Biological analysis of the in-vitro effects of homologous recombination inhibition and its use in cancer treatment through synthetic lethality

Synthetic lethality represents an anticancer strategy that targets tumor specific gene defects. One of the most studied application is the use of PARP inhibitors (e.g. olaparib) in BRCA1/2-less cancer cells. In BRCA2-defective tumors, olaparib (OLA) inhibits DNA single-strand break repair, while BRCA2 mutations hamper homologous recombination (HR) repair. The simultaneous impairment of those pathways leads BRCA-less cells to death by synthetic lethality. The projects described in this thesis were aimed at extending the use of OLA in cancer cells that do not carry a mutation in BRCA2 by combining this drug with compounds that could mimic a BRCA-less environment via HR inhibition. We demonstrated the effectiveness of our “fully small-molecule induced synthetic lethality” by using two different approaches. In the direct approach (Project A), we identified a series of neo-synthesized compounds (named RAD51-BRCA2 disruptors) that mimic BRCA2 mutations by disrupting the RAD51-BRCA2 interaction and thus the HR pathway. Compound ARN 24089 inhibited HR in human pancreatic adenocarcinoma cell line and triggered synthetic lethality by synergizing with OLA. Interestingly, the observed synthetic lethality was triggered by tackling two biochemically different mechanisms: enzyme inhibition (PARP) and protein-protein disruption (RAD51-BRCA2). In the indirect approach (Project B), we inhibited HR by interfering with the cellular metabolism through inhibition of LDH activity. The obtained data suggest an LDH-mediated control on HR that can be exerted by regulating either the energy supply needed to this repair mechanism or the expression level of genes involved in DNA repair. LDH inhibition also succeeded in increasing the efficiency of OLA in BRCA-proficient cell lines. Although preliminary, these results highlight a complex relationship between metabolic reactions and the control of DNA integrity. Both the described projects proved that our “fully small-molecule-induced synthetic lethality” approach could be an innovative approach to unmet oncological needs.

Liquid biopsy for prostate cancer molecular characterization: homologous recombination system and genomic profile

Pathogenic aberrations in homologous recombination DNA repair (HRR) genes occur in approximately 1 to 4 men with advanced prostate cancer (PCa). Treatment with PARP inhibitors (PARPi) has recently been introduced for metastatic castration-resistant PCa patients, increasing clinicians' interest in the molecular characterization of all PCa patients. The limitations of using old, low-quality tumor tissue for genetic analysis, which is very common for PCa, can be overcome by using liquid biopsy as an alternative biomarker source. In this study, we aimed to evaluate the detection of molecular alterations in HRR genes on liquid biopsy compared with tumor tissue from PCa patients. Secondarily, we explored the genomic instability score (GIS), and a broader range of gene alterations for in-depth characterization of the PCa cohort. Plasma samples were collected from 63 patients with PCa. Sophia Homologous Recombination Solution (targeting 16 HRR genes) and shallow whole genome sequencing (sWGS) were used for genomic analysis of tissue DNA and circulating tumor DNA (ct). A total of 33 alterations (mainly on TP53, ATM, CHEK2, CDK12, and BRCA1/2) were identified in 28,5% of PCa plasma patients. By integrating the mutational and sWGS data, the HRR status of PCa patients was determined and a concordance agreement of 85,7% was identified with tumor tissue. A median GIS of 15 was obtained, reaching a score of 63 in 2 samples with double alterations, BRCA1 and TP53. We explored the PCa mutation landscape, and the most significant enriched pathways identified were the sphingosine 1-phosphate (S1P) receptor signaling and the PI3K-AKT-mTOR pathway. HRR analysis on FFPE and liquid biopsy samples show high concordance, demonstrating that the noninvasive ctDNA-enriched plasma can be an optimal alternative source for molecular SNV and CNV analysis. In addition, the evaluation of GIS and pathway interaction should be considered for more comprehensive molecular characterization in PCa patients.

Unveiling the molecular mechanism of BRCA2-RAD51 interaction to tackle cancer onset

Different kinds of lesions can occur to DNA, and among them, one of the most dangerous is the double strand breaks (DSBs). Actually, DSBs can result in mutations, chromosome translocation or deletion. For this kind of lesions, depending on cell cycle phase as well as DNA-end resection, cells have developed specific repair pathways. Among these the error-free homologous recombination (HR) plays a crucial role. HR takes place during S/G2 phases, since the sister chromatids can be used as homologous templates. In this process, hRAD51 and BRCA2 are key players. hRAD51 is a recombinase of 339 amino-acids highly conserved through evolution which displays an intrinsic tendency to form oligomeric structures. BRCA2 is a very large protein of 3418 amino-acids, essential for the recruitment and accumulation of hRAD51 in the nucleus repairing-foci. BRCA2 interacts with hRAD51 through eight, so-called, BRC repeats, composed of 35-40 amino-acids. Mutations within this region have been linked to an increased risk of ovarian cancer development. In particular, several reports highlighted that missense mutations within one BRC repeat can hamper BRCA2 activity. Considering the close homology between the BRC repeats, it is striking how these mutations cannot be counterbalanced by the other non-mutated repeats preserving the function and the interactions of BRCA2 with hRAD51. To date the only interaction that has been structurally elucidated, is the one taking place amid the fourth BRC repeat and hRAD51. Only very little biophysical information is available on the interaction of the other BRC repeats with hRAD51. This thesis aims at elucidating the mechanism of hRAD51-BRCA2 interaction, by means of biophysical and structural approaches.