Unconventional Catalysis in Organic Chemistry: a Computational Mechanistic Study

Catalysis plays a vital role in modern synthetic chemistry. However, even if conventional catalysis (organo-catalysis, metal-catalysis and enzyme-catalysis) has provided outstanding results, various unconventional ways to make chemical reactions more effective appear now very promising. Computational methods can be of great help to reach a deeper comprehension of these chemical processes. The methodologies employed in this thesis are Quantum-Mechanical (QM), Molecular Mechanics (MM) and hybrid Quantum-Mechanical/Molecular Mechanics (QM/MM) methods. In this abstract the results are briefly summarised. The first unconventional catalysis investigated consists in the application of Oriented External Electric Fields (OEEFs) to SN2 and 4e-electrocyclic reactions. SN2 reactions with back-side mechanism can be catalysed or inhibited by the presence of an OEEF. Moreover, OEEFs can inhibit back-side mechanism (Walden inversion of configuration) and promote the naturally unfavoured front-side mechanism (retention of configuration). Electrocyclic ring opening reaction of 3-substituted cyclobutene molecules can occur with inward or outward mechanisms depending on the nature of substituent groups on the cyclobutene structure (torquoselectivity principle). OEEFs can catalyse the naturally favoured pathway or circumvent the torquoselectivity principle leading to different stereoisomers. The second case study is based on Carbon Nanotubes (CNTs) working as nano-reactors: the reaction of ethyl chloride with chloride anion inside CNTs was investigated. In addition to the SN2 mechanism, syn and anti-E2 reactions are possible. These reactions inside CNTs of different radii were examined with hybrid QM/MM methods, finding that these processes can be both catalysed and inhibited by the CNT diameter. The results suggest that electrostatic effects govern the activation energy variations inside CNTs. Finally, a new biochemical approach, based on the use of DNA catalyst was investigated at QM level. Deoxyribozyme 9DB1 catalyses the RNA ligation allowing the regioselective formation of the 3'-5' bond, following an addition-elimination two-step mechanism.

Bioconjugation and synthetic approach towards enantioenriched gem-difluoromethylene compounds through carbenium ions

Bioconjugation of peptides and asymmetric synthesis of gem-difluoromethylene compounds are areas of the modern organic chemistry for which mild and selective methods continue to be developed. This thesis reports new methodologies for these two areas based on the use of stabilized carbenium ions. The reaction that makes the bioconjugation of peptides possible takes place via the direct nucleophilic substitution of alcohols and is driven by the spontaneous formation of stabilized carbenium ions in water. By reacting with the thiol group of cysteine in very mild conditions and with a high selectivity, these carbenium ions allow the site-specific ligation of polypeptides containing cysteine and their covalent derivatization with functionalized probes. The ligation of the indole ring of tryptophan, an emerging target in bioconjugation, is also shown and takes place in the same conditions. The second area investigated is the challenging access to optically active gem-difluoromethylene compounds. We describe a methodology relying on the synthesis of enantioenriched 1,3-benzodithioles intermediates that are shown to be precursors of the corresponding gem-difluoromethylene analogues by oxidative desulfurization-fluorination. This synthesis takes advantage of the highly enantioselective organocatalytic α-alkylation of aldehydes with the benzodithiolylium ion and of the wide possibilities of synthetic transformations offered by the 1,3-benzodithiole group. This approach allows the asymmetric access to complex gem-difluoromethylene compounds through a late-stage fluorination step, thus avoiding the use of fluorinated building blocks.

Novel developments of atropisomeric organic molecules. Design of atropisomeric drugs, fluorescent compounds and investigation of reaction mechanisms.

In recent years, the study of restricted rotation bonds in organic compounds has aroused increasing interest. The reason is that this characteristic can lead to obtaining new properties in organic compounds. In this research thesis, an intense investigation was carried out using DFT calculations and experimental evaluation of the barriers to rotational energies, in order to discover new properties deriving from the restricted rotation bonds. Research has been developed in various fields of organic chemistry, ranging from drugs (the atropisomeric atorvastatin in Chapter 3) to luminescent compounds (aryls amino borane in Chapter 4). Furthermore, an organocatalytic central to axial conversion mechanism was investigated through DFT calculations, finding out interesting outcomes (Chapter 5). Finally, a project in collaboration with Dr. Farran and Prof. Vanthuyne of the Aix-Marseille University was done to investigate the interactions in transition states of rotational barriers.

New Gold(I) complexes: from ligand design to homogeneous catalysis

This PhD thesis summarize the work carried out during three years of PhD course. Several thematic concerning gold(I) chemistry are analysed by crossing data from different chemistry areas as: organic chemistry, organometallic chemistry, inorganic chemistry and computational chemistry. In particular, the thesis focuses its attention on the evaluation of secondary electronic interactions, subsisting between ligand and Au(I) metal centre in the catalyst, and their effects on catalytic activity. The interaction that has been taken in consideration is the Au…Ar π-interaction which is known to prevent the decomposition of catalyst, but exhaustive investigations of further effects has never been done so far. New libraries of carbene (ImPy) and biarylphosphine ligands have been designed and synthetized for the purpose and subsequently utilized for the synthesis of corresponding Au(I) complexes. Resulting catalysts are tested in various catalytic processes involving different intermediates and in combination with solid state information from SC-XRD revealed an unprecedented activation mode which is only explained by considering both electronic nature and strength of Au…Ar π-interaction. DFT calculation carried on catalysis intermediates are in agreement with experimental ones, giving robustness to the theory. Moreover, a new synthetic protocol for the lactonization of N-allenyl indole-2-carboxylic acids is presented. Reaction conditions are optimized with the newly synthetized ImPy-Au(I) catalysts and different substrates are also tested providing a quite broad reaction scope. Chiral ImPy ligands have also been developed for the asymmetric variant of the same reaction and encouraging enantiomeric excess are obtained.

New catalytic strategies for the manipulation of arenes

The aim of this Doctoral Thesis is the development of new catalytic synthetic methodologies in the context of the modern organic chemistry setting, with special focus on the use of cheap, sustainable catalytic materials. Specifically, during the course my PhD, I focused my research on two main distinct catalytic strategies, namely: the use of carbonaceous materials as catalysts (carbocatalysis) and nickel catalysis, also investigating a synergistic combination of the two. These methodologies were explored as means for the manipulation of (hetero)aromatic cores, representing ubiquitous, easily accessible and privileged scaffolds in medicinal or natural products chemistry. Both polar and radical reaction manifolds were engaged as complementary reactivities, capitalizing on metal- as well as organo-based activation modes. Particular attention has been devoted to addressing modern synthetic challenges or highly sought- after methodologies. Specifically, protocols for direct substitution of alcohols, dearomatization of arene nuclei, formation of C-S bonds, carbon dioxide fixation, C-C bond activation and fluoroalkylation were successfully achieved under carbo- or nickel catalyzed conditions.

Organocatalytic asymmetric mannich-type reactions: an easy approach to optically active amine derivatives

The topics I came across during the period I spent as a Ph.D. student are mainly two. The first concerns new organocatalytic protocols for Mannich-type reactions mediated by Cinchona alkaloids derivatives (Scheme I, left); the second topic, instead, regards the study of a new approach towards the enantioselective total synthesis of Aspirochlorine, a potent gliotoxin that recent studies indicate as a highly selective and active agent against fungi (Scheme I, right). At the beginning of 2005 I had the chance to join the group of Prof. Alfredo Ricci at the Department of Organic Chemistry of the University of Bologna, starting my PhD studies. During the first period I started to study a new homogeneous organocatalytic aza-Henry reaction by means of Cinchona alkaloid derivatives as chiral base catalysts with good results. Soon after we introduced a new protocol which allowed the in situ synthesis of N-carbamoyl imines, scarcely stable, moisture sensitive compounds. For this purpose we used α-amido sulfones, bench stable white crystalline solids, as imine precursors (Scheme II). In particular we were able to obtain the aza-Henry adducts, by using chiral phase transfer catalysis, with a broad range of substituents as R-group and excellent results, unprecedented for Mannich-type transformations (Scheme II). With the optimised protocol in hand we have extended the methodology to the other Mannich-type reactions. We applied the new method to the Mannich, Strecker and Pudovik (hydrophosphonylation of imines) reactions with very good results in terms of enantioselections and yields, broadening the usefulness of this novel protocol. The Mannich reaction was certainly the most extensively studied work in this thesis (Scheme III). Initially we developed the reaction with α-amido sulfones as imine precursors and non-commercially available malonates with excellent results in terms of yields and enantioselections.3 In this particular case we recorded 1 mol% of catalyst loading, very low for organocatalytic processes. Then we thought to develop a new Mannich reaction by using simpler malonates, such as dimethyl malonate.4 With new optimised condition the reaction provided slightly lower enantioselections than the previous protocol, but the Mannich adducts were very versatile for the obtainment of β3-amino acids. Furthermore we performed the first addition of cyclic β-ketoester to α-amido sulfones obtaining the corresponding products in good yield with high level of diastereomeric and enantiomeric excess (Scheme III). Further studies were done about the Strecker reaction mediated by Cinchona alkaloid phase-transfer quaternary ammonium salt derivatives, using acetone cyanohydrin, a relatively harmless cyanide source (Scheme IV). The reaction proceeded very well providing the corresponding α-amino nitriles in good yields and enantiomeric excesses. Finally, we developed two new complementary methodologies for the hydrophosphonylation of imines (Scheme V). As a result of the low stability of the products derived from aromatic imines, we performed the reactions in mild homogeneous basic condition by using quinine as a chiral base catalyst giving the α-aryl-α-amido phosphonic acid esters as products (Scheme V, top).6 On the other hand, we performed the addition of dialkyl phosphite to aliphatic imines by using chiral Cinchona alkaloid phase transfer quaternary ammonium salt derivatives using our methodology based on α-amido sulfones (Scheme V, bottom). The results were good for both procedures covering a broad range of α-amino phosphonic acid ester. During the second year Ph.D. studies, I spent six months in the group of Prof. Steven V. Ley, at the Department of Chemistry of the University of Cambridge, in United Kingdom. During this fruitful period I have been involved in a project concerning the enantioselective synthesis of Aspirochlorine. We provided a new route for the synthesis of a key intermediate, reducing the number of steps and increasing the overall yield. Then we introduced a new enantioselective spirocyclisation for the synthesis of a chiral building block for the completion of the synthesis (Scheme VI).

Campionamento e determinazione di sostanze rilevanti per la valutazione della capacità ossidante dell’atmosfera e studio del loro effetto sui materiali ceramici

Carbonyl compounds are very important volatil organic compounds receiving increasing attention due to their critical role in tropospheric organic chemistry and to their effects on human health. They are first photo-oxidation stage of almost all organic compounds and originators of free radicals (OH, O3...). Therfore, continuous determination of their atmospheric concentrations is essential. Currently, field measurements are very limited mainly because of the analytical challenges posed by trace concentrations and interferences arising from atmospheric co-pollutants. Additionally, hydroxyl radical (OH) plays a central role in atmospheric chemistry processes. The measurement of atmospheric OH concentrations is essential for the comprehension of atmospheric chemical and photochemical processes. In this context, objectives of this work were: To perform a continuous survey of atmospheric concentrations of carbonyl compounds on different sites around the area of Bologna. For this purpose, an automatic instrument for the continuous measurement (one hour of time resolution) was developed and used. Additionally, the development of a complete and original analytical method was realised. To develop an original OH generation system in order to evaluate the effect of OH and the reactivity of solid and/or liquid materials of interest. This included the validation of an analytical method for the quantification of OH concentrations generated. Effect of OH on ceramic materials and reactivity of snow surface samples, involved as sink of OH in atmospheric chemistry, were evaluated.

Nuovi processi catalitici per la sintesi di prodotti ad attività farmacologica

The transition metal-catalyzed allylic alkylation (Tsuji-Trost type reaction) is a powerful tool for C-C, C-N, and C-O bond formation, which has been widely applied to organic chemistry over the last decades. Typical substrates for this transformation are activated allylic compounds such as halides, esters, carbonates, carbamates, phosphates, and so on. However, use of these substrates is associated with the disadvantage of generating a stoichiometric amount of chemical waste. Furthermore, these starting materials have to be prepared in an extra step from the corresponding allylic alcohol. Thus, ideal substrates would be the allylic alcohols themselves, with water being the only byproduct in this case. However, the scarse propensity of the hydroxyl moiety to act as good leaving group has significantly limited their use so far. During the last decade significant efforts have been made in order to develop more atom-economical and environmentally-friendly allylic alkylation protocols by employing allylic alcohols directly. In this PhD dissertation two main projects addressing this topic are presented. “Project 1” deals with the development of new metal-catalyzed intramolecular Friedel-Crafts (FC) allylic alkylations of electron-rich (PAPER A), as well as challenging electron-poor arenes (PAPER B) with alcohols. In “Project 2”, gold(I)-catalyzed intramolecular and stereoselective allylic alkylation reactions are reported. In particular, a FC alkylation of indole-containing allylic alcohols is presented in PAPER C. While, an O-alkylation of aminol-containing allylic alcohols is reported in PAPER D. To the best of knowledge, these reports represent the first example of gold(I)-catalyzed stereoselective alkylations with alcohols.

Enantioselective Reactions Promoted by Organocatalytic Species From The Natural Chiral Pool

During the course of my Ph.D. in the laboratories directed by Prof. Alfredo Ricci at the Department of Organic Chemistry “A. Mangini” of the University of Bologna, I was involved in the study and the application of a number of organocatalytic systems, all coming from the natural chiral pool. The first part of this thesis will be devoted to new homogeneous organocatalytic reactions promoted by Cinchona alkaloid-based organocatalysts. Quinine based catalysts were found to be a very effective catalyst for Diels-Alder reactions involving 3-vinylindoles. Excellent results in terms of yields and enantioselectivities were achieved, outlining also a remarkable organocatalytic operational mode mimicking enzymatic catalysis. The same reaction with 2-vinylindoles showed a completely different behaviour resulting in an unusual resolution-type process. The asymmetric formal [3+2] cycloaddition with in situ generated N-carbamoyl nitrones using Cinchona-derived quaternary ammonium salts as versatile catalysts under phase transfer conditions, outlines another application in organocatalysis of this class of alkaloids. During the seven months stage in the Prof. Helma Wennemers’ group at the Department of Chemistry of the University of Basel (Switzerland) I have been involved in organocatalysis promoted by oligopeptides. My contribution regarded the 1,4-addition reaction of aldehydes to nitroolefins. In the work performed at the Department of Organic Chemistry “A. Mangini” of the University of Bologna, in collaboration with the ‘Institut Charles Gerhardt-Montpellier, of Montpellier (France) the possibility of performing for the first time heterogeneous organocatalysis by using a natural polysaccharide biopolymer as the source of chirality was disclosed. With chitosan, derived from deacetylation of chitin, a highly enantioselective heterogeneous organocatalytic aldol reaction could be performed. The use of an eco-friendly medium such as water, the recyclability of the catalytic specie and the renewable nature of the polysaccharide are assets of this new approach in organocatalysis and open interesting perspectives for the use of biopolymers.

Advanced Spectroscopy for the Study of Colourants in Cultural Heritage

Colourants are substances used to change the colour of something, and are classified in three typology of colorants: a) pigments, b) dyes, and c) lakes and hybrid pigments. Their identification is very important when studying cultural heritage; it gives information about the artistic technique, can help in dating, and offers insights on the condition of the object. Besides, the study of the degradation phenomena constitutes a framework for the preventive conservation strategies, provides evidence of the object's original appearance, and contributes to the authentication of works of art. However, the complexity of these systems makes it impossible to achieve a complete understanding using a single technique, making necessary a multi-analytical approach. This work focuses on the set-up and application of advanced spectroscopic methods for the study of colourants in cultural heritage. The first chapter presents the identification of modern synthetic organic pigments using Metal Underlayer-ATR (MU-ATR), and the characterization of synthetic dyes extracted from wool fibres using a combination of Thin Layer Chromatography (TLC) coupled to MU-ATR using AgI@Au plates. The second chapter presents the study of the effect of metallic Ag in the photo-oxidation process of orpiment, and the influence of the different factors, such as light and relative humidity. We used a combination of vibrational and synchrotron radiation-based X-ray microspectroscopy techniques: µ-ATR-FT-IR, µ-Raman, SR-µ-XRF, µ-XANES at S K-, Ag L3- and As K-edges and SR-µ-XRD. The third chapter presents the study of metal carboxylates in paintings, specifically on the formation of Zn and Pb carboxylates in three different binders: stand linseed oil, whole egg, and beeswax. We used micro-ATR-FT-IR, macro FT-IR in total reflection (rMA-FT-IR), portable Near-Infrared spectroscopy (NIR), macro X-ray Powder Diffraction (MA-XRPD), XRPD, and Gas Chromatography Mass-Spectrometry (GC-MS). For the data processing, we explored the data from rMA-FT-IR and NIR with the Principal Component Analysis (PCA).

Study of medicinal and food plants as a source of biologically active compounds.

In the last few decades, scientific evidence has pointed out the health-beneficial effects of phenolic compounds in foods, including a decrease in risk of developing degenerative and chronic diseases, known to be caused by oxidative stress. In this frame can be inserted research carried out during my PhD thesis, which concerns the phytochemical investigation of phenolic composition in sweet cherries (Prunus avium L.), apple fruits (Malus domestica L.) and quinoa seeds (Chenopodium quinoa Willd.). The first project was focused on the investigation of phytochemical profile and nutraceutical value of fruits of new sweet cherry cultivars. Their phenolic profile and antioxidant activity were investigated and compared with those of commonly commercialized cultivars. Their nutraceutical value was evaluated in terms of antioxidant/neuroprotective capacity in neuron-like SH-SY5Y cells, in order to investigate their ability to counteract the oxidative stress and/or neurodegeneration process The second project was focused on phytochemical analysis of phenolic compounds in apples of ancient cultivars with the aim of selecting the most diverse cultivars, that will then be assayed for their anti-carcinogenic and anti-proliferative activities against the hepato-biliary and pancreatic tumours. The third project was focused on the analysis of polyphenolic pattern of seeds of two quinoa varieties grown at different latitudes. Analysis of phenolic profile and in vitro antioxidant activity of seed extracts both in their free and soluble-conjugated forms, showed that the accumulation of some classes of flavonoids is strictly regulated by environmental factors, even though the overall antioxidant capacity does not differ in quinoa Regalona grown in Chile and Italy. During the internship period carried out at the Department of Organic Chemistry at Universidad Autónoma de Madrid (UAM), it was achieved the isolation of two pentacyclic triterpenoids, from an endemic Peruvian plant, Jatropha macrantha Müll. Arg., with bio-guided fractionation technique.

E-cadherin and Choline Kinase: two challenging drug discovery targets

The data presented in this thesis was generated using molecular biology, protein chemistry and X-ray crystallography techniques. However, while the methodologies employed are essentially the same, the research work presented here refers to two different proteins, which are part of different research projects in the laboratory. For this reason, the content of this thesis is divided in two independent parts, each provided with an introduction and a general overview of the research topic and state-ofthe- art, a materials and methods section discussing the techniques used and the protocols followed, and a section where the results are presented and discussed in detail. The first half of the thesis deals with the structural characterization of the complex between human E-cadherin and three different small molecule potential inhibitors identified via a fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) screening campaign that was conducted using a library of commercially available small fluorinated chemical fragments. For this screening phase, we used 19F-NMR as readout. The NMR experiments were done by our collaborator Dr. Marina Veronesi at the D3 PharmaChemistry division of the Italian Institute of Technology (IIT) in Genova (Italy). Functional cell adhesion assays to validate the inhibitory effects of the fragments thus identified were carried out in collaboration with Prof. Frédéric André at the University of Marseille (France). The second half of the thesis describes the structural characterization of Plasmodium falciparum Choline Kinase (PfChoK), an important pharmaceutical target in the fight against malaria, as well as the biochemical characterization of a library of potential inhibitors of PfChoK. These inhibitors were synthetized in the group of Prof. Luisa Carlota López-Cara at the Department of Pharmaceutical and Organic Chemistry of the University of Granada (Spain) in the framework of an ongoing collaboration between the two groups.

Synthetic and mechanistic investigation of new radical processes: reaction of organic azides with group-XIII Lewis acids

Dichloroindium hydride revealed to be a valid alternative to tributyltin hydride for radical reduction of organic (alkyl, aryl, acyl, solfonyl) azides. The new approach entails mild reaction conditions and provides high yields of the corresponding amines and amides, also showing high degrees of selectivity. The system dichloroindium hydride / azides can be utilised in fivemembered ring closures of g-azidonitriles, as a new source of aminyl radicals for the attractive synthesis of interesting amidine compounds in the absence of both toxic reagents and tedious purification procedures. Allylindium dichloride seems a good substitute for dichloroindium hydride for generation of indium centred radicals under photolytic conditions, since it allows allylation of electrophilic azides (e.g. phenylsulfonyl azide) and halogen or ester δ-substituted azides, the latter through a 1,5-H transfer rearrangement mechanism. Evidences of the radical nature of the reactions mechanism were provided by ESR spectroscopy, furthermore the same technique, allowed to discover that the reaction of azides with indium trichloride and other group XIII Lewis acids, in particular gallium trichloride, gives rise to strongly coloured, persistent paramagnetic species, whose structure is consistent with the radical cation of the head-to-tail dimer of the aniline corresponding to the starting azide.