The function of math5 and myocilin in mammalian eye development and disease

Complex molecular events underlie vertebrate eye development and disease. The eye is composed of two major tissue types: the anterior and posterior segments. During development, the retinal progenitor cells differentiate into six neuronal and one non-neuronal cell types. These cell types later organize into the distinct laminar structure of the mature retina which occupies the posterior segment. In the developed anterior segment, both the ciliary body and trabecular meshwork regulate intraocular pressure created by the aqueous humor. The disruption in intraocular pressure can lead to a blinding condition called glaucoma. To characterize molecular mechanisms governing retinal development and glaucoma, two separate mouse knockout lines carrying mutations in math5 and myocilin were subjected to a series of in vivo analyses. ^ Math5 is a murine homologue of Drosophila atonal , a bHLH proneural gene essential for the formation of photoreceptor cells. The expression of math5 coincides with the onset of retinal ganglion cell differentiation. The targeted deletion of mouse math5 revealed that a null mutation inhibits the formation of a majority of the retinal ganglion cells. The mutation also interferes with the normal development of other retinal cell types such as amacrine, bipolar and photoreceptor cells. These results suggest that math5 is a proneural gene responsible for differentiation of retinal ganglion cells and may also have a role in normal development of other neuronal cell types within the retina. ^ Myocilin has two unique protein coding regions bearing homology to non-muscle myosin of Dictyostelium discoideum and to olfactomedin, an extracellular matrix molecule first described in the olfactory epithelium of the bullfrog. Recently, autosomal dominant forms of myocilin mutations have been found in individuals with primary open-angle glaucoma. The genetic linkage to glaucoma suggests a role of myocilin in normal intraocular pressure and ocular function. However, the analysis of mice heterozygous and homozygous for a targeted null mutation in myocilin indicates that it is dispensable for normal intraocular pressure or ocular function. Additionally, the lack of a discernable phenotype in both heterozygous and null mice suggests that haploinsufficiency is not a critical mechanism for MYOC-associated glaucoma in humans. Instead, disease-causing mutations likely act by gain of function. ^ In summary, these studies provide novel insights into the embryonic development of the vertebrate retina, and also begin to uncover the molecular mechanisms responsible for the pathogenesis of glaucoma. ^

Neuroretina specification in mouse embryos requires Six3-mediated suppression of Wnt8b in the anterior neural plate.

Retinal degeneration causes vision impairment and blindness in humans. If one day we are to harness the potential of stem cell-based cell replacement therapies to treat these conditions, it is imperative that we better understand normal retina development. Currently, the genes and mechanisms that regulate the specification of the neuroretina during vertebrate eye development remain unknown. Here, we identify sine oculis-related homeobox 3 (Six3) as a crucial player in this process in mice. In Six3 conditional-mutant mouse embryos, specification of the neuroretina was abrogated, but that of the retinal pigmented epithelium was normal. Conditional deletion of Six3 did not affect the initial development of the optic vesicle but did arrest subsequent neuroretina specification. Ectopic rostral expansion of Wnt8b expression was the major response to Six3 deletion and the leading cause for the specific lack of neuroretina, as ectopic Wnt8b expression in transgenic embryos was sufficient to suppress neuroretina specification. Using chromatin immunoprecipitation assays, we identified Six3-responsive elements in the Wnt8b locus and demonstrated that Six3 directly repressed Wnt8b expression in vivo. Our findings provide a molecular framework to the program leading to neuroretina differentiation and may be relevant for the development of novel strategies aimed at characterizing and eventually treating different abnormalities in eye formation.

Structure-function analyses of {\it PAX6\/} and the molecular bases of aniridia

PAX6 is a transcription activator that regulates eye development in animals ranging from Drosophila to human. The C-terminal region of PAX6 is proline/serine/threonine-rich (PST) and functions as a potent transactivation domain when attached to a heterologous DNA-binding domain of the yeast transcription factor, GAL4. The PST region comprises 152 amino acids encoded by four exons. The transactivation function of the PST region has not been defined and characterized in detail by in vitro mutagenesis. I dissected the PST domain in two independent systems, a heterologous system using a GAL4 DNA-binding site and the native system of PAX6. In both systems, the results show consistently that all four constituent exons of the PST domain are responsible for the transactivation function. The four exon fragments act cooperatively to stimulate transcription, although none of them can function individually as an independent transactivation domain. Combinations of two or more exon fragments can reconstitute substantial transactivation activity when fused to the DNA-binding domain of GAL4, but they surprisingly do not produce much activity in the context of native PAX6 even though the mutant PAX6 proteins are stable and their DNA-binding function remains unaffected. I conclude that the PAX6 protein contains an unusually large transactivation domain that is evolutionarily conserved to a high degree, and that its full transactivation activity relies on the cooperative action of the four exon fragments.^ Most PAX6 mutations detected in patients with aniridia result in truncations of the protein. Some of the truncation mutations occur in the PST region of PAX6, resulting in mutant proteins that retain their DNA-binding ability but have no significant transactivation activity. It is not clear whether such mutants are true loss-of-function or dominant-negative mutants. I show that these mutants are dominant-negative if they are coexpressed with wild-type PAX6 in cultured cells and that the dominant-negative effects result from enhanced DNA-binding ability of these mutants due to removal of the PST domain. These mutants are able to repress the wild-type PAX6 activity not only at target genes with paired domain binding sites but also at target genes with homeodomain binding sites.^ Mutations in the human PAX6 gene produce various phenotypes, including aniridia, Peters' anomaly, autosomal dominant keratitis, and familial foveal dysplasia. The various phenotypes may arise from different mutations in the same gene. To test this theory, I performed a functional analysis of two missense mutations in the paired domain: the R26G mutation reported in a case of Peters' anomaly, and the I87R mutation identified in a patient with aniridia. While both the R26 and the I87 positions are conserved in the paired boxes of all known PAX genes, X-ray crystallography has shown that only R26 makes contact with DNA. I found that the R26G mutant failed to bind a subset of paired domain binding sites but, surprisingly, bound other sites and successfully transactivated promoters containing those sites. In contrast, the I87R mutant had lost the ability to bind DNA at all tested sites and failed to transactivate promoters. My data support the haploinsufficiency hypothesis of aniridia, and the hypothesis that R26G is a hypomorphic allele. ^

The evolution of paired domains

Pax genes are important developmental control genes. They are involved in nervous system development, organogenesis and oncogenesis. A DNA specific binding domain called the paired domain, which is well conserved during evolution, defines Pax genes. Furthermore, Pax genes are also conserved in terms of their functions. For example, the Pax-6 gene has been showed to be one of the master control genes for eye development both in Drosophila and vertebrates. All of these properties of Pax genes make them an excellent model for studying the evolution of gene function. ^ Molecular evolutionary studies of paired domain are carried out in this study. Five Pax genes from cnidarians, which are the most primitive organisms possessing a nervous system, were isolated and characterized for their DNA binding properties. By combining data obtained from Genbank and this study, the phylogenetic relationship between Pax genes was studied. It was found that Pax genes could be divided into five groups: Pax-1/9, Pax-3 /7, Pax-A, Pax-2/5/ 8/B, and Pax- 4/6. Furthermore, Pax-2/5/8/ B, Pax-A and Pax-4/6 could be clustered into a supergroup I, while Pax-1/9 and Pax-3/7 could be clustered into supergroup II. The phylogeny was also supported by studies on DNA binding properties of paired domains from different groups. A statistical method was applied to infer the critical amino acid residue substitutions between two supergroups and within the supergroup I. It was found that two amino acid residues were mainly responsible for the difference of DNA binding between two supergroups, while only one amino acid was critical for the evolution of novel DNA binding properties of Pax-4/6 group from ancestor. Evolutionary implications of these data are also discussed. ^

Positional cloning and characterization of the human aniridia and murine small eye genes

Aniridia (AN) is a congenital, panocular disorder of the eye characterized by the complete or partial absence of the iris. The disease can occur in both the sporadic and familial forms which, in the latter case, is inherited as an autosomal dominant trait with high penetrance. The objective of this study was to isolate and characterize the genes involved in AN and Sey, and thereby to gain a better understanding of the molecular basis of the two disorders.^ Using a positional cloning strategy, I have approached and cloned from the AN locus in human chromosomal band 11p13 a cDNA that is deleted in two patients with AN. The deletions in these patients overlap by about 70 kb and encompass the 3$\sp\prime$ end of the cDNA. This cDNA detects a 2.7 kb mRNA encoded by a transcription unit estimated to span approximately 50 kb of genomic DNA. The message is specifically expressed in all tissues affected in all forms of AN, namely within the presumptive iris, lens, neuroretina, the superficial layers of the cornea, the olfactory bulbs, and the cerebellum. Sequence analysis of the AN cDNA revealed a number of motifs characteristic of certain transcription factors. Chief among these are the presence of the paired domain, the homeodomain, and a carboxy-terminal domain rich in serine, threonine and proline residues. The overall structure shows high homology to the Drosophila segmentation gene paired and members of the murine Pax family of developmental control genes.^ Utilizing a conserved human genomic DNA sequence as probe, I was able to isolate an embryonic murine cDNA which is over 92% homologous in nucleotide sequence and virtually identical at the amino acid level to the human AN cDNA. The expression pattern of the murine gene is the same as that in man, supporting the conclusion that it probably corresponds to the Sey gene. Its specific expression in the neuroectodermal component of the eye, in glioblastomas, but not in the neural crest-derived PC12 pheochromocytoma cell line, suggests that a defect in neuroectodermal rather mesodermal development might be the common etiological factor underlying AN and Sey. ^

Functional analysis of BMP4 signaling in mouse neural development

During early mouse neural development, bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling patterns the dorsal neural tube and defines distinct neural progenitor cell domains along the dorsoventral axis. Unlike the ventral signaling molecule Sonic hedgehog, which has long-range activity by establishing a concentration gradient in the ventral neural tube, these dorsally expressed BMPs appear to have a limited domain of action. This raises questions as to how BMP activity is restricted locally and how restricted BMP signaling directs dorsal neural patterning and differentiation. I hypothesize that BMPs are restricted in the dorsal neural tube for correct dorsoventral patterning. ^ Previous studies have shown that the positively charged basic amino acids located at the N-terminus of several BMPs are essential for heparin binding and diffusion. This provides a novel tool to address these questions. Here I adapted a UAS/GAL4 bigenic mouse system to control the ectopic expression of BMP4 and a mutant form of BMP4 that lacks a subset of the N-terminal basic amino acids. The target genes, UAS-Bmp4 and UAS-mBmp4 , were introduced into the Hprt locus by gene targeting in mouse embryonic stem cells. The expression of the GAL4 transactivator was driven by a roof plate specific Wnt1 promoter. ^ The bigenic mouse embryos exhibit phenotype variations, ranging from mid/hindbrain defects, hemorrhage, and eye abnormalities to vasculture formation. Embryonic death starts around E11.5 because of severe hemorrhage. The different expression levels of the activated transgene may account for the phenotype variation. Further marker analysis reveals that mutant BMP4 induces ectopic expression of the dorsal markers MSX1/2 and PAX7 in the ventral neural tube. In addition, the expression of the ventral neural marker NKX2.2 is affected by the expanded BMP4 activity, indicating that ectopic BMP signaling can antagonize ventral signaling. Comparison of the phenotypes of the Wnt1/ Bmp4 and Wnt1/mBmp4 bigenic embryos that express transgenes at the same level, respectively, shows that mutant BMP4 causes the expansion of dorsal neural fates ventrally while wild type BMP4 does not, suggesting that mutant BMP4 acts farther than wild type BMP4. Together, these data suggest that the N-terminus basic amino acid core controls BMP4 long-range activity in neural development, and that BMP signaling patterns the dorsal neural tube through a secondary signaling pathway that involves homeodomain transcription factors MSX1/2 and PAX7. ^