Strange bedfellows: The ethics and politics of medical futility in Texas

Background: Futile medical treatments are interventions that are not associated with a benefit to the patient. The definition and concept of medical futility are controversial. The Texas Advance Directives Act (TADA) was passed in 1999 to address medically inappropriate interventions by allowing providers to withdraw inappropriate interventions against a surrogate decision maker's wishes following a review, attempt to transfer the patient, and 10-day waiting period. The original legislation was a negotiated compromise by players across the political spectrum. However, in recent years there has been increasing controversy regarding TADA and attempts to alter its applicability in Texas. ^ Purpose: The purpose of this project was to apply Paul Sabatier's advocacy coalition framework (ACF) to gain understanding into the historical, ethical, and political basis of the initial compromise, and determine the sources of conflict that have led to increased opposition to TADA. ^ Methods: Using the ACF model, key actors within the medical futility policy debate in Texas were aggregated into coalitions based on shared beliefs. A narrative summary based analysis identified the core elements of the policy subsystem, as well as the constraints and resources of the subsystem actors. Externalities that promoted adjustments to coalition beliefs and tactics used by coalition participants were analyzed. Data sources included review of the published literature regarding medical futility, as well as analysis of published newspaper accounts and editorials regarding the medical futility issue in Texas, legislative testimony, and review of weblogs and online commentaries dealing with the issue. ^ Results: Primary coalition participants in developing compromise legislation in 1999 were the Providers and Vitalists, with Autonomists gaining a prominent role starting in 2006. Internal factors associated with the breakdown of consensus included changes to the makeup of the governing coalition and changes in individual case information available to the Vitalist coalition. Externalities related to the intertwining of the Sun Hudson case and the Terri Schiavo case generated negative publicity for the TADA from progressive and conservative viewpoints. Dissemination of information in various venues regarding contentious cases was associated with more polarization of viewpoints, and realignment of coalition alliances. ^ Conclusions: The ACF provided an outline for the initial compromise over the creation of the Texas Advance Directives Act as well as the eventual loss of consensus. The debate between the Provider, Vitalist, and Autonomist coalitions has been affected by internal policy evolution, changes in the governing coalition, and important externalities. The debate over medical futility in Texas has had much broader implications in the dispute over Health Care Reform.^

Weight-for-age percentile and its association to community acquired methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus among pediatric patients in Houston, TX

BACKGROUND: Weight has been implicated as a risk factor for symptomatic community-acquired methicillin resistant Staphylococcus Aureus (CA-MRSA). Information from Texas Children's Hospital (TCH) in Houston, TX was used to implement a case-control study to assess weight-for-age percentile (WFA), race and seasonal exposure as risk factors. ^ METHODS: A retrospective chart review to collect data from TCH was conducted covering the time period January 1st, 2008 to May 31st, 2011. Cases were confirmed and identified by the infectious disease department and were matched on a 1:1 ratio to controls that were seen by the emergency department for non-infected fractures from June 1st, 2008 to May 31st, 2011. Data abstraction was performed using TCH's electronic medical records (EMR) system (EPIC ®). ^ RESULTS: Of 702 CA-MRSA identified cases, ages 9 to 16.99, 564 (80.3%) had the variable `weight' present in their EMR, were not duplicates and not determined to be outliers. Cases were randomly matched to a pool of available controls (n=1864) according to age and gender, yielding 539 1:1 matched pairs (95.5% case matching success) with a total study sample size, N=1078. Case median age was 13.38 years with the majority being White (66.05%) and male (59.4%). Adjusted conditional logistic regression analysis of the matched pairs identified the following risk factors to presenting with CA-MRSA infection among pediatric patients, ages 9 to 16.99 years: a) Individual weight in the highest (75th-99.9th) WFA quartile (OR=1.36; 95% confidence interval [CI]=1.06-1.74; P= 0.016), b) Infection during summer months (OR: 1.69; 95% CI=1.2-2.38; P= 0.003), c) patients of African American race/ethnicity (OR= 1.48; 95% CI=1.13-1.95; P= 0.004). ^ CONCLUSIONS: Pediatric patients, 9 to 16.99 years of age, in the highest WFA quartile (75th-99.9th), or of African-American race had an associated increased risk of presenting with CA-MRSA infection. Furthermore, children in this population were at a higher risk of contracting CA-MRSA infection during the summer season.^

Subclavian vein catheter -related infection and hospital costs associated with exchange via a guidewire

An observational study was conducted in a SICU to determine the frequency of subclavian vein catheter-related infection at 72 hours, to identify the hospital cost of exchange via a guidewire and the estimated hospital cost-savings of a 72 hour vs 144 hour exchange policy.^ An overall catheter-related infection ($\geq$15 col. by Maki's technique (1977)) occurred in 3% (3/100) of the catheter tips cultured. Specific infections rates were: 9.7% (3/31) for triple lumen catheters, 0% (0/30) for Swan-Ganz catheters, 0% (0/30) for Cordes catheters, and 0% (0/9) for single lumen catheters.^ An estimated annual hospital cost-savings of $35,699.00 was identified if exchange of 72 hour policy were changed to every 144 hours.^ It was recommended that a randomized clinical trial be conducted to determine the effect of changing a subclavian vein catheter via a guidewire every 72 hours vs 144 hours. ^

Calmodulin -regulated processes and intracellular calcium in the heat stress response of mammalian cells

Three approaches were used to examine the role of Ca$\sp{2+}$- and/or calmodulin (CaM)-regulated processes in the mammalian heat stress response. The focus of the first approach was on the major Ca$\sp{2+}$-binding protein, CaM, and involved the use of CaM antagonists that perturbed CaM-regulated processes during heat stress. The second approach involved the use of a cell line and its BPV-1 transformants that express increased basal levels of CaM, or parvalbumin--a Ca$\sp{2+}$-binding protein not normally found in these cells. The last approach used Ca$\sp{2+}$ chelators to buffer Ca$\sp{2+}$-transients.^ The principle conclusions resulting from these three experimental approaches are: (1) CaM antagonists cause a temperature-dependent potentiation of heat killing, but do not inhibit the triggering and development of thermotolerance suggesting some targets for heat killing are different from those that lead to thermotolerance; (2) Members of major HSP families (especially HSP70) can bind to CaM in a Ca$\sp{2+}$-dependent manner in vitro, and HSP have been associated with events leading to thermotolerance. But, because thermotolerance is not affected by CaM antagonists, and antagonists should interfere with HSP binding to CaM, the events leading to triggering or developing thermotolerance were not strongly dependent on HSP binding to CaM; (3) CaM antagonists can also bind to HSP70 (and possibly other HSP) suggesting an alternative mechanism for the action of these agents in heat killing may involve direct binding to other proteins, like HSP70, whose function is important for survival following heating and inhibiting their activity; and (4) The signal governing the rate of synthesis of another major HSP group, the HSP26 family, can be largely abrogated by elevated Ca$\sp{2+}$-binding proteins or Ca$\sp{2+}$ chelators without significantly reducing survival or thermotolerance suggesting if the HSP26 family is involved in either end point, it may function in (Ca$\sp{2+}$) $\sb{\rm i}$ homeostasis. ^

Dissection of antitumor activity by lymphokine -activated killer cells: Role of FcR+ precursors and obligatory role of tumor necrosis factor-$\alpha$ in antibody -dependent cellular cytotoxicity

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) cultured for varying lengths of time in IL-2 are able to mediate antibody independent cellular cytotoxicity (AICC) as well as antibody dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against a wide range of tumor targets. The objective of our study is to determine the cytotoxic potential of the subset of LAK cells involved in ADCC, the tumor recognition mechanism in ADCC, the kinetics of ADCC mediated by PBL cultured under various conditions and the role of TNF-$\alpha$ in the development and maturation of ADCC effectors in the LAK population.^ The model system in this study for ADCC used a monoclonal antibody 14G2a (IgG2a), that recognizes the GD2 epitope on human melanoma cell line, SK-Mel-1. The target recognition mechanism operative in AICC (traditionally known as lymphokine activated killing or LAK) is an acquired property of these IL-2 activated cells which confers on them the unique ability to distinguish between tumor and normal cells. This recognition probably involves the presence of a trypsin sensitive N-linked glycoprotein epitope on tumor cells. Proteolytic treatment of the tumor cells with trypsin renders them resistant to AICC by PBL cultured in IL-2. However, ADCC is unaffected. This ADCC, mediated by the relatively small population of cells that are positive for the Fc receptor for IgG (FcR), is an indication that this subset of "LAK" cells does not require the trypsin sensitive epitope on tumor cells to mediate killing. Enriching PBL for FcR+ cells markedly enhanced both AICC and ADCC and also reduced the IL-2 requirement of these cells.^ The stoichiometry of Fc receptor (FcR) expression on the cytotoxic effectors does not correlate with ADCC lytic activity. Although FcRs are necessary to mediate ADCC, other factors, appear to regulate the magnitude of cytolytic activity. In order to investigate these putative factors, the kinetics of ADCC development was studied under various conditions (in IL-2 (10u/ml) and 100u/ml), in IL-2(10u/ml) + TNF$\alpha$ (500u/ml) and in TNF-$\alpha$ (500u/ml) alone). Addition of exogenous TNF-$\alpha$ into the four hour cytotoxicity assay did not increase ADCC, nor did anti-TNF antibodies result in inhibition. On the other hand, addition of anti-TNF antibodies to PBL and IL-2 for 24 hours, resulted in a marked inhibition of the ADCC, suggesting that endogenous TNF-$\alpha$ is obligatory for the maturation and differentiation of ADCC effectors. ^

Regulation of {\it neu\/} gene expression by the simian virus 40 large T antigen and tumor suppressors Rb and p53

The neu gene (also c-erbB-2 or HER2) encodes a 185 kilodalton protein that is frequently overexpressed in breast, ovarian and non-small cell lung cancers. Study of the regulation of neu indicates that neu gene expression can be modulated by c-myc or by the adenovirus 5 E1a gene product. This study demonstrates that the transforming protein, large T antigen, of the simian virus 40 represses neu promoter activity. Repression of neu by large T antigen is mediated through the region $-$172 to $-$79 (relative to first ATG) of the neu promoter--unlike through $-$312 to $-$172 for c-myc or E1a. This suggests a different pathway for repression of neu by large T antigen. The 10 amino acid region of large T required for binding the tumor suppressor, retinoblastoma gene product, Rb, is not necessary for repression of neu. Moreover, the tumor suppressors, Rb and p53 can independently inhibit neu promoter activity. Rb inhibits neu through a 10 base pair G-rich enhancer (GTG element) ($-$243 to $-$234) and also through regions close to transcription initiation sites ($-$172 to $-$79). Mutant Rb unable to complex large T is able to repress the region close to transcription initiation but not the GTG enhancer. Thus, Rb inhibits the two regulatory domains of the neu gene by different mechanisms. Both Rb and p53 can repress the transforming activity of activated neu in focus forming assays. These data provide evidence that tumor suppressors regulate expression of growth stimulatory genes such as neu. Therefore, one reason for the overexpression of neu that is frequently seen in breast cancer cells may be due to functional inactivation of Rb and p53 which is also a common occurrence in breast cancer cells. ^

Expression of p53, {\it * ras\/} and PCNA in human colonic neoplasms: Possible biomarkers of malignant potential

Colorectal cancer is a leading cause of cancer mortality and early detection can significantly improve the clinical outcome. Most colorectal cancers arise from benign neoplastic lesions recognized as adenomas. Only a small percentage of all adenomas will become malignant. Thus, there is a need to identify specific markers of malignant potential. Studies at the molecular level have demonstrated an accumulation of genetic alterations, some hereditary but for the most occurring in somatic cells. The most common are the activation of ras, an oncogene involved in signal transduction, and the inactivation of p53, a tumor suppressor gene implicated in cell cycle regulation. In this study, 38 carcinomas, 95 adenomas and 20 benign polyps were analyzed by immunohistochemistry for the abnormal expression of p53 and ras proteins. An index of cellular proliferation was also measured by labeling with PCNA. A general overexpression of p53 was immunodetected in 66% of the carcinomas, while 26% of adenomas displayed scattered individual positive cells or a focal high concentration of positive cells. This later was more associated with severe dysplasia. Ras protein was detected in 37% of carcinomas and 32% of adenomas mostly throughout the tissue. p53 immunodetection was more frequent in adenomas originating in colons with synchronous carcinomas, particularly in patients with familial adenomatous polyposis and it may be a useful marker in these cases. Difference in the frequency of p53 and ras alterationbs was related to the location of the neoplasm. Immunodetection of p53 protein was correlated to the presence of a mutation in p53 gene at exon 7 and 5 in 4/6 carcinomas studied and 2 villous adenomas. Thus, we characterized in adenomas the abnormal expression of two proteins encoded by the most commonly altered genes in colorectal cancer. p53 alteration appears to be more specifically associated with transition to malignancy than ras. By using immunohistochemistry, a technique that keeps the architecture of the tissue intact, it was possible to correlate these alterations to histopathological characteristics that were associated with higher risks for transformation: villous content, dysplasia and size of adenoma. ^

Estradiol and insulin cross -talk in breast cancer

Approximately 33% of clinical breast carcinomas require estrogens to proliferate. Epidemiological data show that insulin resistance and diabetes mellitus is 2–3 times more prevalent in women with breast cancer than those with benign breast lesions, suggesting a clinical link between insulin and estradiol. Insulin and estradiol have a synergistic effect on the growth of MCF7 breast cancer cells, and long-term estradiol treatment upregulates the expression of the key insulin signaling protein IRS-1. The goal of this study was to further define the mechanism(s) of cross-talk between insulin and estradiol in regulating the growth of breast cancer. Using MCF7 cells, acute treatment with insulin or estradiol alone was found to stimulate two activities associated with growth: Erk MAP kinase and PI 3-kinase. However, combined acute treatment had an antagonistic effect on both activities. Acute estradiol treatment inhibited the insulin-stimulated tyrosine phosphorylation of IRS-1 while increasing its serine phosphorylation; the serine phosphorylation was attenuated by the PI 3-kinase inhibitor wortmannin. The acute antagonism observed with combined estradiol and insulin are not consistent with the long-term synergistic effect on growth. In contrast, chronic estradiol treatment enhanced the insulin-sensitivity of breast cancer cells as measured by increases in total cellular insulin-stimulated tyrosine phosphorylation of IRS-1 and activation of PI 3-kinase. Estradiol stimulation of gene transcription was found to require PI 3-kinase activity but not MAP kinase activity. Insulin alone had no effect on ER transcriptional activity, but chronic treatment in combination with estradiol resulted in synergism of ER transcription. The synergistic effect of insulin and estradiol on MCF7 cell growth was also found to require PI 3-kinase but not MAP kinase activity. Therefore, chronic estradiol treatment increases insulin stimulation of PI 3-kinase, and PI 3-kinase is required for estradiol stimulation of gene transcription alone and in combined synergy with insulin. These data demonstrate that PI 3-kinase is the locus for the cross-talk between insulin and estradiol which results in enhanced breast cancer growth with long-term exposure to both hormones. This may have important clinical implications for women with high risk for breast cancer and/or diabetes mellitus. ^

Applying scanning electron microscopy for the ultrastructural and clinical analysis of periprosthetic capsules in implant-based breast reconstruction

La reconstruction en deux étapes par expanseur et implant est la technique la plus répandue pour la reconstruction mammmaire post mastectomie. La formation d’une capsule périprothétique est une réponse physiologique universelle à tout corps étranger présent dans le corps humain; par contre, la formation d’une capsule pathologique mène souvent à des complications et par conséquent à des résultats esthétiques sous-optimaux. Le microscope électronique à balayage (MEB) est un outil puissant qui permet d’effectuer une évaluation sans pareille de la topographie ultrastructurelle de spécimens. Le premier objectif de cette thèse est de comparer le MEB conventionnel (Hi-Vac) à une technologie plus récente, soit le MEB environnemental (ESEM), afin de déterminer si cette dernière mène à une évaluation supérieure des tissus capsulaires du sein. Le deuxième objectif est d‘appliquer la modalité de MEB supérieure et d’étudier les modifications ultrastructurelles des capsules périprothétiques chez les femmes subissant différents protocoles d’expansion de tissus dans le contexte de reconstruction mammaire prothétique. Deux études prospectives ont été réalisées afin de répondre à nos objectifs de recherche. Dix patientes ont été incluses dans la première, et 48 dans la seconde. La modalité Hi-Vac s’est avérée supérieure pour l’analyse compréhensive de tissus capsulaires mammaires. En employant le mode Hi-Vac dans notre protocole de recherche établi, un relief 3-D plus prononcé à été observé autour des expanseurs BIOCELL® dans le groupe d’approche d’intervention retardée (6 semaines). Des changements significatifs n’ont pas été observés au niveau des capsules SILTEX® dans les groupes d’approche d’intervention précoce (2 semaines) ni retardée.

A dictionary of terms used in medicine and the collateral sciences

Mode of access: Internet.

A dictionary of medicine and the allied sciences ... /

Mode of access: Internet.

Transylvania journal of medicine and the associate sciences.

Editors: v.8-9, L.P. Yandell; v.10, Robert Peter.

Scalpel: an entirely original quarterly expositor of the laws of health, and abuses of medicine and domestic life.

Vols. have subtitle: a journal of health, adapted to popular & professional reading, & the exposure of quackery.