Plan zemelʻnogo otvoda s.-kh. arteli "Krasnyĭ Pakharʻ" Krivorogskogo okruga, Sofievskogo raĭona ploshchadiʻ︠u︡ 1380 desi︠a︡tin

Digital image

Plan zemelʻnogo otvoda uchastka N 15 Krivorogskogo okruga, Mikhaĭlovskogo raĭona ploshchadiʻ︠u︡ 329 gektarov

Digital image

Plan zemelʻnogo otvoda uchastka N 165/15 Krivorogskogo okruga, Mikhaĭlovskogo raĭona ploshchadiʻ︠u︡ 329 gektarov

Digital image

Plan uchastka kolonizat︠s︡ionnogo fonda pod Nº 102/7, Krivorogskogo okruga Bozhedarovskogo raĭona ploshchadiʻ︠u︡ 1907 gektarov

Digital image

Moving beyond the business plan in enterprise education

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to approach the debate surrounding the role of business plans in enterprise/entrepreneurship education from a different perspective; that of the student. The paper argues that much of the consternation within this stubborn debate derives from a lack of appreciation of the context actually occurring in the lives of our students. The paper aims to explore several arguments directly related to these contexts. Design/methodology/approach The approach is to build around a combining of cycles of reflective practice via the authors' iterative consultation with each other. The paper seeks to explore the world of the student via an enfolding of the literature, but ultimately we do not claim to have hidden our personal biases. Findings It is important to separate enterprise education (EE) from entrepreneurship education when discussing the role of the business plan. While the business plan has a place in the latter, it makes little sense for it to be a focal learning activity in the former. In addition, we see this outcome as a positive outcome for our field with little point in continuing on with what has become a fairly pointless debate. Practical implications: The paper concludes that once EE is viewed as being distinctly different from entrepreneurship education it is free to be considered with more precision what learning needs exist. Focusing on learning needs changes the direction of the discussion, with the business plan only up for discussion if it contributes a learning activity related to pre-determined learning outcomes. Originality/value The paper offers a constructive way forward from a debate that has been beset with extreme vested interests for too long.

The student business plan: Useful or not?

This article offers a critical discussion of the role of the business plan in current enterprise educational practice. In addition to reviewing recent work that considers the ‘for’ and ‘against’ arguments about the use of business plans in higher education, the authors suggest that the context of student learning is largely omitted from these discussions. As such, they contextualize the debate so that the purpose of the business plan can be better appreciated. They build on recent work that offers alternatives to the business plan – approaches directly focused on customer discovery and explicit testing of assumptions. In doing so, recent concerns about the value of business plans and, conversely, the views of those who argue in favour of the role of business plans in enterprise education, are noted. The article provides insights into emerging alternative practices in the field of enterprise education, practices based on students’ use of such education as a vehicle for skills and knowledge development and/or wealth creation. It is acknowledged that various biases are present in the current debate, including those of the present authors: whilst it is accepted that these biases are unlikely to disappear, the article contextualizes their origins.

Ground Plan for Mill Street Synagogue

Digital image

Plan dachi obrazovannoĭ iz Kolfondov chasti Nº 387 i NºNº 389, 390, 392 i 466, Odesskŏi gubernii Khersoskogo okruga, Snigirskogo raĭona i Nº398 Khersonskogo raĭna razverstannoi na optimalʻnye uchastki

Digital image

Plan poselka na uchastke Nº32 Kachkarovskogo raĭono Khersonskogo okruga

Digital image

Plan poselka Vaĭsbrunen Nº 5 Snigirevskogo raĭona otdelʻnykh khazi︠a︡ĭstv 98

Digital image

Plan poselka Fraĭ.Leben Nº 3 Snigirevskogo raĭona otdelʻnykh khazi︠a︡ĭstv 80

Digital image

Plan zemelʻnogo uchastka poselka I︠U︡dendorf N 2

Digital image

Plan zemelʻnogo uchastka poselka FraĭLeben N 3

Digital image

Plan zemelʻnogo uchastka poselka N 4

Digital image

Plan zemelʻnogo uchastka poselka Vaĭsbrunen N 5

Digital image