Optimal design and operation of compact simulated moving bed processes for enantioseparations

Simulated moving bed (SMB) chromatography is attracting more and more attention since it is a powerful technique for complex separation tasks. Nowadays, more than 60% of preparative SMB units are installed in the pharmaceutical and in the food in- dustry [SDI, Preparative and Process Liquid Chromatography: The Future of Process Separations, International Strategic Directions, Los Angeles, USA, 2002. http://www. strategicdirections.com]. Chromatography is the method of choice in these ¯elds, be- cause often pharmaceuticals and ¯ne-chemicals have physico-chemical properties which di®er little from those of the by-products, and they may be thermally instable. In these cases, standard separation techniques as distillation and extraction are not applicable. The noteworthiness of preparative chromatography, particulary SMB process, as a sep- aration and puri¯cation process in the above mentioned industries has been increasing, due to its °exibility, energy e±ciency and higher product purity performance. Consequently, a new SMB paradigm is requested by the large number of potential small- scale applications of the SMB technology, which exploits the °exibility and versatility of the technology. In this new SMB paradigm, a number of possibilities for improving SMB performance through variation of parameters during a switching interval, are pushing the trend toward the use of units with smaller number of columns because less stationary phase is used and the setup is more economical. This is especially important for the phar- maceutical industry, where SMBs are seen as multipurpose units that can be applied to di®erent separations in all stages of the drug-development cycle. In order to reduce the experimental e®ort and accordingly the coast associated with the development of separation processes, simulation models are intensively used. One impor- tant aspect in this context refers to the determination of the adsorption isotherms in SMB chromatography, where separations are usually carried out under strongly nonlinear conditions in order to achieve higher productivities. The accurate determination of the competitive adsorption equilibrium of the enantiomeric species is thus of fundamental importance to allow computer-assisted optimization or process scale-up. Two major SMB operating problems are apparent at production scale: the assessment of product quality and the maintenance of long-term stable and controlled operation. Constraints regarding product purity, dictated by pharmaceutical and food regulatory organizations, have drastically increased the demand for product quality control. The strict imposed regulations are increasing the need for developing optically pure drugs.(...)

On design and control of simulated moving bed plants

Magdeburg, Univ., Fak. für Elektrotechnik und Informationstechnik, Diss., 2010

Robuste Regelung von Simulated Moving Bed Chromatographieprozessen

Université de Mons, Dissertation, 2016

Simulação de processos de adsorção recorrendo ao Aspen Chromatography

As operações de separação por adsorção têm vindo a ganhar importância nos últimos anos, especialmente com o desenvolvimento de técnicas de simulação de leitos móveis em colunas, tal como a cromatografia de Leito Móvel Simulado (Simulated Moving Bed, SMB). Esta tecnologia foi desenvolvida no início dos anos 60 como método alternativo ao processo de Leito Móvel Verdadeiro (True Moving Bed, TMB), de modo a resolver vários dos problemas associados ao movimento da fase sólida, usuais nestes métodos de separação cromatográficos de contracorrente. A tecnologia de SMB tem sido amplamente utilizada em escala industrial principalmente nas indústrias petroquímica e de transformação de açúcares e, mais recentemente, na indústria farmacêutica e de química fina. Nas últimas décadas, o crescente interesse na tecnologia de SMB, fruto do alto rendimento e eficiente consumo de solvente, levou à formulação de diferentes modos de operação, ditos não convencionais, que conseguem unidades mais flexíveis, capazes de aumentar o desempenho de separação e alargar ainda mais a gama de aplicação da tecnologia. Um dos exemplos mais estudados e implementados é o caso do processo Varicol, no qual se procede a um movimento assíncrono de portas. Neste âmbito, o presente trabalho foca-se na simulação, análise e avaliação da tecnologia de SMB para dois casos de separação distintos: a separação de uma mistura de frutose-glucose e a separação de uma mistura racémica de pindolol. Para ambos os casos foram considerados e comparados dois modos de operação da unidade de SMB: o modo convencional e o modo Varicol. Desta forma, foi realizada a implementação e simulação de ambos os casos de separação no simulador de processos Aspen Chromatography, mediante a utilização de duas unidades de SMB distintas (SMB convencional e SMB Varicol). Para a separação da mistura frutose-glucose, no quediz respeito à modelização da unidade de SMB convencional, foram utilizadas duas abordagens: a de um leito móvel verdadeiro (modelo TMB) e a de um leito móvel simulado real (modelo SMB). Para a separação da mistura racémica de pindolol foi considerada apenas a modelização pelo modelo SMB. No caso da separação da mistura frutose-glucose, procedeu-se ainda à otimização de ambas as unidades de SMB convencional e Varicol, com o intuito do aumento das suas produtividades. A otimização foi realizada mediante a aplicação de um procedimento de planeamento experimental, onde as experiências foram planeadas, conduzidas e posteriormente analisadas através da análise de variância (ANOVA). A análise estatística permitiu selecionar os níveis dos fatores de controlo de modo a obter melhores resultados para ambas as unidades de SMB.

Compact SMB chromatography for binary separation

A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy

Theoretische und experimentelle Studie der Gradienten-Gegenstromchromatographie unter linearen Bedingungen

Simulated Moving Bed (SMB)-Chromatography, solvent gradients, mathematical modelling for linear isotherms

Selective catalytic reduction of nitrogen oxides with ammonia in forced unsteady state reactors - Case based reasoning and mathematical model simulation reasoning

The application of forced unsteady-state reactors in case of selective catalytic reduction of nitrogen oxides (NOx) with ammonia (NH3) is sustained by the fact that favorable temperature and composition distributions which cannot be achieved in any steady-state regime can be obtained by means of unsteady-state operations. In a normal way of operation the low exothermicity of the selective catalytic reduction (SCR) reaction (usually carried out in the range of 280-350°C) is not enough to maintain by itself the chemical reaction. A normal mode of operation usually requires supply of supplementary heat increasing in this way the overall process operation cost. Through forced unsteady-state operation, the main advantage that can be obtained when exothermic reactions take place is the possibility of trapping, beside the ammonia, the moving heat wave inside the catalytic bed. The unsteady state-operation enables the exploitation of the thermal storage capacity of the catalyticbed. The catalytic bed acts as a regenerative heat exchanger allowing auto-thermal behaviour when the adiabatic temperature rise is low. Finding the optimum reactor configuration, employing the most suitable operation model and identifying the reactor behavior are highly important steps in order to configure a proper device for industrial applications. The Reverse Flow Reactor (RFR) - a forced unsteady state reactor - corresponds to the above mentioned characteristics and may be employed as an efficient device for the treatment of dilute pollutant mixtures. As a main disadvantage, beside its advantages, the RFR presents the 'wash out' phenomena. This phenomenon represents emissions of unconverted reactants at every switch of the flow direction. As a consequence our attention was focused on finding an alternative reactor configuration for RFR which is not affected by the incontrollable emissions of unconverted reactants. In this respect the Reactor Network (RN) was investigated. Its configuration consists of several reactors connected in a closed sequence, simulating a moving bed by changing the reactants feeding position. In the RN the flow direction is maintained in the same way ensuring uniformcatalyst exploitation and in the same time the 'wash out' phenomena is annulated. The simulated moving bed (SMB) can operate in transient mode giving practically constant exit concentration and high conversion levels. The main advantage of the reactor network operation is emphasizedby the possibility to obtain auto-thermal behavior with nearly uniformcatalyst utilization. However, the reactor network presents only a small range of switching times which allow to reach and to maintain an ignited state. Even so a proper study of the complex behavior of the RN may give the necessary information to overcome all the difficulties that can appear in the RN operation. The unsteady-state reactors complexity arises from the fact that these reactor types are characterized by short contact times and complex interaction between heat and mass transportphenomena. Such complex interactions can give rise to a remarkable complex dynamic behavior characterized by a set of spatial-temporal patterns, chaotic changes in concentration and traveling waves of heat or chemical reactivity. The main efforts of the current research studies concern the improvement of contact modalities between reactants, the possibility of thermal wave storage inside the reactor and the improvement of the kinetic activity of the catalyst used. Paying attention to the above mentioned aspects is important when higher activity even at low feeding temperatures and low emissions of unconverted reactants are the main operation concerns. Also, the prediction of the reactor pseudo or steady-state performance (regarding the conversion, selectivity and thermal behavior) and the dynamicreactor response during exploitation are important aspects in finding the optimal control strategy for the forced unsteady state catalytic tubular reactors. The design of an adapted reactor requires knowledge about the influence of its operating conditions on the overall process performance and a precise evaluation of the operating parameters rage for which a sustained dynamic behavior is obtained. An apriori estimation of the system parameters result in diminution of the computational efforts. Usually the convergence of unsteady state reactor systems requires integration over hundreds of cycles depending on the initial guess of the parameter values. The investigation of various operation models and thermal transfer strategies give reliable means to obtain recuperative and regenerative devices which are capable to maintain an auto-thermal behavior in case of low exothermic reactions. In the present research work a gradual analysis of the SCR of NOx with ammonia process in forced unsteady-state reactors was realized. The investigation covers the presentationof the general problematic related to the effect of noxious emissions in the environment, the analysis of the suitable catalysts types for the process, the mathematical analysis approach for modeling and finding the system solutions and the experimental investigation of the device found to be more suitable for the present process. In order to gain information about the forced unsteady state reactor design, operation, important system parameters and their values, mathematical description, mathematicalmethod for solving systems of partial differential equations and other specific aspects, in a fast and easy way, and a case based reasoning (CBR) approach has been used. This approach, using the experience of past similarproblems and their adapted solutions, may provide a method for gaining informations and solutions for new problems related to the forced unsteady state reactors technology. As a consequence a CBR system was implemented and a corresponding tool was developed. Further on, grooving up the hypothesis of isothermal operation, the investigation by means of numerical simulation of the feasibility of the SCR of NOx with ammonia in the RFRand in the RN with variable feeding position was realized. The hypothesis of non-isothermal operation was taken into account because in our opinion ifa commercial catalyst is considered, is not possible to modify the chemical activity and its adsorptive capacity to improve the operation butis possible to change the operation regime. In order to identify the most suitable device for the unsteady state reduction of NOx with ammonia, considering the perspective of recuperative and regenerative devices, a comparative analysis of the above mentioned two devices performance was realized. The assumption of isothermal conditions in the beginningof the forced unsteadystate investigation allowed the simplification of the analysis enabling to focus on the impact of the conditions and mode of operation on the dynamic features caused by the trapping of one reactant in the reactor, without considering the impact of thermal effect on overall reactor performance. The non-isothermal system approach has been investigated in order to point out the important influence of the thermal effect on overall reactor performance, studying the possibility of RFR and RN utilization as recuperative and regenerative devices and the possibility of achieving a sustained auto-thermal behavior in case of lowexothermic reaction of SCR of NOx with ammonia and low temperature gasfeeding. Beside the influence of the thermal effect, the influence of the principal operating parameters, as switching time, inlet flow rate and initial catalyst temperature have been stressed. This analysis is important not only because it allows a comparison between the two devices and optimisation of the operation, but also the switching time is the main operating parameter. An appropriate choice of this parameter enables the fulfilment of the process constraints. The level of the conversions achieved, the more uniform temperature profiles, the uniformity ofcatalyst exploitation and the much simpler mode of operation imposed the RN as a much more suitable device for SCR of NOx with ammonia, in usual operation and also in the perspective of control strategy implementation. Theoretical simplified models have also been proposed in order to describe the forced unsteady state reactors performance and to estimate their internal temperature and concentration profiles. The general idea was to extend the study of catalytic reactor dynamics taking into account the perspectives that haven't been analyzed yet. The experimental investigation ofRN revealed a good agreement between the data obtained by model simulation and the ones obtained experimentally.

Kromatografinen erotus bioetanolin valmistuksessa lignoselluloosasta

Bioetanolin tuotanto kiinnostaa monissa maissa johtuen kansainvälisissä sopimuksissa määritellyistä ilmastotavoitteista. Työssä tutkittiin laboratorio-oloissa ioninvaihtohartsien ominaisuuksien ja erotuksen olosuhteiden vaikutusta rikkihapon ja glukoosin kromatografiseen erotukseen. Tehokkaimmaksi hartsiksi osoittautui polysulfonoitu mesohuokoinen vahva kationinvaihtohartsi Finex CS100C. CS100C:lla voitiin erottaa rikkihappoa ja glukoosia tehokkaimmin korkeissa 25 p-% ja 36 p-% glukoosi- ja rikkihappo-pitoisuuksissa. Lisäksi sillä havaittiin suurin tuotto simuloidussa liikkuvassa pedissä. Yhdessä kolonnissa suoritetuissa erotuskokeissa tutkittiin hartsien erotuskykyä rikkihapolle ja glukoosille sekä virtausnopeuden vaikutusta erotukseen lämpötilassa 22 °C. Saatujen tulosten pohjalta valittiin CS11GC, CS16GC ja CS100C tarkempaan isotermin määritykseen ja simulointiin hyvän erotuskyvyn sekä keskinäisten erojen takia. Adsorptioisotermit määritettiin kolonnikokein sekä 22 °C:n että 50 °C:n lämpötilassa. Isotermeistä havaittiin, että tasapaino kiinto- ja liuosfaasien välille saavutetaan rikkihapolla alhaisella 1 cm3/min virtausnopeudella varmemmin kuin suuremmalla 2,5 cm3/min virtausnopeudella. 50 °C:n lämpötilassa hapon ja glukoosin isotermit olivat jyrkempiä kuin 22 °C:n lämpötilassa. Määritettyihin hapon ja sokerin isotermeihin sovitettiin mallit, joiden parametreja käytettiin yksittäisen kolonnin simulointiin. Simuloinnissa oli estimoitavia parametreja yhdellä kolonnilla aineensiirtokertoimet sekä läpäisykäyristä määritetyt isotermiparametrit glukoosille sekä rikkihapolle ja SMB–erotuksessa vyöhykkeiden 2 ja 3 suhteelliset virtausnopeudet. Siirryttäessä lämpötilojen 22 °C ja 50 °C välillä hartsien parametrit muuttuivat sokerille täysin ja hapolle vain aineensiirtokertoimen osalta. CS100C oli tehokkain SMB–erotuksessa korkeimmalla 0,11 cm3/min tuottavuudella 95 %:n saannon saavuttamiseksi 95 % tuotepuhtaudella raffinaatissa ja ekstraktissa.

Cromatografia em leito móvel simulado na produção de substâncias enantiomericamente puras ou enriquecidas em larga escala

There is great interest nowadays in the use of preparative liquid chromatography as an effective tool for the production of enantiomerically pure, or enriched, compounds for the pharmaceutical industry. To make the chromatographic process economically attractive, attention is now focused on the choice of the chromatographic operating mode to minimize eluent consumption and to maximize productivity. Among the alternatives to the traditional batch chromatography, attention is now shifting towards simulated moving bed (SMB) technologies and a review covering the latest developments in this area seems timely. Several aspects of this important analytical technique are presented and details concerning the SMB technology for process optimization are outlined.

Jatkuvatoiminen ioninvaihto ja kompleksoituvien metallien sorptio kloridiympäristössä

Työn tarkoituksena oli tutkia kompleksoituvien metallien erotusta kloridiliuoksesta ioninvaihdolla. Kirjallisessa osassa perehdyttiin metallikompleksien muodostumiseen, ja erityisesti hopean, kalsiumin, magnesiumin, lyijyn ja sinkin muodostamiin komplekseihin kloridin ja nitraatin kanssa. Kirjallisessa osassa käsiteltiin myös metallien erottamista kiintopetikolonneissa jatkuvatoimisilla ioninvaihtomenetelmillä. Tässä työssä jatkuvatoimisen ioninvaihdon prosessivaihtoehdot jaoteltiin pyöriviin ja paikallaan pysyviin kolonneihin, sekä tarkasteltiin eri prosessivaihtoehtoja kolonnien kytkentöjen suhteen. Työn kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin kahdenarvoisten metallien erottamista yhdenarvoisista metalleista sekä luotiin koedataa vastaavanlaisen erotusprosessin simulointiin. Kokeissa käytettiin anioninvaihtohartsia ja kelatoivaa selektiivistä ioninvaihtohartsia. Kahdenarvoisen kalsiumin, magnesiumin, lyijyn ja sinkin adsorptiota hartseihin tutkittiin tasapaino-, kinetiikka- ja kolonnikokeilla. Anioninvaihtohartsilla tehtyjen tasapaino- ja kolonnikokeiden tulokset osoittivat, että hartsi adsorboi tehokkaasti sinkkiä kloridiliuoksista, koska sinkki muodostaa stabiileja anionisia klorokomplekseja. Muiden tutkittujen kahdenarvoisten metallien adsorptio hartsiin oli huomattavasti vähäisempää. Tulosten perusteella tutkittu anioninvaihtohartsi on hyvä vaihtoehto sinkin erottamiseen muista tutkituista kahdenarvoisista metalleista kloridiympäristössä. Kelatoivalla hartsilla tehdyt tasapaino- ja kolonnikokeet osoittivat, että hartsi adsorboi kloridiliuoksista hyvin kahdenarvoista kalsiumia, magnesiumia, lyijyä ja sinkkiä, mutta ei adsorboi yhdenarvoista hopeaa. Tulosten perusteella kahdenarvoisten metallien erottaminen yhdenarvoisista metalleista voidaan toteuttaa kokeissa käytetyllä kelatoivalla ioninvaihtohartsilla.

SMB-laitteiston suunnittelu hydrometallurgisiin sovelluksiin

Työn tarkoituksena oli suunnitella, ohjelmoida ja koekäyttää SMB-laitteisto (Simulated Moving Bed) hydrometallurgisiin erotuksiin. Simuloitu liikkuvapeti saadaan aikaan vaihtamalla sisään- ja ulostuloporttien paikkaa nestevirran suuntaan. Tällöin aikaansaadaan kiintoaineen vastavirtaus minkä johdosta erotustehokkuus kasvaa. Komponenttien retentiotaipumuseroista johtuen komponentit liikkuvat eri nopeuksilla kolonnijärjestelmässä. Enemmän pidättäytyvät komponentit liikkuvat nestevirtaa vastaan ja vähemmän pidättäytyvät komponentit nestevirran mukana. Hydrometallurgiassa vastavirtauksen käyttöä ei ole tieteellisissä julkaisuissa käsitelty laajalti ja saatavilla oleva informaatio onkin kaupallisten yritysten tuottamaa. Hydrometallurgiassa vastavirtausta käyttävissä ioninvaihtolaitteistoissa hyödynnetään irrallisia regenerointivyöhykkeitä. Venttiilijärjestelmän osalta päädyttiin ratkaisuun jossa käytetään yhtä kiertoventtiiliä kullekin virralle, minkä lisäksi kolonnien väleillä käytetään solenoidiventtiiliä. Tämä järjestelmä mahdollistaa yleisimpien SMB-menetelmien käytön mukaan lukien irralliset vyöhykkeet. Laitteiston ohjauksesta vastaa LabVIEW 2010:llä ohjelmoitu ohjelmisto, joka sisältää kaikkien tarvittavien laitteiden ohjausrutiinit. Se mahdollistaa venttiilien synkroniset ja epäsynkroniset vaihdot. Laitteiston puhdistusta varten on ohjelmistoon rakennettu oma rutiini venttiilejä varten. Pumppujen osalta ohjelmisto mahdollistaa vakiovirtauksen sekä lineaaristen ja porrasmuotoisten gradienttien käytön. Ongelmatilanteita varten ohjelmisto valvoo pumppujen ja venttiilien toimintaa ja pysäyttää laitteiston tarvittaessa. Koekäytön avulla pystyttiin todentamaan laitteiston toimivuus.