Towards Empowerment: Narrative Study of Counselling Psychology Trainees and How They Make Sense of Their Personal and Professional Development in the Context of Their Past Experiences

The discipline of counselling psychology continues to grow and change in response to social, economic and political pressures. It has been argued that its quest for a coherent and distinct identity, which emphasises the possibility of the coexistence of multiple approaches, creates an inherently uncertain and dilemmatic training environment that may hinder the development of trainees’ professional identities. In order to gain a deeper understanding of the issue at hand, the aim was to explore how final year trainees and newly qualified counselling psychologists constructed and made sense of their emerging professional identities and what experiences, past and present, they drew upon in the context of their training to shape those identities. Applying narrative inquiry to analyse eight open-ended interviews, eight preliminary themes were originally identified in participants’ narratives, which with further refinements lead to stories of struggle and marginalisation, growth and discovery, and power and resilience. Participants’ stories of struggle and marginalisation emerged in reference to early family dynamics and stressful life experiences, which seemed to also foster a strong identification with the counselling psychology profession, while stories of growth and discovery focused on the importance of having supportive figures, who helped to instill a sense of security and create an atmosphere of openness. It was in this learning environment that participants felt it was possible to develop a more resilient, empowered professional self, which allowed them to shed an earlier sense of struggle and vulnerability. However, where more of an emphasis was placed on power and resilience, there seemed to be less room for participants to express other feelings that came into conflict with their preferred sense of professional self. While there seems to be a need for a ‘safer’ climate, in which trainees could voice and acknowledge anxieties, vulnerabilities and limitations, addressing concerns around power and vulnerability that may be contributing to the silencing of particular voices and identities may be equally important if trainees are to develop coherent and distinct counselling psychologist identities.

Private versus public : how one gay professor negotiates the boundaries between his personal and professional lives /

This study examined how one university professor negotiated the boundaries between his personal life as a gay man and his professional life as a teacher. Using his sexual orientation as a focal point, the study explored the circumstances and underlying assumptions that influenced this professor's decisions to disclose information of a personal nature. Data collection was solicited from a number of sources: (a) In-depth interviews with the participant, his colleagues, students, and friends; (b) Field observation of the participant teaching over a 3 -day period; and (c) A document review of lesson plans, course outlines, student feedback forms, and the participant's teaching portfolio. The researcher maintained both observation journals and reflective journals during this process. Data analysis using the constant comparative method elicited several themes. The participant engaged in a variety of strategies in disclosing his sexual orientation that included: (a) no disclosure at all, (b) assuming people knew, (c) casually mentioning it in conversation, and (d) deliberately planning to tell someone. The participant also engaged in an ongoing assessment of his environment that included evaluating the level of risk in disclosing his sexual orientation and assessing the listener's ability to receive the information. The participant cited numerous reasons for disclosing his sexual orientation. Further inquiry revealed a number of belief systems that underlined these reasons. These belief systems included beliefs around privacy, authenticity, teaching, manners, professionalism, and homosexuality. The conclusions suggested that the participant utilized a consistent process in both his personal and professional lives to determine what information was kept private and what information was made public. While the process used to determine the degree of disclosure was consistent, the actual disclosures themselves varied widely in nature.

Exploring the personal and professional lives of teachers in the search for authenticity /

"We teach who we are" (Palmer, 1998, p. 2). This simple, yet profound, statement was the catalyst that began my thesis journey. Using a combination of self-study and participant narratives, Palmer's idea was explored as search for authenticity. The self-study component of this narrative was enhanced by the stories of two other teachers, both women. I chose to use narrative methodology to uncover and discover the relationship between the personal and professional lives of being a teacher. Do teachers express themselves daily in their classrooms? Do any lessons from the classroom translate into teachers' personal lives? The themes of reflection, authenticity, truth, and professional development thread themselves throughout this narrative study. In order to be true to myself as a teacher/researcher, arts-based interpretations accompany my own and each participant's profile. Our conversations about our pasts, our growth as teachers and journeys as individuals were captured in poetry and photographic mosaics. Through rich and detailed stories we explored who we are as teachers and how we became this way. The symbiotic relationship between our personal and professional lives was illustrated by tales of bravery, self-discovery, and reflection. The revelations uncovered illustrate the powerful role our past plays in shaping the present and potentially the friture. It may seem indulgent to spend time exploring who we are as teachers in a time that is increasingly focused on improving student test scores. Yet, the truth remains that, "Knowing myself is as crucial to good teaching as knowing my students and my subject" (Palmer, 1998, p. 2).

Turning points: the personal and professional circumstances that lead academics to become middle managers

In the current higher education climate, there is a growing perception that the pressures associated with being an academic middle manager outweigh the perceived rewards of the position. This article investigates the personal and professional circumstances that lead academics to become middle managers by drawing on data from life history interviews undertaken with 17 male and female department heads from a range of disciplines, in a post-1992 UK university. The data suggests that experiencing conflict between personal and professional identities, manifested through different socialization experiences over time, can lead to a ‘turning point’ and a decision that affects a person’s career trajectory. Although the results of this study cannot be generalized, the findings may help other individuals and institutions move towards a firmer understanding of the academic who becomes head of department—in relation to theory, practice and research.

Our Lady of Guadalupe : contemporary explorations of personal and cultural identity

Since it first appeared, the image of Our Lady of Guadalupe has remained relatively unchanged. In the last thirty-five years, however, this has been changing. Artists are creating new variations of the icon to represent and express their reinterpretations. In some of these more contemporary images, the figure of Guadalupe has changed dramatically, but still retains enough traditional elements to be easily recognizable. Some of these images have been received with mixed results and have even sparked major controversy. These new, and sometimes controversial depictions of Guadalupe, specifically those created by Ester Hernández, Yolanda M. López and Alma López, will be explored here. Although each artist has her own individual motivations and intentions, all of the images presented here explore personal and cultural identity, as well as seek in some way to honor ordinary, human women through the sacred iconography of Our Lady of Guadalupe.

Teachers’ beliefs about diversity: an analysis from a personal and professional perspective

The purpose of this study was to examine the beliefs that teachers have about diversity and their level of sensitivity towards some topics related to it. Moreover, beliefs were compared according to teachers’ personal and professional views and teaching experience. The Personal and Professional Beliefs about Diversity Scales (Pohan and Aguilar, 1999) were administered to a sample of 233 teachers. Results showed highly positive beliefs towards diversity in all its dimensions (cultural, linguistic and social diversity, ability, gender, sexual orientation and religion), especially regarding its personal implications compared to the professional ones. Likewise, it was observed a significant relationship between years of teaching experience and professional beliefs about diversity, so teachers with no school experience showed a higher tolerance than those with teaching experience, mainly in aspects related to cultural, linguistic and social differences, ability and gender. The implications that these results have for educational practice and the need for the development of multicultural education courses that favour an effective teaching are discussed.

Stray records : or, personal and professional notes /

First edition.

The influence of study and travel abroad on the personal and professional development of students in architecture design programs

International travel has significant implications on the study of architecture. This study analyzed ways in which undergraduate and graduate students benefited from the experience of international travel and study abroad. Taken from the perspective of 15 individuals who were currently or had been architecture students at the University of Miami and Florida International University or who were alumni of the University of Florida and Syracuse University, the research explored how international travel and study abroad enhanced their awareness and understanding of architecture, and how it complemented their architecture curricula. This study also addressed a more personal aspect of international travel in order to learn how the experience and exposure to foreign cultures had positively influenced the personal and professional development of the participants.^ Participants’ individual and two-person semi-structured interviews about study abroad experiences were electronically recorded and transcribed for analysis. A second interview was conducted with five of the participants to obtain feedback concerning the accuracy of the transcripts and the interpretation of the data. Sketch journals and design projects were also analyzed from five participants and used as data for the purposes of better understanding what these individuals learned and experienced as part of their study abroad.^ Findings indicated that study abroad experiences helped to broaden student understanding about architecture and urban development. These experiences also opened the possibilities of creative and professional expression. For many, this was the most important aspect of their education as architects because it heightened their interest in architecture. These individuals talked about how they had the opportunity to experience contemporary and ancient buildings that they had learned about in their history and design classes on their home campuses. In terms of personal and professional development, many of the participants remarked that they became more independent and self-reliant because of their study abroad experiences. They also displayed a sense of global awareness and were interested in the cultures of their host nations. The study abroad experiences also had a lasting influence on their professional development.^

The Impact of Mindfulness Meditation on Educator Growth and Professional Development: A Personal Account

This study examined the use of mindfulness meditation in educator growth and professional development. The purpose was to create recommendations for an effective mindfulness meditation practice for educators. To this end, as the researcher is an educator as well as an experienced mindfulness meditation practitioner, the research methodology was self-study through narrative inquiry. The exploration of mindfulness meditation on the researcher’s personal and professional development was viewed through the lenses of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs and Mezirow’s transformational learning theory. These theories provided an analytical framework that guided this research. Themes were drawn from the exploration and connected with academic literature. The results were a mindfulness meditation framework for educators that is based on the Socratic Method, and utilizes the conceptual frameworks of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs and Mezirow’s transformational learning theory.

Incorporating creativity into teachers practice and self-concept of professional identity

The study explores what happens to teachers practice and ’ professional identity when they adopt a collaborative action research approach to teaching and involve external creative partners and a university mentor. The teachers aim to nurture and develop the creative potential of their learners through empowering them to make decisions for themselves about their own progress and learning directions. The teachers worked creatively and collaboratively designing creative teaching and learning methods in support of pupils with language and communication difficulties. The respondents are from an English special school, primary school and girls secondary school. A mixed methods methodology is adopted. Gains in teacher confidence and capability were identified in addition to shifts in values that impacted directly on their self-concept of what it is to be an effective teacher promoting effective learning. The development of their professional identities within a team ethos included them being able to make decisions about learning that are based on the educational potential of learners that they proved resulted in elevated standards achieved by this group of learners. They were able to justify their actions on established educational principles. Tensions however were revealed between what they perceived as their normal required professionalism imposed by external agencies and the enhanced professionalism experienced working through the project where they were able to integrate theory and practice.

School leaders as both colonized and colonizers: understanding professional identity in an era of no child left behind

This study positioned the federal No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Act of 2002 as a reified colonizing entity, inscribing its hegemonic authority upon the professional identity and work of school principals within their school communities of practice. Pressure on educators and students intensifies each year as the benchmark for Adequate Yearly Progress under the NCLB policy is raised, resulting in standards-based reform, scripted curriculum and pedagogy, absence of elective subjects, and a general lack of autonomy critical to the work of teachers as they approach each unique class and student (Crocco & Costigan, 2007; Mabry & Margolis, 2006). Emphasis on high stakes standardized testing as the indicator for student achievement (Popham, 2005) affects educators’ professional identity through dramatic pedagological and structural changes in schools (Day, Flores, & Viana, 2007). These dramatic changes to the ways our nation conducts schooling must be understood and thought about critically from school leaders’ perspectives as their professional identity is influenced by large scale NCLB school reform. The author explored the impact No Child Left Behind reform had on the professional identity of fourteen, veteran Illinois principals leading in urban, small urban, suburban, and rural middle and elementary schools. Qualitative data were collected during semi-structured interviews and focus groups and analyzed using a dual theoretical framework of postcolonial and identity theories. Postcolonial theory provided a lens from which the author applied a metaphor of colonization to principals’ experiences as colonized-colonizers in a time of school reform. Principal interview data illustrated many examples of NCLB as a colonizing authority having a significant impact on the professional identity of school leaders. This framework was used to interpret data in a unique and alternative way and contributed to the need to better understand the ways school leaders respond to district-level, state-level, and national-level accountability policies (Sloan, 2000). Identity theory situated principals as professionals shaped by the communities of practice in which they lead. Principals’ professional identity has become more data-driven as a result of NCLB and their role as instructional leaders has intensified. The data showed that NCLB has changed the work and professional identity of principals in terms of use of data, classroom instruction, Response to Intervention, and staffing changes. Although NCLB defines success in terms of meeting or exceeding the benchmark for Adequate Yearly Progress, principals’ view AYP as only one measurement of their success. The need to meet the benchmark for AYP is a present reality that necessitates school-wide attention to reading and math achievement. At this time, principals leading in affluent, somewhat homogeneous schools typically experience less pressure and more power under NCLB and are more often labeled “successful” school communities. In contrast, principals leading in schools with more heterogeneity experience more pressure and lack of power under NCLB and are more often labeled “failing” school communities. Implications from this study for practitioners and policymakers include a need to reexamine the intents and outcomes of the policy for all school communities, especially in terms of power and voice. Recommendations for policy reform include moving to a growth model with multi-year assessments that make sense for individual students rather than one standardized test score as the measure for achievement. Overall, the study reveals enhancements and constraints NCLB policy has caused in a variety of school contexts, which have affected the professional identity of school leaders.

A formação continuada nos discursos de professores da educação superior: a experiência da UFPA e do CESUPA

Esta é uma investigação ligada ao campo da formação continuada de professores, acerca dos sentidos que os professores bacharéis e tecnólogos que atuam na educação superior dão à formação continuada, a partir das ações formativas desenvolvidas na Universidade Federal do Pará UFPa) e no Centro Universitário do Estado do Pará (CESUPA). Os dados empíricos produzidos pela análise documental e a entrevista foram analisados a partir das bibliografias nacional e internacional consultadas, que têm uma abordagem crítica sobre o trabalho docente ao fazer um exame minucioso da profissão professor. O estudo remete à compreensão da vivência dos professores nesta formação em andamento nas duas instituições, dos efeitos que os seus modelos de formação continuada provocam no desenvolvimento pessoal e profissional deles, com destaque para os sentidos e interesses anunciados por tais profissionais. A busca pela aprendizagem dá indícios quando os docentes valorizam o acesso às ações formativas, precisamente os conteúdos que possam sustentar a sua prática pedagógica. Do estudo depreendo que a formação continuada é uma arena heterogênea, pouco unificada e que responde a finalidades diversas. Não podemos lhe atribuir uma idéia salvacionista, em que os professores aprenderão como fazer tudo diferente e correto com a formação, mas sim como uma intervenção de atitude crítica sobre as suas práticas pedagógicas e de (re) construção permanente de uma identidade pessoal e profissional docente, em interação mútua.

Relatório de estágio

O presente relatório de estágio de qualificação profissional tem como objetivo refletir criticamente acerca do percurso de desenvolvimento profissional da mestranda durante os momentos de prática pedagógica, no âmbito das unidades curriculares de Prática Pedagógica Supervisionada na Educação Pré-Escolar e Ensino do 1.º CEB. Neste sentido, espelha competências desenvolvidas pela mestranda essenciais para a profissionalidade docente, suportadas por uma postura reflexiva, indagadora, crítica e investigativa, tornando-a capaz de tomar decisões adequadas ao contexto educativo e agir com intencionalidade pedagógica sabendo fazer, ser e estar. Neste sentido, o desenvolvimento dos saberes profissionais foram construídos em articulação com a metodologia de investigação-ação, que se processou numa espiral cíclica de observação, planificação, ação, reflexão e avaliação, tendo ênfase a reflexão pode ser intrínseca e implícita em todas as fases. Importa referir ainda que o desenvolvimento da prática pedagógica em díade de formação potenciou momentos de reflexão partilhada que contribuíram para a transformação de práticas. Realça-se que a elaboração deste relatório assumiu um papel fulcral na consciência do ser professor, uma vez que despoletou na mestranda uma reflexão crítica sobre as práticas e desafios delas decorrentes, contribuindo para a contínua construção de conceções e representações inerentes à identidade pessoal e profissional da futura docente.

Relação supervisiva e desenvolvimento da identidade profissional: acompanhamento das práticas clínicas dos estudantes de enfermagem

Este estudo centrou-se num Curso de Licenciatura em Enfermagem e teve como objetivo compreender a influência da relação supervisiva no desenvolvimento da identidade profissional dos estudantes. Os eixos estruturantes que suportam esta investigação e que concorrem para a definição do seu objeto de estudo articulam-se em torno da relação supervisiva, do desenvolvimento de competências profissionais e do desenvolvimento da identidade pessoal e profissional em contexto clínico. A formação desenvolvida através da prática clínica destina-se a preparar indivíduos de acordo com a atual realidade socioprofissional, onde os sujeitos, independentemente da singularidade de cada um, desenvolvem saberes adquiridos em sala de aula. Quando comparada com o espaço escolar, a aprendizagem em contexto clínico é condicionada por fatores que se caraterizam por maior imprevisibilidade e obriga frequentemente o estudante a confrontar-se com situações únicas e impares. A identidade dos estudantes torna-se assim construída e vivida a partir de um conjunto de dimensões que ocorrem no decurso das vivências clínicas. Metodologicamente optou-se por um estudo etnográfico no âmbito do paradigma qualitativo, numa abordagem longitudinal segundo a lógica do estudo de caso. A natureza dos dados a recolher englobou ainda o recurso a procedimentos de natureza quantitativa. Como técnica de recolha de dados recorremos à observação participante, entrevistas semiestruturadas e questionários. O estudo desenvolveu-se numa Escola Superior de Enfermagem da Zona Norte do país e fizeram parte da população 69 estudantes de uma turma de segundo ano, quatro tutores e um professor. O plano de estudo da referida escola está organizado de forma a que a aprendizagem dos estudantes seja progressivamente integradora de saberes interligando a componente teórica com a componente prática. Assim, os ensinos clínicos estão distribuídos entre o 2º e o 4º ano. Da análise e discussão dos dados e subsequentes conclusões ressalta que, quer a relação supervisiva, quer os contextos clínicos, foram influenciadores do desenvolvimento de competências profissionais, bem como da identidade pessoal e profissional dos estudantes. Verificamos que os dois contextos clínicos estudados – medicina e cirurgia – favoreceram o desenvolvimento de competências distintas, no entanto complementares. Tornou-se visível que, os supervisores do contexto de medicina, possuidores de uma visão holística da profissão de enfermagem, promoveram nos estudantes uma visão integradora do doente, resultante de uma contínua atitude reflexiva sobre a Pessoa Humana. Por sua vez, no contexto de cirurgia, caraterizada por intervenções mais invasivas e mais centradas no tratar, as competências mais valorizadas pelos tutores, embora que de uma forma não verbalmente assumida, foram do domínio técnicocientífico, com especial relevo pelas competências instrumentais.