Productive Diversification and Sustainable Use of Complex Social-Ecological Systems: A Comparative Study of Indigenous and Settler Communities in the Bolivian Amazon

Agricultural and forest productive diversification depends on multiple socioeconomic drivers—like knowledge, migration, productive capacity, and market—that shape productive strategies and influence their ecological impacts. Our comparison of indigenous and settlers allows a better understanding of how societies develop different diversification strategies in similar ecological contexts and how the related socioeconomic aspects of diversification are associated with land cover change. Our results suggest that although indigenous people cause less deforestation and diversify more, diversification is not a direct driver of deforestation reduction. A multidimensional approach linking sociocognitive, economic, and ecological patterns of diversification helps explain this contradiction.

Carbon sequestration in community forests: trade-offs, multiple outcomes and institutional diversity in the Bolivian Amazon

Carbon sequestration in community forests presents a major challenge for the Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD+) programme. This article uses a comparative analysis of the agricultural and forestry practices of indigenous peoples and settlers in the Bolivian Amazon to show how community-level institutions regulate the trade-offs between community livelihoods, forest species diversity, and carbon sequestration. The authors argue that REDD+ implementation in such areas runs the risk of: 1) reinforcing economic inequalities based on previous and potential land use impacts on ecosystems (baseline), depending on the socio-cultural groups targeted; 2) increasing pressure on land used for food production, possibly reducing food security and redirecting labour towards scarce off-farm income opportunities; 3) increasing dependence on external funding and carbon market fluctuations instead of local production strategies; and 4) further incentivising the privatization and commodification of land to avoid transaction costs associated with collective property rights. The article also advises against taking a strictly economic, market-based approach to carbon sequestration, arguing that such an approach could endanger fragile socio-ecological systems. REDD+ schemes should directly support existing efforts towards forest sustainability rather than simply compensating local land users for avoiding deforestation and forest degradation

Indigenous land reconfiguration and fragmented institutions: a historical political ecology of Tsimane’ lands (Bolivian Amazon)

Lands inhabited by indigenous peoples often have low population density but abundant natural resources. For those reasons, many actors have historically attempted to occupy those lands or use the resources in them. Increasing pressures over lands occupied by indigenous peoples have resulted in the awakening of indigenous peoples over their rights to land and resources generating many debates over indigenous peoples' rights to land and self-governance. In this article, we provide a historical and geographical overview of territorial and governance issues among the Tsimane', an indigenous group native to the Bolivian Amazon. We examine how the Bolivian state economic policies implemented during the 20th century affected the Tsimane' ancestral lands, and how – over the late-20th century – the Bolivian state accommodated Tsimane' claims to lands in between multiple interests. We show how national policies led to the reconfiguration of Tsimane' territoriality and to a fragmented institutional representation. Current indigenous territories and indigenous political representation are an expression of conflictive policies that have involved multiple actors and their specific interests on indigenous lands and its resources.

The origin of oriented lakes: evidence from the Bolivian Amazon

The presence of hundreds of rectangular and oriented lakes is one of the most striking characteristics of the Llanos de Moxos (LM) landscape in the Bolivian Amazon. Oriented lakes also occur in the Arctic coastal plains of Russia, Alaska and Canada and along the Atlantic Coastal Plain from northeast Florida to southeast New Jersey and along the coast of northeast Brazil. Many different mechanisms have been proposed for their formation. In the LM, Plafker's (1964) tectonic model, in which subsidence results from the propagation of bedrock faults through the foreland sediments, is the most accepted. However, this model has not been verified. Here, we present new results from stratigraphic transects across the borders of three rectangular and oriented lakes in the LM. A paleosol buried under mid-Holocene sediments is used as a stratigraphic marker to assess the vertical displacement of sediments on both sides of the alleged faults. Our results show that there is no vertical displacement and, therefore, that Plafker's model can be ruled out. We suggest that, among all the proposed mechanisms behind lake formation, the combined action of wind and waves is the most likely. The evidence from the LM provides new hints for the formation of oriented lakes worldwide.

Geomorphology and evolution of the late Pleistocene to Holocene fluvial system in the south-eastern Llanos de Moxos, Bolivian Amazon

In the Bolivian Amazon several paleochannel generations are preserved. Their wide spectrum of morphologies clearly provides crucial information on the type and magnitude of geomorphic and hydrological changes within the drainage network of the Andean foreland. Therefore, in this study we mapped geomorphological characteristics of paleochannels, and applied radiocarbon and optically stimulated luminescence dating. Seven paleochannel generations are identified. Significant changes in sinuosity, channel widths and river pattern are observed for the successive paleochannel generations. Our results clearly reflect at least three different geomorphic and hydrological periods in the evolution of the fluvial system since the late Pleistocene. Changes in discharge and sediment load may be controlled by combinations of two interrelated mechanisms: (i) spatial changes and re-organizations of the drainage network in the upper catchment, and/or (ii) climate changes with their associated local to catchment-scale modifications in vegetation cover, and changes in discharge, inundation frequencies and magnitudes, which have likely affected the evolution of the fluvial system in the Llanos de Moxos. In summary, our study has revealed the enormous potential which geomorphic mapping and analysis combined with luminescence based chronologies hold for the reconstruction of the late Pleistocene to recent fluvial system in a large portion of Amazonia.

Los Andes en movimiento. Identidad y poder en el nuevo paisaje político

Actualmente los pueblos indígenas son actores indispensables en el espacio político de la región andina. En estas sociedades se produjo recientemente una ruptura en la larga continuidad de las prácticas coloniales que perduraron luego de las independencias bajo la forma de lo que se ha llamado el "colonialismo interno". El alcance de esta ruptura depende de la estructura política de cada país y de los acontecimientos que marcan sus destinos. Después, los movimientos y gobiernos de izquierda en Brasil, Ecuador, Bolivia y Venezuela cambiaron el paisaje político del continente. Estos proyectos nacionales se han vuelto un poderoso reto para los movimientos indígenas. Este volumen reúne las ponencias del Coloquio Internacional "Etnicidad y Política", organizado conjuntamente por el Área de Historia de la Universidad Andina Simón Bolívar y la Escuela de Investigación Histórica de la Universidad de Bielefeld, en el marco del proyecto de investigación "Etnización de lo político, negociaciones de inclusión y exclusión en el espacio andino y el espacio sudasiático". Este coloquio, que es la base de la publicación, analizó la situación en la región andina, incluyó algunos apuntes sobre el movimiento afroecuatoriano y abordó los procesos de la coyuntura actual iniciada con la toma de poder de Evo Morales y de Rafael Correa. Contribuyeron a este libro: Christian Büschges, Gonzalo Calque, Olaf Kaltmeier, Carmen Martínez Nava, Pablo Minda Batallas, Pablo Ospina Peralto, Franklin Ramírez Gallegos, Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui, Pablo Stefanoni, Catherine Walsh y León Zamosc.

Fortaleciéndo la soberanía alimentaria mediante la revalorización de saberes ecológicos locales: experiencia en los Andes bolivianos

Ethnobiology research contributes significantly to initiatives that aim to enhance food sovereignty among indigenous and/or traditional people. In Bolivia, one of the Latin-American countries that shows the highest poverty and undernourishment levels, the purpose of this research-action project was to enhance food sovereignty through the revitalization of the local ecological knowledge and to promote local technological innovation processes in the Andean community of Tallija-Confital. During a first step the endogenous knowledge and strategies related to food security and sovereignty were investigated, based on the principles and tools of the Revitalizing Participatory Research (RPR). In a second step local technical innovation processes were supported through a “knowledge dialogue” between exogenous and endogenous knowledge systems, focusing on the processing of the cañahua (Chenopodium pallidicaule Aellen) gluten. The research results demonstrate that Andean people have developed complex endogenous knowledge and strategies to adapt to socio-environmental changes that show a great potential to contribute to the enhancement of food sovereignty. Nevertheless, in the current globalized context that translates into new challenges for local communities, beyond the revitalization of local ecological knowledge, a dialogue between different knowledge systems can lead to important local technological innovation for the improvement of their well-being. Key words: food sovereignty, knowledge dialogue, endogenous development, technological innovation

Distribución social de los conocimientos de medicina tradicional en los Andes: Estudios de caso de Perú y Bolivia

Los factores socio-económicos que influyen sobre los conocimientos de plantas medicinales de la población (personas no especialistas que se auto medican con plantas medicinales) han sido poco estudiado en la investigación etnobotánica. En este marco, el objetivo del trabajo de investigación fue analizar la distribución social del conocimiento sobre plantas medicinales en comunidades rurales de los Andes peruanos y bolivianos. Se realizaron entrevistas detalladas y ejercicios de listados libres en idioma Quechua con la ayuda de un intérprete local con 18 familias de un distrito rural de los Andes peruanos y 18 familias de una subcentral rural de los Andes bolivianos. Se recolectaron muestras botánicas de las plantas junto con los informantes en las dos áreas de estudios de caso. Un análisis cuantitativo de clasificación mostró que, en los dos estudios de caso, los vínculos de parentesco y la historia personal influye sobre las especies de plantas conocidas y usadas, en vez de otros factores como la edad, el nivel de educación, el estatuto socio-económico o la religión. El proceso de migración hacía los centros urbanos y las tierras bajas amazónicas, generalmente considerado como un factor importante en la pérdida de los conocimientos de medicina tradicional, solo tiene un impacto sobre el conocimiento de la población en el caso de familias que migran más de seis meses por año o de manera permanente. La migración no influye sobre los niveles de conocimientos de plantas medicinales ni sobre las estrategias terapéuticas de las familias que migran de forma temporal o por periodos más cortos de tiempo. Se demuestra que el impacto de factores socio-económicos externos que son generalmente considerados como la causa de la pérdida de los conocimientos de medicina tradicional en las altas tierras andinas es limitado. Además, los resultados de investigación implican que en zonas rurales donde la migración tiene un impacto sobre los conocimientos locales, la medicina tradicional podría ser mejor fortalecida si se trabaja estrechamente con familias y su red de parentesco extendida.