroplasty, the French translation of this questionnaire was validated. Its coherence was also validated by comparing the preoperative data with the data obtained from the two other reference clinical scores. RESULTS: The translation was validated using the forward-backward translation procedure from French to English, with correction of all differences or mistranslations after systematized comparison with the original questionnaire in English. The mean overall OHS score was 43.8 points (range, 22-60 points) with similarly good distribution of the overall value of the three scores compared. The correlation was excellent between the OHS and the HHS, but an identical correlation between the OHS and the PMA was only obtained for the association of the pain and function parameters, after excluding the mobility criterion, relatively over-represented in the PMA score. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Subjective questionnaires that contribute a personal appreciation of the results of arthroplasty by the patient can easily be applied on a large scale. This study made a translated and validated version of an internationally recognized, reliable self-assessment score available to French orthopaedic surgeons. The results obtained encourage us to use this questionnaire as a complement to the classical evaluation scores and methods.

The AO comprehensive classification of pediatric long-bone fractures: a web-based multicenter agreement study.

The first AO comprehensive pediatric long-bone fracture classification system has been proposed following a structured path of development and validation with experienced pediatric surgeons. A Web-based multicenter agreement study involving 70 surgeons in 15 clinics and 5 countries was conducted to assess the reliability and accuracy of this classification when used by a wide range of surgeons with various levels of experience. Training was provided at each clinic before the session. Using the Internet, participants could log in at any time and classify 275 supracondylar, radius, and tibia fractures at their own pace. The fracture diagnosis was made following the hierarchy of the classification system using both clinical terminology and codes. kappa coefficients for the single-surgeon diagnosis of epiphyseal, metaphyseal, or diaphyseal fracture type were 0.66, 0.80, and 0.91, respectively. Median accuracy estimates for each bone and type were all greater than 80%. Depending on their experience and specialization, surgeons greatly varied in their ability to classify fractures. Pediatric training and at least 2 years of experience were associated with significant improvement in reliability and accuracy. Kappa coefficients for diagnosis of specific child patterns were 0.51, 0.63, and 0.48 for epiphyseal, metaphyseal, and diaphyseal fractures, respectively. Identified reasons for coding discrepancies were related to different understandings of terminology and definitions, as well as poor quality radiographic images. Results supported some minor adjustments in the coding of fracture type and child patterns. This classification system received wide acceptance and support among the surgeons involved. As long as appropriate training could be performed, the system classification was reliable, especially among surgeons with a minimum of 2 years of clinical experience. We encourage broad-based consultation between surgeons' international societies and the use of this classification system in the context of clinical practice as well as prospectively for clinical studies.

Readmission from orthopedic surgical site infections: an integrative review

Abstract OBJECTIVE Characterizing readmissions from orthopedic surgical site infections. METHOD An integrative review of literature in the LILACS, IBECS, MEDLINE, Cochrane, SciELO and PUBMED databases, using the descriptors Patient readmission, Wound infection, Cross infection, Orthopedic procedures, Orthopedics. RESULTS 78 studies were identified and 10 publications were selected. Surgical site infections are the most common cause of unplanned orthopedic readmissions, representing long periods of hospitalization, new surgical procedures and high costs, and greater possibility of subsequent hospitalizations. Most significant predictors have indicated average length of hospitalization, need for intensive care, emergency status at admission, risk of death, age > 65 years, males and higher body mass index. CONCLUSION Readmission rates have increasingly become measures of quality and concerns about costs. New studies could involve issues related to indirect costs, specifically social and psychological costs.

Manifestations neurologiques des troubles musculosquelettiques [Neurological manifestations in musculoskeletal disorders].

Musculoskeletal disorders are a crossroad among diverse specialties: neurology, rehabilitation, orthopedics, occupational medicine and psycho-traumatology. They are integrated into occupational medicine and encompass overuse syndromes, repeated micro-trauma and focal compressive neuropathies linked with professional or sports' activity. Neurological manifestations are omnipresent. Yet, their importance is not always recognized despite frequent resort to neurologists specialized in peripheral nervous system disorders and neurophysiology, as well as, to behavioral cognition specialists. Therapeutic approaches require preventive and work organization measures, neurophysiologic investigations and imaging in expert hands, and conservative treatment with physiotherapy, with or without paraneural and intra-articular injections.

Outcome of subscapularis muscle release for shoulder contracture secondary to brachial plexus palsy at birth.

Children with unresolved brachial plexus palsy frequently develop a disabling internal rotation contracture of the shoulder. Several surgical options, including soft tissue procedures such as muscle releases and/or transfers, and bone operations such as humeral osteotomy are available to correct this deformity. This study describes the effect of subscapularis muscle release performed in isolation. Thirteen patients (5 boys, 8 girls) were reviewed at an average of 3.5 years after their surgery (range, 2-7 years). Their mean age at operation was 4.7 years (range, 1-8 years). Three children had C5-C6 palsies, 8 had C5-C7 palsies, and 2 had C5-C8 palsies. Postoperatively, patients presented significant gains in shoulder active lateral rotation (+49 degrees, from 5 to 54 degrees), active abduction (+30 degrees, from 63 to 93 degrees), active flexion (+46 degrees, from 98 to 144 degrees), and active extension (+23 degrees, from 7 to 30 degrees). Gains were also observed in passive range of motion, but of a lesser degree. Subscapularis muscle release is a procedure we found to have few significant complications and was highly effective in increasing active range of motion and restoring shoulder function.

Use of a dynamic foot pressure index to monitor the effects of treatment for equinus gait in children with cerebral palsy.

The purpose of this study is to introduce and describe a newly developed index using foot pressure analysis to quantify the degree of equinus gait in children with cerebral palsy before and after injection with botulinum toxin. Data were captured preinjection and 12 weeks postinjection. Ten children aged 2(1/2) to 6(1/2) years took part (5 boys and 5 girls). Three of them had a diagnosis of spastic diplegia and 7 of congenital hemiplegia. In total, 13 limbs were analyzed. After orientation and segmentation of raw pedobarographic data, we determined a dynamic foot pressure index graded 0 to 100 that quantified the relative degree of heel and forefoot contact during stance. These data were correlated (Pearson correlation) with clinical measurements of dorsiflexion at the ankle (on a slow and fast stretch) and video observation (using the Observational Gait Scale). Pedobarograph data were strongly correlated with both the Observational Gait Scale scores (R = 0.79, P < 0.005) and clinical measurements of dorsiflexion on a fast stretch, which is reflective of spasticity (R = 0.70, P < 0.005). We demonstrated the index's sensitivity in detecting changes in spasticity and good correlation with video observations seems to indicate this technique's potential validity. When manipulated and segmented appropriately, and with the development of a simple ordinal index, we found that foot pressure data provided a useful tool in tracking changes in patients with spastic equinus.

Psychopathologie chez les enfants de patients souffrant de troubles liés à une substance ou de troubles de l'humeur

L'objectif principal de cette thèse est d'exposer les résultats des premières évaluations psychopathologiques menées, dans le cadre d'une étude familiale, sur une cohorte d'enfants de patients souffrant de troubles liés à des substances ou de troubles de l'humeur. Plus précisément, nous avons examiné des enfants de patients souffrant de dépendance à l'alcool et à l'héroïne, de troubles bipolaires et unipolaires, ainsi qu'un groupe d'enfants témoins, dont les parents étaient des patients contrôles recrutés dans des départements d'orthopédie. Nous nous sommes ainsi proposé d'étudier de façon précise le risque de psychopathologie chez des enfants de parents malades en menant une étude longitudinale prospective au moyen d'évaluations standardisées. Ces enfants ainsi que leurs parents-patients (probands) sont actuellement évalués chaque trois ans. Nous avons aussi effectué une évaluation des co-parents biologiques de ces enfants afin de tenir compte également de l'impact de leurs éventuels troubles psychiatriques sur les manifestations psychopathologiques de leurs enfants. Le volet longitudinal-prospectif de ces familles est actuellement en cours, et les deux articles contenus dans cette thèse, publiés dans des revues à politique éditoriale, exposent les résultats obtenus lors de l'évaluation initiale de ces enfants et de leurs deux parents. Nous résultats montrent que les enfants de patients, pourtant encore très jeunes (moyenne d'âge d'environ 11 ans), présentent déjà de plus hauts taux de manifestations psychopathologiques que les enfants de parents contrôles. Nous avons également pu démontrer le rôle joué par le co-parent, en plus de celui du parent-patient, dans le développement de psychopathologie chez ces enfants. Ces résultats soulignent la nécessité d'une identification et d'une prise en charge très précoce de ces enfants, et indiquent également l'importance de porter un intérêt clinique non seulement au parent-patient, mais également au co-parent de ces enfants. - This thesis presents the baseline results of psychopathological assessments conducted in a prospective longitudinal cohort study of children whose parents have substance use disorders or mood disorders. More specifically, we examined children of alcohol- and heroin- dependent patients, children of patients with bipolar or unipolar disorders, and, as a control group, children whose parents were recruited in orthopedics departments. Using standardized assessments, we conducted this study to accurately assess the risk of psychopathology in children of parents with these substance use or mood disorders. The prospective longitudinal study of these families is currently ongoing, with the children and their parent-patients (probands) being followed up every three years. We also assessed the biological co-parent in order to determine the impact of their possible psychiatric disorders on the risk of mental disorders in offspring. The two articles of this thesis, which have been published in peer-reviewed journals, present the results of baseline assessments of the children and their two parents. Our results show that the children of patients who are still very young at baseline assessment (mean age about 11 years) already have higher rates of psychopathological manifestations compared with children of control parents. We also demonstrate the effect of the co-parents, in addition to that of the parent-patients, on the development of early psychiatric manifestations in these children. These results emphasize the importance of prompt identification and treatment of these children and highlight the need for clinical care not only of the patient, but also of the co- parent, in order to optimize the prevention of mental disorders in their offspring.

Diagnostic algorithm for a validated displacement grading of pediatric supracondylar fractures.

Background: The first AO comprehensive pediatric long bone fracture classification system has been established following a structured path of development and validation with experienced pediatric surgeons. Methods: A follow-up series of agreement studies was applied to specify and evaluate a grading system for displacement of pediatric supracondylar fractures. An iterative process comprising an international group of 5 experienced pediatric surgeons (Phase 1) followed by a pragmatic multicenter agreement study involving 26 raters (Phase 2) was used. The last evaluations were conducted on a consecutive collection of 154 supracondylar fractures documented by standard anteroposterior and lateral radiographs. Results: Fractures were classified according to 1 of 4 grades: I = incomplete fracture with no or minimal displacement; II = Incomplete fracture with continuity of the posterior (extension fracture) or anterior cortex (flexion fracture); III = lack of bone continuity (broken cortex), but still some contact between the fracture planes; IV = complete fracture with no bone continuity (broken cortex), and no contact between the fracture planes. A diagnostic algorithm to support the practical application of the grading system in a clinical setting, as well as an aid using a circle placed over the capitellum was proposed. The overall kappa coefficients were 0.68 and 0.61 in the Phase 1 and Phase 2 studies, respectively. In the Phase 1 study, fracture grades I, II, III, and IV were classified with median accuracies of 91%, 82%, 83%, and 99.5%, respectively. Similar median accuracies of 86% (Grade I), 73% (Grade II), 83%(Grade III), and 92% were reported for the Phase 2 study. Reliability was high in distinguishing complete, unstable fractures from stable injuries [ie, kappa coefficients of 0.84 (Phase 1) and 0.83 (Phase 2) were calculated]; in Phase 2, surgeons' accuracies in classifying complete fractures were all above 85%. Conclusions: With clear and unambiguous definition, this new grading system for supracondylar fracture displacement has proved to be sufficiently reliable and accurate when applied by pediatric surgeons in the framework of clinical routine as well as research.

Lack of extended venous thromboembolism prophylaxis in high-risk patients undergoing major orthopaedic or major cancer surgery. Electronic Assessment of VTE Prophylaxis in High-Risk Surgical Patients at Discharge from Swiss Hospitals (ESSENTIAL).

Extended pharmacological venous thromboembolism (VTE) prophylaxis beyond discharge is recommended for patients undergoing high-risk surgery. We prospectively investigated prophylaxis in 1,046 consecutive patients undergoing major orthopaedic (70%) or major cancer surgery (30%) in 14 Swiss hospitals. Appropriate in-hospital prophylaxis was used in 1,003 (96%) patients. At discharge, 638 (61%) patients received prescription for extended pharmacological prophylaxis: 564 (77%) after orthopaedic surgery, and 74 (23%) after cancer surgery (p < 0.001). Patients with knee replacement (94%), hip replacement (81%), major trauma (80%), and curative arthroscopy (73%) had the highest prescription rates for extended VTE prophylaxis; the lowest rates were found in patients undergoing major surgery for thoracic (7%), gastrointestinal (19%), and hepatobiliary (33%) cancer. The median duration of prescribed extended prophylaxis was longer in patients with orthopaedic surgery (32 days, interquartile range 14-40 days) than in patients with cancer surgery (23 days, interquartile range 11-30 days; p<0.001). Among the 278 patients with an extended prophylaxis order after hip replacement, knee replacement, or hip fracture surgery, 120 (43%) received a prescription for at least 35 days, and among the 74 patients with an extended prophylaxis order after major cancer surgery, 20 (27%) received a prescription for at least 28 days. In conclusion, approximately one quarter of the patients with major orthopaedic surgery and more than three quarters of the patients with major cancer surgery did not receive prescription for extended VTE prophylaxis. Future effort should focus on the improvement of extended VTE prophylaxis, particularly in patients undergoing major cancer surgery.

Type I osteogenesis imperfecta and multiple osteochondromas in the same child.

A male infant showed a humeral diaphysis fracture at 5 months of age and a distal tibial physis fracture at 2 years of age. A specialized consultant ruled out child abuse. This child had the characteristic features of type I osteogenesis imperfecta: blue sclerae, osseous fragility, and presumably autosomal dominant inheritance, as his father suffered from similar disorders. Later on, multiple painful osteochondromas were also found and some of these were surgically treated. The child's mother showed several peripheral osteochondromas. We describe the follow-up of this patient up to the age of 18 years. To our knowledge, the fortuitous association of these two inherited conditions has not been reported in medical literature.

Computer-assisted two-dimensional preoperative planning for total hip arthroplasty: clinical evaluation.

The purpose of this study is to clinically validate a new two-dimensional preoperative planning software for cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA). Manual and two-dimensional computer-assisted planning were compared by an independent observer for each of the 30 patients with osteoarthritis who underwent THA. This study showed that there were no statistical differences between the results of both preoperative plans in terms of stem size and neck length (<1 size) and hip rotation center position (<5 mm). Two-dimensional computer-assisted preoperative planning provided successful results comparable to those using the manual procedure, thereby allowing the surgeon to simulate various stem designs easily.