Food Safety and Mineral Oil Contaminated Paperboard Packaging: an Analytical Challenge and a Migration Study

Food packaging protects food, but it can sometimes become a source of undesired contaminants. Paper based materials, despite being perceived as “natural” and safe, can contain volatile contaminants (especially if made from recycled paper) able to migrate to food, as mineral oil, phthalates and photoinitiators. Mineral oil is a petroleum product used as printing ink solvent for newspapers, magazines and packaging. From paperboard printing and from recycled fibers (if present), mineral oil migrates into food, even if dry, through the gas phase. Its toxicity is not fully evaluated, but a temporary Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI) of 0.6 mg kg-1 has been established for saturated mineral oil hydrocarbons (MOSH), while aromatic hydrocarbons (MOAH) are more toxic. Extraction and analysis of MOSH and MOAH is difficult due to the thousands of molecules present. Extraction methods for packaging and food have been optimized, then applied for a “shopping trolley survey” on over 100 Italian and Swiss market products. Instrumental analyses were performed with online LC-GC/FID. Average concentration of MOSH in paperboards was 626 mg kg-1. Many had the potential of contaminating foods exceeding temporary ADI tens of times. A long term migration study was then designed to better understand migration kinetics. Egg pasta and müesli were chosen as representative (high surface/weight ratio). They were stored at different temperatures (4, 20, 30, 40 and 60°C) and conditions (free, shelved or boxed packs) for 1 year. MOSH and MOAH kinetic curves show that migration is a fast process, mostly influenced by temperature: in egg pasta (food in direct contact with paperboard), half of MOSH is transferred to food in a week at 40°C and in 8 months at 20°C. The internal plastic bag present in müesli slowed down the startup of migration, creating a “lag time” in the curves.

Advanced solutions for authenticity and quality of virgin olive oils

This Ph.D. project aimed to the development and improvement of analytical solutions for control of quality and authenticity of virgin olive oils. According to this main objective, different research activities were carried out: concerning the quality control of olive oil, two of the official parameters defined by regulations (free acidity and fatty acid ethyl esters) were taken into account, and more sustainable and easier analytical solutions were developed and validated in-house. Regarding authenticity, two different issues were faced: verification of the geographical origin of extra virgin (EVOOs) and virgin olive oils (VOOs), and assessment of soft-deodorized oils illegally mixed with EVOOs. About fatty acid ethyl esters, a revised method based on the application of off-line HPLC-GC-FID (with PTV injector), revising both the preparative phase and the GC injector required in the official method, was developed. Next, the method was in-house validated evaluating several parameters. Concerning free acidity, a portable system suitable for in-situ measurements of VOO free acidity was developed and in-house validated. Its working principle is based on the estimation of the olive oil free acidity by measuring the conductance of an emulsion between a hydro-alcoholic solution and the sample to be tested. The procedure is very quick and easy and, therefore, suitable for people without specific training. Another study developed during the Ph.D. was about the application of flash gas chromatography for volatile compounds analysis, combined with untargeted chemometric data elaborations, for discrimination of EVOOs and VOOs of different geographical origin. A set of 210 samples coming from different EU member states and extra-EU countries were collected and analyzed. Data were elaborated applying two different classification techniques, one linear (PLS-DA) and one non-linear (ANN). Finally, a preliminary study about the application of GC-IMS (Gas Chromatograph - Ion Mobility Spectrometer) for assessment of soft-deodorized olive oils was carried out.

Identification of sunflower genotypes suitable for organic agriculture and development of analytical tools for their traceability

Thanks to the development and combination of molecular markers for the genetic traceability of sunflower varieties and a gas chromatographic method for the determination of the FAs composition of sunflower oil, it was possible to implement an experimental method for the verification of both the traceability and the variety of organic sunflower marketed by Agricola Grains S.p.A. The experimental activity focused on two objectives: the implementation of molecular markers for the routine control of raw material deliveries for oil extraction and the improvement and validation of a gas chromatographic method for the determination of the FAs composition of sunflower oil. With regard to variety verification and traceability, the marker systems evaluated were the following: SSR markers (12) arranged in two multiplex sets and SCAR markers for the verification of cytoplasmic male sterility (Pet1) and fertility. In addition, two objectives were pursued in order to enable a routine application in the industrial field: the development of a suitable protocol for DNA extraction from single seeds and the implementation of a semi-automatic capillary electrophoresis system for the analysis of marker fragments. The development and validation of a new GC/FID analytical method for the determination of fatty acids (FAME) in sunflower achenes to improve the quality and efficiency of the analytical flow in the control of raw and refined materials entering the Agricola Grains S.p.A. production chain. The analytical performances being validated by the newly implemented method are: linearity of response, limit of quantification, specificity, precision, intra-laboratory precision, robustness, BIAS. These parameters are used to compare the newly developed method with the one considered as reference - Commission Regulation No. 2568/91 and Commission Implementing Regulation No. 2015/1833. Using the combination of the analytical methods mentioned above, the documentary traceability of the product can be confirmed experimentally, providing relevant information for subsequent marketing.