The Immune Inhibitor A1 Protease of Bacillus anthracis

Bacillus anthracis, an organism ubiquitous in the soil and the causative agent of anthrax, utilizes multiple mechanisms to regulate secreted factors; one example is the activity of secreted proteases. One of the most abundant proteins in the culture supernates of B. anthracis is the Immune Inhibitor A1 (InhA1) protease. Here, I demonstrate that InhA1 modulates the abundance of approximately half of the proteins secreted into the culture supernates, including substrates that are known to contribute to the ability of the organism to cause virulence. For example, InhA1 cleaves the anthrax toxin proteins, PA, LF, and EF. InhA1 also targets a number of additional proteases, including Npr599, contributing to a complex proteolytic regulatory cascade with far-reaching affects on the secretome. Using an intra-tracheal mouse model of infection, I found that an inhA-null strain is attenuated in relation to the parent strain. The data indicate that reduced virulence of the inhA mutant strain may be the result of toxin protein deregulation, decreased association with macrophages, and/or the inability to degrade host antimicrobial peptides. Given the significant modulation of the secretome by InhA1, it is likely that expression of the protease is tightly regulated. To test this I examined inhA1 transcript and protein levels in the parent and various isogenic mutant strains and found that InhA1 expression is regulated by several mechanisms. First, the steady state levels of inhA1 transcript are controlled by the regulatory protein SinR, which inhibits inhA1 expression. Second, InhA1 abundance is inversely proportional to the SinR-regulated protease camelysin, indicating the post-transcriptional regulation of InhA1 by camelysin. Third, InhA1 activity is dependent on a conserved zinc binding motif, suggesting that zinc availability regulates InhA1 activity. The convergence of these regulatory mechanisms signifies the importance of tight regulation of InhA1 activity, activity that substantially affects how B. anthracis interacts with its environment.

MMP-9/TIMP-1 imbalance induced in human dendritic cells by Porphyromonas gingivalis.

Matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP-9) cleaves collagen, allowing leukocytes to traffic toward the vasculature and the lymphatics. When MMP-9 is unregulated by tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase-1 (TIMP-1), this can lead to tissue destruction. Dendritic cells (DCs) infiltrate the oral mucosa increasingly in chronic periodontitis, characterized by infection with several pathogens including Porphyromonas gingivalis. In this study, human monocyte-derived DCs were pulsed with different doses of lipopolysaccharide of P. gingivalis 381 and of Escherichia coli type strain 25922, as well as whole live isogenic fimbriae-deficient mutant strains of P. gingivalis 381. Levels of induction of MMP-9 and TIMP-1, as well as interleukin-10 (IL-10), which reportedly inhibits MMP-9 induction, were measured by several approaches. Our results reveal that lipopolysaccharide of P. gingivalis, compared with lipopolysaccharide from E. coli type strain 25922, is a relatively potent inducer of MMP-9, but a weak inducer of TIMP-1, contributing to a high MMP-9/TIMP-1 ratio.Whole live P. gingivalis strain 381, major fimbriae mutant DPG-3 and double mutant MFB were potent inducers of MMP-9, but minor fimbriae mutant MFI was not. MMP-9 induction was inversely proportional to IL-10 induction. These results suggest that lipopolysaccharide and the minor and the major fimbriae of P. gingivalis may play distinct roles in induction by DCs of MMP-9, a potent mediator of local tissue destruction and leukocyte trafficking.

Control of chromosomal rearrangements in {\it Escherichia coli\/}

A complete physical map of Escherichia coli K-12 strain MG1655 was constructed by digesting chromosomal DNA with the infrequently cutting restriction enzymes NotI, SfiI and XbaI and separating the fragments by pulsed field gel electrophoresis. The map was used to compare six K-12 strains of E. coli. Although several differences were noted and localized, the map of MG1655 was representative of all the K-12 strains tested. The maps were also used to analyze chromosomal rearrangements in the E. coli strain MG1655. The spontaneous and UV induced frequencies of tandem duplication formation were measured at several loci distributed around the chromosome. The spontaneous duplication frequency varied from 10$\sp{-5}$ to 10$\sp{-3}$ and increased at least ten-fold following mild UV irradiation treatment. Duplications of several regions of the chromosome, including the serA region and the metE region, were mapped using pulsed field gel electrophoresis. Duplications of serA were found to be large, ranging in size from 600 kb to 2100 kb. Several of the duplications isolated at serA were caused by ectopic recombination between IS5 elements and between IS186 elements. Duplications of the metE region, however, were almost exclusively the result of ectopic recombination between ribosomal RNA cistrons. Duplication frequencies were determined at both serA and metE in wild type and mismatch repair mutant strains (mutL, mutS, uvrD and recF). Even though all of the mismatch repair mutations increased duplication frequency of metE, the largest increases were observed in the mutL and mutS strains. Duplication frequency of serA was increased less dramatically by mutations in mismatch repair. Several duplications of metE isolated in a wild type and a mismatch repair mutant were mapped. The results showed that the same repeated sequences were used for duplication formation in the mismatch repair mutant as were used in the wild type strain. Several isolates showed evidence of multiple rearrangements indicating that mismatch repair may play a role in stabilizing the genome by controlling chromosomal rearrangement. ^

A study of the {\it in vivo\/} role of myogenin

Myogenin is a member of the MyoD family of skeletal muscle specific bHLH transcription factors. All of the members of this family have been shown to initiate the muscle differentiation cascade in a variety of nonmuscle cell lines. Many of the properties of the MyoD family have been studied in vitro, but their in vivo roles had not yet been examined. In this thesis, I study the in vivo role of myogenin by creating mice that carry a mutation at the myogenin locus.^ Mice lacking the myogenin protein are born alive, but immobile. Histological examination showed that these mice are severely deficient in skeletal muscle; they show a reduction in the number and density of myofibers. In addition to the reduction in fiber number, these mice express lower levels of a variety of muscle-specific markers. The undifferentiated cells in the muscle forming regions of these mice do express some muscle-specific markers, indicating that these cells are determined but undifferentiated myoblasts. Additional studies show that the major muscle defect arises late in embryogenesis, at a time coincident with secondary myogenesis. Moreover, studies regarding the nature of the remaining myofibers indicate that they are representative of a normal population of myofibers, merely reduced in numbers. In addition, I studied the effects of combining the myogenin mutation with mutations in two other members of the MyoD family, MyoD and myf5. Mice mutant in myogenin + MyoD and myogenin + myf5 show no increase in the severity of the myogenin single mutation, as indicated by histological or molecular examination. These results reveal the unique and essential role of myogenin in mammalian skeletal myogenesis. ^

Functional studies of the homeobox gene {\it Goosecoid\/} during mouse embryogenesis

A fundamental question in developmental biology is to understand the mechanisms that govern the development of an adult individual from a single cell. Goosecoid (Gsc) is an evolutionarily conserved homeobox gene that has been cloned in vertebrates and in Drosophila. In mice, Gsc is first expressed during gastrulation stages where it marks anterior structures of the embryo, this pattern of expression is conserved among vertebrates. Later, expression is observed during organogenesis of the head, limbs and the trunk. The conserved pattern of expression of Gsc during gastrulation and gain of function experiments in Xenopus suggested a function for Gsc in the development of anterior structures in vertebrates. Also, its expression pattern in mouse suggested a role in morphogenesis of the head, limbs and trunk. To determine the functional requirement of Gsc in mice a loss of function mutation was generated by homologous recombination in embryonic stem cells and mice mutant for Gsc were generated.^ Gsc-null mice survived to birth but died hours after delivery. Phenotypic analysis revealed craniofacial and rib cage abnormalities that correlated with the second phase of Gsc expression in the head and trunk but no anomalies were found that correlated with its pattern of expression during gastrulation or limb development.^ To determine the mode of action of Gsc during craniofacial development aggregation chimeras were generated between Gsc-null and wild-type embryos. Chimeras were generated by the aggregation of cleavage stage embryos, taking advantage of two different Gsc-null alleles generated during gene targeting. Chimeras demonstrated a cell-autonomous function for Gsc during craniofacial development and a requirement for Gsc function in cartilage and mesenchymal tissues.^ Thus, during embryogenesis in mice, Gsc is not an essential component of gastrulation as had been suggested in previous experiments. Gsc is required for craniofacial development where it acts cell autonomously in cartilage and mesenchymal tissues. Gsc is also required for proper development of the rib cage but it is dispensable for limb development in mice. ^

A Metalloproteinase Mirolysin of Tannerella forsythia Inhibits All Pathways of the Complement System

Recent reports focusing on virulence factors of periodontal pathogens implicated proteinases as major determinants of remarkable pathogenicity of these species, with special emphasis on their capacity to modulate complement activity. In particular, bacteria-mediated cleavage of C5 and subsequent release of C5a seems to be an important phenomenon in the manipulation of the local inflammatory response in periodontitis. In this study, we present mirolysin, a novel metalloproteinase secreted by Tannerella forsythia, a well-recognized pathogen strongly associated with periodontitis. Mirolysin exhibited a strong effect on all complement pathways. It inhibited the classical and lectin complement pathways due to efficient degradation of mannose-binding lectin, ficolin-2, ficolin-3, and C4, whereas inhibition of the alternative pathway was caused by degradation of C5. This specificity toward complement largely resembled the activity of a previously characterized metalloproteinase of T. forsythia, karilysin. Interestingly, mirolysin released the biologically active C5a peptide in human plasma and induced migration of neutrophils. Importantly, we demonstrated that combination of mirolysin with karilysin, as well as a cysteine proteinase of another periodontal pathogen, Prevotella intermedia, resulted in a strong synergistic effect on complement. Furthermore, mutant strains of T. forsythia, devoid of either mirolysin or karilysin, showed diminished survival in human serum, providing further evidence for the synergistic inactivation of complement by these metalloproteinases. Taken together, our findings on interactions of mirolysin with complement significantly add to the understanding of immune evasion strategies of T. forsythia and expand the knowledge on molecular mechanisms driving pathogenic events in the infected periodontium.

Regulation and transcript analysis of the ceroperon responsible for quorum sensing in Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1

Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1 is a Gram negative facultative photoheterotrophic bacterium that has been shown to have an N-acyl homoserine lactone-based quorum sensing system called cer for c&barbelow;ommunity e&barbelow;scape r&barbelow;esponse. The cer ORFs are cerR, the transcriptional regulator, cerI, the autoinducer synthase and cerA , whose function is unknown. The autoinducer molecule, 7,8- cis-N-(tetradecenoyl) homoserine lactone, has been characterized. The objective of this study was to identify an environmental stimulus that influences the regulation of cerRAI and, to characterize transcription of the cer operon. ^ A cerR::lacZ transcriptional fusion was made and β-Galactosidase assays were performed in R. sphaeroides 2.4.1 strains, wild type, AP3 (CerI−) and AP4 (CerR−). The cerR::lacZ β-Galactosidase assays were used as an initial survey of the mode of regulation of the Cer system. A cerA::lacZ translational fusion was created and was used to show that cerA can be translated. The presence of 7,8-cis-N-(tetradecenoyl) homoserine lactone was detected from R. sphaeroides strains wild type and AP4 (CerR−) using a lasR::lacZ translational fusion autoinducer bioassay. The cerR::lacZ transcriptional fusion in R. sphaeroides 2.4.1 wild type was tested under different environmental stimuli, such as various carbon sources, oxygen tensions, light intensities and culture media to determine if they influence transcription of the cer ORFs. Although lacZ assay data implicated high light intensity at 100 W/m2 to stimulate cer transcription, quantitative Northern RNA data of the cerR transcript showed that low light intensity at 3 W/m2 is at least one environmental stimulus that induces cer transcription. This finding was supported by DNA microarray analysis. Northern analysis of the cerRAI transcript provided evidence that the cer ORFs are co-transcribed, and that the cer operon contains two additional genes. Bioinformatics was used to identify genes that may be regulated by the Cer system by identifying putative lux box homologue sequences in the presumed promoter region of these genes. Genes that were identified were fliQ, celB and calsymin, all implicated in interacting with plants. Primer extension was used to help localize cis-elements in the promoter region. The cerR::lacZ transcriptional fusion was monitored in a subset of different global DNA binding transcriptional regulator mutant strains of R. sphaeroides 2.4.1. Those regulators involved in maintaining an anaerobic photosynthetic lifestyle appeared to have an effect. Collectively, the data imply that R. sphaeroides 2.4.1 activates the Cer system when grown anaerobic photosynthetically at low light intensity, 3 W/m2, and it may be involved in an interaction with plants. ^

DNA incisions stimulate genetic instability of triplet repeat sequences related to human hereditary neurological diseases

The molecular mechanisms responsible for the expansion and deletion of trinucleotide repeat sequences (TRS) are the focus of our studies. Several hereditary neurological diseases including Huntington's disease, myotonic dystrophy, and fragile X syndrome are associated with the instability of TRS. Using the well defined and controllable model system of Escherichia coli, the influences of three types of DNA incisions on genetic instability of CTG•CAG repeats were studied: DNA double-strand breaks (DSB), single-strand nicks, and single-strand gaps. The DNA incisions were generated in pUC19 derivatives by in vitro cleavage with restriction endonucleases. The cleaved DNA was then transformed into E. coli parental and mutant strains. Double-strand breaks induced deletions throughout the TRS region in an orientation dependent manner relative to the origin of replication. The extent of instability was enhanced by the repeat length and sequence (CTG•CAG vs. CGG•CCG). Mutations in recA and recBC increased deletions, mutations in recF stabilized the TRS, whereas mutations in ruvA had no effect. DSB were repaired by intramolecular recombination, versus an intermolecular gene conversion or crossover mechanism. 30 nt gaps formed a distinct 30 nt deletion product, whereas single strand nicks and gaps of 15 nts did not induce expansions or deletions. Formation of this deletion product required the CTG•CAG repeats to be present in the single-stranded region and was stimulated by E. coli DNA ligase, but was not dependent upon the RecFOR pathway. Models are presented to explain the DSB induced instabilities and formation of the 30 nucleotide deletion product. In addition to the in vitro creation of DSBs, several attempts to generate this incision in vivo with the use of EcoR I restriction modification systems were conducted. ^

2-methylthio-N$\sp6$-dimethylallyl modification of adenosine 37 of tRNAs in {\it Escherichia coli\/} K-12

The hypermodified, hydrophobic 2-methylthio-N$\sp6$-(dimethylallyl)-adenosine (ms${2{\cdot}6}\atop1$A) residue occurs $3\sp\prime$ to the anticodon in tRNA species that read codons beginning with U. The first step (i$\sp6$A37 formation) of this modification is catalyzed by dimethylallyl diphosphate:tRNA dimethyallyltransferase (EC 2.5.1.8), which is the product of the miaA gene. Subsequent steps were proposed to be catalyzed by MiaB and MiaC enzymes to complete the ms${2{\cdot}6}\atop1$A37 modification. The study of functions of the ms${2{\cdot}6}\atop1$A37 is very important because this modified base is one of the best candidates for a role in global control in response to environmental stress. This dissertation describes the further delineation of functions of the ms${2{\cdot}6}\atop1$A37 modification in E. coli K-12 cells. This work provides significant information on functions of tRNA modifications in E. coli cells to adapt to stressful environmental conditions. Three hypotheses were tested in this work.^ The first hypothesis tested was that non-optimal translation processes cause increased spontaneous mutagenesis by the induction of SOS response in starving cells. To test this hypothesis, I measured spontaneous mutation rates of wild type cells and various mutant strains which are defective in tRNA modification, SOS response, or oxidative damage repair. I found that the miaA mutation acts as a mutator that increased Lac$\sp+$ reversion rates and Trp$\sp+$ reversion frequencies of the wild-type cells in starving conditions. However, the lexA3(Ind)(which abolishes the induction of SOS response) mutation abolished the mutator phenotype of the miaA mutant. The recA430 mutation, not other identified SOS genes, decreased the Lac$\sp+$ reversion to a less extent than that of the lexA3(Ind) mutation. These results suggest that RecA together with another unidentified SOS gene product are responsible for the process.^ The second hypothesis tested was that MiaA protein binds to full-length tRNA$\sp{\rm Phe}$ molecules in form of a protein dimer. To test this hypothesis, three versions of the MiaA protein and seven species of tRNA substrates were purified. Binding studies by gel mobility shift assays, filter binding assays and gel filtration shift assays support the hypothesis that MiaA protein binds to full-length tRNA$\sp{\rm Phe}$ as a protein dimer but as a monomer to the anticodon stem-and-loop. These results were further supported by using steady state enzyme kinetic studies.^ The third hypothesis tested in this work was that the miaB gene in E. coli exists and is clonable. The miaB::Tn10dCm insertion mutation of Salmonella typhimurium was transduced to E. coli K-12 cells by using P$\sb1$ and P$\sb{22}$ bacteriophages. The insertion was confirmed by HPLC analyses of nucleotide profiles of miaB mutants of E. coli. The insertion mutation was cloned and DNA sequences adjacent to the transposon were sequenced. These DNA sequences were 86% identical to the f474 gene at 14.97 min chromosome of E. coli. The f474 gene was then cloned by PCR from the wild-type chromosome of E. coli. The recombinant plasmid complemented the mutant phenotype of the miaB mutant of E. coli. These results support the hypothesis that the miaB gene of E. coli exists and is clonable. In summary, functions of the ms${2{\cdot}6}\atop1$A37 modification in E. coli cells are further delineated in this work in perspectives of adaptation to stressful environmental conditions and protein:tRNA interaction. (Abstract shortened by UMI.) ^

Msh2 status modulates both apoptosis and mutation frequency in the murine small intestine

Deficiency in genes involved in DNA mismatch repair increases susceptibility to cancer, particularly of the colorectal epithelium. Using Msh2 null mice, we demonstrate that this genetic defect renders normal intestinal epithelial cells susceptible to mutation in vivo at the Dlb-1 locus. Compared with wild-type mice, Msh2-deficient animals had higher basal levels of mutation and were more sensitive to the mutagenic effects of temozolomide. Experiments using Msh2-deficient cells in vitro suggest that an element of this effect is attributable to increased clonogenicity. Indeed, we show that Msh2 plays a role in the in vivo initiation of apoptosis after treatment with temozolomide, N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, and cisplatin. This was not influenced by the in vivo depletion of O6-alkylguanine-DNA-alkyltransferase after administration of O6-benzylguanine . By analyzing mice mutant for both Msh2 and p53, we found that the Msh2-dependent apoptotic response was primarily mediated through a p53-dependent pathway. Msh2 also was required to signal delayed p53-independent death. Taken together, these studies characterize an in vivo Msh2-dependent apoptotic response to methylating agents and raise the possibility that Msh2 deficiency may predispose to malignancy not only through failed repair of mismatch DNA lesions but also through the failure to engage apoptosis.

Modeling the control of DNA replication in fission yeast

A central event in the eukaryotic cell cycle is the decision to commence DNA replication (S phase). Strict controls normally operate to prevent repeated rounds of DNA replication without intervening mitoses (“endoreplication”) or initiation of mitosis before DNA is fully replicated (“mitotic catastrophe”). Some of the genetic interactions involved in these controls have recently been identified in yeast. From this evidence we propose a molecular mechanism of “Start” control in Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Using established principles of biochemical kinetics, we compare the properties of this model in detail with the observed behavior of various mutant strains of fission yeast: wee1− (size control at Start), cdc13Δ and rum1OP (endoreplication), and wee1− rum1Δ (rapid division cycles of diminishing cell size). We discuss essential features of the mechanism that are responsible for characteristic properties of Start control in fission yeast, to expose our proposal to crucial experimental tests.

Yersinia signals macrophages to undergo apoptosis and YopJ is necessary for this cell death

Pathogenic Yersinia spp. carry a large common plasmid that encodes a number of essential virulence determinants. Included in these factors are the Yersinia-secreted proteins called Yops. We analyzed the consequences of wild-type and mutant strains of Yersinia pseudotuberculosis interactions with the macrophage cell line RAW264.7 and murine bone marrow-derived macrophages. Wild-type Y. pseudotuberculosis kills ≈70% of infected RAW264.7 macrophages and marrow-derived macrophages after an 8-h infection. We show that the cell death mediated by Y. pseudotuberculosis is apoptosis. Mutant Y. pseudotuberculosis that do not make any Yop proteins no longer cause host cell death. Attachment to host cells via invasin or YadA is necessary for the cell death phenotype. Several Yop mutant strains that fail to express one or more Yop proteins were engineered and then characterized for their ability to cause host cell death. A mutant with a polar insertion in YpkA Ser/Thr kinase that does not express YpkA or YopJ is no longer able to cause apoptosis. In contrast, a mutant no longer making YopE or YopH (a tyrosine phosphatase) induces apoptosis in macrophages similar to wild type. When yopJ is added in trans to the ypkAyopJ mutant, the ability of this strain to signal programmed cell death in macrophages is restored. Thus, YopJ is necessary for inducing apoptosis. The ability of Y. pseudotuberculosis to promote apoptosis of macrophages in cell culture suggests that this process is important for the establishment of infection in the host and for evasion of the host immune response.

Inactivation of DNA proofreading obviates the need for SOS induction in frameshift mutagenesis

Translesion synthesis at replication-blocking lesions requires the induction of proteins that are controlled by the SOS system in Escherichia coli. Of the proteins identified so far, UmuD′, UmuC, and RecA* were shown to facilitate replication across UV-light-induced lesions, yielding both error-free and mutagenic translesion-synthesis products. Similar to UV lesions, N-2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF), a chemical carcinogen that forms covalent adducts at the C8 position of guanine residues, is a strong replication-blocking lesion. Frameshift mutations are induced efficiently by AAF adducts when located within short repetitive sequences in a two-step mechanism; AAF adducts incorporate a cytosine across from the lesion and then form a primer-template misaligned intermediate that, upon elongation, yields frameshift mutations. Recently, we have shown that although elongation from the nonslipped intermediate depends on functional umuDC+ gene products, elongation from the slipped intermediate is umuDC+-independent but requires another, as yet biochemically uncharacterized, SOS function. We now show that in DNA Polymerase III-proofreading mutant strains (dnaQ49 and mutD5 strains), elongation from the slipped intermediate is highly efficient in the absence of SOS induction—in contrast to elongation from the nonslipped intermediate, which still requires UmuDC functions.

Heme is an effector molecule for iron-dependent degradation of the bacterial iron response regulator (Irr) protein

The bacterial iron response regulator (Irr) protein mediates iron-dependent regulation of heme biosynthesis. Pulse–chase and immunoprecipitation experiments showed that Irr degraded in response to 6 μM iron with a half-life of ≈30 min and that this regulated stability was the principal determinant of control by iron. Irr contains a heme regulatory motif (HRM) near its amino terminus. A role for heme in regulation was implicated by the retention of Irr in heme synthesis mutants in the presence of iron. Addition of heme to low iron (0.3 μM) cultures was sufficient for the disappearance of Irr in cells of the wild-type and heme mutant strains. Spectral and binding analyses of purified recombinant Irr showed that the protein bound heme with high affinity and caused a blue shift in the absorption spectrum of heme to a shorter wavelength. A Cys29 → Ala substitution within the HRM of Irr (IrrC29A) abrogated both high affinity binding to heme and the spectral blue shift. In vivo turnover experiments showed that, unlike wild-type Irr, IrrC29A was stable in the presence of iron. We conclude that iron-dependent degradation of Irr involves direct binding of heme to the protein at the HRM. The findings implicate a regulatory role for heme in protein degradation and provide direct evidence for a functional HRM in a prokaryote.

Concomitant combination therapy for HIV infection preferable over sequential therapy with 3TC and non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors

Exposure to 3TC of HIV-1 mutant strains containing non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NNRTI)-specific mutations in their reverse transcriptase (RT) easily selected for double-mutant viruses that had acquired the characteristic 184-Ile mutation in their RT in addition to the NNRTI-specific mutations. Conversely, exposure of 3TC-resistant 184-Val mutant HIV-1 strains to nine different NNRTIs resulted in the rapid emergence of NNRTI-resistant virus strains at a time that was not more delayed than when wild-type HIV-1(IIIB) was exposed to the same compounds. The RTs of these resistant virus strains had acquired the NNRTI-characteristic mutations in addition to the preexisting 184-Val mutation. Surprisingly, when the 184-Ile mutant HIV-1 was exposed to a variety of NNRTIs, the 188-His mutation invariably occurred concomitantly with the 184-Ile mutation in the HIV-1 RT. Breakthrough of this double-mutant virus was markedly accelerated as compared with the mutant virus selected from the wild-type or 184-Val mutant HIV-1 strain. The double (184-Ile + 188-His) mutant virus showed a much more profound resistance profile against the NNRTIs than the 188-His HIV-1 mutant. In contrast with the sequential chemotherapy, concomitant combination treatment of HIV-1-infected cells with 3TC and a variety of NNRTIs resulted in a dramatic delay of virus breakthrough and resistance development.