Mechanism of surgical stress impairment of murine natural killer cell cytotoxicity

Natural killer cells may provide an important first line of defense against metastatic implantation of solid tumors. This antitumor function occurs during the intravascular and visceral lodgment phase of cancer dissemination, as demonstrated in small animal metastasis models. The role of the NK cell in controlling human tumor dissemination is more difficult to confirm, at least partially because of ethical restraints on experimental design. Nonetheless, a large number of solid tumor patient studies have demonstrated NK cell cytolysis of both autologous and allogeneic tumors.^ Of the major cancer therapeutic modalities, successful surgery in conjunction with other treatments offers the best possibility of cure. However, small animal experiments have demonstrated that surgical stress can lead to increased rates of primary tumor take, and increased incidence, size, and rapidity of metastasis development. Because the physiologic impact of surgical stress can also markedly impair perioperative antitumor immune function in humans, we examined the effect of surgical stress on perioperative NK cell cytolytic function in a murine preclinical model. Our studies demonstrated that hindlimb amputation led to a marked impairment of postoperative NK cell cytotoxicity. The mechanism underlying this process is complex and involves the postsurgical generation of splenic erythroblasts that successfully compete with NK cells for tumor target binding sites; NK cell-directed suppressor cell populations; and a direct impairment of NK cell recycling capacity. The observed postoperative NK cell suppression could be prevented by in vivo administration of pyrimidinone biologic response modifiers or by short term in vitro exposure of effector cells to recombinant Interleukin-2. It is hoped that insights gained from this research may help in the future development of NK cell specific perioperative immunotherapy relevant to the solid tumor patients undergoing cancer resection. ^

ANALYSIS OF THE CORYNEBACTERIUM PARVUM-INDUCED DECLINE OF MURINE NATURAL KILLER CELL-MEDIATED CYTOTOXICITY

Treatment of mice with the immunomodulating agent, Corynebacterium parvum (C. parvum), was shown to result in a severe and long-lasting depression of splenic natural killer (NK) cell-mediated cytotoxicity 5-21 days post-inoculation. Because NK cells have been implicated in immunosurveillance against malignancy (due to their spontaneous occurrence and rapid reactivity to a variety of histological types of tumors), as well as in resistance to established tumors, this decreased activity was of particular concern, since this effect is contrary to that which would be considered therapeutically desirable in cancer treatment (i.e. a potentiation of antitumor effector functions, including NK cell activity, would be expected to lead to a more effective destruction of malignant cells). Therefore, an analysis of the mechanism of this decline of splenic NK cell activity in C.parvum treated mice was undertaken.^ From in vitro co-culturing experiments, it was found that low NK-responsive C. parvum splenocytes were capable of reducing the normally high-reactivity of cells from untreated syngeneic mice to YAC-1 lymphoma, suggesting the presence of NK-directed suppressor cells in C. parvum treated animals. This was further supported by the demonstration of normal levels of cytotoxicity in C. parvum splenocyte preparations following Ficoll-Hypaque separation, which coincided with removal of the NK-suppressive capabilities of these cells. The T cell nature of these regulatory cells was indicated by (1) the failure of C. parvum to cause a reduction of NK cell activity, or the generation of NK-directed suppressor cells in T cell-deficient athymic mice, (2) the removal of C. parvum-induced suppression by T cell-depleting fractionation procedures or treatments, and (3) demonstration of suppression of NK cell activity by T cell-enriched C. parvum splenocytes. These studies suggest, therefore, that the eventual reduction of suppression by T cell elimination and/or inhibition, may result in a promotion of the antitumor effectiveness of C. parvum due to the contribution of "freed" NK effector cell activity.^ However, the temporary suppression of NK cell activity induced by C. parvum (reactivity of treated mice returns to normal levels within 28 days after C. parvum injection), may in fact be favorable in some situations, e.g. in bone marrow transplantation cases, since NK cells have been suggested to play a role also in the process of bone marrow graft rejection.^ Therefore, the discriminate use of agents such as C. parvum may allow for the controlled regulation of NK cell activity suggested to be necessary for the optimalization of therapeutic regimens. ^