The gender wage gap in developing and transition countries

The aim of my dissertation is to study the gender wage gap with a specific focus on developing and transition countries. In the first chapter I present the main existing theories proposed to analyse the gender wage gap and I review the empirical literature on the gender wage gap in developing and transition countries and its main findings. Then, I discuss the overall empirical issues related to the estimation of the gender wage gap and the issues specific to developing and transition countries. The second chapter is an empirical analysis of the gender wage gap in a developing countries, the Union of Comoros, using data from the multidimensional household budget survey “Enquete integrale auprès des ménages” (EIM) run in 2004. The interest of my work is to provide a benchmark analysis for further studies on the situation of women in the Comorian labour market and to contribute to the literature on gender wage gap in Africa by making available more information on the dynamics and mechanism of the gender wage gap, given the limited interest on the topic in this area of the world. The third chapter is an applied analysis of the gender wage gap in a transition country, Poland, using data from the Labour Force Survey (LSF) collected for the years 1994 and 2004. I provide a detailed examination of how gender earning differentials have changed over the period starting from 1994 to a more advanced transition phase in 2004, when market elements have become much more important in the functioning of the Polish economy than in the earlier phase. The main contribution of my dissertation is the application of the econometrical methodology that I describe in the beginning of the second chapter. First, I run a preliminary OLS and quantile regression analysis to estimate and describe the raw and conditional wage gaps along the distribution. Second, I estimate quantile regressions separately for males and females, in order to allow for different rewards to characteristics. Third, I proceed to decompose the raw wage gap estimated at the mean through the Oaxaca-Blinder (1973) procedure. In the second chapter I run a two-steps Heckman procedure by estimating a model of participation in the labour market which shows a significant selection bias for females. Forth, I apply the Machado-Mata (2005) techniques to extend the decomposition analysis at all points of the distribution. In Poland I can also implement the Juhn, Murphy and Pierce (1991) decomposition over the period 1994-2004, to account for effects to the pay gap due to changes in overall wage dispersion beyond Oaxaca’s standard decomposition.

Determination of bioactive and potentially toxic compounds in food: raw material analysis and shelf life evaluation

"Bioactive compounds" are extranutritional constituents that typically occur in small quantities in food. They are being intensively studied to evaluate their effects on health. Bioactive compounds include both water soluble compounds, such as phenolics, and lipidic substances such as n-3 fatty acids, tocopherols and sterols. Phenolic compounds, tocopherols and sterols are present in all plants and have been studied extensively in cereals, nuts and oil. n-3 fatty acids are present in fish and all around the vegetable kingdom. The aim of the present work was the determination of bioactive and potentially toxic compounds in cereal based foods and nuts. The first section of this study was focused on the determination of bioactive compounds in cereals. Because of that the different forms of phytosterols were investigated in hexaploid and tetraploid wheats. Hexaploid cultivars were the best source of esterified sterols (40.7% and 37.3% of total sterols for Triticum aestivum and Triticum spelta, respectively). Significant amounts of free sterols (65.5% and 60.7% of total sterols for Triticum durum and Triticum dicoccon, respectively) were found in the tetraploid cultivars. Then, free and bound phenolic compounds were identified in barley flours. HPLCESI/ MSD analysis in negative and positive ion mode established that barley free flavan-3- ols and proanthocyanidins were four dimers and four trimers having (epi)catechin and/or (epi)gallocatechin (C and/or GC) subunits. Hydroxycinnamic acids and their derivatives were the main bound phenols in barley flours. The results obtained demonstrated that barley flours were rich in phenolic compounds that showed high antioxidant activity. The study also examined the relationships between phenolic compounds and lipid oxidation of bakery. To this purpose, the investigated barley flours were used in the bakery production. The formulated oven products presented an interesting content of phenolic compounds, but they were not able to contain the lipid oxidation. Furthermore, the influence of conventional packaging on lipid oxidation of pasta was evaluated in n-3 enriched spaghetti and egg spaghetti. The results proved that conventional packaging was not appropriated to preserve pasta from lipid oxidation; in fact, pasta that was exposed to light showed a high content of potentially toxic compounds derived from lipid oxidation (such as peroxide, oxidized fatty acids and COPs). In the second section, the content of sterols, phenolic compounds, n-3 fatty acids and tocopherols in walnuts were reported. Rapid analytical techniques were used to analyze the lipid fraction and to characterize phenolic compounds in walnuts. Total lipid chromatogram was used for the simultaneous determination of the profile of sterols and tocopherols. Linoleic and linolenic acids were the most representative n-6 and n-3 essential dietary fatty acids present in these nuts. Walnuts contained substantial amounts of γ- and δ-tocopherol, which explained their antioxidant properties. Sitosterol, Δ5-avenasterol and campesterol were the major free sterols found. Capillary electrophoresis coupled to DAD and microTOF was utilized to determine phenolic content of walnut. A new compound in walnut ((2E,4E)- 8-hydroxy-2,7-dimethyl-2,4-decadiene-1,10-dioic acid 6-O-β-D-glucopiranosyl ester, [M−H]− 403.161m/z) with a structure similar to glansreginins was also identified. Phenolic compounds corresponded to 14–28% of total polar compounds quantified. Aglycone and glycosylated ellagic acid represented the principal components and account for 64–75% of total phenols in walnuts. However, the sum of glansreginins A, B and ((2E,4E)-8-hydroxy- 2,7-dimethyl-2,4-decadiene-1,10-dioic acid 6-O-β-D-glucopiranosyl ester was in the range of 72–86% of total quantified compounds.

Control of peach phenolic compounds content

Phenolic compounds play a central role in peach fruit colour, flavour and health attributes. Phenolic profiles of several peaches and nectarines and most of the structural genes leading to the anthocyanin synthesis in peach fruit have been studied. Moreover, crosses of red and non-red peaches suggested that a major gene controls skin colour of the extreme phenotypes ‘highlighter’ and ‘full-red’. However, there is no data about either the ‘flavan-3-ols specific genes’ (ANR and LAR) or the regulation of the flavonoid metabolism in this crop. In the present study, we determined the concentration of phenolic compounds in the yellowfleshed nectarine Prunus persica cv. ‘Stark Red Gold’ during fruit growth and ripening. We examined the transcript levels of the main structural genes of the flavonoid pathway. Gene expression of the biosynthetic genes correlated well with the concentration of flavan-3-ols, which was very low at the beginning of fruit development, strongly increased at mid-development and finally decreased again during ripening. In contrast, the only gene transcript which correlated with anthocyanin concentration was PpUFGT, which was high at the beginning and end of fruit growth, remaining low during the other developmental stages. These patterns of gene expression could be explained by the involvement of different transcription factors, which up-regulate anthocyanin biosynthesis (PpMYB10 and PpbHLH3), or repress (PpMYBL2) the transcription of the structural genes. These transcription factors appeared to be involved also in the regulation of the lightinduced anthocyanin accumulation in ‘Stark Red Gold’ nectarines, suggesting that they play a critical role in the regulation of flavonoid biosynthesis in peaches and nectarines in response to both developmental and environmental stimuli. Phenolic profiles and expression patterns of the main flavonoid structural and regulatory genes were also determined for the extreme phenotypes denominated ‘highlighter’ and ‘full-red’ and hypotheses about the control of phenolic compounds content in these fruit are discussed.

Expression profiling in developing peach seed and mesocarp as affected by growth regulators

Jasmonates (JAs) and spermidine (Sd) influence fruit (and seed) development and ripening. In order to unravel their effects in peach fruit, at molecular level, field applications of methyl jasmonate (MJ) and propyl dihydrojasmonate (PDJ), and Sd were performed at an early developmental stage (late S1). At commercial harvest, JA-treated fruit were less ripe than controls. Realtime RT-PCR analyses confirmed a down-regulation of ethylene biosynthetic, perception and signaling genes, and flesh softening-related genes. The expression of cell wall-related genes, of a sugar-transporter and hormone-related transcript levels was also affected by JAs. Seeds from JA-treated fruit showed a shift in the expression of developmental marker genes suggesting that the developmental program was probably slowed down, in agreement with the contention that JAs divert resources from growth to defense. JAs also affected phenolic content and biosynthetic gene expression in the mesocarp. Levels of hydroxycinnamic acids, as well as those of flavan-3-ols, were enhanced, mainly by MJ, in S2. Transcript levels of phenylpropanoid pathway genes were up-regulated by MJ, in agreement with phenolic content. Sd-treated fruits at harvest showed reduced ethylene production and flesh softening. Sd induced a short-term and long-term response patterns in endogenous polyamines. At ripening the up-regulation of the ethylene biosynthetic genes was dramatically counteracted by Sd, leading to a down-regulation of softening-related genes. Hormone-related gene expression was also altered both in the short- and long-term. Gene expression analyses suggest that Sd interfered with fruit development/ripening by interacting with multiple hormonal pathways and that fruit developmental marker gene expression was shifted ahead in accord with a developmental slowing down. 24-Epibrassinolide was applied to Flaminia peaches under field conditions early (S1) or later (S3) during development. Preliminary results showed that, at harvest, treated fruit tended to be larger and less mature though quality parameters did not change relative to controls.

Gene therapy for a novel mouse model of Canavan disease

Canavan disease (CD) is a rare leukodystrophy caused by loss-of-function mutations in the gene encoding aspartoacylase (ASPA), an oligodendrocyte-enriched enzyme. It is characterised by the accumulation of the ASPA substrate N-acetylaspartate (NAA) in brain, blood and urine, leading to a spongiform vacuolisation of the brain, severe motoric and cognitive impairments and premature death. To date, no therapy is available due to the lack of a gene-transfer system allowing transgene expression in oligodendrocytes (OLs) and the restoration of the missing enzyme. Hence, the aim of this study was to establish a novel gene-transfer system and its preclinical evaluation in a CD animal model.rnIn the first part of this thesis, a novel ASPA mouse mutant was generated. A βgeo cassette (including the genes encoding β-galactosidase and neomycin) flanked by frt sites was inserted into intron 1 of the intact aspa gene. Additionally, exon 2 was flanked by loxP sites for optional conditional deletion of the targeted locus. The resulting ASPA-deficient aspalacZ/lacZ-mouse was found to be an accurate model of CD and an important tool to identify novel aspects of its complex pathology. Homozygous mutants showed a CD-like histopathology, neurological impairment, behavioural deficits as well as a reduced body weight. Additionally, MRI data revealed changes in brain metabolite composition. rnRecombinant adeno-associated viral (rAAV) vectors have become a versatile tool for gene transfer to the central nervous system because they are efficient, non-toxic and replication-deficient. Based on the natural neurotropism of AAV vectors, AAV-based gene delivery has entered the clinics for the treatment of neurodegenerative diseases. However, the lack of AAV vectors with oligodendroglial tropism has precluded gene therapy for leukodystrophies. In the second part of this work, it was shown that the transduction profile of established AAV serotypes can be targeted towards OLs in a transcriptional approach, using the oligodendrocyte-specific myelin basic protein (MBP) promoter to drive transgene expression in OLs.rnIn the last part of this work, the therapeutic efficacy of AAV-mediated aspa gene transfer to OLs of juvenile aspalacZ/lacZ mice was evaluated. AAV-aspa injections into multiple sites of the brain parenchyma resulted in transduction of OLs in the grey and white matter throughout the brain. Histological abnormalities in the brain of ASPA-deficient mice were ameliorated and accompanied by a reduction of NAA levels. Furthermore, the treatment resulted in normalisation of body weight, motor function and nest-building behaviour. These data provide a proof-of-concept for a successful gene therapy of Canavan disease. This might pave the way towards translation into clinical application and serve as the basis for the genetic treatment of other leukodystrophies.

Übergangsmetallvermittelte [2+2+2]-Zyklotrimerisierungsreaktionen zum Aufbau anellierter Phthalide : Intermediate zur Synthese von Anguzyklinonen

Anguzykline sind eine große Gruppe von Naturstoffen. Ihnen ist gemein, dass sie eine Benz[a]anthracen-Struktur besitzen oder dass sie in der Biosynthese aus einer Verbindung mit einem solchem Grundgerüst hervorgegangen sind. Viele Vertreter der Anguzykline sind bioaktive Substanzen mit insbesondere antibiotischer Wirkung. In dieser Arbeit wurde eine flexible, modulare Synthese für Anguzykline erarbeitet. Eine Schlüsselreaktion stellte die intramolekulare [2+2+2]-Zykloaddition aus Triinen zu Phthaliden dar. Die in dieser Umwandlung eingesetzten Triine enthalten eine Diin- und eine Monoinkomponente, die über eine Esterbindung miteinander verknüpft sind. Die intramolekulare [2+2+2]-Zyklotrimerisierung wurde an zwei verschiedenen Strukturen der Triinsysteme untersucht: Zum einen Triine, in denen Nona-2,8-diinsäuren mit 1-Aryl-propargylalkoholen verknüpft waren und zum anderen Substrate, in denen die Propargylsäureester von 1-Aryl-nona-2,8-diin-1-olen gebildet wurden. Für die Umsetzung wurden zwei verschiedene Katalysatoren verwendet. Neben dem Wilkinsonkatalysator wurde der Rutheniumkatalysator [Cp*RuCl(cod)] eingesetzt. Beide Katalysatoren sind für die Reaktion geeignet und ergänzen sich hinsichtlich der verschiedenen Triinsysteme. Die Phthalide dienten als Intermediate für den Aufbau eines Tetrahydrobenz[a]anthrachinon-Grundgerüst. Zum Aufbau dieser Struktur wurde eine Synthesesequenz zur Gerüstumlagerung vorgestellt und die Synthesemethode auf verschiedene Vertreter der Anguzyklin-Familie angewendet. Besonderes Augenmerk wurde auf die Synthese des Urdamycinon B gelegt, in dem das Grundgerüst C-glykosidisch mit einem Olivosesubstituenten verknüpft ist.

Modellkomplexe oligonuklearer Metalloproteine auf Basis von Salen-Liganden und Spin-Crossover-Verbindungen als Chemosensoren

Der erste Teil der hier vorgestellten Arbeit verfolgt die Synthese potentieller Modellverbindungen oligonuklearer Metalloproteine auf Basis von Salen-Liganden. Dazu wurden zwei Ligandensysteme mit unterschiedlich raumerfüllenden Alkyl-Substituenten modifiziert und auf ihre koordinativen Eigenschaften hin untersucht. Für das Ligandensystem auf Basis des Bis-(salicylidenamino)-propan-2-ols konnten fünf Derivate (H3L1, H3L2A,H3L2B, H3L3, H3L4), für das zweite verwendete Ligandensystem auf Basis des 1H-3,5-Bis-(salicylidenaminomethyl)-pyrazols konnten zwei weitere Derivate (H3L5A, H3L5B) dargestellt und zu Koordinationsverbindungen umgesetzt werden.rnFür den hier verwendeten Bis-(salicylidenamino)-propan-2-ol Liganden H3L1, welcher die geringsten sterischen Anforderungen stellt, konnten mono-, tri- und tetranukleare Koordinationsverbindungen synthetisiert werden. Dabei gelingt es dem Liganden, sich sowohl in planarer als auch in unterschiedlich stark gewinkelter Konformation um ein oder mehrere Metallzentren anzuordnen, wobei der Ligand ein N2O2- seines N2O3-Donorsets zur Koordination nutzt. Die Verbindung {[Ni7(HL1)2(L1)2(OBz)4(OMe)(H2O)]}n zeigt, dass eine Verkettung der so gestalteten dreikernigen Einheiten über das freie Propanol-Sauerstoffatomdes Ligandenrückgrats möglich ist. Mit zunehmendem sterischen Anspruch der angefügten Alkylsubstituenten nimmt die geometrische Flexibilität und somit das Potential des Liganden zur Ausbildung höhernuklearer Strukturen ab. So ist für Liganden mit mittlerem sterischen Anspruch neben mononuklearen Komplexen noch die Gestaltung dinuklearer Systeme möglich. Erhöht man den sterischen Anspruch des Liganden weiter, findet nur noch eine Reaktion zu mononuklearen Verbindungen statt.rnMit den Pyrazol-basierten Ligandensystemen H3L5A und H3L5B konnten dinukleare Kupfer- und Nickelverbindungen synthetisiert werden.rnDer zweite Teil dieser Arbeit befasst sich mit der Gestaltung von Spin-Crossover Systemen (SCO). Dazu soll ein Spinübergang innerhalb des gestalteten schaltbaren Systems an die Anwesenheit eines Signalstoffs gekoppelt werden, so dass diese SCO-Verbindung als Sensor für den Signalstoff eingesetzt werden kann. Dazu wurden zwei unterschiedliche Ansätze entwickelt und untersucht.rnDie erste Methode beruht auf der Kombination eines zum Spin-Crossover befähigten Metallzentrums, eines Capping-Liganden, eines zur Signalstofferkennung funktionalisierten Co-Liganden sowie eines entsprechenden Signalstoffs. Als Capping-Liganden wurden tetra- und pentadentateLigandensysteme eingesetzt und mit unterschiedlich Picolyl-substituierten Monoaza-[12]-krone-4-Derivaten umgesetzt, wobei die Monoazakrone zur Komplexierung des Signalstoffs,hier in Form eines Alkalimetallions, zur Verfügung steht. Nach dieser ersten Methode konnten im Zeitraum dieser Arbeit noch keine zufriedenstellenden Ergebnisse erzielt werden.rnEine vielversprechende zweite Möglichkeit beruht auf der Verwendung eines mehrzähnigen, etablierten Spin-Crossover Liganden,welcher in seiner Peripherie mit einer Bindungstasche zur Aufnahme des Signalstoffmodifiziert wird.Mit Hilfe des so gestalteten Liganden 4'-(4'''-Benzo-[15]-krone-5)-methyloxy-2,2':6',2''-terpyridin ([b15c5]-tpy) gelang die Umsetzung zu entsprechenden Eisen(II)- und Kobalt(II)komplexen der Zusammensetzung [M([b15c5]-tpy)2]2+. Alle synthetisierten Eisen(II)-Komplexe liegen aufgrund der hohen Ligandenfeldstärke des Terpyridins über einen Temperaturbereich von 300 – 400 K in ihrer diamagnetischen Low Spin Form vor. Die entsprechenden Kobalt(II)-Komplexe zeigen über einen Temperaturbereich von 2 – 350 K ein kontinuierliches, aber unvollständiges Spin-Crossover Verhalten.rnDer Einfluss von Signalstoffen auf das Spin-Crossover Verhalten der Kobalt(II)-Systeme wurde in einem ersten Versuch unter der Verwendung von Natriumionen als Signalstoff untersucht. Dabei stellte sich heraus, dass Natriumionen für dieses System zwar nicht als Auslöser eines SCO verwendet werden können, sie aber dennoch eine starke Auswirkung auf den Verlauf des Spin-Crossovers haben.

Mobile goes global: The effect of cell phones on economic growth and development

This study investigates the effect of cell phones on economic development and growth by performing an econometric analysis using data from the International Telecommunications Union and the Penn World Table. It discusses the various ways cell phones can make markets more efficient and how the diffusion of information andknowledge plays into development. Several approaches (OLS, Fixed Effects, 2SLS) were used to test over 20 econometric models. Overall, the mobile cellular subscriptions rate was found to have a positive and significant impact on countries’ level of real per capitaGDP and GDP growth rate. Furthermore, the study provides policy implications for the use of technology to promote global growth.

The Effects of Interstate Speed Limit Increases: Fatality Rates and Traffic Diversion Versus Speed Spillover

This thesis examines two panel data sets of 48 states from 1981 to 2009 and utilizes ordinary least squares (OLS) and fixed effects models to explore the relationship between rural Interstate speed limits and fatality rates and whether rural Interstate speed limits affect non-Interstate safety. Models provide evidence that rural Interstate speed limits higher than 55 MPH lead to higher fatality rates on rural Interstates though this effect is somewhat tempered by reductions in fatality rates for roads other than rural Interstates. These results provide some but not unanimous support for the traffic diversion hypothesis that rural Interstate speed limit increases lead to decreases in fatality rates of other roads. To the author’s knowledge, this paper is the first econometric study to differentiate between the effects of 70 MPH speed limits and speed limits above 70 MPH on fatality rates using a multi-state data set. Considering both rural Interstates and other roads, rural Interstate speed limit increases above 55 MPH are responsible for 39,700 net fatalities, 4.1 percent of total fatalities from 1987, the year limits were first raised, to 2009.

ELECTRICITY GENERATION MODELING AND PHOTOVOLTAIC FORECASTS IN CHINA

With the economic development of China, the demand for electricity generation is rapidly increasing. To explain electricity generation, we use gross GDP, the ratio of urban population to rural population, the average per capita income of urban residents, the electricity price for industry in Beijing, and the policy shift that took place in China. Ordinary least squares (OLS) is used to develop a model for the 1979-2009 period. During the process of designing the model, econometric methods are used to test and develop the model. The final model is used to forecast total electricity generation and assess the possible role of photovoltaic generation. Due to the high demand for resources and serious environmental problems, China is pushing to develop the photovoltaic industry. The system price of PV is falling; therefore, photovoltaics may be competitive in the future.

Microstructural, chemical and isotopic evidence for the origin of late neolithic leather recovered from an ice field in the Swiss Alps

Archaeological leather samples recovered from the ice field at the Schnidejoch Pass (altitude 2756 m amsl) in the western Swiss Alps were studied using optical, chemical molecular and isotopic (δ13C and δ15N of the bulk leather, and compound-specific δ13C analyses of the organic-solvent extracted fatty acids) methods to obtain insight into the origin of the leather and ancient tanning procedures. For comparison, leathers from modern native animals in alpine environment (red deer, goat, sheep, chamois, and calf/cow) were analyzed using the same approach. Optical and electron microscopically comparisons of Schnidejoch and modern leathers showed that the gross structure (pattern of collagen fibrils and intra-fibrils material) of archaeological leather had survived essentially intact for five millennia. The SEM studies of the hairs from the most important archaeological find, a Neolithic leather legging, show a wave structure of the hair cuticle, which is a diagnostic feature for goatskins. The variations of the bulk δ13C and δ15N values, and δ13C values of the main fatty acids are within the range expected for pre-industrial temperate C3 environment. The archaeological leather samples contain a mixture of indigenous (from the animal) and exogenous plant/animal lipids. An important amount of waxy n-alkanes, n-alkan-1-ols and phytosterols (β-sitosterol, sitostanol) in all samples, and abundant biomarker of conifers (nonacosan-10-ol) in the legging leathers clearly indicate that the Neolithic people were active in a subalpine coniferous forest, and that they used an aqueous extract of diverse plant material for tanning leather.

Geklibene šrifṭen : 1. band

L. Ṭolsṭoi. Judiš fun Peretz Hiršbain. Miṭ a forworṭ fun ...

Kozaken : a kawkazer gešichṭe

L. N. Ṭolsṭoi. Iberzeṭtzṭ fun rusiš durch Baʿal Maḥašāvôt

Oggi la storia. Geschichte(n) für ein Jahr

«Oggi, la storia» è un programma radiofonico della Radiotelevisione svizzera RSI che «mira a dare, seppur nel breve formato, profondità storico-filosofica a tematiche legate all’attualità o alle ricorrenze del calendario.» Le illustrazioni di Erik Dettwiler sono tratte dalla serie fotografica «Whiter ain't possible!» nata nel corso degli anni in diverse metropoli europee tra Roma, Bucarest e Berlino, ma anche nella città sudafricana di Johannesburg. L'amicizia tra lo storico e l'artista, sfociata in numerose successive collaborazioni, è nata negli anni 2004/2005 durante il loro soggiorno quali membri dell'Istituto Svizzero di Roma.

Identifying Individual and Group Effects in the Presence of Sorting: A Neighborhood Effects Application

Researchers have long recognized that the non-random sorting of individuals into groups generates correlation between individual and group attributes that is likely to bias naive estimates of both individual and group effects. This paper proposes a non-parametric strategy for identifying these effects in a model that allows for both individual and group unobservables, applying this strategy to the estimation of neighborhood effects on labor market outcomes. The first part of this strategy is guided by a robust feature of the equilibrium in the canonical vertical sorting model of Epple and Platt (1998), that there is a monotonic relationship between neighborhood housing prices and neighborhood quality. This implies that under certain conditions a non- parametric function of neighborhood housing prices serves as a suitable control function for the neighborhood unobservable in the labor market outcome regression. The second part of the proposed strategy uses aggregation to develop suitable instruments for both exogenous and endogenous group attributes. Instrumenting for each individual's observed neighborhood attributes with the average neighborhood attributes of a set of observationally identical individuals eliminates the portion of the variation in neighborhood attributes due to sorting on unobserved individual attributes. The neighborhood effects application is based on confidential microdata from the 1990 Decennial Census for the Boston MSA. The results imply that the direct effects of geographic proximity to jobs, neighborhood poverty rates, and average neighborhood education are substantially larger than the conditional correlations identified using OLS, although the net effect of neighborhood quality on labor market outcomes remains small. These findings are robust across a wide variety of specifications and robustness checks.