Effect of host genotype and prion strain on the phenotypic heterogeneity of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease: the peripheral nervous system involvement and the spectrum of the genetic form

The first study was designed to assess whether the involvement of the peripheral nervous system (PNS) belongs to the phenotypic spectrum of sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (sCJD). To this aim, we reviewed medical records of 117 sCJDVV2, 65 sCJDMV2K, and 121 sCJDMM(V)1 subjects for symptoms/signs and neurophysiological data. We looked for the presence of PrPSc in postmortem PNS samples from 14 subjects by western blotting and real-time quaking-induced conversion (RT-QuIC) assay. Seventy-five (41.2%) VV2-MV2K patients, but only 11 (9.1%) MM(V)1, had symptoms/signs suggestive of PNS involvement and neuropathy was documented in half of the VV2-MV2K patients tested. RT-QuIC was positive in all PNS samples, whereas western blotting detected PrPSc in the sciatic nerve in only one VV2 and one MV2K. These results support the conclusion that peripheral neuropathy, likely related to PrPSc deposition, belongs to the phenotypic spectrum of sCJDMV2K and VV2, the two variants linked to the V2 strain. The second study aimed to characterize the genetic/molecular determinants of phenotypic variability in genetic CJD (gCJD). To this purpose, we compared 157 cases of gCJD to 300 of sCJD. We analyzed: demographic aspects, neurological symptoms/signs, histopathologic features and biochemical characteristics of PrPSc. The results strongly indicated that the clinicopathological phenotypes of gCJD largely overlap with those of sCJD and that the genotype at codon 129 in cis with the mutation (i.e. haplotype) contributes more than the latter to the disease phenotype. Some mutations, however, cause phenotypic variations including haplotype-specific patterns of PrPSc deposition such as the “dense” synaptic pattern (E200K-129M), the intraneuronal dots (E200K-129V), and the linear stripes perpendicular to the surface in the molecular layer of cerebellum (OPRIs-129M). Overall, these results suggest that in gCJD PRNP mutations do not cause the emergence of novel prion strains, but rather confer increased susceptibility to the disease in conjunction with “minor” clinicopathological variations.

Integrating omics in prion diseases as a model to explore the strain paradigm in neurodegenerative diseases

This project aims at deepening the understanding of the molecular basis of the phenotypic heterogeneity of prion diseases. Prion diseases represent the first and clearest example of “protein misfolding diseases”, that are all the neurodegenerative diseases caused by the accumulation of misfolded proteins in the central nervous system. In the field of protein misfolding diseases, the term “strain” describes the heterogeneity observed among the same disease in the clinical and pathologic progression, biochemical features of the aggregated protein, conformational memory and pattern of lesions. In this work, the two most common strains of Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease (CJD), named MM1 and VV2, were analyzed. This thesis investigates the strain paradigm with the production of new multi omic data, and, on such data, appropriate computational analysis combining bioinformatics, data science and statistical approaches was performed. In this work, genomic and transcriptomic profiling allowed an improved characterization of the molecular features of the two most common strains of CJD, identifying multiple possible genetic contributors to the disease and finding several shared impaired pathways between the VV2 strain and Parkinson Disease. On the epigenomic level, the tridimensional chromatin folding in peripheral immune cells of CJD patients at onset and of healthy controls was investigated with Hi-C. While being the first application of this very advanced technology in prion diseases and one of the first in general in neurobiology, this work found a significant and diffuse loss of genomic interactions in immune cells of CJD patients at disease onset, particularly in the PRNP locus, suggesting a possible impairment of chromatin conformation in the disease. The results of this project represent a novelty in the state of the art in this field, both from a biomedical and technological point of view.

Structure determination of proteins and peptides in solution: simulation, chirality and NMR studies

The study of protein fold is a central problem in life science, leading in the last years to several attempts for improving our knowledge of the protein structures. In this thesis this challenging problem is tackled by means of molecular dynamics, chirality and NMR studies. In the last decades, many algorithms were designed for the protein secondary structure assignment, which reveals the local protein shape adopted by segments of amino acids. In this regard, the use of local chirality for the protein secondary structure assignment was demonstreted, trying to correlate as well the propensity of a given amino acid for a particular secondary structure. The protein fold can be studied also by Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) investigations, finding the average structure adopted from a protein. In this context, the effect of Residual Dipolar Couplings (RDCs) in the structure refinement was shown, revealing a strong improvement of structure resolution. A wide extent of this thesis is devoted to the study of avian prion protein. Prion protein is the main responsible of a vast class of neurodegenerative diseases, known as Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE), present in mammals, but not in avian species and it is caused from the conversion of cellular prion protein to the pathogenic misfolded isoform, accumulating in the brain in form of amiloyd plaques. In particular, the N-terminal region, namely the initial part of the protein, is quite different between mammal and avian species but both of them contain multimeric sequences called Repeats, octameric in mammals and hexameric in avians. However, such repeat regions show differences in the contained amino acids, in particular only avian hexarepeats contain tyrosine residues. The chirality analysis of avian prion protein configurations obtained from molecular dynamics reveals a high stiffness of the avian protein, which tends to preserve its regular secondary structure. This is due to the presence of prolines, histidines and especially tyrosines, which form a hydrogen bond network in the hexarepeat region, only possible in the avian protein, and thus probably hampering the aggregation.

Eterogeneità delle proprietà fisico – chimiche della proteina prionica patologica e variabilità fenotipica ceppo specifica nella malattia di Creutzfeldt – Jakob

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs), or prion diseases, are neurodegenerative disorders that affect humans and mammals. Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD), the most common TSE in humans, can be sporadic (sCJD), genetic (gCJD), or acquired by infection. All TSEs are characterised by the accumulation of PrPSc, a misfolded form of the cellular protein PrPC. PrPSc is insoluble in detergents, partially resistant to proteolysis and shows a highly enriched β-sheet secondary structure. Six clinico-pathological phenotypes of sCJD have been characterized which correlate at the molecular level with two types (1 or 2) of PrPSc with distinctive physicochemical properties and the genotype at the polymorphic (methionine or valine) codon 129 of the prion protein gene. According to the protein-only hypothesis, which postulates that prions are composed exclusively of PrPSc, the strains of prions that are largely responsible for the wide spectrum of TSE phenotypes are enciphered in PrPSc conformation. In support to this view, studies mainly conducted in experimental scrapie, have shown that several prion strains can be identified based on distinguishing PrPSc biochemical properties. To further contribute to the understanding of the molecular basis of strains and to develop more sensitive strain typing assays in humans we have analyzed PrPSc biochemical properties in two experimental setting. In the first we compared the size of the core after protease digestion and the glycoform pattern of PrPSc before and after transmission of human prions to non human primates or bank voles, whereas in the second we analyzed the conformational stability of PrPSc associated with sCJD, vCJD or fCJD using guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) as denaturant. Combining the results of the two studies, we were able to distinguish five human strains for at least one biochemical property. The present data extend our knowledge about the extent of strain variation and its relationship with PrPSc properties in human TSEs.

Agenti di encefalopatie spongiformi trasmissibili e zoonosi: tipizzazione molecolare

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE) are neurodegenerative diseases caused by the conversion of the host-encoded cellular protein (PrPC) to a disease-associated isoform (PrPSc). The agent responsible for prion diseases may exist as different strains with specific biological and biochemical properties. According to the protein-only hypothesis, prion strain diversity is enciphered in PrPSc conformation. Molecular strain typing methods are based on the electrophoretic mobility of protease resistant core of PrPSc, on the susceptibility to protease digestion, on the glycosylation profile of PrPres and on the conformational stability of PrPSc. In this study a new conformational stability assay was developed based on the differential solubility of PrPC and PrPSc: CSSA (conformational stability and solubility assay). The conformational stability assay was performed by measuring PrPSc solubility in homogenates treated with increasing concentrations of GdnHCl, in the absence of proteinase K. Indeed, dose-response curves allowed estimation of the concentration of GdnHCl able to solubilise 50% of PrPSc. The results showed that this method is valuable for the biochemical typing of strains in bank voles and it is also a promising tool for molecular analysis of natural prion isolates. CSSA also revealed strain-specific PrPSc conformational stabilities of ovine natural isolates so that this feature, combined with the N-terminal PrPSc cleavage, allowed differentiation of classical scrapie, including CH1641-like, from natural goat BSE and experimental sheep BSE. In view of the implications concerning strain similarity between animal and human TSEs, the physico-chemical properties of the Nor98 with two human prion diseases (VPSPr and GSS) were compared in order to investigate the extent of the similarity between animal and human prion strains. The results showed an unexpected heterogeneity of the molecular features among human and sheep TSEs associated with internal PrPres fragments with the possible exception of Nor98 and a case of GSS P102L. These similarities and differences need further investigation by N- and C-terminal sequencing and biological characterization.

Variabilita' ed evoluzione dei prioni: Mutabilita' in vitro

I prioni, privi di acidi nucleici, esistono come ceppi e possono mutare, in particolare quando attraversano una barriera di specie. Numerosi studi convergono sulla conclusione che le caratteristiche ceppo-specifiche siano inscritte nella conformazione della PrPSc, con la variabilità di ceppo associata a varianti conformazionali della PrPSc. In questo studio ci siamo avvalsi del PMCA, tecnica che riproduce in vitro molti aspetti della biologia dei prioni, per mettere a punto condizioni sperimentali di replicazione che permettessero di osservare fenomeni di mutazione e selezione, onde investigare i meccanismi molecolari e di popolazione alla base della mutabilità dei prioni. In condizioni di replicazione eterologa, che mima la trasmissione tra diverse specie, è stato inizialmente possibile identificare un mutante difettivo della scrapie, caratterizzato da una diversa conformazione della PrPSc e capace di replicare in vitro ma non più in vivo. Le condizioni in cui tale mutante è emerso hanno permesso di sviluppare ulteriori ipotesi di lavoro, basate sul concetto della quasi-specie. Impartendo diversi regimi di replicazione e seguendo l’evoluzione di due ceppi, è stato possibile evidenziare fenomeni di mutazione anche in condizioni di replicazione omologa, in assenza di forti pressioni selettive. In entrambi i ceppi sono emerse varianti conformazionali di PrPSc durante passaggi replicativi ad ampia popolazione, mentre le popolazioni sottoposte a ripetuti colli di bottiglia hanno mostrato un rapido declino del tasso di replicazione. Sono stati infine investigati l’efficacia e il potenziale mutageno di molecole anti-prioniche, ottenendo importanti risultati preliminari sull’efficacia di molecole che legano la PrPC. Questi risultati evidenziano come la mutabilità sia una caratteristica intrinseca dei prioni e supportano l’idea che i prioni siano molto variabili, similmente alle quasi-specie virali, e perciò adattabili e proni a fenomeni di mutazione e selezione. Tali conclusioni hanno impatto su problematiche sanitarie quali lo studio del potenziale zoonotico e i fenomeni di farmaco-resistenza dei prioni.

Skin as a promising biomatrix for the early detection of misfolded proteins by RT-QuIC in neurodegenerative diseases

Real-Time Quaking-Induced Conversion (RT-QuIC) is an ultrasensitive assay capable of detecting pathological aggregates of misfolded proteins in biospecimens. In recent years, efforts have been made to find a more feasible and convenient biomatrix as an alternative to CSF, and skin biopsy may be a suitable candidate. This project aimed to evaluate the diagnostic performance of skin RT-QuIC in 3 different cohorts of patients: 1. Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD), 2. Lewy body disease (LBD), and 3. Isolated REM sleep behavior disorder (iRBD). We studied 71 punch skin samples of 35 patients with CJD, including five assessed in vitam, using 2 two different substrates: Bank vole 23-230 (Bv23-230) and Syrian hamster 23-231 (Ha23-231) recombinant prion protein. Skin prion RT-QuIC showed a 100% specificity with both substrates and a higher sensitivity with the Bv23-230 than Ha23-231 (87.5% vs. 65.6%, respectively). Forty-one patients underwent both lumbar puncture (LB) and skin biopsy; CSF and skin RT-QuIC showed a high level of concordance (38/41, 92.7%). Then, we analyzed samples taken in vitam (n=69) or postmortem (n=49) from patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD), dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB), incidental Lewy body pathology, and neurological controls. Skin α-syn RT-QuIC distinguished LBD patients with an overall accuracy of 94.1% in the two cohorts (sensitivity, 89.2%; specificity, 96.3%). Seventy-nine patients underwent both CSF and skin α-syn RT-QuIC, and the two assays yielded similar diagnostic accuracy (skin, 97.5%; CSF, 98.7%). Finally, we studied 91 iRBD patients and 41 control. In the skin, RT-QuIC showed a sensitivity of 76.9%, specificity of 97.6%, and 82.0% accuracy. 128 participants (88 patients plus 40 controls) underwent both CSF and skin RT-QuIC. The two protocols showed 99.2% of concordance. These works confirmed that skin punch biopsies might represent a valid and convenient alternative to CSF analysis for an early diagnosis of prion diseases and LB-related pathologies.