Verso una regolamentazione dei contratti intelligenti: particolare riferimento al settore finanziario

Esta tesis doctoral aborda un tema complejo y de actualidad. Complejo, porque no es posible estudiarlo desde un punto de vista jurídico, sin un conocimiento previo de la tecnología subyacente - el blockchain. Y de actualidad, porque esta tecnología ya ha tenido un profundo impacto en el sector financiero en general, coincidiendo con una tendencia reguladora en este campo que no tiene precedentes normativos en los que basarse. El mundo financiero, el derecho bancario, el derecho de valores y los contratos comerciales se enfrentan a retos que no se pueden ignorar. Este trabajo de investigación aborda esta tecnología desde una perspectiva jurídica, valorando en qué medida el ordenamiento jurídico se está adaptando al ritmo exigido; en qué medida el régimen jurídico vigente ofrece soluciones y puede aplicarse, con ligeras adaptaciones, a esta nueva realidad económico-comercial; y, por último, cuáles son los elementos y características diferenciales de las aplicaciones de la tecnología blockchain, que deben tenerse en cuenta para una adecuada regulación de las mismas, que responda a los problemas que plantean. Conocer los beneficios, riesgos y ventajas son elementos esenciales a considerar en el proceso de regulación, ya iniciado y guiado por la UE, en su voluntad de apostar por la innovación digital en la economía de la Eurozona.

Implications of Blockchain-Based Smart Contracts on Contract Law

Smart contracts are the most advanced blockchain applications. They can also be used in the contractual domain for the encoding and automatic execution of contract terms. Smart contracts already existed before the blockchain, but they take advantage of the characteristics of that technology. Namely, the decentralised and immutable characters of the blockchain determine that no single contracting party can control, modify, or interrupt the execution of smart contracts. As every new phenomenon, blockchain-based smart contracts have attracted the attention of institutions. For example, in its Resolution of 3 October 2018 on distributed ledger technologies and blockchain, the European Parliament has stressed the need to undertake an in-depth assessment of the legal implications,starting from the analysis of existing legal frameworks. Indeed, the present research thesis aims to verify how blockchain-based smart contracts fit into contract law. To this end, the analysis starts from the most discussed and relevant aspects and develops further considerations. Before that, it provides a detailed description and clarifications about the characteristics, the functioning, and the development of the technology, which is an essential starting point for a high-level quality legal analysis. It takes into considerations already existing rules concerning the use of technology in the life cycle of contracts, from vending machines to computable contracts, and verifies its applicability to blockchain-based smart contracts. The work does not limit to consider the mere technology, but some concrete scenarios of adoption of blockchain-based smart contracts in the contractual domain. Starting from the latter, it focuses on the implications of blockchain-based smart contracts on contract formation, contract performance, and applicable law and jurisdiction.

Distributed argumentation technology: advancing risk analysis and regulatory compliance of distributed ledger technologies for transaction and management of securities

Distributed argumentation technology is a computational approach incorporating argumentation reasoning mechanisms within multi-agent systems. For the formal foundations of distributed argumentation technology, in this thesis we conduct a principle-based analysis of structured argumentation as well as abstract multi-agent and abstract bipolar argumentation. The results of the principle-based approach of these theories provide an overview and guideline for further applications of the theories. Moreover, in this thesis we explore distributed argumentation technology using distributed ledgers. We envision an Intelligent Human-input-based Blockchain Oracle (IHiBO), an artificial intelligence tool for storing argumentation reasoning. We propose a decentralized and secure architecture for conducting decision-making, addressing key concerns of trust, transparency, and immutability. We model fund management with agent argumentation in IHiBO and analyze its compliance with European fund management legal frameworks. We illustrate how bipolar argumentation balances pros and cons in legal reasoning in a legal divorce case, and how the strength of arguments in natural language can be represented in structured arguments. Finally, we discuss how distributed argumentation technology can be used to advance risk management, regulatory compliance of distributed ledgers for financial securities, and dialogue techniques.