Additive Manufacturing by LPBF and WAAM of metals: correlation between production process, microstructure and mechanical properties

In the most recent years, Additive Manufacturing (AM) has drawn the attention of both academic research and industry, as it might deeply change and improve several industrial sectors. From the material point of view, AM results in a peculiar microstructure that strictly depends on the conditions of the additive process and directly affects mechanical properties. The present PhD research project aimed at investigating the process-microstructure-properties relationship of additively manufactured metal components. Two technologies belonging to the AM family were considered: Laser-based Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) and Wire-and-Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM). The experimental activity was carried out on different metals of industrial interest: a CoCrMo biomedical alloy and an AlSi7Mg0.6 alloy processed by LPBF, an AlMg4.5Mn alloy and an AISI 304L austenitic stainless steel processed by WAAM. In case of LPBF, great attention was paid to the influence that feedstock material and process parameters exert on hardness, morphological and microstructural features of the produced samples. The analyses, targeted at minimizing microstructural defects, lead to process optimization. For heat-treatable LPBF alloys, innovative post-process heat treatments, tailored on the peculiar hierarchical microstructure induced by LPBF, were developed and deeply investigated. Main mechanical properties of as-built and heat-treated alloys were assessed and they were well-correlated to the specific LPBF microstructure. Results showed that, if properly optimized, samples exhibit a good trade-off between strength and ductility yet in the as-built condition. However, tailored heat treatments succeeded in improving the overall performance of the LPBF alloys. Characterization of WAAM alloys, instead, evidenced the microstructural and mechanical anisotropy typical of AM metals. Experiments revealed also an outstanding anisotropy in the elastic modulus of the austenitic stainless-steel that, along with other mechanical properties, was explained on the basis of microstructural analyses.

Advanced Functional Organic-Inorganic Hybrid (Nano)Materials: from Theranostics to Organic Electronics and Additive Manufacturing

This work is going to show the activities performed in the frame of my PhD studies at the University of Bologna, under the supervision of Prof. Mauro Comes Franchini, at the Department of Industrial Chemistry “Toso Montanari”. The main topic of this dissertation will be the study of organic-inorganic hybrid nanostructures and materials for advanced applications in different fields of materials technology and development such as theranostics, organic electronics and additive manufacturing, also known as 3D printing. This work is therefore divided into three chapters, that recall the fundamentals of each subject and to recap the state-of-the-art of scientific research around each topic. In each chapter, the published works and preliminary results obtained during my PhD career will be discussed in detail.

Metal additive manufacturing of soft magnetic material for electric machines

This research work concerns the application of additive manufacturing (AM) technologies in new electric mobility sectors. The unmatched freedom that AM offers can potentially change the way electric motors are designed and manufactured. The thesis investigates the possibility of creating optimized electric machines that exploit AM technologies, with potential in various industrial sectors, including automotive and aerospace. In particular, we will evaluate how the design of electric motors can be improved by producing the rotor core using Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) and how the resulting design choices affect component performance. First, the metallurgical and soft magnetic properties of the pure iron and silicon iron alloy parts (Fe-3% wt.Si) produced by LPBF will be defined and discussed, considering the process parameters and the type of heat treatment. This research shows that using LPBF, both pure iron and iron silicon, the parts have mechanical and magnetic properties different from the laminated ones. Hence, FEM-based modeling will be employed to design the rotor core of an SYN RM machine to minimize torque ripple while maintaining structural integrity. Finally, we suggest that further research should extend the field of applicability to other electrical devices.

Advanced Organic Materials: from Additive Manufacturing to Organic Electronics and Biomedical Applications

This manuscript represents an overview on the studies I was involved in during my PhD at the Industrial Chemistry Department “Toso Montanari”, in the ASOM (Advanced Smart Organic Materials) research group under the supervision of Prof. Letizia Sambri and Prof. Mauro Comes Franchini. Those research have been focused on the development of organic materials for advanced applications in different fields, among which organic electronics, additive manufacturing (3D Printing) and biomedical applications can be underlined.

Production and characterization of novel thermoplastic (nano)composite materials for additive manufacturing applications

The increasing environmental global regulations have directed scientific research towards more sustainable materials, even in the field of composite materials for additive manufacturing. In this context, the presented research is devoted to the development of thermoplastic composites for FDM application with a low environmental impact, focusing on the possibility to use wastes from different industrial processes as filler for the production of composite filaments for FDM 3D printing. In particular carbon fibers recycled by pyro-gasification process of CFRP scraps were used as reinforcing agent for PLA, a biobased polymeric matrix. Since the high value of CFs, the ability to re-use recycled CFs, replacing virgin ones, seems to be a promising option in terms of sustainability and circular economy. Moreover, wastes from different agricultural industries, i.e. wheat and rice production processes, were valorised and used as biofillers for the production of PLA-biocomposites. The integration of these agricultural wastes into PLA bioplastic allowed to obtain biocomposites with improved eco-sustainability, biodegradability, lightweight, and lower cost. Finally, the study of novel composites for FDM was extended towards elastomeric nanocomposite materials, in particular TPU reinforced with graphene. The research procedure of all projects involves the optimization of production methods of composite filaments with a particular attention on the possible degradation of polymeric matrices. Then, main thermal properties of 3D printed object are evaluated by TGA, DSC characterization. Additionally, specific heat capacity (CP) and Coefficient of Linear Thermal Expansion (CLTE) measurements are useful to estimate the attitude of composites for the prevention of typical FDM issues, i.e. shrinkage and warping. Finally, the mechanical properties of 3D printed composites and their anisotropy are investigated by tensile test using distinct kinds of specimens with different printing angles with respect to the testing direction.

Development and application of a computer-based methodology for design for additive manufacturing of automotive components

The research project aims to improve the Design for Additive Manufacturing of metal components. Firstly, the scenario of Additive Manufacturing is depicted, describing its role in Industry 4.0 and in particular focusing on Metal Additive Manufacturing technologies and the Automotive sector applications. Secondly, the state of the art in Design for Additive Manufacturing is described, contextualizing the methodologies, and classifying guidelines, rules, and approaches. The key phases of product design and process design to achieve lightweight functional designs and reliable processes are deepened together with the Computer-Aided Technologies to support the approaches implementation. Therefore, a general Design for Additive Manufacturing workflow based on product and process optimization has been systematically defined. From the analysis of the state of the art, the use of a holistic approach has been considered fundamental and thus the use of integrated product-process design platforms has been evaluated as a key element for its development. Indeed, a computer-based methodology exploiting integrated tools and numerical simulations to drive the product and process optimization has been proposed. A validation of CAD platform-based approaches has been performed, as well as potentials offered by integrated tools have been evaluated. Concerning product optimization, systematic approaches to integrate topology optimization in the design have been proposed and validated through product optimization of an automotive case study. Concerning process optimization, the use of process simulation techniques to prevent manufacturing flaws related to the high thermal gradients of metal processes is developed, providing case studies to validate results compared to experimental data, and application to process optimization of an automotive case study. Finally, an example of the product and process design through the proposed simulation-driven integrated approach is provided to prove the method's suitability for effective redesigns of Additive Manufacturing based high-performance metal products. The results are then outlined, and further developments are discussed.

IDeS methodology applied to automotive component re-engineering focused on lightweight and high-strength by additive manufacturing

The project aims to gather an understanding of additive manufacturing and other manufacturing 4.0 techniques with an eyesight for industrialization. First the internal material anisotropy of elements created with the most economically feasible FEM technique was established. An understanding of the main drivers for variability for AM was portrayed, with the focus on achieving material internal isotropy. Subsequently, a technique for deposition parameter optimization was presented, further procedure testing was performed following other polymeric materials and composites. A replicability assessment by means of the use of technology 4.0 was proposed, and subsequent industry findings gathered the ultimate need of developing a process that demonstrate how to re-engineer designs in order to show the best results with AM processing. The latest study aims to apply the Industrial Design and Structure Method (IDES) and applying all the knowledge previously stacked into fully reengineer a product with focus of applying tools from 4.0 era, from product feasibility studies, until CAE – FEM analysis and CAM – DfAM. These results would help in making AM and FDM processes a viable option to be combined with composites technologies to achieve a reliable, cost-effective manufacturing method that could also be used for mass market, industry applications.

Sviluppo di un framework per l'automazione dei test al banco e la prototipazione di algoritmi di controllo di motori a combustione interna

Negli ultimi anni, i limiti sempre più stringenti sulle emissioni inquinanti dei gas di scarico, hanno portato ad un notevole aumento della complessità dei motori a combustione interna. Questa complicazione determina un aumento esponenziale del numero di test da effettuare nella sala prova. I metodi tipici di gestione dei test non possono più essere utilizzati, ma è essenziale creare un sistema che ottimizzi le prove. Per ridurre drasticamente il tempo di esecuzione, è necessario implementare un'architettura in grado di facilitare lo scambio di dati tra i sistemi presenti nella sala prova, e, in aggiunta, definire le strategie di automazione dei test. L'approccio a taluni metodi si presenta ancora complicato in molti gruppi di sviluppo di strategie di controllo motore, anche se, una volta sviluppati, portano e a grandi benefici durante la fase di test. Il lavoro illustra i metodi implementati per la gestione di queste strategie. Prima si descrive l'approccio utilizzato nella calibrazione di anticipo di accensione per mantenere livelli accettabili di detonazione durante il processo di calibrazione. Successivamente è mostrato il sistema di automazione dei test che consente il pieno controllo del punto di funzionamento del motore, la gestione dell'acquisizione e la verifica della stabilità delle condizioni ottenute. L'ultima parte mostra sistemi di prototipazione rapida per la gestione di componenti innovatici del motore.

Sviluppo di impianti ceramici biomimetici a porosità controllata per la rigenerazione del tessuto osseo

La presente ricerca si inquadra nell’ambito della risoluzione dei problemi legati alla chirurgia ossea, per la cura e la sostituzione di parti di osso in seguito a fratture, lesioni gravi, malformazioni e patologie quali osteoporosi, tumori, etc… Attualmente la progettazione di impianti per le sostituzioni/rigenerazioni ossee richiede che i materiali sviluppati siano in grado di “mimare” la composizione e la morfologia dei tessuti naturali, in modo da generare le specifiche interazioni chimiche esistenti nei tessuti dell’organismo con cui vengono a contatto e quindi di biointegrarsi e/o rigenerare l’osso mancante nel miglior modo possibile, in termini qualitativi e quantitativi. Per lo sviluppo di sostituti ossei porosi sono state sperimentate 2 tecnologie innovative: il freeze-casting ed il foaming. Gli impianti ceramici realizzati hanno presentano una dimensione dei pori ed un’interconnessione adeguata sia per l’abitazione cellulare che per la penetrazione dei fluidi fisiologici e la vascolarizzazione. In particolare l’elevata unidirezionalità nei campioni ottenuti mediante freeze-casting si presenta molto promettente poiché fornisce cammini guida che migliorano la vascolarizzazione dell’impianto e l’abitazione cellulare in tempi rapidi e nella parte più interna dello scaffold. D’altra parte, la tecnologia del foaming ha permesso l’ottenimento di materiali apatitici ad alta porosità multidimensionale ed interconnessa con proprietà meccaniche implementate rispetto a tipologie precedenti e, lavorabili dopo sinterizzazione mediante prototipazione rapida. Per questo motivo, questi materiali sono attualmente in corso di sperimentazione, con risultati preliminari adeguati promettenti per un’applicazione clinica, come sostituti ossei di condilo mandibolare, sito estremamente critico per gli sforzi meccanici presenti. È stata dimostrata la possibilità di utilizzare lo scaffold ceramico biomimetico con la duplice funzione di sostituto osseo bioattivo e sistema di rilascio in situ di ioni specifici e di antibiotico, in cui la cinetica di rilascio risulta fortemente dipendente dalle caratteristiche chimico-fisico morfologiche del dispositivo (solubilità, area di superficie specifica,…). Per simulare sempre di più la composizione del tessuto osseo e per indurre specifiche proprietà funzionali, è stata utilizzata la gelatina come fase proteica con cui rivestire/impregnare dispositivi porosi 3D a base di apatite, con cui miscelare direttamente la fase inorganica calcio-fosfatica e quindi realizzare materiali bio-ibridi in cui le due fasi contenenti siano intimamente interagenti. Inoltre al fine di ridurre gli innumerevoli problemi legati alle infezioni ossee alcuni dei materiali sviluppati sono stati quindi caricati con antibiotico e sono state valutate le cinetiche di rilascio. In questa maniera, nel sito dell’impianto sono state associate le funzioni di trasporto e di rilascio di farmaco, alla funzione di sostituzione/rigenerazione ossee. La sperimentazione con la gelatina ha messo in luce proprietà posatamente sfruttabili della stessa. Oltre a conferire allo scaffold un implementata mimesi composizionale del tessuto osseo, ha infatti consentito di aumentare le proprietà meccaniche, sia come resistenza a compressione che deformazione. Unitamente a quanto sopra, la gelatina ha consentito di modulare la funzionalità di dispensatore di farmaco; mediante controllo della cinetica di rilascio, tramite processi di reticolazione più o meno spinti.

Studio e ottimizzazione del processo di fabbricazione additiva (SLM) per applicazioni in ambito biomedicale: produzione di protesi e strutture reticolari

Il progetto di dottorato che verrà presentato in questa tesi è focalizzato sullo sviluppo di un metodo sperimentale per la produzione di protesi personalizzate utilizzando il processo di fabbricazione additiva di Selective Laser Melting (SLM). L’obiettivo è quello di definire una condizione di processo ottimizzata per applicazioni in ambito chirurgico che possa essere generalizzabile, ovvero che ne garantisca la riproducibilità al variare dell’anatomia del paziente e che rappresenti la base per estendere il metodo ad altre componenti protesiche. Il lavoro si è sviluppato lungo due linee principali, la cui convergenza ha permesso di realizzare prototipi di protesi complete utilizzando un solo processo: da una parte la produzione di componenti a massima densità per il raggiungimento di elevate resistenze meccaniche, buona resistenza ad usura e corrosione e controllo di tensioni residue e deformazione delle parti stampate. Dall’altra si sono studiate strutture reticolari a geometria e porosità controllata per favorire l’osteointegrazione della componente protesica post impianto. In questo studio sono stati messe a confronto le possibili combinazioni tra parametri di processo e sono state individuate le correlazioni con le proprietà finali dei componenti stampati. Partendo da queste relazioni si sono sviluppate le strategie tecnologiche per la progettazione e la produzione dei componenti. I test sperimentali svolti e i risultati ottenuti hanno dimostrato la fattibilità dell’utilizzo del processo SLM per la produzione di protesi personalizzate e sono stati fabbricati i primi prototipi funzionali. La fabbricazione di protesi personalizzate richiede, però, anche la progettazione e la produzione di strumentario chirurgico ad hoc. Per questo motivo, parallelamente allo studio della lega di Cromo Cobalto, sono stati eseguiti i test anche su campioni in INOX 316L. Anche in questo caso è stato possibile individuare una finestra operativa di processo che garantisse proprietà meccaniche comparabili, e in alcuni casi superiori, a quelle ottenute con processi convenzionali.

Advanced voxel-based CAD modelling for FSI simulations for automotive structures design

Additive Manufacturing (AM) is nowadays considered an important alternative to traditional manufacturing processes. AM technology shows several advantages in literature as design flexibility, and its use increases in automotive, aerospace and biomedical applications. As a systematic literature review suggests, AM is sometimes coupled with voxelization, mainly for representation and simulation purposes. Voxelization can be defined as a volumetric representation technique based on the model’s discretization with hexahedral elements, as occurs with pixels in the 2D image. Voxels are used to simplify geometric representation, store intricated details of the interior and speed-up geometric and algebraic manipulation. Compared to boundary representation used in common CAD software, voxel’s inherent advantages are magnified in specific applications such as lattice or topologically structures for visualization or simulation purposes. Those structures can only be manufactured with AM employment due to their complex topology. After an accurate review of the existent literature, this project aims to exploit the potential of the voxelization algorithm to develop optimized Design for Additive Manufacturing (DfAM) tools. The final aim is to manipulate and support mechanical simulations of lightweight and optimized structures that should be ready to be manufactured with AM with particular attention to automotive applications. A voxel-based methodology is developed for efficient structural simulation of lattice structures. Moreover, thanks to an optimized smoothing algorithm specific for voxel-based geometries, a topological optimized and voxelized structure can be transformed into a surface triangulated mesh file ready for the AM process. Moreover, a modified panel code is developed for simple CFD simulations using the voxels as a discretization unit to understand the fluid-dynamics performances of industrial components for preliminary aerodynamic performance evaluation. The developed design tools and methodologies perfectly fit the automotive industry’s needs to accelerate and increase the efficiency of the design workflow from the conceptual idea to the final product.

Optimization of an innovative T6 heat treatment for the AlSi10Mg alloy processed by Laser-based Powder Bed Fusion: effect on microstructure, mechanical properties, and tribological behavior

Laser-based Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) technology is one of the most commonly used metal Additive Manufacturing (AM) techniques to produce highly customized and value-added parts. The AlSi10Mg alloy has received more attention in the L-PBF process due to its good printability, high strength/weight ratio, corrosion resistance, and relatively low cost. However, a deep understanding of the effect of heat treatments on this alloy's metastable microstructure is still required for developing tailored heat treatments for the L-PBF AlSi10Mg alloy to overcome the limits of the as-built condition. Several authors have already investigated the effects of conventional heat treatment on the microstructure and mechanical behavior of the L-PBF AlSi10Mg alloy but often overlooked the peculiarities of the starting supersatured and ultrafine microstructure induced by rapid solidification. For this reason, the effects of innovative T6 heat treatment (T6R) on the microstructure and mechanical behavior of the L-PBF AlSi10Mg alloy were assessed. The short solution soaking time (10 min) and the relatively low temperature (510 °C) reduced the typical porosity growth at high temperatures and led to a homogeneous distribution of fine globular Si particles in the Al matrix. In addition, it increased the amount of Mg and Si in the solid solution available for precipitation hardening during the aging step. The mechanical (at room temperature and 200 °C) and tribological properties of the T6R alloy were evaluated and compared with other solutions, especially with an optimized direct-aged alloy (T5 alloy). Results showed that the innovative T6R alloy exhibits the best mechanical trade-off between strength and ductility, the highest fatigue strength among the analyzed conditions, and interesting tribological behavior. Furthermore, the high-temperature mechanical performances of the heat-treated L-PBF AlSi10Mg alloy make it suitable for structural components operating in mild service conditions at 200 °C.

Numerical simulation of the flow and performance evaluation of an aerospike engine

The main focus of this work is to define a numerical methodology to simulate an aerospike engine and then to analyse the performance of DemoP1, which is a small aerospike demonstrator built by Pangea Aerospace. The aerospike is a promising solution to build more efficient engine than the actual one. Its main advantage is the expansion adaptation that allows to reach the optimal expansion in a wide range of ambient pressures delivering more thrust than an equivalent bell-shaped nozzle. The main drawbacks are the cooling system design and the spike manufacturing but nowadays, these issues seem to be overcome with the use of the additive manufacturing method. The simulations are performed with dbnsTurbFoam which is a solver of OpenFOAM. It has been designed to simulate a supersonic compressible turbulent flow. This work is divided in four chapters. The first one is a short introduction. The second one shows a brief summary of the theoretical performance of the aerospike. The third one introduces the numerical methodology to simulate a compressible supersonic flow. In the fourth chapter, the solver has been verified with an experiment found in literature. And in the fifth chapter, the simulations on DemoP1 engine are illustrated.

Toward a peripheral view of manufacturing networks

This doctoral thesis unfolds into a collection of three distinct articles that share an interest in supply firms, or “peripheral firms”. The three studies offer a novel theoretical perspective that I call the peripheral view of manufacturing networks. Building on the relational view literature, this new perspective identifies the supplier-based theoretical standpoint to analyze and explain the antecedents of relational rents in manufacturing networks. The first article, the namesake of the dissertation, is a theoretical contribution that explains the foundations of the “peripheral view of manufacturing networks”. The second article “Framing The Strategic Peripheries: A Novel Typology of Suppliers” is an empirical study with the aim to offer an interpretation of peripheries’ characteristics and dynamics. The third article, “What is Behind Absorptive Capacity? Dispelling the Opacity of R&D” presents an example of general theory development by using data from peripheral firms.

Discrete Event Systems based Design Patterns for Diagnosability Analysis of Automated Manufacturing Systems

The main goal of this thesis is to facilitate the process of industrial automated systems development applying formal methods to ensure the reliability of systems. A new formulation of distributed diagnosability problem in terms of Discrete Event Systems theory and automata framework is presented, which is then used to enforce the desired property of the system, rather then just verifying it. This approach tackles the state explosion problem with modeling patterns and new algorithms, aimed for verification of diagnosability property in the context of the distributed diagnosability problem. The concepts are validated with a newly developed software tool.