A threshold hypothesis of institutional change: collective action in the Italian Alps during the 13th - 19th centuries.

This dissertation is about collective action issues in common property resources. Its focus is the “threshold hypothesis,” which posits the existence of a threshold in group size that drives the process of institutional change. This hypothesis is tested using a six-century dataset concerning the management of the commons by hundreds of communities in the Italian Alps. The analysis seeks to determine the group size threshold and the institutional changes that occur when groups cross this threshold. There are five main findings. First, the number of individuals in villages remained stable for six centuries, despite the population in the region tripling in the same period. Second, the longitudinal analysis of face-to-face assemblies and community size led to the empirical identification of a threshold size that triggered the transition from informal to more formal regimes to manage common property resources. Third, when groups increased in size, gradual organizational changes took place: large groups split into independent subgroups or structured interactions into multiple layers while maintaining a single formal organization. Fourth, resource heterogeneity seemed to have had no significant impact on various institutional characteristics. Fifth, social heterogeneity showed statistically significant impacts, especially on institutional complexity, consensus, and the relative importance of governance rules versus resource management rules. Overall, the empirical evidence from this research supports the “threshold hypothesis.” These findings shed light on the rationale of institutional change in common property regimes, and clarify the mechanisms of collective action in traditional societies. Further research may generalize these conclusions to other domains of collective action and to present-day applications.

Edizione commentata della Cronaca di Venezia di Giovanni Tiepolo (XVI-XVII sec.)

Il seguente studio propone l'esame di una cronaca veneziana del XVI secolo, inedita, dalle origini al 1538/39, che parte della tradizione manoscritta attribuisce al Patriarca di Venezia Giovanni Tiepolo (1619-1631), parte ad Agostino degli Agostini, (1530-1574), un patrizio veneziano il cui nome è legato essenzialmente ad una cronaca dal 421 al 1570. Indipendentemente da chi sia il primitivo autore, la cronaca, di discreto pregio per la storia interna e il funzionamento delle istituzioni veneziane, presenta elementi di spiccata originalità dal punto di vista compositivo e formale che la pongono in una prospettiva storiografica alternativa al dualismo tra la storiografia ufficiale promossa per pubblico decreto e l'iniziativa privata dei diaria del XV-XVI. La cronaca veneziana, abbandonata per formule più sofisticate e innovative di diffusione dell'informazione pubblica, sopravvive, formalmente immutata nella sua arcaicità, rinnovandosi nella tendenza a creare compendi ricchi di documenti e di elenchi, destinati ad aiutare la nobiltà ad orientarsi nel mondo socio-politico contemporaneo. Si consuma così il divorzio fra l'informazione tecnico-politica utile al patriziato nello svolgimento del suo lavoro e la storiografia pubblica che, di fronte alle varie esigenze e ai diversi generi letterari, sceglie ideologicamente di abbracciare il genere delle laus civitatis e della storiografia laudativa ed encomiastica. In questo contesto si inserisce la Cronaca esemplata dal Patriarca Giovanni Tiepolo, chiaro esempio di un tentativo di razionalizzazione dell'informazione in cui le notizie e gli elementi non ritenuti immediatamente utili come le lunghe liste dei 41 elettori, le promissioni ducali, nonchè singoli episodi ed eventi trattati, trovano una collocazione esterna alla cronaca, in quello che Reines definisce l'ormai nascente archivio politico del XVI secolo.

Le Antichità di Bologna di Bartolomeo della Pugliola

For a long time, the work of a Franciscan Friar who had lived in Bologna and in Florence during the 13th and 14th centuries, Bartolomeo Della Pugliola, was thought to have been lost. Recent paleographic research, however, has affirmed that most of Della Pugliola’s work, although mixed into other authors, is contained in two manuscripts (1994 and 3843), currently kept at University Library in Bologna. Pugliola’s chronicle is central to Bolognese medieval literature, not only because it was the privileged source for the important work of Ramponis’ chronicle, but also because Bartolomeo della Pugliola’s sources are several significant works such as Jacopo Bianchetti’s lost writings and Pietro and Floriano Villolas’ chronicle (1163-1372). Ongoing historical studies and recent discoveries enabled me to reconstruct the historical chronology of Pugliola’s work as well as the Bolognese language between the 13th and 14th century The original purpose of my research was to add a linguistic commentary to the edition of the text in order to fill the gaps in medieval Bolognese language studies. In addition to being a reliable source, Pugliola’s chronicle was widely disseminated and became a sort of vulgate. The tradition of chronicle, through collation, allows the study of the language from a diachronic point of view. I therefore described all the linguistics phenomena related to phonetics, morphology and syntax in Pugliola’s text and I compared these results with variants in Villola’s and Ramponis’ chronicles. I also did likewise with another chronicle by a 16th century merchant, Friano Ubaldini, that I edited. This supplement helped to complete the Bolognese language outline from the 13th to the 16th century. In order to analize the data that I collected, I tried to approach them from a sociolinguistic point of view because each author represents a different variant of the language: closer to a scripta and the Florentine the language used by Pugliola, closer to the dialect spoken in Bologna the language used by Ubaldini. Differencies in handwriting especially show the models the authors try to reproduce or imitate. The glossary I added at the end of this study can help to understand these nuances with a number of examples.

Scienza, Tecnica, Politica: Il Problema del Metodo nel Pensiero di Jacopo Aconcio

The aim of this PhD thesis is to study accurately and in depth the figure and the literary production of the intellectual Jacopo Aconcio. This minor author of the 16th century has long been considered a sort of “enigmatic character”, a profile which results from the work of those who, for many centuries, have left his writing to its fate: a story of constant re-readings and equally incessant oversights. This is why it is necessary to re-read Aconcio’s production in its entirety and to devote to it a monographic study. Previous scholars’ interpretations will obviously be considered, but at the same time an effort will be made to go beyond them through the analysis of both published and manuscript sources, in the attempt to attain a deeper understanding of the figure of this man, who was a Christian, a military and hydraulic engineer and a political philosopher,. The title of the thesis was chosen to emphasise how, throughout the three years of the doctorate, my research concentrated in equal measure and with the same degree of importance on all the reflections and activities of Jacopo Aconcio. My object, in fact, was to establish how and to what extent the methodological thinking of the intellectual found application in, and at the same time guided, his theoretical and practical production. I did not mention in the title the author’s religious thinking, which has always been considered by everyone the most original and interesting element of his production, because religion, from the Reformation onwards, was primarily a political question and thus it was treated by almost all the authors involved in the Protestant movement - Aconcio in the first place. Even the remarks concerning the private, intimate sphere of faith have therefore been analysed in this light: only by acknowledging the centrality of the “problem of politics” in Aconcio’s theories, in fact, is it possible to interpret them correctly. This approach proves the truth of the theoretical premise to my research, that is to say the unity and orderliness of the author’s thought: in every field of knowledge, Aconcio applies the rules of the methodus resolutiva, as a means to achieve knowledge and elaborate models of pacific cohabitation in society. Aconcio’s continuous references to method can make his writing pedant and rather complex, but at the same time they allow for a consistent and valid analysis of different disciplines. I have not considered the fact that most of his reflections appear to our eyes as strongly conditioned by the time in which he lived as a limit. To see in him, as some have done, the forerunner of Descartes’ methodological discourse or, conversely, to judge his religious theories as not very modern, is to force the thought of an author who was first and foremost a Christian man of his own time. Aconcio repeats this himself several times in his writings: he wants to provide individuals with the necessary tools to reach a full-fledged scientific knowledge in the various fields, and also to enable them to seek truth incessantly in the religious domain, which is the duty of every human being. The will to find rules, instruments, effective solutions characterizes the whole of the author’s corpus: Aconcio feels he must look for truth in all the arts, aware as he is that anything can become science as long as it is analysed with method. Nevertheless, he remains a man of his own time, a Christian convinced of the existence of God, creator and governor of the world, to whom people must account for their own actions. To neglect this fact in order to construct a “character”, a generic forerunner, but not participant, of whatever philosophical current, is a dangerous and sidetracking operation. In this study, I have highlighted how Aconcio’s arguments only reveal their full meaning when read in the context in which they were born, without depriving them of their originality but also without charging them with meanings they do not possess. Through a historical-doctrinal approach, I have tried to analyse the complex web of theories and events which constitute the substratum of Aconcio’s reflection, in order to trace the correct relations between texts and contexts. The thesis is therefore organised in six chapters, dedicated respectively to Aconcio’s biography, to the methodological question, to the author’s engineering activity, to his historical knowledge and to his religious thinking, followed by a last section concerning his fortune throughout the centuries. The above-mentioned complexity is determined by the special historical moment in which the author lived. On the one hand, thanks to the new union between science and technique, the 16th century produces discoveries and inventions which make available a previously unthinkable number of notions and lead to a “revolution” in the way of studying and teaching the different subjects, which, by producing a new form of intellectual, involved in politics but also aware of scientific-technological issues, will contribute to the subsequent birth of modern science. On the other, the 16th century is ravaged by religious conflicts, which shatter the unity of the Christian world and generate theological-political disputes which will inform the history of European states for many decades. My aim is to show how Aconcio’s multifarious activity is the conscious fruit of this historical and religious situation, as well as the attempt of an answer to the request of a new kind of engagement on the intellectual’s behalf. Plunged in the discussions around methodus, employed in the most important European courts, involved in the abrupt acceleration of technical-scientific activities, and especially concerned by the radical religious reformation brought on by the Protestant movement, Jacopo Aconcio reflects this complex conjunction in his writings, without lacking in order and consistency, differently from what many scholars assume. The object of this work, therefore, is to highlight the unity of the author’s thought, in which science, technique, faith and politics are woven into a combination which, although it may appear illogical and confused, is actually tidy and methodical, and therefore in agreement with Aconcio’s own intentions and with the specific characters of European culture in the Renaissance. This theory is confirmed by the reading of the Ars muniendorum oppidorum, Aconcio’s only work which had been up till now unavailable. I am persuaded that only a methodical reading of Aconcio’s works, without forgetting nor glorifying any single one, respects the author’s will. From De methodo (1558) onwards, all his writings are summae, guides for the reader who wishes to approach the study of the various disciplines. Undoubtedly, Satan’s Stratagems (1565) is something more, not only because of its length, but because it deals with the author’s main interest: the celebration of doubt and debate as bases on which to build religious tolerance, which is the best method for pacific cohabitation in society. This, however, does not justify the total centrality which the Stratagems have enjoyed for centuries, at the expense of a proper understanding of the author’s will to offer examples of methodological rigour in all sciences. Maybe it is precisely because of the reforming power of Aconcio’s thought that, albeit often forgotten throughout the centuries, he has never ceased to reappear and continues to draw attention, both as a man and as an author. His ideas never stop stimulating the reader’s curiosity and this may ultimately be the best demonstration of their worth, independently from the historical moment in which they come back to the surface.

L'univers féminin du picaresque

Les considérations sur le statut de la femme dans la littérature picaresque sont principalement limitées à la production littéraire espagnole. Nous ne pouvons que constater l’absence d’une étude comparatiste s’attachant aux personnages féminins qui peuplent le monde picaresque des pays où ce genre littéraire s’est majoritairement affirmé : l’Espagne, la France et l’Angleterre. Le but de cette analyse est de proposer une comparaison exhaustive entre les personnages féminins des romans picaresques européens de l’époque classique. Ceux-ci sont présentés selon les âges de la vie féminine : l’enfance, la jeunesse, l’âge d’épouse et de mère et la vieillesse. L’exploration de ces catégories d’âges dans lesquelles les rôles féminins se construisent met en évidence la place déterminante qu’ils occupent dans la narration. Leurs tâches, leurs comportements, leurs modes relationnels sont analysés dans les différents espaces et à l’intérieur d’un cadre temporel qui leur sont propres. Les représentations de la femme qui sont diffusées par les écrivains sont bien souvent marquées par une conduite désordonnée. Que les femmes soient victimes d’une société sexiste ou bien qu’elles fassent sciemment de mauvais choix, elles sont dans la majorité des cas, inexorablement condamnées à accepter la condition d’infériorité qui leur est imposée. Il est pourtant une catégorie d’entre elles qui ne s’en tient pas au rôle qui lui est dévolu à l’époque par la société et ses institutions et qui met en place toute une série de stratagèmes lui permettant de se frayer un chemin dans un monde dominé par la supériorité masculine

I regesti delle carte bolognesi dei secc. X-XII trascritti nei cartulari ecclesiastici del XVII-XVIII secolo. Edizione critica

La ricerca ha come oggetto l’edizione critica di circa tremila regesti di documenti di area bolognese datati al X-XII secolo. I documenti sono stati trascritti tra il XVII e XVIII secolo in undici cartulari ecclesiastici, conservati presso l’Archivio di Stato di Bologna. Il lavoro s’inserisce nel progetto di edizione delle carte bolognesi di epoca medievale in corso presso la cattedra di Paleografia latina e Diplomatica dell’Università di Bologna, attualmente incentrata sull’edizione delle carte del secolo XII. La ricerca si propone come strumento di supporto a tale progetto e come completamento delle carte già pubblicate: i cartulari, infatti, offrono spesso copie di documenti mancanti dell’originale o in cattivo stato di conservazione, e costituiscono l’unica traccia di una memoria storica altrimenti perduta. Le raccolte esaminate si collocano a ridosso del periodo napoleonico, quando la maggior parte degli enti ecclesiastici venne soppressa e i loro beni incamerati dallo Stato; esse quindi rispecchiano la condizione dei principali archivi ecclesiastici cittadini dei primi secoli del Medioevo bolognese. La ricerca è strutturata in una prima parte volta a definire in termini storico-diplomatistici la tipologia di fonte esaminata: oggi i cartulari non sono più intesi come semplici raccoglitori di documenti, ma come sistema organico di fonti in grado di far luce su aspetti importanti della storia dell’ente che li ha prodotti. L’indagine del loro contesto di produzione permette di comprenderne meglio le finalità, la forma e il valore giuridico. Parte della ricerca è stata poi incentrata sullo studio delle ragioni che hanno portato gli istituti religiosi bolognesi alla redazione dei cartulari: a tal fine è stata esaminata la legislazione ecclesiastica cinque-settecentesca in materia di conservazione della documentazione e il rapporto della legislazione stessa con la prassi archivistica. Infine è stata realizzata l’edizione critica vera e propria dei regesti, mirante a descrivere le caratteristiche principali di ciascun cartulario.

Hierapolis-Castabala: The Urban Development in A.D. 1st to 3rd Centuries

The goal of the present dissertation is to explore the urbanization process in Castabala in A.D. 1st to 3rd centuries, along with the factors affecting the urbanization of the city and the impact of Romanization on this process, by making use of the buildings that are proven or assumed to date back to this period. A further goal is to provide a general assessment of these buildings based on the finds and findings revealed by the excavations in Castabala, which first started in 2009, and use these as evidence for proposing new dating for buildings that have not been fully dated.