What are the components that contribute to variability in echocardiographic measurements in aortic stenosis?

INTRODUCTION Echocardiography is the standard clinical approach for quantification of the severity of aortic stenosis (AS). A comprehensive examination of its overall reproducibility and the simultaneous estimation of its variance components by multiple operators, readers, probe applications, and beats have not been undertaken. METHOD AND RESULTS Twenty-seven subjects with AS were scanned over 7 months in the echo-department by a median of 3 different operators. From each patient and each operator multiple runs of beats from multiple probe positions were stored for later analysis by multiple readers. The coefficient of variation was 13.3%, 15.9%, 17.6%, and 20.2% for the aortic peak velocity (Vmax), and velocity time integral (VTI), and left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) Vmax and VTI respectively. The largest individual contributors to the overall variability were the beat-to-beat variability (9.0%, 9.3%, 9.5%, 9.4% respectively) and that of inability of an individual operator to precisely apply the probe to the same position twice (8.3%, 9.4%, 12.9%, 10.7% respectively). The tracing (inter-reader) and reader (inter-reader), and operator (inter-operator) contribution were less important. CONCLUSIONS Reproducibility of measurements in AS is poorer than often reported in the literature. The source of this variability does not appear, as traditionally believed, to result from a lack of training or operator and reader specific factors. Rather the unavoidable beat-to-beat biological variability, and the inherent impossibility of applying the ultrasound probe in exactly the same position each time are the largest contributors. Consequently, guidelines suggesting greater standardisation of procedures and further training for sonographers are unlikely to result in an improvement in precision. Clinicians themselves should be wary of relying on even three-beat averages as their expected coefficient of variance is 10.3% for the peak velocity at the aortic valve.

A simple voltage/mass index increases the suspicion of amyloidotic cardiomyopathy: an electrocardiographic and echocardiographic study of 767 patients with increased left ventricular wall thickness due to different causes

Background-Amyloidotic cardiomyopathy (AC) can mimic true left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH), including hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) and hypertensive heart disease (HHD). We assessed the diagnostic value of combined electrocardiographic/echocardiographic indexes to identify AC among patients with increased echocardiographic LV wall thickness due to either different etiologies of amyloidosis or HCM or HHD. Method-First, we studied 469 consecutive patients: 262 with biopsy/genetically proven AC (with either AL or transthyretin (TTR)-related amyloidosis); 106 with HCM; 101 with HHD. We compared the diagnostic performance of: low QRS voltage, symmetric LVH, low QRS voltage plus interventricular septal thickness >1.98 cm, Sokolow index divided by the cross-sectional area of LV wall, Sokolow index divided by body surface area indexed LV mass (LVMI), Sokolow index divided by LV wall thickness, Sokolow index divided by (LV wall/height^2.7); peripheral QRS score divided by LVMI, Peripheral QRS score divided by LV wall thickness, Peripheral QRS score divided by LV wall thickness indexed to height^2.7, total QRS score divided by LVMI, total QRS score divided by LV wall thickness; total QRS score divided by (LV wall/height^2.7). We tested each criterion, separately in males and females, in the following settings: AC vs. HCM+HHD; AC vs. HCM; AL vs. HCM+HHD; AL vs. HCM; TTR vs. HCM+HHD; TTR vs. HCM. Results-Low QRS voltage showed high specificity but low sensitivity for the identification of AC. All the combined indexes had a higher diagnostic accuracy, being total QRS score divided by LV wall thickness or by LVMI associated with the best performances and the largest areas under the ROC curve. These results were validated in 298 consecutive patients with AC, HCM or HHD. Conclusions-In patients with increased LV wall thickness, a combined ECG/ echocardiogram analysis provides accurate indexes to non-invasively identify AC. Total QRS score divided by LVMI or LV wall thickness offers the best diagnostic performance.

Parameters and algorithms to evaluate cardiac mechanics by conductance catheter

This work is structured as follows: In Section 1 we discuss the clinical problem of heart failure. In particular, we present the phenomenon known as ventricular mechanical dyssynchrony: its impact on cardiac function, the therapy for its treatment and the methods for its quantification. Specifically, we describe the conductance catheter and its use for the measurement of dyssynchrony. At the end of the Section 1, we propose a new set of indexes to quantify the dyssynchrony that are studied and validated thereafter. In Section 2 we describe the studies carried out in this work: we report the experimental protocols, we present and discuss the results obtained. Finally, we report the overall conclusions drawn from this work and we try to envisage future works and possible clinical applications of our results. Ancillary studies that were carried out during this work mainly to investigate several aspects of cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) are mentioned in Appendix. -------- Ventricular mechanical dyssynchrony plays a regulating role already in normal physiology but is especially important in pathological conditions, such as hypertrophy, ischemia, infarction, or heart failure (Chapter 1,2.). Several prospective randomized controlled trials supported the clinical efficacy and safety of cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) in patients with moderate or severe heart failure and ventricular dyssynchrony. CRT resynchronizes ventricular contraction by simultaneous pacing of both left and right ventricle (biventricular pacing) (Chapter 1.). Currently, the conductance catheter method has been used extensively to assess global systolic and diastolic ventricular function and, more recently, the ability of this instrument to pick-up multiple segmental volume signals has been used to quantify mechanical ventricular dyssynchrony. Specifically, novel indexes based on volume signals acquired with the conductance catheter were introduced to quantify dyssynchrony (Chapter 3,4.). Present work was aimed to describe the characteristics of the conductancevolume signals, to investigate the performance of the indexes of ventricular dyssynchrony described in literature and to introduce and validate improved dyssynchrony indexes. Morevoer, using the conductance catheter method and the new indexes, the clinical problem of the ventricular pacing site optimization was addressed and the measurement protocol to adopt for hemodynamic tests on cardiac pacing was investigated. In accordance to the aims of the work, in addition to the classical time-domain parameters, a new set of indexes has been extracted, based on coherent averaging procedure and on spectral and cross-spectral analysis (Chapter 4.). Our analyses were carried out on patients with indications for electrophysiologic study or device implantation (Chapter 5.). For the first time, besides patients with heart failure, indexes of mechanical dyssynchrony based on conductance catheter were extracted and studied in a population of patients with preserved ventricular function, providing information on the normal range of such a kind of values. By performing a frequency domain analysis and by applying an optimized coherent averaging procedure (Chapter 6.a.), we were able to describe some characteristics of the conductance-volume signals (Chapter 6.b.). We unmasked the presence of considerable beat-to-beat variations in dyssynchrony that seemed more frequent in patients with ventricular dysfunction and to play a role in discriminating patients. These non-recurrent mechanical ventricular non-uniformities are probably the expression of the substantial beat-to-beat hemodynamic variations, often associated with heart failure and due to cardiopulmonary interaction and conduction disturbances. We investigated how the coherent averaging procedure may affect or refine the conductance based indexes; in addition, we proposed and tested a new set of indexes which quantify the non-periodic components of the volume signals. Using the new set of indexes we studied the acute effects of the CRT and the right ventricular pacing, in patients with heart failure and patients with preserved ventricular function. In the overall population we observed a correlation between the hemodynamic changes induced by the pacing and the indexes of dyssynchrony, and this may have practical implications for hemodynamic-guided device implantation. The optimal ventricular pacing site for patients with conventional indications for pacing remains controversial. The majority of them do not meet current clinical indications for CRT pacing. Thus, we carried out an analysis to compare the impact of several ventricular pacing sites on global and regional ventricular function and dyssynchrony (Chapter 6.c.). We observed that right ventricular pacing worsens cardiac function in patients with and without ventricular dysfunction unless the pacing site is optimized. CRT preserves left ventricular function in patients with normal ejection fraction and improves function in patients with poor ejection fraction despite no clinical indication for CRT. Moreover, the analysis of the results obtained using new indexes of regional dyssynchrony, suggests that pacing site may influence overall global ventricular function depending on its relative effects on regional function and synchrony. Another clinical problem that has been investigated in this work is the optimal right ventricular lead location for CRT (Chapter 6.d.). Similarly to the previous analysis, using novel parameters describing local synchrony and efficiency, we tested the hypothesis and we demonstrated that biventricular pacing with alternative right ventricular pacing sites produces acute improvement of ventricular systolic function and improves mechanical synchrony when compared to standard right ventricular pacing. Although no specific right ventricular location was shown to be superior during CRT, the right ventricular pacing site that produced the optimal acute hemodynamic response varied between patients. Acute hemodynamic effects of cardiac pacing are conventionally evaluated after stabilization episodes. The applied duration of stabilization periods in most cardiac pacing studies varied considerably. With an ad hoc protocol (Chapter 6.e.) and indexes of mechanical dyssynchrony derived by conductance catheter we demonstrated that the usage of stabilization periods during evaluation of cardiac pacing may mask early changes in systolic and diastolic intra-ventricular dyssynchrony. In fact, at the onset of ventricular pacing, the main dyssynchrony and ventricular performance changes occur within a 10s time span, initiated by the changes in ventricular mechanical dyssynchrony induced by aberrant conduction and followed by a partial or even complete recovery. It was already demonstrated in normal animals that ventricular mechanical dyssynchrony may act as a physiologic modulator of cardiac performance together with heart rate, contractile state, preload and afterload. The present observation, which shows the compensatory mechanism of mechanical dyssynchrony, suggests that ventricular dyssynchrony may be regarded as an intrinsic cardiac property, with baseline dyssynchrony at increased level in heart failure patients. To make available an independent system for cardiac output estimation, in order to confirm the results obtained with conductance volume method, we developed and validated a novel technique to apply the Modelflow method (a method that derives an aortic flow waveform from arterial pressure by simulation of a non-linear three-element aortic input impedance model, Wesseling et al. 1993) to the left ventricular pressure signal, instead of the arterial pressure used in the classical approach (Chapter 7.). The results confirmed that in patients without valve abnormalities, undergoing conductance catheter evaluations, the continuous monitoring of cardiac output using the intra-ventricular pressure signal is reliable. Thus, cardiac output can be monitored quantitatively and continuously with a simple and low-cost method. During this work, additional studies were carried out to investigate several areas of uncertainty of CRT. The results of these studies are briefly presented in Appendix: the long-term survival in patients treated with CRT in clinical practice, the effects of CRT in patients with mild symptoms of heart failure and in very old patients, the limited thoracotomy as a second choice alternative to transvenous implant for CRT delivery, the evolution and prognostic significance of diastolic filling pattern in CRT, the selection of candidates to CRT with echocardiographic criteria and the prediction of response to the therapy.

Statistical methods for analysis and processing of medical ultrasound: applications to segmentation and restoration

In this thesis two major topics inherent with medical ultrasound images are addressed: deconvolution and segmentation. In the first case a deconvolution algorithm is described allowing statistically consistent maximum a posteriori estimates of the tissue reflectivity to be restored. These estimates are proven to provide a reliable source of information for achieving an accurate characterization of biological tissues through the ultrasound echo. The second topic involves the definition of a semi automatic algorithm for myocardium segmentation in 2D echocardiographic images. The results show that the proposed method can reduce inter- and intra observer variability in myocardial contours delineation and is feasible and accurate even on clinical data.

L'Amiloidosi transtiretino correlata ereditaria: profilo clinico, fisiopatologico e storia naturale

Background. Hereditary transthyretin (TTR)-related amyloidosis (ATTR) is mainly considered a neurologic disease. We assessed the phenotypic and genotypic spectrum of ATTR in a non-endemic, Caucasian area and evaluated prevalence, genetic background and disease profile of cases with an exclusively cardiac phenotype, highlighting possible hints for the differential diagnosis with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) and senile systemic amyloidosis (SSA) Methods and Results. In this Italian multicenter study, 186 patients with ATTR were characterized at presentation. Thirty patients with SSA and 30 age-gender matched HCM patients were used for comparison. Phenotype was classified as: exclusively cardiac (n= 31, 17%), exclusively neurologic (n= 46, 25%), mixed cardiac/neurologic (n=109, 58%). Among the 8 different mutations responsible for an exclusively cardiac phenotype, Ile68Leu was the most frequent (23/31). Five patients with an exclusively cardiac phenotype developed mild abnormalities at neurological examination but no symptoms during a 36 [14−50] month follow-up. Exclusively cardiac phenotype was characterized by male gender, age > 65 years, heart failure symptoms, concentric left ventricular (LV) “hypertrophy” and moderately depressed LV ejection fraction. This profile was similar to SSA but relatively distinct from HCM. Compared to patients with a mixed phenotype, patients with a exclusively cardiac phenotype showed a more pronounced cardiac involvement on both echocardiogram and ECG. Conclusion. A clinically relevant subset of Caucasian ATTR patients present with an exclusively cardiac phenotype, mimicking HCM or SSA. Echocardiographic and ECG findings are useful to differentiate ATTR from HCM but not from SSA. The role of liver transplantation in these patients is questionable.

Utilzzo dei parametri ecocardiografici tradizionali ed a Doppler tissutale nella valutazione della disfunzione atrio-ventricolare in cani affetti da malattia mitralica cronica

In questo lavoro ci siamo posti come obiettivo lo studio della disfunzione atrio-ventricolare mediante tecniche ecocardiografiche avanzate (come il Tissue Doppler Imaging - TDI) in cani affetti da malattia mitralica cronica (MVD). Una prima parte è volta alla valutazione della funzionalità diastolica del ventricolo destro. Ci siamo proposti di analizzare la funzione del ventricolo destro in cani affetti da malattia del cuore sinistro per comprendere se quest’ultima possa condizionare direttamente la performance del settore cardiaco controlaterale. I risultati più importanti che abbiamo riscontrato sono: l’assenza di differenze significative nella disfunzione sisto-diastolica del ventricolo destro in cani con MVD a diverso stadio; la diretta correlazione tra le variabili TDI di funzionalità del ventricolo destro con il grado di disfunzione del ventricolo sinistro, come indicatori di interdipendenza ventricolare; ed infine il riscontro di una maggior tendenza ad alterazioni diastoliche del ventricolo sinistro in cani con ipertensione polmonare. A quest’ultimo proposito, per quanto riguarda le variabili TDI, il rapporto E/e’ dell’anulus mitralico laterale e settale è risultato avere una differenza significativa tra i cani con ipertensione polmonare e quelli privi di ipertensione polmonare (P<0,01). Nel secondo studio abbiamo applicato il TDI per l’analisi della funzione sisto-diastolica dell’atrio sinistro. Il lavoro è stato articolato in una parte di validazione della metodica su cani normali ed una su animali affetti da MDV. I risultati ottenuti mostrano che la valutazione ecocardiografica delle proprietà di deformazione dell’atrio sinistro basata sul TDI è attuabile e riproducibile nel cane. Abbiamo fornito dei valori di normalità per questa specie e confrontato questi dati con quelli ricavati in cani portatori di MVD. Le differenza tra le varie classi di malattia, nei diversi gradi di dilatazione atriale, sono risultate limitate, ma abbiamo individuato delle correlazioni tra i parametri TDI ed alcune variabili di funzionalità atriale.

Aspetti Ultrasonografici in Corso di Sviluppo Placentare e Adattamento Cardiovascolare nella Cavalla Gravida: ecografia bidimensionale, ecocardiografia ed ecocontrastografia (CEUS)

In corso di gravidanza normale avvengono modificazioni emodinamiche centrali e periferiche volte a garantire le crescenti richieste nutritive dell'unità feto-placentare. L’ecografia con mezzo di contrasto (CEUS-Contrast Enhanced Ultrasonography) a base di microbolle offre una nuova opportunità di monitorare e quantificare la perfusione utero-placentare in condizioni normali e patologiche. L’ecocardiografia è stata ampiamente usata in medicina umana per valutare l’adattamento morfo-funzionale cardiaco materno durante la gravidanza. Gli scopi di questo lavoro prospettico sono stati di applicare, per la prima volta nella specie equina, un mezzo di contrasto di II generazione (Sonovue®), al fine quantificare la perfusione utero-placentare in corso di gravidanza normale, valutandone gli effetti sul benessere materno-fetale e di descrivere le modificazioni nei parametri ecocardiografici morfometrici e funzionali cardiaci, in particolare relativi alla funzione del ventricolo sinistro nel corso di una gravidanza fisiologica. Due fattrici sane di razza Trottatore sono state monitorate ecograficamente in maniera seriale durante l’intero corso della gravidanza, tramite esame bidimensionale, ecocontrastografia dell'unità utero-placentare, flussimetria Doppler delle arterie uterine, ecocardiografia materna in modalità bidimensionale, M-mode, Doppler e Tissue Doppler Imaging. I neonati sono stati clinicamente monitorati e gli invogli fetali esaminati. Il pattern di microperfusione utero-placentare è valutabile quali-quantitativamente tramite la CEUS e dimostra un’aumento del flusso a livello di microvascolarizzazione uterina con l'avanzare della gravidanza; non è stata rilevata la presenza di microbolle a livello di strutture fetali nè effetti dannosi sul benessere materno-fetale. In questo studio sono state osservate delle modificazioni cardiache materne in corso di gravidanza fisiologica, relative all'aumento della FC, del CO ed in particolare all'aumento delle dimensioni dell'atrio sinistro ed a modificazioni nelle onde di velocità di flusso e tissutali di riempimento del ventricolo sinistro.