Highlighting Interdisciplinarity between Physics and Mathematics in Historical Papers on Special Relativity: Development of an Analytical Tool for Characterising Boundary Crossing Mechanisms

Questa tesi di laurea si colloca all'interno del progetto Erasmus + IDENTITIES, il cui obiettivo è sviluppare materiali didattici interdisciplinari per la formazione iniziale degli insegnanti. Nello specifico, si dà seguito ad una ricerca condotta da Lorenzo Miani, finalizzata a mettere in evidenza come la Teoria della Relatività Speciale (STR) sia storicamente nata da una speciale interazione tra matematica e fisica. Tale co-evoluzione è stata cercata, e messa in evidenza, attraverso l’analisi dei quattro articoli fondativi della STR scritti da Lorentz (1904), Poincaré (1906), Einstein (1905) e Minkowski (1908). Per l’analisi di questi articoli abbiamo utilizzato la metafora del “confine”, esposta nella metateoria di Akkerman e Bakker (2011), riferendosi al confine tra Matematica e Fisica. È stato sviluppato uno strumento operativo di analisi di articoli originali per estrarne il rapporto tra le due discipline. Un’analisi di questo tipo può portare un contributo considerevole al Justification Problem, intercettando la possibilità di indagare sull’identità della Matematica, intesa come disciplina. Questo tipo di analisi ha permesso di comprendere gli “stili al confine” di ogni autore, e la natura delle Trasformazioni di Lorentz in quanto oggetto di confine. È inoltre illustrata la progettazione di un’attività per la formazione iniziale degli insegnanti. Questa si configura come un tutorial per lavori di gruppo, ed è stata sperimentata nel corso di Didattica della Fisica dell’Università di Bologna, tenuto dalla Professoressa Olivia Levrini. Grazie all’attività, è stato possibile riflettere sulle identità disciplinari e sull’importanza di fare “esperienze di confine” per superare stereotipi. Lo strumento elaborato nella tesi si apre a sviluppi futuri, dal momento che si presta ad essere utilizzato per l’analisi di una grande varietà di testi e per la costruzione di “boundary zone”, sempre più auspicate e incentivate nei report europei.

The “FRA wheel” as a teaching tool to elaborate on the identity aspects of physics and mathematics as disciplines in interdisciplinary contexts

This thesis project is framed in the research field of Physics Education and aims to contribute to the reflection on the importance of disciplinary identities in addressing interdisciplinarity through the lens of the Nature of Science (NOS). In particular, the study focuses on the module on the parabola and parabolic motion, which was designed within the EU project IDENTITIES. The project aims to design modules to innovate pre-service teacher education according to contemporary challenges, focusing on interdisciplinarity in curricular and STEM topics (especially between physics, mathematics and computer science). The modules are designed according to a model of disciplines and interdisciplinarity that the project IDENTITIES has been elaborating on two main theoretical frameworks: the Family Resemblance Approach (FRA), reconceptualized for the Nature of science (Erduran & Dagher, 2014), and the boundary crossing and boundary objects framework by Akkerman and Bakker (2011). The main aim of the thesis is to explore the impact of this interdisciplinary model in the specific case of the implementation of the parabola and parabolic motion module in a context of preservice teacher education. To reach this purpose, we have analyzed some data collected during the implementation in order to investigate, in particular, the role of the FRA as a learning tool to: a) elaborate on the concept of “discipline”, within the broader problem to define interdisciplinarity; b) compare the epistemic core of physics and mathematics; c) develop epistemic skills and interdisciplinary competences in student-teachers. The analysis of the data led us to recognize three different roles played by the FRA: FRA as epistemological activator, FRA as scaffolding for reasoning and navigating (inhabiting) the complexity, and FRA as lens to investigate the relationship between physics and mathematics in the historical case.

Content and English Language Integrated Learning: The use of Moodle in Aircraft Maintenance Training Programs

The aim of this work is to develop a prototype of an e-learning environment that can foster Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) for students enrolled in an aircraft maintenance training program, which allows them to obtain a license valid in all EU member states. Background research is conducted to retrace the evolution of the field of educational technology, analyzing different learning theories – behaviorism, cognitivism, and (socio-)constructivism – and reflecting on how technology and its use in educational contexts has changed over time. Particular attention is given to technologies that have been used and proved effective in Computer Assisted Language Learning (CALL). Based on the background research and on students’ learning objectives, i.e. learning highly specialized contents and aeronautical technical English, a bilingual approach is chosen, three main tools are identified – a hypertextbook, an exercise creation activity, and a discussion forum – and the learning management system Moodle is chosen as delivery medium. The hypertextbook is based on the technical textbook written in English students already use. In order to foster text comprehension, the hypertextbook is enriched by hyperlinks and tooltips. Hyperlinks redirect students to webpages containing additional information both in English and in Italian, while tooltips show Italian equivalents of English technical terms. The exercise creation activity and the discussion forum foster interaction and collaboration among students, according to socio-constructivist principles. In the exercise creation activity, students collaboratively create a workbook, which allow them to deeply analyze and master the contents of the hypertextbook and at the same time create a learning tool that can help them, as well as future students, to enhance learning. In the discussion forum students can discuss their individual issues, content-related, English-related or e-learning environment-related, helping one other and offering instructors suggestions on how to improve both the hypertextbook and the workbook based on their needs.