Radio follow-up of the gamma-ray flaring gravitational lens B0218+357

B0218+357 è un blazar soggetto al lensing che si trova a z=0.944. Questo sistema consiste in due componenti compatte (A e B) e un anello di Einstein. Recentemente è stato associato ad una sorgente gamma soggetta a burst osservata con il satellite Fermi-LAT. Questo blazar ha mostrato una forte variabilità in banda γ da agosto a settembre del 2012. Gli episodi di variabilità osservati hanno consentito di misurare per la prima volta in banda gamma il ritardo temporale previsto dalla teoria del lensing gravitazionale. Le osservazioni in banda gamma sono state seguite da un programma di monitoring con il Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) in banda radio con lo scopo di verificare l’esistenza di una correlazione tra l’emissione nelle due bande. In questa Tesi tali osservazioni radio sono state analizzate con lo scopo di studiare la variabilità di B0218+357 e, quindi, attestare la connessione tra l’emissione alle alte energie e quella in banda radio. L’obiettivo principale di questo lavoro di Tesi è quello di studiare l’evoluzione della densità di flusso, dell’indice spettrale e della morfologia delle immagini A e B e delle loro sottocomponenti. I dati analizzati sono stati ottenuti con l’interferometro VLBA a tre frequenze di osser- vazione: 2.3, 8.4 GHz (4 epoche con osservazioni simultanee alle due frequenze) e 22 GHz (16 epoche). Le osservazioni hanno coperto un periodo di circa due mesi, subito successivo al flare in banda gamma. La riduzione dei dati è stata effettuata con il pacchetto AIPS. Dall’analisi delle immagini, nella componente B è possibile riconoscere la tipica struttura nucleo-getto chiaramente a tutte e tre le frequenze, invece nella componente A questa struttura è identificabile solo a 22 GHz. A 2.3 e 8.4 GHz la risoluzione non è sufficiente a risolvere nucleo e getto della componente A e l’emissione diffusa risulta dominante. Utilizzando il metodo dello stacking sulle immagini a 2.3 GHz, è stato possibile rivelare le parti più brillanti dell’Einstein ring associato a questa sorgente. Questo è stato possibile poiché la sorgente non ha mostrato alcun segno di variabilità significativa né di struttura né di flusso nelle componenti. Quindi dall’analisi delle curve di luce delle due componenti A e B non è emersa una variabilità significativa chiaramente associabile al flare osservato in banda gamma. Per verificare questo risultato, le curve di luce ottenute sono state confrontate con le osservazioni del radio telescopio OVRO (15 GHz) nel periodo corrispondente alle nostre osservazioni. La curva di luce OVRO è risultata in pieno accordo con le curve di luce ottenute durante questo lavoro di tesi e ha confermato che B0218+257 non ha mostrato un’importante attività radio nel periodo delle osservazioni VLBA. In definitiva, la mancanza di variabilità radio associata a quella osservata nei raggi gamma può essere dovuta al fatto che la regione in cui si è originato il flare gamma è otticamente spessa alle lunghezze d’onda radio, oppure non esiste una precisa correlazione tra le due emissioni, rimanendo quindi un problema aperto da investigare.

Gravitational microscope in MACSJ1206: unveiling galaxy cluster member mass distribution

Gravitational lensing is a powerful tool to investigate the properties of the distribution of matter, be it barionic or dark. In this work we take advantage of Strong Gravitational Lensing to infer the properties of one of the galaxy-scale substructures that makes up the cluster MACSJ1206. It is relatively easy to model the morphology of the visible components of a galaxy, while the morphology of the dark matter distribution cannot be so easily constrained. Being sensitive to the whole mass, strong lensing provides a way to probe DM distribution, and this is the reason why it is the best tool to study the substructure. The goal of this work consists of performing an analysis of the substructure previously mentioned, an early type galaxy (ETG), by analyzing the highly magnified Einstein ring around it, in order to put stringent constraints on its matter distribution, that, for an ETG, is commonly well described by an isothermal profilele. This turns out to be interesting for three main different reasons. It is well known that galaxies in clusters are subject to interaction processes, both dynamic and hydrodynamic, that can significantly modify the distribution of matter within them. Therefore, finding a different profile from the one usually expected could be a sign that the galaxy has undergone processes that have changed its structure. Studying the mass distribution also means studying the dark matter component, which not only still presents great questions today, but which is also not obviously distributed in the same way as in an isolated galaxy. What emerges from the analysis is that the total mass distribution of the galaxy under examination turns out to have a slope much steeper than the isothermal usually expected.

Fermion masses, leptogenesis and gravitational waves in SO(10)

Grand Unification Theories (GUTs) predict the unification of three of the fundamental forces and are a possible extension of the Standard Model, some of them predict neutrino mass and baryon asymmetry. We consider a minimal non-supersymmetric $SO(10)$ GUT model that can reproduce the observed fermionic masses and mixing parameters of the Standard Model. We calculate the scales of spontaneous symmetry breaking from the GUT to the Standard Model gauge group using two-loop renormalisation group equations. This procedure determines the proton decay rate and the scale of $U(1)_{B-L}$ breaking, which generates cosmic strings, and the right-handed neutrino mass scales. Consequently, the regions of parameter space where thermal leptogenesis is viable are identified and correlated with the fermion masses and mixing, the neutrinoless double beta decay rate, the proton decay rate, and the gravitational wave signal resulting from the network of cosmic strings. We demonstrate that this framework, which can explain the Standard Model fermion masses and mixing and the observed baryon asymmetry, will be highly constrained by the next generation of gravitational wave detectors and neutrino oscillation experiments which will also constrain the proton lifetime

Gravitational waves as dark sirens: an astrophysical and cosmological analysis

Despite the success of the ΛCDM model in describing the Universe, a possible tension between early- and late-Universe cosmological measurements is calling for new independent cosmological probes. Amongst the most promising ones, gravitational waves (GWs) can provide a self-calibrated measurement of the luminosity distance. However, to obtain cosmological constraints, additional information is needed to break the degeneracy between parameters in the gravitational waveform. In this thesis, we exploit the latest LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Gravitational Wave Transient Catalog (GWTC-3) of GW sources to constrain the background cosmological parameters together with the astrophysical properties of Binary Black Holes (BBHs), using information from their mass distribution. We expand the public code MGCosmoPop, previously used for the application of this technique, by implementing a state-of-the-art model for the mass distribution, needed to account for the presence of non-trivial features, i.e. a truncated power law with two additional Gaussian peaks, referred to as Multipeak. We then analyse GWTC-3 comparing this model with simpler and more commonly adopted ones, both in the case of fixed and varying cosmology, and assess their goodness-of-fit with different model selection criteria, and their constraining power on the cosmological and population parameters. We also start to explore different sampling methods, namely Markov Chain Monte Carlo and Nested Sampling, comparing their performances and evaluating the advantages of both. We find concurring evidence that the Multipeak model is favoured by the data, in line with previous results, and show that this conclusion is robust to the variation of the cosmological parameters. We find a constraint on the Hubble constant of H0 = 61.10+38.65−22.43 km/s/Mpc (68% C.L.), which shows the potential of this method in providing independent constraints on cosmological parameters. The results obtained in this work have been included in [1].

Spectral distortions of the cosmic microwave background and small-scale gravitational waves as new windows on the Early Universe

In this thesis, we explore constraints which can be put on the primordial power spectrum of curvature perturbations beyond the scales probed by anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background and galaxy surveys. We exploit present and future measurements of CMB spectral distortions, and their synergy with CMB anisotropies, as well existing and future upper limits on the stochastic background of gravitational waves. We derive for the first time phenomenological templates that fit small-scale bumps in the primordial power spectrum generated in multi-field models of inflation. By using such templates, we study for the first time imprints of primordial peaks on anisotropies and spectral distortions of the cosmic microwave background and we investigate their contribution to the stochastic background of gravitational waves. Through a Monte Carlo Markov Chain analysis we infer for the first time the constraints on the amplitude, the width and the location of such bumps using Planck and FIRAS data. We also forecast how a future spectrometer like PIXIE could improve FIRAS boundaries. The results derived in this thesis have implications for the possibility of primordial black holes from inflation.

Centrifuge modeling of earth-reinforced retaining walls

Object of this thesis has been centrifuge modelling of earth reinforced retaining walls with modular blocks facing in order to investigate on the influence of design parameters, such as length and vertical spacing of reinforcement, on the behaviour of the structure. In order to demonstrate, 11 models were tested, each one with different length of reinforcement or spacing. Each model was constructed and then placed in the centrifuge in order to artificially raise gravitational acceleration up to 35 g, reproducing the soil behaviour of a 5 metre high wall. Vertical and horizontal displacements were recorded by means of a special device which enabled tracking of deformations in the structure along its longitudinal cross section, essentially drawing its deformed shape. As expected, results confirmed reinforcement parameters to be the governing factor in the behaviour of earth reinforced structures since increase in length and spacing improved structural stability. However, the influence of the length was found out to be the leading parameter, reducing facial deformations up to five times, and the spacing playing an important role especially in unstable configurations. When failure occurred, failure surface was characterised by the same shape (circular) and depth, regardless of the reinforcement configuration. Furthermore, results confirmed the over-conservatism of codes, since models with reinforcement layers 0.4H long showed almost negligible deformations. Although the experiments performed were consistent and yielded replicable results, further numerical modelling may allow investigation on other issues, such as the influence of the reinforcement stiffness, facing stiffness and varying backfills.

Forecasts on the dark energy anisotropic stress for the esa euclid survey

The cosmological constant Λ seems to be a not satisfactory explanation of the late-time accelerated expansion of the Universe, for which a number of experimental evidences exist; therefore, it has become necessary in the last years to consider alternative models of dark energy, meant as cause of the accelerated expansion. In the study of dark energy models, it is important to understand which quantities can be determined starting from observational data, without assuming any hypothesis on the cosmological model; such quantities have been determined in Amendola, Kunz et al., 2012. In the same paper it has been further shown that it is possible to estabilish a relation between the model-independent parameters and the anisotropic stress η, which can be also expressed as a combination of the functions appearing in the most general Lagrangian for the scalar-tensor theories, the Horndeski Lagrangian. In the present thesis, the Fisher matrix formalism is used to perform a forecast on the constraints that will be possible to make on the anisotropic stress η in the future, starting from the estimated uncertainties for the galaxy clustering and weak lensing measurements which will be performed by the European Space Agency Euclid mission, to be launched in 2020. Further, constraints coming from supernovae-Ia observations are considered. The forecast is performed for two cases in which (a) η is considered as depending from redshift only and (b) η is constant and equal to one, as in the ΛCDM model.

I raggi di Einstein come strumento per la cosmologia

La Tesi presenta uno studio sulla distribuzione dei raggi di Einsten compiuta su campioni di ammassi simulati. Il codice utilizzato, MOKA, consente la costruzione di vasti campioni di ammassi in differenti cosmologie e con differenti parametri strutturali. I risultati ottenuti sono stati confrontati con quelli ottenuti dalla simulazione cosmologica N-body ad alta risoluzione MUSIC. Sono stati quindi prodotti campioni di ammassi per sette valori diversi della normalizzazione dello spettro di potenza e 7 valori diversi del parametro di densità della materia mantenendo la geometria piatta

Black hole evaporation and stress tensor correlations

General Relativity is one of the greatest scientific achievementes of the 20th century along with quantum theory. These two theories are extremely beautiful and they are well verified by experiments, but they are apparently incompatible. Hints towards understanding these problems can be derived studying Black Holes, some the most puzzling solutions of General Relativity. The main topic of this Master Thesis is the study of Black Holes, in particular the Physics of Hawking Radiation. After a short review of General Relativity, I study in detail the Schwarzschild solution with particular emphasis on the coordinates systems used and the mathematical proof of the classical laws of Black Hole "Thermodynamics". Then I introduce the theory of Quantum Fields in Curved Spacetime, from Bogolubov transformations to the Schwinger-De Witt expansion, useful for the renormalization of the stress energy tensor. After that I introduce a 2D model of gravitational collapse to study the Hawking radiation phenomenon. Particular emphasis is given to the analysis of the quantum states, from correlations to the physical implication of this quantum effect (e.g. Information Paradox, Black Hole Thermodynamics). Then I introduce the renormalized stress energy tensor. Using the Schwinger-De Witt expansion I renormalize this object and I compute it analytically in the various quantum states of interest. Moreover, I study the correlations between these objects. They are interesting because they are linked to the Hawking radiation experimental search in acoustic Black Hole models. In particular I find that there is a characteristic peak in correlations between points inside and outside the Black Hole region, which correpsonds to entangled excitations inside and outside the Black Hole. These peaks hopefully will be measurable soon in supersonic BEC.

Observability of high density tracing molecular lines in lensed galaxies with the Atacama large millimeter array

Lo scopo di questo lavoro di tesi è indagare le capacità di ALMA di osservare il continuo e le righe molecolari di emissione di HCN, HCO+ e HNC, in galassie lensate ad alto z, nelle prime fasi della loro formazione. Per farlo vengono utilizzate osservazioni ALMA di righe di emissione molecolare, relative a dati pubblici di Ciclo 0. Queste osservazioni vengono utilizzate per simulare in modo realistico l’emissione da parte di galassie ad alto z e la risposta osservativa del telescopio, assumendo diverse possibili geometrie di lensing. Inoltre le recenti osservazioni ALMA sono state utilizzate per aggiornare le relazioni già esistenti tra la luminosità FIR e la luminosità delle righe molecolari. Queste recenti osservazioni con maggiore sensibilità e risoluzione angolare, sembrano essere in buon accordo con le precedenti osservazioni. Per realizzare questo progetto di tesi, sono stati scaricati dall’archivio ALMA i dati non calibrati relativi a due sorgenti ben studiate: NGC1614, rappresentativa delle galassie di tipo starburst ed IRAS 20551-4250, un AGN oscurato. Il processo di calibrazione è stato ripetuto per esaminare le proprietà dei cubi di dati utilizzando il pacchetto Common Astronomy Software Applications (CASA). Le righe spettrali osservate e l’emissione del continuo sono state successivamente estrapolate ad alto z riscalando adeguatamente le distanze, le dimensioni delle sorgenti e le frequenze di emissione. In seguito è stato applicato un modello di lensing gravitazionale basato su quello di Lapi et al. (2012). Sono state considerate diverse configurazioni tra lente e sorgente per ottenere diverse geometrie delle immagini e diversi fattori di amplificazione. Infine stato utilizzato il software CASA per simulare le osservazioni ALMA in modo da verificare le capacità osservative del telescopio al variare della geometria del sistema. Per ogni riga molecolare e per l’emissione del continuo sono state determinate la sensibilit e la risoluzione che possono essere raggiunte con le osservazioni ALMA e sono state analizzate alcune strategie osservative per effettuare survey di righe spettrali in oggetti lensati. Inoltre stata analizzata la possibilit di caratterizzare oggetti starburst ed AGN dai rapporti tra le righe di emissione delle molecole traccianti di alta densit. Le prestazioni di ALMA consentiranno di distinguere e stimare i contributi relativi di SB ed AGN in galassie lensate a z > 2.5, quindi vicine alla loro presunta epoca di formazione (Lapi et al. 2010), in meno di 5 minuti di osservazione per qualsiasi fattore di magnificazione. Nel presente lavoro sono state inoltre discusse alcune strategie osservative per condurre survey o followup per osservare le righe di HCN(4-3), HCO+(4-3) e HNC(4-3) in galassie lensate a redshift 2.5 < z < 3, dimostrando che sono possibili per campioni statisticamente significativi in tempi relativamente brevi.

Constraining mass and shape of galaxy clusters through large scale structures

The mass estimation of galaxy clusters is a crucial point for modern cosmology, and can be obtained by several different techniques. In this work we discuss a new method to measure the mass of galaxy clusters connecting the gravitational potential of the cluster with the kinematical properties of its surroundings. We explore the dynamics of the structures located in the region outside virialized cluster, We identify groups of galaxies, as sheets or filaments, in the cluster outer region, and model how the cluster gravitational potential perturbs the motion of these structures from the Hubble fow. This identification is done in the redshift space where we look for overdensities with a filamentary shape. Then we use a radial mean velocity profile that has been found as a quite universal trend in simulations, and we fit the radial infall velocity profile of the overdensities found. The method has been tested on several cluster-size haloes from cosmological N-body simulations giving results in very good agreement with the true values of virial masses of the haloes and orientation of the sheets. We then applied the method to the Coma cluster and even in this case we found a good correspondence with previous. It is possible to notice a mass discrepancy between sheets with different alignments respect to the center of the cluster. This difference can be used to reproduce the shape of the cluster, and to demonstrate that the spherical symmetry is not always a valid assumption. In fact, if the cluster is not spherical, sheets oriented along different axes should feel a slightly different gravitational potential, and so give different masses as result of the analysis described before. Even this estimation has been tested on cosmological simulations and then applied to Coma, showing the actual non-sphericity of this cluster.

Determinazione della massa e relazione tra massa e proprietà non termiche in ammassi di galassie

Nella presente tesi, di argomento astrofisico, sono esaminati gli ammassi di galassie (galaxy clusters), ovvero gli oggetti virializzati più grandi dell’Universo. Attraverso una introduttiva analisi morfologica vengono descritte le proprietà di luminosità in banda X e radio dovute alle galassie che li compongono ed al caldo gas intergalattico (ICM IntraCluster Medium) tra queste interposto. In particolare è presa in esame l’emissione radio diffusa di natura non termica di sottostrutture del gas, note con il nome di Aloni, relitti e mini-aloni. Nei capitoli II e III l’attenzione si concentra sul non facile problema della determinazione della massa di un ammasso, proprietà che costituisce il principale oggetto di studio del presente lavoro, passando in rassegna e descrivendo i metodi più utilizzati: analisi dinamica delle galassie (equazione di Jeans ed equazione del viriale), osservazioni in banda X dell’ICM, weak lensing (WL), strong lensing (SL) ed infine WL e SL accoppiati. Una analisi critica ed un confronto tra questi metodi è sviluppata nel capitolo IV, prendendo in considerazione l’ammasso RCS2327. Il conclusivo capitolo V racchiude e collega gli argomenti delle sezioni precedenti cercando una possibile correlazione tra le proprietà emissive non termiche (in banda radio) e le masse di un campione di 28 ammassi, determinate mediante tecnica di weak lensing e strong lensing accoppiate.

Moduli stabilisation and soft supersymmetry breaking in string compactifications

In this thesis, we shall work in the framework of type IIB Calabi-Yau flux compactifications and present a detailed review of moduli stabilisation studying in particular the phenomenological implications of the LARGE-volume scenario (LVS). All the physical relevant quantities such as moduli masses and soft-terms, are computed and compared to the phenomenological constraints that today guide the research. The structure of this thesis is the following. The first chapter introduces the reader to the fundamental concepts that are essentially supersymmetry-breaking, supergravity and string moduli, which represent the basic framework of our discussion. In the second chapter we focus our attention on the subject of moduli stabilisation. Starting from the structure of the supergravity scalar potential, we point out the main features of moduli dynamics, we analyse the KKLT and LARGE-volume scenario and we compute moduli masses and couplings to photons which play an important role in the early-universe evolution since they are strictly related to the decay rate of moduli particles. The third chapter is then dedicated to the calculation of soft-terms, which arise dynamically from gravitational interactions when moduli acquire a non-zero vacuum expectation value (VeV). In the last chapter, finally, we summarize and discuss our results, underling their phenomenological aspects. Moreover, in the last section we analyse the implications of the outcomes for standard cosmology, with particular interest in the cosmological moduli problem.

Planck stars: theory and phenomenology

General Relativity (GR) is one of the greatest scientific achievements of the 20th century along with quantum theory. Despite the elegance and the accordance with experimental tests, these two theories appear to be utterly incompatible at fundamental level. Black holes provide a perfect stage to point out these difficulties. Indeed, classical GR fails to describe Nature at small radii, because nothing prevents quantum mechanics from affecting the high curvature zone, and because classical GR becomes ill-defined at r = 0 anyway. Rovelli and Haggard have recently proposed a scenario where a negative quantum pressure at the Planck scales stops and reverts the gravitational collapse, leading to an effective “bounce” and explosion, thus resolving the central singularity. This scenario, called Black Hole Fireworks, has been proposed in a semiclassical framework. The purpose of this thesis is twofold: - Compute the bouncing time by means of a pure quantum computation based on Loop Quantum Gravity; - Extend the known theory to a more realistic scenario, in which the rotation is taken into account by means of the Newman-Janis Algorithm.

Mathematical models for cellular aggregation: the chemotactic instability and clustering formation

In this thesis we present a mathematical formulation of the interaction between microorganisms such as bacteria or amoebae and chemicals, often produced by the organisms themselves. This interaction is called chemotaxis and leads to cellular aggregation. We derive some models to describe chemotaxis. The first is the pioneristic Keller-Segel parabolic-parabolic model and it is derived by two different frameworks: a macroscopic perspective and a microscopic perspective, in which we start with a stochastic differential equation and we perform a mean-field approximation. This parabolic model may be generalized by the introduction of a degenerate diffusion parameter, which depends on the density itself via a power law. Then we derive a model for chemotaxis based on Cattaneo's law of heat propagation with finite speed, which is a hyperbolic model. The last model proposed here is a hydrodynamic model, which takes into account the inertia of the system by a friction force. In the limit of strong friction, the model reduces to the parabolic model, whereas in the limit of weak friction, we recover a hyperbolic model. Finally, we analyze the instability condition, which is the condition that leads to aggregation, and we describe the different kinds of aggregates we may obtain: the parabolic models lead to clusters or peaks whereas the hyperbolic models lead to the formation of network patterns or filaments. Moreover, we discuss the analogy between bacterial colonies and self gravitating systems by comparing the chemotactic collapse and the gravitational collapse (Jeans instability).