RNAi reduces expression and intracellular retention of mutant cartilage oligomeric matrix protein.

Mutations in cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP), a large extracellular glycoprotein expressed in musculoskeletal tissues, cause two skeletal dysplasias, pseudoachondroplasia and multiple epiphyseal dysplasia. These mutations lead to massive intracellular retention of COMP, chondrocyte death and loss of growth plate chondrocytes that are necessary for linear growth. In contrast, COMP null mice have only minor growth plate abnormalities, normal growth and longevity. This suggests that reducing mutant and wild-type COMP expression in chondrocytes may prevent the toxic cellular phenotype causing the skeletal dysplasias. We tested this hypothesis using RNA interference to reduce steady state levels of COMP mRNA. A panel of shRNAs directed against COMP was tested. One shRNA (3B) reduced endogenous and recombinant COMP mRNA dramatically, regardless of expression levels. The activity of the shRNA against COMP mRNA was maintained for up to 10 weeks. We also demonstrate that this treatment reduced ER stress. Moreover, we show that reducing steady state levels of COMP mRNA alleviates intracellular retention of other extracellular matrix proteins associated with the pseudoachondroplasia cellular pathology. These findings are a proof of principle and the foundation for the development of a therapeutic intervention based on reduction of COMP expression.

Ribozyme-mediated reduction of wild-type and mutant cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) mRNA and protein.

Dominant-negative mutations in the homopentameric extracellular matrix glycoprotein cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) result in inappropriate intracellular retention of misfolded COMP in the rough endoplasmic reticulum of chondrocytes, causing chondrocyte cell death, which leads to two skeletal dysplasias: pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH) and multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (EDM1). COMP null mice show no adverse effects on normal bone development and growth, suggesting a possible therapy involving removal of COMP mRNA. The goal of this study was to assess the ability of a hammerhead ribozyme (Ribo56, designed against the D469del mutation) to reduce COMP mRNA expression. In COS7 cells transfected with plasmids that overexpress wild-type or mutant COMP mRNA and Ribo56, the ribozyme reduced overexpressed normal COMP mRNA by 46% and mutant COMP mRNA by 56% in a dose-dependent manner. Surprisingly, the use of recombinant adenoviruses to deliver wild-type or mutant COMP mRNA and Ribo56 simultaneously into COS7 cells proved problematic for the activity of the ribozyme to reduce COMP expression. However, in normal human costochondral cells (hCCCs) infected only with adenoviruses expressing Ribo56, expression of endogenous wild-type COMP mRNA was reduced in a dose-dependent manner by 50%. In chondrocytes that contain heterozygous COMP mutations (D469del, G427E and D511Y) that cause PSACH, Ribo56 was more effective at reducing COMP mRNA (up to 70%). These results indicate that Ribo56 is effective at reducing mutant and wild-type COMP levels in cells and suggests a possible mode of therapy to reduce the mutant protein load.

Computational identification and functional validation of regulatory motifs in cartilage-expressed genes.

Chondrocyte gene regulation is important for the generation and maintenance of cartilage tissues. Several regulatory factors have been identified that play a role in chondrogenesis, including the positive transacting factors of the SOX family such as SOX9, SOX5, and SOX6, as well as negative transacting factors such as C/EBP and delta EF1. However, a complete understanding of the intricate regulatory network that governs the tissue-specific expression of cartilage genes is not yet available. We have taken a computational approach to identify cis-regulatory, transcription factor (TF) binding motifs in a set of cartilage characteristic genes to better define the transcriptional regulatory networks that regulate chondrogenesis. Our computational methods have identified several TFs, whose binding profiles are available in the TRANSFAC database, as important to chondrogenesis. In addition, a cartilage-specific SOX-binding profile was constructed and used to identify both known, and novel, functional paired SOX-binding motifs in chondrocyte genes. Using DNA pattern-recognition algorithms, we have also identified cis-regulatory elements for unknown TFs. We have validated our computational predictions through mutational analyses in cell transfection experiments. One novel regulatory motif, N1, found at high frequency in the COL2A1 promoter, was found to bind to chondrocyte nuclear proteins. Mutational analyses suggest that this motif binds a repressive factor that regulates basal levels of the COL2A1 promoter.

Characterization of dermatan sulfate proteoglycan 3 (DSPG3) and cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP)

This dissertation describes the identification and characterization of human dermatan sulfate proteoglycan 3 (DSPG3) and the characterization of the transcriptional regulation of human cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) in cartilage, ligament, and tendon cells. DSPG3 and COMP are two extracellular matrix proteins. The function of these ECM proteins is unknown.^ DSPG3 was cloned, sequenced, and shown to be expressed in cartilage, ligament, and placenta. DSPG3 was mapped to human chromosome 12q21, and the genomic structure was identified. 1.6 kb of the promoter region has been sequenced, and several putative SOX9 sites were identified as well as 3 TATA sites. Furthermore, an evolutionary tree of the SLRP gene family, which includes DSPG3, is presented.^ The promoter region of COMP was cloned and sequenced. Several putative transcription factor binding sites were identified including multiple AP2 and SP1 sites. Three transcription start sites were found to be located directly downstream of one of the SP1 sites. In addition, the expression of COMP was demonstrated to be higher in tendon than in cartilage and ligament by both Northern and Western blot analysis, and several regions of the COMP promoter were shown to contain cell-specific regulatory elements. Analysis of the proximal 370bp region of the COMP promoter has also identified distinct patterns of nuclear protein binding for the three tissues, and two SP1 sites may play a role in the tissue-specific expression of COMP. ^

Studies of pseudoachondroplasia chondrocytes and knockdown of the cartilage oligomeric matrix protein

Cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) is a large, homopentameric, extracellular matrix glycoprotein. Mutations in COMP cause two skeletal dysplasias: pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH) and multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (EMD1). These dwarfing conditions are caused by retention of misfolded mutant COMP with type IX collagen and matrilin-3 (MATN3) in the rough endoplasmic reticulum (rER) of the chondrocyte. These proteins form a matrix in the rER that continues to expand until it fills the entire cell, eventually causing cell death. Interestingly, loss of COMP in COMP null mice does not affect normal bone development or growth, suggesting that elimination of COMP (wildtype and mutant) expression may prevent PSACH. The hypothesis of these studies was that a hammerhead ribozyme could eliminate or knockdown COMP mRNA expression in PSACH chondrocytes . To test this hypothesis, a human chondrocyte model system that recapitulates the PSACH chondrocyte phenotype was developed by over-expressing mutant (mt-) COMP in normal chondrocytes using a recombinant adenovirus. Chondrocytes over-expressing mt-COMP developed giant rER cisternae containing COMP, type IX collagen and MATN3. Deconvolution microscopy and computer modeling showed that these proteins formed an ordered matrix surrounding a type II pro-collagen core. Additionally, the results show that a hammerhead ribozyme, ribozyme 56 (Ribo56) reduced over-expressed mt-COMP in COS cells and endogenous COMP in normal chondrocytes and mt-COMP in three PSACH chondrocytes cell line (with different mutations) by 40-70%. Altogether, these studies show that the PSACH cellular phenotype can be created in vitro and that the mt-COMP protein burden can be reduced by the presence of a COMP-specific ribozyme. Future studies will focus on designing ribozymes or short interfering RNA (siRNA) technologies that will result in better knockdown of COMP expression as well as the temporal constraints imposed by the PSACH phenotype. ^

Gene Discovery in Nonsyndromic Cleft Lip with or without Cleft Palate

Nonsyndromic cleft lip with or without cleft palate (NSCLP), a common, complex orofacial birth defect that affects approximately 4,000 newborns each year in the United States, is caused by both genetic and environmental factors. Orofacial clefts affect the mouth and nose, causing severe deformity of the face, which require medical, dental and speech therapies. Despite having substantial genetic liability, less than 25% of the genetic contribute to NSCLP has been identified. The studies described in this thesis were performed to identify genes that contribute to NSCLP and to demonstrate the role of these genes in normal craniofacial development. Using genome scan and candidate gene approaches, novel associations with NSCLP were identified. These include MYH9 (7 SNPs, 0.009≤p<0.05), Wnt3A (4 SNPs, 0.001≤p≤0.005), Wnt11 (2 SNPs, 0.001≤p≤0.01) and CRISPLD2 (4 SNPs, 0.001≤p<0.05). The most interesting findings were for CRISPLD2. This gene is expressed in the fused mouse palate at E17.5. In zebrafish, crispld2 localized to the craniofacial region by one day post fertilization. Morpholino knockdown of crispld2 resulted in a lower survival rates and altered neural crest cell (NCC) clustering. Because NCCs form the tissues that populate the craniofacies, this NCC abnormality resulted in cartilage abnormalities of the jaw including fewer ceratobranchial cartilages forming the lower jaw (three pairs compared to five) and broader craniofacies compared to wild-type zebrafish. These findings suggest that the CRISPLD2 gene plays an important role in normal craniofacial development and perturbation of this gene in humans contributes to orofacial clefting. Overall, these results are important because they contribute to our understanding of normal craniofacial development and orofacial clefting etiology, information that can be used to develop better methods to diagnose, counsel and potentially treat NSCLP patients.

Skeletal abnormalities in mice lacking extracellular matrix proteins, thrombospondin-1, thrombospondin-3, thrombospondin-5, and type IX collagen.

Thrombospondin-5 (TSP5) is a large extracellular matrix glycoprotein found in musculoskeletal tissues. TSP5 mutations cause two skeletal dysplasias, pseudoachondroplasia and multiple epiphyseal dysplasia; both show a characteristic growth plate phenotype with retention of TSP5, type IX collagen (Col9), and matrillin-3 in the rough endoplasmic reticulum. Whereas most studies focus on defining the disease process, few functional studies have been performed. TSP5 knockout mice have no obvious skeletal abnormalities, suggesting that TSP5 is not essential in the growth plate and/or that other TSPs may compensate. In contrast, Col9 knockout mice have diminished matrillin-3 levels in the extracellular matrix and early-onset osteoarthritis. To define the roles of TSP1, TSP3, TSP5, and Col9 in the growth plate, all knockout and combinatorial strains were analyzed using histomorphometric techniques. While significant alterations in growth plate organization were found in certain single knockout mouse strains, skeletal growth was only mildly disturbed. In contrast, dramatic changes in growth plate organization in TSP3/5/Col9 knockout mice resulted in a 20% reduction in limb length, corresponding to similar short stature in humans. These studies show that type IX collagen may regulate growth plate width; TSP3, TSP5, and Col9 appear to contribute to growth plate organization; and TSP1 may help define the timing of growth plate closure when other extracellular proteins are absent.

Chondrosarcoma of the mobile spine and sacrum.

Chondrosarcoma is a rare malignant tumor of bone. This family of tumors can be primary malignant tumors or a secondary malignant transformation of an underlying benign cartilage tumor. Pain is often the initial presenting complaint when chondrosarcoma involves the spine. In the mobile spine, chondrosarcoma commonly presents within the vertebral body and shows a predilection for the thoracic spine. Due to the resistance of chondrosarcoma to both radiation and chemotherapy, treatment is focused on surgery. With en bloc excision of chondrosarcoma of the mobile spine and sacrum patients can have local recurrence rates as low as 20%.

BMP-SIGNALING REGULATES A COMMON TRANSCRIPTIONAL PROGRAM TO CONTROL FACIAL FORM AND SKELETAL MORPHOGENESIS

Much of the craniofacial skeleton, such as the skull vault, mandible and midface, develops through direct, intramembranous ossification of the cranial neural crest (CNC) derived progenitor cells. Bmp-signaling plays critical roles in normal craniofacial development, and Bmp4 deficiency results in craniofacial abnormalities, such as cleft lip and palate. We performed an in depth analysis of Bmp4, a critical regulator of development, disease, and evolution, in the CNC. Conditional Bmp4 overexpression, using a tetracycline regulated Bmp4 gain of function allele, resulted in facial form changes that were most dramatic after an E10.5 Bmp4 induction. Expression profiling uncovered a signature of Bmp4 induced genes (BIG) composed predominantly of transcriptional regulators controlling self-renewal, osteoblast differentiation, and negative Bmp autoregulation. The complimentary experiment, CNC inactivation of Bmp2, Bmp4, and Bmp7, resulted in complete or partial loss of multiple CNC derived skeletal elements revealing a critical requirement for Bmp-signaling in membranous bone and cartilage development. Importantly, the BIG signature was reduced in Bmp loss of function mutants indicating similar Bmp-regulated target genes underlying facial form modulation and normal skeletal morphogenesis. Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) revealed a subset of the BIG signature, including Satb2, Smad6, Hand1, Gadd45g and Gata3 that was bound by Smad1/5 in the developing mandible revealing direct, Smad-mediated regulation. These data indicate that Bmp-signaling regulates craniofacial skeletal development and facial form by balancing self-renewal and differentiation pathways in CNC progenitors.

Genetic analysis of factors regulating mesenchymal cell fates

Formation of cartilage and bone involves sequential processes in which undifferentiated mesenchyme aggregates into primordial condensations which subsequently grow and differentiate, resulting in morphogenesis of the adult skeleton. While much has been learned about the structural molecules which comprise cartilage and bone, little is known about the nuclear factors which regulate chondrogenesis and osteogenesis. MHox is a homeobox-containing gene which is expressed in the mesenchyme of facial, limb, and vertebral skeletal precursors during mouse embryogenesis. MHox expression has been shown to require epithelial-derived signals, suggesting that MHox may regulate the epithelial-mesenchymal interactions required for skeletal organogenesis. To determine the functions of MHox, we generated a loss-of-function mutation in the MHox gene. Mice homozygous for a mutant MHox allele exhibit defects of skeletogenesis, involving the loss or malformation of craniofacial, limb and vertebral skeletal structures. The affected skeletal elements are derived from the cranial neural crest, as well as somitic and lateral mesoderm. Analysis of the mutant phenotype during ontogeny demonstrated a defect in the formation or growth of chondrogenic and osteogenic precursors. These findings provide evidence that MHox regulates the formation of preskeletal condensations from undifferentiated mesenchyme. In addition, generation of mice doubly mutant for the MHox and S8 homeobox genes reveal that these two genes interact to control formation of the limb and craniofacial skeleton. Mice carrying mutant alleles for S8 and MHox exhibit an exaggeration of the craniofacial and limb phenotypes observed in the MHox mutant mouse. Thus, MHox and S8 are components of a combinatorial genetic code controlling generation of the skeleton of the skull and limbs. ^

Molecular mechanisms of chondrocyte-specific expression on the mouse pro$\alpha$1(II) collagen gene

Type II collagen is a major chondrocyte-specific component of the cartilage extracellular matrix and it represents a typical differentiation marker of mature chondrocytes. In order to delineate cis-acting elements of the mouse pro$\alpha1$(II) collagen gene that control chondrocyte-specific expression in intact mouse embryos, we generated transgenic mice harboring chimeric constructions in which varying lengths of the promoter and intron 1 sequences were linked to a $\beta$-galactosidase reporter gene. A construction containing a 3000-bp promoter and a 3020-bp intron 1 fragment directed high levels of $\beta$-galactosidase expression specifically to chondrocytes. Successive deletions of intron 1 delineated a 48-bp fragment which targeted $\beta$-galactosidase expression to chondrocytes with the same specificity as the larger intron 1 fragment. When the Col2a1 promoter was replaced with a minimal $\beta$-globin promoter, the 48-bp intron 1 sequence was still able to target expression of the transgene to chondrocytes, specifically. Therefore a 48-bp intron 1 DNA segment of the mouse Col2a1 gene contains the necessary information to confer high-level, temporally correct, chondrocyte expression to a reporter gene in intact mouse embryos and that Col2a1 promoter sequences are dispensable for chondrocyte expression. Nuclear proteins present selectively in mouse primary chondrocytes and rat chondrosarcoma cells bind to the three putative HMG (High-Mobility-Group) domain protein binding sites in this 48-bp sequence and the chondrocyte-specific proteins likely bind the DNA through minor groove. Together, my results indicate that a 48-bp sequence in Col2a1 intron 1 controls chondrocyte-specific expression in vivo and suggest that chondrocytes contain specific nuclear proteins involved in enhancer activity. ^

Functional studies of the homeobox gene {\it Goosecoid\/} during mouse embryogenesis

A fundamental question in developmental biology is to understand the mechanisms that govern the development of an adult individual from a single cell. Goosecoid (Gsc) is an evolutionarily conserved homeobox gene that has been cloned in vertebrates and in Drosophila. In mice, Gsc is first expressed during gastrulation stages where it marks anterior structures of the embryo, this pattern of expression is conserved among vertebrates. Later, expression is observed during organogenesis of the head, limbs and the trunk. The conserved pattern of expression of Gsc during gastrulation and gain of function experiments in Xenopus suggested a function for Gsc in the development of anterior structures in vertebrates. Also, its expression pattern in mouse suggested a role in morphogenesis of the head, limbs and trunk. To determine the functional requirement of Gsc in mice a loss of function mutation was generated by homologous recombination in embryonic stem cells and mice mutant for Gsc were generated.^ Gsc-null mice survived to birth but died hours after delivery. Phenotypic analysis revealed craniofacial and rib cage abnormalities that correlated with the second phase of Gsc expression in the head and trunk but no anomalies were found that correlated with its pattern of expression during gastrulation or limb development.^ To determine the mode of action of Gsc during craniofacial development aggregation chimeras were generated between Gsc-null and wild-type embryos. Chimeras were generated by the aggregation of cleavage stage embryos, taking advantage of two different Gsc-null alleles generated during gene targeting. Chimeras demonstrated a cell-autonomous function for Gsc during craniofacial development and a requirement for Gsc function in cartilage and mesenchymal tissues.^ Thus, during embryogenesis in mice, Gsc is not an essential component of gastrulation as had been suggested in previous experiments. Gsc is required for craniofacial development where it acts cell autonomously in cartilage and mesenchymal tissues. Gsc is also required for proper development of the rib cage but it is dispensable for limb development in mice. ^

Use of a hypomorphic allele of myogenin to analyze Myogenin-dependent processes in mouse development

Myogenin is a muscle-specific transcription factor essential for skeletal muscle differentiation. A severe reduction in the number of fused myotubes is seen in myogenin-null mice, and the expression of genes characteristic of differentiated skeletal muscle is reduced. Additionally, sternebrae defects are seen in myogenin-null mice, a secondary defect in the sternal cartilage precursors. Very little is known about the quantitative requirement for myogenin in muscle differentiation and thoracic skeletal development in vivo. In this thesis I describe experiments utilizing a mouse line harboring a hypomorphic allele of myogenin, generated by gene targeting techniques in embryonic stem cells. The nature of the hypomorphism was due to lowered levels of myogenin from this allele. In embryos homozygous for the hypomorphic allele, normal sternum formation and extensive muscle differentiation was observed. However, muscle hypoplasia and reduced muscle-specific gene expression were apparent in these embryos, and the mice were not viable after birth. These results suggest skeletal muscle differentiation is highly sensitive to the absolute amounts of myogenin, and reveal distinct threshold requirements for myogenin in skeletal muscle differentiation, sternum formation, and viability in vivo. The hypomorphic allele was utilized as a genetically sensitized background to identify other components of myogenin-mediated processes. Using a candidate gene approach I crossed null mutations in MEF2C and MRF4 into the hypomorphic background and examined whether these mutations affected muscle differentiation and skeleton formation in the myogenin hypomorph. Although MEF2C mutation did not affect any phenotypes seen in the hypomorphic background, MRF4 was observed to be an essential component of myogenin-mediated processes of thoracic skeletal development. Additionally, the hypomorphic allele was very sensitive to genetic effects, suggesting the existence of mappable genetic modifiers of the hypomorphic allele of myogenin. ^

A study of the biology of perlecan

Extracellular matrix (ECM) is a component of a variety of organisms that provides both structural support and influence upon the cells it surrounds. The importance of the ECM is becoming more apparent as matrix defects are linked to human disease. In this study, the large, extracellular matrix heparan sulfate proteoglycan, perlecan (Pln) is examined in two systems. First, the role of Pln in the interaction between a blastocyst and uterine epithelial cells is investigated. In mice, blastocyst attachment and implantation occurs at approximately d 4.5 post coitus. In addition, a delayed implantation model has been used to distinguish between the response of the blastocyst to that of hatching and of becoming attachment competent. ^ The second series of experiments described in this study focuses on the process of chondrogenesis in mice. Pln, commonly expressed with other basement membrane (BM) proteins, was found to be expressed in cartilaginous tissue without other BM proteins. This unusual expression pattern led to further study and the development of an in vitro chondrogenesis assay using the mouse embryonic fibroblast cell line, C3H/10T1/2. When cultured on Pln in vitro, these cells form aggregates and express the cartilage proteins, collagen type II and aggrecan. In examining the participation of the heparan sulfate (HS) chains in this process, the proteoglycan was enzymatically digested to remove the HS chains before the initiation of 10T1/2 cell culture. After digestion, the ability of Pln to stimulate aggregate formation was greatly diminished. Thus, the HS chains participate in the cell induction process. To determine which domain of Pln might be responsible for this activity, recombinant fragments of Pin were used in the cell culture assay. Of all recombinant protein fragments tested, only the domain including the HS chains, domain 1, was able to initiate the morphological change exhibited by the 10T1/2 cells. Similar to native Pln, when HS chains were removed from domain I, chondrogenic activity was abolished. A variant of domain I carrying both HS and chondroitin sulfate (CS) chains retained activity when only HS chains were removed. When both HS and CS chains were removed, then activity was lost. ^ The ability to rapidly stimulate differentiation of 10T1/2 cells in vitro may lead to better control of chondrogenesis in vitro and in vivo, providing better understanding and manipulation of the chondrogenic process. This greater understanding may have benefits for study of cartilage and bone diseases and subsequent treatment options. (Abstract shortened by UMI.)^

Isolation and characterization of cDNAs encoding novel homeoproteins from chondrocytes

Bone morphogenesis is a complex biological process. The multistep process of chondrogenesis is the most important aspect of endochondral bone formation. To study the mechanisms which control this multistep pathway of chondrogenesis during embryonic development, I started by isolating cDNAs encoding novel transcriptional factors from chondrocytes. Several such cDNAs encoding putative homeoproteins were identified from a rat chondrosarcoma cDNA preparation. I have been concentrating on characterizing two of these cDNAs. The deduced amino acid sequence of the first homeoprotein, Cart-1, contains a prd-type homeodomain. Northern hybridization and RNase protection analysis revealed that Cart-1 RNAs were present at high levels in a well differentiated rat chondrosarcoma tumor and in a cell line derived from this tumor. Cart-1 transcripts were also detected in primary chondrocytes, but not in numerous other cell types except very low levels in testis. In situ hybridization of rat embryos at different stages of development revealed relatively high levels of Cart-1 RNAs in prechondrocytic mesenchymal cells and in early chondrocytes of cartilage primordia. It is speculated that Cart-1 might play an important role in chondrogenesis. The second putative homeoprotein, rDlx, contains a Distal-less-like homeodomain. rDlx RNAs were also present at high levels in the rat chondrosarcoma tumor and in the cell line derived from this tumor. In situ hybridization of rat embryos revealed high levels of rDlx transcripts in the developing cartilages and perichondria of mature cartilages. rDlx transcripts were also detected in a number of nonchondrogenic tissues such as forebrain, otic vesicles, olfactory epithelia, apical ectodermal ridge (AER) of limb buds, the presumptive Auerbach ganglia of gastrointestinal tract. The unique expression pattern of rDlx suggests that it might play important roles in chondrogenesis and other aspects of embryogenesis. ^