Gene therapy of cancer: Mechanisms of ``bystander effect'' killing in cells expressing the herpes simplex virus-thymidine kinase gene and its potential clinical applications

At the fore-front of cancer research, gene therapy offers the potential to either promote cell death or alter the behavior of tumor-cells. One example makes use of a toxic phenotype generated by the prodrug metabolizing gene, thymidine kinase (HSVtk) from the Herpes Simplex Virus. This gene confers selective toxicity to a relatively nontoxic prodrug, ganciclovir (GCV). Tumor cells transduced with the HSVtk gene are sensitive to 1-50 $\mu$M GCV; normal tissue is insensitive up to 150-250 $\mu$M GCV. Utilizing these different sensitivities, it is possible to selectively ablate tumor cells expressing this gene. Interestingly, if a HSVtk$\sp+$ expressing population is mixed with a HSVtk$\sp-$ population at high density, all the cells are killed after GCV administration. This phenomenon for killing all neighboring cells is termed the "bystander effect", which is well documented in HSVtk$\sp-$ GCV systems, though its exact mechanism of action is unclear.^ Using the mouse colon carcinoma cell line CT26, data are presented supporting possible mechanisms of "bystander effect" killing of neighboring CT26-tk$\sp-$cells. A major requirement for bystander killing is the prodrug GCV: as dead or dying CT26tk$\sp+$ cells have no toxic effect on neighboring cells in its absence. In vitro, it appears the bystander effect is due to transfer of toxic GCV-metabolites, through verapamil sensitive intracellular-junctions. Additionally, possible transfer of the HSVtk enzyme to bystander cells after GCV addition, may play a role in bystander killing. A nude mouse model suggests that in a 50/50 (tk$\sp+$/tk$\sp-$) mixture of CT26 cells the bystander eradication of tumors does not involve an immune component. Additionally in a possible clinical application, the "bystander effect" can be directly exploited to eradicate preexisting CT26 colon carcinomas in mice by intratumoral implantation of viable or lethally irradiated CT26tk$\sp+$ cells and subsequent GCV administration. Lastly, an application of this toxic phenotype gene to a clinical marking protocol utilizing a recombinant adenoviral vector carrying the bifunctional protein GAL-TEK to eradicate spontaneously-arisen or vaccine-induced fibrosarcomas in cats is demonstrated. ^

Design, synthesis and biological evaluation of 5$\sp\prime$-mononucleotide prodrugs: Strategies to introduce nucleotides into cells

The neutral bis ((pivaloyloxy)methyl) (PIV$\sb2\rbrack$ derivatives of FdUMP, ddUMP, and AZTMP were synthesized as potential membrane-permeable prodrugs of FdUMP, ddUMP, and AZTMP. These compounds were designed to enter cells by passive diffusion and revert to the parent nucleotides after removal of the PIV groups by hydrolytic enzymes. These prodrugs were prepared by condensation of FUdR, ddU, and AZT with PIV$\sb2$ phosphate in the presence of triphenylphosphine and diethyl azodicarboxylate (the Mitsunobo reagent). PIV$\sb2$-FdUMP, PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP, and PIV$\sb2$-AZTMP were stable in the pH range 1.0-4.0 (t$\sb{1/2} = {>}$100 h). They were also fairly stable at pH 7.4 (t$\sb{1/2} = {>}$40 h). In 0.05 M NaOH solution, however, they were rapidly degraded (t$\sb{1/2} < 2$ min). In the presence hog liver carboxylate esterase, they were converted quantitatively to the corresponding phosphodiesters, PIV$\sb1$-FdUMP, PIV$\sb1$-ddUMP, and PIV$\sb1$-AZTMP; after 24 h incubation, only trace amounts of FdUMP, ddUMP, and AZTMP (1-5%) were observed indicating that the PIV$\sb1$ compounds were poor substrates for the enzyme. In human plasma, the PIV$\sb2$ compounds were rapidly degraded with half-lives of less than 5 min. The rate of degradation of the PIV$\sb2$ compounds in the presence of phosphodiesterase I was the same as that in buffer controls, indicating that they were not substrates for this enzyme. In the presence of phosphodiesterase I, PIV$\sb1$-FdUMP, PIV$\sb1$-ddUMP, and PIV$\sb1$-AZTMP were converted quantitatively to FdUMP, ddUMP, and AZTMP.^ PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP and PIV$\sb2$-AZTMP were effective at controlling HIV type 1 infection in MT-4 and CEM tk$\sp-$ cells in culture. Mechanistic studies demonstrated that PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP and PIV$\sb2$-AZTMP were taken up by the cells and converted to ddUTP and AZTTP, both potent inhibitors of HIV reverse transcriptase. However, a potential shortcoming of PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP and PIV$\sb2$-AZTMP as clinical therapeutic agents is that they are rapidly degraded (t$\sb{1/2}$ = approx. 4 minutes) in human plasma by carboxylate esterases. To circumvent this limitation, chemically-labile nucleotide prodrugs and liposome-encapsulated nucleotide prodrugs were investigated. In the former approach, the protective groups bis(N, N-(dimethyl)carbamoyloxymethyl) (DM$\sb2$) and bis (N-(piperidino)carbamoyloxymethyl) (DP$\sb2$) were used to synthesize DM$\sb2$-ddUMP and DP$\sb2$-ddUMP, respectively. In aqueous buffers (pH range 1.0-9.0) these compounds were degraded with half-lives of 3 to 4 h. They had similar half-lives in human plasma demonstrating that they were resistant to esterase-mediated cleavage. However, neither compound gave rise to significant concentrations of ddUMP in CEM or CEM tk$\sp-$ cells. In the liposome-encapsulated nucleotide prodrug approach, three different liposomal formulations of PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP (L-PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP) were investigated. The half-lifes of these L-PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP preparations in human plasma were 2 h compared with 4 min for the free drug. The preparations were more effective at controlling HIV-1 infection than free PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP in human T cells in culture. Collectively, these data indicate that PIV$\sb2$-FdUMP, PIV$\sb2$-ddUMP, and PIV$\sb2$-AZTMP are effective membrane-permeable prodrugs of FdUMP, ddUMP, and AZTMP. ^

Development of prostate cancer gene therapy

Osseous metastases account for most of the morbidity and mortality associated with prostate cancer, for which there are currently no effective therapies. In the skeletal metastatic environment, neoplastic prostatic epithelial cells interact in a bidirectional stimulatory manner with osteoblastic stromal cells. Similarly, the presence of osteoblastic cells is essential for the survival and maintenance of intraosseous prostate cancer cells. In this thesis, I have developed novel gene therapy strategies for the treatment of androgen-independent human prostate cancers in experimental animal models. First, Ad-CMV-p53, a recombinant adenovirus (Ad) containing p53 tumor suppressor gene driven by the universal cytomegalovirus promoter, was effective in inhibiting prostate cancer cell growth, and direct intratumoral injections of Ad-CMV-p53 resulted in tumor regression. Second, because prostate cancer cells as well as osteoblastic cells produce osteocalcin (OC), OC promoter mediated tissue/tumor specific toxic gene therapy is developed to interrupt stromal-epithelial communications by targeting both cell types. Ad-OC-TK, a recombinant Ad containing the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (TK) gene driven by the OC promoter, was generated to inhibit the growth of osteoblastic osteosarcoma with prodrug acyclovir (ACV). Ad-OC-TK/ACV also inhibited the growth of prostate cancer cells and suppressed the growth of subcutaneous and intraosseous prostate tumor. In order to combine treatment modalities to maximize tumor cell-kill with minimized host toxicities, Ad-OC-TK/ACV was applied in combination with low dose methotrexate to eradicate osteoblastic osteosarcoma. In targeting of micrometastatic disease, intravenous Ad-OC-TK/ACV treatment resulted in significant tumor nodule reduction and prolonged the survival of animals harboring osteosarcoma lung metastases without significant host toxicity. Ad-OC-TK is a rational choice for the treatment of prostate cancer skeletal metastasis because OC is uniformly detected in both primary and metastatic human prostate cancer specimens by immunohistochemistry. Ad-OC-TK/ACV inhibits the growth not only of prostate cancer cells but also of their supporting bone stromal cells. Targeting both prostate cancer epithelium and its supporting stroma may be most efficacious for the treatment of prostate cancer osseous metastases. ^

ARRANGEMENT OF GENE LOCI IN EUPLOID CHINESE HAMSTER CELLS AND GENETIC CONSEQUENCES OF REARRANGEMENT IN CHO CELLS

In both euploid Chinese hamster (Cricetulus griseus) cells and pseudodiploid Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells, gene assignments were accomplished by G band chromosome and isozyme analysis (32 isozymes) of interspecific somatic cell hybrids obtained after HAT selection of mouse CL 1D (TK('-)) cells which were PEG-fused with either euploid Chinese hamster cells or HPRT('-) CHO cells. Hybrids slowly segregated hamster chromosomes. Clone panels consisting of independent hybrid clones and subclones containing different combinations of Chinese hamster chromosomes and isozymes were established from each type of fusion.^ These clone panels enabled us to provisionally assign the loci for: nucleoside phosphorylase (NP), glyoxalase (GLO), glutathione reductase (GSR), adenosine kinase (ADK), esterase D (ESD), peptidases B and S (PEPB and -S) and phosphoglucomutase 2 (PGM2, human nomenclature) to chromosome 1; adenylate kinase 1 (AK1), adenosine deaminase (ADA) and inosine triosephosphatase (ITP) to chromosome 6; triosephosphate isomerase (TPI) to chromosome 8; and glucose phosphate isomerse (GPI) and peptidase D (PEPD) to chromosome 9.^ We also confirm the assignments of 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase (PGD), PGM1, enolase 1 (ENO1) and diptheria toxin sensitivity (DTS) to chromosome 2 as well as provisionally assign galactose-1-phosphate uridyl transferase (GALT) and AK2 to chromosome 2. Selection in either HAT or BrdU for hybrids that had retained or lost the chromosome carrying the locus for TK enabled us to assign the loci for TK, galactokinase (GALK) and acid phosphatase 1 (ACP1) to Chinese hamster chromosome 7.^ These results are discussed in relation to current theories on the basis for high frequency of drug resistant autosomal recessive mutants in CHO cells and conservation of mammalian autosomal linkage groups. ^

STUDIES ON THE BIOLOGICAL ACTIVITY OF MACROMOLECULES MICROINJECTED INTO MAMMALIAN SOMATIC CELLS

Red Blood cell mediated and glass needle mediated microinjection technology was used to introduce macromolecules into mammalian somatic cells. The biological activities of DNA synthesis inducing factor(s) (Chapter 1), mitotic factor(s) (Chapter 2), and DNA coding for ovalbumin and thymidine kinase (Chapter 3) were studied following injection into mammalian somatic cells.^ Chapter 1. A cell undergoing DNA replication (S phase) contains a factor(s) that induces DNA synthesis prematurely in a G(,1) nucleus when an S phase cell is fused to a G(,1) cell. An assay for the active factor(s) was developed in which a mixture of s phase extract loaded red blood cells (RBC) and synchronous G(,1) HeLa cells was centrifuged onto Concanavalin A (Con A) treated coverslips and fused by PEG. This technique is called "Centrifusion". The synchronous G(,1) HeLa cells injected with S phase extract initiated DNA synthesis earlier than the control G(,1) cells mock injected with RBC loaded with buffer.^ Chapter 2. It has been demonstrated that fusion between a mitotic and an interphase cell usually leads to breakdown of the interphase nucleus, followed by condensation of the interphase chromatin into discrete chromosomes, a process termed premature chromosome condensation. I wanted to develop an assay for the mitotic factor(s) that induces premature chromosome condensation. Experiments were performed utilizing glass needle mediated microinjection of HeLa cell mitotic extract into interphase somatic mammalian cells in an attempt to induce premature chromosome condensation. However, I was not able to induce premature chromosome condensation in the interphase cells, probably because of an inability to introduce sufficient mitotic factor(s) into the cells.^ Chapter 3. A recombinant plasmid containing the chicken ovalbumin gene and three copies of the Herpes thymidine Kinase gene (pOV12-TK) was introduced into mouse LMTK('-) cell nuclei using glass needle mediated gene transfer resulting in LMTK('+) clones that were selected for in HAT medium. Restriction enzyme analysis of the high molecular weight DNA from 6 HAT medium survivor cell clones revealed the presence of one or at best only a few copies of the 12kb ovalbumin gene per mouse genome. Further analysis showed the ovalbumin DNA was not rearranged and was associated with high molecular weight mouse cell DNA. Each of the analyzed cell clones produced ovalbumin demonstrating that the biological activity of the microinjected ovalbumin was retained. ^

Development of colorectal cancer gene therapy

Colorectal cancer is the number two cancer killer in the United States. Although primary colorectal cancer can be resected by surgery, patients often die from metastatic disease. Liver is the most common site of metastasis for colorectal cancer. It is difficult to selectively kill metastatic colon cancer cells without damaging normal liver functions. Thus it becomes a high priority to develop a selective targeting system for the treatment of colorectal cancer liver metastasis. ^ In the current study, a gene therapy strategy that allows a therapeutic gene to selectively destroy metastatic colon cancer cells without affecting normal liver cells is developed. The APC gene is frequently mutated in colorectal cancers. These mutations activate β-catenin responsive promoters. An optimized β-catenin responsive promoter, containing TCF consensus binding sites, was engineered for this study. This TCF promoter was found to express preferentially in APC mutated/β-catenin activated colorectal cancers while maintaining a low expression level in cell lines of liver origin. A recombinant adenoviral vector AdTCF-TK, in which the TCF promoter controls expression of the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase gene, selectively destroyed colorectal cancer cells in vitro. AdTCF-TK virus and ganciclovir treatment also inhibited the growth of solid tumour derived from the colon cancer cell line DLD-1 in nude mice. In a control experiment, the growth inhibition effect of the same virus was attenuated in a liver cancer cell line. ^ In the present study, a novel method was developed to target therapeutic gene expression to colon cancer cells at reduced liver toxicity to the patients. The same gene therapy design may also be applied to treat tumours carrying mutations in the β-catenin gene, which is a central component of the APC signal transduction pathway. In summary, the principle for a rational design of a cancer specific treatment approach is demonstrated in this study. In the future, mutations in cancer patients will be more easily identified. Using the same principle developed in this study, specific regimen can be designed to treat these patients based on the specific genetic changes found in the tumour. ^