The Influence of Informational and Emotional Advertising Appeals on Advertising Effectiveness – Consumers’ Perspective on the Over-the-Counter Product Advertisements in Finland

Consumers face enormous amounts of promotional messages daily whereas the pharmaceutical companies among other industries spend considerable time and money developing effective advertising strategies. There are multiple possible ways to appeal the target customer in order to increase the effectiveness of the advertisement. In spite of the various possibilities to categorize persuasive communication, the informational and the emotional appeals are the typical approaches. This study assesses the influence of the informational and emotional advertising appeals on the advertising effectiveness in the context of OTCs in Finland. The research method applied in this study is a quantitative survey. The data consists of 461 responses from the target population of 18–80 years old Finnish speaking consumers. The results from the marketing research indicate that the positive correlations of the emotional appeals are much stronger than the positive correlations of the informational appeals relating to the advertising effectiveness. However, on average the Finnish consumers experience the OTC advertisements relying on the informational appeals more effective than the OTC advertisements relying on the emotional appeals. Furthermore, within emotional appeals there is a much greater variety in the experienced advertising effectiveness not providing as stabile and consistent experienced advertising effectiveness compared to the informational appeals. Thus, the OTC advertisement relying more on the emotional appeals are much more risky in terms of advertising effectiveness. There are also differences with the experienced advertising effectiveness between the Finnish consumer groups and the information can be utilised when designing tailored OTC advertisements. The Finnish men consider humorous advertisements more effective than the Finnish women. In addition, the people living outside Uusimaa Region experience higher advertising effectiveness with the advertisements relying more on the informational advertisements compared to the people living in Uusimaa Region. In similar vein, the people with lower education experience higher advertising effectiveness with the advertisements relying more on the informational advertisements compared to the people with high education. Additionally, the older generation perceive an OTC advertisement with a middle-aged celebrity more effective than the younger consumers

Response efficacy : the key to minimizing rejection and maximizing acceptance of emotion-based anti-speeding messages

This study sought to improve understanding of the persuasive process of emotion-based appeals not only in relation to negative, fear-based appeals but also for appeals based upon positive emotions. In particular, the study investigated whether response efficacy, as a cognitive construct, mediated outcome measures of message effectiveness in terms of both acceptance and rejection of negative and positive emotion-based messages. Licensed drivers (N = 406) participated via the completion of an on-line survey. Within the survey, participants received either a negative (fear-based) appeal or one of the two possible positive appeals (pride or humor-based). Overall, the study's findings confirmed the importance of emotional and cognitive components of persuasive health messages and identified response efficacy as a key cognitive construct influencing the effectiveness of not only fear-based messages but also positive emotion-based messages. Interestingly, however, the results suggested that response efficacy's influence on message effectiveness may differ for positive and negative emotion-based appeals such that significant indirect (and mediational) effects were found with both acceptance and rejection of the positive appeals yet only with rejection of the fear-based appeal. As such, the study's findings provide an important extension to extant literature and may inform future advertising message design.

Just give me the facts? literalism versus symbolism in B2B advertising

For decades the prevailing idea in B2B marketing has been that buyers are motivated by product/service specifications. Sellers are put on approved supplier lists, invited to respond to RFPs, and are selected on the basis of superior products, at the right price, delivered on time. The history of B2B advertising is filled with the advice “provide product specifications” and your advertising will be noticed, lead to sales inquiries, and eventually result in higher sales. Advertising filled with abstractions might work in the B2C market, but the B2B marketplace is about being literal. What we know about advertising — and particularly the message component of advertising — is based on a combination of experience, unproven ideas and a bit of social science. Over the years, advertising guidelines produced by the predecessors of BMA (National Industrial Advertising Association, Association of Industrial Advertising, and the Business/Professional Advertising Association) stressed emphasizing product features and tangible benefits. The major publishers of B2B magazines, e.g., McGraw-Hill, Penton Publishing, et al. had similar recommendations. Also, B2B marketing books recommend advertising that focuses on specific product features (Kotler and Pfoertsch, 2006; Lamons, 2005). In more recent times, abstraction in advertising messages has penetrated the B2B marketplace. Even though such advertising legends as David Ogilvy (1963, 1985) frequently recommended advertising based on hard-core information, we’ve seen the growing use of emotional appeals, including humor, fear, parental affection, etc. Beyond the use of emotion, marketers attempt to build a stronger connection between their brands and buyers through the use of abstraction and symbolism. Below are two examples of B2B advertisements — Figure 1A is high in literalism and Figure 1B is high in symbolism. Which approach — a “left-brain” (literal) or “right brain” (symbolic) is more effective in B2B advertising? Are the advertising message creation guidelines from the history of B2B advertising accurate? Are the foundations of B2B message creation (experience and unproven ideas) sound?

Extending the explanatory utility of the EPPM beyond fear-based persuasion

In the 20 years since its inception, the EPPM has attracted much empirical support. Currently, and unsurprisingly given that is a model of fear-based persuasion, the EPPM’s explanatory utility has been based only upon fear-based messages. However, an argument is put forth herein, which draws upon existing evidence, that the EPPM may be an efficacious framework for explaining the persuasive process and outcomes of emotion-based messages more broadly when such messages are addressing serious health topics. For the current study, four different types of emotional appeals were purposefully devised and included a fear, an annoyance/agitation, a pride, and a humour-based message. All messages addressed the serious health issue of road safety, and in particular the risky behaviour of speeding. Participants (N = 551) were exposed to only one of the four messages and subsequently provided responses within a survey. A series of 2 (threat: low, high) x 2 (efficacy: low, high) analysis of variance was conducted for each of the appeals based on the EPPM’s message outcomes of acceptance and rejection. Support was found for the EPPM with a number of main effects of threat and efficacy emerging, reflecting that, irrespective of emotional appeal type, high levels of threat and efficacy enhanced message outcomes via maximising acceptance and minimising rejection. Theoretically, the findings provide support for the explanatory utility of the EPPM for emotion-based health messages more broadly. In an applied sense, the findings highlight the value of adopting the EPPM as a framework when devising and evaluating emotion-based health messages for serious health topics.

Young drivers’ responses to anti-speeding advertisements: Comparison of self-report and objective measures of persuasive processing and outcomes

Objective Self-report measures are typically used to assess the effectiveness of road safety advertisements. However, psychophysiological measures of persuasive processing (i.e., skin conductance response [SCR]) and objective driving measures of persuasive outcomes (i.e., in-vehicle GPS devices) may provide further insights into the effectiveness of these advertisements. This study aimed to explore the persuasive processing and outcomes of two anti-speeding advertisements by incorporating both self-report and objective measures of speeding behaviour. In addition, this study aimed to compare the findings derived from these different measurement approaches. Methods Young drivers (N = 20, Mage = 21.01 years) viewed either a positive or negative emotion-based anti-speeding television advertisement. Whilst viewing the advertisement, SCR activity was measured to assess ad-evoked arousal responses. The RoadScout® GPS device was then installed into participants’ vehicles for one week to measure on-road speed-related driving behaviour. Self-report measures assessed persuasive processing (emotional and arousal responses) and actual driving behaviour. Results There was general correspondence between the self-report measures of arousal and the SCR and between the self-report measure of actual driving behaviour and the objective driving data (as assessed via the GPS devices). Conclusions This study provides insights into how psychophysiological and GPS devices could be used as objective measures in conjunction with self-report measures to further understand the persuasive processes and outcomes of emotion-based anti-speeding advertisements.

A COMUNICAÇÃO PUBLICITÁRIA NAS INSTITUIÇÕES FINANCEIRAS PARA O SEGMENTO DE ALTA RENDA

Esta pesquisa investiga como quatro dos maiores bancos que atuam no Brasil - Bradesco, Itaú, Citibank e BankBoston - utilizam a comunicação para seduzir o público de alta renda. O objetivo é definir quais são os apelos e os valores utilizados nos comerciais de televisão e entender por que os filmes são muitos similares nos argumentos de persuasão. A importância desta pesquisa se define em conseqüência da forte presença dos bancos no meio TV e pelo fato de os principais bancos no Brasil terem lançado num curto espaço de tempo submarcas, um recurso muito utilizado pela indústria com as extensões de marcas, para atender a um mercado de alta renda estimado em 2 milhões de pessoas. Este é um tema novo e ainda pouco explorado na academia. Os métodos utilizados foram a análise de conteúdo, que verificou os argumentos dos comerciais de TV e a pesquisa bibliográfica, que deu o lastro necessário para a definição do problema e embasou a estruturação do estudo Os principais resultados da pesquisa apresentaram a conversão de duas tendências; a primeira vem dos novos valores que sopram da sociedade, destacadamente das pessoas de alta renda no Brasil. Elas têm apresentado novas formas de consumo, que estão muito mais ligadas às emoções. A ostentação e o consumo de produtos sofisticados como sinônimo de status e poder continuam e possivelmente deverão continuar a existir, mas nota-se agora que ao menos parte da elite brasileira busca se diferenciar por valores subjetivos. Estão de volta os valores básicos da sociedade como relacionamento familiar, valorização das coisas simples e melhor aproveitamento do tempo. Por outro lado, a segunda tendência é mercadológica. Com a comoditização dos produtos e serviços, as empresas buscam se diferenciar pela marca e, para fazer a conexão desta com os consumidores, são utilizados argumentos emocionais. Até porque, para se manipular os consumidores, o modo mais eficaz é através da emoção. Pode-se dizer também que, para furar o bloqueio mental que os consumidores erguem em virtude do bombardeio de mensagens que recebem diariamente, o caminho é o de entreter, emocionar. Aliado a tudo isto, os bancos rezam de imagem negativa na sociedade e vêm trabalhando para minimizar esta percepção: querem por intermédio de suas mensagens publicitárias se tornar mais simpáticos, humanos. Quando reunidos esses movimentos - o da sociedade valorizando mais o ser do que o ter e os bancos querendo se humanizar e utilizando abordagens emocionais em sua comunicação - é fácil entender a similaridade de argumentos. Mas será que a falta de diferenciação não continuará trazendo a comoditização dos produtos e serviços para a comoditização da comunicação e fazendo com que ela deixe de cumprir um dos seus papéis fundamentais que é o de fazer um anunciante se diferenciar da concorrência?

A COMUNICAÇÃO PUBLICITÁRIA NAS INSTITUIÇÕES FINANCEIRAS PARA O SEGMENTO DE ALTA RENDA

Esta pesquisa investiga como quatro dos maiores bancos que atuam no Brasil - Bradesco, Itaú, Citibank e BankBoston - utilizam a comunicação para seduzir o público de alta renda. O objetivo é definir quais são os apelos e os valores utilizados nos comerciais de televisão e entender por que os filmes são muitos similares nos argumentos de persuasão. A importância desta pesquisa se define em conseqüência da forte presença dos bancos no meio TV e pelo fato de os principais bancos no Brasil terem lançado num curto espaço de tempo submarcas, um recurso muito utilizado pela indústria com as extensões de marcas, para atender a um mercado de alta renda estimado em 2 milhões de pessoas. Este é um tema novo e ainda pouco explorado na academia. Os métodos utilizados foram a análise de conteúdo, que verificou os argumentos dos comerciais de TV e a pesquisa bibliográfica, que deu o lastro necessário para a definição do problema e embasou a estruturação do estudo Os principais resultados da pesquisa apresentaram a conversão de duas tendências; a primeira vem dos novos valores que sopram da sociedade, destacadamente das pessoas de alta renda no Brasil. Elas têm apresentado novas formas de consumo, que estão muito mais ligadas às emoções. A ostentação e o consumo de produtos sofisticados como sinônimo de status e poder continuam e possivelmente deverão continuar a existir, mas nota-se agora que ao menos parte da elite brasileira busca se diferenciar por valores subjetivos. Estão de volta os valores básicos da sociedade como relacionamento familiar, valorização das coisas simples e melhor aproveitamento do tempo. Por outro lado, a segunda tendência é mercadológica. Com a comoditização dos produtos e serviços, as empresas buscam se diferenciar pela marca e, para fazer a conexão desta com os consumidores, são utilizados argumentos emocionais. Até porque, para se manipular os consumidores, o modo mais eficaz é através da emoção. Pode-se dizer também que, para furar o bloqueio mental que os consumidores erguem em virtude do bombardeio de mensagens que recebem diariamente, o caminho é o de entreter, emocionar. Aliado a tudo isto, os bancos rezam de imagem negativa na sociedade e vêm trabalhando para minimizar esta percepção: querem por intermédio de suas mensagens publicitárias se tornar mais simpáticos, humanos. Quando reunidos esses movimentos - o da sociedade valorizando mais o ser do que o ter e os bancos querendo se humanizar e utilizando abordagens emocionais em sua comunicação - é fácil entender a similaridade de argumentos. Mas será que a falta de diferenciação não continuará trazendo a comoditização dos produtos e serviços para a comoditização da comunicação e fazendo com que ela deixe de cumprir um dos seus papéis fundamentais que é o de fazer um anunciante se diferenciar da concorrência?

A COMUNICAÇÃO PUBLICITÁRIA NAS INSTITUIÇÕES FINANCEIRAS PARA O SEGMENTO DE ALTA RENDA

Esta pesquisa investiga como quatro dos maiores bancos que atuam no Brasil - Bradesco, Itaú, Citibank e BankBoston - utilizam a comunicação para seduzir o público de alta renda. O objetivo é definir quais são os apelos e os valores utilizados nos comerciais de televisão e entender por que os filmes são muitos similares nos argumentos de persuasão. A importância desta pesquisa se define em conseqüência da forte presença dos bancos no meio TV e pelo fato de os principais bancos no Brasil terem lançado num curto espaço de tempo submarcas, um recurso muito utilizado pela indústria com as extensões de marcas, para atender a um mercado de alta renda estimado em 2 milhões de pessoas. Este é um tema novo e ainda pouco explorado na academia. Os métodos utilizados foram a análise de conteúdo, que verificou os argumentos dos comerciais de TV e a pesquisa bibliográfica, que deu o lastro necessário para a definição do problema e embasou a estruturação do estudo Os principais resultados da pesquisa apresentaram a conversão de duas tendências; a primeira vem dos novos valores que sopram da sociedade, destacadamente das pessoas de alta renda no Brasil. Elas têm apresentado novas formas de consumo, que estão muito mais ligadas às emoções. A ostentação e o consumo de produtos sofisticados como sinônimo de status e poder continuam e possivelmente deverão continuar a existir, mas nota-se agora que ao menos parte da elite brasileira busca se diferenciar por valores subjetivos. Estão de volta os valores básicos da sociedade como relacionamento familiar, valorização das coisas simples e melhor aproveitamento do tempo. Por outro lado, a segunda tendência é mercadológica. Com a comoditização dos produtos e serviços, as empresas buscam se diferenciar pela marca e, para fazer a conexão desta com os consumidores, são utilizados argumentos emocionais. Até porque, para se manipular os consumidores, o modo mais eficaz é através da emoção. Pode-se dizer também que, para furar o bloqueio mental que os consumidores erguem em virtude do bombardeio de mensagens que recebem diariamente, o caminho é o de entreter, emocionar. Aliado a tudo isto, os bancos rezam de imagem negativa na sociedade e vêm trabalhando para minimizar esta percepção: querem por intermédio de suas mensagens publicitárias se tornar mais simpáticos, humanos. Quando reunidos esses movimentos - o da sociedade valorizando mais o ser do que o ter e os bancos querendo se humanizar e utilizando abordagens emocionais em sua comunicação - é fácil entender a similaridade de argumentos. Mas será que a falta de diferenciação não continuará trazendo a comoditização dos produtos e serviços para a comoditização da comunicação e fazendo com que ela deixe de cumprir um dos seus papéis fundamentais que é o de fazer um anunciante se diferenciar da concorrência?

Effects of message appeal and service type in CSR communication strategies

Studies highlight the importance of corporate social responsibility (CSR) for companies' stakeholders. Consumers, however, are often unaware of such initiatives. Understanding how to effectively communicate socially responsible initiatives is an important challenge for both researchers and managers, who invest considerable resources in CSR initiatives. This study examines consumers' responses to two types of CSR initiatives (environment-related and employee-based) using two types of message appeals (emotional and rational) across two service types (hedonic and utilitarian). Responses provide data on consumers' awareness of CSR initiatives, attitudes toward the company, perceived company uniqueness, emotional response, and attributions of company motives to engage in CSR activities. Rational appeals more effectively communicate environment-related CSR initiatives, whereas emotional appeals more effectively communicate employee-based CSR initiatives. Effects on consumers' attributions of company motives to engage in CSR are significant in both service types. Finally, rational message appeals affect consumers' CSR awareness and emotional responses in utilitarian service.

An empirical examination of emotional and cognitive responses to threat appeals

Advertising and other forms of communications are often used by government bodies, non-government organisations, and other institutions to try to influence the population to either a) reduce some form of harmful behaviour (e.g. smoking, drunk- driving) or b) increase some more healthy behaviour (e.g. eating healthily). It is common for these messages to be predicated on the chances of some negative event occurring if the individual does not either a) stop the harmful behaviour, or b) start / increase the healthy behaviour. This design of communication is referred to by many names in the relevant literature, but for the purposes of this thesis, will be termed a ‘threat appeal’. Despite their widespread use in the public sphere, and concerted academic interest since the 1950s, the effectiveness of threat appeals in delivering their objective remains unclear in many ways. In a detailed, chronological and thematic examination of the literature, two assumptions are uncovered that have either been upheld despite little evidence to support them, or received limited attention at all, in the literature. Specifically, a) that threat appeal characteristics can be conflated with their intended responses, and b) that a threat appeal always and necessarily evokes a fear response in the subject. A detailed examination of these assumptions underpins this thesis. The intention is to take as a point of departure the equivocality of empirical results, and deliver a novel approach with the objective of reducing the confusion that is evident in existing work. More specifically, the present thesis frames cognitive and emotional responses to threat appeals as part of a decision about future behaviour. To further develop theory, a conceptual framework is presented that outlines the role of anticipated and anticipatory emotions, alongside subjective probabilities, elaboration and immediate visceral emotions, resultant from manipulation of the intrinsic message characteristics of a threat appeal (namely, message direction, message frame and graphic image). In doing so, the spectrum of relevant literature is surveyed, and used to develop a theoretical model which serves to integrate key strands of theory into a coherent model. In particular, the emotional and cognitive responses to the threat appeal manipulations are hypothesised to influence behaviour intentions and expectations pertaining to future behaviour. Using data from a randomised experiment with a sample of 681 participants, the conceptual model was tested using analysis of covariance. The results for the conceptual framework were encouraging overall, and also with regard to the individual hypotheses. In particular, empirical results showed clearly that emotional responses to the intrinsic message characteristics are not restricted to fear, and that different responses to threat appeals were clearly attributed to specific intrinsic message characteristics. In addition, the inclusion of anticipated emotions alongside cognitive appraisals in the framework generated interesting results. Specifically, immediate emotions did not influence key response variables related to future behaviour, in support of questioning the assumption of the prominent role of fear in the response process that is so prevalent in existing literature. The findings, theoretical and practical implications, limitations and directions for future research are discussed.

Using fear appeals to promote cancer screening - are we scaring the wrong people?

There is debate regarding the use of fear appeals (emphasizing severe threats to health) in social marketing, to encourage preventive behaviours, such as screening for breast cancer. While it has been found that fear appeals may result in attitude and behaviour change there is also the risk of inciting inappropriate levels of fear, motivating the wrong audience or instigating maladaptive behaviour in the target group such as denial or defensive avoidance. This study examined the impact of an experimental threat manipulation for mammography screening on a group of women in regional Australia. The study found that varying the level of threat had no impact on stated intentions of the women to undergo mammographic screening. However, it also found that high-threat messages resulted in stronger negative emotional reactions and greater perceived susceptibility among younger women who are not the target group for screening in Australia. The results of this study emphasize the importance of limiting the use of high levels of threat in social marketing campaigns, and ensuring that campaigns are appropriately designed to specifically impact upon and motivate the target group. Copyright © 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.