Prices need no preferences: social trends determine decisions in experimental markets for pain relief.

OBJECTIVE: A standard view in health economics is that, although there is no market that determines the "prices" for health states, people can nonetheless associate health states with monetary values (or other scales, such as quality adjusted life year [QALYs] and disability adjusted life year [DALYs]). Such valuations can be used to shape health policy, and a major research challenge is to elicit such values from people; creating experimental "markets" for health states is a theoretically attractive way to address this. We explore the possibility that this framework may be fundamentally flawed-because there may not be any stable values to be revealed. Instead, perhaps people construct ad hoc values, influenced by contextual factors, such as the observed decisions of others. METHOD: The participants bid to buy relief from equally painful electrical shocks to the leg and arm in an experimental health market based on an interactive second-price auction. Thirty subjects were randomly assigned to two experimental conditions where the bids by "others" were manipulated to follow increasing or decreasing price trends for one, but not the other, pain. After the auction, a preference test asked the participants to choose which pain they prefer to experience for a longer duration. RESULTS: Players remained indifferent between the two pain-types throughout the auction. However, their bids were differentially attracted toward what others bid for each pain, with overbidding during decreasing prices and underbidding during increasing prices. CONCLUSION: Health preferences are dissociated from market prices, which are strongly referenced to others' choices. This suggests that the price of health care in a free-market has the capacity to become critically detached from people's underlying preferences.

Rationing Antiretroviral Therapy for HIV/AIDS in Africa: Efficiency, Equity, and Reality

Background: Rationing of access to antiretroviral therapy already exists in sub-Saharan Africa and will intensify as national treatment programs develop. The number of people who are medically eligible for therapy will far exceed the human, infrastructural, and financial resources available, making rationing of public treatment services inevitable. Methods: We identified 15 criteria by which antiretroviral therapy could be rationed in African countries and analyzed the resulting rationing systems across 5 domains: clinical effectiveness, implementation feasibility, cost, economic efficiency, and social equity. Findings: Rationing can be explicit or implicit. Access to treatment can be explicitly targeted to priority subpopulations such as mothers of newborns, skilled workers, students, or poor people. Explicit conditions can also be set that cause differential access, such as residence in a designated geographic area, co-payment, access to testing, or a demonstrated commitment to adhere to therapy. Implicit rationing on the basis of first-come, first-served or queuing will arise when no explicit system is enforced; implicit systems almost always allow a high degree of queue-jumping by the elite. There is a direct tradeoff between economic efficiency and social equity. Interpretation: Rationing is inevitable in most countries for some period of time. Without deliberate social policy decisions, implicit rationing systems that are neither efficient nor equitable will prevail. Governments that make deliberate choices, and then explain and defend those choices to their constituencies, are more likely to achieve a socially desirable outcome from the large investments now being made than are those that allow queuing and queue-jumping to dominate.

The use of atraumatic restorative treatment in elderly patients: a randomised controlled clinical trial

Objectives: to assess elderly patients’ dental status and dental habits and compare the survival rates, impact on patients’ quality of life and cost-effectiveness of Atraumatic Restorative Treatment (ART) and a conventional treatment (CT) to restore carious lesions in an elderly population. Methods: In this randomised clinical trial, 99 independently living adults (65-90 yrs) with carious lesions were randomly allocated to receive either ART or CT. Details of restored, missing and carious teeth were recorded and patients answered some questions about their oral hygiene and dental attendance habits. Direct and indirect costs were measured based on treatment time, materials and labour. Effectiveness was measured using restoration survival percentage after one year. The survival of restorations was assessed 6 months and one year after restoration placement by an independent examiner. Oralhealth related quality of life (OHRQoL) was assessed using the OHIP-14 at baseline and 2 months after treatment together with a global transition statement. Results: The patient sample comprised 46 (46.46%) male and 53 (53.54) female participants at baseline, with a mean age of 73.18 (SD=6.76). The mean DMFT of the entire sample was 27.10. Ninety patients and 268 restorations could be assessed after one year, 127 ART (46 patients) and 141 conventional restorations (44 patients). 93.7% and 97.2% of the restorations placed were considered successful in the ART and CT groups, respectively. The OHIP scores did not change dramatically 2 months after treatment, in either group. The global transition scale showed an improvement in overall oral health after treatment for the majority of patients. The ART were more cost-effective compared to the CT restorations. Conclusions: ART presented survival rates similar to CT after 1 year and was a more cost-effective alternative to treat the elderly.

The role of regret minimisation in lifestyle choices affecting the risk of coronary heart disease

This paper introduces the discrete choice model-paradigm of Random Regret Minimisation (RRM) to the field of health economics. The RRM is a regret-based model that explores a driver of choice different from the traditional utility-based Random Utility Maximisation (RUM). The RRM approach is based on the idea that, when choosing, individuals aim to minimise their regret–regret being defined as what one experiences when a non-chosen alternative in a choice set performs better than a chosen one in relation to one or more attributes. Analysing data from a discrete choice experiment on diet, physical activity and risk of a fatal heart attack in the next ten years administered to a sample of the Northern Ireland population, we find that the combined use of RUM and RRM models offer additional information, providing useful behavioural insights for better informed policy appraisal.

Management of cystic fibrosis

The pharmacological treatment of cystic fibrosis, together with implications for health economics, therapeutic monitoring and adherence, are discussed

Economic evaluation and its place in dentistry

Objective: This review intends to examine current research surrounding economic assessment in the delivery of dental care. Economic evaluation is an acknowledged method of analysing dental care systems by means of efficiency, effectiveness, efficacy and availability. Though this is a widely used method in medicine, it is underappreciated in dentistry. As the delivery of health care changes there has been recent demand by the public, the profession, and those funding dental treatment to investigate current practices regarding programs themselves and resource allocation.
Methods: A meta-analysis was conducted regarding health economics. The initial search was carried out using Pubmed, Google Scholar, Science Direct, and The Cochrane Library with search terms “health AND economics AND dentistry”. A secondary search was conducted with the terms “heath care AND dentistry AND”. The third part of the entry was changed to address the aims and included the following terms: “cost benefit analysis”, “efficiency criteria”, “supply & demand”, “cost-effectiveness”, “cost minimisation”, “cost utility”, “resource allocation”, “QALY”, and “delivery and economics”. Limits were applied to all searches to only include papers published in English within the last eight years.
Results: Preliminary results demonstrated a limited number of economic evaluations conducted in dentistry. Those that were carried out were mainly confined to the United Kingdom. Furthermore analysis was mainly restricted to restorative dentistry, followed by orthodontics, and maxillofacial surgery, thereby demonstrating a need for investigation in all fields of dentistry.
Conclusion: Health economics has been overlooked in the past regarding delivery of dental care and resource allocation. Economic appraisal is a crucial part of generating an effective and efficient dental care system. It is becoming increasingly evident that there is a need for economic evaluation in all dental fields.

Did the Millennium Development Goals Change Trends in Child Mortality?

There has been little assessment of the role the MDGs have had in progressing international development. There has been a 41 per cent reduction in the under-5 mortality rate worldwide from 1990 to 2011 and an acceleration in the rate of reduction since 2000. This paper explores why this has occurred and results for all developing countries indicate that it is not due to more healthcare or public health interventions but is driven by a coincidental burst of economic growth. Although the MDGs are considered to have played an important part in securing progress against poverty, hunger and disease there is very little evidence to back this viewpoint up. A thorough analysis of the successes and failures of the MDGs is therefore necessary before embarking on a new round of global goals.

Evaluation and Potential Cost-Effectiveness of Active Surveillance Pharmacovigilance for First-Line HAART in Namibia

Thesis (Ph.D.)--University of Washington, 2016-02

Contributos para a avaliação económica de medicamentos em Portu

RESUMO: A importância da avaliação económica na área da saúde tem sido crescente ao longo das últimas três décadas. É um campo de análise multi-disciplinar pelo qual se têm vindo a interessar investigadores de todo o mundo e onde, naturalmente, a economia da saúde tem contributos significativos para dar. Contudo, é uma área ainda relativamente inexplorada em termos de investigação metodológica em Portugal. Espera-se com este trabalho colmatar algumas das lacunas existentes e lançar pontes para investigação futura. Neste estudo pretendem-se desenvolver contributos autónomos, numa óptica de resolução de problemas concretos, para a avaliação económica de medicamentos em Portugal. Em primeiro lugar abordou-se a importância da estimação dos custos nos estudos de avaliação económica em saúde. Em segundo lugar determinou-se o custo de um doente com esclerose múltipla, por nível de severidade em Portugal com recurso à metodologia de estudos custo da doença. Em terceiro lugar, aplicando a mesma metodologia, determinou-se o custo de um doente com psoríase, por nível de severidade, em Portugal. Em quarto lugar mediu-se o impacto da psoríase na qualidade de vida relacionada com a saúde dos indivíduos afectados através de dois instrumentos genéricos de medição da qualidade de vida relacionada com a saúde (SF-36 e EQ-5D) e de dois instrumentos específicos (DLQI e PDI). Em quinto lugar, foi feita a adaptação de um modelo sobre a prevenção do tromboembolismo venoso em cirurgia ortopédica ao contexto nacional com recurso a dados recolhidos numa amostra de hospitais portugueses. Foi ainda apresentada uma estimativa do impacto orçamental decorrente da inclusão, ou não, de um novo medicamento na prática nacional. ABSTRACT: The importance of economic evaluation in the health care sector has been growing in the last three decades. It is a multidisciplinary field of research that attracts attention from researchers working all over the world. It is should be noted that health economics can contribute significantly to the development of this area. However, in Portugal is difficult to find methodological contributes in this field of research. With this work one hope to be able to overcome some of the existing shortcomings. This study seeks to develop independent contributions for the economic evaluation of pharmaceuticals in Portugal, aiming to help to solve existing problems. Firstly, one approached the importance of the accurate estimation of costs in economic evaluations of pharmaceuticals. Secondly, the cost of patient with multiple sclerosis was estimated, by severity level, in Portugal, using a cost of illness methodology. In third place, employing the same methodology, the cost of patient with psoriasis by severity level was estimated for Portugal. In fourth place, the impact of psoriasis in the quality of life related to health was ascertained by two generic measures (SF-36 and EQ-5D) and two specific measures (DLQI and PDI). Lastly, a model on the prevention of venous thromboembolism in orthopedic surgery was adapted for Portugal through the inclusion of data collected in a sample of Portuguese hospita

O financiamento hospitalar e a definição de preços

RESUMO - Inseridos num contexto onde as unidades prestadoras de cuidados de saúde não possuem autonomia para fixar os seus próprios preços, estuda-se através do presente documento o processo de definição de preços do internamento hospitalar português entre 1993 e 2001, no sentido de aferir o grau de sinalização proporcionado ao mercado, uma vez que, na sua essência, um sistema de preços constitui um sistema de incentivos influenciador de comportamentos produtivos ao nível prestador. Utilizou-se a base de dados nacionais do sistema de classificação de doentes Grupos de Diagnóstico Homogéneos e foi caracterizada a evolução e tendência dos pesos relativos dos produtos do internamento hospitalar português. Foi também avaliada a relação da estrutura de preços com a quantidade produzida, a eficiência técnica e as necessidades em saúde da população portuguesa durante o período considerado. Apesar de existir alguma instabilidade durante o período analisado, o ponto de partida e de chegada não diferiu significativamente. Não foi encontrado nenhum padrão de variação que explicasse a instabilidade encontrada entre os produtos mais complexos, mais produzidos ou os que apresentaram maior/menor variação ao longo da década de 90. A hipótese relativa à correlação entre a evolução de preços e as variáveis quantidade, eficiência e necessidades também foi infirmada. Conclui-se que a utilização do sistema de preços constituiu na sua essência um sistema de incentivos neutro, não foi sinalizador para os prestadores e possuiu uma forte correlação com o nível de reposição de custos históricos dos hospitais portugueses.

Identification de biomarqueurs protéiques prédictifs et diagnostiques des maladies coronariennes pour une population de souche canadienne-française

Les biomarqueurs plasmatiques constituent des outils essentiels, mais rares, utilisés pour diagnostiquer les maladies, comme les maladies cardiovasculaires (MCV), et stratifier le niveau de risque associé. L’identification de nouveaux biomarqueurs plasmatiques susceptibles d’améliorer le dépistage et le suivi des MCV représente ainsi un enjeu majeur en termes d’économie et de santé publique. Le projet vise à identifier de nouveaux biomarqueurs plasmatiques prédictifs ou diagnostiques des MCV, à déterminer le profil protéomique plasmatique de patients atteints de MCV et à développer des méthodes innovantes d’analyse d’échantillon plasmatique. L’étude a été effectuée sur une large banque de plasma provenant de 1006 individus de souche Canadienne-Française recrutés à différents stades de la MCV et qui ont été suivis sur une période de 5 ans. Des séries de déplétions ont été réalisées afin de dépléter les 14 protéines majoritaires (colonne IgY14TM) de l’échantillon avant son analyse par trois approches effectuées en parallèle: 1) Une chromatographie liquide (LC) en 2 dimensions qui fractionne les protéines selon le point isoélectrique puis selon le degré d’hydrophobicité, via le système PF2D, suivie par une chromatographie liquide couplée avec une spectrométrie de masse en tandem (LC-MS/MS). 2) Une séparation classique sur gel 1D-SDS-PAGE suivie d’une LC-MS/MS; 3) Par une déplétion plus poussée du plasma avec l’utilisation en tandem avec la colonne IgY14TM d’une colonne SupermixTM permettant de dépléter également les protéines de moyenne abondance, suivie d’une séparation sur gel 1D-SDS-PAGE et d’une analyse LC-MS/MS de la portion déplétée (3a) et de la portion liée à la SupermixTM (3b). Les résultats montrent que le système PF2D permet d’identifier plusieurs profils protéiques spécifiques au groupe MCV. Sur un total de 1156 fractions (équivalent à 1172 pics protéiques pour le groupe contrôle et 926 pics pour le groupe MCV) recueillies, 15 fractions (23 pics protéiques) présentaient des différences quantitativement significatives (p<0,05) entre les 2 groupes. De plus, 6 fractions (9 pics) sont uniquement présentes dans un groupe, représentant d’autres signatures protéomiques et biomarqueurs potentiellement intéressants. Les méthodes 2, 3a et 3b ont permis l’identification de 108, 125 et 91 protéines respectivement avec des chevauchements partiels (31% entre la méthode 2 et 3a, 61% entre 2 et 3b et 19% entre 3a et 3b). Les méthodes 2 et 3 ont permis l’identification de 12 protéines qui présentaient des différences quantitatives significatives entre les 2 groupes. L’utilisation de plusieurs approches protéomiques complémentaires nous ont d’ores et déjà permis d’identifier des candidats biomarqueurs des angines instables avec récidive d’infarctus du myocarde (IM).

Le rôle de l’évaluation économique dans la pratique des médecins de famille = The role of economic evaluation in the practice of family physicians

L’évaluation économique en santé consiste en l’analyse comparative d’alternatives de services en regard à la fois de leurs coûts et de leurs conséquences. Elle est un outil d’aide à la décision. La grande majorité des décisions concernant l’allocation des ressources sont prises en clinique; particulièrement au niveau des soins primaires. Puisque chaque décision est associée à un coût d’opportunité, la non-prise en compte des considérations économiques dans les pratiques des médecins de famille peut avoir un impact important sur l’efficience du système de santé. Il existe peu de connaissances quant à l’influence des évaluations économiques sur la pratique clinique. L’objet de la thèse est de comprendre le rôle de l’évaluation économique dans la pratique des médecins de famille. Ses contributions font l’objet de quatre articles originaux (philosophique, théorique, méthodologique et empirique). L’article philosophique suggère l’importance des questions de complexité et de réflexivité en évaluation économique. La complexité est la perspective philosophique, (approche générale épistémologique) qui sous-tend la thèse. Cette vision du monde met l’attention sur l’explication et la compréhension et sur les relations et les interactions (causalité interactive). Cet accent sur le contexte et le processus de production des données souligne l’importance de la réflexivité dans le processus de recherche. L’article théorique développe une conception nouvelle et différente du problème de recherche. L’originalité de la thèse réside également dans son approche qui s’appuie sur la perspective de la théorie sociologique de Pierre Bourdieu; une approche théorique cohérente avec la complexité. Opposé aux modèles individualistes de l’action rationnelle, Bourdieu préconise une approche sociologique qui s’inscrit dans la recherche d’une compréhension plus complète et plus complexe des phénomènes sociaux en mettant en lumière les influences souvent implicites qui viennent chaque jour exercer des pressions sur les individus et leurs pratiques. L’article méthodologique présente le protocole d’une étude qualitative de cas multiples avec niveaux d’analyse imbriqués : les médecins de famille (niveau micro-individuel) et le champ de la médecine familiale (niveau macro-structurel). Huit études de cas furent réalisées avec le médecin de famille comme unité principale d’analyse. Pour le niveau micro, la collecte des informations fut réalisée à l’aide d’entrevues de type histoire de vie, de documents et d’observation. Pour le niveau macro, la collecte des informations fut réalisée à l’aide de documents, et d’entrevues de type semi-structuré auprès de huit informateurs clés, de neuf organisations médicales. L’induction analytique fut utilisée. L’article empirique présente l’ensemble des résultats empiriques de la thèse. Les résultats montrent une intégration croissante de concepts en économie dans le discours officiel des organisations de médecine familiale. Cependant, au niveau de la pratique, l'économisation de ce discours ne semble pas être une représentation fidèle de la réalité puisque la très grande majorité des participants n'incarnent pas ce discours. Les contributions incluent une compréhension approfondie des processus sociaux qui influencent les schèmes de perception, de pensée, d’appréciation et d’action des médecins de famille quant au rôle de l’évaluation économique dans la pratique clinique et la volonté des médecins de famille à contribuer à une allocation efficiente, équitable et légitime des ressources.