Addressing the Challenges of Child and Family Homelessness

Homeless children in families comprise the fastest-growing group of homeless persons in the United States. Indeed, the American Academy of Pediatrics considers homelessness to be an issue with which pediatricians should be concerned. In this article, we review existing literature to provide a background for researchers, policymakers, and social service providers hoping to understand the phenomenon of child and family homelessness and various strategies used to address it. We begin with a definition and description of the population of homeless families with children. We then offer a broad consideration of the effects of child and family homelessness, from physical health problems like malnutrition and increased incidence of infection to emotional and academic impacts. We end with a platform of policies and other action steps for addressing the problems of homelessness for children and their families.

Arabinosylguanine: Metabolism, action, and lineage-specific cytotoxicity in human leukemia cells

9-β-D-arabinosylguanine (ara-G), an analogue of deoxyguanosine, has demonstrated T-lymphoblast selective anti-leukemia activity both in vitro and in vivo in cell lines and primary cells and in phase I investigations. The present work was initiated to identify factors that result in this selectivity. ^ The cytotoxicity of ara-G is manifest only after its phosphorylation. Experiments using cell lines transfected to overexpress specific nucleoside kinases demonstrated that the phosphorylation of ara-G to its monophosphate is by both cytoplasmic deoxycytidine kinase and mitochondria) deoxyguanosine kinase. Ara-G monophosphate is converted to its 5′-triphosphate (ara-GTP) in cells by these kinases and then incorporated into DNA. Mechanistic studies demonstrated that incorporation of ara-GTP into DNA was a necessary event for the induction of cell death. ^ Pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic studies utilizing three human acute leukemia cell lines, CEM (T-lymphoblastic), Raji (B-lymphoblastic), and ML-1 (myeloid) were performed. CEM cells were most sensitive to ara-G-induced inhibition of colony formation, accumulated ara-GTP at a faster rate and to a greater degree than either Raji or ML-1, but incorporated the lowest number of ara-G molecules into DNA. The position of incorporation was internal and similar in all cell lines. The terminal elimination phase of ara-GTP was >24 h and similar in these cells. Comparisons between inhibition of colony formation and ara-GTP incorporation into DNA demonstrated that while within a cell line there was correlation among these parameters, between cell lines there was no relationship between number of incorporated ara-G molecules and ara-G(TP)-mediated toxicity suggesting that there were additional factors. ^ The expression of membrane bound Fas and Fast was unchanged in all cell lines. In contrast, there was a 2-fold increase in soluble Fast, which was found exclusively in CEM cells. Ara-G-mediated apoptosis in CEM occurred from all phases of the cell cycle and was abrogated partially by Fas antagonist antibodies. These data suggest that Fas-mediated cell death due to the liberation of sFasL may be responsible for the hypersensitivity to ara-G manifested by immature T-cells such as CEM. The role of Fas in ara-G induced death of acute T-lymphoblastic leukemia cells during therapy needs to be tested. ^

Toward a cognitive taxonomy of medical errors.

One critical step in addressing and resolving the problems associated with human errors is the development of a cognitive taxonomy of such errors. In the case of errors, such a taxonomy may be developed (1) to categorize all types of errors along cognitive dimensions, (2) to associate each type of error with a specific underlying cognitive mechanism, (3) to explain why, and even predict when and where, a specific error will occur, and (4) to generate intervention strategies for each type of error. Based on Reason's (1992) definition of human errors and Norman's (1986) cognitive theory of human action, we have developed a preliminary action-based cognitive taxonomy of errors that largely satisfies these four criteria in the domain of medicine. We discuss initial steps for applying this taxonomy to develop an online medical error reporting system that not only categorizes errors but also identifies problems and generates solutions.

Specific, Reversible Cytostatic Protection of Normal Cells Against Negative Effects of Chemotherapy

Chemotherapy is a common and effective method to treat many forms of cancer. However, treatment of cancer with chemotherapy has severe side effects which often limit the doses of therapy administered. Because some cancer chemotherapeutics target proliferating cells and tissues, all dividing cells, whether normal or tumor, are affected. Cell culture studies have demonstrated that UCN-01 is able to reversibly and selectively arrest normal dividing cells; tumor cells lines do not undergo this temporary arrest. Following UCN-01 treatment, normal cells displayed a 50-fold increase in IC50 for camptothecin; tumor cells showed no such increased tolerance. We have examined the response of the proliferating tissues of the mouse to UCN- 01 treatment, using the small bowel epithelium as a model system. Our results indicate that UCN-01 treatment can cause a cell cycle arrest in the gut epithelium, beginning 24 hours following UCN-01 administration, with cell proliferation remaining suppressed for one week. Two weeks post-UCN-01 treatment the rate of proliferation returns to normal levels. 5-FU administered during this period demonstrates that UCN-01 is able to provide protection to normal cells of the mouse within a narrow window of efficacy, from three to five days post-UCN-01. UCN-01 pretreated mice displayed improved survival, weight status and blood markers following 5-FU compared to control mice, indicating that UCN-01 can protect normal dividing tissues. The mechanism by which UCN-01 arrests normal cells in vivo was also examined. We have demonstrated that UCN-01 treatment in mice causes an increase in the G1 phase cell cycle proteins cdk4 and cyclin D, as well as the inhibitor p27. Phosphorylated Rb was also elevated in the arrested cells. These results are a departure from cell culture studies, in which inhibition of G1 phase cyclin dependent kinases led to hyposphosphorylation of Rb. Future investigation will be required to understand the mechanism of UCN-01 action. This is important information, especially for identification of alternate compounds which could provide the protection afforded by UCN-01.

The molecular mechanism of retinoic acid action: Regulation of tissue transglutaminase gene expression

Retinoic acid is a small lipophilic molecule that exerts profound effects on the growth and differentiation of both normal and transformed cells. It is also a natural morphogen that is critical in the development of embryonic structures. The molecular effects of retinoic acid involve alterations in the expression of several proteins and these changes are presumably mediated in part by alterations in gene expression. For instance, retinoic acid causes a rapid induction of tissue transglutaminase, an enzyme involved in protein cross-linking. The molecular mechanisms responsible for the effects of retinoic acid on gene expression have not been characterized. To approach this question, I have isolated and characterized tissue transglutaminase of cDNA clones. The deduced amino acid sequences of tissue transglutaminase and of factor XIIIa showed a relatively high degree of homology in their putative calcium binding domains.^ To explore the mechanism of induction of this enzyme, both primary (macrophages) and cultured cells (Swiss 3T3-C2 and CHO fibroblasts) were used. I found that retinoic acid is a general inducer of tissue transglutaminase mRNA in these cells. In murine peritoneal macrophages retinoic acid causes a rapid accumulation of this mRNA and this effect is independent of concurrent protein synthesis. The retinoic acid effect is not mediated by a post-transcriptional increase in the stability of the tissue transglutaminase mRNA, but appears to involve an increase in the transcription rate of the tissue transglutaminase gene. This provides the first example of regulation by retinoic acid of a specific gene, supporting the hypothesis that these molecules act by directly regulating the transcriptional activity of specific genes. A molecular model for the effects of retinoic acid on the expression of genes linked to cellular proliferation and differentiation is proposed. ^

Stability of specific immunoglobulin secretion by EBV-transformed lymphoblastoid cells and human-murine heterohybridomas

The purpose of this project was to determine if stability of specific antibody secretion improved after fusion of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-transformed lymphoblastoid cells with P3X63Ag8.653 murine myeloma cells. Production of human monoclonal antibodies by Epstein-Barr virus transformation and somatic cell fusion has been used by many laboratories, however the steps involved have not been fully optimized. B lymphocytes isolated from the peripheral blood of normal donors were enriched for Thomsen-Friedenreich (T) antigen-reactive cells by panning on asialoglycophorin. The EBV-transformed lymphoblastoid cell lines generated from asialoglycophorin-adherent B lymphocytes were treated in three different manners: (1) cloned and maintained in culture as monoclonal lymphoblastoid cell lines, (2) cloned and fused with murine myeloma cells or (3) fused shortly after transfomation without prior cloning. Cloned lymphoblastoid cell lines maintained in culture without fusion either died or lost specific antibody secretion within five months. Uncloned lymphoblastoid cells remained viable for up to three months but lost specific antibody secretion within two months probably due to overgrowth by nonspecific clones. In an attempt to increase longevity and to stabilize specific antibody secretion by these cells, the cloned lymphoblastoid cells were fused with murine myeloma cells. In nine of ten fusions no hybrids were recovered. As an alternate approach, uncloned lymphoblastoid cells secreting T antigen-specific antibody were hybridized with murine myeloma cells, hybrids secreting T antigen-specific antibody were recovered in six of seven fusions. Furthermore, T antigen-specific antibodies of high titer were secreted by the heterohybridoma clones for more than five months of continuous culture. These heterohybridoma cells secreted more immunoglobulin, produced greater titers of antibody and maintained specific antibody secretion longer than either monoclonal or polyclonal EBV-transformed lymphoblastoid cells. These studies have conclusively demonstrated that fusion of polyclonal lymphoblastoid cells secreting T antigen-specific antibody with murine myeloma cells results in prolongation of human monoclonal antibody production compared with unfused monoclonal or polyclonal lymphoblastoid cell lines. This procedure should be generally applicable for the production of stable human monoclonal antibody-secreting cells lines from peripheral blood lymphocytes. ^

Characterization and mechanism of action of suppressor factors derived from human T cell hybridomas

This laboratory developed human T-cell hybridomas which constitutively secrete suppressor factors (SF) capable of inhibiting immune responses (Hybridoma 6:589 (1987). The mechanisms by which human T-cell hybridoma-derived SFs (designated 160 and 169) and Jurkat leukemic T-cell line derived SF inhibit the proliferative response to mitogen by human PBMC were investigated. The Jurkat SF had a pI of 5.2 whereas the 160 and 169 SF had pI of 5.7 and 4.7 (two peaks) and 4.7, respectively. The SF was not transforming growth factor-beta based upon neutralization and iummunoprecipitation experiments with anti-TGF-beta polyclonal antibody. Il-2 production by human PBMC cultured with Con A or OKT3 mAb in the presence of SF was found to be inhibited by greater than 80%. The proliferative responses of SF treated PBMC could not be restored by addition of exogeneous human IL-2. Inhibition of the proliferative responses could not be reversed by addition of exogenous rIL-1, rIL-2 or rIL-4 alone or in paired combinations. The expression of IL-2 receptors (TAC Ag) on Con A activated cultures time points was not affected by treatment with any SFs. Both the 160 and 169 hybridoma-derived SFs were found to arrest PHA induced cell cycle progression in G$\sb0$/G$\sb1$ phase, whereas SF from the Jurkat T-cell line arrested progression in the S phase. Pretreatment of PBMC with SF prior to the addition of mitogen, followed by washing, did not alter the proliferative response of these PBMC nor their cell cycle progression suggesting that cell activation is necessary for these SF to inhibit proliferative responses. Northern blot analysis of total mRNA from mitogen stimulated PBMC in the presence of SF, revealed a time dependent accumulation of an IL-2 specific mRNA of increased size (2.8 kB) in addition to the expected 1.0 kB mature IL-2 message. Interferon-gamma mRNA was of the appropriate size but its half-life was prolonged in SF treated cultures. IL-2 receptor and IL-1 beta mRNA expression was not altered in these cells. ^

Molecular basis of retinoid action: The role of retinoic acid receptors in retinoic acid-induced tissue transglutaminase expression

Retinoic acid has profound effects on the cellular growth and differentiation of a variety of cells. However, the molecular basis of retinoic acid action has, until recently, not been well understood. The identification of retinoic acid receptors which bear a high degree of homology to members of the steroid receptor super-family has dramatically altered our understanding of the biology of retinoids. The focus of this dissertation has been toward identification of retinoic acid binding proteins responsible for the effects of this molecule on gene expression.^ We have characterized in detail the retinoic acid-dependent induction of tissue transglutaminase gene expression in a myeloid cell line, human promyelocytic leukemia cells (HL-60 cells). Using cDNA probes specific for tissue transglutaminase, we have determined that the retinoic acid induced increase in enzyme level is due to an increase in the level of tissue transglutaminase mRNA. We have used this model as a probe to investigate the molecular basis of retinoid regulated gene expression.^ This thesis demonstrates that retinoic acid receptors are expressed in cells which induce tissue transglutaminase expression in response to retinoic acid. In Hl-60 cells retinoic acid-induced transglutaminase expression is associated with saturable nuclear retonic acid binding. Transcripts for both the alpha and beta forms of the retinoic acid receptors can be detected in these cells. Pretreatment of HL-60 cells with agents that potentiate retinoic acid-induced transglutaminase expression also modestly induced the alpha form of the retinoic acid receptor. Studies in macrophages and umbilical vein endothelial cells have also associated expression of the beta form of the retinoic acid with retinoic acid induced tissue transglutaminase expression.^ To investigate directly if retinoic acid receptors regulate retinoic acid-induced tissue transglutaminase expression we developed a series of stably transfected Balb-c 3T3 cells expressing different levels of the beta or gamma form of the retinoic acid receptor. These studies indicated that either the beta or gamma receptor can stimulate endogenous tissue transglutaminase expression in response to retinoic acid. These are among the first studies in the steroid field to describe regulation of an endogenous gene by a transfected receptor. ^

Analysis of pp60$\sp{{\rm c}{-}src}$ and pp62$\sp{{\rm c}{-}yes}$ intracellular protein tyrosine kinase function in colon tumor cell growth regulation using herbimycin A, a tyrosine kinase specific inhibitor

Two approaches were utilized to investigate the role of pp60c-src activation in growth control of model colon tumor cell lines. The first approach involved analysis of pp60c-src activity in response to growth factor treatment to determine if transient activation of the protein was associated with ligand induced mitogenic signal transduction as occurs in non-colonic cell types. Activation of pp60c-src was detected using colon tumor cell lysates after treatment with platelet derived growth factor (PDGF). Activation of pp60c-src was also detected in response to epidermal growth factor (EGF) treatment using cellular lysates and intact cells. In contrast, down-regulation of purified pp60c-src occurred after incubation with EGF-treated EGFr immune complexes in vitro suggesting additional cellular events were potentially required for the stimulatory response observed in intact cells. The results demonstrated activation of pp60c-src in colon tumor cells in response to PDGF and EGF which is consistent with the role of the protein in mitogenic signal transduction in non-colonic cell types.^ The second approach used to study the role of pp60c-src activation in colonic cell growth control focused on analysis of the role of constitutive activation of the protein, which occurs in approximately 80% of colon tumors and cell lines, in growth control. These studies involved analysis of the effects of the tyrosine kinase specific inhibitor Herbimycin A (HA) on monolayer growth and pp60c-src enzymatic activity using model colon tumor cell lines. HA induced dose-dependent growth inhibition of all colon tumor cell lines examined possessing elevated pp60c-src activity. In HT29 cells the dose-dependent growth inhibition induced by HA correlated with dose-dependent pp60c-src inactivation. Inactivation of pp60c-src was shown to be an early event in response to treatment with HA which preceded induction of HT29 colon tumor cell growth inhibition. The growth effects of HA towards the colon tumor cells examined did not appear to be associated with induction of differentiation or a cytotoxic mechanism of action as changes in morphology were not detected in treated cells and growth inhibition (and pp60c-src inactivation) were reversible upon release from treatment with the compound. The results suggested the constitutive activation of pp60c-src functioned as a proliferative signal in colon tumor cells. Correlation between pp60c-src inactivation and growth inhibition was also observed using HA chemical derivatives confirming the role of tyrosine kinase inactivation by these compounds in inhibition of mitogenic signalling. In contrast, in AS15 cells possessing specific antisense mRNA mediated inactivation of pp60c-src, HA-induced inactivation of the related pp62c-yes tyrosine kinase, which is also activated during colon tumor progression, was not associated with induction of monolayer growth inhibition. These results suggested a function for the constitutively activated pp62c-yes protein in colon tumor cell proliferation which was different from that of activated pp60c-src. (Abstract shortened by UMI.) ^

AN INVESTIGATION INTO THE MOLECULAR MECHANISMS OF ANDROGEN ACTION IN THE SERTOLI CELL

Steroid hormones regulate target cell function via quantitative and qualitative changes in RNA and protein synthesis. In the testis, androgens are known to play an important role in the regulation of spermatogenesis. The Sertoli cell (SC), whose function is thought to be supportive to the developing germ cell, has been implicated as an androgen target cell. Although cytoplasmic androgen receptors and chromatin acceptor sites for androgen-receptor complexes have been found in SC, effects on RNA synthesis have not previously been demonstrated. In this study, SC RNA synthetic activity was characterized and the effect of testosterone on SC nuclear transcriptional activity in vitro assessed. SC exhibited two fold increases in RNA and ribonucleotide pool concentrations during sexual maturation. These changes appeared to correlate with a previously observed increase in protein concentration per cell over an age span of 15-60 days. Following incubation with ('3)H-uridine, SC from older animals incorporated more label into RNA than SC from younger animals. Since the relative concentration of cytidine nucleotides was higher in SC from older rats, the age-related increase in tritium incorporation may reflect an associated increase in incorporation of ('3)H-CMP into RNA. Alternatively, the enhanced labeling may be the result of either a change in the base composition of the RNA resulting in a higher proportion of CMP and UMP in the RNA, or compartmentalization of the nucleotide pools. The physiologic consequences of these maturational alterations of nucleotide pools remains to be elucidated. RNA polymerase activities were characterized in intact nuclei obtained from cultured rat SC. (alpha)-Amanitin resistant RNA polymerase I+III activity was identical when measured in low or high ionic strength (0.05 M or 0.25 M ammonium sulfate (AS)) in the presence of MnCl(,2) or MgCl(,2), with a divalent cation optimum of 1.6 mM. RNA polymerase II was most active in 0.25 M AS and 1.6 mM MnCl(,2). The apparent Km of RNA polymerase II for UTP was 0.016 mM in 0.05 M AS and 0.037 mM in 0.25 M AS. The apparent Km values for total polymerase activity was 0.008 mM and 0.036 mM at low and high ionic strenghts, respectively. These data indicate that Sertoli cell RNA polymerase activities have catalytic properties characteristic of eukaryotic polymerase activities in general. In the presence of 21 (mu)M testosterone, RNA polymerase II activity increased two fold at 15 minutes, then declined but was still elevated over control values six hours after androgen addition. Polymerase I+III activity was not greatly affected by testosterone. The stimulation of polymerase II measured at 15 minutes was dose-dependent, with a maximum at 0.53 nM and no further stimulation up to 10('-5) M (ED(,50) = 0.25 nM testosterone), and was androgen specific. The results of preliminary RNA isolation and characterization experiments suggested that the synthesis of several species of RNA was enhanced by testosterone administration. These findings have great potential importance since they represent the first demonstration of a direct effect of androgens on the transcriptional process in the Sertoli cell. Furthermore, the results of these studies constitute further evidence that the Sertoli cell is a target for androgen action in the testis. ^

Characterization of recombinant class I MHC alloantigen action upon the survival of disparate heart allografts

Previous studies have led to the development of allochimeric class I MHC proteins as agents that effectively induce donor-specific transplantation tolerance in a rat system with or without additional immunosuppression. Within the α1-helical region of RT1.Au, an epitope that conferred immunologic tolerance was discovered. Studies presented herein were designed to test our central hypothesis that allochimeric proteins onfer tolerance in a mouse model. To test this hypothesis, portal vein (PV) injection of wild-type H2Kd and H2Dd proteins were produced in a bacterial expression system and found to specifically prolong the survival of BALB/c (H2d) heart allografts in C57BL/10 (H2b) recipients. Although a single PV injection of 50 μg α1–α 3 H2Kd alone was ineffective, 50 μg α1 –α3 alone slightly prolonged BALB/c heart allograft survivals. In contrast, the combination of 25 μg α1–α 3 H2Kd and 25 μg α1–α 3 H2Dd proteins prolonged BALB/c graft survivals to 20.2 ± 6.4 days (p < 0.004). The effect was donor-specific, since a combination of 25 μg α1–α3 H2Kd and 25 μg α1–α3 H2Dd proteins failed to affect survivals of third-party C3H (H2k k) heart allografts, namely 9.0 ± 0.0 days in treated versus 7.8 ± 0.5 days in untreated hosts. Thus, the combination of two H2K d and H2Dd proteins is more effective in prolonging allograft survival than a single protein produced in a bacterial expression system. A single PV injection (day 0) of 25 μg α1–α 2 H2Kd and 25 μg α1–α 2 H2Dd proteins to C57BL/10 mice prolonged the survival of BALB/c heart allografts to 22.4 ± 4.5 days. Within a WF to ACI rat heart allograft system, a single PV injection of 20 μg 70–77 u-RT1.Aa induced specific tolerance of allografts. This therapy could be combined with CsA to induce transplantation tolerance. However, combination of 70–77u-RT1.Aa with CTLA4Ig, rapamycin, or AG-490 effectively blocked the induction of transplantation tolerance. Tolerance generated by allochimeric protein could be adoptively transferred to naive recipients. Intragraft cytokine mRNA levels showed a bias towards a Th2-type phenotype. Additionally, studies of cytokine signaling and activation of transcription factors revealed a requirement that these pathways remain available for signaling in order for transplantation tolerance to occur. These studies suggest that the generation of regulatory cells are required for the induction of transplantation tolerance through the use of allochimeric proteins. ^

The mechanism of action of a novel benzo[c]phenanthridine alkaloid, NK314 and the cellular responses

NK314 is a novel synthetic benzo[c]phenanthridine alkaloid that is currently in clinical trials as an antitumor compound, based on impressive activities in preclinical models. However, its mechanism of action is unknown. The present investigations were directed at determining the mechanism of action of this agent and cellular responses to NK314. My studies demonstrated that NK314 intercalated into DNA, trapped topoisomerase IIα in its cleavage complex intermediate, and inhibited the ability of topoisomerase IIα to relax super-coiled DNA. CEM/VM1 cells, which are resistant to etoposide due to mutations in topoisomerase IIα, were cross-resistant to NK314. However, CEM/C2 cells, which are resistant to camptothecin due to mutations in topoisomerase I, retained sensitivity. This indicates topoisomerase IIα is the target of NK314 in the cells. NK314 caused phosphorylation of the histone variant, H2AX, which is considered a marker of DNA double-strand breaks. DNA double-strand breaks were also evidenced by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis and visualized as chromosomal aberrations after cells were treated with NK314 and arrested in mitosis. Cell cycle checkpoints are activated following DNA damage. NK314 induced significant G2 cell cycle arrest in several cell lines, independent of p53 status, suggesting the existence of a common mechanism of checkpoint activation. The Chk1-Cdc25C-Cdk1 G2 checkpoint pathway was activated in response to NK314, which can be abrogated by the Chk1 inhibitor UCN-01. Cell cycle checkpoint activation may be a defensive mechanism that provides time for DNA repair. DNA double-strand breaks are repaired either through ATM-mediated homologous recombination or DNA-PK-mediated non-homologous end-joining repair pathways. Clonogenic assays demonstrated a significant decrease of colony formation in both ATM deficient and DNA-PK deficient cells compared to ATM repleted and DNA-PK wild type cells respectively, indicating that both ATM and DNA-PK play important roles in the survival of the cells in response to NK314. The DNA-PK specific inhibitor NU7441 also significantly sensitized cells to NK314. In conclusion, the major mechanism of NK314 is to intercalate into DNA, trap and inhibit topoisomerase IIα, an action that leads to the generation of double-strand DNA breaks, which activate ATM and DNA-PK mediated DNA repair pathways and Chk1 mediated G2 checkpoint pathway. ^

AN EVALUATION OF THE CONSISTENCY OF IMRT PATIENT-SPECIFIC QA TECHNIQUES

To ensure the integrity of an intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) treatment, each plan must be validated through a measurement-based quality assurance (QA) procedure, known as patient specific IMRT QA. Many methods of measurement and analysis have evolved for this QA. There is not a standard among clinical institutions, and many devices and action levels are used. Since the acceptance criteria determines if the dosimetric tools’ output passes the patient plan, it is important to see how these parameters influence the performance of the QA device. While analyzing the results of IMRT QA, it is important to understand the variability in the measurements. Due to the different form factors of the many QA methods, this reproducibility can be device dependent. These questions of patient-specific IMRT QA reproducibility and performance were investigated across five dosimeter systems: a helical diode array, radiographic film, ion chamber, diode array (AP field-by-field, AP composite, and rotational composite), and an in-house designed multiple ion chamber phantom. The reproducibility was gauged for each device by comparing the coefficients of variation (CV) across six patient plans. The performance of each device was determined by comparing each one’s ability to accurately label a plan as acceptable or unacceptable compared to a gold standard. All methods demonstrated a CV of less than 4%. Film proved to have the highest variability in QA measurement, likely due to the high level of user involvement in the readout and analysis. This is further shown by how the setup contributed more variation than the readout and analysis for all of the methods, except film. When evaluated for ability to correctly label acceptable and unacceptable plans, two distinct performance groups emerged with the helical diode array, AP composite diode array, film, and ion chamber in the better group; and the rotational composite and AP field-by-field diode array in the poorer group. Additionally, optimal threshold cutoffs were determined for each of the dosimetry systems. These findings, combined with practical considerations for factors such as labor and cost, can aid a clinic in its choice of an effective and safe patient-specific IMRT QA implementation.